This ended up being a funny one for me – I was intrigued enough by the premise to give it a go as, a. I like crime fiction, and b. I’m always intrigued by novels with a journalist as one of the main characters.
I couldn’t really say that I liked this book, but at the same time, I couldn’t claim to vehemently dislike it either. I think the best adjective to describe it would be ‘inoffensive’, except to anyone who (like me) once worked in a local newspaper and takes umbrage to the depiction of the profession.
‘The Sunbaker’ jumps around between the minds of four characters (plus an extra one that I won’t spoil, but which kind of gave the game away a little). Nicola Fox is the pathologist whose holiday home becomes a dumping ground for a dead body; Jack Harris is a local journalist and acquaintance who she turns to for support; Caitlin O’Shaughnessy is a local lawyer and is agonising over her relationship with Jack; and Begley, the local, cantankerous cop who isn’t one for any of the protocol, standard or otherwise.
There’s enough going on here to keep me reading, even though the mystery falls apart a little in the second half of the book. There aren’t enough red herrings dotted through to provoke doubt, and the obvious culprits are way too easy and obvious.
The antagonists felt very much like caricatures, with a police communications officer who wouldn’t get a job running a church newsletter.
Of the main characters, I liked Caitlin best of all – it felt like she went on more of a journey as a character. The others were a little one-dimensional for my liking and many of the scenes between Jack and Begley or Jack and Ricky read like a pair of teenagers trying to out-banter each other.
The main issue was that it didn’t feel like there was any jeopardy for any of the characters – they were all spectators, even Nicola whose house was the crime scene(!) and it never felt like any one of the main characters was in any kind of immediate peril.
My last, and biggest gripe, was around the depiction of the journalistic profession. I’m not sure how the newspaper goes out when it has one journalist who writes one story every few days… Add to that that a breaking news story should not include the journalist’s suppositions, and I was already in the ‘hard to win over’ category.
As I said, there was enough in this to keep me reading to the end, and I did like the setting and some of the secondary characters, particularly Marylin/Brenda and Moira, but it all felt a bit too easy for (most of) the characters in the end.
2.5 stars rounded up.
My thank to Echo Publishing, via NetGalley, for the eARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.