I was shocked.
I had a feeling when on page 41, “he moved closer and brushed her ear with his lips”, that he was a creep and hanging with him was not a good idea.
That fact that he was DEAD the whole time and was stuck in a time loop, luring girls in and killing both them and his sister! Like wow.
And at the end after they’ve broken the jar, and realised that they’re in the wrong timeline, AND Eli’s hiding in the woods, “she turned just in time to see Eli’s grinning face among the leaves.” Like no way, how is he there, shouldn’t he be in the past, because Rachel’s still alive and there and Eli shouldn’t be.
And the pendants used to try and make people feel special, icky.
Overall, a shocking book. Did not expect that ending, but Eli was clearly a creep. Going from open and friendly to cold and menacing. And living in a ‘safe’ cave, which was clearly going to be washed out by the tide.