What do you think?
Rate this book
A Tale of Two Dukes
Discover the gorgeous and spicy new regency romance that is perfect for fans of Bridgerton, Lisa Kleypass and Eloisa James. 'I absolutely loved it. Georgian romance at it’s sensational best!' Susan Lewis
No one is more surprised than Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, when she receives an offer of marriage from a man she’s not seen in over a decade. An independent widow, close to thirty, with two rambunctious boys, Viola has no obvious reason to accept the new Lord Ventris’s proposal. And yet… within two weeks, Viola finds herself walking down the aisle towards a man she despises and has sworn she'll never kiss. But kisses are all that’s off nothing else.
Accustomed to living a secretive life on the outskirts of society, Richard Armstrong never expected to inherit a title, nor the significant property that comes with it. But now that he has, he’s determined to keep it within his bloodline, and for that he needs an heir. And so, he seeks out the striking widow of his cousin, the late Duke of Winterflood, and offers his hand.
While their passionate but turbulent union raises eyebrows among their family, and the ton at large, both Viola and Richard carry their own secret reasons for agreeing to marry.
But as they start their new life together, they will soon discover that the shocking secrets they’ve both been keeping cannot stay hidden forever. And the revelations, when they come, could turn both their worlds upside down.
No one is more surprised than Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, when she receives an offer of marriage from a man she’s not seen in over a decade. An independent widow, close to thirty, with two rambunctious boys, Viola has no obvious reason to accept the new Lord Ventris’s proposal. And yet… within two weeks, Viola finds herself walking down the aisle towards a man she despises and has sworn she'll never kiss. But kisses are all that’s off nothing else.
Accustomed to living a secretive life on the outskirts of society, Richard Armstrong never expected to inherit a title, nor the significant property that comes with it. But now that he has, he’s determined to keep it within his bloodline, and for that he needs an heir. And so, he seeks out the striking widow of his cousin, the late Duke of Winterflood, and offers his hand.
While their passionate but turbulent union raises eyebrows among their family, and the ton at large, both Viola and Richard carry their own secret reasons for agreeing to marry.
But as they start their new life together, they will soon discover that the shocking secrets they’ve both been keeping cannot stay hidden forever. And the revelations, when they come, could turn both their worlds upside down.
301 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 20, 2025
263 people are currently reading
334 people want to read
About the author
Emma Orchard
10 books88 followersEmma Orchard was born in Salford. She studied English Literature at the Universities of Edinburgh and York, before working behind the scenes in publishing and television for many years. Her first job was at Mills & Boon, where she met her husband in a classic enemies-to-lovers romance. She now lives in North London.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 127 reviews
Read
January 27, 2026An enjoyable Regency with an unusual premise. Viola is married at 17 to a much older man, a duke who needs an heir. Only, she's the third wife and he clearly can't father kids, so he emotionally neglects her to manipulate her into having an affair with his young cousin. (They find out about this and their eventual affair is carried out in full knowledge of the circs.) Eleven years later the old guy is dead, and the cousin (father of her twins) proposes.
I really liked a lot about this. Viola is a great heroine, a woman who has grown into herself over the years, a determined mother, but realistically dealing with others under the constraints of her life. Her stifling emotional situation is done really well, including the fact that a man doesn't have to be violent or sexually demanding or even actively unkind to be hideously abusive. The grotesque situation of women in marriage is brought across well. Richard is a charming and likeable hero, the bonking is hot and the kids are realistic.
I did feel that the conflict isn't, perhaps, worked out as strongly as it could be. Viola's reasons for resenting Richard aren't fully crystallised (like, if she *actually* believes he's become a terrible person in their time apart then she really should not be marrying him and exposing her kids to him) and I think it would have worked better wih a more interaction-rooted conflict. Plus the external threat wasn't quite built up enough in the end so it felt a bit floppy (an I'd have liked to see Richard go feral, lol). But that said, I read the whole thing in an evening with solid enjoyment, which was enhanced by solid historical grounding and absolutely impeccable editing. God that makes a delightful change. I will read more by Emma Orchard.
I really liked a lot about this. Viola is a great heroine, a woman who has grown into herself over the years, a determined mother, but realistically dealing with others under the constraints of her life. Her stifling emotional situation is done really well, including the fact that a man doesn't have to be violent or sexually demanding or even actively unkind to be hideously abusive. The grotesque situation of women in marriage is brought across well. Richard is a charming and likeable hero, the bonking is hot and the kids are realistic.
I did feel that the conflict isn't, perhaps, worked out as strongly as it could be. Viola's reasons for resenting Richard aren't fully crystallised (like, if she *actually* believes he's become a terrible person in their time apart then she really should not be marrying him and exposing her kids to him) and I think it would have worked better wih a more interaction-rooted conflict. Plus the external threat wasn't quite built up enough in the end so it felt a bit floppy (an I'd have liked to see Richard go feral, lol). But that said, I read the whole thing in an evening with solid enjoyment, which was enhanced by solid historical grounding and absolutely impeccable editing. God that makes a delightful change. I will read more by Emma Orchard.
October 1, 2025
3.5 stars
One Liner: Interesting and has its moments
Viola, the Duchess of Winterflood, is surprised to receive a marriage proposal from a man she hasn’t seen in over a decade. As an independent widow close to thirty with two boys (twins), she has no reason to accept the proposal. However, in two weeks, she walks down the aisle to marry Richard Armstrong.
Richard is used to living a secretive life on the outskirts of society and didn’t expect to inherit a title. But when he does, he needs an heir, and who better than Viola to be his wife?
As the duo starts their new life together, they realize it may not be easy to keep past secrets safe and wonder what the new revelations would do to their marriage.
The story comes in Viola and Richard’s third-person POVs.
My Thoughts:
I’ve read the author’s work before and rated it similarly, I think. The premise has merit, though the title makes sense only towards the end.
Once you start reading, you will guess most of the events, and your guess is likely to be correct (like mine was). Since it is a romance novel, that’s not an issue.
The book is structured a bit differently. The prologue deals with the ‘current’ and the next few chapters take us to the immediate past, which shows the events that led to the prologue. Then, we get back to ‘current’ again, only for the story to travel way back into the crucial past for more chapters, before returning to the ‘current’ timeline again. It’ll help to pay attention to the dates as they don’t appear often.
The dual POV is helpful, though we get more from the FMC’s perspective. It is easy to empathize with her, especially when we know the past events. It shows a glimpse of the life some women had to lead during those times.
The MMC is nice enough, though he could have had more depth. He certainly had the arc and ability for it. Same with the boys. They enhanced the narrative whenever they were around, even if it was just a few scenes.
A couple of side characters were also interesting, though they, too, remain limited to their role in the plot. That said, I’m still not sure why we got such a detailed backstory for certain characters we never meet again! Was it to show the dark side of the lives of the ton? It still could have been simplified.
There is some spice, a bit more in the first half than the second, which works for the plot. I felt like a certain twist wasn’t necessary, but I can see why it was done. Things get sorted well, so not an issue. We also get an epilogue!
To summarize, A Tale of Two Dukes is an interesting read, even if it doesn’t reach its full potential. The uneven pacing can be a bit of a bother, but the book is worth a read.
Thank you, NetGalley and Boldwood Books, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley #ATaleOfTwoDukes
One Liner: Interesting and has its moments
Viola, the Duchess of Winterflood, is surprised to receive a marriage proposal from a man she hasn’t seen in over a decade. As an independent widow close to thirty with two boys (twins), she has no reason to accept the proposal. However, in two weeks, she walks down the aisle to marry Richard Armstrong.
Richard is used to living a secretive life on the outskirts of society and didn’t expect to inherit a title. But when he does, he needs an heir, and who better than Viola to be his wife?
As the duo starts their new life together, they realize it may not be easy to keep past secrets safe and wonder what the new revelations would do to their marriage.
The story comes in Viola and Richard’s third-person POVs.
My Thoughts:
I’ve read the author’s work before and rated it similarly, I think. The premise has merit, though the title makes sense only towards the end.
Once you start reading, you will guess most of the events, and your guess is likely to be correct (like mine was). Since it is a romance novel, that’s not an issue.
The book is structured a bit differently. The prologue deals with the ‘current’ and the next few chapters take us to the immediate past, which shows the events that led to the prologue. Then, we get back to ‘current’ again, only for the story to travel way back into the crucial past for more chapters, before returning to the ‘current’ timeline again. It’ll help to pay attention to the dates as they don’t appear often.
The dual POV is helpful, though we get more from the FMC’s perspective. It is easy to empathize with her, especially when we know the past events. It shows a glimpse of the life some women had to lead during those times.
The MMC is nice enough, though he could have had more depth. He certainly had the arc and ability for it. Same with the boys. They enhanced the narrative whenever they were around, even if it was just a few scenes.
A couple of side characters were also interesting, though they, too, remain limited to their role in the plot. That said, I’m still not sure why we got such a detailed backstory for certain characters we never meet again! Was it to show the dark side of the lives of the ton? It still could have been simplified.
There is some spice, a bit more in the first half than the second, which works for the plot. I felt like a certain twist wasn’t necessary, but I can see why it was done. Things get sorted well, so not an issue. We also get an epilogue!
To summarize, A Tale of Two Dukes is an interesting read, even if it doesn’t reach its full potential. The uneven pacing can be a bit of a bother, but the book is worth a read.
Thank you, NetGalley and Boldwood Books, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley #ATaleOfTwoDukes
September 26, 2025
A tale of marriage, love and loss!
Viola Constantine married Edward, the Duke of Winterflood, a man older than her father. He wants an heir, she wants support for her sisters. The thing is the Duke is impotent.
So comes the time when seventeen years old Viola is entrenched on his estate, slowly going mad for something to do
Enter the Duke’s nephew, Richard whom Edward engineers towards cuckolding him to attain his desire for children at any price.
A breathtaking, steamy Georgian romance novel about a marriage of convenience, of anguish, of lies and manipulations, and of second chance romance.
A Boldwood ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Viola Constantine married Edward, the Duke of Winterflood, a man older than her father. He wants an heir, she wants support for her sisters. The thing is the Duke is impotent.
So comes the time when seventeen years old Viola is entrenched on his estate, slowly going mad for something to do
Enter the Duke’s nephew, Richard whom Edward engineers towards cuckolding him to attain his desire for children at any price.
A breathtaking, steamy Georgian romance novel about a marriage of convenience, of anguish, of lies and manipulations, and of second chance romance.
A Boldwood ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
September 7, 2025
Emma Orchard delivers a richly emotional and layered romance in A Tale of Two Dukes, blending a dual-timeline structure with characters who are both flawed and deeply human.
At its heart is Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, a widow navigating independence, reputation and motherhood. When Richard Armstrong, now the unexpected Lord Ventris, reenters her life with a marriage proposal, it feels less like a fresh start and more like an old wound reopening.
This is a character-driven story, and the dual timeline works beautifully. The first half takes readers back to when Viola was 18 and Richard was 21, and those chapters do the essential work of showing how their choices and vulnerabilities shaped them. The second half moves into the present, where old heartbreak reverberates in every sharp word, tender touch and impossible choice. That structure keeps the story taut and layered, while making even rash decisions feel rooted in something real.
Viola is a compelling heroine: practical, independent and fiercely protective of her sons. Richard, by contrast, is tortured and steadfast. His love for Viola remains unwavering, even as he carries guilt and longing. Their relationship crackles with both ferocity and tenderness. The intimacy between them feels real, enriched by their history. Some of the most poignant scenes ground the romance with sweetness and emotional depth.
Orchard’s prose is elegant and period-true, with rhythms that sometimes call Cecilia Grant to mind. She balances the darker emotional threads with playful touches, including the children’s devotion to their mother and the chaotic, believable texture of big family life.
The pace slows slightly during the travel and Ventris Castle chapters, but even those moments add to the fullness of Viola and Richard’s history. The final resolution is that much more satisfying because of it.
What emerges is a romance that is dark, emotional and deeply moving. Richard’s devotion, Viola’s struggle between practicality and vulnerability, and the weaving of past and present create a love story that lingers well beyond the last page.
At its heart is Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, a widow navigating independence, reputation and motherhood. When Richard Armstrong, now the unexpected Lord Ventris, reenters her life with a marriage proposal, it feels less like a fresh start and more like an old wound reopening.
This is a character-driven story, and the dual timeline works beautifully. The first half takes readers back to when Viola was 18 and Richard was 21, and those chapters do the essential work of showing how their choices and vulnerabilities shaped them. The second half moves into the present, where old heartbreak reverberates in every sharp word, tender touch and impossible choice. That structure keeps the story taut and layered, while making even rash decisions feel rooted in something real.
Viola is a compelling heroine: practical, independent and fiercely protective of her sons. Richard, by contrast, is tortured and steadfast. His love for Viola remains unwavering, even as he carries guilt and longing. Their relationship crackles with both ferocity and tenderness. The intimacy between them feels real, enriched by their history. Some of the most poignant scenes ground the romance with sweetness and emotional depth.
Orchard’s prose is elegant and period-true, with rhythms that sometimes call Cecilia Grant to mind. She balances the darker emotional threads with playful touches, including the children’s devotion to their mother and the chaotic, believable texture of big family life.
The pace slows slightly during the travel and Ventris Castle chapters, but even those moments add to the fullness of Viola and Richard’s history. The final resolution is that much more satisfying because of it.
What emerges is a romance that is dark, emotional and deeply moving. Richard’s devotion, Viola’s struggle between practicality and vulnerability, and the weaving of past and present create a love story that lingers well beyond the last page.
October 27, 2025
This was so much better than I expected, I feel I've lost touch with historical romance.
October 14, 2025
I love when a book has tropes I don't usually enjoy but I end up liking the book anyway. I'm not a big fan of second chance or dual timeline romances but this one worked for me. I appreciated that the characters are older and more mature, we see the consequences of deep loneliness and isolation when a young woman marries for wealth to help her family. I saw a lot of the plot points coming, I'm not sure if there were supposed to be twists, but I would have appreciated more from Richard's POV/backstory. One thing that really stood out to me and I wish was in more historicals was how women's fertility is treated like a commodity by the upper class but also the risks to their life and health they take on with each pregnancy. I recommend if you're looking for an equally sweet and steamy historical romance.
October 13, 2025
I enjoy the author’s writing; though, most of her books are 3 stars for me. I still love checking out her new books, and I was intrigued by the premise of this one. The book has two alternating timelines. One with Viola and Richard in the past as they meet and begin their clandestine romance. And then about a decade later after Viola is a widow. I liked the different timelines as it really showed us a clear picture of the desperate yearning love they had for each other in the past.
Everything was going so well until the third act conflict. Once Richard made his revelation to Viola, I couldn’t get invested in their relationship anymore. I lost major respect for him and felt his apology was insufficient considering he was willing to risk Viola’s life. I won’t say anymore as I don’t want to post spoilers. The rest of the story was a 4-star though.
Everything was going so well until the third act conflict. Once Richard made his revelation to Viola, I couldn’t get invested in their relationship anymore. I lost major respect for him and felt his apology was insufficient considering he was willing to risk Viola’s life. I won’t say anymore as I don’t want to post spoilers. The rest of the story was a 4-star though.
August 20, 2025
I received an ARC copy of this book on NetGalley.
This was an interesting contrast between first love and its evolution.
There was smut and it was appropriately written.
However there seemed a disconnect between the events in the prologue and later events in the book.
There just wasn’t enough conflict to warrant the wedding day reaction.
The different timelines was an interesting construct. But we seemed to be introduced to characters who could have been used further in the development of the story.
I have read other books by this author and have been very impressed.
Unfortunately this one missed the mark for me but I will give this author another chance.
This was an interesting contrast between first love and its evolution.
There was smut and it was appropriately written.
However there seemed a disconnect between the events in the prologue and later events in the book.
There just wasn’t enough conflict to warrant the wedding day reaction.
The different timelines was an interesting construct. But we seemed to be introduced to characters who could have been used further in the development of the story.
I have read other books by this author and have been very impressed.
Unfortunately this one missed the mark for me but I will give this author another chance.
December 11, 2025
3.5. Rated R
I was really enjoying this book, even if it was S L O W going.
🥱. The author has an amazing grip of the English language. She writes well overall.
At points it reminded me of Georgette Heyer.
There were twists and turns. Unexpected reveals. Liked it!
BUT ….. as I got closer to the end it was dragging sooo bad. I just wanted it to be over. I skipped a few pages to make that happen. The very long drawn out ending ruined it for me.
This was my first time reading this author. I may try one more…..
I was really enjoying this book, even if it was S L O W going.
🥱. The author has an amazing grip of the English language. She writes well overall.
At points it reminded me of Georgette Heyer.
There were twists and turns. Unexpected reveals. Liked it!
BUT ….. as I got closer to the end it was dragging sooo bad. I just wanted it to be over. I skipped a few pages to make that happen. The very long drawn out ending ruined it for me.
This was my first time reading this author. I may try one more…..
October 10, 2025
So good
Oh my gosh I can not believe what I just read. The fact that it was known ugh so good. I loved this regency romance so much. It's a very interesting story and I loved how everything ended up turning out.
Oh my gosh I can not believe what I just read. The fact that it was known ugh so good. I loved this regency romance so much. It's a very interesting story and I loved how everything ended up turning out.
August 22, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for sending me this book :)
The premise of this book intrigued me as I couldn’t say I’ve ever read anything like this. I’ve never read a historical romance, but I wanted to try out this new genre. Initially, I was a bit miffed at the start of the story as to what was going on, but as we progress through the story, we are taken on a journey into the backstory of this marriage to Duke Ventris. I enjoyed the way it gave us flashbacks, which were chapters-long and held a lovely romance story. However, when it came around to be the second time around, I started to get a bit impatient to get back to the present because I was beginning to feel a bit disconnected from the events occurring in the present, which did slightly hurt my rating.
Another thing I would love to recognise is the beautiful writing. There are books where the writing may be overly complex, take away from the story, or be so simple that it adds nothing. However, the writing in this book is highly immersive and helped me, as a newbie historical fiction reader, engage with the period it’s set in.
As for the main characters, I haven’t much to say about Viola other than I liked her. While I also enjoyed Richard, I feel his last revelation at the end of Viola was quite out of character. Not only was it a bit unnecessary given how much had already occurred in the story, but given Viola and Richard’s backstory, it didn’t seem plausible for him to do what he revealed himself to have done. It did not matter how the Orchard tried to justify it; I was unconvinced.
I would recommend this to people, and I’m excited to read about Viola’s sisters' upcoming romances, hopefully!
The premise of this book intrigued me as I couldn’t say I’ve ever read anything like this. I’ve never read a historical romance, but I wanted to try out this new genre. Initially, I was a bit miffed at the start of the story as to what was going on, but as we progress through the story, we are taken on a journey into the backstory of this marriage to Duke Ventris. I enjoyed the way it gave us flashbacks, which were chapters-long and held a lovely romance story. However, when it came around to be the second time around, I started to get a bit impatient to get back to the present because I was beginning to feel a bit disconnected from the events occurring in the present, which did slightly hurt my rating.
Another thing I would love to recognise is the beautiful writing. There are books where the writing may be overly complex, take away from the story, or be so simple that it adds nothing. However, the writing in this book is highly immersive and helped me, as a newbie historical fiction reader, engage with the period it’s set in.
As for the main characters, I haven’t much to say about Viola other than I liked her. While I also enjoyed Richard, I feel his last revelation at the end of Viola was quite out of character. Not only was it a bit unnecessary given how much had already occurred in the story, but given Viola and Richard’s backstory, it didn’t seem plausible for him to do what he revealed himself to have done. It did not matter how the Orchard tried to justify it; I was unconvinced.
I would recommend this to people, and I’m excited to read about Viola’s sisters' upcoming romances, hopefully!
September 24, 2025
Spycraft in the service of King George as Napoleon causes trouble on the Continent yet again
October 30, 2025
A modern, smart historical romance. I loved the cultural references. A portrait by Angelica Kauffman? OMG. I love it.
September 20, 2025
4.5 stars!
The Tale of Two Dukes by Emma Orchard is such a refreshing take on historical romance. Instead of relying on the usual tropes of wide-eyed debutantes or instant soulmates, this story explores something far richer: the love of family, the sacrifices we make for those we care about, and the possibility of finding happiness again when life doesn’t follow the path we expect. It’s thoughtful, emotional, and quietly powerful in a way that sets it apart from so many Regency tales.
I was immediately intrigued by the way the story begins—with a sense of mystery that raises countless questions. The structure, moving back and forth in time, was such a clever choice. It allowed me to slowly piece together the characters’ choices and circumstances, adding depth and weight to their journey. This dual perspective gave the book a richness that pulled me in completely and kept me turning pages.
Richard and Viola are both characters I truly enjoyed spending time with. They felt refreshingly sincere—not the simpering or selfish figures you sometimes meet in Regency settings, but strong-willed, stubborn, and deeply human. Their relationship is built on honesty from the very beginning, with “the letter” setting the stage for what’s to come. I loved that Orchard chose to make their motives clear right away; it gave the story a sense of authenticity, as though we were being invited into their inner world rather than being strung along by artificial misunderstandings.
What stood out most to me, though, was the emotional heart of the book. This isn’t just a romance—it’s a story about resilience, about finding joy even in the midst of hardship, and about how love, in all its forms, can be both complicated and redemptive. The way Orchard balances tension, tenderness, and genuine feeling is a testament to her skill as a storyteller.
By the end, I was both satisfied and moved. The Tale of Two Dukes isn’t just another Regency romance; it’s a story that lingers, reminding you that second chances are always possible, and that true love is often found in the most unexpected places.
Highly recommended for anyone who loves historical romance with depth, emotional honesty, and characters who feel like real people.
My sincere thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood books for the ARC received.
The Tale of Two Dukes by Emma Orchard is such a refreshing take on historical romance. Instead of relying on the usual tropes of wide-eyed debutantes or instant soulmates, this story explores something far richer: the love of family, the sacrifices we make for those we care about, and the possibility of finding happiness again when life doesn’t follow the path we expect. It’s thoughtful, emotional, and quietly powerful in a way that sets it apart from so many Regency tales.
I was immediately intrigued by the way the story begins—with a sense of mystery that raises countless questions. The structure, moving back and forth in time, was such a clever choice. It allowed me to slowly piece together the characters’ choices and circumstances, adding depth and weight to their journey. This dual perspective gave the book a richness that pulled me in completely and kept me turning pages.
Richard and Viola are both characters I truly enjoyed spending time with. They felt refreshingly sincere—not the simpering or selfish figures you sometimes meet in Regency settings, but strong-willed, stubborn, and deeply human. Their relationship is built on honesty from the very beginning, with “the letter” setting the stage for what’s to come. I loved that Orchard chose to make their motives clear right away; it gave the story a sense of authenticity, as though we were being invited into their inner world rather than being strung along by artificial misunderstandings.
What stood out most to me, though, was the emotional heart of the book. This isn’t just a romance—it’s a story about resilience, about finding joy even in the midst of hardship, and about how love, in all its forms, can be both complicated and redemptive. The way Orchard balances tension, tenderness, and genuine feeling is a testament to her skill as a storyteller.
By the end, I was both satisfied and moved. The Tale of Two Dukes isn’t just another Regency romance; it’s a story that lingers, reminding you that second chances are always possible, and that true love is often found in the most unexpected places.
Highly recommended for anyone who loves historical romance with depth, emotional honesty, and characters who feel like real people.
My sincere thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood books for the ARC received.
September 3, 2025
A Tale of Two Dukes is a beautifully layered Regency romance full of secrets, passion, and second chances. Emma Orchard takes a classic “marriage of convenience” premise and spins it into a deeply emotional story that balances scandal, longing, and love.
The novel begins with Viola, Dowager Duchess of Winterflood, agreeing to a surprising second marriage with Richard Armstrong, her late husband’s cousin and a man with a less-than-spotless reputation. What looks, at first, like a practical arrangement for financial security quickly unravels into something more complicated. Through the book’s dual-timeline structure, we learn that Viola and Richard once shared a romantic past—one cut short by duty and circumstance. Their rekindled relationship carries not only the weight of that history but also the scars of betrayal, loneliness, and secrets.
Viola is a wonderful heroine. She’s older, wiser, and unwilling to let society dictate her choices. Richard is equally compelling, walking the line between scandalous rogue and devoted partner. Together, their chemistry is undeniable, whether in sharp banter or tender moments. The slow burn between them makes the payoff feel all the more rewarding.
I especially enjoyed how Orchard handled themes of independence, appearances, and the double standards of the era. Viola’s determination to protect her children while forging a life on her own terms made her stand out among Regency heroines. Richard, too, was given depth that made him more than just the typical rakish duke.
The pacing leaned a little slow in places, and I wished for a bit more drama in the present-day storyline, but overall, the emotional intensity and rich atmosphere kept me hooked. Orchard’s writing is elegant, her characters well-drawn, and the romance both spicy and heartfelt.
A Tale of Two Dukes is perfect for readers who enjoy Bridgerton-style drama, second-chance romance, and heroines who break the mold. Emma Orchard continues to shine in the Regency romance space, and this is one I’d easily recommend.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the advanced copy—this is my honest review.
The novel begins with Viola, Dowager Duchess of Winterflood, agreeing to a surprising second marriage with Richard Armstrong, her late husband’s cousin and a man with a less-than-spotless reputation. What looks, at first, like a practical arrangement for financial security quickly unravels into something more complicated. Through the book’s dual-timeline structure, we learn that Viola and Richard once shared a romantic past—one cut short by duty and circumstance. Their rekindled relationship carries not only the weight of that history but also the scars of betrayal, loneliness, and secrets.
Viola is a wonderful heroine. She’s older, wiser, and unwilling to let society dictate her choices. Richard is equally compelling, walking the line between scandalous rogue and devoted partner. Together, their chemistry is undeniable, whether in sharp banter or tender moments. The slow burn between them makes the payoff feel all the more rewarding.
I especially enjoyed how Orchard handled themes of independence, appearances, and the double standards of the era. Viola’s determination to protect her children while forging a life on her own terms made her stand out among Regency heroines. Richard, too, was given depth that made him more than just the typical rakish duke.
The pacing leaned a little slow in places, and I wished for a bit more drama in the present-day storyline, but overall, the emotional intensity and rich atmosphere kept me hooked. Orchard’s writing is elegant, her characters well-drawn, and the romance both spicy and heartfelt.
A Tale of Two Dukes is perfect for readers who enjoy Bridgerton-style drama, second-chance romance, and heroines who break the mold. Emma Orchard continues to shine in the Regency romance space, and this is one I’d easily recommend.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the advanced copy—this is my honest review.
September 16, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Ms. Orchard for the opportunity to read an ARC of this title. An honest review was requested but not required.
I would like to express my deep irritation with NetGalley for supplying me with YET ANOTHER author to add to my towering TBR shelf. (And also my thanks.)
Correct me if I’m wrong, but Emma Orchard first started out writing Georgette Heyer-style fanfiction featured on AO3? (Amazing authors are emerging from the woodwork of AO3 at record speed lately!) I was really impressed by the quality and tone of Ms. Orchard’s writing. I definitely felt a strong Heyer influence, crossed (in this particular story) with a touch of Scarlet Pimpernel, plus a dose of modern heat level.
The characters in this story are Viola, widowed Duchess and mother of two 11-year-old twin boys, and Richard, newly Lord Ventris, who has inherited an rundown estate with a curious will from his aunt leaving her money to him only if he is married with a child by a certain age. The story starts off with a bang and it is very clear that there is more to the situation and the character’s backstory than there appears. The situation is unraveled slowly and painfully (particularly for Viola), like Shrek’s proverbial onion – it has layers! But it's so, so satisfying to see these two characters who have been through so much anguish finally get to the bottom of everything. I also really appreciated the way Richard handled his relationship with his new (step)sons and was respectful of their relationship with their mother as well. Leontina in particular was a striking character and I look forward to enjoying her machinations in future books. (I laughed out loud when Viola told her that in earlier times she’d have been burned at the stake.)
Like I said, I was really impressed by this, and immediately went on a hunt for Ms. Orchard’s other works. I foresee success for this author and I look forward to glomming her other books asap.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I would like to express my deep irritation with NetGalley for supplying me with YET ANOTHER author to add to my towering TBR shelf. (And also my thanks.)
Correct me if I’m wrong, but Emma Orchard first started out writing Georgette Heyer-style fanfiction featured on AO3? (Amazing authors are emerging from the woodwork of AO3 at record speed lately!) I was really impressed by the quality and tone of Ms. Orchard’s writing. I definitely felt a strong Heyer influence, crossed (in this particular story) with a touch of Scarlet Pimpernel, plus a dose of modern heat level.
The characters in this story are Viola, widowed Duchess and mother of two 11-year-old twin boys, and Richard, newly Lord Ventris, who has inherited an rundown estate with a curious will from his aunt leaving her money to him only if he is married with a child by a certain age. The story starts off with a bang and it is very clear that there is more to the situation and the character’s backstory than there appears. The situation is unraveled slowly and painfully (particularly for Viola), like Shrek’s proverbial onion – it has layers! But it's so, so satisfying to see these two characters who have been through so much anguish finally get to the bottom of everything. I also really appreciated the way Richard handled his relationship with his new (step)sons and was respectful of their relationship with their mother as well. Leontina in particular was a striking character and I look forward to enjoying her machinations in future books. (I laughed out loud when Viola told her that in earlier times she’d have been burned at the stake.)
Like I said, I was really impressed by this, and immediately went on a hunt for Ms. Orchard’s other works. I foresee success for this author and I look forward to glomming her other books asap.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
September 9, 2025
A Tale of Two Dukes by Emma Orchard is a standalone (from what I can tell) Regency romance.
Viola was 17 when she wed the Duke of Winterflood, a man about 30 years her senior, in order to provide him with an heir, and protect her family from penury. Her life is miserable until the duke’s cousin, Richard comes to stay, and the two of them fall in love. Years later after the duke’s death, Richard reappears and proposes to Viola, claiming he needs an heir for his newly inherited title.
A Tale of Two Dukes is written in third person, mostly from Viola’s point of view. There are a few chapters from Richard’s point of view, but not a lot.
The story has a number of time jumps, it takes place mainly on 1813, which is present day for the characters, and has several flashback chapters to earlier timelines. I understand why the author did it, I think I would have been much less sympathetic to the characters if the author had told the story in another way, but it’s not my favourite plot device, but it did what it was supposed to do.
Although I ended up enjoying the story, I do wish it had come with a warning about cheating. I’m not a fan of cheating in romances, even if there is an explanation, and the cheating couple are the hero and heroine.
While there are a number of spicy scenes, I would not say they are overly so. And for the most part they are necessary for the story, so they don’t feel gratuitous.
Despite the things I didn’t like about the story, I was invested in Viola and Richard’s relationship so found the book hard to put down.
I enjoyed A Tale of Two Dukes, and will probably give Emma Orchard another try to see if the issues I had with this book are common in her others before deciding if I’ll put her on my regular reading list. I recommend giving this book a try if you are a lover of historical romance and want a story that is slightly out of the ordinary.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Viola was 17 when she wed the Duke of Winterflood, a man about 30 years her senior, in order to provide him with an heir, and protect her family from penury. Her life is miserable until the duke’s cousin, Richard comes to stay, and the two of them fall in love. Years later after the duke’s death, Richard reappears and proposes to Viola, claiming he needs an heir for his newly inherited title.
A Tale of Two Dukes is written in third person, mostly from Viola’s point of view. There are a few chapters from Richard’s point of view, but not a lot.
The story has a number of time jumps, it takes place mainly on 1813, which is present day for the characters, and has several flashback chapters to earlier timelines. I understand why the author did it, I think I would have been much less sympathetic to the characters if the author had told the story in another way, but it’s not my favourite plot device, but it did what it was supposed to do.
Although I ended up enjoying the story, I do wish it had come with a warning about cheating. I’m not a fan of cheating in romances, even if there is an explanation, and the cheating couple are the hero and heroine.
While there are a number of spicy scenes, I would not say they are overly so. And for the most part they are necessary for the story, so they don’t feel gratuitous.
Despite the things I didn’t like about the story, I was invested in Viola and Richard’s relationship so found the book hard to put down.
I enjoyed A Tale of Two Dukes, and will probably give Emma Orchard another try to see if the issues I had with this book are common in her others before deciding if I’ll put her on my regular reading list. I recommend giving this book a try if you are a lover of historical romance and want a story that is slightly out of the ordinary.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 8, 2025
A fusion of the Georgette Heyer Regency historical romance classics, Poldark, and Bridgerton, this book is a surprisingly complex and intrigue-filled drama that brings a heavy dose of British history into play.
Viola married for wealth to a kind (but old) Duke at age 17, knowing he desperately sought to produce an heir in his third marriage before he died, and it now lonely, and trapped in a loveless marriage. His cousin Richard, while visiting, pities and comes to develop feelings for Viola, Flash forward 11 years, and Viola has been widowed for the last three, when Richard approaches her with a unique proposition: he will inherit a castle if he can produce an heir within 18 months, and he wants her to marry him to help him accomplish this goal.
Full of flashbacks, and twists that have turned into downright knots of story, this book provides a hefty chunk of second-chance romance plot to chew on for those who have read any Heyer books and enjoyed Julia Quinn's Bridgerton series or Poldark. It definitely fits squarely into the "spicy regency romance" category, unlike the Heyer books. Freshen up on your memory of historical events around the turn of the 19th to 20th centuries, because you will need to be familiar with quite of few of them to get the full scope of the intrigues and details that happen throughout the story.
I am normally not a fan of "second chance romance." "cheating" or even "tempted to cheat" tropes, but Ms. Orchard provided quite a bit of justification for the events of the story that I didn't find I minded the turn things took. I anticipated some plot twists but not others. I did feel like the second half of the book felt very explanatory, as opposed to actually having anything happen. On the other hand, I hate it when books end abruptly, with what I feel like is truncated resolution, and this book did not bring me that disappointment whatsoever.
Thank you to Boldwood Books, Netgalley, and Emma Orchard for providing me with this Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for my honest review.
Viola married for wealth to a kind (but old) Duke at age 17, knowing he desperately sought to produce an heir in his third marriage before he died, and it now lonely, and trapped in a loveless marriage. His cousin Richard, while visiting, pities and comes to develop feelings for Viola, Flash forward 11 years, and Viola has been widowed for the last three, when Richard approaches her with a unique proposition: he will inherit a castle if he can produce an heir within 18 months, and he wants her to marry him to help him accomplish this goal.
Full of flashbacks, and twists that have turned into downright knots of story, this book provides a hefty chunk of second-chance romance plot to chew on for those who have read any Heyer books and enjoyed Julia Quinn's Bridgerton series or Poldark. It definitely fits squarely into the "spicy regency romance" category, unlike the Heyer books. Freshen up on your memory of historical events around the turn of the 19th to 20th centuries, because you will need to be familiar with quite of few of them to get the full scope of the intrigues and details that happen throughout the story.
I am normally not a fan of "second chance romance." "cheating" or even "tempted to cheat" tropes, but Ms. Orchard provided quite a bit of justification for the events of the story that I didn't find I minded the turn things took. I anticipated some plot twists but not others. I did feel like the second half of the book felt very explanatory, as opposed to actually having anything happen. On the other hand, I hate it when books end abruptly, with what I feel like is truncated resolution, and this book did not bring me that disappointment whatsoever.
Thank you to Boldwood Books, Netgalley, and Emma Orchard for providing me with this Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for my honest review.
September 22, 2025
📖 Title: A Tale of Two Dukes-a standalone
✍🏾 Author: Emma Orchard- I read To Catch a Lord and gave it 4 ⭐
📅Publication date: 9-20-25| Read: 9-20-25
📃 Format: e-Book 301 pgs.
Genre:
*Regency Romance
Tropes:
*marriage of convenience
*lovers to enemies to lovers
*hidden pasts/secrets
*family drama
*forbidden romance
*2nd chance romance
👆🏾POV: 3rd person single
🌎 Setting: 1802- 1813 England- Viola's 1st marriage to present
Summary: Viola is sent a letter of proposal from her deceased husband Edward's cousin-Lord Richard Ventris. He wants to marry her to have an heir, but Viola hates him. Two weeks later they are married, but Viola doesn't want Richard kissing her. They have a sordid past that Viola doesn't want to come to light.
👩🏾 Heroine: Viola Constantine-29, Duchess of Winterflood
👨🏾 Hero: Baron Richard Armstrong-33, Lord Ventris, international trader
🎭 Other Characters:
*Ned & Robin-Viola's twin boys 11 yrs.old
*Edward Armstrong-Viola's deceased husband/Richard's cousin, was still in love w/ previous wife Elizabeth when he married Viola
*Mrs. Leontina Constantine-Viola's mother + Viola's sisters-Sabrina, Allegra, Beatrice, Cecilia, and Bianca
*Tarquin Armstrong-Richard's half brother
*Emily Naismith-Viola's BFF, just got married to Sam Muncaster
*Julia & Elizabeth-Edward's first two wives
*Lord Henry Marchett-Edward's BFF
🤔 My Thoughts: It was a nice change to have an experienced woman with options. She was a dowager, left an estate with two sons. Richard had his own agenda as a baron- left a title and estate but no heirs. Together they remembered a complicated past and hope of a peaceful future.
Rating: 4/5 ✨
Spice level: 4/5 🌶️
🙏🏾Thanks to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for this ARC! I voluntarily give my honest review, and all opinions are my own.
✍🏾 Author: Emma Orchard- I read To Catch a Lord and gave it 4 ⭐
📅Publication date: 9-20-25| Read: 9-20-25
📃 Format: e-Book 301 pgs.
Genre:
*Regency Romance
Tropes:
*marriage of convenience
*lovers to enemies to lovers
*hidden pasts/secrets
*family drama
*forbidden romance
*2nd chance romance
👆🏾POV: 3rd person single
🌎 Setting: 1802- 1813 England- Viola's 1st marriage to present
Summary: Viola is sent a letter of proposal from her deceased husband Edward's cousin-Lord Richard Ventris. He wants to marry her to have an heir, but Viola hates him. Two weeks later they are married, but Viola doesn't want Richard kissing her. They have a sordid past that Viola doesn't want to come to light.
👩🏾 Heroine: Viola Constantine-29, Duchess of Winterflood
👨🏾 Hero: Baron Richard Armstrong-33, Lord Ventris, international trader
🎭 Other Characters:
*Ned & Robin-Viola's twin boys 11 yrs.old
*Edward Armstrong-Viola's deceased husband/Richard's cousin, was still in love w/ previous wife Elizabeth when he married Viola
*Mrs. Leontina Constantine-Viola's mother + Viola's sisters-Sabrina, Allegra, Beatrice, Cecilia, and Bianca
*Tarquin Armstrong-Richard's half brother
*Emily Naismith-Viola's BFF, just got married to Sam Muncaster
*Julia & Elizabeth-Edward's first two wives
*Lord Henry Marchett-Edward's BFF
🤔 My Thoughts: It was a nice change to have an experienced woman with options. She was a dowager, left an estate with two sons. Richard had his own agenda as a baron- left a title and estate but no heirs. Together they remembered a complicated past and hope of a peaceful future.
Rating: 4/5 ✨
Spice level: 4/5 🌶️
🙏🏾Thanks to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for this ARC! I voluntarily give my honest review, and all opinions are my own.
September 26, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for the free ARC in exchange for a review!
A nice historical romance book sums this up pretty well.
Viola and Richard's story unfolds in out of order timelines, which is actually quite enjoyable. I think it was overall structured well, but I do wish it hadn't opened with the wedding, as it was hard to invest in the "3 weeks earlier" deliberations of marriage or not when I just read that they were getting married. However, the back in time story of their first meeting I thought was done well!
I also wasn't totally clear on why Viola thought so badly of him? It seems that And the problem of Richard's brother is hilariously .
Now here's the thing. I was pretty onboard for this being a solidly nice book but at the end when Richard
So I struggle to wholeheartedly recommend the book with that in mind. If you pick it up, you'll have a fine time, but personally with that plot point, I won't be passing it onto anyone. 2.5 stars, rounded up to 3 for Goodreads.
A nice historical romance book sums this up pretty well.
Viola and Richard's story unfolds in out of order timelines, which is actually quite enjoyable. I think it was overall structured well, but I do wish it hadn't opened with the wedding, as it was hard to invest in the "3 weeks earlier" deliberations of marriage or not when I just read that they were getting married. However, the back in time story of their first meeting I thought was done well!
I also wasn't totally clear on why Viola thought so badly of him? It seems that And the problem of Richard's brother is hilariously .
Now here's the thing. I was pretty onboard for this being a solidly nice book but at the end when Richard
So I struggle to wholeheartedly recommend the book with that in mind. If you pick it up, you'll have a fine time, but personally with that plot point, I won't be passing it onto anyone. 2.5 stars, rounded up to 3 for Goodreads.
August 26, 2025
4 Stars
The Tale of Two Dukes by Emma Orchard swept me away in the best possible way. This isn’t your typical regency romance—it’s richer, more layered, and deeply emotional. Told through a dual-timeline with immersive flashbacks, it explores love, betrayal, heartbreak, and second chances with incredible tenderness.
We begin with Viola, Dowager Duchess of Winterflood, entering into a surprising second marriage with Richard—the cousin of her late husband and the man she once secretly loved. Their dynamic is complicated, even hostile at first, but as the story unfolds through flashbacks, we see how their bond began years earlier under impossible circumstances. Viola was trapped in a lonely, manipulative marriage to Edward, the Duke, until Richard entered her world and changed everything.
What I loved most was the beautifully written tension. Viola isn’t your typical regency heroine—she’s independent, complex, and fiercely protective of her twin sons. Richard, equally layered, walks the fine line between scandalous rogue and devoted romantic. The flashback chapters built such a stunning love story, though I occasionally found myself eager to return to the present-day timeline. Still, the emotional payoff was worth it.
Emma Orchard’s prose stands out in the regency romance space—it’s elegant yet highly immersive. The romance is spicy, heartfelt, and full of longing, with characters that feel complex and deeply human. My only small wish? That we saw more of Viola, Richard, and their family life in the present.
Thank you NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the eARC of this book.
The Tale of Two Dukes by Emma Orchard swept me away in the best possible way. This isn’t your typical regency romance—it’s richer, more layered, and deeply emotional. Told through a dual-timeline with immersive flashbacks, it explores love, betrayal, heartbreak, and second chances with incredible tenderness.
We begin with Viola, Dowager Duchess of Winterflood, entering into a surprising second marriage with Richard—the cousin of her late husband and the man she once secretly loved. Their dynamic is complicated, even hostile at first, but as the story unfolds through flashbacks, we see how their bond began years earlier under impossible circumstances. Viola was trapped in a lonely, manipulative marriage to Edward, the Duke, until Richard entered her world and changed everything.
What I loved most was the beautifully written tension. Viola isn’t your typical regency heroine—she’s independent, complex, and fiercely protective of her twin sons. Richard, equally layered, walks the fine line between scandalous rogue and devoted romantic. The flashback chapters built such a stunning love story, though I occasionally found myself eager to return to the present-day timeline. Still, the emotional payoff was worth it.
Emma Orchard’s prose stands out in the regency romance space—it’s elegant yet highly immersive. The romance is spicy, heartfelt, and full of longing, with characters that feel complex and deeply human. My only small wish? That we saw more of Viola, Richard, and their family life in the present.
Thank you NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the eARC of this book.
December 6, 2025
In true Orchard tradition, this romance has a more than the usual amount of sudden passionate encounters and star-crossed lovers with tons of baggage to sort through until they can have their HEA. What I really like about an Emma Orchard romance is that her storylines/set-ups for the main couples are very unique to any other historical romances I've read.
In "A Tale of Two Dukes," Viola is the third wife of the childless Duke Edward. Knowing that after two childless marriages, he is most likely sterile but still desperate to pass his title and fortune to someone other than his wicked cousin, Edward marries Viola with the secret intention of pimping her out to his cousin, Richard. After Richard comes to visit and sees how alone Viola is, he strikes up a friendship which turns into a passionate love affair. They discover Edward's plot and separate, but not before giving Edward exactly what he wants - an heir. Years later, after Edward dies, Richard offers for Viola at last, but his years of secrets and her years of mistrust threaten to forever prevent their HEA. Only total honesty, trust and opening their hearts completely to each other again will mend what is broken.
The story is told in two different timelines with flashbacks to help the reader understand the complexity of Richard and Viola's relationship. I wish we had gotten a scene of the boys finding out Richard was their real father. I was very interested in reading their reactions. I read the e-book and listened to the audiobook (1.75x speed) in tandem. The narrator's performance painted a vivid picture and was not annoying in any way.
In "A Tale of Two Dukes," Viola is the third wife of the childless Duke Edward. Knowing that after two childless marriages, he is most likely sterile but still desperate to pass his title and fortune to someone other than his wicked cousin, Edward marries Viola with the secret intention of pimping her out to his cousin, Richard. After Richard comes to visit and sees how alone Viola is, he strikes up a friendship which turns into a passionate love affair. They discover Edward's plot and separate, but not before giving Edward exactly what he wants - an heir. Years later, after Edward dies, Richard offers for Viola at last, but his years of secrets and her years of mistrust threaten to forever prevent their HEA. Only total honesty, trust and opening their hearts completely to each other again will mend what is broken.
The story is told in two different timelines with flashbacks to help the reader understand the complexity of Richard and Viola's relationship. I wish we had gotten a scene of the boys finding out Richard was their real father. I was very interested in reading their reactions. I read the e-book and listened to the audiobook (1.75x speed) in tandem. The narrator's performance painted a vivid picture and was not annoying in any way.
September 7, 2025
Well this story is long and the prologue sets the present day but the rest of this couples history spans more than a decade! We have 17 year old Viola Constantine a Duchess more than 30 years her senior! She is from a fertile family and he desperately wants an heir so that his feckless next on line will not become the next Duke!
Edward, the Duke is kind but constant memoirs from him and the staff of his late Duchess puts a terrible strain on the marriage! He constantly compares her a very young woman to his late Duchess this sets a terrible precedent with the staff as well!
Edward invites Richard to visit with a very specific plan in mind! It does not take Viola long to overhear it and she is inconsolable! Mr Richard Armstrong the younger more responsible brother of her husbands heir!
Viola and Richard make the best of a very difficult situation and no one the wiser!
Richard has secrets several so dangerous if he whispers one word he’s a dead man! Viola only knows of the gossips as they have spent over a decade apart! It is over three years after the Duke passes that they are reunited!
Viola is a mother and she fears for her son’s safety! So when Richard approaches her now a Baron for her hand in marriage she knows he will keep them safe!
Viola is angry and hurt and resolved to keep Richard at arms length except he also needs a heir! Can two people with such a troubled past ever air their differences?
Can Richard stop his habitual lies? This one you don’t put down and will read far into the night! Bravo so well done!
I received an ARC copy for my unbiased review!
Edward, the Duke is kind but constant memoirs from him and the staff of his late Duchess puts a terrible strain on the marriage! He constantly compares her a very young woman to his late Duchess this sets a terrible precedent with the staff as well!
Edward invites Richard to visit with a very specific plan in mind! It does not take Viola long to overhear it and she is inconsolable! Mr Richard Armstrong the younger more responsible brother of her husbands heir!
Viola and Richard make the best of a very difficult situation and no one the wiser!
Richard has secrets several so dangerous if he whispers one word he’s a dead man! Viola only knows of the gossips as they have spent over a decade apart! It is over three years after the Duke passes that they are reunited!
Viola is a mother and she fears for her son’s safety! So when Richard approaches her now a Baron for her hand in marriage she knows he will keep them safe!
Viola is angry and hurt and resolved to keep Richard at arms length except he also needs a heir! Can two people with such a troubled past ever air their differences?
Can Richard stop his habitual lies? This one you don’t put down and will read far into the night! Bravo so well done!
I received an ARC copy for my unbiased review!
October 7, 2025
My first regency romance!
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for the opportunity to read an advanced reader copy of A Tale of Two Dukes in exchange for an honest review.
This is the first regency romance book that I’ve ever read, and I really enjoyed it!
Just to start, the title was a little misleading— I thought it MIGHT be a “why choose” book, but it definitely is not (so if that’s what you’re expecting, change those expectations!)
But by the end of the book, the title does of course make sense, it’s just worth noting that initially it could be misleading.
I thoroughly enjoyed the plot of this book. Everything seemed really straightforward in the beginning, but I love that I was very surprised by the plot twists and the way their story unraveled and caught me off-guard.
I would find myself confused at times, just in regards to politics and family structures back in the early 1800s, but that’s just a me problem— I get confused when I watch regency shows, too! The way some people have three different names/titles was confusing at times, but that’s just how it was back then, so definitely not a fault of the book or anything!
And the romance, of course, was very steamy and a lot of fun! The tension was a good time, especially the enemies-to-lovers part. And the way they end up together and eventually resolve their differences is very satisfying and well done.
I really enjoyed this book; I look forward to reading more of Emma Orchard’s books in the future!
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for the opportunity to read an advanced reader copy of A Tale of Two Dukes in exchange for an honest review.
This is the first regency romance book that I’ve ever read, and I really enjoyed it!
Just to start, the title was a little misleading— I thought it MIGHT be a “why choose” book, but it definitely is not (so if that’s what you’re expecting, change those expectations!)
But by the end of the book, the title does of course make sense, it’s just worth noting that initially it could be misleading.
I thoroughly enjoyed the plot of this book. Everything seemed really straightforward in the beginning, but I love that I was very surprised by the plot twists and the way their story unraveled and caught me off-guard.
I would find myself confused at times, just in regards to politics and family structures back in the early 1800s, but that’s just a me problem— I get confused when I watch regency shows, too! The way some people have three different names/titles was confusing at times, but that’s just how it was back then, so definitely not a fault of the book or anything!
And the romance, of course, was very steamy and a lot of fun! The tension was a good time, especially the enemies-to-lovers part. And the way they end up together and eventually resolve their differences is very satisfying and well done.
I really enjoyed this book; I look forward to reading more of Emma Orchard’s books in the future!
August 17, 2025
An enjoyable novel with some darker undertones.
Married young to a man much older, Viola was aware that her new husband was still grieving his former wife and needed an heir. What she didn’t realise was how lonely and restricted her life would be and the lengths her husband would go to obtain his heir. Manipulated and unhappy, Viola grasps at what happiness she can and with the birth of her twin sons they become the centre of her world. Widowed in her twenties, Viola has more freedom but continues a fairly solitary life. Three years later, right out of the blue, she receives an insulting offer of marriage from the man she once loved and who is rumoured to be a criminal….
Note: I love how in both this book and the only other I have read by this author (To Catch a Lord) she incorporates some of the strange marriage laws in existence and which many authors seem unaware of. The list of forbidden marriages was drawn up by the Church of England in 1560 and remained unchanged until the 20th century. Many of these seem strange to us now as you could marry your first cousin (Darwin did) but not your deceased husband’s brother. Amongst the lower classes marrying your deceased wife’s younger sister (she came to look after the children) did seem to happen but the couple usually got married in another parish and there were no inheritance rules to worry about!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Married young to a man much older, Viola was aware that her new husband was still grieving his former wife and needed an heir. What she didn’t realise was how lonely and restricted her life would be and the lengths her husband would go to obtain his heir. Manipulated and unhappy, Viola grasps at what happiness she can and with the birth of her twin sons they become the centre of her world. Widowed in her twenties, Viola has more freedom but continues a fairly solitary life. Three years later, right out of the blue, she receives an insulting offer of marriage from the man she once loved and who is rumoured to be a criminal….
Note: I love how in both this book and the only other I have read by this author (To Catch a Lord) she incorporates some of the strange marriage laws in existence and which many authors seem unaware of. The list of forbidden marriages was drawn up by the Church of England in 1560 and remained unchanged until the 20th century. Many of these seem strange to us now as you could marry your first cousin (Darwin did) but not your deceased husband’s brother. Amongst the lower classes marrying your deceased wife’s younger sister (she came to look after the children) did seem to happen but the couple usually got married in another parish and there were no inheritance rules to worry about!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 6, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books and the author for approving my request for an ARC.
This is my first book by this author and I enjoyed her writing style. The book is easy to read and it immediately captured our attention. Though I did not like our Main lead, Lord Ventris, I found myself rooting for our female lead, Viola. I am immensely thankful to all the people who have fought hard for women's rights so that no one in the future has to face the predicament that Viola faces. In today's day and age....it is very difficult to even imagine. Our personal freedom is of utmost importance. How we wish to lead our lives....in all its multifaceted glory should be entirely our choice.
The book was slow in parts and I could not fathom where it was going.....the little twists and turns were fun and one of them was completely mind boggling to me. I absolutely adored the dialogues between Viola and her sons and I wish we had more of such scenes. Ned and Robin were described in great detail but they appeared real only when they had something to speak. Till about 95% in....I was wondering if I was the only one who wasn't understanding the title of the book.....
🫢
Then....it made sense. I am glad that the author sorted it out. Would I recommend this book to anyone who loves historical romance with a dash of mystery? Absolutely.
I would also be on the lookout for future books by this author.
This is my first book by this author and I enjoyed her writing style. The book is easy to read and it immediately captured our attention. Though I did not like our Main lead, Lord Ventris, I found myself rooting for our female lead, Viola. I am immensely thankful to all the people who have fought hard for women's rights so that no one in the future has to face the predicament that Viola faces. In today's day and age....it is very difficult to even imagine. Our personal freedom is of utmost importance. How we wish to lead our lives....in all its multifaceted glory should be entirely our choice.
The book was slow in parts and I could not fathom where it was going.....the little twists and turns were fun and one of them was completely mind boggling to me. I absolutely adored the dialogues between Viola and her sons and I wish we had more of such scenes. Ned and Robin were described in great detail but they appeared real only when they had something to speak. Till about 95% in....I was wondering if I was the only one who wasn't understanding the title of the book.....
🫢
Then....it made sense. I am glad that the author sorted it out. Would I recommend this book to anyone who loves historical romance with a dash of mystery? Absolutely.
I would also be on the lookout for future books by this author.
September 11, 2025
3/5🌟
A Tale of Two Dukes was my latest historical romance fix, and honestly, it took me for a bit of a ride. Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, and Richard, the newly minted Lord Ventris, have all the ingredients; romantic tension, messy history, and just enough drama to keep things spicy. The dual timeline was fun but sometimes made me want to scream “please, just get back to the present!” because I was craving more conflict and yearning (maybe that’s just the romance reader in me).
Emma Orchard’s writing is smooth and evocative, and for a book with its fair share of smut, nothing felt unnecessary. Some side characters deserved more screen time, and I won’t lie; the wedding day drama made me raise an eyebrow. As someone who’s devoured a fair bit of historical romance, I was hoping for more emotional tug and deeper heartache, but that final twist from Richard didn’t hit the mark for me.
Still, I flew through it, enjoyed the banter (Viola’s twins were adorable), and appreciated the richness in the details. Not my favourite from Emma Orchard, but I’m not giving up on her yet. 3/5 stars from someone who loves the genre and always expects a little more yearning with their tea and scandals.
Huge thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for providing me with the digital copy!!
A Tale of Two Dukes was my latest historical romance fix, and honestly, it took me for a bit of a ride. Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, and Richard, the newly minted Lord Ventris, have all the ingredients; romantic tension, messy history, and just enough drama to keep things spicy. The dual timeline was fun but sometimes made me want to scream “please, just get back to the present!” because I was craving more conflict and yearning (maybe that’s just the romance reader in me).
Emma Orchard’s writing is smooth and evocative, and for a book with its fair share of smut, nothing felt unnecessary. Some side characters deserved more screen time, and I won’t lie; the wedding day drama made me raise an eyebrow. As someone who’s devoured a fair bit of historical romance, I was hoping for more emotional tug and deeper heartache, but that final twist from Richard didn’t hit the mark for me.
Still, I flew through it, enjoyed the banter (Viola’s twins were adorable), and appreciated the richness in the details. Not my favourite from Emma Orchard, but I’m not giving up on her yet. 3/5 stars from someone who loves the genre and always expects a little more yearning with their tea and scandals.
Huge thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for providing me with the digital copy!!
September 14, 2025
This was my first book by Emma Orchard, and I definitely will read more. Her writing style is reminiscent of Balogh and Heyer, not particularly lively but definitely containing the details, wit, and scandal I associate with the regency.
The novel begins with a flashforward prologue, then we spend several chapters being brought up to speed. The prologue from Richard's perspective was interesting because his impressions of Viola at this event and time are mostly inaccurate. In this case, I do think it worked to go back to the origin of Viola and Richard straight after and work through the events that brought them together and parted them. Unfortunately Viola must endure a lot and put her trust in Richard after feeling betrayed by him to secure her happy ending. There were many romantic dialogues, but I didn't always feel the chemistry between the characters. That could be because they had their guards up with each other for much of the book.
Orchard includes a lot of historical details about customs and marriage laws that many others gloss over when writing regencies, and I enjoy that because it helps us understand the positions women were in then. Not a lot of authors are writing historicals like this at the moment, and I would definitely recommend this one.
Thank you to Boldwood and Netgalley for the e-arc.
The novel begins with a flashforward prologue, then we spend several chapters being brought up to speed. The prologue from Richard's perspective was interesting because his impressions of Viola at this event and time are mostly inaccurate. In this case, I do think it worked to go back to the origin of Viola and Richard straight after and work through the events that brought them together and parted them. Unfortunately Viola must endure a lot and put her trust in Richard after feeling betrayed by him to secure her happy ending. There were many romantic dialogues, but I didn't always feel the chemistry between the characters. That could be because they had their guards up with each other for much of the book.
Orchard includes a lot of historical details about customs and marriage laws that many others gloss over when writing regencies, and I enjoy that because it helps us understand the positions women were in then. Not a lot of authors are writing historicals like this at the moment, and I would definitely recommend this one.
Thank you to Boldwood and Netgalley for the e-arc.
September 18, 2025
Viola is a widow of several years when a proposal of marriage comes her way from a man she hasn't seen in over a decade. At first. she won't consider the proposal but soon she decides to accept with a few ground rules, one of which is that he may not kiss her. This begins an enemies-to-lovers romance of sorts. Both have secrets that will come out and their attraction becomes passion.
Thi s was a really good read, and I liked the way the past is intertwined with the present. There is history between the pair, but it is drawn out slowly so that it really is satisfying when they reach the point of happiness. The story from the past touches on some issues that wouldn't have been discussed much during the time, and I suspect is realistic in some ways with what might have occurred in some families. The book was an easy read, and I devoured it quite greedily once I started. There's plenty of romance along the way with a bit of spice thrown in to entice even more. I should advise that the title is a bit misleading, seeming a bit like a story with a love triangle. That said, I kind of understand it too but suspect many will expect differently when choosing the book.
Overall, this was a lovely book, and I rate it four stars. Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for providing a free advance reader copy. My feedback is totally voluntary.
Thi s was a really good read, and I liked the way the past is intertwined with the present. There is history between the pair, but it is drawn out slowly so that it really is satisfying when they reach the point of happiness. The story from the past touches on some issues that wouldn't have been discussed much during the time, and I suspect is realistic in some ways with what might have occurred in some families. The book was an easy read, and I devoured it quite greedily once I started. There's plenty of romance along the way with a bit of spice thrown in to entice even more. I should advise that the title is a bit misleading, seeming a bit like a story with a love triangle. That said, I kind of understand it too but suspect many will expect differently when choosing the book.
Overall, this was a lovely book, and I rate it four stars. Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for providing a free advance reader copy. My feedback is totally voluntary.
September 18, 2025
I enjoyed the book however it was hard to get into and in places was boring for me!
Blurb
No one is more surprised than Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, when she receives an offer of marriage from a man she’s not seen in over a decade. An independent widow, close to thirty, with two rambunctious boys, Viola has no obvious reason to accept the new Lord Ventris’s proposal. And yet… within two weeks, Viola finds herself walking down the aisle towards a man she despises and has sworn she'll never kiss. But kisses are all that’s off limits: nothing else.
Accustomed to living a secretive life on the outskirts of society, Richard Armstrong never expected to inherit a title, nor the significant property that comes with it. But now that he has, he’s determined to keep it within his bloodline, and for that he needs an heir. And so, he seeks out the striking widow of his cousin, the late Duke of Winterflood, and offers his hand.
While their passionate but turbulent union raises eyebrows among their family, and the ton at large, both Viola and Richard carry their own secret reasons for agreeing to marry.
But as they start their new life together, they will soon discover that the shocking secrets they’ve both been keeping cannot stay hidden forever. And the revelations, when they come, could turn both their worlds upside down.
Blurb
No one is more surprised than Viola, Duchess of Winterflood, when she receives an offer of marriage from a man she’s not seen in over a decade. An independent widow, close to thirty, with two rambunctious boys, Viola has no obvious reason to accept the new Lord Ventris’s proposal. And yet… within two weeks, Viola finds herself walking down the aisle towards a man she despises and has sworn she'll never kiss. But kisses are all that’s off limits: nothing else.
Accustomed to living a secretive life on the outskirts of society, Richard Armstrong never expected to inherit a title, nor the significant property that comes with it. But now that he has, he’s determined to keep it within his bloodline, and for that he needs an heir. And so, he seeks out the striking widow of his cousin, the late Duke of Winterflood, and offers his hand.
While their passionate but turbulent union raises eyebrows among their family, and the ton at large, both Viola and Richard carry their own secret reasons for agreeing to marry.
But as they start their new life together, they will soon discover that the shocking secrets they’ve both been keeping cannot stay hidden forever. And the revelations, when they come, could turn both their worlds upside down.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 127 reviews