The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins

by Melanie Dickerson

My only remaining marriage prospects were the head gardener, the vicar, and the steward. But how could I marry any of them when I was in love . . . with Lord Brookhaven?

Charlotte Robbins accepts a governess position for the Earl of Brookhaven's siblings despite rumors of the earl's severe and mysterious demeanor. As a lowly governess, Charlotte entertains thoughts of possible romance with an eligible servant until she does fall unexpectedly in love--with the pensive earl himself.

But love does not mean a match is possible, and the earl's friends warn Charlotte that if he were to fall for her, it would ruin him. Just as Charlotte resigns herself to the impossibility of her feelings, she receives news that she has inherited a fortune from a long-lost relative. Now thrust into London high society, Charlotte grapples with suitors vying for her attention, but her heart still belongs to the Earl of Brookhaven. As secrets unfold, she's no longer certain if her newfound fortune is a blessing--or if it is the very thing that threatens the love she's always longed for.

"A unique story with a richly tapestried setting that makes this Regency novel sparkle to the very end."--Laura Frantz, Christy Award-winning author of The Indigo Heiress

In this captivating rags-to-riches, upstairs/downstairs historical Regency romance for fans of Jane Eyre, New York Times bestselling author Melanie Dickerson weaves a stunning tale of a mysterious fortune, forbidden love, and a brooding love interest.

Genres: Romance, Historical Fiction, Regency, Historical, Historical Romance, Fiction, Christian

320 pages, Paperback

First published March 1, 2026

About the author

Melanie Dickerson is the New York Times bestselling author of happily-ever-after romance. She believes in love, laughter, afternoon tea, and the power of story.

With a million books sold and numerous awards, including two Christy Awards, two Golden Quills, a National Readers Choice Award, Christian Retailing’s Best, and Book Buyers’ Best Awards, her books have hit #1 in her category on the New York Times bestseller list.

When she’s not writing, Melanie can be found watching Pride and Prejudice for the hundredth time, cozying up to her handsome hero husband, or shaking her head at her slightly unhinged Jack Russell terrier. She lives in the beautiful foothills of the Appalachians near Huntsville, Alabama.

Reviews

[Kay’s Library · Rating 3 out of 5]

✨Spoiler-free Review✨
The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins by Melanie Dickerson
⭐️⭐️⭐️

This book was such a sweet read ❤️

The story follows Charlotte Robbins, a humble governess who accepts a position at the estate of the broody and misunderstood Earl of Brookhaven, where she is tasked with teaching his younger siblings. As expected in a Regency romance, feelings begin to grow - but their difference in social standing creates a barrier that feels impossible to overcome. Everything shifts when Charlotte unexpectedly becomes the heir to a large fortune from an uncle she’s never met!💰

One of my favorite parts of this book was the Christian element woven throughout the story. Charlotte openly speaks about her faith, references Scripture, and seeks to honor God in her actions - and she does so with such grace. ✝️ It felt natural and encouraging rather than forced, which I really appreciated. Her character was easy to admire in that regard. 🥹

The romance itself was also very sweet. I loved the dynamic between Charlotte and the earl - he has that classic broody exterior, but as you get to know him, you see the depth of his character and heart. 🥰

I also really enjoy the side characters, especially the children - they added a lot of charm to the story! ❤️❤️❤️

That said, there were a few areas where the story didn’t fully land for me. 😅 The humor wasn’t quite as strong as I personally enjoy in Regency novels, and I found myself wishing there was more banter between the main characters. The story also started off really strong but became increasingly repetitive as it went on, both in plot and character development…🥲

My biggest struggle was with the pacing toward the end. After so much buildup of pining, tension, and emotional conflict - the resolution felt very rushed. Everything seemed to wrap up a bit too quickly, and I just wanted more time in those final moments!!!! 😩

Overall, I have mixed feelings. I truly enjoyed my time reading this book and LOVED the authors prose - it was cozy, faith-filled, and heartfelt - but it didn’t quite reach the level of a new favorite for me.🙁

⚠️Content Warnings
- Homelessness
- Injured Children

•••
I received a complimentary ARC of this book from the publisher & NetGalley - all thoughts are my own.

[Jacquelyn 💐 {This Rapunzel Reads} [Jesus Christ, my Living Hope] · Rating 4 out of 5]

Melanie Dickerson is an auto buy author for me and I’ve been so excited to read this one ever since I heard that it was coming out! I have really missed her writing and stories! The cover is just stunning! First, it wasn’t as good as her other regency books. I highly recommend that trilogy. Charlotte was a good character. She did annoying with how much she cried like over everything. I liked William better than I liked her at times. Although I wish he would’ve just told her that he loved her like what is taking so long? I thought Charlotte and William were good together and I liked them better in the first half than in the second in some ways. The storyline was kind of like a lot of other regency romances I have read before, but that didn’t really bother me too much. A couple things I didn’t like…there was a comment about following your heart and as Christian, we are to follow God and not our hearts. The faith content in here was light until towards the end. I didn’t care for some of the descriptions of William’s chest when Charlotte would stare at him…it was unnecessary. Overall, it could have been better, but I enjoyed it. I look forward to her next regency romance in August!

[Emily Waits (emilylovesreading_) · Rating 5 out of 5]

(I received a complimentary copy of this title from the author. All opinions expressed are my own.)

This was the first book I’ve ever read by Melanie Dickerson, but it definitely won’t be my last! Melanie has another book coming out later this year, and I am already SO excited for it after reading this title.

“The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins” is a clean/kisses only Regency romance with light faith themes. I truly enjoyed this title so much!

Read “The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins” for:

-1814 England
-Regency Romance
-No-spice
-Governess + Earl
-Christian faith themes
-Rags to Riches

I highly recommend this title!

[Moriah Chavis · Rating 4 out of 5]

I'm a huge fan of Melanie Dickerson's work, so I was very excited to learn about her new book! I am familiar with her work because of her fairytale retellings, so this one was a little different. It was once again historical fiction, but it had more of PRIDE AND PREJUDICE feel than fairytale. However, as a fan of P&P, I didn't mind. Lord Brookhaven was another version of Mr. Darcy, and I enjoyed the small glimpses of his POV. The story is mainly told through Charlotte Robbins's eyes, however.

The book was predictable, which isn't a bad thing! It was an easy, light read. I can't wait to read the next thing Melanie writes!

[Carrie Schmidt · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars

The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins by Melanie Dickerson was a delight to read! Charlotte Robbins may be an orphan who’s spent her entire life in at the same school, first as a student and then as a teacher, in one little English town, but she’s an avid reader and still dreams of her own happily-ever-after like the ones she’s read about. I loved this balance between Charlotte’s practical upbringing (and independent spirit) and her romanticism, an endearing dichotomy that made her even more relatable in my opinion. We see this as she leaves without much fuss from the only place she’s lived, the only friends she’s known, since the death of her parents and travels solo to Berkshire to start her new job as the governess to an earl… but also makes a mental list of who on the estate might be an eligible husband before she’s even arrived. To be honest, that made me giggle (because it reminded me of my romance-dreaming heart in college) and I knew right then that Charlotte and I were going to be great friends.

William – the earl I just mentioned – is the typical brooding earl in some respects when we first meet him. Yet he’s not arrogant or detached, which put him in my good graces quite early on. The fact that he seems to genuinely respect Charlotte and values both her opinion and her company only added to his appeal, even if some of his decisions surprised me. He cares about his young half-siblings under Charlotte’s tutelage, and it’s a pleasure to watch him quietly fall in love with her, even if he drove me half-crazy by keeping those feelings to himself for so long. Ah but his friends are quick to remind us all that it is simply not done for an earl to marry a governess and just when it seems all hope is lost… a twist sends us hurtling into part two of the story and suddenly he and Charlotte are on much more level ground. I have to say that, even though I wasn’t expecting the particular circumstances regarding Charlotte’s change of fortune, I loved seeing the growth and challenges it brings to both sides of her character – the practical and the romantic. I also enjoyed exploring the question (with myself, since I’m a solo reader lol) of whether she and William would have found a happily-ever-after much sooner (and perhaps with less angst) if things had stayed as they were.

Bottom Line: It was such a joy to be back in the pages of a Regency romance written by Melanie Dickerson, and The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins is a charming one filled with heart, gentle swoon, and just the right amount of surprises. Charlotte Robbins is such a refreshing heroine who feels wonderfully real, whose dreams of love paired with her determination to stand on her own make her a joy to follow through this story. And as a fellow reader who occasionally (ahem) let fictional romances set my expectations a little high, I found her dreams of a storybook HEA completely relatable. Especially as the Earl of Brookhaven’s quiet respect and growing affection add a gentle sweetness to their easy friendship and kindle those flames of hope in her heart. I loved the character growth that Dickerson developed in both Charlotte and William, and I smiled more than once as I read their story. If you love the Jane Eyre aesthetic (minus the crazy wife in the attic) and books by Julie Klassen, you’re definitely going to want to read The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins too!

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)

first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower

[Rachel Trout · Rating 3 out of 5]

Rags-to-Riches💰 Regency Romance

I love Melanie Dickerson, and have enjoyed reading her entire backlist in the last few years. I was really looking forward to TGFOMR, especially since it has been a long while since she released a new book. With that said, The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins didn't do it for me. (Which is sad because I actually really enjoyed Melanie's other regency romances! They were very well done!)

What worked:
-The MMC, Lord Brookhaven was very likeable and developed enough. I enjoyed his POV the most, and found his character very likable from the start. There were a few brief moments of his inner thoughts towards certain other characters sprinkled throughout the story that I found humorous. I wish we could have had more of those.
-There were 4 child characters in the book that I really enjoyed. I wish they had had a larger role in the plot. There was a big chunk of the story in the middle where they weren't mentioned, and I found myself wondering about them and wishing for more content about them.
-The beginning and ending 20ish percents were much more enjoyable to read than the 60 percent of the middle. The 2 main characters were interacting, and the story was moving.

What didn't work:
-FIRST PERSON POV. It *kills* me that some authors that I've really enjoyed before are feeling pressure (likely from their publishers) to write in first person POV when that's just not their thing. This story was written in dual POV with the FMC told in first person and making up probably 75% of the story. It was several chapters in when we got Lord Brookhaven's POV which was told from third person, and it just worked better. The FMC came off naive and overly self centered (but in a pious, somewhat annoying way) because her POV was a LOT of her inner thoughts and feelings as well as bits of dialogue that were too lengthy and uninteresting. It would have been better to have her experiences communicated more through her POV. (For example, I hardly had a mental picture of any setting, and the characters' appearances were not described in any memorable detail. What does Miss Robbins even look like? I'm not sure we really know.)
-For being a romance, the romance between the two main characters just wasn't happening. There was no tension, yearning, or much spark simply because of the plot itself. When they are together in the story, it works well, but there was just too much else going on.

Overall, the storyline and the first person POV just did not work for me. With that said, Melanie Dickerson will continue to be an auto-read author for me and one that I will recommend to others. I hope Bethany House will give her some better editors and more creative control in the future because she is a good storyteller.

*Thank you to Bethany House and Melanie Dickerson for this ARC of The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins. I am very grateful for the opportunity to review this title. The opinions expressed above are completely my own.

[Chloe · Rating 4 out of 5]

⭐️4.50

Immediately drawn in by the beautiful cover, I was so ready to dive into Melanie Dickerson’s new Regency story. I’ve been a fan of her works for years now, and she is an automatic read for me. I was so pleased to receive the paperback to read!

