So begins the journey of Ash—short for Pin Asher9919—who awakens on a hospital bed on, he believes, a different planet after an automobile accident took the bodily life of an Earth human named Edward Fleishman. Ash is told he was the victim of a serious brain injury and miraculously recovered from being brain dead in a coma, but Ash feels he knows the his spirit has replaced the distressed spirit of the former Edward Fleishman.
Thus, Ash's new life on earth begins, complete with a spouse who is a stranger to him, a body he is not sure how to use, a world he must learn to navigate, and a government he can't trust.
Mitchell Waldman's latest novel, The Visitor, is now available from All Things That Matter Press! The Visitor is a unique blend of science fiction, social commentary, and human drama. It stands out for its exploration of identity, alienation, and the human condition, themes that may resonate with readers of speculative fiction and literary works alike. It may appeal to readers who enjoy introspective narratives and stories that challenge perceptions of reality, much like works of Philip K. Dick of Kashuo Ishiguro’s Never Let Me Go. Its unique blend of genres and themes may make it a compelling read that stands out in the literary landscape. (For more info on the book and reviews, see https://mitchellanddiana.com/books/th...)
His last story collection is entitled Brothers, Fathers, and Other Strangers. Of the work readers have said "Waldman has crafted a nuanced and engaging collection. His stories set us on an emotional tightrope, daring us to forgo a safety net, while seducing us to look down and discover who we are. Sometimes poignantly devastating, and other times savagely funny, he guides us through family trauma, corporate America, and faithful understanding to remind us if we can be less of a stranger to the world, maybe we can be less of a stranger to ourselves." (Josh Penzone, author of The Court of Vintage Woods: Linked Stories). Readers have also said that "Brothers, Fathers, and Other Strangers is remarkable for its scope, honesty, imagination, social sensitivity, and moral concern." (Robert Wexelblatt, author of The Thirteenth Studebaker, Hsi-wei Tales, etc.) And it has been said that "[i]n Brothers, Fathers, and Other Strangers, Waldman explores masculinity, but not stereotypical masculinity. In these stories, you will see men battling their memories and emotions as they attempt to come to grips with their pasts and make a way for their lives. Waldman sets his work in reality with a dash of fantasy and the occasional twist ending. Waldman is doing something special in the short story form, and his stories will entertain, enlighten, and elate." (Hardy Jones, author of Resurrection of Childhood: A Memoir, and Every Bitter Thing). The Academy of the Heart and Mind recently said of Brothers, Fathers, and Other Strangers that "Waldman’s short story collection will resonate with readers who are seeking a deep dive into how others have a massive influence on the people we are inside and out." For more information on the book, visit https:https://mitchellanddiana.com/books/br...)
Waldman's fiction and poetry has appeared in many journals and anthologies. He is also the author of the story collection Petty Offenses and Crimes of the Heart and the novel A Face in the Moon.
Waldman serves as Fiction Editor for Blue Lake Review (http://bluelakereview.weebly.com), and was co-editor (with Diana Waldman) of the anthologies WOUNDS OF WAR: POETS FOR PEACE, and HIP POETRY (originally published by Wind Publications).
His book reviews have appeared at Scribes World and Midwest Book Review.
Waldman studied with Mark Costello (author of THE MURPHY STORIES and MIDDLE MURPHY) and Paul Friedman (author of AND IF DEFEATED ALLEGE FRAUD and SERIOUS TROUBLE) at the University of Illinois (Champaign-Urbana), studied advertising at the University of Texas at Austin, and has a J.D. from Southern Illinois University.
Mitchell worked as an attorney/editor in the legal publishing field for over 35 years, before retiring in 2022.
Born in Chicago, he currently lives in Rochester, New York, with his partner, Diana Waldman, a journalist, editor, and poet, and the author of the poetry collection, A WOMAN'S SONG.
Mitchell is working on a new short story collection which should be available soon.
