What do you think?
Rate this book
Not-So-Savage Barbarians #4
The Barbarian's Claim
I’ve been alone most of my life. No family, no home. No one would care if I disappeared. I wouldn’t survive another year on my own. In a desperate attempt to survive, I volunteered as tribute to the barbarians after hearing they now accepted males. At least if I died, I would have done something good by sparing someone else. But it wasn’t at all what I was expecting. And when my protector abandons me for being unable to speak, I’m left floundering again until someone else steps up to take his place. He’s dangerous and scarred, and people give him a wide berth, but he offers me something I haven’t had since I was a child. Safety. I’d be a fool to walk away now.
165 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 2, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 181 reviews
September 3, 2025
I can't give any of the Barbarians books more than 3 stars because they lack depth, but that doesn't mean I don't enjoy them in the same way I enjoy a frappuccino: as a sweet snack with no nutritional value but quite tasty.
The fourth installment features Matthew, who volunteers as tribute to escape homelessness and ridicule. Matthew is traumatized and selectively mute; he stutters and possibly has a learning disability and auditory processing disorder, but he's resilient and a hard worker.
Einar becomes Matthew's protector by chance. Einar, gruff and antisocial, lives on the outskirts and is not commitment material (why is unclear). He prefers silence, so Matthew's quiet nature is like a balm to his soul.
There's plenty of hurt/comfort here. Also punishment - if you've been jonesing for a beheading, you won't be disappointed.
What else? Hunting/skinning of animals, more bathing in the river, angry barbarians attacking Matthew, other male tributes coming to his aid, etc. Oh, and sex. Obviously.
The fourth installment features Matthew, who volunteers as tribute to escape homelessness and ridicule. Matthew is traumatized and selectively mute; he stutters and possibly has a learning disability and auditory processing disorder, but he's resilient and a hard worker.
Einar becomes Matthew's protector by chance. Einar, gruff and antisocial, lives on the outskirts and is not commitment material (why is unclear). He prefers silence, so Matthew's quiet nature is like a balm to his soul.
There's plenty of hurt/comfort here. Also punishment - if you've been jonesing for a beheading, you won't be disappointed.
What else? Hunting/skinning of animals, more bathing in the river, angry barbarians attacking Matthew, other male tributes coming to his aid, etc. Oh, and sex. Obviously.
![Profile Image for Carol [Goodreads Addict].](https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1626057011i/10717098._UX200_CR0,33,200,200_.jpg)
October 15, 2025
The Barbarian’s Claim is book four in the Not-So-Savage Barbarians series by Amy Padilla. I love this series. I might even be a little addicted to this clan of Barbarians who are actually loving and caring.
Matthew is twenty years old. I have to admit that his history broke my heart. After a family tragedy, he pretty much lost his ability to speak. He can get a few shaky words out at times but most of the time, he just freezes up. In the town he lived in, he was outcast, barely surviving living on the streets. So once he learned that males were allowed to be tributes, he volunteered. He thought it couldn’t be any worse than the life he was currently leading.
“Was there ever going to be a time when someone wished for me to be there?”
Matthew’s first protector pretty much abandoned him after realizing he didn’t speak. The huge, scarred barbarian, Einar, took him in and it was here that Matthew found patience, caring, and safety. With Einar, he began to feel a bit more confident. But still, he constantly worried that he might do something to displease him and cause him to cast him out.
This was such a fantastic story of finally finding a place to belong where you felt accepted and safe. I love how this clan reveres their tributes above all else. Matthew brought out the best in Einar as well, helping him to also feel more accepted since he was a bit of an outcast himself, by his own choosing. You would never think a story about a clan of barbarians would be sweet and swoony but it is. I can’t wait to read the next book, The Physician’s Barbarian.
Matthew is twenty years old. I have to admit that his history broke my heart. After a family tragedy, he pretty much lost his ability to speak. He can get a few shaky words out at times but most of the time, he just freezes up. In the town he lived in, he was outcast, barely surviving living on the streets. So once he learned that males were allowed to be tributes, he volunteered. He thought it couldn’t be any worse than the life he was currently leading.
“Was there ever going to be a time when someone wished for me to be there?”
Matthew’s first protector pretty much abandoned him after realizing he didn’t speak. The huge, scarred barbarian, Einar, took him in and it was here that Matthew found patience, caring, and safety. With Einar, he began to feel a bit more confident. But still, he constantly worried that he might do something to displease him and cause him to cast him out.
This was such a fantastic story of finally finding a place to belong where you felt accepted and safe. I love how this clan reveres their tributes above all else. Matthew brought out the best in Einar as well, helping him to also feel more accepted since he was a bit of an outcast himself, by his own choosing. You would never think a story about a clan of barbarians would be sweet and swoony but it is. I can’t wait to read the next book, The Physician’s Barbarian.
