What do you think?
Rate this book
Kutchinsky's Egg: A Family's Story of Obsession, Love, and Loss
A riveting, heart-stopping family memoir that blends art, obsession, and love as the author searches for the spectacular jeweled egg that consumed her father’s dreams—and spelled her family’s downfall.
320 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 31, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
April 11, 2026
A good read when it’s acting as a History, less so when it’s acting as a Memoir.
Like most histories written by a member of the family of the subject, this has some prioritization issues in terms of content that take what could have been a great story and turned it into one that is…fine.
The egg and its journey is the best part of this, and Kutchinsky (mostly) remembers that the egg is the star. Where the content gets messier and less appealing is in how much time it spends on family history.
Some of that is very necessary to the story, inextricably linked to the fate of the titular egg. But Kutchinsky spends a LOT of time on her fraught relationship with her father and her parents marital struggles, which isn’t interesting to anyone outside their family, and far exceeds what needs to be there to support the story of the egg and how it was entangled with the family’s personal issues.
I would have preferred more about the jewelry business, history of the stones, and detail about how the egg and other pieces were made to so much memoirish detail that is mostly sad and frankly, fairly boring.
But the egg itself is captivating, and when it’s allowed to act as the central character of the story, this is a great read.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
Like most histories written by a member of the family of the subject, this has some prioritization issues in terms of content that take what could have been a great story and turned it into one that is…fine.
The egg and its journey is the best part of this, and Kutchinsky (mostly) remembers that the egg is the star. Where the content gets messier and less appealing is in how much time it spends on family history.
Some of that is very necessary to the story, inextricably linked to the fate of the titular egg. But Kutchinsky spends a LOT of time on her fraught relationship with her father and her parents marital struggles, which isn’t interesting to anyone outside their family, and far exceeds what needs to be there to support the story of the egg and how it was entangled with the family’s personal issues.
I would have preferred more about the jewelry business, history of the stones, and detail about how the egg and other pieces were made to so much memoirish detail that is mostly sad and frankly, fairly boring.
But the egg itself is captivating, and when it’s allowed to act as the central character of the story, this is a great read.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
Did Not Finish
April 3, 2026DNF @ 52%
I was expecting to hear how the author tracked down the famous Argyle Library Egg after it's location being unknown for years. Maybe eventually the book becomes that. but after getting halfway through the book and reading nothing but the Kutchinsky families dirty laundry and the egg still hadn't even been created yet, I was bored and threw in the towel.
I don't rate dnf books now that Goodreads has the dnf shelf, because that's not fair in my opinion, but of what I read I'd rate it 2☆. The author is a good writer, I think this may have been a more interesting read for me if it had been written as a novel. As is, I didn't care about any of the people in the book because everyone was painted in a negative light. With no one to root for and no egg in sight I felt zero motivation to keep reading.
I was expecting to hear how the author tracked down the famous Argyle Library Egg after it's location being unknown for years. Maybe eventually the book becomes that. but after getting halfway through the book and reading nothing but the Kutchinsky families dirty laundry and the egg still hadn't even been created yet, I was bored and threw in the towel.
I don't rate dnf books now that Goodreads has the dnf shelf, because that's not fair in my opinion, but of what I read I'd rate it 2☆. The author is a good writer, I think this may have been a more interesting read for me if it had been written as a novel. As is, I didn't care about any of the people in the book because everyone was painted in a negative light. With no one to root for and no egg in sight I felt zero motivation to keep reading.
April 21, 2026
Kutchinsky's Egg: A Family's Story of Obsession, Love, and Loss is, at its core, a story that feels almost too strange to be true—which is precisely what gives it its peculiar power. Serena Kutchinsky has taken what could have been a niche family anecdote about wealth and eccentricity and turned it into something far more compelling: a generational excavation of obsession, identity, and the emotional wreckage left behind by ambition run wild.
The uniqueness of the narrative lies in its central object: the Argyle Library Egg, a two-foot-tall monument of gold and pink diamonds that was intended to rival the legendary creations of Peter Carl Fabergé. It’s the kind of premise that borders on absurdity—a glittering, almost surreal artifact that manages to feel both mythical and grotesquely tangible. That tension fuels the book. The egg is not just a luxury object; it becomes a character in its own right, looming over the Kutchinsky family like a curse.
Serena’s journey to track down this object decades after it disappeared is admirable in its sheer persistence. There is something undeniably compelling about a daughter trying to understand the father she lost—not just to death, but to obsession long before that. Her investigation spans continents and decades, weaving together family history, diaspora narratives, and the opaque world of high-end jewelry. It’s difficult not to respect the tenacity required to pursue such a singular, elusive goal, especially when the answers threaten to destabilize the very mythologies that hold a family together.
And yet—admiration only goes so far before frustration sets in.
Because the more one reads about Paul Kutchinsky’s grand project, the harder it becomes to view it as anything other than an astonishingly bad idea. The scale alone is staggering: a massive, mechanically complex egg encrusted with tens of thousands of diamonds, created at enormous expense and intended for a buyer who never materialized. The price tag—reportedly in the millions—was not just ambitious; it was delusional.
It’s here that the book provokes a kind of incredulous anger. One finds oneself wanting to shout at Paul across the decades: What did you think would happen? The egg was not merely a risky venture; it was a catastrophic gamble that took down a family business, a marriage, and ultimately the man himself. The narrative makes clear that this was not a slow, inevitable decline but a self-inflicted implosion, driven by ego and a refusal to recognize limits.
Serena, for all her insight, does not entirely escape this critique. Her own obsessive quest to locate the egg mirrors her father’s fixation in ways that are clearly intentional but not always comfortable to read. The memoir is, by definition, subjective, and she is honest about being drawn into the same gravitational pull. Still, there are moments when her pursuit feels less like a search for understanding and more like a continuation of the same destructive pattern. You begin to wonder whether the egg is not just a relic of obsession but a mechanism that perpetuates it.
Complicating matters further is the murky portrait of the Kutchinsky family itself. The book hints—sometimes more than hints—at a legacy of backroom dealings, betrayals, and ethically dubious behavior. There is a sense that Paul’s downfall did not emerge in a vacuum but was part of a broader culture of risk-taking and secrecy. At times, he comes across less as a tragic visionary and more as a man entangled in his own questionable decisions, someone who blurred the line between ambition and opportunism.
The connection to Fabergé is particularly telling. Paul’s obsession with surpassing Fabergé’s eggs is framed as an artistic aspiration, but it also feels like a fundamental misunderstanding of what made those objects significant in the first place. Fabergé’s creations are inseparable from their historical context—specifically their association with the Russian imperial family and, by extension, the violent end of the Romanov dynasty execution. Without that history—the opulence followed by annihilation—the eggs risk becoming little more than extravagant curiosities. Paul’s attempt to replicate their grandeur without their context results in something hollow: a spectacle without a story, or at least without the right one.
Ironically, Serena’s book supplies that missing narrative. By embedding the egg within a deeply personal and often painful family history, she gives it the emotional weight her father could not. The object that once seemed like a monument to vanity becomes, in her hands, a symbol of loss, longing, and the complicated inheritance of obsession.
The emotional core of the memoir, however, belongs not just to Serena but to the constellation of women around her—herself, her sister Katrina, and her mother Holly. Their dynamic often reads like a modern echo of Hamilton’s famous trio, “Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy.” There’s a similar interplay of loyalty, rivalry, and differing responses to a shared patriarchal force. Each woman processes Paul’s legacy in her own way, creating a layered portrait of grief and resilience that anchors the book’s more extravagant elements.
In the end, Kutchinsky’s Egg is as frustrating as it is fascinating. Its uniqueness is undeniable; few memoirs revolve around something so bizarre, so glittering, and so destructive. Serena Kutchinsky deserves credit for chasing this story to its end, even when that meant confronting uncomfortable truths about her father—and herself. But the lingering impression is not one of triumph. It’s a kind of weary disbelief that so much was sacrificed for something so fundamentally misguided.
The egg may be extraordinary. The decision to create it was not.
The uniqueness of the narrative lies in its central object: the Argyle Library Egg, a two-foot-tall monument of gold and pink diamonds that was intended to rival the legendary creations of Peter Carl Fabergé. It’s the kind of premise that borders on absurdity—a glittering, almost surreal artifact that manages to feel both mythical and grotesquely tangible. That tension fuels the book. The egg is not just a luxury object; it becomes a character in its own right, looming over the Kutchinsky family like a curse.
Serena’s journey to track down this object decades after it disappeared is admirable in its sheer persistence. There is something undeniably compelling about a daughter trying to understand the father she lost—not just to death, but to obsession long before that. Her investigation spans continents and decades, weaving together family history, diaspora narratives, and the opaque world of high-end jewelry. It’s difficult not to respect the tenacity required to pursue such a singular, elusive goal, especially when the answers threaten to destabilize the very mythologies that hold a family together.
And yet—admiration only goes so far before frustration sets in.
Because the more one reads about Paul Kutchinsky’s grand project, the harder it becomes to view it as anything other than an astonishingly bad idea. The scale alone is staggering: a massive, mechanically complex egg encrusted with tens of thousands of diamonds, created at enormous expense and intended for a buyer who never materialized. The price tag—reportedly in the millions—was not just ambitious; it was delusional.
It’s here that the book provokes a kind of incredulous anger. One finds oneself wanting to shout at Paul across the decades: What did you think would happen? The egg was not merely a risky venture; it was a catastrophic gamble that took down a family business, a marriage, and ultimately the man himself. The narrative makes clear that this was not a slow, inevitable decline but a self-inflicted implosion, driven by ego and a refusal to recognize limits.
Serena, for all her insight, does not entirely escape this critique. Her own obsessive quest to locate the egg mirrors her father’s fixation in ways that are clearly intentional but not always comfortable to read. The memoir is, by definition, subjective, and she is honest about being drawn into the same gravitational pull. Still, there are moments when her pursuit feels less like a search for understanding and more like a continuation of the same destructive pattern. You begin to wonder whether the egg is not just a relic of obsession but a mechanism that perpetuates it.
Complicating matters further is the murky portrait of the Kutchinsky family itself. The book hints—sometimes more than hints—at a legacy of backroom dealings, betrayals, and ethically dubious behavior. There is a sense that Paul’s downfall did not emerge in a vacuum but was part of a broader culture of risk-taking and secrecy. At times, he comes across less as a tragic visionary and more as a man entangled in his own questionable decisions, someone who blurred the line between ambition and opportunism.
The connection to Fabergé is particularly telling. Paul’s obsession with surpassing Fabergé’s eggs is framed as an artistic aspiration, but it also feels like a fundamental misunderstanding of what made those objects significant in the first place. Fabergé’s creations are inseparable from their historical context—specifically their association with the Russian imperial family and, by extension, the violent end of the Romanov dynasty execution. Without that history—the opulence followed by annihilation—the eggs risk becoming little more than extravagant curiosities. Paul’s attempt to replicate their grandeur without their context results in something hollow: a spectacle without a story, or at least without the right one.
Ironically, Serena’s book supplies that missing narrative. By embedding the egg within a deeply personal and often painful family history, she gives it the emotional weight her father could not. The object that once seemed like a monument to vanity becomes, in her hands, a symbol of loss, longing, and the complicated inheritance of obsession.
The emotional core of the memoir, however, belongs not just to Serena but to the constellation of women around her—herself, her sister Katrina, and her mother Holly. Their dynamic often reads like a modern echo of Hamilton’s famous trio, “Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy.” There’s a similar interplay of loyalty, rivalry, and differing responses to a shared patriarchal force. Each woman processes Paul’s legacy in her own way, creating a layered portrait of grief and resilience that anchors the book’s more extravagant elements.
In the end, Kutchinsky’s Egg is as frustrating as it is fascinating. Its uniqueness is undeniable; few memoirs revolve around something so bizarre, so glittering, and so destructive. Serena Kutchinsky deserves credit for chasing this story to its end, even when that meant confronting uncomfortable truths about her father—and herself. But the lingering impression is not one of triumph. It’s a kind of weary disbelief that so much was sacrificed for something so fundamentally misguided.
The egg may be extraordinary. The decision to create it was not.
January 7, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this advance reader copy.
All I have to say is, I would have written the book too. The authors family story is interesting from escaping a troubled Eastern Europe to reestablishment in London, to the creating, losing, and rediscovering the famous egg. My only complaint is I wish this was written as a fiction book, a historical fiction more specifically, because it would bring a wider audience. Still I would recommend it to patrons wanting something unique and willing to go toward non fiction.
3.5*
All I have to say is, I would have written the book too. The authors family story is interesting from escaping a troubled Eastern Europe to reestablishment in London, to the creating, losing, and rediscovering the famous egg. My only complaint is I wish this was written as a fiction book, a historical fiction more specifically, because it would bring a wider audience. Still I would recommend it to patrons wanting something unique and willing to go toward non fiction.
3.5*
April 14, 2026
I thought this would be interesting. It didn't keep my attention. Very dry.
March 31, 2026
HAPPY PUB DAY TO THIS GEM (bad pun I know)
Lots of storytellers share their family stories of rags to riches (and sometimes back to rags). Many Jews have gripping stories to share about their family's flight from East to West over the 19th and 20th century and the success (or failure) they find in a new, often hostile country. But it is likely (actually almost certain) that no one has a story to tell like Serena Kutchinsky. In a transfixing narrative, Kutchinsky offers a rags to riches to rags story, a family tale of flight from Eastern Europe to the slums of London to financial success with the House of Kutchinsky, but also along the way, at the center of it all, the remarkable story of a toddler sized, bejewelled mechanical diamond encrusted egg (think Faberge but larger and gaudier) on which her father staked his career, his family's fortune, and the reputation of the storied family jewelry business. Kutchinsky sets out to unravel this complicated, ultimately tragic, part of her history, while also trying to locate the ultimate location of the "Argyle Library Egg" as the egg became known. Highly recommend for family memoirs and historical memoirs. Thank you to Scribner and Netgalley for the DRC
Lots of storytellers share their family stories of rags to riches (and sometimes back to rags). Many Jews have gripping stories to share about their family's flight from East to West over the 19th and 20th century and the success (or failure) they find in a new, often hostile country. But it is likely (actually almost certain) that no one has a story to tell like Serena Kutchinsky. In a transfixing narrative, Kutchinsky offers a rags to riches to rags story, a family tale of flight from Eastern Europe to the slums of London to financial success with the House of Kutchinsky, but also along the way, at the center of it all, the remarkable story of a toddler sized, bejewelled mechanical diamond encrusted egg (think Faberge but larger and gaudier) on which her father staked his career, his family's fortune, and the reputation of the storied family jewelry business. Kutchinsky sets out to unravel this complicated, ultimately tragic, part of her history, while also trying to locate the ultimate location of the "Argyle Library Egg" as the egg became known. Highly recommend for family memoirs and historical memoirs. Thank you to Scribner and Netgalley for the DRC
Read
April 14, 2026* I do not rate NF books. *
Mini Audiobook Review: Thank you so much to Scribner books for the complimentary book! Thank you so much to Simon Audio for the complimentary audio!
This book is out now!
[in references to damaging letters]"I think he kept them because he'd been taught by his father that power came from what you didn't say. From what you held in reserve, and the possibility of leverage was something you never threw away."
This was such an interesting book! I had never heard of this egg and certainly never heard of the story of the creator and the whole history behind it. The family dynamic in this was so intriguing to me! I wanted more of Paul's relationship with his brother that he was estranged from. The first half of the book was okay. A lot of history of the family starting with the creation of her family's jewelry business and then goes into learning more about her grandfather into her father's childhood. Where it really got interested was when we got to the 80s and her father's idea of creating the egg. At one point in the book, Serena said there was the before the egg and after the egg. Pretty much everything would change when the egg came into the picture.
Yes the author was close to the subject matter as it was her family and you could tell that she really did her research to put into this. I was though getting thrown off when she would interchangeably call her dad by dad and his name Paul. The last bit of this book was filled with lies, death and the treasure hunt of finding the egg. Serena does do the narration in this and it only made sense that she told her family's story. She is a journalist and as I mentioned she really did her researched and it was organized so well with the time table of events.
Overall I thought this was a really well done story & I'm glad I read it! The egg is a beautiful egg. Oh and incase you are wondering, the egg was valued at $11.3 million USD back in 1990 when it was created which is close to $30 million now.
Mini Audiobook Review: Thank you so much to Scribner books for the complimentary book! Thank you so much to Simon Audio for the complimentary audio!
This book is out now!
[in references to damaging letters]"I think he kept them because he'd been taught by his father that power came from what you didn't say. From what you held in reserve, and the possibility of leverage was something you never threw away."
This was such an interesting book! I had never heard of this egg and certainly never heard of the story of the creator and the whole history behind it. The family dynamic in this was so intriguing to me! I wanted more of Paul's relationship with his brother that he was estranged from. The first half of the book was okay. A lot of history of the family starting with the creation of her family's jewelry business and then goes into learning more about her grandfather into her father's childhood. Where it really got interested was when we got to the 80s and her father's idea of creating the egg. At one point in the book, Serena said there was the before the egg and after the egg. Pretty much everything would change when the egg came into the picture.
Yes the author was close to the subject matter as it was her family and you could tell that she really did her research to put into this. I was though getting thrown off when she would interchangeably call her dad by dad and his name Paul. The last bit of this book was filled with lies, death and the treasure hunt of finding the egg. Serena does do the narration in this and it only made sense that she told her family's story. She is a journalist and as I mentioned she really did her researched and it was organized so well with the time table of events.
Overall I thought this was a really well done story & I'm glad I read it! The egg is a beautiful egg. Oh and incase you are wondering, the egg was valued at $11.3 million USD back in 1990 when it was created which is close to $30 million now.
May 10, 2026
What stayed with me after reading Kutchinsky's Egg was the uneasy way the jeweled egg functions as both artwork and emotional catastrophe. The object itself becomes a kind of gravitational force in the memoir, pulling ambition, family identity, financial ruin, and grief into the same orbit until it is impossible to separate the father from the obsession that consumed him.
I appreciated how Serena Kutchinsky structures the narrative as both investigation and inheritance. The search for the missing egg gives the book the momentum of a mystery, but the deeper question concerns why certain dreams become inseparable from self destruction. The memoir also carefully traces the family’s immigrant history and the rise of the House of Kutchinsky, which adds another layer about reinvention, status, and the pressure to build something lasting enough to justify sacrifice. The contrast between the extravagance of the jewelry world and the emotional instability underneath it gives the book much of its tension.
This book will reward readers who enjoy family memoirs driven by obsession, unanswered questions, and material objects carrying emotional weight across generations. I finished it thinking about how certain family legends remain unresolved because the mystery itself becomes part of the inheritance.
I appreciated how Serena Kutchinsky structures the narrative as both investigation and inheritance. The search for the missing egg gives the book the momentum of a mystery, but the deeper question concerns why certain dreams become inseparable from self destruction. The memoir also carefully traces the family’s immigrant history and the rise of the House of Kutchinsky, which adds another layer about reinvention, status, and the pressure to build something lasting enough to justify sacrifice. The contrast between the extravagance of the jewelry world and the emotional instability underneath it gives the book much of its tension.
This book will reward readers who enjoy family memoirs driven by obsession, unanswered questions, and material objects carrying emotional weight across generations. I finished it thinking about how certain family legends remain unresolved because the mystery itself becomes part of the inheritance.
May 10, 2026
Disappointing. Can't believe WSJ recommended this title. Author should have paid a ghost writer. Subtitle makes it sound as if this will be an enthralling mystery. Instead, it becomes boring. Style is so awkward; tone is that of a middle schooler struggling with her relationship with parents. Even though her father's behavior is not admirable or even honest most of the time, I don't know if a loving daughter (as she seems to say most of the time) should have told the world of the story of his questionable passion (s).
April 12, 2026
A fantastical story of an exquisite treasure, and how its creation destroyed the man who conceived and created it, while blowing apart his entire family at the same time. There are so many characters here, and their lengthy histories really bogged down the story of the egg itself. It seemed impossible to me that I had never heard of Kutchinsky's egg before. How can such a remarkable object be so obscure?
April 13, 2026
I'm an egg collector, so the title alone drew me to this book. I struggled through the lengthy family history and got a bit tired of the author as narrator....but once the egg entered the story my interest grew. Will try to get a hard copy of the book from the library in the hope there will some interesting photos of the principal character -- the EGG!!
April 27, 2026
Kutchinsky’s Egg is an interesting family memoir and mystery. I learned about the jewelry empire they built and then how it fell. I never quite understood why her dad thought this egg would set him apart when it seemed so much like Fabergé, but it’s nonetheless an intriguing read. I just wish it had resolved with a bit more suspense.
Did Not Finish
May 8, 2026This seemed like it was going to be a really interesting story, but I felt like I might have been sharing the thoughts that family members of the author might have had while reading it-- aka, "did you really have to talk about 'fucking' a few pages into this nice story commemorating your dad's life's work?" I left off there-
May 12, 2026
I have no idea what led me to this because I had no idea who these people were/are. It is the story of a family of Jewish jewelers, their migration to England, the crazed ambition of the author’s father to design a huge, intricate, gold and bejeweled egg. The story has a cautionery “lifestyles of the rich” flavor; the author gives a glamorous take on her family.
April 24, 2026
While I admittedly started skimming toward the end, I found the first half fascinating. It's about the egg, but it's also about assimilation, family relationships, and making your own mark on the world.
May 6, 2026
The egg stuff is interesting, but largely it’s an unexceptional family memoir about a bunch of unpleasant people. I would have liked to read more about the techniques used to make the egg and some better pictures of the egg. More egg!
May 27, 2026
I really had to push myself to finish this book. The description made it sound so exciting. In my opinion, there was too much unnecessary information that made the story drag on.
Th8is boo0k was not for me.
I received this galley from NetGalley.
Th8is boo0k was not for me.
I received this galley from NetGalley.
2026
October 22, 2025Non-fiction November TBR
📱 Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner
📱 Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner
Review of advance copy received from Shelf Awareness Pro
This was a great story. Had not heard of it, so happy to make its acquaintance.
May 4, 2026
I totally agree with Samantha that the historical recounting was interesting, but the memoir part was not at all. Even the ending didn’t really deliver what I would have expected.
May 12, 2026
Very interesting!!
May 22, 2026
very interesting read. library borrow
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews