What do you think?
Rate this book
This Quiet Sky
There is nothing extraordinary about Tucker O’Shay’s dreams. Go to college. Become president. Fall in love. And pretend like he has enough time to get it all done.
Sixteen-year-old Sarah Miller doesn’t expect anything out of the ordinary when she begins her first day at the one-room-school house in her new hometown of Rocky Knob. But when she meets seventeen-year-old Tucker O’Shay—the boy with the fatal illness who volunteers to tutor her in algebra—she finds herself swept up in a friendship that changes the way she sees the world and a love that changes her life.
Sixteen-year-old Sarah Miller doesn’t expect anything out of the ordinary when she begins her first day at the one-room-school house in her new hometown of Rocky Knob. But when she meets seventeen-year-old Tucker O’Shay—the boy with the fatal illness who volunteers to tutor her in algebra—she finds herself swept up in a friendship that changes the way she sees the world and a love that changes her life.
158 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2014
60 people are currently reading
2233 people want to read
About the author
Joanne Bischof
19 books1,306 followersAn ECPA Christy Award winner and an ACFW Carol Award winner, Joanne Bischof DeWitt writes deeply layered fiction that tugs at the reader’s heartstrings. Joanne’s 2016 novel, THE LADY AND THE LIONHEART, received an extraordinary 5 Star TOP PICK! from Romantic Times Book Reviews among other critical acclaim.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 223 reviews
July 12, 2017
Remind me again how I'm supposed to return to normal life after that? *sobs*
June 18, 2018
This book is absolutely amazing. I can’t even describe just how beautiful it is. I loved it so much and have read it multiple times now.
I was pulled into the story from the very beginning. The setting and characters of this book are perfect. You will fall in love with this story. This book is just so real. It doesn’t have the perfect “happily ever after” ending and that makes this book that much more special. This book is full of dreams and heartbreak, and it is the most beautiful book I have ever read.
I would definitely recommend this book.
I was pulled into the story from the very beginning. The setting and characters of this book are perfect. You will fall in love with this story. This book is just so real. It doesn’t have the perfect “happily ever after” ending and that makes this book that much more special. This book is full of dreams and heartbreak, and it is the most beautiful book I have ever read.
I would definitely recommend this book.
August 24, 2018
This book had no permission to break my heart like that.
May 17, 2016
This book ... so sad, but so beautiful! Joanne Bischof writes with such tenderness and grace! I loved her other books, and loved this bittersweet, little novella, This Quiet Sky.
It centers around a sixteen-year-old girl, Sarah, who attends a one-room schoolhouse in 1885. There she meet Tucker O'Shay, the boy who rocks her world; who heightens her dreams. The boy who is ill. In a breathless tale of discovery and heartache, we hear Sarah's story.
This Quiet Sky connects to Joanne Bischof's THE CADENCE OF GRACE series; Sarah to be Lonnie Sawyer's aunt.
I'm not one for tragedies, but there's just something about this simple, impacting short story. The classic-ness and warmth to the writing. The vividness of the characters and their emotions and dreams. The message to live every moment to the fullest! Aw, it was radiantly beautiful in a heart-squeezing way. I appreciated how it showed the journey through fear and grief. Though mournful in many ways, This Quiet Sky somehow bursts with hope.
Note: This is definitely a romance, and there is some kissing. Some kissing scenes were a bit much in my opinion. I would recommend at least 16 and up.
It could feel something like Janette Oke's or L.M. Montgomery's novels. Such a sweet, lyrical, old-fashioned touch to the writing style. (Though it was written in first person, I believe).
Anyway, I loved it in some way or another. The Epilogue was precious, in, yes, a bittersweet kind of way. I do like how it ties into THE CADENCE OF GRACE series ... makes me want to read them again!
Don't miss this heartfelt, historical tale! It's truly touching. I can't wait to read more by Joanne Bischof!
It centers around a sixteen-year-old girl, Sarah, who attends a one-room schoolhouse in 1885. There she meet Tucker O'Shay, the boy who rocks her world; who heightens her dreams. The boy who is ill. In a breathless tale of discovery and heartache, we hear Sarah's story.
This Quiet Sky connects to Joanne Bischof's THE CADENCE OF GRACE series; Sarah to be Lonnie Sawyer's aunt.
I'm not one for tragedies, but there's just something about this simple, impacting short story. The classic-ness and warmth to the writing. The vividness of the characters and their emotions and dreams. The message to live every moment to the fullest! Aw, it was radiantly beautiful in a heart-squeezing way. I appreciated how it showed the journey through fear and grief. Though mournful in many ways, This Quiet Sky somehow bursts with hope.
Note: This is definitely a romance, and there is some kissing. Some kissing scenes were a bit much in my opinion. I would recommend at least 16 and up.
It could feel something like Janette Oke's or L.M. Montgomery's novels. Such a sweet, lyrical, old-fashioned touch to the writing style. (Though it was written in first person, I believe).
Anyway, I loved it in some way or another. The Epilogue was precious, in, yes, a bittersweet kind of way. I do like how it ties into THE CADENCE OF GRACE series ... makes me want to read them again!
Don't miss this heartfelt, historical tale! It's truly touching. I can't wait to read more by Joanne Bischof!
January 17, 2018
Beautiful, heartbreaking, sweet, sad this book is all of that. I could not put it down. Have a box of tissues handy.
October 2, 2018
https://thrivinghope.blogspot.com/201...
