Taking a deep dive into astrology, The Unraveling of Julia had a completely different feel from Scottoline’s last novel, What Happened to the Bennetts, which I absolutely loved. A quick, easy read packed full of supernatural elements and generational trauma, I easily connected with the protagonist even if I found some of the topics just a bit too out there and “woo woo” for my personal taste. That being said, the solid pacing, evocative descriptions, emotional depth, and compelling characters had me immersed in the pages from beginning to end. A deftly blended combo of mystery/thriller and women’s fiction with a side helping of the paranormal, it was a page-turner for sure.
All said and done, while it definitely wasn’t my favorite by Scottoline, I still had a blast racing through the pages. With dual mysteries, a sweet romance, and an unreliable narrator central to it all, Julia’s profound journey to discover herself delivered some well-executed twists, even if they were rather predictable at times. But the strong characterizations and vividly drawn setting were what drew me in and kept me hooked until the end. After all, I felt I was right there in Italy alongside of Julia. So despite the fact that the premise was a bit over-the-top, I still found that I couldn’t put it down thanks to its original plot and gothic atmosphere. Ultimately, I suggest giving it a try. I’m definitely glad that I did in the end. Rating of 3.5 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
Lately, Julia Pritzker is beginning to think if she’s cursed. She’s lost her adoptive parents, then her husband is murdered. When she realizes that her horoscope essentially foretold his death, she begins to spiral. She fears her fate is written in the stars, not held in her own hands.
Then a letter arrives out of the blue, informing her that she has inherited a Tuscan villa and vineyard – but her benefactor is a total stranger named Emilia Rossi. Julia has no information about her biological family, so she wonders if Rossi could be a blood relative. Bewildered, she heads to Tuscany for answers.
There, Julia is horrified to discover that Rossi was a paranoid recluse with delusions of grandeur, who believed herself to be a descendent of Duchess Caterina Sforza, a legendary Renaissance ruler. Julia is stunned by her uncanny resemblance to Rossi and even to Caterina, then she unearths eerie parallels between them, including an obsession with astrology.
Before long, Julia suspects she’s being followed, and strange things begin to happen. Not even a chance meeting with a handsome Florentine can ease her disturbed mind. When events turn deadly, she breaks with reality.
Julia’s harrowing struggle becomes a search for her identity, a race to save her sanity, and ultimately, a question of her very survival.
Thank you to Lisa Scottoline, Grand Central Publishing, and NetGalley for my complimentary digital and physical copies. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: July 15, 2025
Content warning: domestic abuse, murder, stalking, gaslighting, mental illness, grief, child abuse, car accident, confinement