Celebrate the birthday of the book that made a Giant-Size impact on comics! Revisit the fateful day that Professor X gathered an all-new, all-different, multinational mix of mutants - as Storm, Nightcrawler, Colossus, Banshee, Sunfire, Thunderbird and some guy named Wolverine unite with Cyclops in the rescue tale that ushered in four decades of uncanny adventures! See how the original team reacted to the newly expanded roster! Learn the tragic histories of Colossus and Wolverine! Ask yourself "What If?" they all died or never even met! And savor the explosive epic that revealed the group's true deadly genesis - and the ill-fated existence of a previous team! COLLECTING: Giant-Size X-Men 1, 3-4; Classic X-Men 1; X-Men Origins: Colossus; X-Men Origi ns: Wolveri ne; X-Men: Deadly Genesis 1-6; What If? (1989) 9, 23; materi al from X-Men Gold 1
Len Wein was an American comic book writer and editor best known for co-creating DC Comics' Swamp Thing and Marvel Comics' Wolverine, and for helping revive the Marvel superhero team the X-Men (including the co-creation of Nightcrawler, Storm, and Colossus). Additionally, he was the editor for writer Alan Moore and illustrator Dave Gibbons' influential DC miniseries Watchmen.
Wein was inducted into the Will Eisner Comic Book Hall of Fame in 2008.
A great reprint of the original introduction of some of the most iconic non-original X-men (minus two or three). The heaviest negative here is the included retcon, "Deadly Genesis." Juxtaposing the original story with an overly grim-dark revision that felt unnecessary. The other additional stories were OK, but they all seemed to be there just to pad the book out. Hopefully, you can find a reprint or digital copy of just Giant-Sized X-Men #1, since that was really all we needed to celebrate the 40th anniversary.
This was a fun read. It was fun to revisit the classic and seminal Giant-size X-Men issue that introduced the Uncanny X-Men and breathed new life into the series. It was also fun reading the other issues they tied into this collection; I had not read most of them (other than >Deadly Genesis) and enjoyed them as well .
In any case, it was a fun compilation to read. It moved at a fast pace. I enjoyed most of the artwork. It held my interest from start to finish. I especially enjoyed the What if issues at the end (loved those two runs of that series!) and am glad that I picked this up at a cheap price.
Xavier recruiting around the world, from Germany to Canada, from Banshee's peculiar way of speaking to Ororo's liquid eyes. On their first mission, this new team (especially Japanese Sunfire) faces internal differences. Two groups; two eras; can they get along well? For how long? Nightcrawler as the philosopher. Wolverine as the hot-headed skirt-chaser. A little on the origins of Piotr Rasputin (Colossus), with the government always getting involved; a James (Logan), from the 19th century into the 20th as a violent force of Nature. 21st century: Xavier gone; Jean Grey no more a team member; a space shuttle coming to Earth with an all-powerful stranger (?)... Is the Professor to blame? Finally, two possibilities for a world with no X-Men. Quotations = Colossus: Does [my power] not belong to the State? Henry McCoy on the Avengers: "...a decidedly more socially acceptable amalgamation of super heroes."
A great telling of Giant Sized X Men, retellings parrallel stories, what ifs and a couple of post-stories related to it. I remember reading about the Krakoa story in a book I got from primary school during a week when they were selling books in the music hut. It was one of the first books I tried to read that were above my reading level. To this day I remember glimpses of it and not really comprehending the detail. Reading this comic anthology 30 years on really fills in some gaps.
In more ways than one this anthology fills in gaps, what happened to the x men since and what happened in the stories behind the scenes. Giant Sized x men remains an iconic storyline and this anthology truly curates stories in a way that doesn't necessarily follow chronology or continuity. A perfect sense of editing.
I enjoyed the classic stories, less so the modern additions like Deadly Genesis (really? of a 50/50 team, the boys lived and the girls died?) I especially enjoyed the What If stories, where the team beats Krakoa first try, Lorna's presence prevents the Pheonix saga because she shouts at Scott and Jean to listen and remember her power set. Obviously, it means there's less diversity, which is a problem. In that way, the original Giant Sized was a good move, but I like happier AUs.
I do appreciate Deadly Genesis for making Scott's turn against Prof. X by All-New X-Men feel plausible.
I was turned-on to X-Men by a blogger called ComicBookGirl19. There are more interesting themes than I'd realized: about how society treats the Other and a fairly nuanced exploration of what tolerance really means. I enjoyed getting to know the characters and some compelling art. Interesting too, to see how comic book art changes over decades.
For years I'd heard the the basic story about an island capturing the orginal x-men forcing a new team to form, but I'd never read it. This tome will provide you with that story as well as a new chapter in the tale you probably didn't hear about. It also provides two what if stories that are fun as well as come behind the scenes material.