What do you think?
Rate this book
Mark of the Lion #3
Demring i nord
The third installment in the Mark of the Lion trilogy.
Following A Voice in the Wind and An Echo in the Darkness, As Sure as the Dawn continues the chronicles of Hadassah, a Christian slave woman living during the height of the Roman Empire. She has saved the life of the scorned child of a disreputable Roman woman and the Germanic gladiator, Atretes. For her faith, Hadassah now languishes in condemnation, awaiting death in a dungeon beneath the arena. Atretes, who holds fast to his dreams of revenge for the slaughter of his people, wants his son back. So he seeks out John the Beloved, who is the key to finding the custodian of his son, and brings his war-weary soul closer to redemption.
Following A Voice in the Wind and An Echo in the Darkness, As Sure as the Dawn continues the chronicles of Hadassah, a Christian slave woman living during the height of the Roman Empire. She has saved the life of the scorned child of a disreputable Roman woman and the Germanic gladiator, Atretes. For her faith, Hadassah now languishes in condemnation, awaiting death in a dungeon beneath the arena. Atretes, who holds fast to his dreams of revenge for the slaughter of his people, wants his son back. So he seeks out John the Beloved, who is the key to finding the custodian of his son, and brings his war-weary soul closer to redemption.
568 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 1995
1412 people are currently reading
20142 people want to read
About the author
Francine Rivers
59 books21.2k followersNew York Times bestselling author Francine Rivers continues to win both industry acclaim and reader loyalty around the globe. Her numerous bestsellers include Redeeming Love, A Voice in the Wind, and Bridge to Haven, and her work has been translated into more than thirty different languages. She is a member of Romance Writers of America's coveted Hall of Fame as well as a recipient of the Lifetime Achievement Award from American Christian Fiction Writers (ACFW).
www.francinerivers.com
www.facebook.com/FrancineRivers
Twitter: @FrancineRivers
www.francinerivers.com
www.facebook.com/FrancineRivers
Twitter: @FrancineRivers
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,128 reviews
December 7, 2016
I'm not sure how to begin this review. Despite the one star review I gave it, I did enjoy it more so towards the ending and there was a lot of spiritual wisdom and entertainment speckled throughout it.. buutttt there were just some things I didn't like about this book. And since I got to start somewhere, I might as well get my "problems" with the book out of the way. So brace yourself peeps.
In this Mark of the Lion series, I noticed a discomforting trend. The romantic relationships between the main characters (Hadassah and Marcus in the first two books, and then Atretes and Rizpah and the third) all began on tumultuous and dangerous grounds. I'm talking about abuse here, people: emotional, physical, and spiritual. You can argue that it is to be somewhat expected in the first two books due to Hadassah being a slave and Marcus her owner and although that doesn't make it right, I appreciate how Francine shows the darker nature of that time and slavery and the effects of living in it. But in As Sure As Dawn, it was very unsettling as I continued to read Rizpah and Atretes love story unfold.
As Sure As Dawn picks up with Atretes seeking out his son only to discover that the child, though still a babe, is not willing to depart from his mother so easily to be weaned by another and Rizpah is as unwilling to yield her son back to his father who abandoned him. Thus begins their rocky relationship. Though Atretes is cruel to her in speech and in his handling with her, and also regards her Christian faith mockingly, somehow Rizpah realizes that she has fallen head over heels in love with him. Uh... come again?
Let's rewind and push pause.
Problem #1: This literally happened out of nowhere and in such a short time frame from their meet. There was no build or possible sustenance to her love. He hadn't showed any amount of kindness to her, practically threw her out of his house when they first met, threatened to kill her, and exerted physical and emotional pain on her, and she constantly found herself brought to her worst when ever she was around him. This leads me to believe that ultimately, Rizpah fell in love with the handsome face and build of Atretes which is more akin to lust than I dare say would be called romantic love, so can we just call it that.
I admit it is easy to fall into this trap, I mean so many of real-life relationship abuse stories start off on rocky ground, so I appreciate Mrs. Rivers bringing this to light, however, the abuse Rizpah endured from Atretes seemed to be glazed over and unconfronted as if it's something to be expected from such a "manly man". Pfft! It might as well been an issue that stayed in the dark if it was only going to encourage women who are in such situations to stay and endure, and that things will eventually get better!
Atretes had all the warning signs of being abusive. So are we really surprise when we find out that he is? I'm glad Francine didn't hide this even after Atretes "sees the light". However, at the same time, I felt like Francine may have undermined the effects of abuse. It was never challenged, or flagged as wrong but daily introduced as normal.
Problem #2: As soon as Atretes meets Rizpah, he begins to lust after her when he notices how beautiful she is and somehow that is translated into love. Um... no. I seriously did not see where his lust ended in his love began. Throughout the book, he makes it a goal to break down Ripzah walls to take pleasure in her as if she's a conquest. He orders her around like a slave (and she is in no way in bondage to him) and treats her like one as well. Multiple times he takes advantage of her by forcing himself upon his embrace and kissing her harshly when she definitively says no and despite her pushing away.
Sidebar: If you are in a relationship that is showing early signs of abuse (possessiveness, jealousy, domineering behavior, etc.), whether through words or actions, don't stick around! That's a relationship that you don't need to be in. Seek guidance and help. And please don't marry them thinking it will make things better!
I appreciate books that bring the trauma of relationship abuse to the forefront but to make it okay or to dance it over it? Uh... NO. You have a choice and a voice in a relationship and women especially should see that walking away from this type of behavior early on is perhaps the best route to take!
I have no problem at all with Christian books bringing some of these "problems" to light in their books because these are real issues and life just isn't peaches and rainbows. But I just felt that the issues were hardly addressed as being negative, were glazed over, and to an extent encourages women readers that this type of behavior is okay and to stick it out. You shouldn't have to subject yourself to that type of treatment. Justifying staying in a bad relationship, or even encouraging someone to pursue or entertain someone in order to be a "light" in their life is not honorable or admirable. It's plain dumb, and I mean that in the most encouraging way. Seriously, don't be dumb.
Alright, I know I must sound like a broken record, but I just had to say it because it didn't seem like Mrs. Rivers ever would. My problems with the novel made it such a challenge for me to enjoy anything else that was going on in the story, and it wasn't until I got three-fourths of the way that my interest start to resurface, and a huge portion of this was due to the fact that it was slow pace (and that's a common trait I have found while reading Francine Rivers books). But even though it does get better towards the end, it was all just a little too late for me.
One last thing: Abuse comes in many shapes and forms and if you're lucky you will see the early warning signs. No one deserves to be abused. It is NOT an act of love. If you are being abused, please get help.
