Finished Reading
Pre-Read notes
I was honestly smitten with the Title of this one, and that bird on the original cover. That image force my perspective to shift, I felt, and I was in for any story that did the same!
Final Review
My aliveness is beaming out of me, every pore shining with the fact that I’m alive. I’m so fucking alive I’m shaking. We’re alive, you and me, we’re alive, and that’s why I’m running now, running down the trail with my Birkenstocks flopping and my great misshapen belly straining to stay upright, p56
Review summary and recommendations
I admit I have an embarrassing weakness for disaster and survival stories, and this one is both. This completely miserable but totally memorable protagonist is a young pregnant woman who must survive a massive earthquake and its aftermath.
The FMC of this book will probably be a terrible mother, but I love her as the protagonist of this story! I was rooting for her the whole way. I loved how this story's is unafraid to be hopeful in a high stakes and terrifying situation.
I recommend this to readers of thrillers, disaster stories, and action books. I also think fans of strong female characters, fast-paced reads, and mom narratives.
People have done harder things than this. People have been through worse than this. Nobody I know, but still, people. p162
Reading Notes
Seven things I loved:
1. My belly distended, a blimp exiting sideways out of my body. I walk in stiff little jerky motions like a stork. p6 Best description of pregnancy ever 🤣
2. Some really brilliant depictions of anxiety from first person POV. Her efforts don't feel forced or hurried, which is sometimes my experience of anxiety from first person. The details of her experience are perfectly fish-out-of-water.
3. The description of inflation over the last 30 years from first person is actually sort of harrowing to read. It's really brilliant writing!
4. Maybe we’re not telling the jokes, we are the joke. Now that we’re pregnant, we’re forced to be part of some enormous collective joke about women.... I really like how this author writes about being pregnant. It's so real and, yes, darkly funny, even given her circumstances.This would be a great joke: the pregnant woman who couldn’t just stay home like she was supposed to, like everybody else would have preferred, who couldn’t wait for the ambulance, who forgot to grab water, who lost her phone and purse and keys, who didn’t buy the whistle even after being told to buy the whistle, didn’t text her husband back, didn’t tell anyone where she was going, who couldn’t JUST WAIT. Who doesn’t even know if her baby is alive, even though she is a mother and a mother is supposed to FEEL THESE THINGS. I am the joke. That damn bra strap sliding down my arm over and over. p142
5. The thread of the plot is fascinating, both seemingly random and clearly the cohesive force of the story. Just excellent work on this unique form!
6. Throughout this brilliant disaster story, the fmc speaks in first person to her unborn baby. I don't always go for this kind of first/second person mashup, but it works really well here, becoming part of the character's internal monolog.
7. Some moving depictions of grief in this book, without going over the top. Hyperbole, in the few instances it arises, seems to be in response to the setting, which is unfriendly.
One thing I didn't love:
This section isn't only for criticisms. It's merely for items that I felt something for other than "love" or some interpretation thereof.
1. The confrontation in the opening scene feels theatrical to me. It's just a little too out of reach. But the scene is propulsive for sure. *edit honestly I think it was intentional for the author to do this, because she has some interesting development in for these two characters. You almost need this scene to establish the characters' grit.
Rating: 🪨🪨🪨🪨🪨 /5 pieces of rubble
Recommend? yes!
Finished: Mar 17 '25
Format: accessible digital arc, NetGalley
Read this book if you like:
☄️ disaster stories
🫄 mom stories
🏋🏻♀️ strong female characters
👩🏼🤝👩🏾 unlikely friends
Thank you to the author Emma Pattee, publishers MarySue Rucci Books, and NetGalley for an accessible advance digital copy of TILT. All views are mine.
---------------