Miss Charlotte Robbins was in every way a respectable, charming, and admirable young woman. Her love interest, the Earl of Brookhaven, is the perfect companion—spoiling all other men Miss Robbins meets. I loved how their friendship blossomed through like-minded conversation and perspectives on the world around them. Her gaining a mysterious fortune adds a new dimension to the already enthralling story and makes you wonder how their budding romance will weather the storms of brutal high society.

I loved the way Lady Derringer, the Earl’s aunt, reminded me of Lady Catherine and DeBourg in Pride and Prejudice with their all-knowing interference, BUT, this Down-wager Duchess worked for the advantage of the couple, which was a delight to witness. Even better, the Earl was a Darcy-coded MMC, with his broody behavior, insecurity of his feelings for Charlotte, and the fact that he is quite the eligible bachelor able to do much good with the property and other assets he owns is just the cherry on top.

I would have liked for William, the Earl, to have had a slightly faster “awakening”, if you will, of recognizing that Charlotte is 100% the complete opposite of his ex-fiancée. Maybe I’m just impatient, but I do feel like towards the end the pacing became a little slow, losing the build up for the climax of the story. And after the big plot twist is revealed to Charlotte, I wish we had seen more of the direct impact it had on high society and those around her.

However, this was a delightful and engaging Regency story, full of restrictive societal expectations and pressures, plot twists to keep you in proper suspense, a sweet, no-spice romance with notes of Pride and Prejudice, and it will leave you with a smile on your face when you come to the end. Sound like your cup of tea? Pick up this book now!!

[Melissa (christianbooksandcoffee) · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was an enjoyable read! I really liked Charlotte’s character and Lord Brookhaven’s character. Their first meeting was very sweet and I loved their interactions. This book has a part one and a part two. I really loved the first part. It was great with her being the governess and the children being involved in the story. Part two I didn’t like as much, it kind of felt like a different story. The main characters didn’t interact like they did in the first part. I would have liked to see more romance between them in the second part. I loved Charlotte’s love of children even taking in two orphans. And I loved that Lord Brookhaven shared that love with her. I loved all the children in this book, they were so cute. I also liked Mrs Merryweather and Hattie. Good Christian content. Overall this was an enjoyable story and I recommend.
⭐️⭐️⭐️.75

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author and netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

[Audrey Colman · Rating 4 out of 5]

Did someone say a book with Jane Eyre vibes, and written by Melanie Dickerson!? Well, sign me up!

I was absolutely thrilled when Melanie asked me if I’d like an advanced copy, especially since we’d had some delightful discussions about Jane Eyre.

A governess story is always up my alley, and reading about Charlottes love for the Earl’s siblings, and then the orphans, hit me in the feels! The romance was perfection, but Charlotte’s love and care for the children was what stood out even more.

The instant connection between Charlotte and the Earl was perfectly Jane Eyre-like, and I really enjoyed every scene they had together. I would’ve loved it if he’d shared about his feelings sooner, and maybe divulged the secret earlier as well. But in the end, they got their HEA and that’s what matters most!

Thank you again, Melanie, for my copy!

[Courtney Pityer · Rating 5 out of 5]

I will say this newest regency romance novel was truly a wonderful story. There are some elements that do remind me of Jane Eyre so that was a very nice surprise to see weaved into there. The story itself was perfect and I found myself in love and intrigued by the characters.

We are introduced to Charlotte who has recently accepted a governess position for the younger siblings of a Lord Brookehaven. The Earl himself is a very mysterious man himself. Charlotte finds herself drawn to him but recoils because of her position in society.

However she soon finds that she is an Heiress to a large fortune. In a way the tables have turned for her. But with this fortune comes great responsibility and there are those with bad intentions lurking around the corner.

[Suzan · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a sweet Christian fiction read inspired by Jane Eyre. It’s set in Regency London and follows governess Charlotte Robbins and the brooding Earl of Brookhaven as they navigate class differences, mutual attraction, secrets, and guarded hearts.

When Charlotte unexpectedly inherits a fortune, she’s thrust into high society, where she struggles to find genuine relationships. I enjoyed watching her grow and mature while staying true to herself.

It’s a light, predictable but charming story—perfect if you’re in the mood for an easy, wholesome escape with a lovable heroine.

[Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls) · Rating 3 out of 5]

3 stars, personally ⭐️ Christian Fiction - Regency

About this book:

“My only remaining marriage prospects were the head gardener, the vicar, and the steward. But how could I marry any of them when I was in love . . . with Lord Brookhaven?
Charlotte Robbins accepts a governess position for the Earl of Brookhaven's siblings despite rumors of the earl's severe and mysterious demeanor. As a lowly governess, Charlotte entertains thoughts of possible romance with an eligible servant until she does fall unexpectedly in love--with the pensive earl himself.
But love does not mean a match is possible, and the earl's friends warn Charlotte that if he were to fall for her, it would ruin him. Just as Charlotte resigns herself to the impossibility of her feelings, she receives news that she has inherited a fortune from a long-lost relative. Now thrust into London high society, Charlotte grapples with suitors vying for her attention, but her heart still belongs to the Earl of Brookhaven. As secrets unfold, she's no longer certain if her newfound fortune is a blessing--or if it is the very thing that threatens the love she's always longed for.”


Series: Unclear if it is part of a connecting series or not.