HOLY HOLY HOLY COW THIS IS NOT OKAY I HATE THIS SO MUCH I HATE IT ALL I CAN'T EVEN NOPE NOPE THIS IS NOT HAPPENING. Jk it's happening. AGAINST MY WILL. Wow. My heart. My poor, poor heart. Nobody should feel this kind of pain, okay? This is so wrong. I should not be so mad at this. I shouldn't have woken in the middle of the night after finishing this book, in tears, my chest literally aching because of these stupidly adorable characters. This should not be a thing! I'm not kidding! Actually, I am! Becuase I LOVE how achingly beautiful and SAD and heartbreaking this is! Again..... IT'S SO COMPLICATED. Literally, I finished this the day I bought it because I couldn't put it down and I cried probably a total of 3 times in it-- mind you, this wasn't just tearing up kind of crying. I had to shut the book to protect the pages from the flood of tears that were literally dripping off my cheeks. IT WAS THAT KIND OF DEVASTATING SADNESS THAT REEKED FROM THIS BOOK AND IT WAS SO WORTH IT. I had read "The Lady and the Lionheart" and LOVEDDD it so much that I had to buy this, despite all the warnings that so many people had cried in it. I basically lost my heart with this book. I can't even look at the Tucker that I know the same. Like. That's not okay.
first reaction: WHATTTTTT IS THIS???! THIS IS NOT OKAY!! I AM NOT OKAY!!!!!! YOU SE THAT *points* THATS MY HEART TORN UP, TORCHED, AND STAMPED ON BY THIS BOOK. YOU WANNA KNOW WHY I WILL NEVER TRUST JOANNE BISCHOF AGAIN, TWO WORDS: TUCKER O’SHAY. I HOPE YOURE HAPPY JOANNE, YOU HAVE ACTUALLY OFFICIALLY RUINED MY LIFE UGH.
HOLY HOLY HOLY COW THIS IS NOT OKAY I HATE THIS SO MUCH I HATE IT ALL I CAN'T EVEN NOPE NOPE THIS IS NOT HAPPENING. Jk it's happening. AGAINST MY WILL. Wow. My heart. My poor, poor heart. Nobody should feel this kind of pain, okay? This is so wrong. I should not be so mad at this. I shouldn't have woken in the middle of the night after finishing this book, in tears, my chest literally aching because of these stupidly adorable characters. This should not be a thing! I'm not kidding! Actually, I am! Becuase I LOVE how achingly beautiful and SAD and heartbreaking this is! Again..... IT'S SO COMPLICATED. Literally, I finished this the day I bought it because I couldn't put it down and I cried probably a total of 3 times in it-- mind you, this wasn't just tearing up kind of crying. I had to shut the book to protect the pages from the flood of tears that were literally dripping off my cheeks. IT WAS THAT KIND OF DEVASTATING SADNESS THAT REEKED FROM THIS BOOK AND IT WAS SO WORTH IT. I had read "The Lady and the Lionheart" and LOVEDDD it so much that I had to buy this, despite all the warnings that so many people had cried in it. I basically lost my heart with this book. I can't even look at the Tucker that I know the same. Like. That's not okay.
first reaction: WHATTTTTT IS THIS???! THIS IS NOT OKAY!! I AM NOT OKAY!!!!!! YOU SE THAT *points* THATS MY HEART TORN UP, TORCHED, AND STAMPED ON BY THIS BOOK. YOU WANNA KNOW WHY I WILL NEVER TRUST JOANNE BISCHOF AGAIN, TWO WORDS: TUCKER O’SHAY. I HOPE YOURE HAPPY JOANNE, YOU HAVE ACTUALLY OFFICIALLY RUINED MY LIFE UGH.
November 8, 2014
This book will impact you.
With her signature grace and heartwarming style, Joanne has crafted yet another unforgettable story: this time it may not end the way you expect.
Going in, I knew how things might play out, so I was prepared to cry. Little did I know how *joyful* the end of the book would leave me. Not only because the ending left some unexpected hope to be had, but because the entire story was just that: one of hope.
Sarah is relatable, shy, not great at math. But Tucker is, so he becomes her tutor--and a dear friend. Then, more.
In that sweet way Joanne is so good at, she spins their love story with tact and great spirit. And the tragedy feels less like tragedy and more like a longing fulfilled. It's hard to explain, really. You just need to read it.
And be prepared to not only cry but see great joy.
With her signature grace and heartwarming style, Joanne has crafted yet another unforgettable story: this time it may not end the way you expect.
Going in, I knew how things might play out, so I was prepared to cry. Little did I know how *joyful* the end of the book would leave me. Not only because the ending left some unexpected hope to be had, but because the entire story was just that: one of hope.
Sarah is relatable, shy, not great at math. But Tucker is, so he becomes her tutor--and a dear friend. Then, more.
In that sweet way Joanne is so good at, she spins their love story with tact and great spirit. And the tragedy feels less like tragedy and more like a longing fulfilled. It's hard to explain, really. You just need to read it.
And be prepared to not only cry but see great joy.
December 16, 2017
I am not okay right now.
I am just not okay.
I am so. Not. Okay.
This book hurt my heart. Don't read it if you don't want to cry, or at least have your heart broken.
Sarah and Tucker were such sweet, amazing characters. I wasn't super attached to them at first, but eventually they captured my heart. Tucker's attitude, and philosophy and outlook on life was so profound and beautiful. Sarah was such a realistic character, and I found myself relating to her more and more as I read.
