The title of this book is a misnomer in that there is little about actually being a soldier but rather presents a disjointed history of WWII along with a lot of complaining about Sergeants and Officers being too privileged. The author’s post-war research is interesting but oddly out of sync with more traditional WWII treatises. Serving as a junior enlisted man normally doesn't adequately prepare one for critiquing the most senior military Generals or overall war effort at the highest civilian levels, but Mr. Jones apparently thought otherwise.
As an Army veteran, I find his teenage take on the Army quite myopic and juvenile. He volunteered at 17 years of age . . . uneducated and inexperienced at life. He clearly did not excel in the Army, remaining a junior enlisted man throughout his time in the service. His attitude remained very anti-war, which is consistent with many combat veterans, and quite anti-military which is not.
Most volunteers in the 1930’s era military were escaping depression era poverty or some brush with the law, or not fitting into society and looking for some excitement without understanding what the military was all about. From reading his various biographies, it strikes me that Mr Jones was a young tough with a chip on his shoulder, and carried that attitude throughout his military and post-war civilian life.
His wartime experience certainly provided him fodder to write about and the somewhat unique perspective of functioning at a low-grunt level throughout his military years. The crudeness, bitterness and feeling that the Army was somehow “unfair” to junior enlisted personnel never left him, and he put the powerful feelings to good use in a number of books. Or perhaps, he recognized he had the opportunity to write from this unique perspective, and took advantage of it.
If you are looking for a book about the realities of soldiering during WWII, this may not be the book for you. I would suggest “Living on Borrowed Time” by William Horton. If the Viet Nam era is more your interest, I suggest “Filtered by Time” by Robert Faulkender. Both are excellent books written by combat veterans with better grasps on the reality of their times.