For more information on Mitchell's and Diana's books and writings, see their web page at: https
The author provides a solid narration to a story that, for me, felt like a more light-hearted mixing of Heinlein’s Stranger in a Strange Land and John Carpenter’s Starman, with a touch of Burton’s Edward Scissorhands thrown in.
The main premise of the novel becomes a vehicle for social commentary—and criticism—while maintaining a level of suspense. Admittedly, there does require a certain suspension of disbelief often required in stories like this, but that is because it is really almost told more as a modern sci-fi fairy tale than hard fiction (I also had flashes of an “Edward Scissorhands fish out of water” kind of feel).
All this to say, if you enjoy light sci-fi and or modern fairy tale that puts society and politics in a critical lens, you’ll definitely want to give this a chance.
I have always wondered what it would be like to remember your past life after being reincarnated. The Visitor takes this premise a step further, by putting us in the shoes of an extraterrestrial being waking up as a human after a near‑fatal accident. Ash, the alien consciousness inhabiting Edward Fleishman’s body, must navigate not only the confusion of identity but also the absurdities of modern society.
Through Ash’s eyes, everyday life—phones, jobs, politics, even eating meat—becomes strange and unsettling. Waldman uses this outsider perspective to critique government, media, and consumer culture, showing how easily people are manipulated by fear, propaganda, and the promise of possessions. The novel balances satire with psychological tension, as Ash struggles to reconcile his alien detachment with the emotional pull of Edward’s family, especially his wife Lucille.
The story builds toward darker territory when authorities begin hunting “aliens” in their midst, turning Ash’s existence into a metaphor for persecution and paranoia. While the plot occasionally slows for reflection, the ambiguity of whether Ash is truly an alien or suffering neurological trauma keeps the reader engaged.
The Visitor is an intriguing, short work of science fiction that will certainly get you thinking about some things you probably feel strongly about. The book took some political turns I was not expecting, and I would say that if you are looking for a book to help you forget about issues of modern politics, this is not the book for you.
The story centers around this being, "Ash," that awakens in the body of a human named Edward. This human had been in an accident that had left those that knew him thinking he would never wake up. He is hailed as a miracle by many when he does regain consciousness. This overall did strike me as fairly novel and as something different in terms of what I've personally read before.
The being is confused, and he is questioning throughout the book how and why he has found himself in this new life in this new creature, this "human."
The being describes living past lives and in alien societies that are far beyond the limitations of humanity. There is talk of being beyond such things as hunger, homelessness, greed, religion, violence, the concept of nations, patriotism, and the need for laws.
The being, "Ash," initially takes a rather philosophical, sort of detached, view of humanity, although he seems to form more of a decisive, more emotional opinion as the pages go on, perhaps as he becomes more in touch with his humanity.
The book takes a critical view of government, of America, US healthcare, the presidential administration in the book, and peoples' ideas about what freedom is.
Ash holds to this belief of all life forms, more or less, everything, being part of 'the Whole.' An attack on one part is an attack on the Whole, that sort of belief.
Some government entities catch on to Ash possibly being an alien. He ends up imprisoned in violation of his alleged rights. This is essentially by a president who has made it a campaign initiative to find aliens in their midst who undoubtedly--in his view--mean to do humanity harm.
The Visitor had me thinking about the classic, Stranger in a Strange Land, with the way it took this outsider alien perspective lens and analyzed modern humanity through it. It was interesting when later in the book, the main character actually even references by name that same title.
The book also made me think of Slaughterhouse 5, with this ongoing dilemma multiple characters had in the book of thinking, essentially, "Is it all true? Or am I actually crazy?" The word gaslighting did cross my mind multiple times as I read the book.
I believe a lot of readers will relate to a lot of the sentiments in this book. On some level though, in the end, I didn't see much new here. In general, the things criticized here have been criticized countless times before. There is not much offered in the way of solutions, either. There are not any in-depth analyses or really substantive ideas discussed about what is to be done about the problems Ash identifies with humanity. It's as if to say on a very basic level, humanity is greedy, selfish, a lost cause, etc. and just needs to get with the program and care about each other more. And that America just needs to be like the rest of the world.
If the book went further such as to propose how this is to be accomplished, it may have made for a more exciting/engaging and unique read.
The book also wraps up very quickly at the end, especially with regards to the presidential election. I will also admit that it troubled me that Ash seemed to basically learn most of what he knew about humanity from what he saw on the television.
The main character, this alien being living in the human body known as Edward, seems to basically resolve at the end to just live his life, enjoy his time on earth, and die. It would have spoken more to me if he had dedicated his human life to showing humanity the 'right' way forward, or at least trying; something to that effect.
A reflective dystopian sci-fi novel, "The Visitor" by Mitchell Waldman, explores themes of identity and social control through the story of Ash, who perceives himself as an off-world spirit in the body of Edward Fleishman after a life-altering accident. He encounters uncertainty regarding his identity as he wakes up to an unfamiliar spouse and a society enveloped in surveillance. The narrative's tension hinges on whether his experience is an alien possession or a result of neurological trauma, maintaining ambiguity throughout.
The novel effectively critiques contemporary life by focusing on the pressures of bureaucracies and "helpful" authorities, transforming mundane interactions into tests of identity and consent. Influences from authors like Orwell and Philip K. Dick resonate through the reflective voice that prioritises characters' inner struggles over dramatic spectacles.
However, familiar tropes associated with amnesia and possession may be overly recognisable to seasoned readers, undermining some of the novel's subversive potential. The overt references to classic dystopian narratives may also set specific expectations that the prose does not always fulfil. While ambiguity serves as a compelling device, certain sections risk becoming repetitive without introducing new insights.
Waldman’s writing style is steady and introspective, offering a minimalistic worldbuilding approach that invites readers to perceive dystopia through implications rather than overt descriptions. This book appeals to literary-oriented sci-fi enthusiasts drawn to themes of embodiment and memory, seeking a narrative filled with introspection and social critique rather than high-concept action.
Overall, "The Visitor" is recommended for those who appreciate psychological complexity, although readers preferring fast-paced plots may find it too contemplative.
Strong premise, promising start, disappointing execution. I like to start with the good. Ash wakes up in the unfamiliar body of Edward, who was in a horrific car accident from which he was not expected to recover. The descriptions of an alien spirit trying to assimilate the memories and take on the life of a human are curious and compelling. The perspective of Ash, in the body of a human, is at times wonderfully done, and is the highlight of the book. Edward’s wife, Lucille, is a steadfast, faithful companion, and one of the more heartening aspects of The Visitor, though her overriding goal, stated perhaps a few too many times, is for a return to the norm for her and the love of her life. By the end she hasn’t developed much at all. Edward’s estranged brother is brought in and never really earns his word count. There are small hints of an overall bigger plot, but unfortunately, what comes out is a rather cartoonish scheme by an inept president who is nothing more than a lampooning device. There’s a lot of political soapboxing here, and pretty much nothing but negative observations about humanity as a whole. I actually enjoy these things if done strategically and carefully, regardless of which side of an issue the author might stand. This is… a lot; what makes it borderline intolerable after a while is that it does little to nothing for the (thin) plot. Stylistically, it has its challenges, though none of these would, in and of themselves, be a deal breaker for me. But be warned, run-on sentences are the norm here. I counted over 200 words in one rambler, and 100 isn’t rare at all. It’s as if the author started with the premise and ran with it but had no idea how to conclude Ash’s journey as Edward. Thus, about halfway through, everything related to plot starts to feel contrived. There’s a potential gem in here, but as executed it’s hard to recommend it.