April 1, 2026
4.25**** stars
Matthew & Einar
haha, the slow burn I didn’t know I needed (not that it still didn’t drive me nuts tho).
ahhhh, that broke my heart. Good things these books are bound to get sweet eventually.
Besides loving to see all the characters from the previous books, especially Simon ofc, I adored this romance between the village’s recluse and the tribute who couldn’t sleep and no one seemed to want. *huff They were such a good match.
also: the capability porn is strong in these books.
***************
Not-So-Savage Barbarians Series
Book 0.5 - The Unexpected Barbarian
Book 1 - The Barbarian's Tribute - 4.0 stars
Book 2 - Saved by a Barbarian - 3.5 stars
Book 3 - Seducing a Barbarian - 4.5 stars ♡
Book 4 - The Barbarian's Claim - 4.25
Book 5 - The Physician's Barbarian - 3.5 stars
Book 6 - Prince of the Barbarians - 4.0 stars
⇢ sequel series: Savagely Sweet Barbarians
Matthew & Einar
haha, the slow burn I didn’t know I needed (not that it still didn’t drive me nuts tho).
“You know of Rath and Finn, yes?” I waited for him to nod before continuing. “You have seen them together?” Again, he nodded, still frowning. “That will not happen with us. I cannot give you that. I can take care of your needs and keep you safe. Nothing more.”
ahhhh, that broke my heart. Good things these books are bound to get sweet eventually.
Besides loving to see all the characters from the previous books, especially Simon ofc, I adored this romance between the village’s recluse and the tribute who couldn’t sleep and no one seemed to want. *huff They were such a good match.
[…] he drew me between his legs, pressing his lips against the scar on my belly. It was his morning ritual, reminding me of what he would do to protect me if anyone thought they could hurt me.
also: the capability porn is strong in these books.
***************
Not-So-Savage Barbarians Series
Book 0.5 - The Unexpected Barbarian
Book 1 - The Barbarian's Tribute - 4.0 stars
Book 2 - Saved by a Barbarian - 3.5 stars
Book 3 - Seducing a Barbarian - 4.5 stars ♡
Book 4 - The Barbarian's Claim - 4.25
Book 5 - The Physician's Barbarian - 3.5 stars
Book 6 - Prince of the Barbarians - 4.0 stars
⇢ sequel series: Savagely Sweet Barbarians
December 31, 2025
Matthew + Einar 🖤
Barbarian recluse | Non-verbal MC | Hurt comfort | Age gap
Einar was the clan recluse and Matthew struggled with his speech, so he was non-verbal most of the time. The initial "protector" Matthew was assigned to didn't protect him at all and chose to berate him for his speech issues. Einar never wanted a bondmate. He enjoyed his space and silence. But he couldnt ignore the sweet quiet man who needed protection.
⚠️ potential spoilers below in detailed tropes, content and warning lists
Tropes/content:
Barbarian
Clan recluse
Scarred face
20 year age gap (20 and 40)
Self volunteered tribute
Mostly non verbal MC due to trauma
Stutter
Cave sex
Good boy
Rimming
Cum as lube
Checks his hole to make sure he didn't hurt him
Very quick bonding. Didn't wait for a ceremony.
"This is just protection and sex. I can't offer you love."
Panic attacks
Hurt comfort
Found family
Matthew messed around a bit with a boy when he was in an orphanage but he's never had sex that was pleasurable. Always hurt him. So it's almost like he's experiencing everything for the first time with Einar
Kisses his scar
Mine
Unspoken no kissing rule at first
Touch him and did
Strict roles
Warnings:
Matthew lost his entire family in a house fire
Snake bite
Stab wound and surgery on MC
Barbarian recluse | Non-verbal MC | Hurt comfort | Age gap
Einar was the clan recluse and Matthew struggled with his speech, so he was non-verbal most of the time. The initial "protector" Matthew was assigned to didn't protect him at all and chose to berate him for his speech issues. Einar never wanted a bondmate. He enjoyed his space and silence. But he couldnt ignore the sweet quiet man who needed protection.
⚠️ potential spoilers below in detailed tropes, content and warning lists
Tropes/content:
Barbarian
Clan recluse
Scarred face
20 year age gap (20 and 40)
Self volunteered tribute
Mostly non verbal MC due to trauma
Stutter
Cave sex
Good boy
Rimming
Cum as lube
Checks his hole to make sure he didn't hurt him
Very quick bonding. Didn't wait for a ceremony.
"This is just protection and sex. I can't offer you love."
