What do you think?
Antique: A Novel
An uplifting, magical story about a once-celebrated antique appraiser who gets caught in the thrall of a strange, powerful necklace—one that has the power to transform her life, and the fortunes of those around her.
Grace Schaffer is adrift. Raised by an eminent but emotionally withdrawn scholar, her talent landed her a coveted spot on Antiques Roadshow, where she charmed legions of viewers. But she's recently fallen from her gilded perch, losing her career, her marriage and her very identity in the process, leaving her with the same question her clients so often ask of What is it worth? Or, the question that beats beneath it, What am I worth?
In a last-ditch attempt to revive her career, she signs on to an amateur travelling show, where an old, tarnished necklace catches her eye. Imbued with a strange and sudden confidence, she begins predicting the precise amount that objects will sell for at auction—far beyond their market values. As she performs act after act of this seeming divination, Grace catches the attention of detractors and fans alike, all clamoring to see what she’ll do next. Caught in the necklace’s strange and possibly dangerous thrall, Grace is soon thrust into the hunt to uncover a lost masterpiece… before it disappears forever, taking her hopes and dreams with it.
As Grace struggles to find her own worth outside the comfort of marriage, the limelight of career, of even the necklace’s awesome power, she comes face to face with the hardest appraisal of all…herself. Antique takes readers on an exhilarating journey of art and love, one that will leave them believing in the magic that lies within us all—should we dare to use it.
Grace Schaffer is adrift. Raised by an eminent but emotionally withdrawn scholar, her talent landed her a coveted spot on Antiques Roadshow, where she charmed legions of viewers. But she's recently fallen from her gilded perch, losing her career, her marriage and her very identity in the process, leaving her with the same question her clients so often ask of What is it worth? Or, the question that beats beneath it, What am I worth?
In a last-ditch attempt to revive her career, she signs on to an amateur travelling show, where an old, tarnished necklace catches her eye. Imbued with a strange and sudden confidence, she begins predicting the precise amount that objects will sell for at auction—far beyond their market values. As she performs act after act of this seeming divination, Grace catches the attention of detractors and fans alike, all clamoring to see what she’ll do next. Caught in the necklace’s strange and possibly dangerous thrall, Grace is soon thrust into the hunt to uncover a lost masterpiece… before it disappears forever, taking her hopes and dreams with it.
As Grace struggles to find her own worth outside the comfort of marriage, the limelight of career, of even the necklace’s awesome power, she comes face to face with the hardest appraisal of all…herself. Antique takes readers on an exhilarating journey of art and love, one that will leave them believing in the magic that lies within us all—should we dare to use it.
347 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 3, 2026
About the author
Seth Panitch
3 books34 followersSeth Panitch’s debut novel, ANTIQUE, will be released February 3, 2026 by Grand Central/ Hachette Publishing. His plays Dammit, Shakespeare!, Hell: Paradise Found (Broadway Play Publishing, Inc.), Alcestis Ascending, and Separate and Equal have all been produced Off Broadway, and his films Service to Man and The Coming are distributed by Freestyle Entertainment Studios and Terror Films. Seth is also a Professor of Theatre and directs the MFA Acting Program at the University of Alabama. Far more importantly, he is married to Laura Panitch, who does not seem to mind when he creeps upstairs to write, or when he lets their dog Moses use him as a jungle gym. Seth is a proud member of the Author’s Guild, the Dramatists Guild of America, the Society of Directors and Choreographers, and the Illuminati – although he has steadfastly refused to have their names tattooed onto his chest.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews
April 23, 2026
If you are a lover of antiques you will love this book. Whether it's for the thrill of maybe finding that elusive piece of history that will bring you fortune or just the happiness of finding something that speaks to your heart.
I really enjoy watching The Antiques Road Show on PBS. And also searching all the nooks and crannies of all the shops along the antiques trail. The old books, paintings, and the occasional piece of furniture call to me.
This was a fun page turner following a young appraiser and her search for her "grail."
I really enjoy watching The Antiques Road Show on PBS. And also searching all the nooks and crannies of all the shops along the antiques trail. The old books, paintings, and the occasional piece of furniture call to me.
This was a fun page turner following a young appraiser and her search for her "grail."
November 19, 2025
I really enjoyed this debut novel. It started a little slow but the magical realism experienced by Grace, an antique appraiser, was a pick me up, for sure. Grace had reached the summit of appraisers by being on the popular Antiques Roadshow but fell out of grace (no pun intended) and had to start over. The appraisers were an interesting group, and Jerome Zwick, was probably my favorite character. He supported Grace in his own way and helped her regain her confidence and independence. It made me happy to see Grace come into her own. I rate this book a 3.5 rounded up to 4⭐️.
Thanks to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the eARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
Thanks to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the eARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
June 10, 2026
Antique is a thoughtful magical realism novel centered on Grace, an antique appraiser who discovers a mysterious necklace that gives her the uncanny ability to predict exactly what objects will sell for at auction. While there is a magical element at the heart of the story, this is ultimately much more about Grace’s personal journey than about the magic itself.
One thing I appreciated was Grace as a protagonist. I’m often hesitant when reading female main characters written by male authors, but Grace felt authentic, vulnerable, and determined. Watching her gradually find her voice and wrestle with questions of purpose, identity, and legacy made for an engaging character arc.
The novel reminded me quite a bit of Aftertaste by Daria Lavelle. Where Aftertaste used magical realism to explore the fine dining world, Antique uses it to explore collectors, appraisers, and auction houses. As someone who knows very little about antiques, I found that aspect of the book fascinating. The details of the auction world were immersive and often surprisingly ruthless.
The strongest theme for me was the exploration of value. The story repeatedly asks what makes something worth what it is worth. Is it rarity? History? Sentiment? Ownership? The answer is constantly shifting depending on who is looking at the object and what story accompanies it. That theme carried emotional weight throughout the novel and connected beautifully to Grace’s own search for meaning.
The family relationships are also a major part of the story and provide much of its emotional depth.
My main criticism is that I would have liked more development for some of the supporting characters, particularly Victor and Grace’s mother. Their relationships with Grace felt important, but I wanted a deeper exploration of both.
Overall, this wasn’t entirely my usual type of book, but I’m glad I read it. Readers who enjoy thoughtful literary fiction, light magical realism, family stories, and niche professional worlds will likely find a lot to appreciate here. And if you’re interested in antiques or collecting, this one feels especially worth picking up.