Ash wakes up in another person's body on a planet not his own. He truly is a stranger in a land so strange it's difficult for him to accept his life there. Ash has taken on the body of a middle-aged man named Edward Fleishman, whose wife, Lucille, is delighted that her husband has awakened from a coma after being declared brain dead. Ash, now Edward, has trouble fitting into this world--no way could he work at Edward's old job as an accountant, for example. More poignantly, he is no longer the Edward that Lucille knows and loves, and she is endlessly distressed over this. Eventually the alien Edward, thinking to explain to Lucille, tells her that he actually is an alien in Edward's body, which causes her to urge him to see a mental health professional. Sadly, this brings Edward to the attention of federal authorities who are in the process of hunting down and imprisoning aliens. Edward's brother, Jake, enters the book approximately in the middle, when Edward and Lucille decide to get out of town for awhile. Jake is an odd guy who had worked as a scientist. He and Edward had been estranged, but as the circumstances of the story play out, the two brothers are reconciled and Jake becomes a caring older brother. I found it funny that Edward spent a great deal of time observing humanity on earth and he came up with many of the opinions that a liberal American baby boomer might have--he has no use for cell phones or guns, and has to overcome a strong distaste for eating animals. Edward, formerly Ash, undergoes less of a personal growth arc and more of a slow acceptance of his life on earth as he develops love for his earthly family.
The Visitor is a speculative fiction novel that explores the premise of an alien being called Ash, whose spirit/essence hops from one body to another at the moment of ‘death’. This time, it finds itself inside the body of a man named Edward Fleishman, who was involved in a serious crash. Ash is none by the most limited access to Edward’s memories as he tries to navigate the confusing and troubling world of contemporary USA.
It begins as an intriguing examination of human society and the English language, as Ash tries to rise to the challenges of a normal human life. Especially difficult, certainly for the first half of the book, is his home life with Edward’s wife, Lucille, who doesn’t realise how right she is when she considers that post-accident Edward is ‘a changed man’. Despite his initial alien detachment, however, Ash slowly begins to open up to human feelings and develop his own relationship with Lucille, which shows some nice and subtle character development. In the latter stages, all subtlety is thrown out the window, and the story darkens as the US president abuses his power to hunt down ‘illegal aliens’.
In a way, the story needed a change of pace, as the initial premise has begun to grow a little stale, but I did get a touch of whiplash at the suddenness of the shift from scalpel to sledgehammer. As a rule, I’m not a fan of main characters losing all agency. In this case, I realise that’s the point: to show how innocent people become completely at the mercy of those in power. Nevertheless, I would have liked to see the character’s actions achieve something. As it was, the climax felt somewhat rushed and unearned.
Ultimately, it was an interesting read, seeing a snapshot of modern life as seen through the eyes of an alien.
For those who enjoy Kurt Vonnegut’s most famous work, it’s Slaughterhouse-Five in reverse. The alien comes to earth, but not for any really coherent reason-it’s just a kismet reincarnation thing. (The essential daily journal feel of Vonnegut’s work persists.) To underline the emphasis on social commentary, the alien’s idyllic conflict-free former life on planet Fastitus is sprinkled throughout, to Earth’s detriment - and that of President Wulff.
The names get me. Wulff. Trog, whose 1970s jive lingo magically disappears as he is eventually recruited by the almighty government. Boris Hingelhopper. (Envision Lurch in an oversized frog costume.) Rudolf Himeineder. I’d say ‘you can’t make this stuff up’, but …fiction.
Some parts are genuinely amusing - only an alien trapped in an accountant’s body would mistake a woman’s need to pee as a romantic affirmation. Also, some of the earthling descriptions seem inspired by the Nathan Pyle cartoons.
Some parts are well-worn tropes (like a secret new branch of the U.S. Government acting like Soviet Russian goons). Others offer unnecessary padding (the alien’s formerly estranged brother affirming to himself that he is an oddball).
The ‘amnesia’ regarding Edward’s former life is somewhat reminiscent of “Regarding Henry”. But instead of returning to the mothership or re-becoming a Pin, the bring inhabiting Edward’s body spiritually swims off into …who knows where.
We’ve been on a journey of exploration. I say goodbye, the author apparently wanted to say hello.
“He wakes up in a different body.” And from this instantly gripping opening line, The Visitor never lets go.