All in all, a very sweet, heartbreaking book! Recommended!
CONTENT NOTE: There is a fair bit of romance, and a few semi-detailed kisses. Recommended for ages 16+.
I am just not okay.
I am so. Not. Okay.
This book hurt my heart. Don't read it if you don't want to cry, or at least have your heart broken.
Sarah and Tucker were such sweet, amazing characters. I wasn't super attached to them at first, but eventually they captured my heart. Tucker's attitude, and philosophy and outlook on life was so profound and beautiful. Sarah was such a realistic character, and I found myself relating to her more and more as I read.
All in all, a very sweet, heartbreaking book! Recommended!
CONTENT NOTE: There is a fair bit of romance, and a few semi-detailed kisses. Recommended for ages 16+.
September 5, 2018
I cannot tell you guys the last time a book made me feel so much! This book is absolutely beautiful!!! It made me smile, and cry (something I rarely do when reading books). Tucker is one of the most beautiful characters I've ever met <3 His and Sarah's story is just heart breaking and I loved every bit of it! I will definitely reread this one again in the future. 5 stars. I highly recommend it!!!!
June 21, 2018
Just. Too. Sweet. My heart can't take it. *tears flow*
July 25, 2018
About this book:
“There is nothing extraordinary about Tucker O’Shay’s dreams. Go to college. Become president. Fall in love. And pretend like he has enough time to get it all done.
Sixteen-year-old Sarah Miller doesn’t expect anything out of the ordinary when she begins her first day at the one-room-school house in her new hometown of Rocky Knob. But when she meets seventeen-year-old Tucker O’Shay—the boy with the fatal illness who volunteers to tutor her in algebra—she finds herself swept up in a friendship that changes the way she sees the world and a love that changes her life.”
Series: Connected to another series by the author.
Spiritual Content- A Scripture is read and mentioned a few times (not recognized as a Scripture, however); Talks about God & asking Him questions; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Sarah gets mad at God at a point, but gets better; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers & blessings over food; Mentions of churches & sermons; Mentions of Christmas songs; A few mentions of events in the Bible; A couple mentions of Bibles; A couple mentions of blessings; A couple mentions of sins; A mention of a book of the Bible; A mention of the sermon on the Mount; A mention of church mice; A mention of a hymn.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a form of ‘suckered’ and two ‘drat’s; Mentions of deaths; A couple mentions of a husband abusing his wife; A couple mentions of cheating; A couple mentions of sarcasm.
Sexual Content- a finger kiss, a hand kiss, a cheek kiss, two head/hair kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, four detailed kisses, a very detailed kiss; Remembering a kiss (semi-detailed); Touches, Nearness, Brushes, Heat/Warmth, & Tingles (semi-detailed); Noticing, Staring, & Butterflies (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of (and talks about) kisses & kissing; Mentions of flirting, blushes, & talking to the opposite gender; A few mentions of (being married and) feeling a husband’s skin and waking up next to him; A couple mentions of impropriety; A couple mentions of Maggie and her admirers; A mention of a man cornering Sarah; A mention of an attempted “necking” that resulted in the man being slapped; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Sarah’s parents were 14 & 19 when they married; A few mentions of Sarah saying she has no curves & later on the curves that she gets; A few mentions of a cancer that only men get (details are never named).
-Sarah Miller, age 16
1st person P.O.V. of Sarah
Set in 1885 (Epilogue in 1903)
149 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- One Star
My personal Rating- One Star
I was hoping to enjoy this one due to it being a Historical YA (something we don’t see too often) but, unfortunately, the sexual content was so much. The touchy and kissy parts are just too much for me to feel comfortable with reading—especially since this is supposed to be a Young Adult book.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
“There is nothing extraordinary about Tucker O’Shay’s dreams. Go to college. Become president. Fall in love. And pretend like he has enough time to get it all done.
Sixteen-year-old Sarah Miller doesn’t expect anything out of the ordinary when she begins her first day at the one-room-school house in her new hometown of Rocky Knob. But when she meets seventeen-year-old Tucker O’Shay—the boy with the fatal illness who volunteers to tutor her in algebra—she finds herself swept up in a friendship that changes the way she sees the world and a love that changes her life.”
Series: Connected to another series by the author.
Spiritual Content- A Scripture is read and mentioned a few times (not recognized as a Scripture, however); Talks about God & asking Him questions; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Sarah gets mad at God at a point, but gets better; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers & blessings over food; Mentions of churches & sermons; Mentions of Christmas songs; A few mentions of events in the Bible; A couple mentions of Bibles; A couple mentions of blessings; A couple mentions of sins; A mention of a book of the Bible; A mention of the sermon on the Mount; A mention of church mice; A mention of a hymn.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a form of ‘suckered’ and two ‘drat’s; Mentions of deaths; A couple mentions of a husband abusing his wife; A couple mentions of cheating; A couple mentions of sarcasm.
Sexual Content- a finger kiss, a hand kiss, a cheek kiss, two head/hair kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, four detailed kisses, a very detailed kiss; Remembering a kiss (semi-detailed); Touches, Nearness, Brushes, Heat/Warmth, & Tingles (semi-detailed); Noticing, Staring, & Butterflies (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of (and talks about) kisses & kissing; Mentions of flirting, blushes, & talking to the opposite gender; A few mentions of (being married and) feeling a husband’s skin and waking up next to him; A couple mentions of impropriety; A couple mentions of Maggie and her admirers; A mention of a man cornering Sarah; A mention of an attempted “necking” that resulted in the man being slapped; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Sarah’s parents were 14 & 19 when they married; A few mentions of Sarah saying she has no curves & later on the curves that she gets; A few mentions of a cancer that only men get (details are never named).
