All My Love, Always: A sweeping dual-timeline romantic saga about soulmates, secrets, and second chances.

by Sarah Arcuri

From Italian American storyteller and social media sensation Sarah Arcuri comes the highly anticipated follow-up to her beloved debut The Owner & The Wife—a sweeping novel about soulmates, second chances, and the secrets that can unravel everything.

It is the summer of 2011, and Scarlett Valenti is a woman fighting to hold her world together. Four years after the death of her husband, famed culinary star Francesco Valenti, she’s left with a crumbling legacy, mounting debt, and a restaurant on the verge of collapse. With the future of her family hanging in the balance, Scarlett makes the desperate sell their treasured Montauk beach house to save what matters most.

What’s meant to be one final summer in Montauk with her children takes an unexpected turn when Enzo Valenti—her late husband’s estranged brother and the one man Scarlett vowed to forget—arrives with a suitcase and a promise to help. Their reluctant reunion soon stirs up long-buried feelings, memories they can’t erase, and the secret Scarlett has spent nearly twenty years trying to hide.

As the family gathers under one roof and finds themselves drawn together by one last golden summer, new bonds are formed, love and loyalty collide, façades begin to crack, and Scarlett is forced to confront the question that has haunted her for if the truth comes out and her family discovers who she really is, will it destroy everything, and everyone, she loves?

Told in riveting then-and-now timelines, All My Love, Always is a sweeping saga of fate, forgiveness, and the fragile threads that hold a family together. From the windswept shores of Montauk to the glittering seas of the Amalfi Coast to the heart of Manhattan’s Little Italy, this is an unforgettable exploration of a woman torn between duty and desire, and how sometimes, losing everything is the only way to begin again.

403 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 20, 2025

Reviews

[Jessi · Rating 5 out of 5]

I cannot rave enough about this book. I absolutely loved the first one, and was so excited when this was announced. Sarah has a way of painting a clear picture with her words, that I felt I was transported right there along with the characters and experiencing everything they were. I felt like I was in the restaurant, on the beach, felt all of the feelings they were.....

There were laughs, some very sad moments and some moments that you could relate to and felt deep in your soul. I don't want to get into too many details because I don't want to spoil anything for anyone, but this is a story you can truly get lost in and forget everything happening around you. I was so said when this was over, but it was wrapped up in the most beautiful and perfect way.

I absolutely cannot wait to see what comes next from Sarah - she is top 2 of my favorite authors.

[Michele Fiore · Rating 5 out of 5]

“All My Love, Always” is a novel that explores love, grief, and the quiet resilience of the human heart. Set against the vivid backdrop of New York City and the windswept shores of Montauk, during two very different times.

At its core, the story is about a woman learning to navigate loss while rediscovering herself in places both familiar and foreign. The love story is heartfelt and raw—and the author’s writing style pulls you into every emotion. She has the power of weaving past and present together seamlessly.

This is a story that lingers. It’s not just about romance or sorrow—it’s about finding light and love in unexpected places. And learning to live again!
I never wanted this book to end.

[Stephanie Mcgoldrick · Rating 5 out of 5]

Best Sequel of all time

If you read The Owner and The Wife. This is the best sequel I’ve ever read. It is Twenty Five Years later and Scarlet is married with two children to Enzo’s brother. There marriage is falling apart and Enzo Scarlet’s lover from Twenty Five Years ago shows up.After finding his Brother hit her. Scarlet realizes her love for Enzo is still strong. But still will not leave
Francesco who now is a celebrity chef and cheating on her. Scarlet and Enzo wrote letters to each other years ago. And still kept in touch Scarlet has secrets that she has kept for years to herself and hoping no one will ever find out .

[Jordan Styles · Rating 5 out of 5]

Both All My Love Always and the first book in the series, The Owner & The Wife, were captivating from the very beginning. It felt like I was standing in the same room with the Valenti family as their story unfolded. The depth and complexity of their challenges perfectly conveyed, evoking such a variety of emotions throughout the books. I can’t wait for Sarah’s future publications - she has a knack for storytelling and creating a world you can dive into.

[Rachel Clavner · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love this book!!! While reading it I could really feel the words and could imagine what everything and everyone looked like. I looked forward to reading it every day/night. Now that I’m finished I just wait for the Next Book or maybe even a movie. Being an Italian American this book hit home, with family, with love, with wine.

[RICKI · Rating 5 out of 5]

THIS is the BEST!

I absolutely loved the first book, but this one right here is the BEST! When a book can make you cry and laugh out loud, it’s the real deal! Can’t wait for the next from Sarah!