4.5/5 stars
Recommended if you like: magic, survival stories, dragons, dual POV
Big thanks to Margaret K. McElderry Books, Netgalley, and the author for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This book was a nice, quick read, but it's also an uncomplicated read. I was a bit influenced by the Waxways trilogy while reading this and definitely wanted a more ruthless, scheming main character. Obviously this book is not those books, but I did come in with the Waxways series in mind and all the deviousness those characters carry, and I was expecting something similar. While the characters are hiding things, sometimes quite big things, I couldn't help but feel as though the leadup to those secrets wasn't that major. By the time they're revealed, I was kind of just like 'okay' and moved on. (also, frankly, Marken's secret isn't really a secret, we're literally told what happens in the first 10 chapters and then he acts like that account was wrong)
Another issue I have is that it didn't really feel like the characters had any particular agency. I mean, Pearl steps in when the windmaster starts dying, but a ship's crash is obviously outside of anyone's control. Then they're on the island and other people make the decision to mutiny and other people decide how to spend the group's energy, and things just sort of happen. The dragoness hunts them, but I never really felt any danger even though she does very much kill a bunch of the group. The warden and Levi are out for blood, which actually did seem like it had more conflict potential, but that problem sort of gets solved. Everything was just so neat and generally seemed likely to occur regardless of whether Pearl and/or Marken did anything for it to happen.
That being said, I'm always a sucker for survival stories, and I did enjoy the early tension between the various factions of survivors. At the start there were three main groups: the warden and guards, the crewmembers, and the passengers. There's an obvious side we're meant to root for, and surprisingly few passengers want to pick the other side. Likewise, there's a tension between desires at the beginning as well, between the people who want to stay on the beach and see if they're discovered quickly, and the people who want to explore the island and see what they have to work with for survival and escape. This phase lasts a surprisingly short time, and I do wish we'd gotten a little more out of it before things came to a head between the crewmembers and warden.
The dragoness poses new challenges to the group, aside from the troubles of surviving on a random island. Reintgen takes an interesting approach to dragons in this book and I was quite intrigued. I wish we got more of a chance to really explore the creatures more, though since Pearl is the only 'expert' I do get why we don't. Considering the dragon is determined to murder all humans, I was expecting her to be a bigger threat, and she did pick off the survivors, but I didn't really feel the threat. The dragoness ended up feeling somewhat like a caricature villain and for a creature that is supposedly extremely intelligent and adaptable, I was expecting something more difficult to overcome.
I liked both Pearl and Marken and they both brought different things to the table. Pearl is pretty grounded and is knowledgeable about a number of different subjects. She's good in a crisis and is able to generalize her knowledge to a range of different circumstances, as we can see when she tries to save the windmaster and in her conversations with Marken re: magic.
Marken is someone vastle knowledgeable about magic but less familiar with things like socialization. He has a good sense of humor though and while he puts on somewhat of an arrogant front, it's clear fairly quickly that Marken has a good head on his shoulders and doesn't mind taking the backseat when needed.