-Sarah Miller, age 16
1st person P.O.V. of Sarah
Set in 1885 (Epilogue in 1903)
149 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- One Star
My personal Rating- One Star
I was hoping to enjoy this one due to it being a Historical YA (something we don’t see too often) but, unfortunately, the sexual content was so much. The touchy and kissy parts are just too much for me to feel comfortable with reading—especially since this is supposed to be a Young Adult book.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
December 14, 2017
Re-Read December 2017:
Ouchhhhhh. I stayed up till 2 am ugly crying over this book because my poor heart. This story was crushing. Beautiful. Inspiring. Important.
And it taught me to listen for the sound of the cavalry.
His eyes are still closed, voice soft and near. Just for me. "I heard the cavalry when you sat beside me that first day."
5 stars!
///
WHO GAVE YOU PERMISSION TO CRUSH MY HEART AGAIN?! Seriously, I'm still recovering from Some Kind of Happiness, no need to kill my feels again.
But this book was so beautiful and touching and tragic. <3 It was written in first person present tense (again) and *gasp* I actually didn't mind! So either I'm starting to like it or it just suits the book really well.
I'm really at a loss as to what to say right now. This book was so. good. AND I WILL NEVER RECOVER. *sobs and pets the pretty cover*
Also, Tucker was really precious, just going to throw that out there. <3
Ouchhhhhh. I stayed up till 2 am ugly crying over this book because my poor heart. This story was crushing. Beautiful. Inspiring. Important.
And it taught me to listen for the sound of the cavalry.
His eyes are still closed, voice soft and near. Just for me. "I heard the cavalry when you sat beside me that first day."
5 stars!
///
WHO GAVE YOU PERMISSION TO CRUSH MY HEART AGAIN?! Seriously, I'm still recovering from Some Kind of Happiness, no need to kill my feels again.
But this book was so beautiful and touching and tragic. <3 It was written in first person present tense (again) and *gasp* I actually didn't mind! So either I'm starting to like it or it just suits the book really well.
I'm really at a loss as to what to say right now. This book was so. good. AND I WILL NEVER RECOVER. *sobs and pets the pretty cover*
Also, Tucker was really precious, just going to throw that out there. <3
March 4, 2016
So good, I can't even describe it! I needed tissues for about the last third -- the tears started to come like crazy. So sad, but such a great story.
First book I've read by Joanne, but I need to read her others. Definitely recommend This Quiet Sky!!
First book I've read by Joanne, but I need to read her others. Definitely recommend This Quiet Sky!!
November 3, 2019
Okay, I'll admit it: this book didn't exactly blow me away like I was hoping/expecting it would (my rating is between 3.5 and 4 stars; I don't know which!). BUT it was still good and very, very sweet. <3
Read
September 11, 2016This book. Wow, that hurt.
And now I have to go socialize. ;P
Full review to come!
And now I have to go socialize. ;P
Full review to come!
October 23, 2019
Quick, sweet, tragic. Sort of reminded me of a hallmark movie in that sense. Good for when you have a feel hours to kill and want some feels. You know from page one how it will end, but still you hope for some sort of miracle.
December 22, 2017
What I Loved...
Sarah and Tucker. Sarah is probably one of my favorite MCs of all time. She's so realistic and so strong, but in a quiet sort of way. I can definitely relate to her in her problems with algebra. xD I love how she interacts with the other characters, especially Tucker. And Tucker... Well, he's TUCKER. What's not to love?
Aaallll the feels. EVERYTHING about this book pulled at my heartstrings. I found myself smiling one minute, sighing the next, laughing a little bit, and then wanting to bawl my eyes out a few pages later. This is definitely heartfelt fiction.
Joanne Bischof's writing style. If you've stuck around my blog for awhile, you know that Joanne Bischof's other book, To Get To You, is another favorite book of mine, and one of the top reasons that I love this author's books is because of her writing style. Just read the quote below. YOU WILL UNDERSTAND.
What I Loved...
There wasn't anything that I didn't like about This Quiet Sky. It's that good.
Overall
I loved everything about This Quiet Sky and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good weekend read. =)
Sarah and Tucker. Sarah is probably one of my favorite MCs of all time. She's so realistic and so strong, but in a quiet sort of way. I can definitely relate to her in her problems with algebra. xD I love how she interacts with the other characters, especially Tucker. And Tucker... Well, he's TUCKER. What's not to love?
Aaallll the feels. EVERYTHING about this book pulled at my heartstrings. I found myself smiling one minute, sighing the next, laughing a little bit, and then wanting to bawl my eyes out a few pages later. This is definitely heartfelt fiction.
Joanne Bischof's writing style. If you've stuck around my blog for awhile, you know that Joanne Bischof's other book, To Get To You, is another favorite book of mine, and one of the top reasons that I love this author's books is because of her writing style. Just read the quote below. YOU WILL UNDERSTAND.
What I Loved...
There wasn't anything that I didn't like about This Quiet Sky. It's that good.
Overall
I loved everything about This Quiet Sky and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good weekend read. =)
August 15, 2016
I just ugly sobbed for the last quarter of the book. Fifteen solid minutes, and this book deserves all five stars I've given it, maybe even more than that.
This Quiet Sky broke my heart, and yet filled it with a lovely newness I've never felt before.
It was so beautiful, so heart-wrenching, and so refreshing. I'm kind of speechless, and this is definitely a new favorite.
I loved the sweet, sweet romance between Tucker and Sarah, how it was warm and tender, but never inappropriate.
I loved the smooth, crisp, writing style, and the way the book (and the author) made me feel like a friend.
I loved the characters, I loved the plot, and was so sad when it was over -- yet, it was a good length.
Even though This Quiet Sky tore my heart out, I didn't feel hopeless at the end. It was a good ending, if it had to end the way it did.
Now, please excuse me, and let me return to my sobbing. And...go buy this book.
This Quiet Sky broke my heart, and yet filled it with a lovely newness I've never felt before.
It was so beautiful, so heart-wrenching, and so refreshing. I'm kind of speechless, and this is definitely a new favorite.
I loved the sweet, sweet romance between Tucker and Sarah, how it was warm and tender, but never inappropriate.
I loved the smooth, crisp, writing style, and the way the book (and the author) made me feel like a friend.
I loved the characters, I loved the plot, and was so sad when it was over -- yet, it was a good length.
Even though This Quiet Sky tore my heart out, I didn't feel hopeless at the end. It was a good ending, if it had to end the way it did.
Now, please excuse me, and let me return to my sobbing. And...go buy this book.
January 25, 2026
It's taken me this long to write my review because I didn't know how to put my feelings into words... and I still don't.
This is what I say each time after reading one of Bischof's books, and I don't think I'll ever be able to stop saying it. She writes exquisite masterpieces that do more than just tug at my heartstrings. They break me and piece me back together better than I ever was before. They leave me longing for more yet forever content with what's been given to me.
Read this book. You'll see what I mean 🤎🦋
This is what I say each time after reading one of Bischof's books, and I don't think I'll ever be able to stop saying it. She writes exquisite masterpieces that do more than just tug at my heartstrings. They break me and piece me back together better than I ever was before. They leave me longing for more yet forever content with what's been given to me.
Read this book. You'll see what I mean 🤎🦋
December 28, 2018
So I just read this and if you follow me on Instagram you'll know that I already said this but SERIOUSLY! I haven't read a book this amazing and beautiful and just (my heart. I don't even know how to describe it) since I read I Don't Dance by Jesseca Wheaton. If you guys have known me for any amount of time you know I adore I Don't Dance. This book is as good. That's saying A LOT.
It is a romance, but so clean, and so sweet, and so beautiful, melodies. I hear the calvary. And I did cry. I cried. I literally shook as I cried and cried until I could read again.
It was like... y'all, I don't even know how to express how amazing it was. Please just go order it from your library right now or (better yet) but a copy RIGHT NOW! It's so good. 😭😭😭😭.
The romance was a tad bit more physical than I Don't Dance but in no way was it inappropriate and I wouldn't even worry about it any. 16 and up (because I don't recommend reading romances if you're younger than that) but content wise it was clean enough for even 12 and up.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 FIVE STARS!
It is a romance, but so clean, and so sweet, and so beautiful, melodies. I hear the calvary. And I did cry. I cried. I literally shook as I cried and cried until I could read again.
It was like... y'all, I don't even know how to express how amazing it was. Please just go order it from your library right now or (better yet) but a copy RIGHT NOW! It's so good. 😭😭😭😭.
The romance was a tad bit more physical than I Don't Dance but in no way was it inappropriate and I wouldn't even worry about it any. 16 and up (because I don't recommend reading romances if you're younger than that) but content wise it was clean enough for even 12 and up.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 FIVE STARS!
October 16, 2016
(Updated review from a re read)
Okay.
I reviewed this book a longggggg time ago. I just re read (hahaha again it's practically suicide).... well listened on audio (which makes it stab your fragile heart 192719 times harder) but ya know, some books are worth dying for.
This is one of them.
Tucker O'Shay
He is precious
Makes me cry. I rarely, if not ever, cry in books. I've only cried for this one and maybe 1 or 2 others. I started the audio and after like 30 seconds I was fighting tears.
Tucker O'Shay for president please! He would be perfect
I hate this book. Like I don't want to never read it again. I hate it cause Tucker rips my heart and it makes me want to curl up and cry.
Horrible in a good way. I love it so much.
I'm 99% sure rereading this shortens my life span.
Sarah.
Oh man.
She's so sweet to Tucker and gahhhh.
I just can't. I'm having in-coming tears legit right now.
Okay okay
I'm good now
Their relationship is the sweetest thing you will ever grave your eyes upon ever.
I can't make a ship name because why would you purposely send a package you know will never arrive?
I ship it.
But ack. I can't
I can't
I can't
Now I'm just ranting and being emotional
But the book is so great. It's has this feel when you read it that makes you feel like you're on a porch with her. Listening to her story. Eating shortbread and laughing about the little bit of hair that won't stay in place.
Yeah it's like 159 pages
But no page is wasted
No par is 'eh I could care less'
Every page is special and I want to copy them all and make a wall in my room cause why not?
Oh Tucker. The chapter where he.... where Sarah
Benjamin comes
She's sobbing
I can't even say what. It breaks me every time.
It's unconditional love.
This is a very jumbled review
But go read this book now cause it'll change you
Okay.