Ash – also known as Pin Asher9919 – awakens in the body of Edward Fleishman, navigating Earth through the eyes of a consciousness that is profoundly not human. What follows is a clever, often darkly funny exploration of identity, belonging, and the quiet absurdities of modern life. Seen through Ash’s “box-fresh” perspective, everyday human behaviours – our phone obsessions, emotional overreactions, even the logic of money – are gently ridiculed with almost childlike curiosity and sharp insight.
Beneath the subtly observed wit sits a more unsettling undercurrent. Waldman uses Ash’s predicament as a clear allegory for the persecution of the outsider, blending speculative fiction with political satire as a paranoid, election-driven America turns its attention toward rooting out “illegal aliens.” This time, one who truly is from another world. Touches of Men in Black-style menace give way to something more intimate and disturbing as Ash is abducted, detained, examined, and effectively “disappeared.”
Smart, compassionate, and quietly unsettling, The Visitor is a thoughtful sci-fi novel with a strong inner voice and a protagonist who is easy to empathise with. A highly enjoyable, reflective read. Thoroughly recommended.
At the heart of this narrative lies the profound bewilderment of an outside observer, Ash, as he faces the absurdities of daily life. The book uses the concept of swapped identity as a magnifying glass to analyze how human beings are constantly bombarded and shaped by the media. Through the protagonist's eyes, our society appears as a closed circuit of contradictory messages, where advertisements create artificial needs and news reports serve only to fuel anxiety and confusion.The author focuses heavily on a critique of the information system: Ash observes with detachment a world where truth has become a commodity, drowned out by "Fake News" and political propaganda aimed solely at the emotional control of the masses. This constant manipulation is contrasted with the fragility of personal memory and identity, suggesting that in a world so saturated with external stimuli, it is nearly impossible to remain true to oneself or to discern what is real.The storytelling highlights the self-destructive nature of a planet obsessed with possession and profit, where people seem to have lost the capacity for independent thought. The result is a portrait of a humanity that, while chasing a happiness promised by screens, ignores its own real-world problems and allows itself to be passively led by egocentric leaders and consumerist messaging.
At first glance, The Visitor draws on familiar science fiction ideas—an alien inhabiting a human body and trying to survive in an unfamiliar world. Yet the novel is less interested in the mechanics and more in the psychological strain and fractured sense of self. Through Ash’s uneasy place in a life that isn’t truly his, especially his interactions with a wife who insists he is her husband, the story builds tension, doubt, and isolation.
Seen through Ash’s eyes, ordinary modern life becomes strange and distorted. Advertising, media, and political messaging take on an unsettling quality, quietly critiquing how perception can be shaped until it feels normal.
Identity is central. Ash struggles not only to understand his surroundings but to trust who he is at all. With unreliable memories and a body that isn’t his, he exists in constant uncertainty, giving the story a lingering emotional weight.
Stylistically, the novel maintains a tense mood but occasionally slows for reflection, and some commentary is fairly explicit. The early chapters are also deliberately opaque, revealing information gradually.
Even so, The Visitor is a compelling blend of science fiction and psychological thriller. It uses an unusual premise to explore identity, perception, and belonging, leaving a lasting impression through the uneasy way it reframes the familiar world.
Waldman does a superb job of setting up a quirky story with plenty of twists & social commentary. When the protagonist wakes from a coma after a traumatic accident, Edward becomes the darling of the press for being the latest miracle.
Only one problem—he’s still remembers his previous lives, including as Pin Asher9919 on a different planet (hence his nickname Ash). He goes about trying to adapt to the complexities and barbarities of Earth while Lucille, Edward’s wife, struggles to accept the series of events that have rocked her world.
As Edward/Ash learns some of the nuances of human life, such as eating the flesh of other creatures and drinking beer, the author begins weaving in real-life aspects of political and social trends spreading around the world. He keenly highlights some of the absurdities in our civilizations as Edward/Ash gets caught up in circumstances beyond his control in a similar vein as Billy Pilgrim in Vonnegut’s 𝑆𝑙𝑎𝑢𝑔ℎ𝑡𝑒𝑟 𝐻𝑜𝑢𝑠𝑒 𝐹𝑖𝑣𝑒 𝑜𝑟 𝑡ℎ𝑒 𝐶ℎ𝑖𝑙𝑑𝑟𝑒𝑛’𝑠 𝐶𝑟𝑢𝑠𝑎𝑑𝑒.
If you’re a fan of thoughtful Science Fiction that doesn’t rely on aliens invading the Earth or AI and androids challenging their creators for supremacy, 𝑇ℎ𝑒 𝑉𝑖𝑠𝑖𝑡𝑜𝑟 is an excellent choice.
Edward Fleishman had an accident that no one expected him to survive; his body did, but he didn’t; his spirit moved out, and Ash’s moved in. Upon waking up in Edward's body, Ash doesn't know what is happening, but he manages to recall some of his past lives and knows he is on Earth because he vaguely remembers being here once long ago.
He struggles to navigate this strange new world and does his best to relate to people who he is supposed to know, including Edward's wife, Lucille. The strange customs, habits, beliefs, and behaviours of humanity and how easily they are manipulated and controlled by their masters seem absurd to an outsider looking in.
Like great art, this book reflects the best and worst of humanity, incorporating shades of light and dark with humour, friendship, love, and irony in parallel with the shadowy underworld of secrets, politics, and control. It had me hooked from the first page.
The Visitor takes a simple premise and turns it into a layered exploration of identity, memory, and what it means to belong in your own skin. Mitchell Waldman writes with an unsettling calm that makes Ash’s confusion feel real and deeply human, even as the world around him grows more surreal. The pace is deliberate, sometimes meandering, but the ideas and emotion carry it through. It is less about aliens or technology and more about consciousness itself, blurring the line between science fiction and psychological drama. Thoughtful, eerie, and memorable.
The Visitor offers a fascinating concept and thoughtful reflections on identity and human behavior. The outsider perspective is engaging, though the narrative style becomes repetitive as similar patterns recur across chapters. Still, the book has a unique charm and a sincere philosophical core.
If you enjoy introspective sci‑fi, body‑swap stories, or novels like Stranger in a Strange Land or Starman, you’ll likely appreciate what Waldman is doing here. A thoughtful read with a memorable premise.
While the premise of an off-world consciousness waking up in a human body is fascinating, the execution struggles. The author relies heavily on long narratives and excessive telling rather than showing us Ash’s profound disorientation. Furthermore, countless descriptive "-ly" adverbs crowd the prose, making the pacing sluggish. Dialogue tags become repetitive and distracting, often explaining emotions that should be self-evident. There is a clever psychological core buried underneath, but it gets lost in the flat exposition and heavy-handed stylistic choices.
Really interesting story, just a bit too slow for me. I liked the idea of waking up in someone else’s body and not knowing who or where you are. It feels more like a psychological trip than a sci-fi adventure. Ash’s confusion and struggle to fit in were written really well. The story makes you think about identity, memory, and what makes us human. Beautifully written, but I wished it moved a little faster.
This book feels like stepping into someone else’s life right along with the main character. It’s eerie in a calm way, where you’re never totally sure what’s real, but that’s kind of the point. It’s thoughtful and slow-burning, more about identity and belonging than action. It lingers after you’re done.
This is a relatively quick read with short snappy chapters that keep the pace moving. The concept of alien v reincarnation is interesting and I needed to find out how it ended. The lighter moments made me smile. Interesting take on what aliens might think of humans. Nice easy read, and I hope Ash has a better time of it in the future… wherever that may be!
The Visitor is a different kind of science fiction story. It is not at all what I expected or wanted. Waldman uses the story to offer a critique of American society. He points out many of America's shortcomings. The 'problem' is that his observations are spot on. However, he glosses over the good aspects of our society. That is disappointing.