Seal Cove has all the elements of an under water sea monster novel that I love. Unfortunately, despite having everything like its location in Nova Scotia and involving a lighthouse which I love, and the appearance of an unknown sea creature, everything else for me falls flat. I always hate to give a negative review, but in this case, if reviewing it means telling it like it is, then I'm at that point.
Seal Cove is about a large beached unknown creature that appears to be dead. It is taken back to a holding pool by the residents of this small town and kept wet to keep it from drying out and decaying before they can contact someone on the mainland about what they have. Out and out, the story is fairly straight forward, however there is a point where it goes wrong and that starts right at the beginning.
One of the biggest flaws for me is the fact that the author gave too much excessive dialog to his characters. While we all like to have character development, there are far too many characters and their banter between each other is very non-existing to the plot. I know what the author was trying to do, but having all his characters interacting completely with each others, the smallest piece of banters like one character ball busting the other and each other, is something I don't mind usually, but here its just too much.
I love to have at least one character I care about, two is even better. But in this story, there are so many characters to follow, that I think I ended up not caring about any of them at all, at least half way thru the book I realized it. It all became so tedious that I couldn't even tell who was talking any more.
The monster action thought there was a little of it, and I mean little, at the beginning, and in my head I was like "ok this is going to be good. How ever that wasn't the case. The real monster action didn't occur until more than half way thru the book at page 150. I wanted to like it so much, but I couldn't. I fond myself really speed reading and even skipping whole pages just to hurry to the end. Not something I usually do, but I was getting a little tired of it all. When the monster action did happen, I couldn't get into it. everything was played second fiddle like to the characters of the story. The character development worked the wrong way for me.
This book had a good chance to be something much better, but I can almost understand what the author was trying to do. The dialog all came off like it was a movie script, like it was written for certain characters to do all this bantering about with each other. It was just another major hurdle to getting to the end.
I love these stories but this one fell way to short of the mark. I usually try to refrain from reading reviews of books I have an interest in and don't want to be swayed. This time thought I did read the review for it, but as much as there were some people raving about the characters, there were more reviews that refuted it. I should have taken heed, but I didn't want to be swayed. Maybe I should have listened.
While this is not the best review I have ever given, it was needed. and after reading a few other reviews of people that had finished reading it, I thought long and hard about what I had read of them. and now I knew I was really on the mark about it.
It you like a lot of character banter with your main course of monsters, the this is the novel for you. But if not, then you might want to do a little more review reading just to make sure before ordering this book. It could have had a better editor that probably would have recommended that too much of one thing is not a good idea. Still, his idea for the story itself had merit.
on to the next book.