I reviewed this book a longggggg time ago. I just re read (hahaha again it's practically suicide).... well listened on audio (which makes it stab your fragile heart 192719 times harder) but ya know, some books are worth dying for.
This is one of them.
Tucker O'Shay
He is precious
Makes me cry. I rarely, if not ever, cry in books. I've only cried for this one and maybe 1 or 2 others. I started the audio and after like 30 seconds I was fighting tears.
Tucker O'Shay for president please! He would be perfect
I hate this book. Like I don't want to never read it again. I hate it cause Tucker rips my heart and it makes me want to curl up and cry.
Horrible in a good way. I love it so much.
I'm 99% sure rereading this shortens my life span.
Sarah.
Oh man.
She's so sweet to Tucker and gahhhh.
I just can't. I'm having in-coming tears legit right now.
Okay okay
I'm good now
Their relationship is the sweetest thing you will ever grave your eyes upon ever.
I can't make a ship name because why would you purposely send a package you know will never arrive?
I ship it.
But ack. I can't
I can't
I can't
Now I'm just ranting and being emotional
But the book is so great. It's has this feel when you read it that makes you feel like you're on a porch with her. Listening to her story. Eating shortbread and laughing about the little bit of hair that won't stay in place.
Yeah it's like 159 pages
But no page is wasted
No par is 'eh I could care less'
Every page is special and I want to copy them all and make a wall in my room cause why not?
Oh Tucker. The chapter where he.... where Sarah
Benjamin comes
She's sobbing
I can't even say what. It breaks me every time.
It's unconditional love.
This is a very jumbled review
But go read this book now cause it'll change you
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 23, 2017
This book broke my heart. Honestly. I’m still sniffling, and my eyes are burning from crying. I was warned, knew the book plot, but still, this book broke through and crushed my heart. It’s beautiful, incredibly powerful, and heart-breaking.
I’ve heard it compared to Anne of Green Gables in its feel, and I have to agree in some respects; although this story was so unique and special compared to any other I’ve read. I loved the feel and setting of the story, and Tucker and Sarah’s first meeting in the schoolhouse did remind me of Anne’s and Gilbert’s. But so much more powerful. The depth and meaning woven into this story is so incredible and far exceeded my expectations even after I had read glowing reviews from my friends! In many ways, reading this book was like reading a childhood favorite book, a book I’ve loved all my life and never will go old of; it held the same charm while reading it.
Tucker is so “Tucker.” There’s no other way I could really describe him, and I’m only typing this with tears in my eyes and a smile over his sense of humor and everything else about him. From the moment when he was introduced, coughing over poor Sarah’s awful algebra exam answers, he won my heart, and I was pulled into this little novella that I was only planning on reading a chapter or two of before going to bed. Instead, I was up till two a.m. reading.
Knowing the end, I was wondering how in the world the author would be able to pull off an ending that was meaningful and not full of despair or cliché. But she did, leaving me not feeling empty but rather smiling and reminded of how amazingly beautiful trust in God looks like lived out in a person’s life.
This Quiet Sky is a masterfully written novella by Joanne Bischof that I’d highly recommend getting your hands on a copy of. I’m fully planning on ordering a paperback for myself before the day’s out. I know I’ll be lending it out and rereading, without a doubt.
I’ve heard it compared to Anne of Green Gables in its feel, and I have to agree in some respects; although this story was so unique and special compared to any other I’ve read. I loved the feel and setting of the story, and Tucker and Sarah’s first meeting in the schoolhouse did remind me of Anne’s and Gilbert’s. But so much more powerful. The depth and meaning woven into this story is so incredible and far exceeded my expectations even after I had read glowing reviews from my friends! In many ways, reading this book was like reading a childhood favorite book, a book I’ve loved all my life and never will go old of; it held the same charm while reading it.
Tucker is so “Tucker.” There’s no other way I could really describe him, and I’m only typing this with tears in my eyes and a smile over his sense of humor and everything else about him. From the moment when he was introduced, coughing over poor Sarah’s awful algebra exam answers, he won my heart, and I was pulled into this little novella that I was only planning on reading a chapter or two of before going to bed. Instead, I was up till two a.m. reading.
Knowing the end, I was wondering how in the world the author would be able to pull off an ending that was meaningful and not full of despair or cliché. But she did, leaving me not feeling empty but rather smiling and reminded of how amazingly beautiful trust in God looks like lived out in a person’s life.
This Quiet Sky is a masterfully written novella by Joanne Bischof that I’d highly recommend getting your hands on a copy of. I’m fully planning on ordering a paperback for myself before the day’s out. I know I’ll be lending it out and rereading, without a doubt.
August 19, 2016
{3.5 stars}
Okay, so I read this over a year ago and now have just been able to write a normal review. That's the bad thing about writing one right after you finish an emotional driven book. This. Book. Will. Make. You. Cry.
Sarah and Tucker are so sweet together. I was attached wtih them from the moment they meet at the school, and how well they compliment each other. I read this book in one sitting and was teary-eyed the rest of the day.
Now to the part that I always hate...
Dislikes:
-A little too romantic for my taste. I passed over it the first time because I loved the book so much, but it did bother me mainly because they were so young!!
-There was so little about Sarah's family. I know that wasn't the focus of the book, but they almost felt like puppets, there yet not noticeable in the least.
-I hadn't thought of it much until I read a review that pointed it out (https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...), but there isn't a lot of Christanity in this book. When I read this book a second time, I realized that. Since it is a short book, I don't mind too much, but I still would have liked a little bit more.
