It Girl

by Allison Pataki

A sweeping, sensational novel of America’s first “It Girl,” whose dramatic journey to center stage echoes through the decades—from the New York Times bestselling author of The Magnificent Lives of Marjorie Post.

New York, 1900. At the dawn of a new century, the city’s streets teem with electricity, automobiles, a brash young President Teddy Roosevelt—and the It Girls. As artist’s muses and working models, these independent young women soar to stardom not because of their pedigrees or inherited wealth, but because of their talent, charisma, and irresistible beauty. Pop culture is born, and in a world alight with Mr. Edison’s new bulbs, no one shines brighter than America’s sweetheart, Evelyn Talbot.
But the journey to stardom was not simple or straight. As a young girl, a grieving Evelyn is forced to take care of her widowed mother and kid brother. While working as a shopgirl, she is recruited as a studio model, and soon catches the eye of the preeminent artists of her age. When Broadway comes calling, Evelyn solidifies her status as the first self-made American female celebrity, a “Gibson Girl,” the most sought-after face of her time. Enter a parade of powerful and power-hungry men, from world-famous architect Stanley Pierce, the visionary behind Manhattan’s mansions and iconic landmarks, to Hal Thorne, the shockingly wealthy railroad heir and premiere “playboy” of high society. Each man promises comfort, glamour, security—even love. But fame and fortune are cruel teachers.
When Evelyn finds herself at the center of a murder of passion declared “the Crime of the Century,” the sins of the men in her life are blamed on her. In the media frenzy that erupts, Evelyn realizes that—to survive—she will have to take charge of her own ending. But can this artists’ muse turned showgirl pull off the greatest act of her life? 
It Girl is a breathtaking ride inspired by a singular artist and survivor who captured the heart of American society. In Allison Pataki’s talented hands, we see Evelyn find the power to change not only the world around her, but her own destiny.

Genres: Historical Fiction, Fiction, Adult Fiction, Adult, Historical, Drama, American History

416 pages, Hardcover

Expected publication March 10, 2026

About the author

ALLISON PATAKI is the NYTimes Bestselling author of THE TRAITOR'S WIFE, THE ACCIDENTAL EMPRESS, SISI:EMPRESS ON HER OWN, WHERE THE LIGHT FALLS, and the memoir, BEAUTY IN THE BROKEN PLACES.

Her work has been translated into more than a dozen languages, has been featured on The TODAY Show, The NY Times, The Huffington Post, USA Today, FOX News, Morning Joe, and more.

Visit AllisonPataki.com to connect and find out more.

Reviews

[Annette · Rating 5 out of 5]

It Girl brings to light the story based on real-life of Evelyn Nesbit - model, actress, and one of those first girls for whom beauty and talent allowed to become independent. They were one of those giving birth to the pop-culture.

Evelyn’s story begins in 1897 Pittsburgh when she is an apple in her father’s eye who encourages her to dream big, but the fairy tale talk ends when her father dies suddenly.

In order to help pay the bills, the mother takes thirteen year old Evelyn out of school and gets her a job at department store. Evelyn is told to present herself as sixteen year old, and to observe what life could be.

Evelyn’s features grab attention of a customer who is a sketch artist and approaches Evelyn to pose for her. This is the beginning of cascading steps that lead Evelyn to the Broadway stage and ultimately her greatest fame.

After arriving in NYC in 1899, she begins her career in the city with the city’s most venerated artist James Carroll Beckwith. Then, Charles Dana Gibson, the famed sketch artist who wants Evelyn to be the next Gibson girl.

But when a stage agent approaches Evelyn, that’s when her interest truly peaks. She wants to sing and dance on stage. Movement makes her feel alive, so different from stagnant posing.

As she becomes a chorus girl, she catches an eye of Stanley Pierce (based on real-life architect Stanford White), a much older admirer who becomes her benefactor, showering her and her mother with luxury living, goods and travels.

When things get rocky between them, to pacify her, he gets hear a lead role in Shakespeare’s beloved masterpiece –The Tempest. She resents his help but here is her big chance to become a serious actress.

When she nears twenty, she becomes one of the oldest girls backstage. The girls her age move on as soon as they receive marriage proposal. It seems as at the right time the right man appears, Hal Thorne (based on real-life railroad tycoon Henry Thaw) – steel and railroad heir.

The novel is narrated in the first person with eloquent prose. The voice of Evelyn sounds very real and endearing. She exemplifies a character of someone who at young age loses support much needed at such fragile age, and someone who becomes a supporter of the family at very young age. The characters are well-developed, intriguing and flawed.

The author is known for staying close to the facts with historical figures and events in her biographical fiction. With this biographical fiction, the author takes more creative liberties. The very ending is completely different from the real one.

Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

[Stephanie · Rating 4 out of 5]

It Girl tells the story of Evelyn Talbot, a Gilded Age “It Girl” who rose from rags to riches as a model, actress, and star. Loosely based on Evelyn Nesbit, whose own life was full of scandal, the novel blends history and fiction in a way that immediately drew me in since I love reading about this era.

The first half was especially compelling. Evelyn begins modeling around age 13 to help support her struggling family in Pittsburgh, who are living in a cramped boarding house and barely scraping by. They scavenge for food, work grueling hours, and rely on her early jobs for survival. When Evelyn is discovered, they move to New York where she quickly becomes a celebrated model, appearing in Coca Cola ads and on calendars.