Thank you to Seth Panitch for providing me with a gifted copy of Antique.
One thing I appreciated was Grace as a protagonist. I’m often hesitant when reading female main characters written by male authors, but Grace felt authentic, vulnerable, and determined. Watching her gradually find her voice and wrestle with questions of purpose, identity, and legacy made for an engaging character arc.
The novel reminded me quite a bit of Aftertaste by Daria Lavelle. Where Aftertaste used magical realism to explore the fine dining world, Antique uses it to explore collectors, appraisers, and auction houses. As someone who knows very little about antiques, I found that aspect of the book fascinating. The details of the auction world were immersive and often surprisingly ruthless.
The strongest theme for me was the exploration of value. The story repeatedly asks what makes something worth what it is worth. Is it rarity? History? Sentiment? Ownership? The answer is constantly shifting depending on who is looking at the object and what story accompanies it. That theme carried emotional weight throughout the novel and connected beautifully to Grace’s own search for meaning.
The family relationships are also a major part of the story and provide much of its emotional depth.
My main criticism is that I would have liked more development for some of the supporting characters, particularly Victor and Grace’s mother. Their relationships with Grace felt important, but I wanted a deeper exploration of both.
Overall, this wasn’t entirely my usual type of book, but I’m glad I read it. Readers who enjoy thoughtful literary fiction, light magical realism, family stories, and niche professional worlds will likely find a lot to appreciate here. And if you’re interested in antiques or collecting, this one feels especially worth picking up.
Thank you to Seth Panitch for providing me with a gifted copy of Antique.
March 7, 2026
Appraising art and ourselves (traveling roadshows NJ, New England, Indiana, upstate NY, NYC, London (ancient times to present-day): Antique is so electrifying, it’s hard to believe it’s Seth Panitch’s debut novel.
On display is a passion for the arts. Creative juices. A flair for the dramatic by the Professor of Theatre at the University of Alabama who runs their MFA Acting Program. Having written Off Broadway plays and films, he appears to have transmitted his performance art writing skills into another format to produce a wildly entertaining literary performance.
Crediting the “experts, appraisers, creators, producers, and guests of the Antiques Roadshow,” (now in its 30th season), his author notes also say he “cannot watch the legendary show without laughing, crying, or learning something new about the art within us all.” So it follows then that he’d want to open us to the mystique of the art world crafting an original story with heart, while offering an impressive knowledge of ancient history and antiquities pitting compassion against prevailing art market appraisals.
This fictional roadshow takes us to the world’s top auction houses Sotheby’s and Christie’s, to Bonham’s and Heritage Auctions, and to Main Street ones.
America’s Antiques Roadshow was inspired by the British version that launched in 1979. Even the description of it shows off Panitch’s energetic writing style: as “an empire that spanned nine British Prime Ministers and eight US Presidents spawning a worldwide sensation over which the sun, quite literally, never set.” Expect, then, to feel the sensational frenzy of an exciting auction as if you were sitting in the audience holding your numbered paddle glued to the auctioneer caught up in the process.
Inventing a struggling Appraisal Experts Roadshow with a cast of appraisal characters needing to prove their worth, the main character, Grace Schaffer, is most need of recovering her former glory and sense of worth.
Once a celebrity appraisal expert at Christie’s, Grace has fallen from grace. As a consequence, her Manhattan art gallery Schaffer and Schaffer has also fallen on hard times. Reputations in the art world can fall precipitously; trust is hard to earn back. The second Schaffer is a painful reminder of her renowned art historian father who passed away two years ago when the novel opens. Flailing, she feels disgraced and is terribly lonesome.
Grace could use a bit of magic. Panitch delivers it to her.
In so doing, his vision for putting on a brilliant literary show not only asks “What is it worth?” but “What am I worth?” Panitch’s immeasurable gifts – dazzling prose, setting up intrigue, and insight into human nature and groupthink – reveal a master at his game.
Antique raises the bar on fiction with its finesse of how all of us are constantly appraising everything and everyone in life. Including, especially, ourselves.
Grace’s story began in childhood, “swept up” into her father’s world. Albert was one of the “True Art Historians, and her “magnetic north.” In awe of him; he, sadly, in awe of himself. The only time she could enter his “forbidden world,” the only way she got to spend any time with him, was in his stately office. All it takes are two words to picture a young girl respectfully knocking on the door of her father’s kingdom, addressing him as his Columbia University students’ do, “Dr. Schaffer,” he never correcting her, for you to know something odd is afoot.
Meanwhile, Grace’s mother Shirley is treated with borderline disdain. Condescending messages sent that she couldn’t possibly grasp the complexities, intricacies, history of Art. The triangular family dynamics are provocative; gratifying when Grace and the reader see what the real Shirley is made of.
Grace’s story is one of second chances. A die-hard supporter from her previous life, Elaine demonstrates what’s it’s truly like when a colleague’s respect is no-holds back as she sticks her neck out to support discredited Grace, offering her a way to re-enter the appraisal world, revive her gallery business, and herself. When she invites Grace to join the Appraisal Experts Roadshow, Grace is unsure of herself, rusty, wary and weary of others appraising her, directly or indirectly. One appraiser is particularly nasty; satisfying when she gets what she deserves artfully without the crassness.
When Grace comes into possession of something her colleagues don’t have, something comes over her. You can guess at what might have happened to account for her downfall, but you’ll never guess what is about to happen.
Panitch never bores. Starting on page one, he introduces an ancient object that’s at least five thousand years old. Its powers are bewitching, as is the prose:
“The object is a necklace, once “six strings . . . threaded with the riches of Empire.” Its provenance traced back to the “Babylonian God of Wisdom.” Passed down through the Biblical ages to Egypt, to the Sinai, to the Ottoman Turks to 1917, the “Common Era,” when it’s “stolen by an American spy. What’s left is one string: “twelve cylindrically shaped stones of pure onyx spaced with Nubian gold nuggets . . . fastened in the very center, between two crimson bloodstones, hung the celestial globe itself: a marble-size stone of the finest lapis lazuli, mined in the ancient limestone beds of Pakistan. It emerged from the earth a perfect sphere” with “golden pyrite inclusions that shimmer like starbursts across the deep blue face of the stone. To hold the globe was to grasp the Cosmos.”