-So maybe this is not really a dislike, but it still ruined my day. And don't look at the spoiler if you haven't read the book!!
Likes:
-Oh yay...likes are easy :) I know I already mentioned Sarah and Tucker, but let me bring them up again. I just love them and their friendship.
-The scene when Sarah and Tucker first meet.
-I love the writing style. It makes it more dear to heart because it's happening in the present.
-The prologue was a great way to wrap up things. There even was a little hint of something for the future.
Truly this is a five star book! Even my brother rated it that (and so did I) back when he first read it and I don't debate his rating for a moment!-https://www.goodreads.com/review/show.... So folks, this is an amazing book, but just remember the cons ;) They didn't bother me the first read too much, but once my brain was cleared I noticed them.
Okay, so I read this over a year ago and now have just been able to write a normal review. That's the bad thing about writing one right after you finish an emotional driven book. This. Book. Will. Make. You. Cry.
Sarah and Tucker are so sweet together. I was attached wtih them from the moment they meet at the school, and how well they compliment each other. I read this book in one sitting and was teary-eyed the rest of the day.
Now to the part that I always hate...
Dislikes:
-A little too romantic for my taste. I passed over it the first time because I loved the book so much, but it did bother me mainly because they were so young!!
-There was so little about Sarah's family. I know that wasn't the focus of the book, but they almost felt like puppets, there yet not noticeable in the least.
-I hadn't thought of it much until I read a review that pointed it out (https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...), but there isn't a lot of Christanity in this book. When I read this book a second time, I realized that. Since it is a short book, I don't mind too much, but I still would have liked a little bit more.
-So maybe this is not really a dislike, but it still ruined my day. And don't look at the spoiler if you haven't read the book!!
Likes:
-Oh yay...likes are easy :) I know I already mentioned Sarah and Tucker, but let me bring them up again. I just love them and their friendship.
-The scene when Sarah and Tucker first meet.
-I love the writing style. It makes it more dear to heart because it's happening in the present.
-The prologue was a great way to wrap up things. There even was a little hint of something for the future.
Truly this is a five star book! Even my brother rated it that (and so did I) back when he first read it and I don't debate his rating for a moment!-https://www.goodreads.com/review/show.... So folks, this is an amazing book, but just remember the cons ;) They didn't bother me the first read too much, but once my brain was cleared I noticed them.
December 18, 2017
Oh, my heart! This story brings so many words to mind - tragic, yes, but also triumphant, poignant, tender, and beautiful. This is one of the more well-done novellas I've read. It is a complete story, and it is just long enough for a story of such depth. Perhaps it's a bit heavy, yes, but it's not without hope, nor is it depressing. It is real and features true-to-life sadness. Even knowing that this story was probably going to go a certain way, I still read eagerly, loving the prose and that unique quality of writing that is entirely Joanne Bischof.
The characters came to life for me. Sarah is a lovely. I loved her realism, and I related to her so much - especially her shyness and her lack of math skills. Tucker O'Shay starts out as her tutor, then becomes much more important to her as the story progresses. Tucker is just one of the best characters I've "met" this year. His friendship with Sarah is special and tugged at my heart. They choose risk instead of safety, and though it brought them pain, it was ultimately the best choice. I feel richer for having experienced their story.
The epilogue does a nice job of answering questions about Sarah's future, and it also connects nicely to the characters in the Cadence of Grace series (though I've only read book one of that). I also thought that perhaps a new happiness was on the horizon for Sarah, but that could have just been my romantic heart finding things that weren't there. Regardless, it provided a lovely sense of closure.
The characters came to life for me. Sarah is a lovely. I loved her realism, and I related to her so much - especially her shyness and her lack of math skills. Tucker O'Shay starts out as her tutor, then becomes much more important to her as the story progresses. Tucker is just one of the best characters I've "met" this year. His friendship with Sarah is special and tugged at my heart. They choose risk instead of safety, and though it brought them pain, it was ultimately the best choice. I feel richer for having experienced their story.
The epilogue does a nice job of answering questions about Sarah's future, and it also connects nicely to the characters in the Cadence of Grace series (though I've only read book one of that). I also thought that perhaps a new happiness was on the horizon for Sarah, but that could have just been my romantic heart finding things that weren't there. Regardless, it provided a lovely sense of closure.
July 10, 2017
This is one of my favorite books. Even if it will make your heart hurt. Sarah and Tucker- perfect yet impossible. Joanne Bischof does an excellent job spinning this tale, and it will really help your appreciation of the story if you read the Cadence of Grace series first. Don't miss this novella!
January 28, 2016
ohmyword this book! it's so good!! it kind of had an 'Anne Of Green Gables' feel.
Tucker guys.
Tuckerrrr.
me loves him...
rating: clean (some kissing)
Tucker guys.
Tuckerrrr.
me loves him...
rating: clean (some kissing)
December 18, 2021
Rocky Knob, Virginia 1885
Sweet love story about young love and loss.
Sweet love story about young love and loss.
June 12, 2015
See full review at The Power of Words: http://bit.ly/1I7N2TJ
I read This Quiet Sky last week, pondered for a while about what to say in my review, then decided to read it a second time instead. However, I'm still no closer to finding adequate words to do justice to this heartfelt and memorable story.