The second half shifts in tone. Since this is well before the Me Too era, it is not hard to anticipate some of the darker experiences awaiting Evelyn. I found the narrative leaned more on her personal relationships than on her career as a performer, and I would have liked to see more of the latter. Still, it was entertaining, if a bit surface level, in capturing the complexities of the time. There is tragedy that occurs, and I felt it was brushed off.

I have enjoyed Allison Pataki’s other novels for the way she highlights women in different historical periods, and this one fit that same mold.

Overall: an enjoyable, if not deeply layered, read.

[Monica Hills · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a fascinating look at the life of Evelyn Talbot, a girl who was raised in poverty to become a Broadway sen sensation in the early 1900s. Based on a real person, Evelyn has the look that draws everyone in. As a young girl, Evelyn is spotted and becomes an artist's muse. She works her way up to model and then actress. The only problem is that this is a man's world and there are many wealthy men who want to take advantage of Evelyn. Her mother, who should be looking out for her, really only craves the comfort and security that Evelyn's new found fame has brought. Evelyn must figure out how to have it all including her freedom.

Evelyn's story was captivating and an excellent read for anyone who loves historical fiction or strong females. I loved her intelligence and spirit. She had so much happen to her in her life and I always love to read about women who can accomplish so much when there is so much against them. I appreciate that the author included an author's note where she described the life of the real Evelyn Nesbit. You know an author is really talented when they can take a real person from history and turn their life into an interesting story with great characters. This book should definitely be on everyone's TBR shelf for 2026.

Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for this ARC.

[Christine M in Texas (stamperlady50) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Absolutely fascinating. I had never heard of The Gibson girls, but anything this author writes, I read. She has an amazing gift as an author. This story was based on a real person and Pataki adds to her story which makes for a fascinating and engaging story. Her life was not an easy one and I felt for her and her circumstances. The ending was icing on the cake, when she found out what her life could truly be and I loved how it played out. Don’t want to give away the ending. Will be preordering as well.

[Dustin · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really really really enjoyed this book, I've never read any of this authors work, but I feel I must find more from her. This was such an amazing story, at times tragic and sad, and other joyful and happy! When this book comes out, it is a must read!

[Kristi · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book isn't historical fiction, as the author has taken liberties with a true story and made it her own. She describes in the author notes what she did to modify the true story of Evelyn Nesbit, the woman on whom the main character is based. I found both the real story and the story written by the author of this book to be very compelling.

It was so easy to empathize with Evelyn. Her life was rough from a very young age. As more of her story is revealed, my heart hurt for her. On the other side of it I absolutely loathed Stanley Pierce. What a nasty piece of work this guy was. I wished I could have had a conversation with this guy. I wasn't much fond of Evelyn's mother either. Wish I could have had a word with her, too. This story evoked so many emotions while I was reading it. Characters I liked and characters I just couldn't stand. I thought the author did a great job in creating a wide range of characters, and as a result, it added a lot of depth to the story.

This book is over 400 pages, so there is plenty of time to spend with Evelyn and get to know her from childhood to womanhood. This is a story that I was really able to immerse myself in. The story is very well written and has a good flow to it from chapter to chapter. This is the second book I have read by this author, and I like her writing style. She has a way of pulling the reader into the story and keeping their attention. I found myself looking up things as I was reading the story. Reading about Madison Square Garden was interesting, as I had no idea what it looked like during the time of this story.

I highly recommend this book. Even though it isn't technically historical fiction, it has that feel to it. It is a well-written story and one that will stay with me for a long time.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my opinion.

[Christine Cazeneuve · Rating 5 out of 5]

Another magnificent story by Allison Pataki. This book is based on the life of Evelyn Nesbit and is an absolutely incredible tale. The author does an amazing job of weaving the true facts of Nesbit's life with our fictional character Evelyn Talbot's life. Evelyn's story is sad, tragic, inspiring, hopeful and satisfying. Told with just the right amount of details - this book has it all! Thanks to Netgalley, the author and publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion.

[Dianne · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.5 Stars

Trigger warning: rape and pedophilia.

Also, try not to do any research on these people, as it may spoil the book for you.

This is a Historical/FICTION book. Remember the word ' fiction' when you are reading this, since many reviewers are getting hung up on some things that don't fit their idea of what this book is about.

I did some mild research (Wiki) on who these people were based on other reviewers naming names. And becuase of that, some parts of this book were spoiled for me, but the biggest shock was how the author ended this book. Let me tell you, it was a huge shock, and it was wonderful.

The only reason why I didn't give this a full 4-star rating was that the characters annoyed me so much. I realize this book was written at the turn of the last century, and times were WAY different, but I still thought that Evelyn should have stood up for herself a bit more and not have been so naive. Perhaps she should have just asked more questions of those around her who had more experience in the arts and the theater. I just can't help myself. When I see a person who has been warned and still does what she was warned against, I get annoyed.

However, this book has very richly drawn characters, and an interesting plot twist near the end of the book and a wonderful look into the lives of the artists' models, the Gibson Girls and Vaudeville.


I would highly recommend It Girl: A Novel, especially to book clubs looking for something a tad more controversial to discuss.