Spiritual Content- Scriptures are mentioned, referenced, remembered, & quoted; Prayers & Thanking God; Talks about God & His will; 'H’s are not capital when referring to God; Church going; Lord Brookhaven asks if Charlotte was taught to fear God and her sins being found out, but Charlotte responds that she was taught to fear God but because of reading the Bible for herself views it as more of a reverence (Lord Brookhaven asks if she uses her own sense to understand the Bible and Charlotte says she believes Scripture is true and helpful and likes to draw her “own conclusions about what it means”; This is a reference to men in this time believing that clergymen should explain the Bible to women, but Lord Brookhaven says he respects it); Charlotte imagines marrying a certain clergyman who think that his work is more important to him than her and is upset by the thought; Charlotte comments at the end that she can “literally feel God’s love” more after knowing what it’s like to be “loved deeply and well" (by a man); Mentions of God, Jesus, His mercy and grace, His creations, & His will; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of churches, church going, clergymen, sermons, & men having the church be their occupation; A few mentions of Providence; A few mentions of Christian charity; A couple mentions of events in the Bible; A couple mentions of being blessed; A couple mentions of a cross necklace; A couple mentions of sins; A mention of comparing one’s self to others not being a Christian thing to do; A mention of christenings; A mention of spiritual epiphanies; A mention of someone trying to “eke [their] way into heaven”; A mention of someone’s concerning spiritual state based off a suggestion he gave; A mention of “hypocritical clergy” a man met who were “not particularly pious, too lazy for good deeds, and seeking an easy life”;
*Note: Charlotte thinks “Dear Lord” once and it does not seem to be a prayer or talking to God; A woman mumbles “Lord bless me” when startled; A couple mentions of luck & being lucky.


Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘damnable’ (used as an adjective to describe a strongly disliked man), a ‘blast’, and three ‘stupid’; A couple mentions of curses (said, not written); Some eye rolling & sarcasm; A lie (by Charlotte, to get out of an awkward situation); Charlotte drinks watered-down wine at a dinner party; *Spoilers* About half-way, William blackmails a shady solicitor to say Charlotte was left a large sum of money an estranged uncle in order for her to be able to do anything she wants and to accepted into society; Towards the end, the solicitor tries to con the money out of Charlotte for himself, but William stops it from happening and the truth about the money is revealed to Charlotte *End of Spoilers*; William wishes to choke a man for his actions (but does not); William recalls feeling the “desire to erase his own existence” after his broken engagement; Mentions of deaths, those near death, illnesses, & grief (including of parents, an uncle); Mentions of a carriage accident, a child being ran over by a carriage, injuries, an injured child, pain, someone fainting when seeing blood, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of criminals, thieves, stealing, ploys to steal from another (acting hurt or distracting their victims), & children being used for begging and pickpocketing by adults; Mentions of orphaned children living on the street & being used and mistreated by evil people; Mentions of arrests & prisons/jails; Mentions of bullies, bulling, fighting, & physical fights between children; Mentions of lies, lying, liars, & deceit/deception; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of alcohol, drinking, someone drinking often, drunks, & others getting tipsy/drunk; Mentions of smoking, tobacco, & pipes (seen and done on-page by Lord Brookhaven; Charlotte hopes that her future husband smokes a pipe deeming it perhaps the “most masculine thing in the world”); A few mentions of blackmail; A few mentions of threats; A few mentions of gambling; A few mentions of hatred; A few mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of an injured baby rabbit (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of children being beaten and punished at schools; A couple mentions of duels with pistols or swords; A mention of a woman dying in childbirth (to twins); A mention of a man abusing and trying to drag his daughter away (due to her withholding her wages from him); A mention of frostbite;
*Note: Charlotte is an orphan and feels alone in the world with no one to care for her (so she often has dreamed about falling in love, getting married, and having a family of her own); Charlotte is told about an injured young boy being screamed at and punished by his mother for embarrassing her in front of her friends (William); Side characters show prejudice to orphaned street children (including a woman speaks harshly about street children and says they will steal and attack others (calling them “vermin”, but Charlotte defends the children)); Mentions of orphaned children scarfing food as if it might disappear any moment and fearing that necessities can be withheld from them if they misbehaved or didn’t show gratitude; Mentions of classic authors, books, & fictional characters (Shakespeare, Burns, Wordsworth, Milton, Jonathan Swift, Thomas Gray, Jane Austen, Walter Scott); A couple mentions of it being expected for a titled man to not love his wife or children; A mention of a couple unable to have children of their own; A mention of a woman having no children that survived infancy; A mention of gypsies;


Sexual Content- Three hand kisses (one is barely-above-not-detailed), a fingers-to-lips touch, and three semi-detailed kisses; Wanting to kiss & Staring at lips (barely-above-not-detailed); Touches, Embraces, Dancing, Tingles/Shivers, Warmth, Nearness (up to semi-detailed); Wanting to embrace (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes, Winks, & Flirting; Noticing & Staring (including the hair on his chest a few times, barely-above-not-detailed); Flirting & Jealousy; Charlotte has a moment of concern about someone thinking that William is setting her up to be his paramour (which she would never agree to be and does not think that is his intent); William’s friends suggest setting Charlotte up in her own house (as his mistress) because no one will judge him for it as long as he is discreet, but William is appalled by their suggestion of ruining her and leading her to “a life of degradation and sin” (one friend says for him to “enjoy life a little” with her before he has to get married and produce an heir; William is upset at the friends for suggesting it and says Charlotte would not allow it; *Spoilers* His friends tell Charlotte that she must reject him if he confesses or it will ruin his standing in society *End of Spoilers*; As a note, one of these friends plans to have a career in the church); Charlotte enjoys a man flirting with her (thinking it makes her feel “alive and…pretty”) but knows he is after her fortune; A married woman invites William to her home and says she’s been lonely (he is shocked by her suggestion and leaves without a response to her comment); Mentions of married and unmarried people having paramours (including William’s parents having “numerous paramours”); Mentions of reputations & chaperones; Mentions of an engaged woman running off with another man; Mentions of love & there being little affection between some married couples; Mentions of flirting; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of “evil men” who prey on women; A few mentions of a man showing unwanted attention and smiling in a “predatory” way towards Charlotte; A few mentions of men’s chest hair; A couple mentions of married couples separating and having lovers; A couple mentions of an affair; A couple mentions of kisses; A mention of a man marrying a much younger woman; A mention of a lovesick man; A mention of someone of “questionable birth”; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Charlotte wishes to marry for love and will not settle for less; A friend of Charlotte tells her that her mother says that love comes after marriage which makes Charlotte wonder if that is right as she’s known that to be the case for some couples and others whose love died after originally being a love match; There are a few conversations and suggestions about doing what Charlotte’s heart tells her to do when faced with a proposal; Charlotte notes that she’s not willing to overlook a large age difference like other women who marry “someone old enough to be their grandfather”.