First, the tangibles. This Quiet Sky is a poignantly beautiful novella, exquisite in its simplicity, and a prequel to Be Still My Soul, book #1 in the Cadence of Grace series. It's a tender, bittersweet story of the young, but enduring, love between Lonnie's Aunt Sarah and Tucker O'Shay. And it's penned by a master at crafting imagery, rich characters, emotions, and invaluable life lessons. In Joann's capable hands, a story of love that would seem hopeless on the surface is transformed into a heartwarming portrait of the hope that only comes from above.
Tucker and Sarah are so very real and easy to relate to - from Tucker's vulnerability, intellect, self confidence, and sense of humor, to Sarah's journey from friendship into a relationship which led her to the putting of another's needs first. This Quiet Sky reflects life, the realities of which are seen in Tucker's words, "Sometimes an entirely different equation than you expect is staring you in the face." And there's just the right injection of humor with great scenes, such as Tucker's conjugation of Latin verbs and the favorite "Tucker stories" shared at a family birthday party. reflect
Now for the intangibles . . . I am so glad that Joann told the story that was on her heart, and I believe it is a story that had to be told. This Quiet Sky is in a class all by itself, for I can't think of another story to which it could be compared. The best stories entertain, but in addition to that, they challenge you, make you change or grow in some way - and that's what This Quiet Sky did for me.
I want to be like Sarah when I grow up - to be able to see the person, not the illness; to risk; to love selflessly and grow in the ways that she did. I wish I could have reached out and embraced Sarah when she realized, "It's now I who will be brave for him."
Joann ends with an epilogue that takes place several years later, giving beautiful closure to the story. Another character that I'm drawn to is Benjamin, Tucker's brother, and I hope that Joann will someday return to Rocky Knob, Virginia, with more stories from these families.
This Quiet Sky is a story that lives on in my heart and I am a better person for having read it. Very highly recommended.
Thank you to Joann for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
I read This Quiet Sky last week, pondered for a while about what to say in my review, then decided to read it a second time instead. However, I'm still no closer to finding adequate words to do justice to this heartfelt and memorable story.
First, the tangibles. This Quiet Sky is a poignantly beautiful novella, exquisite in its simplicity, and a prequel to Be Still My Soul, book #1 in the Cadence of Grace series. It's a tender, bittersweet story of the young, but enduring, love between Lonnie's Aunt Sarah and Tucker O'Shay. And it's penned by a master at crafting imagery, rich characters, emotions, and invaluable life lessons. In Joann's capable hands, a story of love that would seem hopeless on the surface is transformed into a heartwarming portrait of the hope that only comes from above.
Tucker and Sarah are so very real and easy to relate to - from Tucker's vulnerability, intellect, self confidence, and sense of humor, to Sarah's journey from friendship into a relationship which led her to the putting of another's needs first. This Quiet Sky reflects life, the realities of which are seen in Tucker's words, "Sometimes an entirely different equation than you expect is staring you in the face." And there's just the right injection of humor with great scenes, such as Tucker's conjugation of Latin verbs and the favorite "Tucker stories" shared at a family birthday party. reflect
Now for the intangibles . . . I am so glad that Joann told the story that was on her heart, and I believe it is a story that had to be told. This Quiet Sky is in a class all by itself, for I can't think of another story to which it could be compared. The best stories entertain, but in addition to that, they challenge you, make you change or grow in some way - and that's what This Quiet Sky did for me.
I want to be like Sarah when I grow up - to be able to see the person, not the illness; to risk; to love selflessly and grow in the ways that she did. I wish I could have reached out and embraced Sarah when she realized, "It's now I who will be brave for him."
Joann ends with an epilogue that takes place several years later, giving beautiful closure to the story. Another character that I'm drawn to is Benjamin, Tucker's brother, and I hope that Joann will someday return to Rocky Knob, Virginia, with more stories from these families.
This Quiet Sky is a story that lives on in my heart and I am a better person for having read it. Very highly recommended.
Thank you to Joann for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
December 2, 2015
I'm debating 3.5 stars here. Such a sweet and sad story wrapped in one! It does help give one a new perspective on life--what if you knew your life was near ending?
The story of Tucker and his illness and friendship with Sarah was touching. The romance? I'm just not a big romance fan, so having the whole book revolving around their love, the many moments of touching, the kisses, etc. pulled my personal rating lower.
Also, being written in first person, present tense was very different! It was neat, but something I don't think I've read before (at least in this length).
There did not seem to be a very strong Christian message throughout the entire book--mainly one or two chapters when Tucker is sharing what he's been learning, being sick. But as for God being a part of their everyday lives, it wasn't really there (another reason I'd consider 3.5).
But if you want an easy read that is super sweet and may induce some tears, this is the book!
*I received this book from the author as a gift and was not expected to review it*
The story of Tucker and his illness and friendship with Sarah was touching. The romance? I'm just not a big romance fan, so having the whole book revolving around their love, the many moments of touching, the kisses, etc. pulled my personal rating lower.
Also, being written in first person, present tense was very different! It was neat, but something I don't think I've read before (at least in this length).
There did not seem to be a very strong Christian message throughout the entire book--mainly one or two chapters when Tucker is sharing what he's been learning, being sick. But as for God being a part of their everyday lives, it wasn't really there (another reason I'd consider 3.5).
But if you want an easy read that is super sweet and may induce some tears, this is the book!
*I received this book from the author as a gift and was not expected to review it*
July 21, 2015
This is a beautifully gripping book. Attachment to the characters is guaranteed ... as is a good cry. Definitely recommended.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 223 reviews