Grace is drawn to the deep blue stone artifact despite its poor condition. Lapis lazuli is a stone with ancient and modern spiritual history. Believed to have “healing” powers that can reveal “inner truth.” Again, fitting for Grace. Her appraisal of the object shocks. Grace doesn’t back down, instead digs in, not wanting to crush the dreams of someone in need of a break, luck, a boost.
An element of the appraisal process we might not have considered, given we’re inclined to focus on the currency side of it, is the emotional impact of letting down the owner of the object. Grace will surely win your heart. So too her low self-esteem believing the “celestial globe” has granted her fantastical powers.
The ancient stone conveys ancient history of the Cosmos. How the Earth was considered spherical “dates all the way back to the 6th century BC,” chimes in the oldest appraiser Jerome on the fictional roadshow. At seventy, the thirty-year age difference with Grace charms as their relationship comes alive for each other.
Panitch’s antique roadshow makes stops in shopping malls, historic venues, small cities, and big ones. At each one, Grace holds the “celestial globe” in her hands, feels it go from cold to warmer, then starts spinning “faster and faster,” getting hotter, “metamorphosing into dizzying, impossible combinations.” The force of its energy fires up Grace to appraise seemingly worthless objects at astronomical valuations.
Along with the drama, you’ll detect a melancholy sentiment on how the “Modern and Avant-Garde” movements have taken over today’s art market beyond anything imaginable.
So too Panitch’s spinning of Grace’s extraordinary appraisals. How they turn out, and what they say about Grace.
On display is a passion for the arts. Creative juices. A flair for the dramatic by the Professor of Theatre at the University of Alabama who runs their MFA Acting Program. Having written Off Broadway plays and films, he appears to have transmitted his performance art writing skills into another format to produce a wildly entertaining literary performance.
Crediting the “experts, appraisers, creators, producers, and guests of the Antiques Roadshow,” (now in its 30th season), his author notes also say he “cannot watch the legendary show without laughing, crying, or learning something new about the art within us all.” So it follows then that he’d want to open us to the mystique of the art world crafting an original story with heart, while offering an impressive knowledge of ancient history and antiquities pitting compassion against prevailing art market appraisals.
This fictional roadshow takes us to the world’s top auction houses Sotheby’s and Christie’s, to Bonham’s and Heritage Auctions, and to Main Street ones.
America’s Antiques Roadshow was inspired by the British version that launched in 1979. Even the description of it shows off Panitch’s energetic writing style: as “an empire that spanned nine British Prime Ministers and eight US Presidents spawning a worldwide sensation over which the sun, quite literally, never set.” Expect, then, to feel the sensational frenzy of an exciting auction as if you were sitting in the audience holding your numbered paddle glued to the auctioneer caught up in the process.
Inventing a struggling Appraisal Experts Roadshow with a cast of appraisal characters needing to prove their worth, the main character, Grace Schaffer, is most need of recovering her former glory and sense of worth.
Once a celebrity appraisal expert at Christie’s, Grace has fallen from grace. As a consequence, her Manhattan art gallery Schaffer and Schaffer has also fallen on hard times. Reputations in the art world can fall precipitously; trust is hard to earn back. The second Schaffer is a painful reminder of her renowned art historian father who passed away two years ago when the novel opens. Flailing, she feels disgraced and is terribly lonesome.
Grace could use a bit of magic. Panitch delivers it to her.
In so doing, his vision for putting on a brilliant literary show not only asks “What is it worth?” but “What am I worth?” Panitch’s immeasurable gifts – dazzling prose, setting up intrigue, and insight into human nature and groupthink – reveal a master at his game.
Antique raises the bar on fiction with its finesse of how all of us are constantly appraising everything and everyone in life. Including, especially, ourselves.
Grace’s story began in childhood, “swept up” into her father’s world. Albert was one of the “True Art Historians, and her “magnetic north.” In awe of him; he, sadly, in awe of himself. The only time she could enter his “forbidden world,” the only way she got to spend any time with him, was in his stately office. All it takes are two words to picture a young girl respectfully knocking on the door of her father’s kingdom, addressing him as his Columbia University students’ do, “Dr. Schaffer,” he never correcting her, for you to know something odd is afoot.
Meanwhile, Grace’s mother Shirley is treated with borderline disdain. Condescending messages sent that she couldn’t possibly grasp the complexities, intricacies, history of Art. The triangular family dynamics are provocative; gratifying when Grace and the reader see what the real Shirley is made of.
Grace’s story is one of second chances. A die-hard supporter from her previous life, Elaine demonstrates what’s it’s truly like when a colleague’s respect is no-holds back as she sticks her neck out to support discredited Grace, offering her a way to re-enter the appraisal world, revive her gallery business, and herself. When she invites Grace to join the Appraisal Experts Roadshow, Grace is unsure of herself, rusty, wary and weary of others appraising her, directly or indirectly. One appraiser is particularly nasty; satisfying when she gets what she deserves artfully without the crassness.
When Grace comes into possession of something her colleagues don’t have, something comes over her. You can guess at what might have happened to account for her downfall, but you’ll never guess what is about to happen.
Panitch never bores. Starting on page one, he introduces an ancient object that’s at least five thousand years old. Its powers are bewitching, as is the prose:
“The object is a necklace, once “six strings . . . threaded with the riches of Empire.” Its provenance traced back to the “Babylonian God of Wisdom.” Passed down through the Biblical ages to Egypt, to the Sinai, to the Ottoman Turks to 1917, the “Common Era,” when it’s “stolen by an American spy. What’s left is one string: “twelve cylindrically shaped stones of pure onyx spaced with Nubian gold nuggets . . . fastened in the very center, between two crimson bloodstones, hung the celestial globe itself: a marble-size stone of the finest lapis lazuli, mined in the ancient limestone beds of Pakistan. It emerged from the earth a perfect sphere” with “golden pyrite inclusions that shimmer like starbursts across the deep blue face of the stone. To hold the globe was to grasp the Cosmos.”
Grace is drawn to the deep blue stone artifact despite its poor condition. Lapis lazuli is a stone with ancient and modern spiritual history. Believed to have “healing” powers that can reveal “inner truth.” Again, fitting for Grace. Her appraisal of the object shocks. Grace doesn’t back down, instead digs in, not wanting to crush the dreams of someone in need of a break, luck, a boost.