-Charlotte Robbins, age 25
-William/Lord Brookhaven
P.O.V. switches between them (Charlotte in 1st person, William in 3rd person)
Set in 1814 (Epilogue in 1815)
320 pages

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars

Charlotte is a unique character. She’s not the typical regency female main character. She’s a bit…overeager to fall in love, down to her list of potential husbands at her new position. She’s a dreamer, but also sensible. She has a love for life and a sunshine personality which added to the book’s springtime setting like a swirl of fresh air. She wears her heart on her sleeve and cries quite a bit, but it’s because of caring for others and her own dreams. I liked her and how she desired to be married and have a family of her own, but I wanted to tell her to seek God’s will for her life rather than focusing on her goal for her life. She reminded me a bit of myself as a teenager, so I think that’s why this element was more noticeable to me when I was reading. Charlotte has a desire to be married and fall in love which is wonderful, but I would be a bit concerned for a young preteen reading this book and developing (or highlighting) the longing for the future or looking for a husband around every corner. That said, as someone who was that way as a teenager, I probably would have loved this book and felt a kinship to Charlotte because of it.

While Charlotte falls quick for William, it didn’t feel like insta-love or attraction based only on physical appearances because they had some personal conversations where they shared their feelings on different topics, so that felt more believable to me. I didn’t personally love how she noticed and thought about his chest hair a few times—I feel like I’m as red as a tomato just typing those words—but other than that, they do not feel like they were overly admiring the other’s appearance. I wish there had been a little more descriptions used for Charlotte and William: It’s noted that they are both kind and good multiple times. It became a little repetitive and made me think that everyone else around them must have been either stuck-up snobs or awfully mean (neither which seems to be the fully case).

Because of her chapters being in first person and we get a lot about her feelings and emotions, it almost felt like a diary at times. This will probably be a pro or a con for some readers.

I didn’t love the conversations about doing what Charlotte’s heart tells her to do when regarding a potential marriage. I wish there had been more discussion about praying for the right path and trusting God rather than trusting her heart and what would please her. The only potential suitor who brings up about praying about her answer to his proposal wasn’t William, which was a bit disappointing. There’s a comment from Charlotte that marrying the man is all she needs to make her happy. These few technical parts aside, I did enjoy this book and Charlotte’s caring nature, especially towards the children she meets.


Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...



*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review.

[Noah Faith · Rating 5 out of 5]

The good fortune of Miss Robbins review

The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins is a clean, no spice, Christian fiction story inspired by Jane Eyre, set in regency London, following the lives of governess Miss Charlotte Robbins, and Lord Brookhaven as they battle with social classes. It's a great, clean read for young adults and up, I can highly recommend it!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I have been a huge fan of Melanie Dickerson for some time now and have greatly enjoyed every book I've read of hers (which is all of them XD).The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins is no exception! This book kept me turning each page in the best way possible, wanting to see what would happen next! The characters were sweet, real, lovable and in my opinion, very relatable! I've read both Melanie Dickerson's fantasy fairytale retellings as well as her regency series, and can honestly say I love them both equally. Her writing style is so wonderful and captivating; each new story sucks you in, whether we're in regency London or medieval Germany! The plotline for The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins was just as captivating and well written, with not too much drama to keep you stressing but enough angst to keep you invested in their lives! Miss Charlotte Robbins was sweet and relatable, and Lord Brookhaven was so endearing. I loved how he pursued her and viewed her as his equal, not caring about their differing social standing, and his care of his siblings was so sweet! Overall it was definitely a five star read, I loved the plot, related to the characters and felt as though I was there with them, entirely immersed in the story! I can't wait to read her next upcoming book, A Mismatch Made in London!


If you are new to this author and are looking for more great clean, no spice reads for yourself or your teens, here are some more wonderful stories from Melanie Dickerson!


✨ The Regency Spies of London is a three book series set in regency London again, following the lives of three different women thrust into situations, and entwined with mysteries needing to be solved with the help of a handsome gentleman.

✨ The Imperiled Young Widows is a four book see set in regency London. It can be read as a continuation with the regency spies of London series, as there are a couple characters whose names get mentioned in some of the books, but can also be read as a standalone series. Each book follows the lives of four young widows who now find their lives in danger with more mysteries to be solved!

✨The Hagenheim series is an eleven book fantasy series set in medieval Germany, with each book based off of a different fairytale. Sleeping Beauty, Beauty and The Beast, Cinderella, and Snow White are just a few of the Wonderful retellings in this series!

[Christian Shelves · Rating 3 out of 5]

If I were to boil down this book's plot into one premise, it would be that it reads as a social experiment. Although it would be intriguing to discover how people would respond in such conditions, I did feel that this social experiment came across as more of a case study rather than a story that I could fully immerse myself in. Despite this, I could appreciate that Miss Charlotte Robbins is a lovely character who demonstrates a deep devotion to caring for others, exemplifying the Christian virtues of compassion and selflessness. In facing a change in circumstances, it is refreshing that she remains committed to her values and convictions; would that we could all pass the tests we encounter with such resolve and grace.

However, it is disappointing how this all comes about in that she should never have had to be tested in the first place, even if that wasn't the sole intention. I love reading Regency romance, but this one felt a little too schemed with assumptions and misunderstandings that were wholly avoidable due to an unwillingness to act when required and constant interference that only reinforced existing behaviours that readers would have already been aware of. The romance (or lack thereof) felt like it ran in circles with the main male character dragging his heels and not having that strong a reason to do so, prolonging the story even further. Along with a noticeable absence of his siblings in the second half, there were instances that took me out of the book while reading, which slightly dampened my experience with it.

Saying that, these challenges may not affect other readers, and in which case, the book is still enjoyable and page-turning as I was curious to see how things would finally come to pass. The compassion for children in need is admirable and the book succeeds in raising the plight of those who are defenseless without the resources in place to care for them. While we may not all be called to take on this particular cause, it's a reminder for Christians to love mercy and act justly while walking humbly with the Lord. Overall, if character-driven stories are your cup of tea, Miss Robbins is a pretty aspirational character to meet, especially if viewing her story through the lens of her interactions with the children rather than her romance and time in the marriage market.

Review Link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...

Many thanks to Bethany House Publishers and LibraryThing for providing a complimentary copy of this book for review consideration.

[Debbie · Rating 3 out of 5]

"The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins" is a romance set in 1814 in England. Charlotte longs for some of the adventure found in the novels she reads, so she accepts a position as a governess in hopes of finding a man of equal status who will fall in love with her. Instead, she finds a friendship with the Earl, who enjoys talking with her due to her unconventional opinions. He's tired of society's expectations, but his friends see his preference for Charlotte and warn him that he can't possibly marry her unless she had a large fortune. Suddenly, she has 50,000 pounds....but the Earl doesn't follow up on his generosity. Poor Charlotte's also been warned away from the Earl, so she's left fending off fortune hunters while debating what to do with her future.

The main characters were likable, and I appreciated that the romance was based on shared interests, values, and friendship. However, nothing actually stood in the way of their marriage. They loved each other and neither cared about high society's opinion. But the Earl was once engaged to a woman who ran off with someone wealthier than him, so he decided (with no reason) that Charlotte would do the same so he refused to declare his love.

The storyline was rather predictable--even the Earl's aunt told him that his scheme was a bad one. And I know it's meant to be humorous, but Charlotte would have been taught dancing etiquette along with the actual movements. Surely she knew that she had the right to say "no" to invitations--she even overhears others doing so. And, strangely, no one in high society actually seemed to follow good manners as many invited themselves to events, for example. Some parts just didn't feel believable.

Charlotte wonders what God's will is for her life and how to use her fortune for good. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable, if somewhat predictable, romance.

I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.

[Sharon the Librarian · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5

An orphaned young lady who was fortunate enough to be raised and teach in a school for girls, desires to see more of the world. She accepts a position as governess for an earl's young wards, knowing that her prospects for marriage will likely come from other servants.

"The harvest always looks greater in another man's field."

She is not one to hold her tongue, regardless of what is 'proper' among society. She is honest and has many stimulating conversations with the earl. He was raised by cold and unfeeling parents, and though he does not want to be like them, does have a surly reputation. Their many conversations lead to feelings that she knows will lead to heartache, but she dreams of what a life with him would be like. But she is a governess and a relationship with her could lead to ruin.

"I like honesty. There is very little of it these days, as society makes coward out of men and women alike."

When she inherits a large sum from an "uncle" she was not aware she had, her life suddenly changes. Those who looked down on her because of her status are now admirers. She is uncertain whether they are sincere in their interest or simply interested in her money.

I love the Earl's Aunt, Lady Derringer, and her kindness to Charlotte. She sees and accepts her as she is. I love her confidence and that she knows her worth regardless of the circumstances of her birth and her station. I love her belief in love, and she would rather be alone than in a loveless marriage.

The frustration on both of their parts not knowing of the others feelings was..... frustrating. A simple conversation would have solved their angst long before. I did enjoy their mutual affection for those less fortunate and how it eventually is what beings them together.

This Christian Regency story will keep you up too late reading, make you smile and sigh, as well as audibly tell them to "JUST TELL HIM ALREADY!"

Thank you to NetGalley, Bethany House, and the author for an early copy of the book to read and enjoy.

[Darla · Rating 5 out of 5]

The moment when the Earl of Brookhaven (William) recommends two books to the new governess (Charlotte) stole my heart.

What books? Pride & Prejudice and Sense & Sensibility.😍

And this is a loose retelling of one of my favorite classics: Jane Eyre.

So, it is little wonder I have given this Regency read all the stars.🌟

Some additional notes on what made this one really sparkle for me:

📔That cover! With Lowndesbury House in the background and William holding Charlotte's hand. Swoon.💕

🙏Both William and Charlotte are striving to build their faith and bloom where they are planted. Woven throughout is a favorite verse of mine: For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them. ~ Eph. 2:10

🤣When a governess goes from $0 to $50,000 the suitors come out of the woodwork. Charlotte encounters some humorous situations as each man attempts to separate her from the herd for a one-on-one proposal.

👭Charlotte is originally hired to instruct the much younger twin siblings of Lord Brookhaven. Then in London she finds herself unable to disregard the needs of street urchins. What good is $50,000 pounds if you don't use it to help those around you?

🏏Pall mall - before it was a cigarette brand, it was a game like our modern croquet. Charlotte has had lots of practice and she shines. A fun addition to the plot!

It has been awhile since I read a Melanie Dickerson title and now I wonder why. This was a delightfully clean and engaging Regency romance. I am again a positive outlier. Getting in my boat to head off to the island.😎

Thank you to Bethany House and Edelweiss+ for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.

[Rebecca · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars
"If Miss Charlotte Robbins remains unattached, we would like to offer the position of governess to her . . . . "

Aspiring to better her future, Charlotte Robbins leaves the only home she has ever known, Mrs Southey's School for Young Ladies, to accept a governess position at Lowndesbury House, where an earl resides while raising his much younger siblings. Never expecting to form a friendship with a man far above her station, Charlotte has a difficult time understanding her strong attraction to Lord Brookhaven and his seeming fondness for her.

Believing herself to have been orphaned, Charlotte is astonished when it comes to her attention that she has inherited a large sum of money from an uncle whom she never knew existed. Suddenly thrust into London society with many choices and little knowledge of how to proceed, Charlotte wonders if her simple life as a governess had been a gift far more valuable than wealth.

In a "tale as old as time" sort of way this story meanders through the corridors of an upstairs-downstairs imagining with a well positioned twist that turns the entire story on its head. Things are not as they seem, leaving Charlotte to wonder if anyone will ever truly love her for who she is rather than who she is not.

I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers through Interviews and Reviews.

[Laura · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins by Melanie Dickerson is a rags-to-riches story that may appeal to fans of historical fiction.

The story follows Charlotte Robbins when she accepts a governess position for the Earl of Brookhaven’s siblings. She has dreams of falling in love with a fellow servant, but is surprised when she begins to have feelings for the Earl.

The Earl’s friends see that he is also showing signs that he is interested in her, but his friends warn Charlotte that a relationship between them would ruin him. But as luck would have it, Charlotte suddenly becomes an heiress, and the tables are turned.

For the most part, I enjoyed this story, but while fortune hunters come out of the woodwork in pursuit of Charlotte, the Earl never pursues her, even though she knows he is interested in her. This carried on for a long time, with Charlotte receiving multiple proposals, and, honestly, it bothered me to no end. But the ending made up for it. So while I found that I was getting frustrated with the Earl’s ridiculousness, I did enjoy the outcome of his rather crazy decisions.

If you enjoy historical romance, you will probably like The Good Fortune of Miss Robbins.

I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Bethany House Publishers via NetGalley, for my honest opinion.

[Susan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sweet rags to riches story of a young woman who unexpectedly inherits a fortune. Set against the atmospheric background of regency London, this story explores the superficial relationships of society. Will Charlotte change from the sweet, caring young woman to one who seeks the approval of the ton over her own sense of morality?

Ms. Charlotte Robbins is a young governess, recently out in the world. She quickly impresses her employer with her intelligence and fresh perspective, unsullied by society's shallow opinions and expectations. The Earl of Brookhaven is a brooding hero, whose past hurts hide behind an armor that makes him unwilling to open his heart to love.

I loved that we got a glimpse of Lord Brookhaven's POV every once in a while. It grounded the story, giving a little more depth to Charlotte's innocence and inexperience in society. While I liked her, it was refreshing to see her character grow and mature through her experience.

This is a light read, a delightful escape. While the plot is predictable, readers will love to root for the young heroine as she remains a breath of fresh air, looking for a real love that will look past her fortune and love her for herself.

****I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and Netgalley. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.

[geekoutonreading : Tiffany · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Falling in love with him was as inevitable as my next breath."

When Charlotte Robbins gets an opportunity to be the governess of Lord Brookhaven's younger siblings, she jumps at the chance. After being orphaned as a child, and spending her life at Mrs. Southy's School for Young Ladies, Miss Robbins is ready for adventure!

Once she accepts the position, her mind gets to daydreaming about finding a husband, but not just any husband, one that will truly and deeply love her.

Forming a bond with Lord Brookhaven, who himself deals with abandonment issues, will she be able to control her feelings for him, knowing the difference in social standing?

When she unexpectedly falls into an "inheritance", Charlotte's life changes - new social settings and social circles, new prospects for a husband, and new opportunities. But where does her heart actually lie? And with whom? Will she be able to find the unconditional love that she has been longing for her whole life?

This was my first book by Melanie Dickerson, and I enjoyed it immensely! This book was like a mix of Bridgerton and a Jane Austen novel, with a Christian undertone. Absolutely delightful!!

*Thank you to Uplit Reads, Bethany House Fiction, Melanie Dickerson, and Netgalley for a complimentary physical copy and ebook. All opinions expressed are my own.*

[Christine Barth · Rating 1 out of 5]

This review by librarian Christine Barth was first published in the Jan. 2026 issue of Library Journal.

Dickerson (The Peasant's Dream), known for her young adult fairy-tale retellings set in the fictional Hagenheim, has turned her attention to chaste Regency romances for adults in recent years. This novel features Charlotte Robbins, a well-educated orphan hired as a governess for the wealthy earl of Brookhaven. A chance encounter on the roof on her first night of employment cements an unlikely bond above Charlotte's station.
Hoping for a more likely match-perhaps the head gardener or the vicar-Charlotte cares for the earl's orphaned nieces and nephews until an unexpected windfall from a mysterious uncle comes her way. Thrust into London society, Charlotte has everything she has ever dreamed of, but she is not as happy as she anticipated. In addition, she must use great discernment regarding would-be suitors looking more at her newfound dowry than her good qualities.
VERDICT: This rags-to-riches tale will satisfy readers looking for a happily ever after. For more nuanced Regency narratives, check out Carolyn Miller's "Regency Brides" books or Erica Vetsch's "Serendipity & Secrets" series.

[Scott County Library System · Rating 3 out of 5]

This review by librarian Christine Barth was first published in the Jan. 2026 issue of Library Journal.

Dickerson (The Peasant's Dream), known for her young adult fairy-tale retellings set in the fictional Hagenheim, has turned her attention to chaste Regency romances for adults in recent years. This novel features Charlotte Robbins, a well-educated orphan hired as a governess for the wealthy earl of Brookhaven. A chance encounter on the roof on her first night of employment cements an unlikely bond above Charlotte's station.
Hoping for a more likely match-perhaps the head gardener or the vicar-Charlotte cares for the earl's orphaned nieces and nephews until an unexpected windfall from a mysterious uncle comes her way. Thrust into London society, Charlotte has everything she has ever dreamed of, but she is not as happy as she anticipated. In addition, she must use great discernment regarding would-be suitors looking more at her newfound dowry than her good qualities.
VERDICT: This rags-to-riches tale will satisfy readers looking for a happily ever after. For more nuanced Regency narratives, check out Carolyn Miller's "Regency Brides" books or Erica Vetsch's "Serendipity & Secrets" series.

[Katie Marie · Rating 4 out of 5]

Society deems lowly governess Charlotte Robbins beneath the man she is in love with. But when she inherits a mysterious fortune, will wealth increase her chances of finding a fairytale romance? Or is true love governed by far more than material possessions?

This book is a combination of the best elements of Jane Eyre, Pride and Prejudice, and Emma.
In all honesty, I went into it expecting it to be a very predictable regency romance that didn't excite me, but I was pleasantly surprised to find myself thoroughly enjoying this book by the end! The lovable characters and the twists and turns in the second half of the story reeled me in, and the writing was captivating. I also appreciated that this was a clean romance with some deeper themes regarding a person's worth compared to their wealth. I recommend it to readers who love wholesome, slow-burn romances with broody MMCs who can't voice their feelings to save their lives!

Special thanks to Bethany House and Melanie Dickerson for my early copy.

[Regency_Fan_ Michelle RegencyFanMichelleAndMore · Rating 3 out of 5]

I wanted to love this one. On paper, it had everything I usually adore—Regency setting, class tension, a governess heroine, forbidden affection, and a unique rags-to-riches twist. The premise felt perfectly suited to my tastes.

Charlotte’s unexpected inheritance adds an interesting dimension to the story, and I appreciated the fresh angle on the rags-to-riches trope. Watching her navigate a shift in status and identity had strong potential, and I admired the concept behind it.

Unfortunately, the romance itself never fully took hold for me. While the scenes between Charlotte and the Earl of Brookhaven work well when they are together, I didn’t feel the tension or yearning that typically anchors this type of love story. The emotional spark felt muted, and without that steady thread of longing, it was difficult to stay fully invested in their relationship.

There was also quite a bit happening around them, which sometimes overshadowed the central romance. Instead of heightening the stakes, the additional plot elements made the story feel more drawn out than emotionally compelling. As a result, I found myself admiring the structure of the story more than feeling connected to it.

This is one of those books where all the pieces are present and the concept is strong, but the emotional pull simply didn’t land for me the way I hoped it would.

I received a complimentary copy of this book and was under no obligation to leave a positive review.

[Cayla · Rating 5 out of 5]

Special Note: I received this book as an ARC through Library Thing in exchange for an honest review.

Over the years, I've read perhaps five or six books written by Melanie Dickerson. She does not disappoint. Her books are enjoyable. At first, I thought I was reading a new retelling of the classic, "Jane Eyre," but then I wasn't so sure. I do love the references to Jane Austen and "Pride and Prejudice." Miss Robbins and Lord Brookhaven are truly a match for each other. They seem to understand each other better than most people I know.

Miss Robbins learns a lot about people in this book. Many of the people she encounters place higher value on titles, lands, and money than family and friends. It's never enough for them. They all aim for higher ranks of upper nobility. She wants love, respect, and genuine friendship. Sadly, some of these characters are even willing to go to great lengths to get what they want.

I also like the cover art of the book. It fits the story well.

I highly recommend this book. I hope you love it as much as I do.

[Anna |This Curly Girl Reads| · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.5 ⭐️This was a sweet story💕 I liked both Charlotte and William (though I didn’t always agree with his choices). I read one review that said they didn’t care for the first person POV. I actually liked it alot. And though switching to 3rd person for William’s point of view was a little different, it really didn’t bother me.

Read this story if you enjoy:
📖 Rags to Riches/Cinderella Stories
📖 Regency Society
📖 Brooding MMC
📖 Grumpy/Sunshine
📖 Friends to More
📖 Gentle-paced stories

The end was a little abrupt for me. After so much waiting and waiting on the “climax”, I was sad to have it wrap up so quickly. I did like that there was a brief epilogue 🥰

Overall this was a light read, enjoyable read. I would definitely read the next in the series (and I hope these characters show up there too!)

Thank you, Melanie Dickerson and Netgalley for a free copy of this book! All these thoughts and opinions are my own.

Content: mentions of mistresses/setting someone up to be a mistress (no details, doesn’t actually happen)

[Christina Egan · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed this regency romance that takes place in England in 1814 in the English countryside as well as in London. Charlotte gets what seems to be her dream job working as a governess to two twins that are being raised by the Earl of Brookhaven. Charlotte is an orphan who grew up and then taught at Mrs. Southey’s School for Young Ladies- never having travelled from this home. She arrives as Lowndesbury House and is astounded by the grandeur of it only to find that the servants won’t speak to her and the only friend she finds is the Earl himself. They have an attraction but both know that a match or marriage is not possible between them. The Earl has other plans though…
I enjoyed the storyline as well as all of the details of life in high society in England during this time period as well as the slow burn no spice sweet romance.

Thank you to Uplit Reads, NetGalley, Bethany House, and Melanie Dickerson for an advance copy of this book to review.
I also loved the cover of this book- loved all of the detail of the English home of an Earl!

[Rae · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this sweet, faith-filled Regency romance. Charlotte is such a kind and strong heroine who knows her own mind. I loved seeing her life change from governess to heiress and the lessons she learnt as a result. Her relationship with the Earl felt genuine and full of quiet emotion — I truly felt for both of them as their motivations were noble.

It’s a gentle, hopeful story about love, faith, and finding your place in the world. Perfect for anyone who loves clean historical romance with heart. This is not part of a series but will have you wanting to read the rest of Melanie Dickerson's book.

I receive complimentary books from various sources, including NetGalley, authors, and others. I am not required to write a positive review, and I have not received any compensation for my thoughts.

[Randi Sampson · Rating 4 out of 5]

When it comes to Regency reads, the class differences and forbidden love seem like pretty common tropes... and understandably so, there's something that's always so intriguing about that. But there was something about this one that really felt unique... with the surprise inheritance giving an unexpected twist that kept things intriguing. Charlotte and Lord Brookhaven such a beautiful and natural chemistry between them that I couldn't help but enjoy. Beyond that, you could see that both of the characters had good hearts, making me root for their happily ever after all that much more. There were a lot of secrets to unravel in this sweet story, and I found myself unable to look away, curious to see how it would all play out. If you love Regency romance, this is one not to be missed!

**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.