What do you think?
Rate this book
It's No Wonder: The Life and Times of Motown's Legendary Songwriter Sylvia Moy
The biography of Sylvia Moy, Motown’s first certified female in-house producer and songwriter, and one of the authors behind classic hits like “My Cherie Amour,” “Uptight (Everything’s Alright),” and a slew of other time-honored tunes.
Imagine a world without the music of Stevie Wonder. A world without hits like “I Was Made to Love Her” and “Shoo-Be-Doo-Be-Doo-Da-Day.” That's the world we would live in had it not been for Sylvia Moy, a woman whose legacy has been carefully tucked away within the annals of music history—until now.
It’s No Wonder examines the groundbreaking career of the pioneer who battled sexism and broke down barriers to become Motown’s first certified female in-house songwriter and producer. As the lone woman in a room full of men, the odds were stacked against Moy from the start. Amidst racial strife at the height of the Civil Rights Movement, most African American women who were allowed into the music industry could only dream of a career as a singer. Nevertheless, the Detroit native found unprecedented success as both a songwriter and producer. In addition to single-handedly saving Stevie Wonder's early career at Motown, Moy solidified herself as one of the label's most prolific composers, penning many of Wonder's classic hits as well as songs for other Motown acts like “Honey Chile,” “It Takes Two,” “This Old Heart of Mine (Is Weak For You),” “My Baby Loves Me,” “(We've Got) Honey Love,” “Forget Me Not,” “With a Child's Heart,” and countless others.
Meticulously researched, fiercely feminist, and told with the cooperation of Moy's estate, It's No Wonder is a historical corrective that restores Sylvia Moy to her rightful place at the forefront of music history.
Imagine a world without the music of Stevie Wonder. A world without hits like “I Was Made to Love Her” and “Shoo-Be-Doo-Be-Doo-Da-Day.” That's the world we would live in had it not been for Sylvia Moy, a woman whose legacy has been carefully tucked away within the annals of music history—until now.
It’s No Wonder examines the groundbreaking career of the pioneer who battled sexism and broke down barriers to become Motown’s first certified female in-house songwriter and producer. As the lone woman in a room full of men, the odds were stacked against Moy from the start. Amidst racial strife at the height of the Civil Rights Movement, most African American women who were allowed into the music industry could only dream of a career as a singer. Nevertheless, the Detroit native found unprecedented success as both a songwriter and producer. In addition to single-handedly saving Stevie Wonder's early career at Motown, Moy solidified herself as one of the label's most prolific composers, penning many of Wonder's classic hits as well as songs for other Motown acts like “Honey Chile,” “It Takes Two,” “This Old Heart of Mine (Is Weak For You),” “My Baby Loves Me,” “(We've Got) Honey Love,” “Forget Me Not,” “With a Child's Heart,” and countless others.
Meticulously researched, fiercely feminist, and told with the cooperation of Moy's estate, It's No Wonder is a historical corrective that restores Sylvia Moy to her rightful place at the forefront of music history.
Audible Audio
First published February 10, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
March 5, 2026
This book is incredibly well-researched. I truly appreciated the depth of the narrative. Having grown up loving Motown and writing dozens of college papers on the label's social impact, I was surprised—and thrilled—to find so much new material here.
It is both frustrating and eye-opening to realize that while Motown artists were collectively battling segregation, female musicians and producers like Sylvia Moy were fighting a "double war." They faced systemic racial barriers on top of the era's rigid gender constraints. Sylvia was a true icon, and I recommend this read to anyone who loves music history or stories of resilient, "badass" women.
As a Jacksonville, Florida native and a lifelong Motown fan, I was also fascinated to learn about Sylvia’s close friendship with Rita Carter Perry. Perry was a trailblazing force at Motown as a key executive and publicist before making history in our backyard as the founder of the Jacksonville Free Press—becoming the first Black woman in Florida to own and publish a weekly newspaper.
If you love Motown, strong females and historical reads, this one is for you.
It is both frustrating and eye-opening to realize that while Motown artists were collectively battling segregation, female musicians and producers like Sylvia Moy were fighting a "double war." They faced systemic racial barriers on top of the era's rigid gender constraints. Sylvia was a true icon, and I recommend this read to anyone who loves music history or stories of resilient, "badass" women.
As a Jacksonville, Florida native and a lifelong Motown fan, I was also fascinated to learn about Sylvia’s close friendship with Rita Carter Perry. Perry was a trailblazing force at Motown as a key executive and publicist before making history in our backyard as the founder of the Jacksonville Free Press—becoming the first Black woman in Florida to own and publish a weekly newspaper.
If you love Motown, strong females and historical reads, this one is for you.
April 19, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for a digital advance reader copy. All comments and opinions are my own unless otherwise noted.
This was a detailed and well-researched account of the history of Motown, music, and specifically the career of award-winning songwriter and music producer Sylvia Moy.
The author explains her motivation for writing this biography: “Sylvia fought tooth and nail for public recognition because her name was never listed on records as a producer. Though Motown greatly profited from her contributions, the company failed to accurately and truthfully document her accomplishments; consequently, she has long been overlooked within the annals of music history.”
While the way Sylvia was deliberately refused label credit was beyond frustrating, she handled this treatment and “held her own with dignity, integrity and grace.” Not only was she fighting against a sexist industry, but she also had to contend with racism.
I enjoyed learning about the songs I grew up singing including “My Cherie Amour,” “I Was Made to Love Her,” and “Uptight” – in fact, many of the songs that Sylvia wrote were for Stevie Wonder. This book is not only the biography of Sylvia Moy, but also the history of Motown, as well as the story of Stevie Wonder’s career.
Some disappointing elements: I was expecting a discography listing all of Sylvia’s songs (both written and produced) as well as an index. This would have provided the finishing touch to the author’s research and writing efforts. Another round of edits would have tightened up the narrative and helped to eliminate the repetition.
This is a book for readers of women's history, American history, African American history, music, and Motown.
This was a detailed and well-researched account of the history of Motown, music, and specifically the career of award-winning songwriter and music producer Sylvia Moy.
The author explains her motivation for writing this biography: “Sylvia fought tooth and nail for public recognition because her name was never listed on records as a producer. Though Motown greatly profited from her contributions, the company failed to accurately and truthfully document her accomplishments; consequently, she has long been overlooked within the annals of music history.”
While the way Sylvia was deliberately refused label credit was beyond frustrating, she handled this treatment and “held her own with dignity, integrity and grace.” Not only was she fighting against a sexist industry, but she also had to contend with racism.
I enjoyed learning about the songs I grew up singing including “My Cherie Amour,” “I Was Made to Love Her,” and “Uptight” – in fact, many of the songs that Sylvia wrote were for Stevie Wonder. This book is not only the biography of Sylvia Moy, but also the history of Motown, as well as the story of Stevie Wonder’s career.
Some disappointing elements: I was expecting a discography listing all of Sylvia’s songs (both written and produced) as well as an index. This would have provided the finishing touch to the author’s research and writing efforts. Another round of edits would have tightened up the narrative and helped to eliminate the repetition.
This is a book for readers of women's history, American history, African American history, music, and Motown.
March 27, 2026
though repetitive at times with names and songs, Slyvia's story offers a glimpse of making music behind the scenes socially, emotionally, professionally, and societally.
March 3, 2026
As a music lover, I loved reading this book and learning more about Sylvia Moy. She was such an important figure in music, and someone I didn't know much about. Without her, we sould not have had Stevie Wonder. Imagine a world without "Songs in the Key of Life."
I thought the writing was great in this book. There was a level of humor and curiosity, coupled with great writing.
I thought the writing was great in this book. There was a level of humor and curiosity, coupled with great writing.
March 26, 2026
I was really keen to read this book.
Sylvia Moy was a trailblazer as one of the female creatives in the male-dominated Motown environment, whose contribution has been very much overlooked. Most histories of the label pay her little or no notice. For example, Nelson George’s Where Did Our Love Go?, considered by many to be the definitive book on the history of Motown, mentions her only once, merely as “Jobete staff songwriter Sylvia Moy”, in the context of her co-write of “It Takes Two”.
The style of the writing, for my money, is very dry, more in the style of an academic textbook.
It is perfectly attributed and annotated, with comprehensive bibliography and notes sections.
I would have appreciated an index though.
And it would have been very useful to provide a list of her Motown credits - Nelson George provides this is his book, and it would have been very Interesting to compare both for instances where her contributions might not have been officially credited. She never received a production credit. The label on The Isleys’ “This Old Heart Of Mine” single only lists Holland/Dozier/Holland as writers - Sylvia co-writing role is uncredited.
There is a lot of good background social history in the book, not always germane to the story, or the story I’m interested in, which is fair enough - you want to draw a readership other than superannuated Motown junkies like myself!
Some of the information is selective in my opinion - there’s a lot about drummer Benny Benjamin, while his fellow Funk Brothers member, the hugely important and influential (ask Paul McCartney) bassist James Jamerson, gets scant mention. This would make me question the author’s depth of musical knowledge.
There is quite an amount of repetition between the chapters. One Berry Gordy quote is mentioned twice - on the same page!
One other thing that did irk me was the constant descriptors for people. For example, Louvain Demps is introduced very early on as a childhood friend and a member of the Andantes. But most of her 30-odd subsequent mentions are “Andantes member Demps”, “background singer Demps”, etc. it’s like the author had to keep reminding herself who the people were as she went on.
There were the kind of things I used to do to pad out word counts on writing assignments, but it’s not necessary here - it’s a 300-page book that could have come in a little shorter with no issue. A decent editor should have sorted that out early in the process.
Sylvia Moy was a trailblazer as one of the female creatives in the male-dominated Motown environment, whose contribution has been very much overlooked. Most histories of the label pay her little or no notice. For example, Nelson George’s Where Did Our Love Go?, considered by many to be the definitive book on the history of Motown, mentions her only once, merely as “Jobete staff songwriter Sylvia Moy”, in the context of her co-write of “It Takes Two”.
The style of the writing, for my money, is very dry, more in the style of an academic textbook.
It is perfectly attributed and annotated, with comprehensive bibliography and notes sections.
I would have appreciated an index though.
And it would have been very useful to provide a list of her Motown credits - Nelson George provides this is his book, and it would have been very Interesting to compare both for instances where her contributions might not have been officially credited. She never received a production credit. The label on The Isleys’ “This Old Heart Of Mine” single only lists Holland/Dozier/Holland as writers - Sylvia co-writing role is uncredited.
There is a lot of good background social history in the book, not always germane to the story, or the story I’m interested in, which is fair enough - you want to draw a readership other than superannuated Motown junkies like myself!
Some of the information is selective in my opinion - there’s a lot about drummer Benny Benjamin, while his fellow Funk Brothers member, the hugely important and influential (ask Paul McCartney) bassist James Jamerson, gets scant mention. This would make me question the author’s depth of musical knowledge.
There is quite an amount of repetition between the chapters. One Berry Gordy quote is mentioned twice - on the same page!
One other thing that did irk me was the constant descriptors for people. For example, Louvain Demps is introduced very early on as a childhood friend and a member of the Andantes. But most of her 30-odd subsequent mentions are “Andantes member Demps”, “background singer Demps”, etc. it’s like the author had to keep reminding herself who the people were as she went on.
There were the kind of things I used to do to pad out word counts on writing assignments, but it’s not necessary here - it’s a 300-page book that could have come in a little shorter with no issue. A decent editor should have sorted that out early in the process.
May 24, 2026
An extremely well-written and researched book about Sylvia Moy - an overlooked creative talent working in Motown and the creator behind many songs we know and love. I am glad she is finally getting her due! The book begins with a description of a clip from the Geraldo Rivera show about Women in Motown - she was the outlier voice of what it was really like being a woman working at Motown. The industry would not list her as a producer and she often did not get credit for songs she wrote. We learn about her background - her parents were part of the great migration and moved to Detroit in 1937 looking for a better life. She faced hardships and hurdles - she did not want to get married but got pregnant and the baby died - born premature. She was rejected from Wayne State University's music department because she could not read music so she became a professional singer to raise money to pay for college. A white record company president told her she can sing but will never be a writer. Her parents told her to keep writing! Berry Gordy started Motown and Hitsville USA after getting cheated out of payments for songs. Sylvia made her way to Motown and ran into many obstacles due to sexism. She knew that in order to succeed she would need to work with untapped new vocal talent and create something unique and special. This is how she got connected to work with Little Stevie wonder. He was an incredible performer but his career was at risk. Nobody else wanted to write for him and she wrote incredible songs such as "Uptight" "Ma Cherie Amour" and others that made his career. The line "Ain't too proud to beg" was her line (something a persistent suitor had said to her). The way she marked her songs is by putting tiles of other songs she wrote into the songs. She wrote "This Old Heart of Mine" - Isley Brothers - and she did not get credit. She wrote "Signed, Sealed, Delivered" - her name was left off the credits. Ultimately all of this toxic behavior and micro and macro aggressions took its toll. She had a nervous breakdown and ultimately recovered. She started a nonprofit for youth in telecommunications and media. She finally was inducted in the Songwriter's Hall of Fame in 2006 -- very long overdue. I am so glad this book was written and we are able to ensure she is not lost to history. I highly recommend this book.
Thank you to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for an ARC and I voluntarily left this review.
Thank you to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for an ARC and I voluntarily left this review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Without Sylvia Moys, Little Stevie Wonder’s career would have halted to a dead end before adulthood. There would have been no Uptight, no My Cherie Amor, no I Was Made to Love Her.
Without Sylvia Moys, Michelle wrote that she and Barack Obama would never have gotten together. They bonded over Stevie Wonder’s music.
She wrote It Takes Two sung my Marvin Gaye, who always believed in Sylvia.
I grew up in Metro Detroit when Motown ruled the airwaves. As a preteen with a transistor radio, Motown was the background to my teenage years, and to this day, hearing an old Motown classic brings back nostalgic memories.
I was curious to learn about this ‘legendary songwriter’ who I had never heard of. I encountered a musical genius who found success in a male dominated world.
Sylvia was the first woman songwriter hired by Berry Gordy. She wanted to perform, and had a spectacular voice; she even sang with the Detroit Symphony! But she was shy and the stress of performing affected her health.
She wanted to produce. As esteemed and as talented as she was, she was still dismissed and sidelined, her work as producer uncredited. Later in life, she ran her own studio in Detroit.
Her collaboration with Stevie Wonder was central to her success. Wonder was on the verge of being let go when Sylvia asked to work with him. She helped train his voice and developed songs that reflected his strengths and personality. He was eternally grateful.
Thanks to the publisher for a free book through NetGalley.
Without Sylvia Moys, Michelle wrote that she and Barack Obama would never have gotten together. They bonded over Stevie Wonder’s music.
She wrote It Takes Two sung my Marvin Gaye, who always believed in Sylvia.
I grew up in Metro Detroit when Motown ruled the airwaves. As a preteen with a transistor radio, Motown was the background to my teenage years, and to this day, hearing an old Motown classic brings back nostalgic memories.
I was curious to learn about this ‘legendary songwriter’ who I had never heard of. I encountered a musical genius who found success in a male dominated world.
Sylvia was the first woman songwriter hired by Berry Gordy. She wanted to perform, and had a spectacular voice; she even sang with the Detroit Symphony! But she was shy and the stress of performing affected her health.
She wanted to produce. As esteemed and as talented as she was, she was still dismissed and sidelined, her work as producer uncredited. Later in life, she ran her own studio in Detroit.
Her collaboration with Stevie Wonder was central to her success. Wonder was on the verge of being let go when Sylvia asked to work with him. She helped train his voice and developed songs that reflected his strengths and personality. He was eternally grateful.
Thanks to the publisher for a free book through NetGalley.
March 10, 2026
I really enjoyed this book and was happy I chose to read/listen to it for the final season challenge. The book isn't released yet in the UK but was happy to find the audiobook on Spotify. I found the reader easy to listen to and found it unusally not annoying - which I do with most audiobooks. Even so have pre-ordered the physical book so I can move through at my own pace.
I understand there has been some disagreement between the family and author - however I've learned about somone I'd never heard of before. Granted my knowlege and people behind the music is quite limited and limited to the sonics of the music and the wider US politics at the time so this was really engaging for me.
I realise that Motown was key to Sylvia's career and did interest me. This is not meant as a criticism but would have loved to find out a lot more about her post-Motown career as well. I'd also like to hear more about the Disco/Hi-NRG and Hip-Hop influences flowing through Sylvia's path and the various communities her writing touched and 1611. Maybe this already exists (?) If it does please leave a comment!
Overall I thought it was a well written and narrated.. As said ordering the book, as had to listen to the audio, so I can go through at my own pace and look up some names - I struggle on audio for this in general, nothing to to with the way it was narrated or written - its a me thing! That said it was easy to follow and would imagine it to be so in book form. I'd recommend the book.
I understand there has been some disagreement between the family and author - however I've learned about somone I'd never heard of before. Granted my knowlege and people behind the music is quite limited and limited to the sonics of the music and the wider US politics at the time so this was really engaging for me.
I realise that Motown was key to Sylvia's career and did interest me. This is not meant as a criticism but would have loved to find out a lot more about her post-Motown career as well. I'd also like to hear more about the Disco/Hi-NRG and Hip-Hop influences flowing through Sylvia's path and the various communities her writing touched and 1611. Maybe this already exists (?) If it does please leave a comment!
Overall I thought it was a well written and narrated.. As said ordering the book, as had to listen to the audio, so I can go through at my own pace and look up some names - I struggle on audio for this in general, nothing to to with the way it was narrated or written - its a me thing! That said it was easy to follow and would imagine it to be so in book form. I'd recommend the book.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This book was well researched and such a fun read. This book was written at a time when women's rights and credit for their work is STILL up for debate and up for grabs.
I learned so many things from this book. I had never heard of this almost silent wonder in Motown. I am not very well versed in this genre or timeframe, as I am in other genres of music and the industry. I was quite surprised to learn that she had such a pivotal role in the career of Stevie Wonder. What isn't a wonder is that she (like so many other women of color) had to fight for credit for her work and take on an industry that was mostly male.
Thank you for writing a book that highlights the hard work and dedication of a woman of color. So many of these stories were and still are suppressed. It's important that we learn more so these women can get the credit they deserve.
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving my review voluntarily.
I learned so many things from this book. I had never heard of this almost silent wonder in Motown. I am not very well versed in this genre or timeframe, as I am in other genres of music and the industry. I was quite surprised to learn that she had such a pivotal role in the career of Stevie Wonder. What isn't a wonder is that she (like so many other women of color) had to fight for credit for her work and take on an industry that was mostly male.
Thank you for writing a book that highlights the hard work and dedication of a woman of color. So many of these stories were and still are suppressed. It's important that we learn more so these women can get the credit they deserve.
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving my review voluntarily.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 4, 2026
A book which peaks behind the scenes on Motown is always going to pick my interest. Stevie Wonder is one of the artists of my lifetime. But it was this sentence in the synopsis that made me want to read it: "Meticulously researched and fiercely feminist, It's No Wonder is a historical corrective that restores Sylvia Moy to her rightful place at the forefront of music history."
And yes, the book lived up to that promise. I should have been able to zip through this book, but I found myself looking up songs mentioned in the book that I was less familiar with. As an accomplished lyricist, Moy "marked" her songs in a way that the amateur ethnomusicologist in me just had to research. But this book is not simply about craft: we learn about Moy as a person and dedicated and cherished member of her family. I would recommend this book for scholars on women's history, American history, ethnomusicologists, Black history, Motown enthusiasts and more.
And yes, the book lived up to that promise. I should have been able to zip through this book, but I found myself looking up songs mentioned in the book that I was less familiar with. As an accomplished lyricist, Moy "marked" her songs in a way that the amateur ethnomusicologist in me just had to research. But this book is not simply about craft: we learn about Moy as a person and dedicated and cherished member of her family. I would recommend this book for scholars on women's history, American history, ethnomusicologists, Black history, Motown enthusiasts and more.
April 1, 2026
A beautiful in-depth look at female songwriter, singer, and producer Sylvia Moy’s life. It was both incredibly horrifying and inspiring to see how a talented black woman could get ignored and taken advantage of again and again by a predatory and sexist music industry, and still rise against it.
The book is incredibly well researched, though may have benefited from some more editing. There was a lot of repetition and extraneous name dropping. Some anecdotes seemed a little unnecessary to include.
That being said, this was a great love letter to one of Motown’s first female producers that had me genuinely emotionally invested in her story. Seeing her start her own production company and work so closely with kids and younger artists in music education had me crying.
Recommend listening to the audiobook while you read this one! The narrator is absolutely fantastic.
The book is incredibly well researched, though may have benefited from some more editing. There was a lot of repetition and extraneous name dropping. Some anecdotes seemed a little unnecessary to include.
That being said, this was a great love letter to one of Motown’s first female producers that had me genuinely emotionally invested in her story. Seeing her start her own production company and work so closely with kids and younger artists in music education had me crying.
Recommend listening to the audiobook while you read this one! The narrator is absolutely fantastic.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a well researched, well written book about the life of one of Motown's unsung heroes. I had seen Sylvia Moy's name credited on some of my old Motown records and she was mentioned in passing in some of the books I've read, but I had no idea what a vital role she played at Motown and especially in the career of Stevie Wonder. This book not only chronicles her story as a singer, songwriter and producer but also highlights the challenges she faced as an African American woman in a predominantly male industry and her struggles to get credit for her work. Highly recommended
Thanks to NetGalley and Da Capo for an advanced reader copy.
Thanks to NetGalley and Da Capo for an advanced reader copy.
February 23, 2026
(4.5 rounded up) An interesting history of a woman’s whose contributions have often gone overlooked even though her music is widely known.
The irony isn’t lost of me that a book about a woman whose contributions were often overshadowed or uncredited due to sexism in the industry also has such a large focus on the career of a man who she in many ways made possible.
This is a well researched and well written piece. I only wish she lived long enough to see the full recognition.
Disclosure: I received a gifted ARC from the publisher. No review was required and all opinions are my own.
The irony isn’t lost of me that a book about a woman whose contributions were often overshadowed or uncredited due to sexism in the industry also has such a large focus on the career of a man who she in many ways made possible.
This is a well researched and well written piece. I only wish she lived long enough to see the full recognition.
Disclosure: I received a gifted ARC from the publisher. No review was required and all opinions are my own.
March 9, 2026
It feels wrong not rating this a 5. I love Motown and all things Detroit. It was fascinating reading a story I've never heard of - I never knew this woman and that she was behind so many incredible songs. And a driving force behind Stevie Wonder. A woman in the shadows not given credit. I gave it a four because it took me a minute to get into it. The book really got good after around 90 pages.
March 30, 2026
I listened to the book and the narration was monotone. The book was drawn out and did not hold my attention. I found myself fast forwarding and skipping chapters. I lost interest very quickly with this book.
March 26, 2026
Informative and insightful book.
April 14, 2026
A little repetitive but interesting nonetheless. Puts meaning to “behind every great man is an even greater woman.”
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews