What do you think?
Rate this book
Oak Creek Thriller #2
Never Strike Twice
Every three years, a new victim appears, marked by the same sinister symbol…
The small town of Oak Creek is rocked by the discovery of a body branded with a mysterious black mark. Investigations soon link the killing to a slew of unsolved murders from years before where every victim was left with an identical symbol.
Newly retired, Detective Charlotte Dawes is brought back to town to lend her expertise, having worked on the murders as a rookie. She soon uncovers a disturbing pattern where bodies appear every few years to the day, murdered as if by clockwork.
Drawing closer to the shocking truth, Charlotte must race against time to figure out who is behind such meticulously calculated crimes, before the clock strikes its last…
What readers are saying about the Oak Creek Thriller
‘This is the start of something special… prepare to fall in love with this new world and its darkly addictive pace.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I was completely held hostage by my Kindle the whole way til the end.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘Okay, wow! This book was just… whoosh! Mind blown… a masterclass in suspense. Gripping, intelligent, and so compelling, I reread it the moment I finished. I haven’t been able to stop thinking about it since.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I'm kind of fangirling right now. Honestly, I was blown away by how much I enjoyed it.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘A tour de force.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I devoured this book in a day and was left wanting more.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘Dark, intelligent, and absolutely relentless. From the first chilling chapter, the story pulls you into a dangerous web of lies, betrayal, and secrets that refuse to stay buried. The tension is thick, the atmosphere ominous, and the twists… genuinely shocking.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I was completely blown away… it was sheer brilliance… pure awesomeness!’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘Chilling, gruesome, dark. Excellent novel… Definitely a winner…’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I haven't read such a twisted murder mystery in a long time… A fantastic story that I read in a day.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I had to force myself to put it down and go to bed.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘This book was absolutely phenomenal!’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The small town of Oak Creek is rocked by the discovery of a body branded with a mysterious black mark. Investigations soon link the killing to a slew of unsolved murders from years before where every victim was left with an identical symbol.
Newly retired, Detective Charlotte Dawes is brought back to town to lend her expertise, having worked on the murders as a rookie. She soon uncovers a disturbing pattern where bodies appear every few years to the day, murdered as if by clockwork.
Drawing closer to the shocking truth, Charlotte must race against time to figure out who is behind such meticulously calculated crimes, before the clock strikes its last…
What readers are saying about the Oak Creek Thriller
‘This is the start of something special… prepare to fall in love with this new world and its darkly addictive pace.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I was completely held hostage by my Kindle the whole way til the end.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘Okay, wow! This book was just… whoosh! Mind blown… a masterclass in suspense. Gripping, intelligent, and so compelling, I reread it the moment I finished. I haven’t been able to stop thinking about it since.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I'm kind of fangirling right now. Honestly, I was blown away by how much I enjoyed it.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘A tour de force.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I devoured this book in a day and was left wanting more.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘Dark, intelligent, and absolutely relentless. From the first chilling chapter, the story pulls you into a dangerous web of lies, betrayal, and secrets that refuse to stay buried. The tension is thick, the atmosphere ominous, and the twists… genuinely shocking.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I was completely blown away… it was sheer brilliance… pure awesomeness!’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘Chilling, gruesome, dark. Excellent novel… Definitely a winner…’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I haven't read such a twisted murder mystery in a long time… A fantastic story that I read in a day.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘I had to force myself to put it down and go to bed.’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
‘This book was absolutely phenomenal!’ Reader review, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
292 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 22, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Never Strike Twice by Alex Sigmore
Synopsis /
The small town of Oak Creek is rocked by the discovery of a body branded with a mysterious black mark. Investigations soon link the killing to a slew of unsolved murders from years before where every victim was left with an identical symbol.
Newly retired, Detective Charlotte Dawes is brought back to town to lend her expertise, having worked on the murders as a rookie. She soon uncovers a disturbing pattern where bodies appear every few years to the day, murdered as if by clockwork.
Drawing closer to the shocking truth, Charlotte must race against time to figure out who is behind such meticulously calculated crimes, before the clock strikes its last…
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Alex Sigmore for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Back in May of this year, I had the opportunity to read The Darkest Game, the first book in Sigmore's Oak Creek Thriller Series and I was thoroughly impressed. In it we are introduced to Detective Charlotte Dawes, a seasoned cop with over twenty years on the force; who, together with rookie detective, Mona LaSalle solve a series of macabre murders orchestrated by a seriously disturbed individual.
In Never Strike Twice the pair are back; but this time around finds Dawes retired and LaSalle a more experienced detective. However, neither of the pair are completely happy. Although recently retired, Dawes is finding that time now moves at a snails pace. She's not adjusting well to living a more sedate lifestyle – she craves that adrenaline rush of chasing a killer. Of the two, LaSalle has had more personal growth – she's come on as a detective, but still questions herself about her place in the force and whether she is respected by her peers.
LaSalle is called to a crime scene where the body is thought to be the victim of a victim of a hit and run. It's only when LaSalle is processing the scene, she notices that the victim had some sort of symbol seared into the wrist on one arm. Looking into this mysterious symbol further, LaSalle discovered that it bore similarities to a cold case – a case that had been investigated by her old friend Charlotte Dawes. So with little hesitation, LaSalle contacted Dawes about her findings.
As the investigation progressed, so did the realisation that the hit and run victim had a solid connection with Dawes' cold case. This results in Dawes being officially brought on as a consultant. The pairing of Dawes and LaSalle is back again.
What is it with small towns? They seem to provide the perfect backdrop for murder. Or in this case 'murders'. I'm not going to go down that rabbit hole, or overthink too much; but what it does do is bring to the fore that personal connection to the victim or victims. And because of that 'personal' element, it elevates the crime to a level above your standard police procedural. The reader becomes invested. I know I was.
Sigmore has thought through this narrative – with the cold case of 25 years prior weaving its way into the present. The Oak Creek township is still coming to grips with the fallout from serial killer John McCormick in the previous book, so everyone is in a state of high anxiety about this current case. This is one of those series the reader will need to read in order – so you're lucky – we are only two books in; but I'm hoping there will be plenty more to come!
Sigmore builds the suspense through atmosphere and his characters, poking at the reader's mindset – could it possibly be another serial killer? It's a nice blend of procedural crime and psychological thriller, two of my favourite themes to read.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for February 05, 2026.
Synopsis /
The small town of Oak Creek is rocked by the discovery of a body branded with a mysterious black mark. Investigations soon link the killing to a slew of unsolved murders from years before where every victim was left with an identical symbol.
Newly retired, Detective Charlotte Dawes is brought back to town to lend her expertise, having worked on the murders as a rookie. She soon uncovers a disturbing pattern where bodies appear every few years to the day, murdered as if by clockwork.
Drawing closer to the shocking truth, Charlotte must race against time to figure out who is behind such meticulously calculated crimes, before the clock strikes its last…
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Alex Sigmore for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Back in May of this year, I had the opportunity to read The Darkest Game, the first book in Sigmore's Oak Creek Thriller Series and I was thoroughly impressed. In it we are introduced to Detective Charlotte Dawes, a seasoned cop with over twenty years on the force; who, together with rookie detective, Mona LaSalle solve a series of macabre murders orchestrated by a seriously disturbed individual.
In Never Strike Twice the pair are back; but this time around finds Dawes retired and LaSalle a more experienced detective. However, neither of the pair are completely happy. Although recently retired, Dawes is finding that time now moves at a snails pace. She's not adjusting well to living a more sedate lifestyle – she craves that adrenaline rush of chasing a killer. Of the two, LaSalle has had more personal growth – she's come on as a detective, but still questions herself about her place in the force and whether she is respected by her peers.
LaSalle is called to a crime scene where the body is thought to be the victim of a victim of a hit and run. It's only when LaSalle is processing the scene, she notices that the victim had some sort of symbol seared into the wrist on one arm. Looking into this mysterious symbol further, LaSalle discovered that it bore similarities to a cold case – a case that had been investigated by her old friend Charlotte Dawes. So with little hesitation, LaSalle contacted Dawes about her findings.
As the investigation progressed, so did the realisation that the hit and run victim had a solid connection with Dawes' cold case. This results in Dawes being officially brought on as a consultant. The pairing of Dawes and LaSalle is back again.
What is it with small towns? They seem to provide the perfect backdrop for murder. Or in this case 'murders'. I'm not going to go down that rabbit hole, or overthink too much; but what it does do is bring to the fore that personal connection to the victim or victims. And because of that 'personal' element, it elevates the crime to a level above your standard police procedural. The reader becomes invested. I know I was.
Sigmore has thought through this narrative – with the cold case of 25 years prior weaving its way into the present. The Oak Creek township is still coming to grips with the fallout from serial killer John McCormick in the previous book, so everyone is in a state of high anxiety about this current case. This is one of those series the reader will need to read in order – so you're lucky – we are only two books in; but I'm hoping there will be plenty more to come!
Sigmore builds the suspense through atmosphere and his characters, poking at the reader's mindset – could it possibly be another serial killer? It's a nice blend of procedural crime and psychological thriller, two of my favourite themes to read.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for February 05, 2026.
February 9, 2026
We’re back in Oak Creek with our favorite detective, Mona LaSalle, who’s called to a disturbing crime scene where a body is discovered with a strange symbol branded onto the victim’s wrist. When another body turns up bearing a different symbol, Mona knows this case is unlike anything she’s handled before and calls in the only person who might be able to help, Charlotte Dawes.
Charlotte may be retired, but she misses the work, and as soon as Mona explains the details of the case, Charlotte can’t shake the feeling that it’s connected to the very first major investigation she worked on twenty-five years ago. As more bodies begin to surface, Mona and Charlotte must race against time to uncover the meaning behind the symbols and understand why these specific people are being targeted, before the killer strikes again.
I flew through this book in just two days and was fully invested from start to finish. The pacing is fast, the mystery is compelling, and the dynamic between Mona and Charlotte continues to be a highlight. I’m already craving more from this duo.
I highly recommend reading the first book in the series, The Darkest Game, before picking this one up because there are references to past events that add depth to both characters and make the story even more impactful.
Charlotte may be retired, but she misses the work, and as soon as Mona explains the details of the case, Charlotte can’t shake the feeling that it’s connected to the very first major investigation she worked on twenty-five years ago. As more bodies begin to surface, Mona and Charlotte must race against time to uncover the meaning behind the symbols and understand why these specific people are being targeted, before the killer strikes again.
I flew through this book in just two days and was fully invested from start to finish. The pacing is fast, the mystery is compelling, and the dynamic between Mona and Charlotte continues to be a highlight. I’m already craving more from this duo.
I highly recommend reading the first book in the series, The Darkest Game, before picking this one up because there are references to past events that add depth to both characters and make the story even more impactful.
February 6, 2026
I was so excited to read the second book of the Oak Creek Thriller Series. Sigmore does a great job of character development for Mona and Charlotte. This thriller will keep you on the edge of your seat, trying to follow a very messed up game of cat and mouse. Connecting the current case to a case 20 years ago was an added dynamic to figure out how all the pieces of the puzzle fit together. If you haven't read Alex Sigmore's Oak Creek Thriller Series this is your sign to add it to your TBR. Thank you NetGalley for the ARC.
March 14, 2026
What a fantastic book this was to read. Kept you really intrigued all the way through, trying to work out who the killer was. Great characters too, which helped keep you enthralled too alongside the storyline itself. Definitely a book to recommend!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It’s so good to see Charlotte Dawes back again, even if, as this book quickly proves, retirement really doesn’t suit her. When Mona LaSalle (who feels far more confident and more mature this time around) asks for Charlotte’s help with a new case eerily similar to one she worked on 25 years ago, Charlotte dives in headfirst. Because, let’s be honest, she was never going to stay retired.
I really liked the concept of the recurring murders; the victims branded with a symbol and the killings happening on a clockwork timeline. It takes serious restraint and planning from the killer, and the book did a great job showing that chilling precision. I also loved the dynamic between the seasoned detective and the newer investigator, old-school instinct meeting fresh perspective.
My only wish? I wanted to go just a bit deeper into the killing, reasons and all that.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4★) and I really hope book three is on the way soon!
Thank you, NetGalley & Storm Publishing, for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Book review: Alex Sigmore Never Strike Twice.
Storm Publishing, thank you so much along with NetGalley for my gifted ARC.
Returning to Oak Creek feels a bit like visiting that quiet neighbor who always waves hello but somehow knows far too much about everyone on the street. Never Strike Twice pulled me right back into that uneasy, small-town atmosphere where the past isn’t just remembered, it’s actively lurking. Alex Sigmore has a talent for making familiarity feel dangerous, and this second installment in the Oak Creek Thriller series leans fully into that strength.
This story centers on retired detective Charlotte Dawes, who proves almost immediately that retirement does not suit her. When a new body turns up bearing a symbol identical to one from an old unsolved case, Charlotte is drawn back into an investigation that never really let her go. I loved how her history with the case added emotional gravity. This isn’t just about catching a killer, it’s about unfinished business, lingering guilt, and the weight of victims who were never given justice. That personal connection elevates the story beyond a standard procedural.
The structure of the crimes themselves is deeply unsettling. Murders occurring every few years, almost by schedule, scratched that particular itch I have for pattern-based thrillers. Sigmore takes his time revealing the significance of the symbol and the ritualistic elements behind it, and I appreciated the restraint. Instead of rushing toward twists, the book lets tension seep in gradually, building dread through repetition, timing, and implication. Oak Creek becomes a character in its own right, a town shaped by secrets and silence.
Charlotte’s interactions with the current investigation added a layered dynamic I really enjoyed. There’s a quiet contrast between experience and fresh perspective, and it highlights how cases evolve over time while trauma often stays frozen. The pacing is steady rather than frantic, which worked well for me. This is the kind of thriller that trusts the reader to stay engaged without constant action, and that confidence pays off.
“There’s something terrifying about a crime that waits patiently for its moment.”
While Never Strike Twice is clearly part of a series, it functions well on its own. Readers familiar with Oak Creek will feel the emotional callbacks more deeply, but new readers won’t be lost. The writing carries the story with a controlled, assured voice, and even in darker moments, it never feels gratuitous. The horror here comes from intention and inevitability, not shock value.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is a smart, methodical crime thriller that rewards patience and attention. It’s unsettling without being overwhelming, character-driven without losing momentum, and atmospheric in a way that lingers long after the final page. If you enjoy crime novels with cold cases, ritualistic elements, and flawed investigators who refuse to let the past stay buried, this is absolutely one to add to your list.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½ out of 5 stars
#NeverStrikeTwice #AlexSigmore #StormPublishing #BookReview #CrimeThriller #MysteryBooks #ThrillerReads #PsychologicalThriller #NetGalley #ARCReview
Storm Publishing, thank you so much along with NetGalley for my gifted ARC.
Returning to Oak Creek feels a bit like visiting that quiet neighbor who always waves hello but somehow knows far too much about everyone on the street. Never Strike Twice pulled me right back into that uneasy, small-town atmosphere where the past isn’t just remembered, it’s actively lurking. Alex Sigmore has a talent for making familiarity feel dangerous, and this second installment in the Oak Creek Thriller series leans fully into that strength.
This story centers on retired detective Charlotte Dawes, who proves almost immediately that retirement does not suit her. When a new body turns up bearing a symbol identical to one from an old unsolved case, Charlotte is drawn back into an investigation that never really let her go. I loved how her history with the case added emotional gravity. This isn’t just about catching a killer, it’s about unfinished business, lingering guilt, and the weight of victims who were never given justice. That personal connection elevates the story beyond a standard procedural.
The structure of the crimes themselves is deeply unsettling. Murders occurring every few years, almost by schedule, scratched that particular itch I have for pattern-based thrillers. Sigmore takes his time revealing the significance of the symbol and the ritualistic elements behind it, and I appreciated the restraint. Instead of rushing toward twists, the book lets tension seep in gradually, building dread through repetition, timing, and implication. Oak Creek becomes a character in its own right, a town shaped by secrets and silence.
Charlotte’s interactions with the current investigation added a layered dynamic I really enjoyed. There’s a quiet contrast between experience and fresh perspective, and it highlights how cases evolve over time while trauma often stays frozen. The pacing is steady rather than frantic, which worked well for me. This is the kind of thriller that trusts the reader to stay engaged without constant action, and that confidence pays off.
“There’s something terrifying about a crime that waits patiently for its moment.”
While Never Strike Twice is clearly part of a series, it functions well on its own. Readers familiar with Oak Creek will feel the emotional callbacks more deeply, but new readers won’t be lost. The writing carries the story with a controlled, assured voice, and even in darker moments, it never feels gratuitous. The horror here comes from intention and inevitability, not shock value.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is a smart, methodical crime thriller that rewards patience and attention. It’s unsettling without being overwhelming, character-driven without losing momentum, and atmospheric in a way that lingers long after the final page. If you enjoy crime novels with cold cases, ritualistic elements, and flawed investigators who refuse to let the past stay buried, this is absolutely one to add to your list.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½ out of 5 stars
#NeverStrikeTwice #AlexSigmore #StormPublishing #BookReview #CrimeThriller #MysteryBooks #ThrillerReads #PsychologicalThriller #NetGalley #ARCReview
February 14, 2026
★★★☆☆ (closer to 2.5)
Never Strike Twice is the second book in the Oak Creek series and sees the small town rocked by the discovery of a body branded with a sinister black symbol. The killing is soon linked to a string of unsolved murders from 24 years earlier, each victim marked in the same way. Newly retired Detective Charlotte Dawes is drawn back into the investigation, having worked the original case as a rookie. As old wounds reopen and patterns begin to emerge, Charlotte must uncover who is behind these calculated crimes before another life is lost.