In this Mark of the Lion series, I noticed a discomforting trend. The romantic relationships between the main characters (Hadassah and Marcus in the first two books, and then Atretes and Rizpah and the third) all began on tumultuous and dangerous grounds. I'm talking about abuse here, people: emotional, physical, and spiritual. You can argue that it is to be somewhat expected in the first two books due to Hadassah being a slave and Marcus her owner and although that doesn't make it right, I appreciate how Francine shows the darker nature of that time and slavery and the effects of living in it. But in As Sure As Dawn, it was very unsettling as I continued to read Rizpah and Atretes love story unfold.
As Sure As Dawn picks up with Atretes seeking out his son only to discover that the child, though still a babe, is not willing to depart from his mother so easily to be weaned by another and Rizpah is as unwilling to yield her son back to his father who abandoned him. Thus begins their rocky relationship. Though Atretes is cruel to her in speech and in his handling with her, and also regards her Christian faith mockingly, somehow Rizpah realizes that she has fallen head over heels in love with him. Uh... come again?
Let's rewind and push pause.
Problem #1: This literally happened out of nowhere and in such a short time frame from their meet. There was no build or possible sustenance to her love. He hadn't showed any amount of kindness to her, practically threw her out of his house when they first met, threatened to kill her, and exerted physical and emotional pain on her, and she constantly found herself brought to her worst when ever she was around him. This leads me to believe that ultimately, Rizpah fell in love with the handsome face and build of Atretes which is more akin to lust than I dare say would be called romantic love, so can we just call it that.
I admit it is easy to fall into this trap, I mean so many of real-life relationship abuse stories start off on rocky ground, so I appreciate Mrs. Rivers bringing this to light, however, the abuse Rizpah endured from Atretes seemed to be glazed over and unconfronted as if it's something to be expected from such a "manly man". Pfft! It might as well been an issue that stayed in the dark if it was only going to encourage women who are in such situations to stay and endure, and that things will eventually get better!
Atretes had all the warning signs of being abusive. So are we really surprise when we find out that he is? I'm glad Francine didn't hide this even after Atretes "sees the light". However, at the same time, I felt like Francine may have undermined the effects of abuse. It was never challenged, or flagged as wrong but daily introduced as normal.
Problem #2: As soon as Atretes meets Rizpah, he begins to lust after her when he notices how beautiful she is and somehow that is translated into love. Um... no. I seriously did not see where his lust ended in his love began. Throughout the book, he makes it a goal to break down Ripzah walls to take pleasure in her as if she's a conquest. He orders her around like a slave (and she is in no way in bondage to him) and treats her like one as well. Multiple times he takes advantage of her by forcing himself upon his embrace and kissing her harshly when she definitively says no and despite her pushing away.
Sidebar: If you are in a relationship that is showing early signs of abuse (possessiveness, jealousy, domineering behavior, etc.), whether through words or actions, don't stick around! That's a relationship that you don't need to be in. Seek guidance and help. And please don't marry them thinking it will make things better!
I appreciate books that bring the trauma of relationship abuse to the forefront but to make it okay or to dance it over it? Uh... NO. You have a choice and a voice in a relationship and women especially should see that walking away from this type of behavior early on is perhaps the best route to take!
I have no problem at all with Christian books bringing some of these "problems" to light in their books because these are real issues and life just isn't peaches and rainbows. But I just felt that the issues were hardly addressed as being negative, were glazed over, and to an extent encourages women readers that this type of behavior is okay and to stick it out. You shouldn't have to subject yourself to that type of treatment. Justifying staying in a bad relationship, or even encouraging someone to pursue or entertain someone in order to be a "light" in their life is not honorable or admirable. It's plain dumb, and I mean that in the most encouraging way. Seriously, don't be dumb.
Alright, I know I must sound like a broken record, but I just had to say it because it didn't seem like Mrs. Rivers ever would. My problems with the novel made it such a challenge for me to enjoy anything else that was going on in the story, and it wasn't until I got three-fourths of the way that my interest start to resurface, and a huge portion of this was due to the fact that it was slow pace (and that's a common trait I have found while reading Francine Rivers books). But even though it does get better towards the end, it was all just a little too late for me.
One last thing: Abuse comes in many shapes and forms and if you're lucky you will see the early warning signs. No one deserves to be abused. It is NOT an act of love. If you are being abused, please get help.
July 17, 2017
It was a great book and a wonderful ending to an amazing series. It was sad to know that I wouldn't be able to follow the lives of Rizpah and Arteres anymore. As well as Haddassa and Marcus. :)
I suggest this series to everyone. Now I am a Francine River's reader. I am off to my next book of hers. :)
I suggest this series to everyone. Now I am a Francine River's reader. I am off to my next book of hers. :)
March 6, 2011
While I adore the 2nd book of the series, I think this was my favorite. Atretes is frustrating and intense, and while I wanted very much to come through the pages of the book and strangle him, I loved reading his journey. I think his struggle with anger and what was done to him is so similar to many people today, that stubborn pride that just won't let you loose to experience God even when He makes himself obvious.
And then there's Rizpah, my favorite character in the entire series. I can relate to her so much, especially with the why-did-I-say-that aspect. Her journey with Atretes, Theophilus (I love that Rivers pulls a real life person into the story) and her baby Caleb is beautiful (reading about her son growing up through all of this was very gut-wrenching at times and at others brought a smile to my face).
One of the things that I really appreciate about this book is the miracles. I am naturally very suspicious of anything called a miracle. I know that God performed many miracles in the Old Testament and Jesus performed many in the New Testament, but they just don't happen today. In this book the purpose of miracles became very obvious to me; they aren't for the Wow-factor. They happen because there is no other way to reach the person. In "As Sure as the Dawn" there was no other way to reach Atretes and the Chatti people.
So I finished this book feeling a little sad that the series was over. I would have loved to continue reading about Haddassah and Marcus and Rizpah and Atretes.
And then there's Rizpah, my favorite character in the entire series. I can relate to her so much, especially with the why-did-I-say-that aspect. Her journey with Atretes, Theophilus (I love that Rivers pulls a real life person into the story) and her baby Caleb is beautiful (reading about her son growing up through all of this was very gut-wrenching at times and at others brought a smile to my face).
One of the things that I really appreciate about this book is the miracles. I am naturally very suspicious of anything called a miracle. I know that God performed many miracles in the Old Testament and Jesus performed many in the New Testament, but they just don't happen today. In this book the purpose of miracles became very obvious to me; they aren't for the Wow-factor. They happen because there is no other way to reach the person. In "As Sure as the Dawn" there was no other way to reach Atretes and the Chatti people.
So I finished this book feeling a little sad that the series was over. I would have loved to continue reading about Haddassah and Marcus and Rizpah and Atretes.
July 23, 2016
This book was a big disappointment for me, because I simply adored the first 2 books from the Mark Of The Lion, in fact, I don’t remember crying as much while reading a book as I cried during A Voice in The Wind and especially An Echo in The Darkness. I adored Hadassah and Marcus and despite knowing that their story ended with Book II I sill wanted to read Book III and discover what happened to Atretes.
For the first time while reading these Christian books, the constant preaching and christianization bothered me deeply. I found all the characters very weak compared to those from the other books. Rizpah was in my opinion a poor copy of Hadassah and I even missed Julia that crazy, conniving bitch. I also did not felt a personal, strong connection with the love story between Atretes and Rizpah. As for the plot, I expected far more from Francine Rivers.
On a positive note let me say that I do not regret reading this, by all means, Francine Rivers is a great writer, her books are still among my all time favorites, I just felt this book to be very different from the other two, it should have been a separate book and not the ending of the trilogy or at least some loose pieces should have been addressed here, for instance, Atretes knowing that Hadassah survived the arena, Hadassah knowing that Atretes found his son and ultimately discovered the lord among others.
For the first time while reading these Christian books, the constant preaching and christianization bothered me deeply. I found all the characters very weak compared to those from the other books. Rizpah was in my opinion a poor copy of Hadassah and I even missed Julia that crazy, conniving bitch. I also did not felt a personal, strong connection with the love story between Atretes and Rizpah. As for the plot, I expected far more from Francine Rivers.
On a positive note let me say that I do not regret reading this, by all means, Francine Rivers is a great writer, her books are still among my all time favorites, I just felt this book to be very different from the other two, it should have been a separate book and not the ending of the trilogy or at least some loose pieces should have been addressed here, for instance, Atretes knowing that Hadassah survived the arena, Hadassah knowing that Atretes found his son and ultimately discovered the lord among others.
January 7, 2026
✨ Spoiler-Free Book Review ✨
Title: As Sure as the Dawn
Author: Francine Rivers
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
(THIS IS BOOK THREE IN THE MARK OF THE LION TRILOGY - PROCEED WITH CAUTION TO AVOID POTENTIAL SPOILERS OF BOOKS 1 &2)
Summary:
Atretes, once a fierce Germanic warrior, is captured by the Roman Empire and forced into slavery as a gladiator. After earning his freedom, he embarks on a dangerous journey to return home. A journey that may lead him to God, redemption, and unexpected love along the way.
Plot:
I’ve heard some readers describe this book as slow, but that wasn’t my experience at all. While the story does require patience, I believe that’s intentional and necessary given Atretes’ character. He isn’t someone with an easy, childlike faith or a soft heart. He is deeply wounded - shaped by betrayal, violence, and loss - and incredibly pessimistic about the world around him. Because of that, his journey unfolds gradually. Still, I felt there was always something happening that kept me engaged and eager to see what came next.
Pacing:
The pacing felt very balanced. It never dragged, but it also wasn’t rushed. I always had time to process events and emotions while still feeling compelled to keep reading.
What I Loved:
Atretes was very different from the types of characters I usually read about, and I loved how this story pushed me outside my comfort zone. The book powerfully explores pride and how it hardens us and keeps us from experiencing the fullness of life God intends for us. I also deeply loved Rizpah. Even when Atretes treated her poorly, she consistently embodied both love and truth. Her ability to balance compassion with conviction was beautiful and impactful.
What I Didn’t Love:
This book contains several very heavy topics that I wouldn’t normally gravitate toward. There are moments involving sexual assault, child endangerment, death, and graphic violence. While I understand why these elements are included, they can be difficult to read.
Faith Element:
The faith thread in this book was incredibly strong. It shows the importance of perseverance - of not giving up on people, but also the wisdom of knowing when to “shake the dust off your feet” and move on to those who are ready to hear the truth. The spiritual journey is woven throughout the entire story in a powerful and meaningful way.
Writing:
Absolutely breathtaking. Francine Rivers has a remarkable gift for storytelling. Her writing is rich with emotional depth, vivid imagery, and layered characters. You don’t just read the story, you feel immersed in it.
Would I Recommend It?
Absolutely!… but with caution. Because of the intense content and trigger warnings, this book (and the entire series) is not for the faint of heart. That said, the payoff is inspiring, redemptive, and uplifting. In my opinion, it is worth walking through the painful parts to reach the hope waiting on the other side.
‼️⚠️Trigger / Content Warnings:⚠️‼️
• Child danger and injury
• Past child death
• Physical and emotional abuse
• Sexual assault
• Mention of the word “rape”
• Brief mention of Infertility
• Graphic violence and death
• Racism and sexism
• Persecution of Christians
• Grief and loss
• Trauma
• Slavery
• Suicide
Title: As Sure as the Dawn
Author: Francine Rivers
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
(THIS IS BOOK THREE IN THE MARK OF THE LION TRILOGY - PROCEED WITH CAUTION TO AVOID POTENTIAL SPOILERS OF BOOKS 1 &2)
Summary:
Atretes, once a fierce Germanic warrior, is captured by the Roman Empire and forced into slavery as a gladiator. After earning his freedom, he embarks on a dangerous journey to return home. A journey that may lead him to God, redemption, and unexpected love along the way.
Plot:
I’ve heard some readers describe this book as slow, but that wasn’t my experience at all. While the story does require patience, I believe that’s intentional and necessary given Atretes’ character. He isn’t someone with an easy, childlike faith or a soft heart. He is deeply wounded - shaped by betrayal, violence, and loss - and incredibly pessimistic about the world around him. Because of that, his journey unfolds gradually. Still, I felt there was always something happening that kept me engaged and eager to see what came next.
Pacing:
The pacing felt very balanced. It never dragged, but it also wasn’t rushed. I always had time to process events and emotions while still feeling compelled to keep reading.
What I Loved:
Atretes was very different from the types of characters I usually read about, and I loved how this story pushed me outside my comfort zone. The book powerfully explores pride and how it hardens us and keeps us from experiencing the fullness of life God intends for us. I also deeply loved Rizpah. Even when Atretes treated her poorly, she consistently embodied both love and truth. Her ability to balance compassion with conviction was beautiful and impactful.
What I Didn’t Love:
This book contains several very heavy topics that I wouldn’t normally gravitate toward. There are moments involving sexual assault, child endangerment, death, and graphic violence. While I understand why these elements are included, they can be difficult to read.
Faith Element:
The faith thread in this book was incredibly strong. It shows the importance of perseverance - of not giving up on people, but also the wisdom of knowing when to “shake the dust off your feet” and move on to those who are ready to hear the truth. The spiritual journey is woven throughout the entire story in a powerful and meaningful way.
Writing:
Absolutely breathtaking. Francine Rivers has a remarkable gift for storytelling. Her writing is rich with emotional depth, vivid imagery, and layered characters. You don’t just read the story, you feel immersed in it.
Would I Recommend It?
Absolutely!… but with caution. Because of the intense content and trigger warnings, this book (and the entire series) is not for the faint of heart. That said, the payoff is inspiring, redemptive, and uplifting. In my opinion, it is worth walking through the painful parts to reach the hope waiting on the other side.
‼️⚠️Trigger / Content Warnings:⚠️‼️
• Child danger and injury
• Past child death
• Physical and emotional abuse
• Sexual assault
• Mention of the word “rape”
• Brief mention of Infertility
• Graphic violence and death
• Racism and sexism
• Persecution of Christians
• Grief and loss
• Trauma
• Slavery
• Suicide
December 14, 2021
4.25 stars
This series is truly unforgettable. Though I didn't love this book quite as much as the first two in the series, it was still fantastic.
Atretes is a character we meet in the first book in this series, and though he doesn't play much of a part in book two, I'm happy we get the conclusion of his story. Rizpuh is our heroine and I found her so relatable. As much as I love and adore Hadassah, and I know she wasn't perfect, sometimes she seemed that way. Rizpuh had a problem keeping her mouth shut sometimes, and honestly, same, but she was always trying to do God's will in her life.
Atretes was hard to like at times, but I ended up really liking him throughout the story. And then there was that last 15-20% leading up to the ending. I get it, but yikes. It was probably the only reason this wasn't a full five stars. Still, I enjoyed this so much and these books are so wonderful and important to read!
This series is truly unforgettable. Though I didn't love this book quite as much as the first two in the series, it was still fantastic.
Atretes is a character we meet in the first book in this series, and though he doesn't play much of a part in book two, I'm happy we get the conclusion of his story. Rizpuh is our heroine and I found her so relatable. As much as I love and adore Hadassah, and I know she wasn't perfect, sometimes she seemed that way. Rizpuh had a problem keeping her mouth shut sometimes, and honestly, same, but she was always trying to do God's will in her life.
Atretes was hard to like at times, but I ended up really liking him throughout the story. And then there was that last 15-20% leading up to the ending. I get it, but yikes. It was probably the only reason this wasn't a full five stars. Still, I enjoyed this so much and these books are so wonderful and important to read!
“God's will isn't hidden away like the myths and philosophies and knowledge of the world. Jesus told us openly and daily what his will for us is. Love one another.”
Audio book source: Hoopla
Story Rating: 4.25 stars
Narrator: Richard Ferron
Narration Rating: 4 stars
Genre: Historical Fiction
Length: 20h 12m
August 10, 2011
Dude, the first half of this book = romance novel. Straight up, with less nakedness and with the word "Jesus" muttered as something other than a curse or expression of sexual fulfillment.
The middle part = summarization of Bible stories through one character's pages and pages of talking. As if the people of the "projected" audience don't freakin' know. And as if anybody who appreciates good writing wants to see pages of info-dump via dialogue.
Second half of book = I don't even know. But, the actual ire I experienced was directed at the characters and managed to, at times, distract me from the frustration I had with the writer behind it all, that I bumped this up from 1.5 to 2.0 stars. Good thing, too, since we don't have half-stars around here.
Immediate reaction upon finishing = I tossed it onto the table and blew a raspberry at it.
The middle part = summarization of Bible stories through one character's pages and pages of talking. As if the people of the "projected" audience don't freakin' know. And as if anybody who appreciates good writing wants to see pages of info-dump via dialogue.
Second half of book = I don't even know. But, the actual ire I experienced was directed at the characters and managed to, at times, distract me from the frustration I had with the writer behind it all, that I bumped this up from 1.5 to 2.0 stars. Good thing, too, since we don't have half-stars around here.
Immediate reaction upon finishing = I tossed it onto the table and blew a raspberry at it.
December 31, 2024
This was a 5 ⭐️ series! Francine Rivers has blessed us with these three powerful stories. They will forever be a part of me. I’m sad they are over for they have brought such encouragement to my own Christian life. I cannot recommend them enough. If you haven’t read this series, read them. Thank you Lord for the works of good Christian Fiction!
March 16, 2016
*sigh*
Francine Rivers, what am I going to do with you?
Seriously, I'm not sure where to begin. The first two books in the series followed different characters, and although at times the religious elements smacked a bit too much like American evangelicalism (more on that in a bit) they did reflect good historical research and some smattering of knowledge of ancient bits of the faith (like the Jesus Prayer, or the prayer of unbelief). One of our main characters, Atretes: the German barbarian brought to Rome as a POW and forced into the Arena, disappeared completely during the second book of this trilogy. Which is a completely legitimate way of structuring a trilogy. However, I found it extremely odd that book two ends with nearly everything tied up neatly except for Atretes. No really, we have a big wedding, mass conversion, etc. But Not mention of Atretes. Then comes this book. (Spoilers forthwith so, you have been warned).
The end of book #1 A Voice in the Wind, Hadassah (a Jewish slave convert) rescues Atretes' newborn from being left on the rocks by bringing it to John the Baptist who in turn gives it to a grieving widow who recently lost her own child.
Book three catches up on that thread, where Atretes and Rizpah forced to live together for the sake of their mutual child (probably the best way to describe the awkward situation). Nearly the first half of the book continues the tone of the other books in the trilogy, as we see devoted pious woman struggle with her humanity and her Evangelical desires to see Atretes not be consumed by his inner demons. Atretes, having won his freedom in Voice is now hungry for the adrenaline of the arena and the Emperor's friends would be more than happy to put him back into it. Feeling that Germania is the only likely safe refugee, Atretes decided to take Rizpah and their son Caleb back, which they do as they join a group of Christians heading out to evangelize the barbarian Europe above, Lead by a Centurion convert , Theo (I forget his full name, and since this was returned digitally to my library, We'll stick with his nick name). This is the point the books dives off the cliff, and really I have to address the entire series as a whole.
Christian fiction, as a genre is messy. It's like Christian cinema. It's mostly catered to Evangelicals, has a very hard time balancing the need to convert/teach a moral and be entertaining, and often is had to write well without running into something stupid or smacking of heresy. To this point, the only overtly religious fiction published since the 1980s invention of the genre that have had comparable quality to a regular work of mainstream fiction is The Last Disciple trilogy by Hank Hanegraaf. Which itself was set in the same time period, of post Ascension, pre-council ancient Rome. The first two books in the Mark of the Lion series were flawed but well written. There was the usual trend of writing to a female audience (I guess Male Evangelicals don't read, because nearly any Lifeway is completely dedicated to romances), with romantic elements. Weirdly, all three books have love interests who are emotionally, physically, and somewhat spiritually abusive. But I'm going to chalk that up to the fact that A) these characters are well rounded, evil vile characters are giving empathetic rounding, B) Girls can't seem to get enough of broken rebels they can fix. Isn't that right , Jimmy?
I do find it weird, that a 'date and convert' tone comes across these books, but I'm not going to look too hard at that, because this volume has bigger problems.
#1)The plot is aimless here, there is no tension of the first two books. The first two books used a method of trading off each Character's plot or subplot creating a eb and flow of tension. We were always wondering what crazy thing Julia was going to do, or where Marcus was going to get himself if he looked any deeper in himself. Not here. There's some slight tension between our leads, but once we know they're going to Germania, it kinda seals the fact they are going to end up together. The rest of the tension apparently is suppose to be from getting there. Yay. Road Trip.
As soon as our group gets to Rome, Atretes has a trust issue melt down and Rizpah (who had made the weird vow of never lying to him, no matter what) is forced to tell him about her life on the streets before her first husband took her in and helped her find a better path. Among other things lifted from Les Mes she happened to be a harlot. And this starts off the weird tension of emotional and psychical abuse. Rivers had a weird way about writing sex, and especially homosexuality in her other books in the series, but other than what feels like writing without real knowledge of how things work they end up being much more level than most evangelicals who write (three dimensional I should say). Here we get attempted rape as tension for overcoming one's lust.
No, really.
Oh, and apparently Theo is going to beat St. Boniface to the punch and convert all the heathen. Which would be great, except everything that happens makes St.Boniface's story much more interesting. Heck, the climax blatantly steals from it.
Anyway, while our merry band is crossing across Europe, we eventually narrow down to Theo and our leads, who get ambushed by Germans. Who kill Rizpah. With an arrow to the heart.
And the laying on of hands, and prayer from St. Theo literally brings her back alive with nothing but a scar. This of course immediately causes Atretes to convert.
....
See, book, this is not good writing. I think this has more to do with Evangelical Christianity, which put's one's spiritual climax at conversion instead of discipleship like mainline and High churches, but random miracles and fake climaxes do not good writing make. As a Christian, I'm not against miracles at all, but in this book they seem to be written in to fix plot holes or pull a Deus ex machina. Literally as soon as we get to the Village, River's pulls a Pocahontas and BAM! Theo and Rizpah can instantly speak perfect German. (as a German speaker, this is incredulous. Yes, I do know the early church was gifted the gift of speaking in other languages via the Holy Spirit, but permanent and instant Rosetta Stoning seems to be more unbelievable, than if an apostle were present).
This of course sets us up for a weird, weird last third where Theo, Atretes, and Rizpah all battle satanic forces in the village in order to help convert Atrete's tribe. It's so awkwardly written, the whole thing comes across as a vastly superior written Chick Track, and honestly makes me question what sort of Evangelical Rivers is. I won't go into details, because honestly, it's too bothersome to rehash the third, and of course spoilers, but it feels incredibly theologically shallow. Almost if Rivers did take a chick track, the story of St. Boniface, and table scraps from the first two books and put it into the blender.
Rivers falls into the genres own trap, as Atretes' conversion is treated in a way of informing the readers. Before his conversion Atretes' ask to hear about the Good News and Theo literally spends about 10 pages summarizing the Old Testament. Was there going to be a test at the end of the Chapter? Rivers, you cannot write a track, and a fiction book at the same time. There ultimately felt as if the book had nothing to drive it forward, but convertitus. Which is a shame since this book's cover is what made me invest in the series to begin with.
May 16, 2010
There are books that are good, even great, books that you will remember and offer glowing recommendations to all you meet. And then there are books like As Sure as the Dawn, which, days later, will still leave you in awe and wonder. There’s power behind this story, that transformative, tremor-inducing power that makes you forget this is a work of fiction and not something that raised itself out of the ground.
This is considered Christian fiction, which by definition already holes itself to certain prejudices. Francine Rivers, however, is a tremendous story-teller who appeals to Christians and non-Christians without compromising the crux of her message. The characters are flawed, weak, and remarkably human, and not the perfect, holier than thou robots one might expect to find in this genre.
Needless to say, I loved everything about this final installment in this trilogy and would highly recommend.
This is considered Christian fiction, which by definition already holes itself to certain prejudices. Francine Rivers, however, is a tremendous story-teller who appeals to Christians and non-Christians without compromising the crux of her message. The characters are flawed, weak, and remarkably human, and not the perfect, holier than thou robots one might expect to find in this genre.
Needless to say, I loved everything about this final installment in this trilogy and would highly recommend.
July 3, 2007
Okay, I know these are Christian books, but I read them because they came highly recommended. The first two had good stories, good enough to overcome the preaching. The third basically drudged up some leftover characters from the first two books and had them quote the entire Bible to eachother. Oh, plus there were some pretty outrageous "heavenly miracles" in this book, while the other two managed to tell a good story without depending on acts of God for the storyline to progress.
January 26, 2020
Now this one is special. It was about the spiritual battle we all face and how the Name of Jesus saves. How having a humble, servant heart speaks louder of Jesus than yelling about salvation. It’s still so relevant to our time. Thank you Francine Rivers!
March 15, 2017
…I don’t want this series to end… but I must say it, yes, a fitting end to the Mark of the Lion saga. As Sure as the Dawn told another powerful story; another tale of a life completely turned around. This time, we focus on Atretes, the fierce and feared gladiator. Except he’s not a gladiator anymore, but many would like to see him in the arena again. He now has his son, and the woman, Rizpah, who’s become a mother to his son… Yet will his relentless anger take all that away from him?
Two hot-tempered individuals. They share the love of the little baby, Caleb. And in the end, they long to serve God, but will their human desires and drives ruin their attempt? Will everything crash and be demolished under the force of evil, or is God yet in control?
Powerful as always. Vivid. Real. This is no fluffy make-belief. This is a tale that makes your heart pound and goosebumps rise on your skin. Your heart sing in joyousness, or your soul cry out in terror.
Atretes had a fierce and vile anger and bitterness. But God’s love was way, way bigger, much, much deeper. It was/is eternal!
This book was a little different from the first two, Hadassah’s story (A Voice in the Wind) and Marcus’s story (An Echo in the Darkness). It took us to a different place and setting, in Germania; we met a lot of new people. Atretes was really the only character from the first books that was in As Sure as the Dawn. Yet it still carried the same awesome message.
As Sure as the Dawn, another poignant story… I only wish it wasn’t the last of the Mark of the Lion!
Two hot-tempered individuals. They share the love of the little baby, Caleb. And in the end, they long to serve God, but will their human desires and drives ruin their attempt? Will everything crash and be demolished under the force of evil, or is God yet in control?
Powerful as always. Vivid. Real. This is no fluffy make-belief. This is a tale that makes your heart pound and goosebumps rise on your skin. Your heart sing in joyousness, or your soul cry out in terror.
Atretes had a fierce and vile anger and bitterness. But God’s love was way, way bigger, much, much deeper. It was/is eternal!
This book was a little different from the first two, Hadassah’s story (A Voice in the Wind) and Marcus’s story (An Echo in the Darkness). It took us to a different place and setting, in Germania; we met a lot of new people. Atretes was really the only character from the first books that was in As Sure as the Dawn. Yet it still carried the same awesome message.
As Sure as the Dawn, another poignant story… I only wish it wasn’t the last of the Mark of the Lion!
September 11, 2010
This book really spoke to me until they reached the Chatti. Then it became sort of weird. I definitely found the power of Satan stronger in this book. I've got some great lessons from it, almost more so than the first two. I could identify with Rizpah and her struggles as a born again Christian. I was hesitant to read it in the beginning but I am so glad I did.
April 26, 2022
I absolutely adored the romance, but I can say I preferred the first two. It was still a beautiful story with beautiful testimonies, but it operated far more on the edge of impossible.
There was less salvation based on the character of Christ and more his power. Kinda mixed feelings, but I loved the story.
There was less salvation based on the character of Christ and more his power. Kinda mixed feelings, but I loved the story.
February 8, 2025
Another reading approximately 30 years after the first.
December 14, 2021
As Sure as the Dawn is the third book in the 'Mark of the Lion' series. Readers are introduced to Atretes in the first 2 books. He's taken captive and brought to Rome to be a gladiator. Over the course of the books, he gains his freedom but loses so much in the process.
Julia -from the first 2 books - has his child and in book 3 we learn the baby is alive (he thought the child had died). The baby was thrown away like trash except he was saved by Hadassah and given to a widowed Christian woman who had lost her own baby.
The battle between Atretes and Rizpuh keeps the story moving forward. Rizpuh's love for Caleb (Atretes's baby) is endearing but she has the battle of convincing Atretes that she's trustworthy.
This book is Atretes's journey to finding Christ and believing he is worthy of forgiveness even though he has lived a life of sin. Rizpuh is one of the many people put in his life to plant the seed that he is a child of God. Rizpuh's life becomes the catalyst to what finally gets Atretes to believe in God. But like all Christians even AFTER you are a follower you still falter because no human is perfect. Atretes learns he must always be seeking the true God.
Julia -from the first 2 books - has his child and in book 3 we learn the baby is alive (he thought the child had died). The baby was thrown away like trash except he was saved by Hadassah and given to a widowed Christian woman who had lost her own baby.
The battle between Atretes and Rizpuh keeps the story moving forward. Rizpuh's love for Caleb (Atretes's baby) is endearing but she has the battle of convincing Atretes that she's trustworthy.
This book is Atretes's journey to finding Christ and believing he is worthy of forgiveness even though he has lived a life of sin. Rizpuh is one of the many people put in his life to plant the seed that he is a child of God. Rizpuh's life becomes the catalyst to what finally gets Atretes to believe in God. But like all Christians even AFTER you are a follower you still falter because no human is perfect. Atretes learns he must always be seeking the true God.
Audiobook source: Hoopla
Narrator: Richard Ferrone
Length: 20H 12M
June 18, 2009
This book started out strong and with great potential to be a blessing like the first two... it in the last third of the book it got too weird for me! I know that God can do anything so the events in the book are possible- it was just a little ridiculous. There were lost of amazing miracles that flowed with the book and didn't seem over the top- but then there was a reserection, and all of sudden two characters are amazed at there ability to suddenly speak German.
I did get a couple great things from the book though-
They are talking about being a poor witness, and the answer is "God takes the poor, foolish things of this world to bring glory to his name. Jesus wasn't born in the exhalted halls of kings, but in a stable. You know who the enemy is. Satan is a powerful adversary who know you almost as intimately as the Lord does. He attacks through the mind and flesh, trying to seperate you from Christ."
"That doesn't fill me with confidence. Who am I to fight Satan?"
"You don't. THe Lord is with you and goes before you into battle. You only have to stand firm in your faith."
I felt like this was sooo packed full of good stuff- first the part with her questioning her ability to be used by God, I worry about that sometimes, what if they ask a question I don't have an answer to? or what if I don't make sense or blah, blah, blah! This was a good reminder that if I'm willing and in tune with God's word- he'll take it and use it to his glory. If I just plant the seed- He'll provide the rain and the sunshine!
Then it was a scary reminder that Satan knows us and knows just what to do to pull us down- we have to be on constant gaurd!
Finally I liked the part about us not having to fight satan! We just have to stand firm in our faith, and God will take care of him!
The next great section is talking about Gods great gift of salvation-
and they have the thought that Salvation is a gift not something we can earn or appreciate fully. "Jesus left his heavenly throne, his glory and honor, took the form of a humble man. He suffered and died for me. And what do I do? More often then not, I take my salvation for granted. I fill my mind with unimportant things.Oh, that God would put it in my head and hear what he has done for me every morning as I awaken."
That last sentence- WOW! That is my prayer as well- I'm going to start asking for that to be the first thought in my head in the morning each morning. What a blessing that would be to have my first thought of the day be about my Saviour!
I did get a couple great things from the book though-
They are talking about being a poor witness, and the answer is "God takes the poor, foolish things of this world to bring glory to his name. Jesus wasn't born in the exhalted halls of kings, but in a stable. You know who the enemy is. Satan is a powerful adversary who know you almost as intimately as the Lord does. He attacks through the mind and flesh, trying to seperate you from Christ."
"That doesn't fill me with confidence. Who am I to fight Satan?"
"You don't. THe Lord is with you and goes before you into battle. You only have to stand firm in your faith."
I felt like this was sooo packed full of good stuff- first the part with her questioning her ability to be used by God, I worry about that sometimes, what if they ask a question I don't have an answer to? or what if I don't make sense or blah, blah, blah! This was a good reminder that if I'm willing and in tune with God's word- he'll take it and use it to his glory. If I just plant the seed- He'll provide the rain and the sunshine!
Then it was a scary reminder that Satan knows us and knows just what to do to pull us down- we have to be on constant gaurd!
Finally I liked the part about us not having to fight satan! We just have to stand firm in our faith, and God will take care of him!