An element of the appraisal process we might not have considered, given we’re inclined to focus on the currency side of it, is the emotional impact of letting down the owner of the object. Grace will surely win your heart. So too her low self-esteem believing the “celestial globe” has granted her fantastical powers.
The ancient stone conveys ancient history of the Cosmos. How the Earth was considered spherical “dates all the way back to the 6th century BC,” chimes in the oldest appraiser Jerome on the fictional roadshow. At seventy, the thirty-year age difference with Grace charms as their relationship comes alive for each other.
Panitch’s antique roadshow makes stops in shopping malls, historic venues, small cities, and big ones. At each one, Grace holds the “celestial globe” in her hands, feels it go from cold to warmer, then starts spinning “faster and faster,” getting hotter, “metamorphosing into dizzying, impossible combinations.” The force of its energy fires up Grace to appraise seemingly worthless objects at astronomical valuations.
Along with the drama, you’ll detect a melancholy sentiment on how the “Modern and Avant-Garde” movements have taken over today’s art market beyond anything imaginable.
So too Panitch’s spinning of Grace’s extraordinary appraisals. How they turn out, and what they say about Grace.
June 15, 2026
Seth Panitch, the Author of "Antigue" has written a captivating, unique, and astonishing novel. The Genres for this bewitching novel are: Magical Realism, Fantasy, Fiction, Women's Divorce Fiction, and Women's Life Fiction, Mystery and Suspense. The author vividly describes the landscapes, the antique and creative objects, and the dramatic and colorful characters. The characters are complex, complicated, creative, talented, quirky, artistic, and each character has their goals and problems. The author writes about antique appraisers, and also mentions Road Shows, where people show their antiques to see if they are worth anything. Some questions that I ponder as I read this book: Do you believe in magic? Do you believe a physical item is magical, or a person has magic in themselves?
The female protagonist, Grace Schaeffer is searching for the meaning in her life. She is a divorced, well-know antique appraiser that used to work on Antiques Roadshow. Somehow she feels the need to find herself and her mission in life. Grace discovers an antique necklace, that has weathered many seasons, but the lapis in the center gets cool and hot. Grace starts working in small Roadshows, and does appraisals for antiques, jewelry and Art. Somehow while wearing the necklace, Grace has strong feelings about the appraisals of certain things, and puts them at a higher price. She is so enthralled, that other appraisers think she has overstepped. She gets both positive and negative feedback on the worth of the items. It seems that Grace could be headed in a dangerous or questionable position.
An old painting is at question, as Grace is convinced is is quite exceptional and valuable. She is convinced a certain Impressionist Artist created this. This puts her at odds with her ex-husband, Vic, who is and expert at appraising as well. Grace has to learn the hardest appraisal of all, the value of herself. I appreciate how the author shows the love and appreciation for artistic creations. The author also discusses the importance of self-worth, family, friends, community, love , hope and magic. I highly recommend this magical book.
The female protagonist, Grace Schaeffer is searching for the meaning in her life. She is a divorced, well-know antique appraiser that used to work on Antiques Roadshow. Somehow she feels the need to find herself and her mission in life. Grace discovers an antique necklace, that has weathered many seasons, but the lapis in the center gets cool and hot. Grace starts working in small Roadshows, and does appraisals for antiques, jewelry and Art. Somehow while wearing the necklace, Grace has strong feelings about the appraisals of certain things, and puts them at a higher price. She is so enthralled, that other appraisers think she has overstepped. She gets both positive and negative feedback on the worth of the items. It seems that Grace could be headed in a dangerous or questionable position.
An old painting is at question, as Grace is convinced is is quite exceptional and valuable. She is convinced a certain Impressionist Artist created this. This puts her at odds with her ex-husband, Vic, who is and expert at appraising as well. Grace has to learn the hardest appraisal of all, the value of herself. I appreciate how the author shows the love and appreciation for artistic creations. The author also discusses the importance of self-worth, family, friends, community, love , hope and magic. I highly recommend this magical book.
July 11, 2026
This was a great debut. I always enjoy trying a debut. You can really find some gems, and that is what I got reading this book. Magical Realism is something I enjoy very much in my reads. In this book, we have Grace, who is an antiques appraiser, and appeared on Antiques Roadshow. She's gone through some hard times, including getting divorced, and losing her career. She signs on to be on an amateur travelling antique show, and happens to come across an intriguing necklace. This necklace seems to have some magical powers to it. It enhances her appraisal talents and she begins to know exactly what things would go for, and well over their worth. I loved the stories of the families and people that she helps throughout the book. That added an emotional aspect to the story. I really enjoyed this unique look at the art and antique world, it's something I'm not too familiar with. It was definitely well written and I'm happy I read it.
Thank you to the publisher, Author, and Suzy approved book tours for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to the publisher, Author, and Suzy approved book tours for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
June 17, 2026
You know I have a thing for unique stories, and this one completely captivated me.
Antique is a magical, uplifting novel that blends the fascinating world of antiques with a journey of self-discovery.
It’s about finding confidence, embracing change, and discovering that our true worth can’t be measured by anyone but ourselves.
Antique is a magical, uplifting novel that blends the fascinating world of antiques with a journey of self-discovery.
It’s about finding confidence, embracing change, and discovering that our true worth can’t be measured by anyone but ourselves.
February 7, 2026
Captivating!
I was so intrigued from the beginning to the end, the characters, the mystery, the magic, all kept me on the edge not wanting to put it down! Every part of me cheering Grace on through the journey as I could easily relate to her feelings. It was beautifully written with emotional connection. I love how the past was interwoven with the present and how it all came together at the end. I couldn’t put it down, read it in 2 days! We’ll done!
I was so intrigued from the beginning to the end, the characters, the mystery, the magic, all kept me on the edge not wanting to put it down! Every part of me cheering Grace on through the journey as I could easily relate to her feelings. It was beautifully written with emotional connection. I love how the past was interwoven with the present and how it all came together at the end. I couldn’t put it down, read it in 2 days! We’ll done!
July 17, 2026
A really unique story. I loved the magical realism in this book and I loved the antique roadshow setting I have never read anything like that before.