*ARC supplied by the publisher Ballantine Books/Random House Publishing, the author, and NetGalley.

[Tammy O · Rating 4 out of 5]

Allison Pataki’s books capture my attention, no matter who she writes about.

“It Girl” is a poignant tale of Evelyn Talbot’s childhood of poverty and her tenacious rise to stardom. She is very naive and it quickly becomes evident that some of the people who help her along the way do not have her best interests at heart.

Mr. Gibson told her, “Learn to swim. And then you’ll survive.” Eventually Evelyn grows up and comes to understand his message. But her glamorous lifestyle in New York gives us a fascinating glimpse into early Broadway and the Gilded Age.

Based on the true life story of Evelyn Nesbit.

Special thanks to the publishers at NetGalley for the advanced reader copy to review.

[Joan · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.0. I’ve enjoyed Allison Pataki’s books, all very well researched and well written. This one, as she admits, is more fiction than historical fact, but it still is very interesting. She has loosely based this novel on Evelyn Nesbit, a Broadway actress, the subject of portraits from well known painters, the face of advertisements, and a beauty from the turn of the century. In the novel, the woman, Evelyn Talbot, apparently follows the life of Ms. Nesbit, but there are digressions. I had never heard of Evelyn Nesbit, but I learned about the times during the Gilded Age as well as the difficult life that Ms Nesbit as a child and then even as a successful person. Well researched, good character development, and interesting to read. Thank you Netgalley for an advance copy in exchange for a candid and unbiased review.

[Paula Storm · Rating 4 out of 5]

I truly loved the magnificent lives of marjorie post by this author. So when the opportunity came up to review another book by Alison Pataki, I jumped to the chance! Although I was unfamiliar with the subject, Evelyn Nesbit (Talbot in the book) I was excited to dive in. Wow! What a challenging but privileged life she led. I learned a lot, and my heart broke for her. Alison Pataki has become one of my must read authors.

[ROBYN MARKOW · Rating 4 out of 5]

This HF is by turns a spicy , poignant and revelent fictionalized account of Artist's Model Turned turned Broadway Showgirl Evelyn Nesbit; called Evelyn Talbot in this novel. The story opens in The late 1890's & Evelyn ,her mother and younger brother ,Kit ,have fallen on hard times after the father ,who Evelyn was very close to, suddenly passes. The family is left penniless, forced to eat from dumpsters & beg outside of restaurants for any left-over food. After humiliating themselves when asking for money from of the wealthiest women in Pittsburgh, her mother,who dreams of becoming a dressmaker to the town's Millionaire's Row women, decided to give up that dream for a job as a shopgirl in Wanamaker's Dept store . She then gets her daughter to lie about her age so she can work there as well . iNot long after working there she gets discovered by a local female artist , who while shopping gets waited on by Evelyn,notices her striking beauty and wants the teenager to pose for her,which he does .

This leads to other modeling gigs w/artists and illustrators such as William Frederic Church and Charles Dana Gibson( who used Evelyn as his inspo for his famous "Gibson Girl") Soon Evelyn's beautiful face is everywhere from Candy Boxes to a semi -nude painting;which although the male artist handles it well,Evelyn feels exposed , awkward and relieved when it's over.

Tired of sitting for hours on end while modeling and w/enough money saved ,Evelyn persuades her mother to let them relocate to New York City,where Evelyn can try out for Broadway shows. After putting her brother Kit in a boarding school ,they make the move. Living in a boardinghouse while Evelyn auditions & then lands a part in the chorus . She loves being able to perform rather than sit for portraits and soon lands a featured role. Then the men come calling..

The much-older Stanley Pierce ( based on real-life architect Stanford White) becomes infatuated with Evelyn after watching her onstage repeatedly . He soon makes an "Arrangement" for Evelyn and her mother to live at the Aubodon ,a posh hotel that he designed, w/their every want & need generously supplied. Evelyn (now only 15 ) is thrilled at first but then things go south when he drugs his young mistress and "Unvirgins" her. He also likes to have her play on a red velvet swing . She soon finds out about his other woman ( all also most likely on the "Younger Side" ) and a disillusioned Evelyn decides -to her mother's dismay -to leave "Stanny".

After a brief summer affair w/a young illustrator who,much to Evelyn's auger,is bought off by Pierce ,Evelyn meets Hal Throne( Based on Railroad Tycoon Henry Thaw) They soon marry , moving to Pittsburgh,where Evelyn feels like a caged bird ,living in the same large, cold mansion where she begged just a few years before. Her mother-in-law is a rigid church-going widow who despises her new daughter -in-law,whom she's frequently left alone with while Hal goes golfing & hanging out at his gentlemen's club. He's also fiercely jealous of his new bride's former relationship w/Stanley Pierce and starts becoming abusive to Evelyn, also going around w/a pistol to "Protect his Booful Wife"'

The book comes to a head when Evelyn begs Hal to take her to NYC as an anniversary gift. What happens next is quite different from the actual events which bothered me a little,though I liked how Pataki let Evelyn take matters into her own hands. This was a fast -moving tale which sadly parallels recent events regarding exploited under-age girls which added a layer of pathos to it . I enjoyed "It Girl" though I felt it could've gone a bit deeper emotionally . Recommended for those who enjoy their HF mixed w/ scandal . ( I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review)

[Lisa · Rating 3 out of 5]

This is inspired by Evelyn Nesbit, a Gibson Girl. In this version, Evelyn Talbot has similar ups and downs, with a chance to rewrite her ending. It's sad that her main suitors were able to hide their evil sides for so long.

Side note: I hate the cover. It doesn't feel representative of the novel's time period.

Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for the ARC.

[Sara]

I crack my egg of love
crush my power
sing to sun
dance to moon
shag my star
iam girl nt aged with leaf fall
darw my love of art
paint my futur aginst poor past
fight my war
iam girl nt aged with flying year
murder any stone
play with clock of grom
sea my words
sing my dream
iam girl nt aged with storm of season

[Literary Redhead · Rating 5 out of 5]

A compelling fictionalized story based on the life of Gibson girl and Gilded Age "It Girl," Evelyn Nesbit. The author writes masterful historical fiction that illuminates exceptional women: Their lives, their hopes, their triumphs and downfalls, and It Girl is a perfect example of why I love her work. Highly recommended!

[Debbie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Allison Pataki is a go to author for me. She has written a fictionalized account of the tragic life of Evelyn Nesbit changing the names of the actual people involved. Her writing made the time period of the early 20th century come alive. All her characters were well developed which kept the story moving along. The main character was a naive teenager with extraordinary good looks which made her in high demand as a model, chorus girl and actress. She quickly learned the price of becoming the top It Girl as she became the pursuit of many men. Excellent writing about a time period when women didn’t have much power makes this a book that I highly recommend. Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for an advanced eGalley of this book for an honest review. All opinions are my own. #ItGirl #AllisonPataki #NetGalley

[Barbara Monaghan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Very interesting novel based loosely on the life of Evelyn Nesbit, the original Gibson Girl or maybe, the first super model., The main character, Evelyn, goes from poor daughter of a single mother to a star of Broadway and well-know "it girl". She has plenty of hardships and tragedies, but she's one smart cookie and forges her own unique path. Perfect book club read.

[Katie M · Rating 4 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this book! And OMG THE COVER! What a gorgeous cover! It took me a little while to get through but that is because I had a lot going personally and when I would get settled in for the night, I was so tired that I would fall asleep right away. But some parts of the book I had to pause to take in because of the heaviness of the situation. Yes, I wanted to punch him in the face! (won't spoil who!). It is books like this that remind me how lucky I am to be alive now and not back then. I know many of us would say, "we wouldn't take that crap" if we were alive back then, but we would have been in different situations and wouldn't know better.

I thoroughly enjoyed this story and Allison Pataki books!

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced copy. I am not a reviewer who will retell the plot, just my feelings towards the book as the reader can look up the plot themselves.

[Sheri · Rating 4 out of 5]

“It Girl” by Allison Pataki is a well written and entertaining historical fiction based on the real life story of Evelyn Nesbit. The novel chronicles the life of a woman coming from incredible poverty to becoming America’s most famous muse, beloved showgirl and Broadway actress. I was fully immersed into her tragic life and the difficulties of trying to survive as an independent woman during the roaring twenties. She was surrounded by unscrupulous men and a mother who was only interested in her daughter for her own financial security, which forced her to become a survivor in a world that wanted to totally control her.
The author has artfully modified the historical facts to create a compelling, emotional, and illuminating story that will stay with me for a long time.

Thank you NetGalley and Ballantine for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

[Karen · Rating 5 out of 5]

"IT GIRL"
BY: ALLISON PATAKI

ALLISON PATAKI has managed to write another compelling, and mesmerizing historical fiction novel called, ":IT GIRL," that I couldn't put down. I used to be a serious lover of historical fiction, but have really segued into Literary fiction being my favorite genre except for very few Author's and she is one that I will tell you that I moved this one ahead for a treat. She is my top favorite author who I have actually gone back and read her back list which are either ten or eleven and this is AMAZING! I say to myself each time she writes her newest one that she has written another intoxicating narrative that is about a fascinating, meticulously researched character driven story where I could name the woman, but I trust if you want to know who you'll find out either in the synopsis or other reviews. I should disclose that in this one I honestly didn't read the synopsis because I trust this Yale educated author enough to know that each time she crafts her newest offering I wonder how she manages to keep me so engrossed that I am in book paradise thinking after I turn the last page , my thoughts are the latest one is my new favorite. In all honesty her last three have been my favorites, but I would recommend this, and her last two are my favorites, but then again they are all favorites, and I'm a reader that can't be categorized. The reason being is I read many genres, and except for the overly saturated market with Romance that is targeted for a younger reader, that I am not. I also avoid the genre of Young Adult, I read most everything else. Not that there's anything wrong with those two genres, because, there are some that I will read in those genres that I have found memorable depending on the Author, Generally speaking I have enjoyed very few, but I don't rule them out completely.

I would add that I recommend for any reader who has been kind enough to get to this point in my review to try out this Brilliant Author's novels, since this doesn't come out for a few months at least. If you like recommendations there are her two prior novels, that I highly recommend "FINDING MARGARET FULLER," which is the one published prior to this one, and the one before that is called, "THE MAGNIFICENT LIVES OF MARJORIE POST." I realize that most people have long reading lists of their own, but if you wanted to get an idea of whether you would love this one, I can confidently say that you would find those two fascinating, of course this is, as well. Especially if you like fiction that is based on the lives of remarkable women that this wonderful author is exceptional in both her striking character development and plot which you learn something new while they are page turners, that are written as close to the historical facts. I can promise that you will be in skillfully & talented hands for a multitude of reasons.

Just for the purpose of this review, of "IT GIRL," this one is deeply atmospheric that places you with it starting out around the end of the 1800's, and it features the cold, and Gray poor section of a small city near Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The imagery of the prose is not just reading the text, but it was something that I felt as a young thirteen year old girl named, Florence Evelyn Talbot, who is the Main Female Character whose first person point of view is hungry who forages for discarded scraps to feed herself, her beloved younger brother Kit, and her widowed mother in their one room bordering house for their supper. Her mother is no shrinking violet, but also has Florence collect the other inhabitants rent in what she is uncomfortable doing, but she obeys her mother who insists on calling her Florence, even though she hates it, and everybody else calls her Evelyn.

They were much better off before her father died, who Evelyn was much closer to her father since he always read to her and told her how smart she was, and he told her often she will attend college. It is Christmas, which is Evelyn's birthday, and her mother decides to have them walk to the richer part of Pittsburgh where they approach a castle and her mother shows up uninvited on the widow of a multimillionaire railroad, and steel tycoon basically looking for a handout. This rich widow happens to be very cold, and judgmental, but Evelyn's mother receives $5.00, and a meal by the reluctant heiress by Evelyn's mother reminding this cold women of her dealings with the church. Mrs. Talbot uses this large sum to move to a better place.

Evelyn, Kit, and Mrs, Talbot move to Philadelphia where she takes a very disappointed Evelyn , who longs to attend school since she remembers her fathers influence of how he taught her the importance of an education.. Mrs. Talbot dismisses Evelyn's education instead she thinks of herself forcing Evelyn to work with her at a fancy department store. Evelyn is told by her mother that she won't be going to school because she is to work as a shop girl at that same fancy store as her mother for twelve hour shifts. It is a lucky turn of events that an artist notices her beauty who is a kind woman named Leah Dawson who explains to Evelyn that she would love for her to model for her, and she'll work less hours and earn more than at the store by earning a dollar a day. The arrangement is a positive experience for both the artist and model. Not only does she sell her portraits of Evelyn to various vendors , she makes Evelyn gain experience who she is recognized through her room mate's friend named Violet who also sees Evelyn's face, and poise be well received by Leah Dawson's mega success at being the hit since Evelyn possesses the quality that has what happens to be the look that advertisers and artists craved she was a sensation, Violet noticed Evelyn and knew she found the perfect model for Evelyn to be her model as the angel for her project out of stained glass for Mr Tiffany;, personally. Leah and her two friends encourage Evelyn to go to Manhattan, because she is talented and she'll earn $5.99-$10.00 per day which is much more money, and less grueling, and her face is sought out since her beauty, has made her rare which has been on many different merchandise, advertisements that Leah has saved which will be her portfolio, provided by Leah who also gives her a card to contact a famous, respected artist to seek which will lead to more recognition, more work, and has instilled in her to find her light. It is important to emphasize that Evelyn doesn't know how her look is special and what success she will have. She is heartbroken that her younger brother can't join both her and her mother, yet. Evelyn is thinking of her mother she dreams to earn enough to set her up in her own seamstress shop, get decent living quarters big enough so her brother can join them. She is closer to her brother and has paid his tuition at a boarding school where she knows he'll be warm, be fed, and she hopes he makes friends.,while he gets an education. As soon as possible she plans on him joining them as she earns enough since she hated leaving him. Her mother is an opportunist who is Evelyn's Chaperone who Evelyn obeys. When you think about it Evelyn has elevated her family 's living standards, as well off now from her modeling money has transformed her family from poverty. How many thirteen year old girls have that much responsibility with the thoughtfulness towards supporting the three of them without ever complaining? Her mother can sit while Evelyn earns by her talent pleasing who hires her, and she becomes the top Gibson girl. She soars not just because of her look, but because she is pleasant, and can satisfy by being able to pose without moving which is hard work but her mother never thanked her or praised her. She has rescued her family from freezing cold and hunger to warmth along with a respected living arrangement having to lie about her age with always her goal of her family reuniting. She only has dreams of someday finishing her education once every one in her family is situated.

I hope you know that there's so much more that you will enjoy as Evelyn is only thirteen, possibly fourteen with a fast paced plot that is intriguing, and Evelyn was important to me that you see how kind and humble but more importantly selfless with her thoughts of working to keep her family comfortable. Allison Pataki will entertain you with her stunning writing that her storytelling will immerse you as Evelyn has many years that unfold. The synopsis in my humble opinion is spoiler territory, and her life unfolds with this exquisite writing I hope you love it as much as I did. Believe me the writing is balanced since there are highs and lows but the synopsis gives away too much, which I recommend skipping, I am grateful I didn't read it because I think I wouldn't have the rewards of surprise which enhanced my reading experience. If you need to read it, this author wrote a different trajectory, and she has included her Author's Note which I could hug her for including it because I have read early ARCS that don;t add such a coveted and detailed section until closer to the date of Publication. Not so with this Author, which adds to my admiration since I think it is what I enjoy when reading historical fiction. She is a Professional and it shows since she separates fact from fiction which she stayed mostly to the historical record, and she tells you where she used creative liberties. There's also listed non fiction books which I already bought a good one that was inexpensive that is highly reviewed that I can't wait to read. That's how much I loved this. I hope you love it and my review was longer so thank you for reading it. Know that this Author is accessible yet Polished and as good at this genre to engage you as it gets. This novel deserves to reach as wide of an audience as possible. It's a Lifetime Favorite! PROFESSIONAL & POLISHED AUTHOR! FIVE PLUS, DAZZLING STARS!

Publication Date: March 10, 2026

Thank you to Net Galley. Allison Pataki, and Ballantine/Ballantine Books for generously providing me with my FANTASTIC ARC, in exchange for a fair and honest review. All opinions are my own, as always.

#ItGirl #AllisonPataki #Ballantine #BallantineBooks #NetGalley

[Michele · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book certainly did not disappoint. Allison wrote fabulous characters, some I loved and needed a hug, and others were despicable. The emotions were all over on this one, love, anger, heartache, and confusion for this poor young girl. I had no idea where this one was going, but bravo on a fantastic ending. Definitely well worth reading. Thank you Penguin Random House, for the advanced copy through NetGalley. Happy reading!!

[Danna · Rating 3 out of 5]

I’ve had Allison Pataki on the to-read shelf for a while, so I was glad to receive an invite to read an early copy of It Girl. It Girl tells the story of Florence, aka, stage name, Evelyn Talbot (neé Evelyn Nesbit), a once-in-a-generation beauty who took America by storm in the late 1890s/early 1900s.

Growing up poor with her brother and single mother in a small town outside Pittsburgh, Evelyn had no idea how beautiful she was. Evelyn’s mother struggled to hold the house together with seamstress jobs, but dreamed of more. When the opportunity for Evelyn to sit as an artist’s model at a surprisingly high wage comes their way, Evelyn’s mother approves it, despite initial misgivings.

Through a whirlwind, Evelyn becomes first, an “it girl,” the face of everything from cheese to Tiffany stainless glass, to Coca Cola wall calendars. Her looks bring them to Manhattan, where Evelyn is courted by one rich, influential man after another. She grows up fast.

It Girl tells it all: it’s an epic novel that takes us from Evelyn’s early adolescent years through her early 20s. For me, it started off strong and then floundered to a disappointing last 1/3 or so. I enjoyed Evelyn’s early days as a model and show girl. I found her relationships with Stanley Pierce trying and the next with Hal Thorne even worse (both because the men are horrid and because the story realllllly dragged). I stuck with it to find out about the murder mentioned in the blurb, which took its sweet time to arrive, otherwise I probably would have given up early. I think this book could have easily been 100 pages shorter.

Prior to It Girl, I hadn’t heard of Evelyn Nesbit, the foundation for Evelyn Talbot. It’s an interesting history, especially considering how infatuated our culture has become with the “it girls” of today.

2.5 stars rounded up. Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

[Annette Geiss · Rating 4 out of 5]

Allison Pataki never disappoints! I was very fortunate to receive this advanced copy of “It Girl.” I thoroughly enjoyed reading this fictionalized version of the life of Evelyn Nesbit. An incredibly interesting and difficult life. I will not give anymore details, as I do not want to create spoilers.
#ItGirl, #Goodreads, #NetGalley

[Heather Starr · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love Allison Pataki’s books. While I’m not really into pop culture and what happens to famous people, this was an interesting book. This is the story of Evelyn Talbot, the first It Girl set in the early 1900’s. Evelyn goes through many trials on her path to stardom, as I imagine young girls now still go through currently trying to become famous.

[Kimberly · Rating 5 out of 5]

Book review: Allison Pataki’s It Girl.
Ballantine Books, thank you so much, along with NetGalley, for my gifted ARC.

I picked this up expecting a glamorous historical fiction read with pretty dresses, big personalities, and a little drama sprinkled in for flavor. What I got instead was a sharp, emotionally loaded look at the very early machinery of fame and how brutally efficient it’s always been at chewing up young women and calling it entertainment. This book is cozy in the sense that it’s immersive and compulsively readable, but content-wise it absolutely pulls no punches, and I appreciated that.

Evelyn Talbot is introduced to us as a girl who has learned far too early that beauty can be a lifeline and a trap at the same time. Watching her rise from shopgirl to artist’s muse to full-blown cultural obsession is fascinating, especially because Pataki makes sure we understand the cost of every step upward. There’s glamour, yes, but there’s also manipulation, exploitation, and a constant hum of danger beneath the surface. Every man who promises Evelyn safety, comfort, or love comes with fine print, and none of it is written in her favor.

One of the things Pataki does especially well is pacing the illusion of security. Just when Evelyn seems settled, admired, or protected, the rug is pulled out again. It creates a reading experience that feels tense without being a thriller, and emotional without being overwrought. The first portion of the book takes its time setting up Evelyn’s childhood and early modeling career, which I actually liked. It made the later sections hit harder because you understand exactly what she’s losing along the way.

What surprised me most is how modern this story feels. Swap out Broadway posters for social media feeds and you can clearly see the blueprint for influencer culture, celebrity trials, and public moral outrage. Evelyn is adored, consumed, judged, and blamed in equal measure, often for choices that were never fully hers to begin with. There were moments where I had to put the book down and just sit with the frustration of it all, which is probably the highest compliment I can give a historical novel.

My favorite line sums up the entire reading experience for me: “Fame doesn’t ask permission. It simply takes.” That sentence captures Evelyn’s journey, the men around her, and the era itself perfectly.

The ending felt particularly satisfying, not because it’s neat or painless, but because it allows Evelyn agency in a way history so often denied women like her. Pataki doesn’t erase the damage, but she does give her heroine the dignity of choice, and I closed the book feeling both emotionally wrung out and oddly hopeful.

If you enjoy historical fiction that blends glamour with social commentary, complicated female leads, and a sharp examination of power, this one is absolutely worth your time. Just don’t expect a light, frilly read. This story has teeth.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½ out of 5 stars

#ItGirl #AllisonPataki #HistoricalFiction #BookReview #NetGalley #BallantineBooks #ARCReview #GildedAge #WomenInHistory #Bookstagram #ReadHistoricalFiction

[Linda · Rating 4 out of 5]

Ya gotta trust your own stuff.

Allison Pataki is known for her solid historical fiction. I've always been a fan. But This Girl was not completely sold on the It Girl. It began quite well and then started to shift into the weeds for me. It was a 3.5 Stars kicked up to 4 Stars because of all the research Pataki does for her craft. Let's discuss.

Pataki takes us into the life of her fictional character, Evelyn Talbot, living in Pittsburgh in 1897. (This entire book is based on the true life of the original Gibson Girl, Evelyn Nesbit. Pataki changes character names and eventually veers into WooWoo Land with her ending. It gave her liberties throughout in order to create her own scenarios and circumstances. Sometimes it worked and sometimes it didn't.)

After Evelyn's father dies, she and her mother and younger brother fall on hard times. Evelyn's mother becomes a demanding individual. It's here and further in that I wish we had more background into this woman. She forces her then thirteen year old daughter to lie about her age and work at a department store. Fate steps in and an artist requests that Evelyn model for her because of Evelyn's eye-catching beauty even at such a young age. Her mother insists that she lie and presents herself as a sixteen year old. And this will open doors for Evelyn in the future as she will be the most famous Gibson Girl and the recognizable face on commercial products.

Broadway opens its arms to the lovely Evelyn. It's here that Evelyn will be swept up into the lights and the notoriety of her stage presence. And in the wings are wealthy men clamoring for her attention. Stanley Pierce steps forward with promises of making all her wishes come true. And momma has gotten used to the good life and welcomes in Stanley.

Pataki pulls no punches when it comes to Stanley.....much like a whiff of rotten cheese. But both momma and Evelyn continue to be whisked away even when Evelyn knows the dark truth of this relationship. Evelyn does like her champagne chilled and at the ready. That's when the book turned for me.

Evelyn is no longer the young innocent. She plays the game well for her own benefit. Additionally, Pataki draws Evelyn at this stage as simply a reactionary to her interactions with others and other circumstances. Yes, these times were heavily against women. That's why the ending was off the charts. Yup, ya gotta trust your own stuff, Evelyn. But why did you drink so long from the illicit fountain before you finally bailed?

Still a worthy read because of Allison Pataki.

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Ballantine Books and to the talented Allison Pataki for the opportunity.

[HalKid2 · Rating 4 out of 5]

Allison Pataki’s newest historical fiction does not disappoint! IT GIRL, based on the life of showgirl Evelyn Nesbit and what was called the Trial of the Century (20th) is engrossing from the start and takes some deliciously original twists and turns. It’s also a rich look at American society in the early 1900s with income inequality, robber barons and working children. Awarded four stars but if pressed, I might go as high as 4.5.

First a little background. If you don’t know, Evelyn Nesbit was an early 20th century cultural phenomenon because of her unusual beauty. Showcased by prominent artists and used in advertising, she later moved to theater, where she captured the attention of two famous men - prominent New York City architect Stanford White (Madison Square Garden) and wealthy Pittsburgh businessman Harry Thaw. Thaw winds up marrying Evelyn and then stands trial for killing Stanford White. That’s the true history.

In Pataki’s version, these names are all changed. Nesbit becomes Evelyn Talbot, White becomes Stanley Pierce, and Thaw turns into Hal Thorne. I didn’t quite understand why the name changes were necessary until the very end of the novel. So make sure you read the final Author’s Note.

IT GIRL relates Evelyn’s “Cinderella” journey from rags to riches. Though born into a comfortable Pittsburg family, Evelyn, her younger brother, and mother quickly become poor after the sudden death of her beloved father. There’s barely enough food and the family’s living conditions go from bad to worse. That is until a local artist spots Evelyn in a store and suggests to Mrs.Talbot that Evelyn she could make money modeling. What follows is the meteoric rise to fame for a girl of just 14 years old. First in Philadelphia, then to New York City.

What I think Pataki does best is give voice to Evelyn herself. Even though decisions were being made her mother and others, ostensibly in her interest, readers get to see how Evelyn’s life is transformed by those who wish to gain something from her success. I suspect it’s a story many child actors would identify with.

Another important theme explored is what happens when powerful and wealthy men have an interest in a beautiful but essentially poor girl/woman. It isn’t pretty and there were parts of Evelyn’s story that made me decidedly uncomfortable to read. Especially now that our culture has recognized a #MeToo movement and there’s less toleration of sexual harassment.

There are a few points where I thought the voice of Evelyn was a bit too sophisticated for her age and experience —some observations that felt too adult-like. But that didn’t really detract from my enjoyment of the book, which I highly recommend.

[Ethel · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the story of Florence Evelyn Talbot, but known as Evelyn Nesbit. Told in the early 1900's, when as a 13 year old she took the world by storm. She became an artist's model from the beginning of her career, as famous artists (such as James Beckwith ) used her as a model. She was quite young, however, living with her mother and younger brother in near poverty, she left school at her mother's request and made money for the family modeling for artists. It didn't take long before her face was used in advertisements and became most popular. It also didn't take long before she found herself on Broadway, first in the chorus and making it to stardom. Yes, she was the "Gibson Girl" finding herself wanted by many an ardent male follower. She was naive, and young having lied about her age to secure a job and really didn't have the "street smarts" needed as she advanced. Her mother became her manager as she herself couldn't find employment herself as a seamstress when they first moved to Philadelphia and then to New York. But scandal followed America's sweetheart when she became the center of a murder of passion.

This novel is based on the true story of Evelyn Nesbit. Once you open the Prologue you are hooked from the very beginning. With great detail of the times she lived in along with good character development you have an excellent book. Of course there are many supporting characters that are fictional and a few alterations as the story goes on, yet it makes for an interesting read. Nesbit had a sorrowful and tragic life in spite of her popularity. She never had a childhood filled with happiness since she was the family's bread winner. Her father having died when she was 10 years old and her mother couldn't find much work to support them. I have to wonder as I was reading this, if Nesbit knew she was being used - first by her mother (ugh) and then by others? Certainly, as you read this, you know she was no fool, it was the only life she knew.

I have read other books by Ms. Pataki, all of them wonderful and well written. Highly recommended. My thanks to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

P.S. Nesbit's story was also made into a movie in 1951 called "The Girl On The Red Velvet Swing."

[Sallie · Rating 5 out of 5]

When I saw this book by Allison Pataki I knew it would be one that I would really want to read. I am a huge fan of her storytelling and l look forward to anything she writes. This historical Fiction is a fabulous story. It is set in the late 1800 when Evelyn Talbot was a 13 year old girl. When her father dies Evelyn has to drop out of school to help her mother earn money to support herself and her two children. Her dream of an education is shattered but is soon replaced by the opportunity to be an artist model. She lies about her age in order to work at a local department store and quickly gains the attention of some of the most famous artists of the time. One thing leads to another and she becomes famous herself as she poses for Charles Dana Gibson, Tiffany, and many other famous and wealthy men of that time period. One benefactor helps her make her way to Broadway and she becomes very famous. She has several wealthy suitors who chase her and want to have a relationship with her but each time she is totally taken over by them. Her mother becomes her agent and they live a very wealthy existence paid for by one wealthy man after another. This is a book that book clubs will rush to present She is so very young that she has no concept what is going on in her life and believes these men are truly devoted to her.
This is an inside look at the life of a showgirl at that time and also the social things going on in New York Pennsylvania and Philadelphia.

Once I started reading this book I could not put it down and just loved it. It is based on the actual life of Evelyn Nesbit who was the first IT GIRL. After you finish reading this book you will most certainly want to learn more about the actual person Evelyn Nesbit If I could give this book more stars I would do so.

I wish to thank Net Galley and Ballantine Books for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this book. I have voluntarily read and reviewed this advanced copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Jo Dervan · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a novel about Evelyn Nesbit, an exceptionally beautiful young woman who became famous in the later part of the 19th century and beginning of the 20th century.
The author changed the name of Evelyn and many of the characters and concocted a story around some facts from Evelyn’s life.
Evelyn Talbot was born in a small town in Pennsylvania. Her father’s death left her family impoverished.
So her mother took her to Philadelphia where her beauty made her a perfect subject for artists and photographers. She was even photographed for advertisements for many different products.
After a few months, she and her mother moved to NYC where she continued to pose and even became famous as the Gibson Girl. Next she became a chorus girl on Broadway. She attracted the attentions of many men including Stanford Pierce. Pierce was a wealthy man who had designed many famous buildings. Soon after they met, he set her and her mother up in a suite in a luxurious NYC hotel. Eventually he drugged and raped the teenaged girl and became her lover and continued as her patron.
Evelyn caught the attention of Hal Thorne, the heir to a railroad and oil fortune. He persued her and finally persuaded her to marry him. The marriage was not a good one as Thorne proved to have problems with Alcohol and drugs. The couple also lived in the family mansion with Thorne’s mother who hated Evelyn.
In this story Evelyn was able to fake her death when her husband tried to kill Stanford Pierce. She was able to escape to Europe and start a new life.
This event and others varied from Evelyn Nesbit’s real life.
I enjoyed the story as the author portrayed the lifestyles of the rich and famous as well as their amoral activities.
I received this ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.