Panic attacks
Hurt comfort
Found family
Matthew messed around a bit with a boy when he was in an orphanage but he's never had sex that was pleasurable. Always hurt him. So it's almost like he's experiencing everything for the first time with Einar
Kisses his scar
Mine
Unspoken no kissing rule at first
Touch him and did
Strict roles
Warnings:
Matthew lost his entire family in a house fire
Snake bite
Stab wound and surgery on MC
April 3, 2026
I enjoy this series. It's a great way to just switch your brain for a while.
July 21, 2026
Yesssss!!! I was looking for broody/grumpy x anxious/lonely and this was exactly what I had in mind. Hit all the tropes I wanted. These are short and stay fairly shallow so they're never gonna be all time favorites, but I had a good time while reading it.
I love when the grumpy/broody MC really is an asshole and doesn't secretly have a heart of gold with everyone - truly a soft ONLY for him situation and that's exactly Einar's deal. He doesn't really give too many shits about anyone else but damn does he end up being EXACTLY what Matthew needed. Over there thinking he can't possibly be a good partner while literally doing every single thing right and doing it effortlessly, without thought. Absolutely top tier.
Matthew was one of the saddest, loneliest MCs I've read (besides that guy from Hellfire & Tinsel - Jesus Christ that guy). He deserved every good thing and luckily Einar was willing to give them.
The bad guys in these are all kind of cartoonishly bad but I don't care, it fits the vibe. It does feel like the tribe needs to clean house sometimes, though. 👀
This was cute and hit the spot for that specific dynamic of grumpy guy takes care of lonely boi. Not sure that I'll read more of these as this was the one I wanted, but they're so easy breezy that they make good palate cleansers so I might fit them in here and there.
*
*
*
*
*
Safety (may contain spoilers)
SA/rape: None
Other person drama: None
I love when the grumpy/broody MC really is an asshole and doesn't secretly have a heart of gold with everyone - truly a soft ONLY for him situation and that's exactly Einar's deal. He doesn't really give too many shits about anyone else but damn does he end up being EXACTLY what Matthew needed. Over there thinking he can't possibly be a good partner while literally doing every single thing right and doing it effortlessly, without thought. Absolutely top tier.
Matthew was one of the saddest, loneliest MCs I've read (besides that guy from Hellfire & Tinsel - Jesus Christ that guy). He deserved every good thing and luckily Einar was willing to give them.
The bad guys in these are all kind of cartoonishly bad but I don't care, it fits the vibe. It does feel like the tribe needs to clean house sometimes, though. 👀
This was cute and hit the spot for that specific dynamic of grumpy guy takes care of lonely boi. Not sure that I'll read more of these as this was the one I wanted, but they're so easy breezy that they make good palate cleansers so I might fit them in here and there.
He put a great deal of trust in me. I intended to honor that, even if I could not provide him with the relationship he was looking for. I could offer him protection and trust between us. For him, that would have to be enough.
“It will fit,” he growled, like he could see the question written on my face.
His roughened hand slid down my spine, making me shiver. “Good boy,” he crooned. My eyes squeezed shut on the praise, my whole being lighting up. I hadn’t known I needed to hear that until he spoke the words.
“What do you need, Matthew?” I prompted again. I wanted him to be able to tell me what he needed from me. If he felt safe to use his voice with someone, I wanted it to be me.
“I will go nowhere, kolrav. Wherever you wish me to be, that is where I will stay.”
*
*
*
*
*
Safety (may contain spoilers)
SA/rape: None
Other person drama: None
January 23, 2026
3.5⭐️ I don’t know, I guess I’m a sucker for these bite-sized stories about big, feral barbarians with secret hearts of gold. I can’t stop reading them.
September 7, 2025
Late night thoughts
I wholeheartedly believe that Simon was only created to be part of this book and be Matthew’s friend. I really enjoyed this book more than third book. The story did have a happy ending but honestly I felt like there could had been more to tell. Definitely my favorite out of the three.
I wholeheartedly believe that Simon was only created to be part of this book and be Matthew’s friend. I really enjoyed this book more than third book. The story did have a happy ending but honestly I felt like there could had been more to tell. Definitely my favorite out of the three.
August 23, 2025
Homeless and an outcast in his town, Matthew decides to offer himself up as tribute to the barbarians in the hopes that living amongst them would offer him a better life.
Things don’t quite go as planned though, when Matthew’s protector abandons him after learning that he doesn’t speak. Up steps Einar, the clan recluse, who treats Matthew with unexpected kindness.
Despite his rough and gruff exterior, Einar was a total softy for Matthew and it was so stinking adorable! I loved how patient and kind he was with Matthew, and never pressured him to be anything other than himself.
Things don’t quite go as planned though, when Matthew’s protector abandons him after learning that he doesn’t speak. Up steps Einar, the clan recluse, who treats Matthew with unexpected kindness.
Despite his rough and gruff exterior, Einar was a total softy for Matthew and it was so stinking adorable! I loved how patient and kind he was with Matthew, and never pressured him to be anything other than himself.
August 6, 2026
Cuteeee
September 2, 2025
This book is my absolute favourite in the series.
My heart broke for Mathew: he was an absolute sweetheart and the glimpses into past, just broke me.
Einar was quiet and look scary but that couldn’t be further from the truth. He was gruff, badass and spoke his mind yet with Mathew a much gentler, patient yet understanding side of came out.
These two were simply beautiful together. There was one part at the end, that had me in tears but I’m glad things worked out. Mathew eventually came out of his shell and it warmed my heart watching him open up.
*I voluntarily read this book. All opinions stated are solely my own and no one else's*
My heart broke for Mathew: he was an absolute sweetheart and the glimpses into past, just broke me.
Einar was quiet and look scary but that couldn’t be further from the truth. He was gruff, badass and spoke his mind yet with Mathew a much gentler, patient yet understanding side of came out.
These two were simply beautiful together. There was one part at the end, that had me in tears but I’m glad things worked out. Mathew eventually came out of his shell and it warmed my heart watching him open up.
*I voluntarily read this book. All opinions stated are solely my own and no one else's*
October 21, 2025
Einer is by far my favourite barbarian.
March 22, 2026
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐🌟
Spice Level:🌶️🌶️.75
Point of view: Dual, 1st Person
Characters
∎ Matthew
⇒ tribute / Non-verbal(has a stutter) / 20 / Bottom
∎ Einar
⇒ barbarian / scars on face / 40 / Top
🏷️TROPES & TAGS🏷️
◆ Age gap
◆ Hurt-Comfort
◆ size difference
◆ self volunteered tribute
◆ non verbal MC due to trauma
◆ torch him and die
◆ found family
◆ orphan MC
🍷SPICE AND KINKS🍷
Cave sex
good boy
rimming
fingering
cuming hands free
Anal
oral
●Dynamic: strict top bottom roles
⚠️TW/CW⚠️
◉ MC having a on page panic attack
◉ MC stabbed and hospitalized
◉ snake bite
◉ mentions of losing family my house fire
◉ MC being ignored and neglected
💭THOUGHTS💭
EINARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR. he my favorite barbarian. 😭 I love him so muchhh. this books is my favorite in the series 🙌🏼
Spice Level:🌶️🌶️.75
Point of view: Dual, 1st Person
Characters
∎ Matthew
⇒ tribute / Non-verbal(has a stutter) / 20 / Bottom
∎ Einar
⇒ barbarian / scars on face / 40 / Top
🏷️TROPES & TAGS🏷️
◆ Age gap
◆ Hurt-Comfort
◆ size difference
◆ self volunteered tribute
◆ non verbal MC due to trauma
◆ torch him and die
◆ found family
◆ orphan MC
🍷SPICE AND KINKS🍷
Cave sex
good boy
rimming
fingering
cuming hands free
Anal
oral
●Dynamic: strict top bottom roles
⚠️TW/CW⚠️
◉ MC having a on page panic attack
◉ MC stabbed and hospitalized
◉ snake bite
◉ mentions of losing family my house fire
◉ MC being ignored and neglected
💭THOUGHTS💭
EINARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR. he my favorite barbarian. 😭 I love him so muchhh. this books is my favorite in the series 🙌🏼
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 8, 2026
RE-READ 4-8-26: after finishing the second book in the spinoff series - which had a Matthew cameo! 🥰 - I wanted a re-read, and it's just as sweet as I remembered!
ORIGINAL 5-STAR REVIEW 9-2-25: Awwwwwww, this might be my favorite so far! 🥰🥰🥰 I absolutely adored it.
ORIGINAL 5-STAR REVIEW 9-2-25: Awwwwwww, this might be my favorite so far! 🥰🥰🥰 I absolutely adored it.
April 14, 2026
I love this series
Another fantastic book in the barbarian series. I think Matthew is just precious.
Kinda wish that Einar’s solitude was explained but it didn’t detract from my enjoyment
Another fantastic book in the barbarian series. I think Matthew is just precious.
Kinda wish that Einar’s solitude was explained but it didn’t detract from my enjoyment
September 3, 2025
4⭐️ 2🌶️
MOOD: lighthearted, sad, tense
TROPES: age gap, found family
GENRES: historical romance, lgbtq+ romance
MAIN CHARACTERS: Matthew and Einar
THE GOOD: This was a quick and fun read. Matthew and Einar have different struggles but, against some early preconsceptions, they work well together. Matthew finding a home and Einar finding something outside his lonliness & solitude, reluctantly at first, make the story as enjoyable as it was. It does follow a formula which I assume is similar in other books in the series. This is book 4 and I did not read book 1- 3 but I have read other Amy Padilla books. It read fine as a standalone, I just wondered if Finn and Simon had other stories already since they were some of the side characters mentioned.
THE MEH: The names got me - I know it's not a new name but the name Matthew felt out of place for the indistinct time period.
CW: violence, blood, sexual content, death
DISCLAIMER: I received an advance review copy. This is my honest review.
MOOD: lighthearted, sad, tense
TROPES: age gap, found family
GENRES: historical romance, lgbtq+ romance
MAIN CHARACTERS: Matthew and Einar
THE GOOD: This was a quick and fun read. Matthew and Einar have different struggles but, against some early preconsceptions, they work well together. Matthew finding a home and Einar finding something outside his lonliness & solitude, reluctantly at first, make the story as enjoyable as it was. It does follow a formula which I assume is similar in other books in the series. This is book 4 and I did not read book 1- 3 but I have read other Amy Padilla books. It read fine as a standalone, I just wondered if Finn and Simon had other stories already since they were some of the side characters mentioned.
THE MEH: The names got me - I know it's not a new name but the name Matthew felt out of place for the indistinct time period.
CW: violence, blood, sexual content, death
DISCLAIMER: I received an advance review copy. This is my honest review.
September 2, 2025
- series
- age gap
- found family
This is the 4th in a series, for some odd reason I've jumped in at Book 4 having not read the others, but I still picked up the story and characters and really enjoyed it. Matthew decides to offer himself up voluntarily when the barbarian clans come to claim their yearly tribute. He's an outcast in his town, ostracized for no good reason other than the townspeople are terrible. He's shy, with a bad stammer and even lower self esteem when he comes to the barbarian camp. His original protector fails spectacularly in that mission, and he finds himself with the self-imposed camp outcast Einar. Right from the start Einar is protective of him, looking out for him when nobody else was willing to.
Although this is a short read, there's plenty of story here and I'm assuming cameos from the other books too. I liked the unfolding of Einar and Matthew's story, I loved how patient Einar was with Matthew and how willing he was to help once he got past his initial grumpiness at finding himself saddled with a tribute. These two work together so well, Matthew softening Einar's hard edges and Einar bringing Matthew out of his shell, slowly but surely. This was a fun read, I liked the setting of the barbarian camp and the cast of surrounding characters too. I may go and find the previous books, I liked this so much.
- age gap
- found family
This is the 4th in a series, for some odd reason I've jumped in at Book 4 having not read the others, but I still picked up the story and characters and really enjoyed it. Matthew decides to offer himself up voluntarily when the barbarian clans come to claim their yearly tribute. He's an outcast in his town, ostracized for no good reason other than the townspeople are terrible. He's shy, with a bad stammer and even lower self esteem when he comes to the barbarian camp. His original protector fails spectacularly in that mission, and he finds himself with the self-imposed camp outcast Einar. Right from the start Einar is protective of him, looking out for him when nobody else was willing to.
Although this is a short read, there's plenty of story here and I'm assuming cameos from the other books too. I liked the unfolding of Einar and Matthew's story, I loved how patient Einar was with Matthew and how willing he was to help once he got past his initial grumpiness at finding himself saddled with a tribute. These two work together so well, Matthew softening Einar's hard edges and Einar bringing Matthew out of his shell, slowly but surely. This was a fun read, I liked the setting of the barbarian camp and the cast of surrounding characters too. I may go and find the previous books, I liked this so much.
August 31, 2025
The Barbarian's Claim is the 4th book in the Not-So-Savage Barbarians series. In my opinion this series is best read in order. This is the story of Einar a barbarian and Mathew a tribute. This story pulled on my heart stings so much that I actually cried a couple of times. Matthew volunteers to be a tribute thinking if he dies at least he is saving someone else. His first barbarian protector doesn't like Mathew because he doesn't talk, not realizing that he can't. Einar doesn't feel like he would do well as a protector but he ends up becoming Mathew's and things go from there. I loved this story so much. Watching these two figure things out and become more was so satisfying. I think this is my favorite book in the series so far. I would definitely recommend this book and series.
received a free review copy
received a free review copy
September 8, 2025
I loved this book so much!
Not-So-Savage Barbarians has quickly become my favorite series of the year. Each book gets better and better.
In The Barbarian’s Claim, we get Einar’s story (the dangerous, reclusive barbarian) and Mathew, the tribute who volunteered to step into this world. I don’t want to give away too much, because this is one of those books best experienced fresh, with all its emotions hitting you firsthand.
I can't wait for the next book. I don't want this series to ever end. Can we have many, many more books, please?
Not-So-Savage Barbarians has quickly become my favorite series of the year. Each book gets better and better.
In The Barbarian’s Claim, we get Einar’s story (the dangerous, reclusive barbarian) and Mathew, the tribute who volunteered to step into this world. I don’t want to give away too much, because this is one of those books best experienced fresh, with all its emotions hitting you firsthand.
I can't wait for the next book. I don't want this series to ever end. Can we have many, many more books, please?
Read
July 7, 2026Based on the blurb of Matthew's unwanted origin, I thought I would find this to be the most sappy, emotional one. Instead, I felt the measured, quiet presence of these two men to dominate, which makes sense. I'm glad within the series that each couple distinguishes themselves. Comparatively lower-heat, after Simon's libido in the previous installment.
On reflection, I'm a little surprised that we don't get more of Einar's backstory. It didn't affect my overall enjoyment, but we got surprisingly little reference to his scars and past bloodlust.
On reflection, I'm a little surprised that we don't get more of Einar's backstory. It didn't affect my overall enjoyment, but we got surprisingly little reference to his scars and past bloodlust.
September 8, 2025
i swear, this series is like chicken soup for the soul for me. it's got mountains of men who are endlessly sweet and caring, it has forced proximity and found family vibes, characters from previous books show up without that being annoying and usually star barbarian's that showed up in previous ones as well.
it's just taking a vacation inside my head.
and now, i will finish this review with the best burn i've ever read:
“Your mouth must be jealous of your ass with the amount of shit spewing from your lips,” he sneered, marching around Orn to stand in front of me.
it's just taking a vacation inside my head.
and now, i will finish this review with the best burn i've ever read:
“Your mouth must be jealous of your ass with the amount of shit spewing from your lips,” he sneered, marching around Orn to stand in front of me.
November 1, 2025
These are such silly little books, but I really enjoy them as a palate cleanser. And it was definitely a good vehicle to get me out of my reading slump because it’s very fan fiction-y and easy to read. I actually really enjoyed the relationship in this particular story as well. It was probably one of my favorites after Simon’s book.
October 27, 2025
I wasn’t sure how I was going to feel about this one, but I ended up really enjoying it. I liked the progression of their relationship and how each gained something they needed but love grew out of it.
July 20, 2026
Poor Matthew never had a chance 😭🥺 Einar should’ve made Orin suffer even more😡
December 13, 2025
Another book in this series that I enjoyed very much.
Oooohhh poor Matthew, he lived out in the streets and nobody cared about him. Becoming a tribute was certainly the best that could happen to him.
I loved how Einar and Matthew were perfect for each other. The barbarian was different to his fellow clan members and that made him understand Matthew. They were very sweet together, but then all couples i this series are swoony.
Finn kept crying in this book too and that fact made me laugh because, well, he was a very sensitive man and everything made him cry.
I also like about this series that all the tributes seem to be finding their place in the clan helping others or doing a specific job themselves.
Well, another good and entertaining installment in the series.
Oooohhh poor Matthew, he lived out in the streets and nobody cared about him. Becoming a tribute was certainly the best that could happen to him.
I loved how Einar and Matthew were perfect for each other. The barbarian was different to his fellow clan members and that made him understand Matthew. They were very sweet together, but then all couples i this series are swoony.
Finn kept crying in this book too and that fact made me laugh because, well, he was a very sensitive man and everything made him cry.
I also like about this series that all the tributes seem to be finding their place in the clan helping others or doing a specific job themselves.
Well, another good and entertaining installment in the series.
![Profile Image for ˗ˏˋ⟡ ݁₊ [sophie] ෆ ꒱ྀ.](https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1768515559i/120802966._UX200_CR0,11,200,200_.jpg)
November 11, 2025
“ But every time I felt like I could be happy, my only life only got worse. So when I heard the town asking for volunteers for tributes for the barbarians clans, I thought maybe if I did something good for someone else, I’d at lest get the chance to have something better in my next life”.
¿He visto que existía esta novela y me la he leído en menos de lo que canta un gallo? Sí. No me he escondido durante años no me voy a esconder ahora. Ha estado mucho mejor que la tercera entrega. Le da unas cuantas vueltas. Este protagonista me ha dado ternura y creo que se queda en mis favoritos.
¿He visto que existía esta novela y me la he leído en menos de lo que canta un gallo? Sí. No me he escondido durante años no me voy a esconder ahora. Ha estado mucho mejor que la tercera entrega. Le da unas cuantas vueltas. Este protagonista me ha dado ternura y creo que se queda en mis favoritos.
June 1, 2026
Reread: 4,5*
Because I decided to read all of the Barbarians stories after all, I reread Matthew and Einar's story. And just like the first time, I absolutely loved it on my second read.
Unlike Finn, Matthew is written in a way that doesn't annoy me. He's not a damsel in distress; he's strong in his own way, and I was really happy with how his relationship with Einar developed.
It was also interesting that this was one of the few stories in the series that actually mentioned the characters' ages. There's a significant age gap here—Matthew has just turned twenty, while Einar is forty. However, neither of them is bothered by it, and together they make an absolutely wonderful couple.
I was a little disappointed that Einar never actually told Matthew that he loved him. On the other hand, his actions throughout the rest of the series speak for themselves. Einar quite literally lives for Matthew, and their relationship is absolutely beautiful. This is definitely one of those books that I'll reread again in the future.
4*
I KNEW it had potential! I love 2 asocials together, they were so great!
Because I decided to read all of the Barbarians stories after all, I reread Matthew and Einar's story. And just like the first time, I absolutely loved it on my second read.
Unlike Finn, Matthew is written in a way that doesn't annoy me. He's not a damsel in distress; he's strong in his own way, and I was really happy with how his relationship with Einar developed.
It was also interesting that this was one of the few stories in the series that actually mentioned the characters' ages. There's a significant age gap here—Matthew has just turned twenty, while Einar is forty. However, neither of them is bothered by it, and together they make an absolutely wonderful couple.
I was a little disappointed that Einar never actually told Matthew that he loved him. On the other hand, his actions throughout the rest of the series speak for themselves. Einar quite literally lives for Matthew, and their relationship is absolutely beautiful. This is definitely one of those books that I'll reread again in the future.
4*
I KNEW it had potential! I love 2 asocials together, they were so great!
September 6, 2025
I’ve been really enjoying this series and was looking forward to Einar’s book, because who doesn’t love a scarred, grumpy barbarian finding love? I had high hopes, and it did start out with great potential, but there was just something missing that’s kept me from truly loving Matthew and Einar’s story. Book one is my favorite so far, and has become a sort of comfort read for me. There’s just something special about Rath and Finn, which I was hoping that magic would happen again with this book, but it fell a little short.
Honestly, that’s probably the main issue. This book needed to be longer in order to really flesh out Matthew’s trauma. And I really wanted to see more of his healing with Einar, but it all ends fairly abruptly. The other books are similar in length (under 200 pages), but, somehow, the author achieved better depth with those than this one. It’s also unclear why Einar doesn’t think he’s bondmate material. He’s particular and gruff, but that doesn’t mean he can’t find a good match (obviously…Matthew). And it’s also not that he’s just not ready to settle down. And he doesn’t sleep around or have a regular bedmate either. He just has this notion that he can’t love someone like he thinks they should be loved. There’s no one way to love someone…maybe that was the point, but it isn’t clearly made here. And Einar never has this epiphany.
After Einar and Matthew become intimate, I expected Einar to show more emotion. But even when Matthew tells him that he loves him, Einar doesn’t reciprocate 😢 He clearly does love Matthew, and shows it through action, but he doesn’t say it back, and that really bothered me. Matthew has no family left and he just wants to be loved and accepted for who he is. Einar accepts him and protects him and supports and encourages him, but I wanted to feel more of a sweetness from him. It’s hard to explain, but it’s like he’s the best protector, but lacks care and compassion. I love me a broody alpha male, but I want him to have a soft spot for his person at least. Einar is patient and generous and kind, but really not sweet. But Matthew doesn’t seem to mind that he isn’t overly affectionate or passionate. He prefers his protection and patience and acceptance over all else.
They DO love each other. And it’s easy to see. But I just wanted MORE. And I wanted to see them living together as an official couple more and getting Matthew’s speech and confidence built up. Overall, I still enjoyed their story and will likely read it again, but it did let me down a little since I was hoping for another power couple like Finn and Rath.
Honestly, that’s probably the main issue. This book needed to be longer in order to really flesh out Matthew’s trauma. And I really wanted to see more of his healing with Einar, but it all ends fairly abruptly. The other books are similar in length (under 200 pages), but, somehow, the author achieved better depth with those than this one. It’s also unclear why Einar doesn’t think he’s bondmate material. He’s particular and gruff, but that doesn’t mean he can’t find a good match (obviously…Matthew). And it’s also not that he’s just not ready to settle down. And he doesn’t sleep around or have a regular bedmate either. He just has this notion that he can’t love someone like he thinks they should be loved. There’s no one way to love someone…maybe that was the point, but it isn’t clearly made here. And Einar never has this epiphany.
After Einar and Matthew become intimate, I expected Einar to show more emotion. But even when Matthew tells him that he loves him, Einar doesn’t reciprocate 😢 He clearly does love Matthew, and shows it through action, but he doesn’t say it back, and that really bothered me. Matthew has no family left and he just wants to be loved and accepted for who he is. Einar accepts him and protects him and supports and encourages him, but I wanted to feel more of a sweetness from him. It’s hard to explain, but it’s like he’s the best protector, but lacks care and compassion. I love me a broody alpha male, but I want him to have a soft spot for his person at least. Einar is patient and generous and kind, but really not sweet. But Matthew doesn’t seem to mind that he isn’t overly affectionate or passionate. He prefers his protection and patience and acceptance over all else.
They DO love each other. And it’s easy to see. But I just wanted MORE. And I wanted to see them living together as an official couple more and getting Matthew’s speech and confidence built up. Overall, I still enjoyed their story and will likely read it again, but it did let me down a little since I was hoping for another power couple like Finn and Rath.
September 6, 2025
Since we're at book 4, you should already know what you're getting into when you open this.
Matthew is possibly the saddest of sacks so far, though. He genuinely hopes for the best, but sadly, "the best" means "able to survive," and nothing more. He lost his family at a young age, got turned out from the orphanage at 17, and has been starving and freezing on the streets of his town ever since. He volunteers as tribute for his town and is taken by the barbarians.
Matthew does not speak except for the extremely rare occasion. When he does, he usually stutters and it's no louder than a whisper. After a rocky start and a barbarian that didn't care anything about him, Einar takes over his care (the one that helped Patrick in the forest and saved Simon in his book).
Einar is quiet and patient. He notices how young Matthew looks, especially with how slight he's built, and sets about essentially fattening him up. He teaches Matthew some of the language and how to do a few different jobs.
Matthew is extremely hard on himself and often considers himself stupid and useless for every one of his shortcomings. He struggles finding any value in himself. However, it may well be that his struggles end up helping him: when Einar feels it would be best for Matthew to move on and settle down with someone else, Matthew experiences panic attacks and begs him not to send him away. Einar is hopeless to say no to Matthew, especially since he worries about anyone else doing enough to care for Matthew. Obviously, they eventually commit to each other.
In the end, I wish there'd been more backstory for both of these. Also, I feel like there's a few plot holes/inconsistencies:
Finn is sweet as pie, patient, and absolutely nonconfrontational, but just a few minutes into a language lesson with Matthew and Matthew is crying and shutting down. What happened in that lesson?
And every book hammers in the idea that "this tribe is different, we value our tributes and place them above everything," but man nearly every book depends on some conflict within the tribe and there's been some *real* assholes, so maybe they're not as good and kind as they think they are, hmmmmm???
Anyway. Probably not supposed to look into it too deeply...
Matthew is possibly the saddest of sacks so far, though. He genuinely hopes for the best, but sadly, "the best" means "able to survive," and nothing more. He lost his family at a young age, got turned out from the orphanage at 17, and has been starving and freezing on the streets of his town ever since. He volunteers as tribute for his town and is taken by the barbarians.
Matthew does not speak except for the extremely rare occasion. When he does, he usually stutters and it's no louder than a whisper. After a rocky start and a barbarian that didn't care anything about him, Einar takes over his care (the one that helped Patrick in the forest and saved Simon in his book).
Einar is quiet and patient. He notices how young Matthew looks, especially with how slight he's built, and sets about essentially fattening him up. He teaches Matthew some of the language and how to do a few different jobs.
Matthew is extremely hard on himself and often considers himself stupid and useless for every one of his shortcomings. He struggles finding any value in himself. However, it may well be that his struggles end up helping him: when Einar feels it would be best for Matthew to move on and settle down with someone else, Matthew experiences panic attacks and begs him not to send him away. Einar is hopeless to say no to Matthew, especially since he worries about anyone else doing enough to care for Matthew. Obviously, they eventually commit to each other.
In the end, I wish there'd been more backstory for both of these. Also, I feel like there's a few plot holes/inconsistencies:
Finn is sweet as pie, patient, and absolutely nonconfrontational, but just a few minutes into a language lesson with Matthew and Matthew is crying and shutting down. What happened in that lesson?
And every book hammers in the idea that "this tribe is different, we value our tributes and place them above everything," but man nearly every book depends on some conflict within the tribe and there's been some *real* assholes, so maybe they're not as good and kind as they think they are, hmmmmm???
Anyway. Probably not supposed to look into it too deeply...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 181 reviews