June 26, 2026
Thank you SuzyApprovedBookTours @sethpanitch and Grand Central Publishing for my #gifted copy.
Queue 🎵music🎶 from: Unwritten By: Natasha Bedingfield
Sometimes, the magic of a novel lies not within the author (though it is where the magic starts), but in the reader – if the reader is willing to believe in the magic. For me, Panitch made the magic come alive in his debut novel! As I read, I was transported to each city and 'roadshow' set, the characters and their emotions leapt off the page, the jewels, the stars, the constellations all sparkled and glowed. Yes, the story centers around antiques, OLD things, relics reserved for dusty shelves, back closets, and cobwebbed attics; BUT, it questions the very meaning of ‘OLD’.
For me, the magic lay in its character driven plot and the full character arc of the FMC, Grace (Gracie) Schaffer. Panitch makes the reader feel everything Grace does, from the warmth of the lapis lazuli necklace, the feeling of an artifact with life and meaning simmering below its surface, to her all-true emotions of self-doubt, shame, wonder, passion, and the ever-present longing to belong, be noticed, and to be loved.
Antique sets the stage to truly ask, “what is ‘WORTH’”…and quietly urges the reader to seek true worth, not only in each character and artifact, but in ourselves.
Queue 🎵music🎶 from: Unwritten By: Natasha Bedingfield
Sometimes, the magic of a novel lies not within the author (though it is where the magic starts), but in the reader – if the reader is willing to believe in the magic. For me, Panitch made the magic come alive in his debut novel! As I read, I was transported to each city and 'roadshow' set, the characters and their emotions leapt off the page, the jewels, the stars, the constellations all sparkled and glowed. Yes, the story centers around antiques, OLD things, relics reserved for dusty shelves, back closets, and cobwebbed attics; BUT, it questions the very meaning of ‘OLD’.
For me, the magic lay in its character driven plot and the full character arc of the FMC, Grace (Gracie) Schaffer. Panitch makes the reader feel everything Grace does, from the warmth of the lapis lazuli necklace, the feeling of an artifact with life and meaning simmering below its surface, to her all-true emotions of self-doubt, shame, wonder, passion, and the ever-present longing to belong, be noticed, and to be loved.
Antique sets the stage to truly ask, “what is ‘WORTH’”…and quietly urges the reader to seek true worth, not only in each character and artifact, but in ourselves.
July 21, 2026
Antique by Seth Panitch is a blend of magical realism, mystery, and contemporary fiction centered on self-discovery.
The novel follows Grace Schaffer, a talented antique appraiser whose life has unraveled. Once a popular expert on Antiques Roadshow, Grace has lost her career, her marriage, and much of her confidence. Looking for a fresh start, she joins a small traveling appraisal show.
Everything changes when she acquires an ancient, tarnished necklace with mysterious origins. After putting it on, Grace develops an uncanny ability to predict exactly what antiques will sell for at auction—often at prices far beyond what experts expect. Her extraordinary accuracy brings her fame but also skepticism, jealousy, and danger.
As Grace's reputation grows, she becomes involved in the search for a long-lost masterpiece, leading her into a mystery involving art, history, and the necklace's ancient power. Along the way, she must decide whether her success comes from the necklace's magic or from believing in herself for the first time in years.
At its heart, Antique explores themes of:
Self-worth versus monetary value
Second chances
Healing after personal loss
The enduring power of art and history
The question of whether true value comes from objects—or from the people who treasure them
The novel follows Grace Schaffer, a talented antique appraiser whose life has unraveled. Once a popular expert on Antiques Roadshow, Grace has lost her career, her marriage, and much of her confidence. Looking for a fresh start, she joins a small traveling appraisal show.
Everything changes when she acquires an ancient, tarnished necklace with mysterious origins. After putting it on, Grace develops an uncanny ability to predict exactly what antiques will sell for at auction—often at prices far beyond what experts expect. Her extraordinary accuracy brings her fame but also skepticism, jealousy, and danger.
As Grace's reputation grows, she becomes involved in the search for a long-lost masterpiece, leading her into a mystery involving art, history, and the necklace's ancient power. Along the way, she must decide whether her success comes from the necklace's magic or from believing in herself for the first time in years.
At its heart, Antique explores themes of:
Self-worth versus monetary value
Second chances
Healing after personal loss
The enduring power of art and history
The question of whether true value comes from objects—or from the people who treasure them
September 7, 2026
As one who’s interested in history and antiques, I found this book fascinating. It helped me see a snippet of the antique appraisal world. One I’ve always been curious about, but hadn’t yet had a chance to see into until now.
Grace, after setbacks in her life between relationships and her career on the Antiques Roadshow, found a necklace that changed her life. Little did she realize how her life would shift at that point. How she’d see changes in so many unexpected areas.
First, I really enjoyed the process of the world. It not only rekindled my interest in the antiquing world, but also taught me much of it. I never truly contemplated the complexities of it.
But, what really stood out to me in the story was Grace’s growth. It was an experience to witness changes from where she started, stumbled, doubted, to then her gradual confidence. I always appreciate character growth when reading.
This story is one I hope for a sequel, too. To further jump into this world, and to continue following Grace’s next adventure. Because, surely, this really is a unique one!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, received from Seth Panitch. However, all thoughts and views reflected are strictly my own opinions.
Grace, after setbacks in her life between relationships and her career on the Antiques Roadshow, found a necklace that changed her life. Little did she realize how her life would shift at that point. How she’d see changes in so many unexpected areas.
First, I really enjoyed the process of the world. It not only rekindled my interest in the antiquing world, but also taught me much of it. I never truly contemplated the complexities of it.
But, what really stood out to me in the story was Grace’s growth. It was an experience to witness changes from where she started, stumbled, doubted, to then her gradual confidence. I always appreciate character growth when reading.
This story is one I hope for a sequel, too. To further jump into this world, and to continue following Grace’s next adventure. Because, surely, this really is a unique one!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, received from Seth Panitch. However, all thoughts and views reflected are strictly my own opinions.
June 16, 2026
I have to say if you are looking for a female empowering story with a little bit of magic weaved into the story then Antique is a book you should definitely consider reading! Before reading this debut I really had no idea what to expect but deep down I had a feeling that this story would be very wonderful! Overall if you are wanting to read a story about someone reinventing themself go for it because it might be a helpful tool if you are trying to do the same thing. I really admired the main fmc Grace because no matter what she was going through she managed to pick herself up and continue on with a hobby that made her happy.
As mentioned our main character Grace who has always had a love for all things old. After her divorce she decides to move on with a job with a antiques tour show. She comes into possession of this necklace that somehow manages to boost her confidence. Within time she manages to make something of herself but she also learns that with great sucess also comes with great responsibility.
As mentioned our main character Grace who has always had a love for all things old. After her divorce she decides to move on with a job with a antiques tour show. She comes into possession of this necklace that somehow manages to boost her confidence. Within time she manages to make something of herself but she also learns that with great sucess also comes with great responsibility.
August 2, 2026
Firstly, a massive thank you to Seth Panitch for going to great lengths to send me a copy of his debut novel to Australia. It was a challenge that we both took on wholeheartedly and I’m so thankful we did.
This story was beautifully written and so easy to connect with. Based on antiques initially, it was really based on human connection and value. I love that Grace’s valuations were deeply entrenched in the personal connection to objects rather than monetary value.
The magical realism added a wonderful twist. As the story progressed, I kept wanting to dive back in. I needed to know the outcome of the hunt of the authentication as well as the journey Grace was on.
Such a unique premise and a wonderful read. I highly recommend diving into this debut.
This story was beautifully written and so easy to connect with. Based on antiques initially, it was really based on human connection and value. I love that Grace’s valuations were deeply entrenched in the personal connection to objects rather than monetary value.
The magical realism added a wonderful twist. As the story progressed, I kept wanting to dive back in. I needed to know the outcome of the hunt of the authentication as well as the journey Grace was on.
Such a unique premise and a wonderful read. I highly recommend diving into this debut.
August 15, 2026
This is a captivating story that includes magical realism. Grace is at a low point in her life with her marriage over and her career as an antiques appraiser suffering after a major setback. She finds an old necklace with an amulet that doesn’t seem to be worth much. However, its powers soon become apparent. Soon Grace is making wild estimates on the value of objects yet her career is starting to get back on track. What magic does this necklace hold? Is Grace in charge of her life or is it the amulet? This books asks the question, “Who determines the value of an object? Of a person?”
I found this novel highly enjoyable and a quick read.
I found this novel highly enjoyable and a quick read.
August 17, 2026
Oh my gosh. This book is very magical in all the best ways. A woman struggling for breath after a divorce and a chaotic moment in her career is taken on a quest with a work of art she assigned as her possible Grail, only to discover she's on a quest to self-discovery. Truly an endearing and enchanting book about loss, grief, connection, and the wonderful world of art. I loved the author's beautiful writing on art and the intricate woven details that make a masterpiece--even into the masterpieces of our own life soundtracks. I'm serious. It's truly a remarkable book that will motivate you to believe in your own Magic. 🙌
May 26, 2026
So this was a well done debut novel by this author and while there was quite a lot to like, there were a few odd choices I thought that kept me from giving this book 4 stars. The story, along with some of the character development and dialog is what elevates this twilight zone episode to full length novel. Our FMC is Grace, a 46 year old antique appraiser, formerly star of the Antiques Roadshow, who has fallen on tough times after losing her father to a stroke, her husband to a younger woman, her marriage to divorce which results in a loss of identity and confidence in herself. During a field appraisal at the down strata roadshow she works with now, she ends up with a mysterious necklace that defies an ordinary description. The author includes a great description of the necklace along with the true description of it's magical provenance which was a really fascinating fantasy and I found myself wishing he had included a bit more of that story. But this is Grace's story, and right away she finds that her desire to people please is enhanced while wearing the necklace. She's able to communicate with it and together they change a few lives. Inevitably the third act conflict puts Grace at odds with the necklace. Here's where for me the story got a little screwy. The necklace breaks but somehow Grace finds it restored within her bag once again. A long lost treasure of purely sentimental value is found also seemingly without explanation, and worse of all Grace has an impossibly magical encounter which just doesn't seem earned. For me it begged the question, should Grace's value be a thing determined by others, or one she determines for herself? It was good to read a magical realism book written by a new author and I look forward to what he comes up with next.
June 15, 2026
Antique by Seth Panitch is a debut fantasy/mystery novel about antique appraiser, Grace Schaffer. Grace gains the ability to predict auction values from a mysterious, magical necklace, while working on a traveling roadshow.
This story blends magical realism with the world of antiques and art. It exploring themes of value, identity, and self-discovery.
If you are a fan of antiquing, antique road shows, or impressionist art, you will probably enjoy this book.
This story blends magical realism with the world of antiques and art. It exploring themes of value, identity, and self-discovery.
If you are a fan of antiquing, antique road shows, or impressionist art, you will probably enjoy this book.
June 18, 2026
Antique is a mesmerizing, magical story about discovering your worth and trusting yourself. This is a masterpiece! The format and pacing were intentionally crafted and engaging, making this book an easy page-turner. I especially love how each appraisal became a mystery. The way Grace, the main character, described each detail in arriving at the final number was enthralling. There were even a few fake-outs that caught me off guard. The art was described in lush prose that made me feel as if I were viewing a real painting. Seth Panitch's writing is exquisite. That is how I described this book 50% in, and that held through the end. Every character was interesting and well-developed. I, of course, rooted for Grace most, but I also loved Jerome, Patty, and Robert. The only person I wish I had learned more about was Grace's mom, Shirley. I would love to know her story but I enjoyed how she was revealed through Grace's narrative. Overall, this book moved me and made me consistently ponder the difference between worth and value. Who determines worth and how do we find it within ourselves? I absolutely loved this book and highly recommend it to anyone who loves magical realism, history, art, or antiquing.
June 26, 2026
Having grown up watching Antiques Roadshow with my mom and grandma, I knew this would be a fun read!
And boy was I right! It's such a unique read! Full of magical realism and interesting characters. Art, mystery, magic, and a sense of healing that was so beautifully done. Hard to believe this is a debut!
And boy was I right! It's such a unique read! Full of magical realism and interesting characters. Art, mystery, magic, and a sense of healing that was so beautifully done. Hard to believe this is a debut!
July 16, 2026
I quite enjoyed this debut work.
I liked the main character, her determination, and growth, and as someone who cherishes the few heirloom pieces I’ve received, I REALLY liked the Antiques Roadshow of it all.
Maybe my Last Supper painting will surprise me with its own set of powers?
While this author has no back catalogue at present, I can’t wait to see where he’s headed.
I liked the main character, her determination, and growth, and as someone who cherishes the few heirloom pieces I’ve received, I REALLY liked the Antiques Roadshow of it all.
Maybe my Last Supper painting will surprise me with its own set of powers?
While this author has no back catalogue at present, I can’t wait to see where he’s headed.
August 4, 2026
Here's a great debut full of art, family relationships, history, and magical realism.
Grace becomes the owner of a very special necklace that gives her the ability to accurately predict what an item will sell for at auction. This causes some problems with her coworkers.
Throughout the story, we see all the many sides of Grace's personality: her genuineness, confidence, insecurity, and her remorse. A few chapters were about younger Grace and the family dynamics which shaped her, which made the reader understand her reactions better.
I found the focus on antiques so different from other books I've read. In addition, all of the excitement of auctions poured out in the story and kept me very engaged.
Thank you to the author for sending a copy and some Churus for my cats. I really enjoyed the book!
Grace becomes the owner of a very special necklace that gives her the ability to accurately predict what an item will sell for at auction. This causes some problems with her coworkers.
Throughout the story, we see all the many sides of Grace's personality: her genuineness, confidence, insecurity, and her remorse. A few chapters were about younger Grace and the family dynamics which shaped her, which made the reader understand her reactions better.
I found the focus on antiques so different from other books I've read. In addition, all of the excitement of auctions poured out in the story and kept me very engaged.
Thank you to the author for sending a copy and some Churus for my cats. I really enjoyed the book!
Want to Read
February 14, 2026ty hachette for the copy!
June 6, 2026
I loved this book. This novel follows the main character, Grace, who is an antiques appraiser. She discovers an old necklace that seems to pull her towards high appraisals on items. I’m not a huge antique show person - but the RUSH that was portrayed in this book of items going to auction was perfect.
If you’re a fan of the show antiques roadshow, this book is perfect for you. I loved the character development, multiple timelines, the bits of mystery with the unknown history and origin of some of the pieces - it was very well done and flowed beautifully.
If you’re a fan of the show antiques roadshow, this book is perfect for you. I loved the character development, multiple timelines, the bits of mystery with the unknown history and origin of some of the pieces - it was very well done and flowed beautifully.
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
Other than watching a handful of Antique Roadshow episodes I know nothing of the antique dealing world, but I know a good story when I read one.
July 18, 2026
ANTIQUE was the second book that I have read recently with a magical realism theme. If you haven’t read this type of book before, it would be a good one to try! The main character of Grace was easy to like and root for. I give the author credit for developing her character effectively. If you like antiques, art, and magical realism…give this one a try!
Many thanks to Seth Panitch for my gifted copy.
This review will be shared to my Instagram account (@coffee.break.book.reviews) in the future.
Many thanks to Seth Panitch for my gifted copy.
This review will be shared to my Instagram account (@coffee.break.book.reviews) in the future.
February 11, 2026
Grace Schaffer follows in the footsteps of her father who is a scholar of historical artifacts. She got her father’s attention after digging in their own backyard and finding an arrowhead as a child. As an adult she eventually landed a coveted spot on Antiques Roadshow. Her time there was too short. She loses her job, gets a divorce, and feels like she has lost her identity.
Grace accepts a job on an amateur antiques tour show. She makes friends but she has lost her confidence and fears, letting everyone down until one day she appraises a necklace.
The necklace gives her a magical ability that helps build her confidence. While wearing the necklace and appraising the items, a number pops into her head. A number much higher than she and the other appraisers think is reasonable. Somehow, each item is sold for the amount she was given. She is successful and begins to feel like a celebrity. Each of her appraisals have helped people in need and it makes her feel good about herself and her world.
While appraising a painting, she goes head-to-head with her ex-husband who is famous for art appraisals. Because he questions her appraisal, they are both brought in at the auction. One of them will be destroyed.
This is a story about doing good for both you and others and how that can conflict. It has a little magic involved so you will need to be willing to believe in something that science can’t measure.
It’s a story about what is important in life and what we can do to make the world better.
This is the first book I’ve read by this author. I did enjoy it and would recommend it to anyone who likes a little fantasy. I think that if you have ever watched Antiques Roadshow, you might enjoy seeing what goes on in the background knowing that one decision can often make or break someone whose counting on finding that one in a million treasure.
First published February 3, 2026.
Thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for sending this book for review. All opinions are my own.
You can follow my reviews at Get Lost in a Book - Virginia-Gruver.com
Grace accepts a job on an amateur antiques tour show. She makes friends but she has lost her confidence and fears, letting everyone down until one day she appraises a necklace.
The necklace gives her a magical ability that helps build her confidence. While wearing the necklace and appraising the items, a number pops into her head. A number much higher than she and the other appraisers think is reasonable. Somehow, each item is sold for the amount she was given. She is successful and begins to feel like a celebrity. Each of her appraisals have helped people in need and it makes her feel good about herself and her world.
While appraising a painting, she goes head-to-head with her ex-husband who is famous for art appraisals. Because he questions her appraisal, they are both brought in at the auction. One of them will be destroyed.
This is a story about doing good for both you and others and how that can conflict. It has a little magic involved so you will need to be willing to believe in something that science can’t measure.
It’s a story about what is important in life and what we can do to make the world better.
This is the first book I’ve read by this author. I did enjoy it and would recommend it to anyone who likes a little fantasy. I think that if you have ever watched Antiques Roadshow, you might enjoy seeing what goes on in the background knowing that one decision can often make or break someone whose counting on finding that one in a million treasure.
First published February 3, 2026.
Thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for sending this book for review. All opinions are my own.
You can follow my reviews at Get Lost in a Book - Virginia-Gruver.com
June 16, 2026
A huge thank you to Seth for reaching out and gifting me a copy of this book!
As someone who doesn't typically read a lot of fantasy, I absolutely loved this story. Seth’s writing flows beautifully, allowing me to easily picture the vibrant places Grace visits without crossing the line into the over-the-top, overly dense prose that usually steers me away from this genre.
(This might be a total "reader quirk" thing, but I also have to shout out the formatting as the font choice and size made this such a smooth, physically easy reading experience)
The story follows Grace, a woman at a major crossroads. Fresh off a divorce, she has also had to walk away from her beloved role on the Antiques Roadshow, where she had become a bit of a celebrity. Now facing an uncertain future on the traveling appraiser circuit, she stumbles upon a seemingly innocuous necklace. Once she puts it on, her appraisals completely change. She's no longer measuring a piece's true worth, but rather following a strange pull. Is the necklace forcing her to hunt down something far more valuable?
If you’ve ever watched Antiques Roadshow, you already know the thrill of waiting with bated breath to see if someone brought in a priceless treasure or a total dud. But what I hadn’t fully appreciated until reading this book is the appraiser's side of the equation, their own deep desire to find that elusive "Grail" piece among a lifetime of ordinary objects. That perspective made this story such a blast to explore!
Alongside Grace’s hunt for rare antiquities, we get to witness a beautiful journey of personal growth. It was so satisfying to watch her finally step out of the shadows of her genius father and husband, claiming the independence she truly deserves.
Whether you’re a seasoned thriller reader looking to widen your scope or just searching for a story about finding one's own "Grail," you’ll want to add this book to your summer TBR!
As someone who doesn't typically read a lot of fantasy, I absolutely loved this story. Seth’s writing flows beautifully, allowing me to easily picture the vibrant places Grace visits without crossing the line into the over-the-top, overly dense prose that usually steers me away from this genre.
(This might be a total "reader quirk" thing, but I also have to shout out the formatting as the font choice and size made this such a smooth, physically easy reading experience)
The story follows Grace, a woman at a major crossroads. Fresh off a divorce, she has also had to walk away from her beloved role on the Antiques Roadshow, where she had become a bit of a celebrity. Now facing an uncertain future on the traveling appraiser circuit, she stumbles upon a seemingly innocuous necklace. Once she puts it on, her appraisals completely change. She's no longer measuring a piece's true worth, but rather following a strange pull. Is the necklace forcing her to hunt down something far more valuable?
If you’ve ever watched Antiques Roadshow, you already know the thrill of waiting with bated breath to see if someone brought in a priceless treasure or a total dud. But what I hadn’t fully appreciated until reading this book is the appraiser's side of the equation, their own deep desire to find that elusive "Grail" piece among a lifetime of ordinary objects. That perspective made this story such a blast to explore!
Alongside Grace’s hunt for rare antiquities, we get to witness a beautiful journey of personal growth. It was so satisfying to watch her finally step out of the shadows of her genius father and husband, claiming the independence she truly deserves.
Whether you’re a seasoned thriller reader looking to widen your scope or just searching for a story about finding one's own "Grail," you’ll want to add this book to your summer TBR!
July 4, 2026
Grace is struggling with who she is and what's next for her. The divorce from her unfaithful husband has been hard, her career is also down the drain and she is also on the brink of losing this last chance she has. She has always enjoyed seeing the enjoyment that is brought to those who think they have a treasure and when Grace confirms, it's a happy ending. Lately that hasn't been the case and so when a mother and her daughter come with a book that isn't worth hardly anything, she just blurts out the most outrageous amount. What is she doing? How could she give these people such false hope, knowing they will never come close to what she quoted them. But this feeling just comes over her and she can't help it. So after this sells for her quoted price and then it happens again with another object. People are coming to see her, they want her to quote their objects and what Grace realizes that it's not about the dollar amount these items are worth, but the worth they are to that person, that family and what it really means even if it is some partly broken, dingy worthless items that's been collecting dust on a shelf for years. She realizes these objects are helping those who really need it at a time when they have no other option. I really enjoyed this novel and have always loved searching through estate sales and Goodwill stores for trinkets and items that may not mean anything to anyone, but stand out to me for some reason. Thank you to the author for the complementary novel and to Suzy Approved Book Tours. This review is of my own opinion and accord.
August 22, 2026
I finished my first ever author-gifted book and what a journey! Antique by Seth Panitch was a charming little adventure, which took me out of my typical genre comfort zone.
Grace is recently divorced and flailing at her job appraising items on an Antiques Roadshow knock off. She’s looking for worth in herself as well as the things laid before her. One day she comes across a strange necklace and suddenly her fortunes turn around. But the real story has little to do with the necklace and everything to do with a painting discovered in an unlikely attic, owned by a young man named Robert. Grace embarks down a path to authenticate the painting, and either reward its owner handsomely or lead to nothing but devastation and embarrassment.
The premise gave me National Treasure meets The Wizard of Oz vibes. A globe-trotting, puzzle-filled tale with a touch of whimsy and magic…though don’t we think Grace had it all within her the whole time?
As far as critiques go: I found myself wishing for more depth and connection to the characters along the way. I also thought Robert’s creepy and greedy father would’ve popped up in the pages to add some hearty conflict. I wasn’t entirely sold on the magic necklace aspect and I think the story would have worked just as well without it.
There is something undeniably endearing about Antique. It’s imaginative, adventurous, and a little bit whimsical. I think it’s a great selection heading into the early days of fall, and would recommend its quirky, somewhat old fashioned spirit to readers looking to escape the day to day hum of a 9-to-5 life.
Grace is recently divorced and flailing at her job appraising items on an Antiques Roadshow knock off. She’s looking for worth in herself as well as the things laid before her. One day she comes across a strange necklace and suddenly her fortunes turn around. But the real story has little to do with the necklace and everything to do with a painting discovered in an unlikely attic, owned by a young man named Robert. Grace embarks down a path to authenticate the painting, and either reward its owner handsomely or lead to nothing but devastation and embarrassment.
The premise gave me National Treasure meets The Wizard of Oz vibes. A globe-trotting, puzzle-filled tale with a touch of whimsy and magic…though don’t we think Grace had it all within her the whole time?
As far as critiques go: I found myself wishing for more depth and connection to the characters along the way. I also thought Robert’s creepy and greedy father would’ve popped up in the pages to add some hearty conflict. I wasn’t entirely sold on the magic necklace aspect and I think the story would have worked just as well without it.
There is something undeniably endearing about Antique. It’s imaginative, adventurous, and a little bit whimsical. I think it’s a great selection heading into the early days of fall, and would recommend its quirky, somewhat old fashioned spirit to readers looking to escape the day to day hum of a 9-to-5 life.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews