A vivid and visceral portrayal of the most famous naval battle in history, focusing on the human cost of war, by a brilliant military historian
‘A gripping read, full of fascinating insights…deeply moving…Brilliant’ Adam Zamoyski
At about 1.15 in the afternoon of 21 October 1805, Vice Admiral Horatio Nelson was struck by a 15-millimetre French musket round fired from of the Redoutable, a distance of some 70 feet to HMS Victory’s quarter deck. It fractured his left shoulder, pierced his lung and emerged to sever the spine.
In this fresh and vibrant retelling of the battle of Trafalgar, Paul O’Keeffe traces the course of events both prior and subsequent to that fatal from 6.30 in the morning, as the British ships began their approach towards the enemy fleet, until the cessation of firing that followed the apocalyptic destruction of the French 74-gun Achille at 5.45 in the afternoon.
We also learn about the battle’s dramatic how a violent storm destroyed the surviving French and Spanish ships; how news of victory travelled and was celebrated in London; how Nelson’s body was brought home and given a spectacular funeral.
Paying meticulous attention to little explored details, O’Keeffe gives us a front-row view of events. Gripping and immersive, this is a unique account of Trafalgar for a new generation of readers.
‘If you think you know it all about the battle of Trafalgar, think again. Paul O’Keeffe’s new book is full of fascinating information … His book is a must’ Nicholas Best, author of Trafalgar
I went into Trafalgar: Battle and Aftermath really wanting to enjoy it the subject is one of the most dramatic and defining naval battles in history.
But I found it a surprisingly cumbersome read.
It lacks a clear narrative thread, jumping between moments without building any real sense of momentum or cohesion. At times it feels less like a structured book and more like a series of loosely connected fragments or research notes.
There are undoubtedly interesting details throughout, but they’re buried within a disjointed flow that makes it hard to stay engaged. You’re constantly waiting for the story to take shape and it never quite does.
Having seen some of the very positive reviews, I have to admit I find them difficult to reconcile with the reading experience. For me, this wasn’t just dense it was unnecessarily hard work.
A real shame, because the subject matter deserves far more compelling storytelling.
Although this book is a useful addition to the Trafalgar bibliography, it has at least a couple of serious errors. On page 114 Collingwood is described to be a Rear Admiral when he was a Vice Admiral. But it is on page 243 that an inexplicable error is made: The death of General Wolfe is given as occurring during the American War of Independence, when Wolfe was in fact killed in 1759 during the siege of Quebec in the seven-years war. Also Benjamin West's painting of that event was completed in 1770 and not 1771. Given the thanks accorded by the author to his proof reader, these are 'surprising' mistakes..