The central mystery is engaging, and the premise certainly has the bones of a compelling thriller. However, I was confused by the synopsis claim that “every three years, a new victim appears,” as that simply isn’t what happens in the story. The timeline centres on murders from 24 years ago and the present day, so the “every three years” angle feels misleading.
One thing that tends to frustrate me in books aiming to be police procedurals is when investigations clearly ignore legal realities. There’s a scene involving breaking into church outbuildings and then using what was found to obtain a warrant — which wouldn’t realistically hold up. Moments like that pulled me out of the story. I also wasn’t keen on the final explanation of the case being fully spelled out for the reader when there was already enough information available to draw those conclusions independently.
I do think this is a series where reading the first book would help, as the character dynamics and backstory feel assumed rather than fully developed here. The characters themselves are serviceable but somewhat two-dimensional — particularly the victims, who could have been more fleshed out to create greater emotional impact. While the plot moves at a steady pace, the tension never quite builds to the level I was expecting, and a few coincidences make certain revelations feel less earned.
Overall, this is an alright thriller — enjoyable enough while reading, but nothing that particularly sets it apart in a crowded genre. There are some minor inconsistencies and believability issues that proved slightly distracting. I’m genuinely surprised by the number of five-star reviews, as for me this lands closer to a 2.5 than a solid 3.
Thank you to Alex Sigmore, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for the advance copy.
Never Strike Twice is the second book in the Oak Creek series and sees the small town rocked by the discovery of a body branded with a sinister black symbol. The killing is soon linked to a string of unsolved murders from 24 years earlier, each victim marked in the same way. Newly retired Detective Charlotte Dawes is drawn back into the investigation, having worked the original case as a rookie. As old wounds reopen and patterns begin to emerge, Charlotte must uncover who is behind these calculated crimes before another life is lost.
The central mystery is engaging, and the premise certainly has the bones of a compelling thriller. However, I was confused by the synopsis claim that “every three years, a new victim appears,” as that simply isn’t what happens in the story. The timeline centres on murders from 24 years ago and the present day, so the “every three years” angle feels misleading.
One thing that tends to frustrate me in books aiming to be police procedurals is when investigations clearly ignore legal realities. There’s a scene involving breaking into church outbuildings and then using what was found to obtain a warrant — which wouldn’t realistically hold up. Moments like that pulled me out of the story. I also wasn’t keen on the final explanation of the case being fully spelled out for the reader when there was already enough information available to draw those conclusions independently.
I do think this is a series where reading the first book would help, as the character dynamics and backstory feel assumed rather than fully developed here. The characters themselves are serviceable but somewhat two-dimensional — particularly the victims, who could have been more fleshed out to create greater emotional impact. While the plot moves at a steady pace, the tension never quite builds to the level I was expecting, and a few coincidences make certain revelations feel less earned.
Overall, this is an alright thriller — enjoyable enough while reading, but nothing that particularly sets it apart in a crowded genre. There are some minor inconsistencies and believability issues that proved slightly distracting. I’m genuinely surprised by the number of five-star reviews, as for me this lands closer to a 2.5 than a solid 3.
Thank you to Alex Sigmore, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for the advance copy.
April 8, 2026
If you think small towns are peaceful… Oak Creek would like a word. And maybe a body. 👀
There’s something deeply unsettling about a killer who doesn’t rush. One who waits. Plans. Strikes like clockwork. And Never Strike Twice thrives on that quiet, creeping dread.
We’re back in Oak Creek, where a seemingly simple hit-and-run unravels into something far more sinister when a mysterious symbol is discovered burned into the victim’s wrist. And just like that… the past claws its way back.
Enter Detective Mona LaSalle and her mentor, the not-so-retired Charlotte Dawes—because apparently retirement and serial killers don’t believe in clean breaks. 😌
What I absolutely loved here is how personal this case feels. This isn’t just another investigation—it’s unfinished business. A cold case from 25 years ago resurfaces, dragging guilt, memories, and long-buried secrets into the present. And trust me, Oak Creek has a lot buried beneath its quiet charm.
The dynamic between Mona and Charlotte? SO good.
Charlotte is restless, craving the chaos she supposedly left behind, while Mona is stepping into her own—but still haunted by her past and questioning her place. Watching them navigate this case together felt like a perfectly balanced dance between experience and instinct.
And can we talk about the structure of these crimes?
Murders spaced out over years. A pattern. A ritual. A killer playing the longest game imaginable. It scratched that pattern-loving, puzzle-solving part of my brain in the best way 🧩
Add in whispers of cult-like elements, generational secrets, and a town still reeling from previous horrors—and the tension? Deliciously suffocating.
Sigmore doesn’t rush. He lets the suspense simmer, slowly tightening the noose until you’re completely hooked. It’s not just about shocking twists—it’s about inevitability. That eerie feeling that something terrible has been set in motion… and there’s no stopping it.
This is the kind of thriller that pulls you in quietly and then refuses to let go. Atmospheric, character-driven, and layered with just enough darkness to keep you glancing over your shoulder.
⚠️ Highly recommend reading this series in order—and lucky for you, we’re only two books in (for now 👀).
If you love:
🖤 Cold cases colliding with the present
🖤 Small-town secrets
🖤 Cat-and-mouse tension
🖤 Flawed, compelling detectives
…then consider this your next obsession.
I devoured this one—and I’m already waiting (impatiently) for the next trip back to Oak Creek.
There’s something deeply unsettling about a killer who doesn’t rush. One who waits. Plans. Strikes like clockwork. And Never Strike Twice thrives on that quiet, creeping dread.
We’re back in Oak Creek, where a seemingly simple hit-and-run unravels into something far more sinister when a mysterious symbol is discovered burned into the victim’s wrist. And just like that… the past claws its way back.
Enter Detective Mona LaSalle and her mentor, the not-so-retired Charlotte Dawes—because apparently retirement and serial killers don’t believe in clean breaks. 😌
What I absolutely loved here is how personal this case feels. This isn’t just another investigation—it’s unfinished business. A cold case from 25 years ago resurfaces, dragging guilt, memories, and long-buried secrets into the present. And trust me, Oak Creek has a lot buried beneath its quiet charm.
The dynamic between Mona and Charlotte? SO good.
Charlotte is restless, craving the chaos she supposedly left behind, while Mona is stepping into her own—but still haunted by her past and questioning her place. Watching them navigate this case together felt like a perfectly balanced dance between experience and instinct.
And can we talk about the structure of these crimes?
Murders spaced out over years. A pattern. A ritual. A killer playing the longest game imaginable. It scratched that pattern-loving, puzzle-solving part of my brain in the best way 🧩
Add in whispers of cult-like elements, generational secrets, and a town still reeling from previous horrors—and the tension? Deliciously suffocating.
Sigmore doesn’t rush. He lets the suspense simmer, slowly tightening the noose until you’re completely hooked. It’s not just about shocking twists—it’s about inevitability. That eerie feeling that something terrible has been set in motion… and there’s no stopping it.
This is the kind of thriller that pulls you in quietly and then refuses to let go. Atmospheric, character-driven, and layered with just enough darkness to keep you glancing over your shoulder.
⚠️ Highly recommend reading this series in order—and lucky for you, we’re only two books in (for now 👀).
If you love:
🖤 Cold cases colliding with the present
🖤 Small-town secrets
🖤 Cat-and-mouse tension
🖤 Flawed, compelling detectives
…then consider this your next obsession.
I devoured this one—and I’m already waiting (impatiently) for the next trip back to Oak Creek.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
There's something rotten at the heart of Oak Creek, a small town an hour outside of Chicago. A young woman is killed in a hit and run with the initial signs pointing to it being an unfortunate accident - but it doesn't add up. When the body of a young man of the same age is discovered just a few days later, it begins to seem as if a pattern is emerging; not only that but the case might just be linked to a case from twenty five years ago. Fortunately for lead detective Mona LaSalle, the woman who worked that original case - Charlotte Dawes - just happens to be a friend. Together the two race to catch a killer, uncovering dark secrets and fighting their own personal demons along the way.
This was a really compelling read, I was really invested from the outset and I liked the two leading female characters; their pairing isn't exactly a new idea (retired detective called in to consult on current case by young detective who looks up to them) but it is done well and fairly convincingly. Elements of the killings in this book are unusually dark - and the motive especially so; which I appreciated. The pacing was good, which is impressive given its short length - and I loved the highly unusual tie to thousand year old practices in Wales given that the book is set near Chicago; lovely touch.
There was nothing I strongly disliked here; the characters are a little two dimensional - which is understandable for the length of the book, but I felt a few of them (particularly the murder victims) could have been better developed in order to make them more relateable. There's also not a great deal of tension build up, even as the narrative gained pace I didn't really feel any increased urgency. This is book two in a series and I haven't read the first, and there were definitely points at which I felt like I was missing something as a reader, which was a bit of a shame. However, enjoyable read and definitely one to put on your list if you like a darker mystery.
- Thanks to NetGalley for granting me the ARC in exchange for an honest review -
This was a really compelling read, I was really invested from the outset and I liked the two leading female characters; their pairing isn't exactly a new idea (retired detective called in to consult on current case by young detective who looks up to them) but it is done well and fairly convincingly. Elements of the killings in this book are unusually dark - and the motive especially so; which I appreciated. The pacing was good, which is impressive given its short length - and I loved the highly unusual tie to thousand year old practices in Wales given that the book is set near Chicago; lovely touch.
There was nothing I strongly disliked here; the characters are a little two dimensional - which is understandable for the length of the book, but I felt a few of them (particularly the murder victims) could have been better developed in order to make them more relateable. There's also not a great deal of tension build up, even as the narrative gained pace I didn't really feel any increased urgency. This is book two in a series and I haven't read the first, and there were definitely points at which I felt like I was missing something as a reader, which was a bit of a shame. However, enjoyable read and definitely one to put on your list if you like a darker mystery.
- Thanks to NetGalley for granting me the ARC in exchange for an honest review -
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Never Strike Twice opens with a compelling concept: a small town terrorized by murders that occur every three years, each victim marked with the same ominous symbol. The premise promises a tense, time-driven thriller, and the return of retired Detective Charlotte Dawes — who worked the original cases as a rookie — is an intriguing narrative choice.
However, the execution struggled to fully draw me in. By chapter eight, the novel had established a fair amount of backstory surrounding the historical murders, but very little forward momentum. While I understood what happened in the past, it remained unclear what was actively unfolding in the present or why the current investigation felt urgent. The story spends significant time revisiting prior cases and internal reflection, which slows pacing and delays the buildup of suspense.
The procedural elements are detailed, but at times they come at the expense of tension. The recurring three-year pattern is an excellent hook, yet the narrative doesn’t initially capitalize on it to create a sense of imminent danger. As a result, the mystery felt more observational than suspenseful for much of the early portion of the book.
That said, the foundation is solid. Charlotte Dawes is a believable, grounded protagonist, and readers who enjoy methodical investigations and gradual reveals may find the structure more rewarding as the story progresses. The resolution ultimately brings coherence to the pattern and motivations behind the crimes, even if the journey there requires patience.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is a slow-burn procedural with a strong idea at its core, but it may test readers who are looking for early tension, clear stakes, and a stronger sense of present-day urgency. Best suited for readers who prefer atmospheric crime novels over fast-paced thrillers.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
However, the execution struggled to fully draw me in. By chapter eight, the novel had established a fair amount of backstory surrounding the historical murders, but very little forward momentum. While I understood what happened in the past, it remained unclear what was actively unfolding in the present or why the current investigation felt urgent. The story spends significant time revisiting prior cases and internal reflection, which slows pacing and delays the buildup of suspense.
The procedural elements are detailed, but at times they come at the expense of tension. The recurring three-year pattern is an excellent hook, yet the narrative doesn’t initially capitalize on it to create a sense of imminent danger. As a result, the mystery felt more observational than suspenseful for much of the early portion of the book.
That said, the foundation is solid. Charlotte Dawes is a believable, grounded protagonist, and readers who enjoy methodical investigations and gradual reveals may find the structure more rewarding as the story progresses. The resolution ultimately brings coherence to the pattern and motivations behind the crimes, even if the journey there requires patience.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is a slow-burn procedural with a strong idea at its core, but it may test readers who are looking for early tension, clear stakes, and a stronger sense of present-day urgency. Best suited for readers who prefer atmospheric crime novels over fast-paced thrillers.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Huge thanks to Storm Publishing, author Alex Sigmore, and NetGalley for granting me access to the ARC.
This is the second book of the Oak Creek series, and just like the first book, it's fast-paced and gripping throughout. Seeing former detective Charlotte Dawes not being able to adjust to and come to terms with retirement and jumping right back into action with Mona LaSalle on another serial killing case felt like coming back home.
Again, we are following Charlotte Dawes and Mona LaSalle, investigating a series of murders targeting young people. This time, they have to protect
potential future victims while trying to find out the cold-blooded killer behind the murders. On top of the chilling nature of the case, Dawes strongly feels that the case is eerily similar to an unsolved case she worked on 25 years ago, and thus makes it her priority to solve both cases this time, even if it almost kills her.
By the second book, I am now officially a fan of Alex Sigmore's writing; straight to the point, clear, and very easy to get into. I flew through this second book of the series, this time with more familiarity with the characters. That's also why I could empathize with Charlotte Dawes' restlessness as if I were the one who just retired from a lifetime of crime-solving. The connections between now and 25 years ago were masterfully drawn, and the tension kept building further with every chapter. I also loved how Sigmore shed light on how much religious fanaticism can obscure logical thinking, leading to unimaginable acts by regular people.
The only thing I wasn't a fan of was the part where the entire case was "explained" to the reader, even though there was enough information for the reader to make that deduction alone. Other than that, the book delivered pure crime thriller gold, and I really hope the Oak Creek series continues because I don't think I can stay away from Charlotte and Mona for too long!
This is the second book of the Oak Creek series, and just like the first book, it's fast-paced and gripping throughout. Seeing former detective Charlotte Dawes not being able to adjust to and come to terms with retirement and jumping right back into action with Mona LaSalle on another serial killing case felt like coming back home.
Again, we are following Charlotte Dawes and Mona LaSalle, investigating a series of murders targeting young people. This time, they have to protect
potential future victims while trying to find out the cold-blooded killer behind the murders. On top of the chilling nature of the case, Dawes strongly feels that the case is eerily similar to an unsolved case she worked on 25 years ago, and thus makes it her priority to solve both cases this time, even if it almost kills her.
By the second book, I am now officially a fan of Alex Sigmore's writing; straight to the point, clear, and very easy to get into. I flew through this second book of the series, this time with more familiarity with the characters. That's also why I could empathize with Charlotte Dawes' restlessness as if I were the one who just retired from a lifetime of crime-solving. The connections between now and 25 years ago were masterfully drawn, and the tension kept building further with every chapter. I also loved how Sigmore shed light on how much religious fanaticism can obscure logical thinking, leading to unimaginable acts by regular people.
The only thing I wasn't a fan of was the part where the entire case was "explained" to the reader, even though there was enough information for the reader to make that deduction alone. Other than that, the book delivered pure crime thriller gold, and I really hope the Oak Creek series continues because I don't think I can stay away from Charlotte and Mona for too long!
February 6, 2026
I didn't realise when I started this book that it was the second in a series and, although it can be read as a standalone, I did feel that I missed some of the background story.
Retirement wasn't sitting well with ex Detective Charlotte Daws, she wasn't the type to join the local knitting group, or the book club, she was missing the buzz of her job, she was missing the adrenaline rush, what was she going to do with the rest of her life ?
A phone call from a younger ex colleague, asking for help, piqued Charlotte's curiosity. Detective Mona La Salle had a problem, the body of what appeared to be an accidental hit and run had a branding burn on her arm, a branding burn that had been done post mortem, a branding burn that looked like a ritualistic symbol. Mona's first thought was to contact her old colleague for advice, she knew that twenty five years ago, Charlotte had investigated a serial killer, a serial killer who was never caught, a serial killer who had branded his five victims, a case that had haunted Charlotte.
Charlotte's adrenaline started pumping, she was only too glad to help, this couldn't possibly be related to the murders that she had been unable to solve............or could it ?
This story follows Mona, who had grown more confident over the years, she could now take control but wasn't afraid to ask for help, and her still dynamic mentor, it is a gripping story, the tension rises along with the body count, could it possibly add up to five like twenty five years ago ? Charlotte couldn't afford to loose this case, the killer needed to be stopped before he reached his goal and she needed closure.
I really enjoyed this story, I would urge reading the previous book if possible to obtain the most enjoyment but I definitely look forward to any subsequent books in the series.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary.
Retirement wasn't sitting well with ex Detective Charlotte Daws, she wasn't the type to join the local knitting group, or the book club, she was missing the buzz of her job, she was missing the adrenaline rush, what was she going to do with the rest of her life ?
A phone call from a younger ex colleague, asking for help, piqued Charlotte's curiosity. Detective Mona La Salle had a problem, the body of what appeared to be an accidental hit and run had a branding burn on her arm, a branding burn that had been done post mortem, a branding burn that looked like a ritualistic symbol. Mona's first thought was to contact her old colleague for advice, she knew that twenty five years ago, Charlotte had investigated a serial killer, a serial killer who was never caught, a serial killer who had branded his five victims, a case that had haunted Charlotte.
Charlotte's adrenaline started pumping, she was only too glad to help, this couldn't possibly be related to the murders that she had been unable to solve............or could it ?
This story follows Mona, who had grown more confident over the years, she could now take control but wasn't afraid to ask for help, and her still dynamic mentor, it is a gripping story, the tension rises along with the body count, could it possibly add up to five like twenty five years ago ? Charlotte couldn't afford to loose this case, the killer needed to be stopped before he reached his goal and she needed closure.
I really enjoyed this story, I would urge reading the previous book if possible to obtain the most enjoyment but I definitely look forward to any subsequent books in the series.
Thank you Storm Publishing and Net gallery for this ARC, my review is totally voluntary.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Never Strike Twice is a gripping, atmospheric thriller that sinks its hooks in from the very first chapter and refuses to let go. Alex Sigmore delivers a cleverly structured mystery that blends small‑town secrets, ritualistic killings, and a detective who can’t quite outrun the ghosts of her past.
The story centres on Oak Creek, a town still haunted by a series of murders that have remained unsolved for decades. When another body appears—branded with the same chilling symbol as the earlier victims—the quiet façade of the town cracks open once again. The decision to bring retired Detective Charlotte Dawes back into the fold is inspired; she’s seasoned, sharp, and carries just enough emotional baggage to make her compelling without ever slipping into cliché.
What really elevates the book is the rhythm of the murders. The idea of a killer who strikes every three years, almost to the day, gives the narrative a ticking‑clock tension that never lets up. Sigmore uses this structure beautifully, weaving past and present into a pattern Charlotte becomes increasingly desperate to decipher. The pacing is tight, the atmosphere moody, and the sense of inevitability builds with every chapter.
Oak Creek itself feels like a character—insular, watchful, and full of people who know more than they’re willing to say. As Charlotte digs deeper, the layers of the town peel back in a way that feels organic and satisfyingly twisty.
This is a thriller that rewards attention without ever feeling overcomplicated. It’s smart, suspenseful, and anchored by a protagonist you can’t help rooting for. Fans of procedural mysteries with a psychological edge will find a lot to love here.
A tense, well‑crafted page‑turner that kept me guessing right up to the final reveal. I’ll be thinking about this one for a while.
with thanks to Alex Sigmore, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
The story centres on Oak Creek, a town still haunted by a series of murders that have remained unsolved for decades. When another body appears—branded with the same chilling symbol as the earlier victims—the quiet façade of the town cracks open once again. The decision to bring retired Detective Charlotte Dawes back into the fold is inspired; she’s seasoned, sharp, and carries just enough emotional baggage to make her compelling without ever slipping into cliché.
What really elevates the book is the rhythm of the murders. The idea of a killer who strikes every three years, almost to the day, gives the narrative a ticking‑clock tension that never lets up. Sigmore uses this structure beautifully, weaving past and present into a pattern Charlotte becomes increasingly desperate to decipher. The pacing is tight, the atmosphere moody, and the sense of inevitability builds with every chapter.
Oak Creek itself feels like a character—insular, watchful, and full of people who know more than they’re willing to say. As Charlotte digs deeper, the layers of the town peel back in a way that feels organic and satisfyingly twisty.
This is a thriller that rewards attention without ever feeling overcomplicated. It’s smart, suspenseful, and anchored by a protagonist you can’t help rooting for. Fans of procedural mysteries with a psychological edge will find a lot to love here.
A tense, well‑crafted page‑turner that kept me guessing right up to the final reveal. I’ll be thinking about this one for a while.
with thanks to Alex Sigmore, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Rounded down 3.75 ⭐
Never Strike Twice is the continuation of the pairing of Detective Mona LaSalle and retired Detective Charlotte Dawes. I previously read the first book in this duet, The Darkest Game, and loved it. In this story, LaSalle is called to the scene where a body of a young woman is thought to be the victim of a hit and run. Upon closer inspection, LaSalle discovers a symbol branded on the woman's arm. As she researches, she discovers that a similar case happened 25 years ago, and one of the detectives was her friend, Charlotte Dawes.
Dawes is struggling with being retired, so when LaSalle asks her to consult on this case, Dawes agrees. Both women are internally struggling with where their lives go after what happened in book 1. As they work together there are many interesting elements that seem to be pertinent to this case. I loved the use of an ancient Wales religion! They eventually identify a pattern and connect the victims to a cultish kind of group!
This is a slow burn book that is equally focused on plot and characters. I believe that you really need to read the first book so that you understand these characters better. I enjoyed this book, but not quite as much as the first. I felt that at times it relied too much on the internal struggles of Dawes, and not as much on LaSalle, who I feel is the more interesting of the two. The pacing for the most part is steady, but there wasn't as much development of the victims characters as in the previous book, and so I was very interested in the case, but missed the connection that I felt in the first novel.
That being said, it still kept my attention for both the mystery and the characters. Enough so that I want to see what happens with LaSalle! This is a dark read, and slow burn!
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Never Strike Twice is the continuation of the pairing of Detective Mona LaSalle and retired Detective Charlotte Dawes. I previously read the first book in this duet, The Darkest Game, and loved it. In this story, LaSalle is called to the scene where a body of a young woman is thought to be the victim of a hit and run. Upon closer inspection, LaSalle discovers a symbol branded on the woman's arm. As she researches, she discovers that a similar case happened 25 years ago, and one of the detectives was her friend, Charlotte Dawes.
Dawes is struggling with being retired, so when LaSalle asks her to consult on this case, Dawes agrees. Both women are internally struggling with where their lives go after what happened in book 1. As they work together there are many interesting elements that seem to be pertinent to this case. I loved the use of an ancient Wales religion! They eventually identify a pattern and connect the victims to a cultish kind of group!
This is a slow burn book that is equally focused on plot and characters. I believe that you really need to read the first book so that you understand these characters better. I enjoyed this book, but not quite as much as the first. I felt that at times it relied too much on the internal struggles of Dawes, and not as much on LaSalle, who I feel is the more interesting of the two. The pacing for the most part is steady, but there wasn't as much development of the victims characters as in the previous book, and so I was very interested in the case, but missed the connection that I felt in the first novel.
That being said, it still kept my attention for both the mystery and the characters. Enough so that I want to see what happens with LaSalle! This is a dark read, and slow burn!
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
February 5, 2026
Mona is called in to a strange hit-and-run in town. Noticing a weird symbol burned into the victims wrist, she realises things aren't exactly what they seem. After some digging she finds one other case from 25 years ago with burns in the victims as well, and tries to connect the dots from the past to present day with the same detective from the previous case, her mentor Charlotte.
*****
This is the second book in the series, and after the twist and turns of the last one and finding Mona's serial murderer parent, I wasn't sure how this one would be able to pull off the same big investigation in such a small town. I was delightfully surprised that not only did we get a flash into young Charlotte and the unsolved case that haunted her career, but also Mona slowly coming out of her shell in current day and landing another big case.
Adding in the twist of underlying religious cults, secrets that have been in the small town since before it's inception, and Mona feeling the undercurrent of what her father trained her to be coming back to the surface, and I was hooked! This one had a great fast pace, dual POV's of both FMC's as they solved the case, and the same style of the last novel where background characters did the more police work that didn't advance the story as much, while Mona and Charlotte tackled the main investigation to really keep everything moving along and exciting.
All in all, I loved this one, and I can't wait to see what else the author does!
*****
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
*****
This is the second book in the series, and after the twist and turns of the last one and finding Mona's serial murderer parent, I wasn't sure how this one would be able to pull off the same big investigation in such a small town. I was delightfully surprised that not only did we get a flash into young Charlotte and the unsolved case that haunted her career, but also Mona slowly coming out of her shell in current day and landing another big case.
Adding in the twist of underlying religious cults, secrets that have been in the small town since before it's inception, and Mona feeling the undercurrent of what her father trained her to be coming back to the surface, and I was hooked! This one had a great fast pace, dual POV's of both FMC's as they solved the case, and the same style of the last novel where background characters did the more police work that didn't advance the story as much, while Mona and Charlotte tackled the main investigation to really keep everything moving along and exciting.
All in all, I loved this one, and I can't wait to see what else the author does!
*****
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I was so excited to see another book in this series! I really enjoyed the first one, and this one would be just as good. Detective Charlotte Dawes returns to Oak Creek at Mona LaSalle’s request due to similarities between her newest case and one that Charlotte investigated 25 years ago. Charlotte may be retired, but she’s not adjusting well, and she’s thrilled to be involved as a consultant on this one, even though it brings back dark memories of that case. It involved five victims with their throats and necks cut and mysterious burn marks on their forearms. The body that was just found has a strange symbol branded into the flesh on the – you guessed it – forearm.
There’s the usual ‘is it or is it not related’ before everyone finally agrees that it must be, especially when the next victim is found. Then it’s a matter of determining what the victims have in common. And when they realize what it is, they believe they have it all figured out. But it’s never that simple, is it? And in Mona and Charlotte’s case, it’s much darker and more macabre than they ever imagined.
It’s great to see Mona and Charlotte working together again, and hopefully, there will be more from these characters in the future. Although, really, how much more violence can one little town take! But I guess, based on what we learn about the history of Oak Creek in this book, there could be plenty more craziness in the future. That was a cool element to introduce, and of course, I had to look up just how to pronounce the Welsh words.
So glad I read this follow-up, and you’ll have to do the same!
There’s the usual ‘is it or is it not related’ before everyone finally agrees that it must be, especially when the next victim is found. Then it’s a matter of determining what the victims have in common. And when they realize what it is, they believe they have it all figured out. But it’s never that simple, is it? And in Mona and Charlotte’s case, it’s much darker and more macabre than they ever imagined.
It’s great to see Mona and Charlotte working together again, and hopefully, there will be more from these characters in the future. Although, really, how much more violence can one little town take! But I guess, based on what we learn about the history of Oak Creek in this book, there could be plenty more craziness in the future. That was a cool element to introduce, and of course, I had to look up just how to pronounce the Welsh words.
So glad I read this follow-up, and you’ll have to do the same!
February 8, 2026
Mona is a young detective who is still trying to overcome being known as the daughter of a serial killer. She has a different approach than most to cases and while beginning to investigate her newest murder case, she feels that there may be some similarities to a case that retired detective Charlotte worked on many years ago that remains unsolved. She enlists Charlotte’s help with her case and feels it may be beneficial for the both of them to have her insight. As they dive deeper into the investigation, things get more and more dangerous.
This is the second book of the Oak Creek series. I have not yet read the first and feel that it would have been beneficial, but not completely necessary. I felt that the author gave enough background that I did not feel like I was completely in the dark having missed a lot of details. This story was a bit of a slow start but quickly intensified in terms of action and detail. By the second half of the book, I could not put it down. Mona is quirky as the FMC and I think this shined a light on how different the thought process can be. The author has a gift for throwing in twists to knock you off of the track you believe you’re on to figuring out the killer. The details of the murders were descriptive and well thought out. I didn’t see some aspects of the ending coming. By the end of the story I did feel like I needed a story map to connect all of the people and aspects of the case. This is a great story for those who like puzzles! *Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance copy in exchange for an honest review!
This is the second book of the Oak Creek series. I have not yet read the first and feel that it would have been beneficial, but not completely necessary. I felt that the author gave enough background that I did not feel like I was completely in the dark having missed a lot of details. This story was a bit of a slow start but quickly intensified in terms of action and detail. By the second half of the book, I could not put it down. Mona is quirky as the FMC and I think this shined a light on how different the thought process can be. The author has a gift for throwing in twists to knock you off of the track you believe you’re on to figuring out the killer. The details of the murders were descriptive and well thought out. I didn’t see some aspects of the ending coming. By the end of the story I did feel like I needed a story map to connect all of the people and aspects of the case. This is a great story for those who like puzzles! *Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance copy in exchange for an honest review!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Set in Oak Creek, the gripping crime thriller centres on Detective Mona LaSalle as she is drawn into a new case that slowly reveals unsettling connections to a case newly retired Charlotte Dawes worked 25 years earlier- a case that was never solved and never truly forgotten.
Mona and Charlotte’s relationship, already established in the first Oak Creek book, brings emotional depth and credibility to the investigation. Charlotte’s experience with the original case complements Mona’s instincts in the present, and their shared determination to finally uncover the truth drives the story forward. Their bond is rooted in trust, shared trauma, and a mutual refusal to let the victims be forgotten.
The pacing is steady and tense, with a growing sense of unease as the body count rises and the pattern behind the murders becomes clearer. Rather than relying purely on shock, Never Strike Twice builds suspense through atmosphere, character, and the unsettling idea that some killers never stop.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is a compelling blend of procedural crime and psychological suspense. It works amazingly well as a standalone but is especially enjoyable if you are familiar with the Oak Creek series and follow the personal and shared character development between Mina and Charlotte. As with the first novel, The Darkest Game, I flew through this so quickly- the writing style, the plot and the characters coming together to offer a fantastic addition to the Oak Creek series.
Mona and Charlotte’s relationship, already established in the first Oak Creek book, brings emotional depth and credibility to the investigation. Charlotte’s experience with the original case complements Mona’s instincts in the present, and their shared determination to finally uncover the truth drives the story forward. Their bond is rooted in trust, shared trauma, and a mutual refusal to let the victims be forgotten.
The pacing is steady and tense, with a growing sense of unease as the body count rises and the pattern behind the murders becomes clearer. Rather than relying purely on shock, Never Strike Twice builds suspense through atmosphere, character, and the unsettling idea that some killers never stop.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is a compelling blend of procedural crime and psychological suspense. It works amazingly well as a standalone but is especially enjoyable if you are familiar with the Oak Creek series and follow the personal and shared character development between Mina and Charlotte. As with the first novel, The Darkest Game, I flew through this so quickly- the writing style, the plot and the characters coming together to offer a fantastic addition to the Oak Creek series.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The latest murder in Oak Creek where a body marked with a strange black symbol reopens a string of cold cases that once haunted the town. With the killings matching a series of ritualistic murders from years earlier, retired detective Charlotte Dawes is pulled back into the investigation she first encountered as a rookie. As she works alongside the younger detective now leading the case, Charlotte uncovers a chilling pattern, the killer strikes on a precise cycle, leaving bodies like clockwork. The blend of folklore inspired motives, atmospheric tension, and a killer who seems to follow an ancient timetable gives the story a unique edge that sets it apart from typical small town thrillers.
What makes Never Strike Twice so gripping is the way it balances procedural detail with psychological unease. The pacing stays taut as the murders escalate, and the shifting timelines and clues create a sense of inevitability that keeps the reader fully engaged. Charlotte and Mona make a compelling duo, and the deeper they dig, the more disturbing the truth becomes. Smart, moody, and filled with twists that land, this instalment is a strong addition to the Oak Creek series, equally satisfying for returning readers and newcomers who enjoy crime fiction with a dark, methodical heartbeat. Very enjoyable.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy, all opinions expressed are my own.
What makes Never Strike Twice so gripping is the way it balances procedural detail with psychological unease. The pacing stays taut as the murders escalate, and the shifting timelines and clues create a sense of inevitability that keeps the reader fully engaged. Charlotte and Mona make a compelling duo, and the deeper they dig, the more disturbing the truth becomes. Smart, moody, and filled with twists that land, this instalment is a strong addition to the Oak Creek series, equally satisfying for returning readers and newcomers who enjoy crime fiction with a dark, methodical heartbeat. Very enjoyable.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy, all opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Twenty five years ago, Charlotte Dawes, then a newbie detective was called to the scene of a gory mass murder. Five young people killed and displayed in an abandoned iron foundry. Despite catching the killer, it’s something that has continued to haunt her.
Fast forward to today and Charlotte , newly-retired, is finding it difficult to adjust to her new found freedom. A call from Mona Lasalle, someone she has worked with previously, sees her meeting up with her to discuss a current case she is involved in. This time there is only one body, but there are striking similarities to the case she worked on twenty-five years ago.
Never Strike Twice is a clever, well-constructed novel that totally involves the reader. At the very start of this case, the deceased is a hit and run. It is only when a second body is discovered that a pattern begins to emerge and Mona contacts Charlotte for assistance. But how can this be connected, when the original case is twenty-five years old and the perpetrator has been caught
Gradually a pattern begins to emerge, and through interviews, progress is made. It certainly isn’t fast paced, it takes its time. It is slower and more methodical. This gives the reader time to absorb the detail and in some ways I found this made the story more interesting.
I really enjoyed the read and look forward to more from Alex Sigmore.
My thanks to Storm, the author and Netgalley for an ARC of Never Strike Twice in exchange for an honest review.
Fast forward to today and Charlotte , newly-retired, is finding it difficult to adjust to her new found freedom. A call from Mona Lasalle, someone she has worked with previously, sees her meeting up with her to discuss a current case she is involved in. This time there is only one body, but there are striking similarities to the case she worked on twenty-five years ago.
Never Strike Twice is a clever, well-constructed novel that totally involves the reader. At the very start of this case, the deceased is a hit and run. It is only when a second body is discovered that a pattern begins to emerge and Mona contacts Charlotte for assistance. But how can this be connected, when the original case is twenty-five years old and the perpetrator has been caught
Gradually a pattern begins to emerge, and through interviews, progress is made. It certainly isn’t fast paced, it takes its time. It is slower and more methodical. This gives the reader time to absorb the detail and in some ways I found this made the story more interesting.
I really enjoyed the read and look forward to more from Alex Sigmore.
My thanks to Storm, the author and Netgalley for an ARC of Never Strike Twice in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Never Strike Twice delivers a solid, gritty crime thriller with a premise that hooks quickly and keeps the pages turning, but it doesn’t quite rise above the genre’s familiar beats. Sigmore clearly knows how to build tension, and the darker tone of the story is one of its strengths—there’s a persistent sense of menace that works well, especially in the investigation scenes.
The plot moves at a steady pace, with enough twists to maintain interest, though some of them feel predictable if you’re a seasoned crime reader. The central mystery is engaging, but it occasionally relies on coincidences that make certain revelations feel less earned. The title’s theme is compelling, yet the story doesn’t always explore it as deeply as it could have.
Character-wise, the protagonist is capable and believable, but a bit underdeveloped emotionally. Secondary characters serve their purpose in advancing the plot, though few truly stand out or linger after the final chapter. The dialogue is serviceable, if sometimes stiff, and the prose is clean but rarely memorable.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is an enjoyable, dark crime novel that satisfies in the moment without leaving a lasting impact. It’s a decent pick if you’re in the mood for a straightforward thriller, but readers looking for deeper character work or a more original take may find it falls slightly short.
The plot moves at a steady pace, with enough twists to maintain interest, though some of them feel predictable if you’re a seasoned crime reader. The central mystery is engaging, but it occasionally relies on coincidences that make certain revelations feel less earned. The title’s theme is compelling, yet the story doesn’t always explore it as deeply as it could have.
Character-wise, the protagonist is capable and believable, but a bit underdeveloped emotionally. Secondary characters serve their purpose in advancing the plot, though few truly stand out or linger after the final chapter. The dialogue is serviceable, if sometimes stiff, and the prose is clean but rarely memorable.
Overall, Never Strike Twice is an enjoyable, dark crime novel that satisfies in the moment without leaving a lasting impact. It’s a decent pick if you’re in the mood for a straightforward thriller, but readers looking for deeper character work or a more original take may find it falls slightly short.
January 10, 2026
Primero que nada, muchísimas gracias Net Galley por darme la oportunidad de leerlo!
Mona, una detective, es llamada a una escena del crimen donde yace muerta una joven con un extraño símbolo en su brazo. Poco a poco, van ocurriendo más asesinatos, cada víctima con un símbolo distinto. Luego de investigar, se dan cuenta de que estas mismas marcas fueron encontradas en un caso sin resolver de hace 25 años.
¡Qué libro más bueno! Comencé sin muchas expectativas y me sorprendió un montón. Quedas enganchado desde la primera página y no puedes soltarlo hasta terminarlo, ¡yo lo leí en menos de 24 horas!
A medida que van apareciendo más víctimas y más evidencia, uno cree que ya sabe quién es el culpable. Sin embargo, ese final no lo adivinaras para nada.
A pesar de eso, debo admitir que hubo algunas cosas que no entendí, pero supongo que se debe a que este es el segundo libro de la serie y, lamentablemente, me di cuenta muy tarde y no leí el primero. Aun así, después de leer este libro, estoy deseando leer el anterior.
Debo advertirles que se describen escenas bastante grotescas y muy gráficas, así que si no te gustan ese tipo de cosas, tenlo en cuenta antes de leer el libro. En definitiva, es un thriller adictivo que definitivamente recomiendo si te gustan las historias oscuras y llenas de giros.
Mona, una detective, es llamada a una escena del crimen donde yace muerta una joven con un extraño símbolo en su brazo. Poco a poco, van ocurriendo más asesinatos, cada víctima con un símbolo distinto. Luego de investigar, se dan cuenta de que estas mismas marcas fueron encontradas en un caso sin resolver de hace 25 años.
¡Qué libro más bueno! Comencé sin muchas expectativas y me sorprendió un montón. Quedas enganchado desde la primera página y no puedes soltarlo hasta terminarlo, ¡yo lo leí en menos de 24 horas!
A medida que van apareciendo más víctimas y más evidencia, uno cree que ya sabe quién es el culpable. Sin embargo, ese final no lo adivinaras para nada.
A pesar de eso, debo admitir que hubo algunas cosas que no entendí, pero supongo que se debe a que este es el segundo libro de la serie y, lamentablemente, me di cuenta muy tarde y no leí el primero. Aun así, después de leer este libro, estoy deseando leer el anterior.
Debo advertirles que se describen escenas bastante grotescas y muy gráficas, así que si no te gustan ese tipo de cosas, tenlo en cuenta antes de leer el libro. En definitiva, es un thriller adictivo que definitivamente recomiendo si te gustan las historias oscuras y llenas de giros.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Never Strike Twice by Alex Sigmore is a gripping, dark crime thriller and a strong second installment in the Oak Creek series.
This book pulled me in quickly with its chilling premise: a modern-day murder marked by a disturbing symbol that echoes a gruesome case from 25 years earlier. The connection between past and present is handled really well, slowly unfolding in a way that keeps the tension high. The investigation feels methodical and realistic, and while the subject matter is dark—with some non-graphic gore—it never feels gratuitous.
What truly makes this story shine is the partnership between Mona LaSalle and retired detective Charlotte Dawes. They make an excellent team, balancing experience with fresh perspective, and I loved the mutual respect and trust between them. Their dynamic adds emotional depth to the procedural elements and makes the story feel grounded. The inclusion of Welsh folklore and ritualistic elements gives the mystery an extra layer of intrigue and sets it apart from more standard serial-killer thrillers.
Overall, this is an immersive, well-written crime novel with strong characters, a clever mystery, and a steadily building sense of unease. Fans of procedural thrillers with a dark edge will really enjoy this one.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.
This book pulled me in quickly with its chilling premise: a modern-day murder marked by a disturbing symbol that echoes a gruesome case from 25 years earlier. The connection between past and present is handled really well, slowly unfolding in a way that keeps the tension high. The investigation feels methodical and realistic, and while the subject matter is dark—with some non-graphic gore—it never feels gratuitous.
What truly makes this story shine is the partnership between Mona LaSalle and retired detective Charlotte Dawes. They make an excellent team, balancing experience with fresh perspective, and I loved the mutual respect and trust between them. Their dynamic adds emotional depth to the procedural elements and makes the story feel grounded. The inclusion of Welsh folklore and ritualistic elements gives the mystery an extra layer of intrigue and sets it apart from more standard serial-killer thrillers.
Overall, this is an immersive, well-written crime novel with strong characters, a clever mystery, and a steadily building sense of unease. Fans of procedural thrillers with a dark edge will really enjoy this one.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is the second Oak Creek Thriller in the series, and having finished it, I can only hope there’s more to come—though I dread to think what else could possibly happen in that poor, long-suffering little town. Oak Creek is rapidly establishing itself as somewhere you’d visit briefly… and leave at speed.
I enjoyed spending time with Detectives Mona LaSalle and Charlotte Dawes: a ‘rookie’ with a ‘novel’ personality (not the most original history, but at least a different lens), paired with a retired Chicago ‘consultant’ who is very clearly incapable of actually retiring. The characters are a little flat at present, but I’m choosing to believe—optimistically—that they’ll gain some depth as the series progresses.
The plot is solid enough, but it’s the writing that really does the heavy lifting. Sigmore is an assured, confident storyteller, and that experience shows on the page, even when the story itself occasionally plays it safe.
“Never Strike Twice” will appeal to readers who enjoy crime novels led by flawed, determined women who refuse to quit, give in, or quietly accept the soul-numbing monotony of everyday life.
My thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC of “Never Strike Twice” by Alex Sigmore.
I enjoyed spending time with Detectives Mona LaSalle and Charlotte Dawes: a ‘rookie’ with a ‘novel’ personality (not the most original history, but at least a different lens), paired with a retired Chicago ‘consultant’ who is very clearly incapable of actually retiring. The characters are a little flat at present, but I’m choosing to believe—optimistically—that they’ll gain some depth as the series progresses.
The plot is solid enough, but it’s the writing that really does the heavy lifting. Sigmore is an assured, confident storyteller, and that experience shows on the page, even when the story itself occasionally plays it safe.
“Never Strike Twice” will appeal to readers who enjoy crime novels led by flawed, determined women who refuse to quit, give in, or quietly accept the soul-numbing monotony of everyday life.
My thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the ARC of “Never Strike Twice” by Alex Sigmore.
February 5, 2026
NEVER STRIKE TWICE, #2 - Another interesting, immersing story with good characters, a bit of non-graphic gore and Welsh folklore. Mona and Charlie make a good team. Source: Netgalley and Storm. 4*
THE DARKEST GAME, #1 - This is an unexpected, delightful surprise. The subject matters are dark but the interesting characters, intriguing story lines and the author's writing style made for an immersing read. The two female detectives worked well with each other, and in a way, helped with healing themselves. Source: Netgalley. 5*
THE FORGOTTEN WIFE - A bit too wordy and repetitive making it difficult to keep reading sometimes. I found Winter to be a stupid person in her thoughts and actions. Getting drunk and then wanting to search the house while her husband Fenton is there is an example. She's an annoying person and doesn't pick up on what Fen is actually telling her, knowing his family and her being an engineer she should click on the subtleties. Laura has a bit of mystery to her, what's her game? She was not what I expected. The story did get better and it has interesting story lines, good characters, some actually likeable, and a little unpredictability, along with the usual predictables. Source: Netgalley and Storm Publishing.
THE DARKEST GAME, #1 - This is an unexpected, delightful surprise. The subject matters are dark but the interesting characters, intriguing story lines and the author's writing style made for an immersing read. The two female detectives worked well with each other, and in a way, helped with healing themselves. Source: Netgalley. 5*
THE FORGOTTEN WIFE - A bit too wordy and repetitive making it difficult to keep reading sometimes. I found Winter to be a stupid person in her thoughts and actions. Getting drunk and then wanting to search the house while her husband Fenton is there is an example. She's an annoying person and doesn't pick up on what Fen is actually telling her, knowing his family and her being an engineer she should click on the subtleties. Laura has a bit of mystery to her, what's her game? She was not what I expected. The story did get better and it has interesting story lines, good characters, some actually likeable, and a little unpredictability, along with the usual predictables. Source: Netgalley and Storm Publishing.
February 9, 2026
The actual story started 25 years ago when a newly appointed detective, Charlotte Dawes, failed to solve 5 murders that still haunt her today, and now retired, gets a call from Mona LaSalle, whom she has previously worked with, asking for details of the 25-year-old murder that was never solved, as Mona feels these are connected. They take on Charlotte as a consultant, so no badge, but even Charlotte has her doubts whether they are connected, but rather than stay at home fiddling with her thumbs, she agrees to help. With the first murder, it is classed as a hit and run, but Mona knew that it was not; it was murder, but when another young body appears, a different type of killing to confuse the police, using a different method, that is when it looks like a repeat of the 25yrs old crime, and what they were all thinking were there 3 more to go, and what of the church that seems to use pagan rites still has this anything to do with the crimes.
Very good read; the author keeps you wanting to keep reading, but I had the feeling I had read this story before. I did wonder whether the author changed the title and the cover, but that has not been mentioned, so there must be another book with virtually the same style of story.
Worth a read, you would not be disappointed.
Very good read; the author keeps you wanting to keep reading, but I had the feeling I had read this story before. I did wonder whether the author changed the title and the cover, but that has not been mentioned, so there must be another book with virtually the same style of story.
Worth a read, you would not be disappointed.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is the second book set in Oak Creek. In the first installment, we met Mona, a local detective, and Charlotte, an experienced detective who came from Chicago to assist with a complex case. The two women developed a strong bond, and when Mona discovers potential links between her current case and one of Charlotte’s cold cases, she calls on her for help.
The first book was incredibly suspenseful, and I hoped the author would manage to keep me glued to the story again—and I can confidently say he absolutely did!
A serial killer is known for using the same method and targeting a certain type of victim. But what was happening here? Multiple killers or a particularly cunning perpetrator? Time will tell…
It was enjoyable to see Mona’s growth, and to say Charlotte isn’t tough would be a gross understatement.
What drives someone to commit these murders? As is often the case, trauma and a heartbreaking story lie at the root.
Justice comes to those who can wait, but it’s always best not to take matters into your own hands—alert the police and let them do their job.
I’m definitely looking forward to book three. Five stars.
Thank you.
The first book was incredibly suspenseful, and I hoped the author would manage to keep me glued to the story again—and I can confidently say he absolutely did!
A serial killer is known for using the same method and targeting a certain type of victim. But what was happening here? Multiple killers or a particularly cunning perpetrator? Time will tell…
It was enjoyable to see Mona’s growth, and to say Charlotte isn’t tough would be a gross understatement.
What drives someone to commit these murders? As is often the case, trauma and a heartbreaking story lie at the root.
Justice comes to those who can wait, but it’s always best not to take matters into your own hands—alert the police and let them do their job.
I’m definitely looking forward to book three. Five stars.
Thank you.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Sinister and disturbing are two words that come to mind when I think about this thriller. The first chapter, that was filled with descriptions of the bodies, was creepy and chilling, which immediately let me know that this was going to be one of those books that hooked me and held on tight until I finished it.
A hit and run victim seems to be a case of open and close. Although it is a tragedy, the only thing left to do is find the driver, but Detective Mona LaSalle sees something that makes her realize there is a lot more to this story. It is eerily similar to a cold case from 25 years ago.
This terrifying thriller was addictive and binge worthy. The characters are awesome. I loved the two female detectives who are so good at their job, even though one is "retired". They are tough and tenacious. They had other male detectives, but these ladies led the charge, and led it well. There is something dark going on in Oak Creek, and there is no one better to solve this mystery than this dynamic duo.
Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A hit and run victim seems to be a case of open and close. Although it is a tragedy, the only thing left to do is find the driver, but Detective Mona LaSalle sees something that makes her realize there is a lot more to this story. It is eerily similar to a cold case from 25 years ago.
This terrifying thriller was addictive and binge worthy. The characters are awesome. I loved the two female detectives who are so good at their job, even though one is "retired". They are tough and tenacious. They had other male detectives, but these ladies led the charge, and led it well. There is something dark going on in Oak Creek, and there is no one better to solve this mystery than this dynamic duo.
Thank you to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 5, 2026
Never Strike Twice
by Alex Sigmore
Pub Date: Feb 05 2026
Never Strike Twice by Alex Sigmor, is the high-octane second installment in the Detective Silas Warren series. It follows the events of the debut, Strike Me Dead, and solidifies Silas Warren as a standout "grit-and-intellect" protagonist. The story finds Detective Silas Warren attempting to move on from the trauma of his previous case when a new, terrifying pattern emerges. A killer is targeting victims in a way that mimics lightning strikes—random, fast, and devastating—but with a level of calculation that suggests a deeply personal vendetta. As the bodies pile up, Silas must navigate a web of local corruption and his own fraying mental state to stop a murderer who seems to be playing a long game of psychological torture.
Unfortunately I had not read the first book in the Detective Silas Warren series but I was able to still enjoy this book. I plan on reading the first book as this book was very good. I liked the character, Silas, he's really very good at his job, he's very likable. I liked the pacing of the book and also the short chapters. I do recommend this book.
by Alex Sigmore
Pub Date: Feb 05 2026
Never Strike Twice by Alex Sigmor, is the high-octane second installment in the Detective Silas Warren series. It follows the events of the debut, Strike Me Dead, and solidifies Silas Warren as a standout "grit-and-intellect" protagonist. The story finds Detective Silas Warren attempting to move on from the trauma of his previous case when a new, terrifying pattern emerges. A killer is targeting victims in a way that mimics lightning strikes—random, fast, and devastating—but with a level of calculation that suggests a deeply personal vendetta. As the bodies pile up, Silas must navigate a web of local corruption and his own fraying mental state to stop a murderer who seems to be playing a long game of psychological torture.
Unfortunately I had not read the first book in the Detective Silas Warren series but I was able to still enjoy this book. I plan on reading the first book as this book was very good. I liked the character, Silas, he's really very good at his job, he's very likable. I liked the pacing of the book and also the short chapters. I do recommend this book.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
My Review:
Never Strike Twice is a police/crime thriller revisiting
Oak Creek. It is book 2 of the Oak Creek Thriller series. It is a standalone book as I did not read book 1, The Darkest Game.
The book immediately grabbed my attention and brings the reader back to 25 years ago. I could not put it down and finished in 1 day! I enjoyed following retired Detective Charlotte Dawes to Oak Creek.
There were twists and turns around every corner.
I gave this book a 4.5 stars as I was not disappointed at all. The book was a great read and kept me on the edge of my seat. I was able to read book 2 despite not reading book 1 however I do feel I need to go back to read book 1, The Darkest Game. There some occasions in the book that it is clear there is some minor details that I don't understand since I didn't read the first book. My recommendation is to start with book 1 if you have the chance. I will be adding Alex Sigmore books to my TBR list for sure! If you enjoy crime/police/serial killers you will love this book!
I highly recommend this book!!
Never Strike Twice is a police/crime thriller revisiting
Oak Creek. It is book 2 of the Oak Creek Thriller series. It is a standalone book as I did not read book 1, The Darkest Game.
The book immediately grabbed my attention and brings the reader back to 25 years ago. I could not put it down and finished in 1 day! I enjoyed following retired Detective Charlotte Dawes to Oak Creek.
There were twists and turns around every corner.
I gave this book a 4.5 stars as I was not disappointed at all. The book was a great read and kept me on the edge of my seat. I was able to read book 2 despite not reading book 1 however I do feel I need to go back to read book 1, The Darkest Game. There some occasions in the book that it is clear there is some minor details that I don't understand since I didn't read the first book. My recommendation is to start with book 1 if you have the chance. I will be adding Alex Sigmore books to my TBR list for sure! If you enjoy crime/police/serial killers you will love this book!
I highly recommend this book!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews