• Birth Date: March 11th, 1972 • Blood Type: A • Zodiac: Pisces
Kazune Kawahara (河原和音) made her manga debut at age 18 with Kare no Ichiban Sukina Hito (His Most Favorite Person). Also, while thinking of her manga, she often spaces out and brings grocery baskets home. Adores her nieces.
Uh, yay, and stuff. This is really good and I still don’t love reading it. I’m torn because this achieves a lot this volume, but it feels like a lot of strong work for something that doesn’t quite deserve it.
As usual, the side stuff is what I really come for. I could watch Sui and Mio bounce off themselves and Sae for days on end and not get bored. Normally Mio is the scene-stealing queen, but Sui is absolutely on fire this volume.
Besides being the world’s best support person as Sae goes through it with Koki, Sui also manages to be the world’s best salesperson and has the makings of a top-tier gambling addict. The smash cut of her at the festival is golden.
The festival is actually one of the better ones I have seen lately. It has some unique events, no maid cafes for a change, and I’m always happy to see Sae show off by being strong. I know she has a complex about it, but I like when she’s just herself.
I still find Koki so damn boring and there is something about this art, which I enjoyed just fine during High School Debut, that doesn’t really work for me. It feels like a series of static shots rather than anything real to me, like reference photos that got used instead of drawn over.
Subaru still doesn’t really register as a rival, which is good since she’s Koki’s cousin and all. I liked that she pushed Sae a little bit this volume. She’s energetic and popular, but not crazy annoying.
A lot of the rival stuff gets just tossed, actually, as sudden communication happens and everything decides to work itself out. It’s weird to say after this many volumes, but it does feel like a bit of an ‘oh, okay, it happened’ moment. I mean, this is more realistic than some sort of grand moment, but a lot of people are reading for those grand moments.
I also didn’t love that the last chapter is basically just a flashback showing Sae and Koki falling in love from elementary school. We’ve heard this story already in these very pages and neither of them are compelling enough to make this compelling material.
Genuinely this is a pain to review. It’s objectively well done, lots of clever stuff and some great character work with the B team. Yet I feel like I could not care less about Koki and that really drags this for me. Sae rocks and I would have liked a story more focused on her grappling with her body image, but that’s not exactly the genre.
3.5 stars - I will round up because it is objectively well done, but not because I think it is stellar work. Absolutely rate it higher if you’ve been invested from the start.
4.5 stars. My emotions! My emotions! I cried. I squeed. I love this. It is a littlr drawn out, which is why there is half a star off, but it's so sweet. My tender girlish heart is beating so strongly for these characters. Ahhh! So cute. Feet kicking cuteness.
Gets an extra quarter-star because--to my surprise--these two dunderheads actually managed to confess to each other, face-to-face, without either of them dodging the issue, or having some sort of eleventh-hour misinterpretation of the other's words.
Good going! Well, then. What's next?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This volume is undeniably better than the last, yet I can't help but feel like I've reached a natural stopping point with the series. Initially, I was really rooting for Iwata and Kameshiro, but they are both incredibly dull individuals and I was increasingly detached in whether they will finally get together or not. There are better shoujo romance series out there!
Per quanto riguarda i manga di ambientazione scolastica, "A star brighter than the sun" lo metto più meno sullo stesso livello di "Diary of a Female Lead": due storie abbastanza carine, mq che trovo un po' lontane dalla profondità di altri titoli con la stessa ambientazione di fondo, "Skip and Loafer" su tutti, ma anche "Credimi, è amore". Se non altro, all'alba del quinto volume, il rischio triangolo sembra essere tramontato definitivamente: il festival della scuola diventa il momento giusto che spinge i due protagonisti a dichiararsi e a far finalmente chiarezza sui rispettivi sentimenti. Menomale perché sto tira e molla mi stava logorando 😮💨 Sae non mi dispiace come personaggio: è una ragazza solare, sempre pronta a spendersi per gli altri, ma gli idioti sentono la necessità di fare commenti solo sulla sua altezza, sul suo fisico e sul suo amore per il cibo. E credo che in parte questi commenti e osservazioni, oltre a tutti i momenti di miscommunication di cui sono pieni i primi quattro volumi, abbiano contribuito a rafforzare la sua idea di non avere alcuna speranza con Koki. Fortunatamente il ragazzo ha pensato bene di parlare e di chiarire tutto - un sentimento che per entrambi ha radici lontane e che ora può essere esplorato. Tuttavia la storia è ancora lunga, quindi il drama non richiesto è sempre dietro l'angolo (nel mentre speriamo che il compagno di classe se ne faccia una ragione e non diventi un elemento di disturbo inutile).
Liked this volume more, it feels like more happened than the last which felt like the same thing each chapter. We also have a flashback chapter seeing his POV, its cute. I like the side characters more than our MCs they seem to add more to the story honestly lol. Good friends for the win always.
This manga is so sweet and tender, the "drama" isn't necessarily the usual tropes but rather the fear of sharing your emotions to the people around you, the fear of unreciprocated feelings.
I love a friends-to-lovers story, and this is showing the progression in such a sweet way. I love the glimpses of their history that we’re getting. And the confessions in this volume? The sweetest, cutest scenes!