America has always been sustained by rebellion and activism. It is up to us to continue the fight.
America's founding was a contradictory one. When the Declaration of Independence was signed 250 years ago, it painted a beautiful vision of freedom and equality. It was quite the gutsy move, declaring freedom, especially economic and religious freedom amid slavery and oppression for others. Indeed, for the majority of our nation's history, America hasn't lived up to its founding vision of freedom. Various movements have helped define and shape America, for good or bad, nudging us toward greater freedoms at times and pulling us back at others.
In our current era, these contradictions feel even more profound, and many of us are left wondering if America will ever live up to the promises of her founding, or if we are moving even further away from those hopes. Yet, a deeper look at our history reveals key revolutionary moments in which the promise of America has been fully realized. We've Been Here Before draws together the stories of these movements as a powerful reminder that America has always been sustained and challenged by rebellion and activism. Longtime journalists Michael I. Days and Angela P. Dodson compellingly profile the individuals who led those movements--the mavericks, rebels, outliers, and ordinary citizens who had extraordinary impact--paying particular attention to the women and people of color history has overlooked. At this important historical milestone, let us look back to celebrate those moments and let them guide our future.
Publisher's During the final stages of production for this book, Michael I. Days tragically passed away. Days was a pioneering journalist whose career left an indelible mark on American media. As the first Black editor of the Philadelphia Daily News, he led the paper to a Pulitzer Prize for Public Service in 2010, cementing his reputation as a fearless advocate for truth and accountability. Beyond his editorial achievements, Days championed diversity in newsrooms, serving as vice president of diversity and inclusion for the Philadelphia Media Network and holding leadership roles in the National Association of Black Journalists, including serving as president of its Philadelphia chapter. Inducted into the NABJ Hall of Fame in 2017, he was widely celebrated for mentoring countless young journalists and fostering inclusive storytelling. This book stands as just one part of the legacy he leaves behind, and we are grateful for his many contributions.
I think there's very little doubt that "We've Been Here Before: How Rebellion and Activism Have Always Sustained America" both lives in our history and is built for current times.
Written by the recently passed Michael I. Days with Angela P. Dodson, "We've Been Here Before" tells the story of how America has always been sustained by rebellion and activism.
"We've Been Here Before" is planted within the Declaration of Independence's promise of a nation built on freedom and equality yet also the acknowledgement that we've done a poor job of living up to this ideal.
As I was reading "We've Been Here Before," I felt it profoundly. I can't help but feel like there's a certain hopefulness here precisely because we've been here before and survived these trying times. Yet, I also can't help but be concerned because I wonder "Will we ever learn?"
Days and Dodson examine some of America's most powerful movements with extended attention given to racial equality, immigration rights, unions, voting rights, and gender rights. A relatively quick read, there's no question that significant movements are left out (disability rights, for example), but it would be nearly impossible to cover them all and it's remarkable how much is covered here. "We've Been Here Before" is compelling to read, extensively researched, and beautifully written.
More than anything, "We've Been Here Before" is a challenge to all of us to fight to ensure that democracy is around for generations to come and that our willingness to rebel must survive. It's integral to who we are as Americans. Guaranteed to appeal to those interested in civil rights along with cultural and ethnic studies, "We've Been Here Before" is a reminder that we have, indeed, been here before and it's our generation's turn to sustain America via good trouble and passionate activism.
The authors chronicle the rebels, outliers, and ordinary citizens who forced America to confront its founding contradictions, focusing on the overlooked women and people of colour who shaped the nation.
Indigenous resistance is traced from early assimilation attempts like the Harvard Indian College through the horrors of the Trail of Tears and residential boarding schools. This unbroken chain of survival connects directly to the modern LandBack movement, framing President Biden’s apology as a necessary step in an ongoing reckoning. The fight for religious freedom, which began with the Mayflower Pilgrims escaping British persecution, only for settlers to practice a selective liberty that initiated a cultural battle.
The response to enslavement was constant and fierce, ranging from daily defiance to daring escapes via the Underground Railroad. These acts provoked legislative backlashes like the Fugitive Slave Act and the Negro Act of 1740, following uprisings led by Cato, Prosser, and Vesey. In response, abolitionists secured arms and funds, with Frederick Douglass exposing the hypocrisy of the Fourth of July—a friction that ultimately triggered Southern secession.
Women’s rights evolved from servitude and legal nonexistence to educational breakthroughs through women's colleges. Silenced in early abolitionist spaces, women organised their own resistance at various conventions to secure suffrage, resulting in the subsequent modern waves of feminism.
Labour rights came from mining disasters, the Matewan Massacre, and the Battle of Blair Mountain alongside unionisation, as well as strikes like the Great Railroad, the Washing Society, Haymarket, Homestead, Pullman, and Flint Sit-Down. This demand for accountability mirrors the Civil Rights and Peace movements.
Finally, environmentalism. The book links Rachel Carson's Silent Spring and the creation of Earth Day directly to the climate crisis, up to global warming and Greta Thunberg's bold confrontations with world leaders.
Progress isn't linear. When the nation regresses, ordinary people have always been the ones to pull it back toward its founding ideals.
As America approaches its 250th anniversary, We’ve Been Here Before by Michael I. Days and Angela P. Dodson offers a timely reminder that many of the debates shaping our nation today are not new. Through chapters on Indigenous resistance, slavery and abolition, women’s suffrage, labor organizing, civil rights, and the anti-war movement, the authors explore how generations of Americans have fought to expand the meaning of freedom, equality, and citizenship.
One of the book’s greatest strengths is its ability to connect historical events to contemporary issues without losing sight of the people whose sacrifices helped shape the nation. The authors make a compelling case that progress has never been guaranteed and that many of the rights Americans enjoy today were secured through persistence, activism, and collective action.
I especially appreciated the chapters on the labor movement and civil rights, which highlighted stories that are often overlooked in traditional history discussions. The book is accessible, well-researched, and written in a journalistic style that keeps the pages turning. The book succeeds in its goal of encouraging readers to examine America’s past in order to better understand its present.
I also want to acknowledge co-author Michael I. Days, who passed away before the book’s publication. His journalistic voice and commitment to telling these stories are evident throughout the text.
Thanks to the authors and the African American Literature Book Club (AALBC) for providing an advance review copy.
Recommended for readers who enjoy American history, social justice, civil rights, labor history, political nonfiction, current affairs, and books that connect historical events to today’s cultural and political conversations.
Thank you to LibraryThing Early Reviewers for my copy of this book.
When the government stops caring about most of the citizens in the country, especially those that historically been marginalized, the fight back from authors and publishers is awesome. I have read some amazing books this year on democracy, fighting back, what to look out for, and what to say to those who see no problem (although I don't encounter a lot of those anymore.) We've Been Here Before is a rather depressing title that tells the absolute truth. But the subtitle, How Rebellion and Activism Have Always Sustained America gives us hope, and to quote a famous person who actually loved his country and it's people, I have the Audacity of Hope.
I really enjoyed reading an advance copy of We’ve Been Here Before. The book does a great job of showing how activism and resistance have always been part of American history, even during periods that felt deeply divided or unstable.
What I appreciated most was how relevant it felt to the current political and social climate without becoming overly preachy or hopeless. The historical parallels were fascinating, and the writing made complex topics approachable and engaging.
Recommended for readers interested in history, politics, social justice, or civic engagement.
I like the hope contained in this book. A great survey of the advancements that we’ve made due to the efforts of change leaders and citizens willing to fight for justice. A reminder to all of us that we’ve got to keep fighting even in these dark days.