The next great section is talking about Gods great gift of salvation-
and they have the thought that Salvation is a gift not something we can earn or appreciate fully. "Jesus left his heavenly throne, his glory and honor, took the form of a humble man. He suffered and died for me. And what do I do? More often then not, I take my salvation for granted. I fill my mind with unimportant things.Oh, that God would put it in my head and hear what he has done for me every morning as I awaken."
That last sentence- WOW! That is my prayer as well- I'm going to start asking for that to be the first thought in my head in the morning each morning. What a blessing that would be to have my first thought of the day be about my Saviour!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 6, 2012
It was awful--a 300-page, pressure-cookery romance novel. This book also had the most problematic theology of the trilogy, and an unsatisfying ending.
Let me just pick one big problem with this book. It's about a Christian woman falling in love with a very unsaved man (as are the previous two books in the series). Outside fiction, this is known as "dating evangelism" and it is madness. Apart from anything else, how can a woman respect a man who she's leading spiritually?
I mean no disrespect to Mrs Rivers as I know some of her books have been useful to some of my friends. I hear good things about "Redeeming Love", for instance. But this one was a bit of a dud and I will not be reading any more of her books while I'm a spinster.
Let me just pick one big problem with this book. It's about a Christian woman falling in love with a very unsaved man (as are the previous two books in the series). Outside fiction, this is known as "dating evangelism" and it is madness. Apart from anything else, how can a woman respect a man who she's leading spiritually?
I mean no disrespect to Mrs Rivers as I know some of her books have been useful to some of my friends. I hear good things about "Redeeming Love", for instance. But this one was a bit of a dud and I will not be reading any more of her books while I'm a spinster.
February 2, 2011
The Mark of the Lion Trilogy are some of my favorite books. They were excellent, and dare I go as far as to say they were even life-changing? I realize these books are fiction, however, I believe that they must be somewhat representative of what life may have been like centuries ago, shortly after the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Realizing what the early Christians risked to follow Him shows how strong their faith was...in comparison with my easy life in a country where I am allowed to worship as I please without the fear of persecution. And, the parallels between ancient Rome as described in this book, and modern day America are striking.
I gave this book, the third in the trilogy, 4 stars while I gave the first two books the full five stars. This book was also great and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it, however I knocked it down a star because I felt like there were a few parts that were just "too much" for me in terms of believability. I think that everyone should take the time (and it won't take much because you won't want to put these down) to read all three of these books. They are sure to be classics in Christian literature.
I gave this book, the third in the trilogy, 4 stars while I gave the first two books the full five stars. This book was also great and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it, however I knocked it down a star because I felt like there were a few parts that were just "too much" for me in terms of believability. I think that everyone should take the time (and it won't take much because you won't want to put these down) to read all three of these books. They are sure to be classics in Christian literature.
December 30, 2014
What can I say about this book. It was so wonderful, yet I felt so sad when I finished it. This amazing trilogy was over .
I loved Rizpah; what an inspiring character. I loved Theophilus. I loved Atretes, but I was a little disappointed at how he kind of just 'forgot' about the Lord, and went back into the way he had been. I absolutely abhorred Anomia. She was worse than Julia! Overall, such a wonderfully inspiring and amazing book. Looking back on the series, I have to say that the first was my favorite. I love Hadassah! :)
I loved Rizpah; what an inspiring character. I loved Theophilus. I loved Atretes, but I was a little disappointed at how he kind of just 'forgot' about the Lord, and went back into the way he had been. I absolutely abhorred Anomia. She was worse than Julia! Overall, such a wonderfully inspiring and amazing book. Looking back on the series, I have to say that the first was my favorite. I love Hadassah! :)
September 16, 2016
Didn't want this series to end and put the book down after the last page with a sigh of satisfaction and regret. Satisfaction at a lovely ending to the three book series and a sigh of regret that the journey was ended.
June 6, 2017
Izvrsno zaokružena trilogija, svaka čast!
October 27, 2020
Oh my. A few weeks later and I successfully finished the whole trilogy. It's a little sad to see all of these characters go, but I am honestly ready to read some different genres now hah. So...REVIEW:
It was okay. I did like it, but there's always some things that I'd like to change about Francine's book. I loved Ripzah's character. I like that she's a lot different from Hadassah because she had way more faults and struggles, and was hilarious when she got mad at Atretes. The one thing I got a little annoyed about these books was that the man was the one who was sinning. I know - usually people would be like, yay! Female power! Men are weak! But, that's the last thing I wanted. I was hoping that eventually, there would be a Christian man as the main character, perhaps changing a woman's faith. I mean, I'm glad that most of the women were Christian, but it would've been nice to have a variety and balance of stories and characters.
Also, the main male characters in the trilogy - both Marcus and Atretes - were incredibly masculine. It was annoying. They were angry and abusive and couldn't control themselves around women. If someone were to ask me what my favorite male character of the series was, I would say Theophilus or Alexander (which is kind of sad because they were side characters but still). Those men...gah. Respectful, determined, and MUCH more calmer. I guess both Ripzah and Hadassah like those "passionate and really out there" types of men...but for me? Absolutely not. The epilogue did help a bit - we got to see a gentle Atretes and that made his character better for me. I forgive you, Atretes. I have a major dislike for you, but it's okay. You became relatively normal.
Anywhooo I know I criticize these books a lot, but I promise you, it is a lifechanging read! It's frustrating in a good way, because now I always think about the books and wonder how I could've written it. They're also SO LONG so you have books to read for a long period of time. Hehe. I seriously did learn a lot with these books about how to use my Christian faith in my daily life. Though the characters were on extremes in the scale, whether they were simply pure or simply sinful, I can take the good parts on both sides and relate it to my own life. Overall, I'm still glad I was able to read these books and if any of you end up reading it, I'd love to discuss them with you!
It was okay. I did like it, but there's always some things that I'd like to change about Francine's book. I loved Ripzah's character. I like that she's a lot different from Hadassah because she had way more faults and struggles, and was hilarious when she got mad at Atretes. The one thing I got a little annoyed about these books was that the man was the one who was sinning. I know - usually people would be like, yay! Female power! Men are weak! But, that's the last thing I wanted. I was hoping that eventually, there would be a Christian man as the main character, perhaps changing a woman's faith. I mean, I'm glad that most of the women were Christian, but it would've been nice to have a variety and balance of stories and characters.
Also, the main male characters in the trilogy - both Marcus and Atretes - were incredibly masculine. It was annoying. They were angry and abusive and couldn't control themselves around women. If someone were to ask me what my favorite male character of the series was, I would say Theophilus or Alexander (which is kind of sad because they were side characters but still). Those men...gah. Respectful, determined, and MUCH more calmer. I guess both Ripzah and Hadassah like those "passionate and really out there" types of men...but for me? Absolutely not. The epilogue did help a bit - we got to see a gentle Atretes and that made his character better for me. I forgive you, Atretes. I have a major dislike for you, but it's okay. You became relatively normal.
Anywhooo I know I criticize these books a lot, but I promise you, it is a lifechanging read! It's frustrating in a good way, because now I always think about the books and wonder how I could've written it. They're also SO LONG so you have books to read for a long period of time. Hehe. I seriously did learn a lot with these books about how to use my Christian faith in my daily life. Though the characters were on extremes in the scale, whether they were simply pure or simply sinful, I can take the good parts on both sides and relate it to my own life. Overall, I'm still glad I was able to read these books and if any of you end up reading it, I'd love to discuss them with you!
April 30, 2017
3.5 stars
First 75% of book = 5 stars; last 25%=2 stars
Loved this book up until the last part when Rizpah was betrayed by her husband. Frustrating all the way around how this whole scene happened. To me, it overshadowed the ending. I found it hard to forgive Atretes so quickly...would have liked to see him make things 'right' with Rizpah before the book ended. My goodness, he left her for weeks on end without her baby and food! All because she was trying to keep HIM from sinning. Didn't like this turn of events on this story AT ALL. Wished Rivers didn't keep writing 'things like this' in this trilogy. The only book, of the three, that didn't frustrate me was book 2. It's frustrating enough to make me hesitant to recommend series even though I couldn't put these books down. The storyline just got frustrating...kind of how I feel about Maas' TOG series. Oh well.
I had hoped this book would have weaved in tidbits of Hadassah and Marcus' story. For example, when Atretes went back to Rome for him to discover that Hadassah didn't die. Maybe Atretes ending up using one of Marcus' ships to sail (since Marcus found God). Also, weaving in Julia's death and Atretes making peace with that for Caleb's sake would have been nice.
On a side note, this book gives a nice synopsis of the Old Testament. That's not an easy task but Rivers does it successfully. It's a good overview of the people, places, and why behind things.
Overall, I liked the series but the 'things like this' (see above, lol) kept me from loving it. There were lots of life lessons in this series that I appreciated and copied in my notes. I also like that these books made me think...'Am I forgiving? Can I move on quickly when wronged? Would I help someone who tried to kill me?' (Ummm, that's a tough one)...and many others. For that, I'm grateful. And, that's a testament to the fact that books DO impact/influence us. Thank you Ms. Rivers for that!
First 75% of book = 5 stars; last 25%=2 stars
Loved this book up until the last part when Rizpah was betrayed by her husband. Frustrating all the way around how this whole scene happened. To me, it overshadowed the ending. I found it hard to forgive Atretes so quickly...would have liked to see him make things 'right' with Rizpah before the book ended. My goodness, he left her for weeks on end without her baby and food! All because she was trying to keep HIM from sinning. Didn't like this turn of events on this story AT ALL. Wished Rivers didn't keep writing 'things like this' in this trilogy. The only book, of the three, that didn't frustrate me was book 2. It's frustrating enough to make me hesitant to recommend series even though I couldn't put these books down. The storyline just got frustrating...kind of how I feel about Maas' TOG series. Oh well.
I had hoped this book would have weaved in tidbits of Hadassah and Marcus' story. For example, when Atretes went back to Rome for him to discover that Hadassah didn't die. Maybe Atretes ending up using one of Marcus' ships to sail (since Marcus found God). Also, weaving in Julia's death and Atretes making peace with that for Caleb's sake would have been nice.
On a side note, this book gives a nice synopsis of the Old Testament. That's not an easy task but Rivers does it successfully. It's a good overview of the people, places, and why behind things.
Overall, I liked the series but the 'things like this' (see above, lol) kept me from loving it. There were lots of life lessons in this series that I appreciated and copied in my notes. I also like that these books made me think...'Am I forgiving? Can I move on quickly when wronged? Would I help someone who tried to kill me?' (Ummm, that's a tough one)...and many others. For that, I'm grateful. And, that's a testament to the fact that books DO impact/influence us. Thank you Ms. Rivers for that!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 8, 2022
this is my first ever DNF. That should tell y'all something.This book is rife with abuse and violence from the male main character and self-flagellation from the female main character when she stands up for herself and her child. I am sure Atretes will become a paragon of Christian virtue when he converts but every page is hard to read and I don't think I can make it that far. The behavior in this book supports missionary dating, the responsibility of a woman to save a fallen man, submission of women in the face of violence, entitlement over children from parental figures. Writing about these things is okay; writing reflects life and life can be horrible. But each of these elements is celebrated as Atretes being manly and wounded, and every horrible thing he does draws Rizpah more into love with him. No one should be suggesting in the slightest that women should put up with any of the behavior reflected in this book-- not from a Christian man or a non Christian man. I made it to Ch. 17.
July 2, 2012
This book captured my attention much more than what I had expected. Francine delivers very intense scenes & doesn't sugarcoat the message of the Bible. As always, you feel like you're in the shoes of the main characters drawing you into their battles & their triumphs. In my mind I questioned some of the supernatural things that were attributed to the Lord, and then I wondered why He wouldn't show His power in the face of darkness. We have been amazed at what God is doing in these days to open people's eyes to the truth instead of being overcome by the enemy, especially in the Middle East.
June 9, 2021
I have a lot of thoughts on this book. I will share a couple. I found in this series that it seems like the desirable male is abusive, verbally and/or physically. I felt like these were beauty and the beast type stories, only the male stays abusive and the female just doesn’t seem to care. I also felt the author may have crossed the line with sexual descriptions. The overall feeling I got from this book was that it was similar to a trashy romance novel.
January 15, 2026
Ummm...yikes. While I loved the first 2 books in the series, I nearly DNFed this one many times. I get that the time period and setting meant things were pretty dark and dirty, but there was still WAY too much sexual content. So many parts of this book didn't sit right with me. It was soooo long, and most of the content was either preaching that went on and on and on, scripture quotes, or again, all the sexual stuff. Plus the male MC (main character) is a terrible jerk, or a practically a "narcissist" if you want to use the term that's popular right now. And then the supposedly mature believer/ mentor type character condones the female MC marrying the male MC right after he gets saved, without waiting to see if he has a changed life. 😅 Which is a terrible idea because he doesn't change hardly at all until a long time later. And then there's all the miracles that don't work very well, and the plot that is...🤔
September 23, 2025
Wow my absolute favourite of the whole series. I love how the story played out. Atretes’ arc is so well done along with a host of other characters. Rizpah is so encouraging to read about her struggles and then victories nevertheless. And Theophilus is the best character by far. His father heart and amazingly deep character carried so much richness.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,128 reviews