What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lumber Baron's Wife
Not yet published
Expected 14 Apr 26When the young wife of a powerful lumber baron vanishes into the wilds of frontier Michigan, her friend is left to unravel the truth in this captivating dual-timeline novel from bestselling author Lynn Austin.
1873. After a devastating loss, Hannah Wagner never imagined she’d leave her comfortable home for the harsh, unfamiliar wilderness near Lake Michigan. But when Henry Abernathy, a friend of her husband, John, offers them a fresh start in a booming lumber town, where John’s skills as a doctor are sorely needed, Hannah reluctantly agrees. There, she meets Kate Abernathy, Henry’s spirited, much younger wife. Kate’s sharp tongue and outsider status have made her unwelcome among the town’s elite, and when she begins confiding in Hannah, it’s clear her marriage is not what it seems . . . and that a secret from her past could destroy everything.
Present day. Ashley Gilbert never planned to settle in Michigan, but when her husband lands his dream job as a conservationist, she agrees to follow. While restoring their historic home—built in the 19th-century for a doctor and his wife—Ashley becomes captivated by its past and its connection to the nearby Abernathy mansion, now being transformed into a museum. While volunteering with the restoration, she stumbles upon the unsolved mystery of Kate Abernathy’s disappearance. What begins as curiosity soon becomes a quest for the truth—one that will connect her to two women whose stories and struggles echo and inspire her own.
Standalone historical fiction about marriage, grief, and the power of female friendships from the author of All My Secrets and Long Way HomeA richly layered Christian women’s fiction novel with elements of mystery, perfect for fans of Martha Hall Kelly, Kristy Cambron, and Susan MeissnerIncludes discussion questions for book clubs
1873. After a devastating loss, Hannah Wagner never imagined she’d leave her comfortable home for the harsh, unfamiliar wilderness near Lake Michigan. But when Henry Abernathy, a friend of her husband, John, offers them a fresh start in a booming lumber town, where John’s skills as a doctor are sorely needed, Hannah reluctantly agrees. There, she meets Kate Abernathy, Henry’s spirited, much younger wife. Kate’s sharp tongue and outsider status have made her unwelcome among the town’s elite, and when she begins confiding in Hannah, it’s clear her marriage is not what it seems . . . and that a secret from her past could destroy everything.
Present day. Ashley Gilbert never planned to settle in Michigan, but when her husband lands his dream job as a conservationist, she agrees to follow. While restoring their historic home—built in the 19th-century for a doctor and his wife—Ashley becomes captivated by its past and its connection to the nearby Abernathy mansion, now being transformed into a museum. While volunteering with the restoration, she stumbles upon the unsolved mystery of Kate Abernathy’s disappearance. What begins as curiosity soon becomes a quest for the truth—one that will connect her to two women whose stories and struggles echo and inspire her own.
Standalone historical fiction about marriage, grief, and the power of female friendships from the author of All My Secrets and Long Way HomeA richly layered Christian women’s fiction novel with elements of mystery, perfect for fans of Martha Hall Kelly, Kristy Cambron, and Susan MeissnerIncludes discussion questions for book clubs
368 pages, Paperback
Expected publication April 14, 2026
1045 people want to read
About the author
Lynn Austin
70 books5,742 followersFor many years, Lynn Austin nurtured a desire to write but frequent travels and the demands of her growing family postponed her career. When her husband's work took Lynn to Bogota, Colombia, for two years, she used the B.A. she'd earned at Southern Connecticut State University to become a teacher. After returning to the U.S., the Austins moved to Anderson, Indiana, Thunder Bay, Ontario, and later to Winnipeg, Manitoba.
It was during the long Canadian winters at home with her children that Lynn made progress on her dream to write, carving out a few hours of writing time each day while her children napped. Lynn credits her early experience of learning to write amid the chaos of family life for her ability to be a productive writer while making sure her family remains her top priority.
Extended family is also very important to Austin, and it was a lively discussion between Lynn, her mother, grandmother (age 98), and daughter concerning the change in women's roles through the generations that sparked the inspiration for her novel Eve's Daughters.
Along with reading, two of Lynn's lifelong passions are history and archaeology. While researching her Biblical fiction series, Chronicles of the Kings, these two interests led her to pursue graduate studies in Biblical Backgrounds and Archaeology through Southwestern Theological Seminary. She and her son traveled to Israel during the summer of 1989 to take part in an archaeological dig at the ancient city of Timnah. This experience contributed to the inspiration for her novel Wings of Refuge.
Lynn resigned from teaching to write full-time in 1992. Since then she has published 27 novels. Eight of her historical novels, Hidden Places, Candle in the Darkness, Fire by Night, A Proper Pursuit, and Until We Reach Home have won Christy Awards in 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008, and 2009 for excellence in Christian Fiction. Fire by Night was also one of only five inspirational fiction books chosen by Library Journal for their top picks of 2003, and All She Ever Wanted was chosen as one of the five inspirational top picks of 2005. Lynn's novel Hidden Places has been made into a movie for the Hallmark Channel, starring actress Shirley Jones. Ms Jones received a 2006 Emmy Award nomination for her portrayal of Aunt Batty in the film.
It was during the long Canadian winters at home with her children that Lynn made progress on her dream to write, carving out a few hours of writing time each day while her children napped. Lynn credits her early experience of learning to write amid the chaos of family life for her ability to be a productive writer while making sure her family remains her top priority.
Extended family is also very important to Austin, and it was a lively discussion between Lynn, her mother, grandmother (age 98), and daughter concerning the change in women's roles through the generations that sparked the inspiration for her novel Eve's Daughters.
Along with reading, two of Lynn's lifelong passions are history and archaeology. While researching her Biblical fiction series, Chronicles of the Kings, these two interests led her to pursue graduate studies in Biblical Backgrounds and Archaeology through Southwestern Theological Seminary. She and her son traveled to Israel during the summer of 1989 to take part in an archaeological dig at the ancient city of Timnah. This experience contributed to the inspiration for her novel Wings of Refuge.
Lynn resigned from teaching to write full-time in 1992. Since then she has published 27 novels. Eight of her historical novels, Hidden Places, Candle in the Darkness, Fire by Night, A Proper Pursuit, and Until We Reach Home have won Christy Awards in 2002, 2003, 2004, 2008, and 2009 for excellence in Christian Fiction. Fire by Night was also one of only five inspirational fiction books chosen by Library Journal for their top picks of 2003, and All She Ever Wanted was chosen as one of the five inspirational top picks of 2005. Lynn's novel Hidden Places has been made into a movie for the Hallmark Channel, starring actress Shirley Jones. Ms Jones received a 2006 Emmy Award nomination for her portrayal of Aunt Batty in the film.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews
March 20, 2026
I have enjoyed Lynn Austin's historical fiction books for many years. She does a wonderful job at weaving historical accuracy with dimensional characters and clear themes of faith.
I was drawn to this particular story because of the unique premise and the setting close to my own home. It's 1873 and Hannah and her doctor husband decide to leave the comfort of New York to settle among a newly established lumber town on the shores of Lake Michigan. Hoping to get a fresh start and heal from grief, Hannah and John soon find their new friends (an area Lumber Baron and his young wife) might get them entangled in more drama than they expected. When tragedy strikes & the wife mysteriously disappears, Hannah finds the deepest pain can be redeemed into the healing.
Jump forward to the present day Ashley and her husband are looking to settle in that same Michigan town 150 years later. As they work through marriage tensions, financial struggles, and an unexpected surprise, Ashley finds clues to the mystery of the Lumber Baron's that might finally lead to the truth.
I appreciated the clear themes of Gospel forgiveness & redemption, true friendship, and the inherent value of life. I also was interested in the elements of historical home restoration and valuing & caring for nature.
But overall, I found the story to be a bit drawn out for my preferences. I was repeatedly frustrated by the relationship of Ashley and her husband and their inability to communicate through the tensions. I also was uncomfortable with how their "surprise" was handled, even though they came to a good decision at the end.
😇: Tyndale Publisher; strong themes of gospel forgiveness, bible study represented, positive portrayal of Christian community
💋: nothing explicit on-page; marriage intimacy alluded to; the characters investigate a supposed brothel
🤐: no language!
Content considerations: off-page death of children, physical abuse in marriage, assault referenced off-page, abortion discussed, drinking
Thank you to the publisher for a complimentary book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed are completely my own.
I was drawn to this particular story because of the unique premise and the setting close to my own home. It's 1873 and Hannah and her doctor husband decide to leave the comfort of New York to settle among a newly established lumber town on the shores of Lake Michigan. Hoping to get a fresh start and heal from grief, Hannah and John soon find their new friends (an area Lumber Baron and his young wife) might get them entangled in more drama than they expected. When tragedy strikes & the wife mysteriously disappears, Hannah finds the deepest pain can be redeemed into the healing.
Jump forward to the present day Ashley and her husband are looking to settle in that same Michigan town 150 years later. As they work through marriage tensions, financial struggles, and an unexpected surprise, Ashley finds clues to the mystery of the Lumber Baron's that might finally lead to the truth.
I appreciated the clear themes of Gospel forgiveness & redemption, true friendship, and the inherent value of life. I also was interested in the elements of historical home restoration and valuing & caring for nature.
But overall, I found the story to be a bit drawn out for my preferences. I was repeatedly frustrated by the relationship of Ashley and her husband and their inability to communicate through the tensions. I also was uncomfortable with how their "surprise" was handled, even though they came to a good decision at the end.
😇: Tyndale Publisher; strong themes of gospel forgiveness, bible study represented, positive portrayal of Christian community
💋: nothing explicit on-page; marriage intimacy alluded to; the characters investigate a supposed brothel
🤐: no language!
Content considerations: off-page death of children, physical abuse in marriage, assault referenced off-page, abortion discussed, drinking
Thank you to the publisher for a complimentary book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed are completely my own.
November 24, 2025
I have read and loved some of Lynn Austin’s historical fiction backlist so I was thrilled to see that she has a new intriguing title coming out in 2026. Though I enjoyed the book overall, there are a couple of things that prevented this from being an exceptional reading experience for me.
Kate, the lumber baron’s wife, often reminded me of a modern teenager in terms of her vocabulary and behavior. To me, it just took me out of the historical time period far too often.
I appreciated the prevalent pro-life theme throughout the book, but have to say there was a point of concern when the youth minister and his wife are said to have tried IVF with no success. Christians need to be educating themselves more on the moral implications of IVF. Do we celebrate the lives that are a result of this practice? Yes, absolutely we do, but that doesn’t mean we should be promoting that which is not God’s design. If you’re unaware of all the concerning issues surrounding IVF, I encourage you to check out Katy Faust’s research through her organization Them Before Us. Thousands of babies are just sitting on ice likely never to be born. All that being said, I do still think the book has positive qualities.
What I liked:
* The Gospel is presented beautifully.
* pro-life message
* Dual timeline
Thank you, Tyndale House for a complimentary e-ARC of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Kate, the lumber baron’s wife, often reminded me of a modern teenager in terms of her vocabulary and behavior. To me, it just took me out of the historical time period far too often.
I appreciated the prevalent pro-life theme throughout the book, but have to say there was a point of concern when the youth minister and his wife are said to have tried IVF with no success. Christians need to be educating themselves more on the moral implications of IVF. Do we celebrate the lives that are a result of this practice? Yes, absolutely we do, but that doesn’t mean we should be promoting that which is not God’s design. If you’re unaware of all the concerning issues surrounding IVF, I encourage you to check out Katy Faust’s research through her organization Them Before Us. Thousands of babies are just sitting on ice likely never to be born. All that being said, I do still think the book has positive qualities.
What I liked:
* The Gospel is presented beautifully.
* pro-life message
* Dual timeline
Thank you, Tyndale House for a complimentary e-ARC of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
September 29, 2025
(I received a complimentary copy of this title. All opinions are my own.)
I was so excited to read Lynn Austin’s upcoming release! Lynn Austin writes wonderful Christian fiction, and “The Lumber Baron’s Wife” will be one of the most exciting releases this coming spring.
This story is set in Michigan in the 1870’s and also in present day Michigan. There are three points of view in this story, and I found each one to be really enjoyable!
This story has very strong faith themes, rich history, and mystery. 🙌🏻
I prefer to leave content warnings off of my reviews to avoid potential spoilers, but I do keep track of them. This book does have some content that may be difficult for some to read. If you would like a list of content warnings, please feel free to let me know in the comments or send me a DM. Happy to help you. ❤️
Another great Christian historical fiction! Definitely recommend!
I was so excited to read Lynn Austin’s upcoming release! Lynn Austin writes wonderful Christian fiction, and “The Lumber Baron’s Wife” will be one of the most exciting releases this coming spring.
This story is set in Michigan in the 1870’s and also in present day Michigan. There are three points of view in this story, and I found each one to be really enjoyable!
This story has very strong faith themes, rich history, and mystery. 🙌🏻
I prefer to leave content warnings off of my reviews to avoid potential spoilers, but I do keep track of them. This book does have some content that may be difficult for some to read. If you would like a list of content warnings, please feel free to let me know in the comments or send me a DM. Happy to help you. ❤️
Another great Christian historical fiction! Definitely recommend!
September 13, 2025
Lynn Austin is an auto-read for me, and The Lumber Baron’s Wife reminded me why. I cared equally about both timelines, which is rare for split-time fiction.
In 1870s Michigan, Hannah Wagner’s grief and self-imposed isolation intersect with Kate Abernathy, a young woman with a troubled past who doesn’t fit in. In the present, Ashley Gilbert moves to Michigan for her husband David’s conservationist job and uncovers Kate’s mysterious disappearance while restoring a historic home. Each woman has a relatable struggle, whether it’s their ache for a stable home, need for acceptance, or the right words to share their faith. Hannah is the character who showed the most growth, and I admired her honest self-reflection toward the end of the book. David, though? His selfishness, like Henry Abernathy’s, grated on me, proving Austin’s skill for crafting flawed, believable characters.
The Christian threads are strong. The story promotes the sanctity of life, serving your neighbor, and witnessing to unbelievers. One of the most memorable scenes is when Ruth, the chaplain’s wife, explains salvation through a courtroom picture: Kate pleads guilty, but Jesus steps in, saying, “Father, I’ll take her guilt. Let me take her place,” and the judge declares, “Justice has been served. You’re free to go” (Romans 8:1, ESV). In doctrinal terms, the act itself illustrates substitutionary atonement—Christ taking the sinner’s penalty—while the verdict captures justification, God’s legal declaration that the sinner is free and righteous in Christ. ❤️
I also value how much I learned through the story. The narrative traces Michigan’s white pine era and the human costs of the lumber boom, the rhythms of Great Lakes life, and how national events like the Great Chicago Fire drove demand for lumber and reshaped communities.
I recommend this to readers of Christian historical fiction, to longtime Lynn Austin fans, and to book clubs. It would pair nicely with Jocelyn Green’s Veiled in Smoke, which mentions the Great Chicago Fire.
Content notes: emotional and physical abuse, drinking, prostitution, abortion.
Disclosure: I received a copy from the publisher and was not required to leave a review. The opinions are my own.
In 1870s Michigan, Hannah Wagner’s grief and self-imposed isolation intersect with Kate Abernathy, a young woman with a troubled past who doesn’t fit in. In the present, Ashley Gilbert moves to Michigan for her husband David’s conservationist job and uncovers Kate’s mysterious disappearance while restoring a historic home. Each woman has a relatable struggle, whether it’s their ache for a stable home, need for acceptance, or the right words to share their faith. Hannah is the character who showed the most growth, and I admired her honest self-reflection toward the end of the book. David, though? His selfishness, like Henry Abernathy’s, grated on me, proving Austin’s skill for crafting flawed, believable characters.
The Christian threads are strong. The story promotes the sanctity of life, serving your neighbor, and witnessing to unbelievers. One of the most memorable scenes is when Ruth, the chaplain’s wife, explains salvation through a courtroom picture: Kate pleads guilty, but Jesus steps in, saying, “Father, I’ll take her guilt. Let me take her place,” and the judge declares, “Justice has been served. You’re free to go” (Romans 8:1, ESV). In doctrinal terms, the act itself illustrates substitutionary atonement—Christ taking the sinner’s penalty—while the verdict captures justification, God’s legal declaration that the sinner is free and righteous in Christ. ❤️
I also value how much I learned through the story. The narrative traces Michigan’s white pine era and the human costs of the lumber boom, the rhythms of Great Lakes life, and how national events like the Great Chicago Fire drove demand for lumber and reshaped communities.
I recommend this to readers of Christian historical fiction, to longtime Lynn Austin fans, and to book clubs. It would pair nicely with Jocelyn Green’s Veiled in Smoke, which mentions the Great Chicago Fire.
Content notes: emotional and physical abuse, drinking, prostitution, abortion.
Disclosure: I received a copy from the publisher and was not required to leave a review. The opinions are my own.
March 17, 2026
The Lumber Baron's Wife by Lynn Austin is a beautifully written story of faith, compassion, redemption & healing.
This dual timeline book follows the lives of Kate Abernathy, the young, "wild" wife of a wealthy lumber baron,
Hannah Wagner, the doctor's wife who is dealing with the loss of her 3 children and having to leave her home where they are buried. Once she arrived in Michigan she is asked to groom Kate in the late 1800's.
In present time Ashley Gilbert, gives up her career dreams and moves to Michigan so her husband can take a dream job as a conservationist. She falls in love with a historic home built during the lumber boom owned by John & Hannah Wagner in a western Lake Michigan town She convinces her husband to purchase it and starts to dig into it's history as well as the history and restoration of the home nearby that belonged to Lumber Baron, Henry Abernathy and the mystery that surrounds it.
The book portrays the lumber industry, social expectations and the hard decisions each of the women have to make.
What makes this book stand out is its quiet yet powerful message: redemption is possible even in the most broken circumstances.
Overall, The Lumber Baron's Wife is a moving and thoughtful novel for those who enjoy historical fiction with strong faith themes, meaningful character, and a deeply hopeful message. It is a reminder that God can work through even the most painful situations to bring about healing and new beginnings.
Lynn tackles some difficult topics such as abortion, abuse, death & mental illness but as always does it with such grace. The book is truly amazing and the end justifies the means.
Favorite lines in the book:
"The Choices we make are very important. Regret can be a very heavy weight to get out from under."
"Birth and death, sorrow and joy, suffering and peace came tangled together in this precarious dance of life."
Thank you Lynn Austin for giving me the opportunity to ARC read this beautiful story in exchange for an honest review.
This dual timeline book follows the lives of Kate Abernathy, the young, "wild" wife of a wealthy lumber baron,
Hannah Wagner, the doctor's wife who is dealing with the loss of her 3 children and having to leave her home where they are buried. Once she arrived in Michigan she is asked to groom Kate in the late 1800's.
In present time Ashley Gilbert, gives up her career dreams and moves to Michigan so her husband can take a dream job as a conservationist. She falls in love with a historic home built during the lumber boom owned by John & Hannah Wagner in a western Lake Michigan town She convinces her husband to purchase it and starts to dig into it's history as well as the history and restoration of the home nearby that belonged to Lumber Baron, Henry Abernathy and the mystery that surrounds it.
The book portrays the lumber industry, social expectations and the hard decisions each of the women have to make.
What makes this book stand out is its quiet yet powerful message: redemption is possible even in the most broken circumstances.
Overall, The Lumber Baron's Wife is a moving and thoughtful novel for those who enjoy historical fiction with strong faith themes, meaningful character, and a deeply hopeful message. It is a reminder that God can work through even the most painful situations to bring about healing and new beginnings.
Lynn tackles some difficult topics such as abortion, abuse, death & mental illness but as always does it with such grace. The book is truly amazing and the end justifies the means.
Favorite lines in the book:
"The Choices we make are very important. Regret can be a very heavy weight to get out from under."
"Birth and death, sorrow and joy, suffering and peace came tangled together in this precarious dance of life."
Thank you Lynn Austin for giving me the opportunity to ARC read this beautiful story in exchange for an honest review.
March 25, 2026
This was THE book that finally got me out of a reading slump! The cover matches the story perfectly in that it’s darker/heavier but so so beautiful!
Setting it as a split time mystery, Lynn Austin wrote her all of her main characters already married which gave the book a different feel than most other Christian fiction out there — I loved that aspect! The reader gets pulled into the marriages right away and gets to experience how each work through various trials.
I’m left with the message of how we can truly touch and bring light into other peoples lives by sharing our faith and pouring out Gods love onto them, no matter who they are.
The Lumber Barons Wife is now rivaling for the top spot as my favorite Lynn Austin novel. Definitely read this one!
** Trigger warnings: marital abuse, child loss, parent loss, infertility, brief mention of attempted rape (non descriptive), conversations regarding abortion and IVF, brothels and prostitution (non descriptive)
Setting it as a split time mystery, Lynn Austin wrote her all of her main characters already married which gave the book a different feel than most other Christian fiction out there — I loved that aspect! The reader gets pulled into the marriages right away and gets to experience how each work through various trials.
I’m left with the message of how we can truly touch and bring light into other peoples lives by sharing our faith and pouring out Gods love onto them, no matter who they are.
The Lumber Barons Wife is now rivaling for the top spot as my favorite Lynn Austin novel. Definitely read this one!
** Trigger warnings: marital abuse, child loss, parent loss, infertility, brief mention of attempted rape (non descriptive), conversations regarding abortion and IVF, brothels and prostitution (non descriptive)
December 8, 2025
Once again Lynn Austin hits it out of the park. She is a go to author for me. I love her historical stories because they bring to light little known times and people. The Lumber Barons devastated Michigan in their greed to have more. Austin points this out and how important it is to think of nature while using it.
3 women's stories are intertwined with each other. 2 in the 1800's as they each try to find their way. Heather who is grieving the loss of her 3 young children and Kate who is a young wife to one of the Lumber Baron's who past did not prepare her for life on a millionaire. The 3rd who is trying to figure out what she wants out of life. After moving to Michigan with her husband, Ashley is at loose ends as to what to do to support not only her husband, but to also help their family.
Beautifully written, this story kept my attention the whole entire book. Maybe partly because it is set in my home state, but mostly because it is an interesting story that shows we can learn and support each other even when we are separated by time.
3 women's stories are intertwined with each other. 2 in the 1800's as they each try to find their way. Heather who is grieving the loss of her 3 young children and Kate who is a young wife to one of the Lumber Baron's who past did not prepare her for life on a millionaire. The 3rd who is trying to figure out what she wants out of life. After moving to Michigan with her husband, Ashley is at loose ends as to what to do to support not only her husband, but to also help their family.
Beautifully written, this story kept my attention the whole entire book. Maybe partly because it is set in my home state, but mostly because it is an interesting story that shows we can learn and support each other even when we are separated by time.
January 26, 2026
4.5 stars this was gooooood
The mystery kept me going! And I connected to both timelines loved loved loved
The mystery kept me going! And I connected to both timelines loved loved loved
September 23, 2025
Another stellar read by Lynn Austin! An engaging dual timeline story with an unsolved mystery, interesting history, and relationship issues at its core. Set in Michigan in a town built on the lumber industry, between 1873-4 and present day.
A well-written and perfectly paced story that managed to touch on deep issues relevant to today. The marriages in both time periods had serious difficulties that had me wanting to pray for the characters, they felt so real. The friendship between Hannah and Kate was especially touching and convicting at times. It made me think about what it means to truly be a good friend to someone who is different, addressing fears, and reaching out to others who are struggling with faith and hope. The house restoration project was an interesting way to bring out the history of the area and delve into the mystery. Loved how it brought people together and paralleled the personal restoration and faith journey of Hannah.
Highly recommend to readers who enjoy books with flawed characters, faith and hope. 5 stars!
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are completely my own.)
A well-written and perfectly paced story that managed to touch on deep issues relevant to today. The marriages in both time periods had serious difficulties that had me wanting to pray for the characters, they felt so real. The friendship between Hannah and Kate was especially touching and convicting at times. It made me think about what it means to truly be a good friend to someone who is different, addressing fears, and reaching out to others who are struggling with faith and hope. The house restoration project was an interesting way to bring out the history of the area and delve into the mystery. Loved how it brought people together and paralleled the personal restoration and faith journey of Hannah.
Highly recommend to readers who enjoy books with flawed characters, faith and hope. 5 stars!
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are completely my own.)
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Lumber Baron's Wife was my first book by Lynn Austin. I had been wanting to read a book of hers for quite some time, and when I saw this book was releasing, I was eager to read it. I read this book as a buddy read, which I found helped me pull so much additional depth from the story as we discussed. Check out my buddy's review as well (@hotcocoaandbooks)
The first chapter of the book definitely made me say "Hmm", as we learn something quite shocking about one of the characters right off of the bat. I really wasn't sure what to expect after that, and was not super hopeful about where it was going. A few more chapters in, however, I was fully hooked into the story, and had a hard time putting the book down. There was just enough mystery and suspense to keep me engaged, while not getting into anything dark or sinister (I don't care for murder mysteries type plots).
The story was told through dual timelines and multiple points of view. In the 1875 timeline, Hannah and Kate's perspective alternates, with much of Kate's story being told through her journal entries, while Hanna's perspective is more narrative. The current day timeline is told through Ashley's perspective. Ashley becomes connected to Hannah and Kate when she moves to a former logging town in Michigan, and ends up buying a historic home and helping to restore the mansion, that has become famous from the mystery surrounding it's former first lady who went missing and was never found. I enjoy the way that the author tied the three women's stories together, and showed us new glimpses of their stories, bringing to light new information in layers.
I found the 1875 lumber town setting extremely fascinating. The book had great historical features, and there were so many little historical details included that you'll feel immersed in the story. I particularly loved the minute details about the style of the houses, even down to the floor tiles, wood trim, and stenciling details. As a lover of home decor, this part of the story really captivated me. I enjoyed how the characters in Ashley's timeline worked to restore the mansion, and that process that they went through.
There were really great characters in the story, like Hannah and Ashley, but also some very off putting characters like Henry, and David. As much as I distrusted and disliked Henry, who is Kate's much older millionaire husband in 1875, I was disgusted by David, who is Ashley's husband in the current day timeline. David was selfish, immature, and bordered very closely to emotionally abusive (in my opinion). While he did have a bit of a redemptive arc by the end of the story, I was largely disappointed in how his and Ashley's story ended.
There were some strong faith moments throughout the story. Kate and Ashley both seem to be searching for God, and are surrounded by characters, like Hannah, who help them along their journey. There was an opportunity for Ashley to have a beautiful salvation arc, but that did feel like a missed opportunity by the end of the book. I enjoyed Kate's arc, but hoped for more at the end. It was a bittersweet ending all around, but felt like it was a bit rushed, and I would have liked to see more about the characters' healing on page. The loose ends were technically tied up, but it did not feel as resolved as I would have liked.
What I enjoyed about the story:
🪵 1870's Michigan lumber town setting
🪵 Historical home details & refurbishment
🪵 Dual timeline, tripple POV
🪵 Gritty, hard moments
🪵 Strong faith content (God's timing)
🪵 A very colorful character
⚠️ Content Warnings:
- Spousal abuse (physical & emotional) & manipulation, missing person, abduction, abortion/child loss, adoption, fire devastation, grief
This book can be hard to read at some points, but the grapple will leave you with so much to unpack. There is real struggle and grit present in multiple storylines, and the characters go through hard things. The faith held all things together, as we saw God working behind the scenes in both His timing and how he orchestrated people and events together to work things out for His good.
My rating: 4 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐
I recommend this story for those who enjoy a strong historical fiction with a lot of grit. If you are easily triggered, this may be one to skip, though I feel the author handled each difficult topic with care. I think sometimes reading a book like this that is hard is important, because it reminds us that everyone is managing their own set of troubles, and we don't always know what other people are facing. We can show love and acceptance to people, even when we can't see how the Lord is using us to minister to someone else. I look forward to reading more books by this author!
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The first chapter of the book definitely made me say "Hmm", as we learn something quite shocking about one of the characters right off of the bat. I really wasn't sure what to expect after that, and was not super hopeful about where it was going. A few more chapters in, however, I was fully hooked into the story, and had a hard time putting the book down. There was just enough mystery and suspense to keep me engaged, while not getting into anything dark or sinister (I don't care for murder mysteries type plots).
The story was told through dual timelines and multiple points of view. In the 1875 timeline, Hannah and Kate's perspective alternates, with much of Kate's story being told through her journal entries, while Hanna's perspective is more narrative. The current day timeline is told through Ashley's perspective. Ashley becomes connected to Hannah and Kate when she moves to a former logging town in Michigan, and ends up buying a historic home and helping to restore the mansion, that has become famous from the mystery surrounding it's former first lady who went missing and was never found. I enjoy the way that the author tied the three women's stories together, and showed us new glimpses of their stories, bringing to light new information in layers.
I found the 1875 lumber town setting extremely fascinating. The book had great historical features, and there were so many little historical details included that you'll feel immersed in the story. I particularly loved the minute details about the style of the houses, even down to the floor tiles, wood trim, and stenciling details. As a lover of home decor, this part of the story really captivated me. I enjoyed how the characters in Ashley's timeline worked to restore the mansion, and that process that they went through.
There were really great characters in the story, like Hannah and Ashley, but also some very off putting characters like Henry, and David. As much as I distrusted and disliked Henry, who is Kate's much older millionaire husband in 1875, I was disgusted by David, who is Ashley's husband in the current day timeline. David was selfish, immature, and bordered very closely to emotionally abusive (in my opinion). While he did have a bit of a redemptive arc by the end of the story, I was largely disappointed in how his and Ashley's story ended.
There were some strong faith moments throughout the story. Kate and Ashley both seem to be searching for God, and are surrounded by characters, like Hannah, who help them along their journey. There was an opportunity for Ashley to have a beautiful salvation arc, but that did feel like a missed opportunity by the end of the book. I enjoyed Kate's arc, but hoped for more at the end. It was a bittersweet ending all around, but felt like it was a bit rushed, and I would have liked to see more about the characters' healing on page. The loose ends were technically tied up, but it did not feel as resolved as I would have liked.
What I enjoyed about the story:
🪵 1870's Michigan lumber town setting
🪵 Historical home details & refurbishment
🪵 Dual timeline, tripple POV
🪵 Gritty, hard moments
🪵 Strong faith content (God's timing)
🪵 A very colorful character
⚠️ Content Warnings:
- Spousal abuse (physical & emotional) & manipulation, missing person, abduction, abortion/child loss, adoption, fire devastation, grief
This book can be hard to read at some points, but the grapple will leave you with so much to unpack. There is real struggle and grit present in multiple storylines, and the characters go through hard things. The faith held all things together, as we saw God working behind the scenes in both His timing and how he orchestrated people and events together to work things out for His good.
My rating: 4 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐
I recommend this story for those who enjoy a strong historical fiction with a lot of grit. If you are easily triggered, this may be one to skip, though I feel the author handled each difficult topic with care. I think sometimes reading a book like this that is hard is important, because it reminds us that everyone is managing their own set of troubles, and we don't always know what other people are facing. We can show love and acceptance to people, even when we can't see how the Lord is using us to minister to someone else. I look forward to reading more books by this author!
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.75 stars
When I first saw the cover for this book, I knew I had to read it. The fact that I was chosen to read the ARC, made me quite happy! It has been a while since I have read a Lynn Austin book. I've always loved her writing with its depth and history.
The book takes place in the 1870s and current day. It starts out sounding like there is going to be a mystery of sorts because we get a reveal that is shocking. Kate is the wife of a lumber baron, has gone missing. Hannah is in shock to hear about her friend being gone.
Hannah backtracks into her memories about where Kate might be or what might have happened to her. She is living in Brooklyn, NY with her husband John. They have lost their three children to an illness and are really suffering in spirit. John is a doctor and Hannah feels like it is his fault that the children didn't survive or even received their illness due to him. It was heartbreaking to read. He wants to give her a change of scenery and give them a new start by moving them out to Michigan with his friend Henry and his brand-new wife Kate, who is quite young.
Kate writes diary entries. Sometimes her entries are an echo of Hannah's experiences but through Kate's perspective. It is slightly repetitive at time, but her entries are not too long and are important to the story anyway.
The modern-day perspective comes from Ashley. She has been married for three years to David, who works in ecology and trying to preserve nature. He loves his job a lot. She restores houses and loves the history that they hold. He wants to move them to Michigan, and they are trying to decide where to live once they get there. She falls in love with an old house from the late 1870s and wants to buy it, while David wants a more modern house that costs more money. She also wants to work on restoring the lumber baron's home. She meets a woman named Freida who is spunky and gets her involved in the community.
Each of these women have their own pains and problems.
The story did seem to go a little slowly at first, but halfway through, it became more action packed, had things in it that I truly enjoyed learning about, and was filled with heartbreak but also a lot of grace and growth.
I really loved the character of Kate. She was so kind and gentle. She was very caring for others throughout the story, even if she wasn't really into wanting to be prim and proper. It was just really great to see how calm she could be in hard moments! Hannah definitely learned a lot from her when you'd think that Hannah would have taught Kate a lot. They had a good friendship even if they were so very different.
As for Ashley, my heart really felt for her in this story. I didn't like her husband much at all the entire book but at least the story about the acorn affected him (if you read it, you'll know).
I think this book would have many triggers for people, but it was good and I enjoyed it all. I didn't like the ending though. I wanted to explore more. I wanted to know more about what happened to different characters (several). I just felt the ending was in need of more (in the epilogue).
I thought there was a good amount of talk about faith in this story. There is a lot of talk about prayer, God, finding Jesus, and how His love can help guide us.
content: There are deaths of children and people throughout this book that are talked about. There is talk about domestic abuse and people getting injuries as well. There is talk about infertility, talk about abortions and the trauma left because of them, talk about attempted rape, talk about murder, talk about burlesques and mentions of prostitution (and people looking down on them).
When I first saw the cover for this book, I knew I had to read it. The fact that I was chosen to read the ARC, made me quite happy! It has been a while since I have read a Lynn Austin book. I've always loved her writing with its depth and history.
The book takes place in the 1870s and current day. It starts out sounding like there is going to be a mystery of sorts because we get a reveal that is shocking. Kate is the wife of a lumber baron, has gone missing. Hannah is in shock to hear about her friend being gone.
Hannah backtracks into her memories about where Kate might be or what might have happened to her. She is living in Brooklyn, NY with her husband John. They have lost their three children to an illness and are really suffering in spirit. John is a doctor and Hannah feels like it is his fault that the children didn't survive or even received their illness due to him. It was heartbreaking to read. He wants to give her a change of scenery and give them a new start by moving them out to Michigan with his friend Henry and his brand-new wife Kate, who is quite young.
Kate writes diary entries. Sometimes her entries are an echo of Hannah's experiences but through Kate's perspective. It is slightly repetitive at time, but her entries are not too long and are important to the story anyway.
The modern-day perspective comes from Ashley. She has been married for three years to David, who works in ecology and trying to preserve nature. He loves his job a lot. She restores houses and loves the history that they hold. He wants to move them to Michigan, and they are trying to decide where to live once they get there. She falls in love with an old house from the late 1870s and wants to buy it, while David wants a more modern house that costs more money. She also wants to work on restoring the lumber baron's home. She meets a woman named Freida who is spunky and gets her involved in the community.
Each of these women have their own pains and problems.
The story did seem to go a little slowly at first, but halfway through, it became more action packed, had things in it that I truly enjoyed learning about, and was filled with heartbreak but also a lot of grace and growth.
I really loved the character of Kate. She was so kind and gentle. She was very caring for others throughout the story, even if she wasn't really into wanting to be prim and proper. It was just really great to see how calm she could be in hard moments! Hannah definitely learned a lot from her when you'd think that Hannah would have taught Kate a lot. They had a good friendship even if they were so very different.
As for Ashley, my heart really felt for her in this story. I didn't like her husband much at all the entire book but at least the story about the acorn affected him (if you read it, you'll know).
I think this book would have many triggers for people, but it was good and I enjoyed it all. I didn't like the ending though. I wanted to explore more. I wanted to know more about what happened to different characters (several). I just felt the ending was in need of more (in the epilogue).
I thought there was a good amount of talk about faith in this story. There is a lot of talk about prayer, God, finding Jesus, and how His love can help guide us.
content: There are deaths of children and people throughout this book that are talked about. There is talk about domestic abuse and people getting injuries as well. There is talk about infertility, talk about abortions and the trauma left because of them, talk about attempted rape, talk about murder, talk about burlesques and mentions of prostitution (and people looking down on them).
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Lumber Baron’s Wife by Lynn Austin, I enjoyed this book but not as much as I enjoyed some of her previous books it has two POV‘s Ashley and current day and Hanna in 1874. There’s also the POV of Katie‘s diary so I guess there’s three POV. OK Hanna is still morning over the loss of her three children due to malaria and as it’s the 1800s despite her husband John being a doctor she lost all three of them. when her husband‘s old army buddy Henry comes to visit he also comes with his wife Katie who’s 20 years younger than him and a proposition for John and Hanna to move to Michigan from Brooklyn to a town that is booming with lumber. Hanna doesn’t want to go but loves her husband or at least wants to love him and so she thinks maybe a change of scenery will do her well and so she goes. Soon after they arrive he even bills him a beautiful house but with Henry comes his much younger, insecure, baudy, brutally honest, ignorant wife Katie.. I don’t call her ignorant to be mean there’s just things about the upper crust she doesn’t know until Henry begs Hanna to help her out with that and although reluctant Hanna does in they even become great friends. They become so close Hanna starts believing maybe Henry is abusing her new much younger friend. In current day Ashley and husband David have been married for three years and he’s finally found a job that fuels his passion and so they make a long distance move to Michigan she is an army brat who has moved many times in her life and just wants a place to belong David on the other hand grew up in a run down trailer thinking his dad who he had fond memories of just abandoned them. The two are very different but love each other immensely even when it comes to picking their home where David wants a sleek brand new house Ashley is shown Hanna‘s 150 year-old Victorian and falls in love with it. Ashley is a historian but unfortunately there’s no museum jobs available nor museums in the area. OK let me stop here because this book is supposed to be about Hanna and her friend who goes missing but let me just say Katie doesn’t go missing too much later in the book and I mean much later Ashley and David move in to Hanna‘s home now they’re home and things go from pretty good to pretty bad for both couples the ones in the present and the ones in the past. The ending however is picture perfect and something you always get with a book by the author. I absolutely love the ending I really did enjoy this book the these are the things I didn’t like Katie seemed like such a smart cookie but even when Hanna would tell her not to dress provocative she did it anyway when she tried to give her helpful advice sometimes she took it and sometimes she didn’t not to mention Katie has a dark secret that she tells Hanna about leaving Hanna speechless to save the lease but soon her past will come to find her and eventually the past won’t be the only thing looking for Katie. In the current day book the thing that bothered me was that Ashley gets pregnant and David wants her to have an abortion and she’s thinking about it but all I could think is had I aborted my first child how could I look the second in the eye and just say it’s just byluck that you’re here. Either way it was still a good book that was just some things that irked me about it but I am still a big fan of Lynn Austin books because this is the first i’ve ever had issue with. I still recommend it because my irks aren’t going to be yours. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Dual timelines provide the framework for Lynn Austin’s new Historical Fiction gem, THE LUMBER BARON’s WIFE. Featuring a trio of resilient women, readers will be inspired by their strength, determination and courage in the face of life altering tragedy.
1873 - John and Hannah’s marriage is floundering. Altho’ they still love each other, the loss of their children has shaken their foundation, including their faith. An offer from Henry, a war buddy of John’s, now a millionaire lumber mill owner from Michigan, gives them an opportunity for a new beginning. John, a doctor, will become the doctor for all Henry’s mill workers and loggers, along with their families. Hannah has been strongly invited to take care of the baron’s new bride, Kate. She is young and ill prepared to take her social place alongside the prominent businessman. This will be an interesting relationship to watch!
Present Day - Ashley and David are on their way Michigan. He has landed what he believes is a lifelong dream job. While David loves his new job, Ashley doesn’t have a local job and is missing her prior, potentially lifelong career opportunity, with the museum in Philadelphia. First things first, they need to agree on a house to purchase; not an easy task for this opposites attract couple.
As is the way with most dual timeline stories, they need a point of intersection. In this story, physical homes for our three couples make for an engaging point of commonality. Henry and Kate live in the town’s grandest home - the Baron’s house. As part of the package to entice John and Ashley to accept his offer of employment, Henry built a smaller but very high quality home for them. It’s this place, the Doctor’s House, where Ashley and David come to reside.
So much of this book is focused of the three couples and how each member adjusts to significant changes, to healing hurts from childhood and their own present day trauma. In addition, Hannah is trying to educate Kate to be more genteel, a better social partner for Henry’s business associates and their high society wives. This is a project Hannah really doesn’t want.
If you’ve read the publisher’s description of this book, you might be expecting a missing person mystery. That element does not occur until the last 15% of the story and then it consumes less than half of that remaining time. Tidbits of the missing wife’s story are dropped into the current timeline but restoring the home is far more important to the storyline.
This didn’t affect my enjoyment of the story but were I looking for the promised mystery, missing person focused story, I might be disappointed.
Friendship, forgiveness, loss, faith - these are primary themes running thru the book. Austin uses well placed scripture verses and character experiences to share the gospel. It flows naturally, is not accusatory or preachy. Characters and their development are the highlight of this relationship driven story.
Recommended for readers of inspirational fiction, historical fiction, late 19th century Michigan, Michigan lumber business history and relationship driven stories📚
I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley eARC, via Kindle, with thanks to the publisher and author.
1873 - John and Hannah’s marriage is floundering. Altho’ they still love each other, the loss of their children has shaken their foundation, including their faith. An offer from Henry, a war buddy of John’s, now a millionaire lumber mill owner from Michigan, gives them an opportunity for a new beginning. John, a doctor, will become the doctor for all Henry’s mill workers and loggers, along with their families. Hannah has been strongly invited to take care of the baron’s new bride, Kate. She is young and ill prepared to take her social place alongside the prominent businessman. This will be an interesting relationship to watch!
Present Day - Ashley and David are on their way Michigan. He has landed what he believes is a lifelong dream job. While David loves his new job, Ashley doesn’t have a local job and is missing her prior, potentially lifelong career opportunity, with the museum in Philadelphia. First things first, they need to agree on a house to purchase; not an easy task for this opposites attract couple.
As is the way with most dual timeline stories, they need a point of intersection. In this story, physical homes for our three couples make for an engaging point of commonality. Henry and Kate live in the town’s grandest home - the Baron’s house. As part of the package to entice John and Ashley to accept his offer of employment, Henry built a smaller but very high quality home for them. It’s this place, the Doctor’s House, where Ashley and David come to reside.
So much of this book is focused of the three couples and how each member adjusts to significant changes, to healing hurts from childhood and their own present day trauma. In addition, Hannah is trying to educate Kate to be more genteel, a better social partner for Henry’s business associates and their high society wives. This is a project Hannah really doesn’t want.
If you’ve read the publisher’s description of this book, you might be expecting a missing person mystery. That element does not occur until the last 15% of the story and then it consumes less than half of that remaining time. Tidbits of the missing wife’s story are dropped into the current timeline but restoring the home is far more important to the storyline.
This didn’t affect my enjoyment of the story but were I looking for the promised mystery, missing person focused story, I might be disappointed.
Friendship, forgiveness, loss, faith - these are primary themes running thru the book. Austin uses well placed scripture verses and character experiences to share the gospel. It flows naturally, is not accusatory or preachy. Characters and their development are the highlight of this relationship driven story.
Recommended for readers of inspirational fiction, historical fiction, late 19th century Michigan, Michigan lumber business history and relationship driven stories📚
I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley eARC, via Kindle, with thanks to the publisher and author.
September 24, 2025
There have been moments when I’ve stepped out of my usual comfort zone, questioning myself, “Why did I do this?!” But this wasn’t one of those times. I was genuinely excited to be chosen to receive a complimentary ARC of this book by Tyndale House Publishers. The moment I laid eyes on the cover of The Lumber Baron’s Wife by Lynn Austin, I was captivated. It immediately sparked my curiosity—what’s the story behind the beautiful woman in green facing away? Where is she headed? What is her story?
This beautiful piece of artwork travels through time, reclaiming truth & showing the restorative hope of Christ. The lenses of Hannah, Kate, and Ashley show us the intricacies of life through grief, death, sorrow, sin, unbelief, abuse, and much more. Though many years pass between the time of Hannah & Kate, and the modernized world of Ashley—still, life holds to the same hardships.
Yet, even in the darkest of shadows, His light is evident throughout. The climactic crescendo of hope through Christ is woven throughout with scripturally based truths in the darkest of times, taking believer & unbeliever alike on a journey towards Him.
Lynn shows us compassion unlike any other. She shows us His blessings in such beautiful ways that we can only glorify Him. She shows us redemption, rescue, and love through His people & plan.
👉For the unbeliever, I recommend this.
👉For the believer, I recommend this.
👉For the prodigal, I recommend this.
To loosely quote a line in the book, I will say this for an absolute fact: “This beautiful story will have you clinging to the hope of the Gospel, right in front of you. Repentance, forgiveness, and new life” are found throughout these pages. 🙌🏻✝️
I encourage every person to add this to their wishlist immediately! It comes out in April 2026.
‼️Content Warning: There are scenes of death, abuse, abortion, prostitution, and alcoholism.
Again, I thank Tyndale House Publishers for the complimentary ARC of this book. My review is 100% my own opinion.
#thelumberbaronswife #books #bookreview #netgalley #bookish #bookstagram #jesus #faith #arc
This beautiful piece of artwork travels through time, reclaiming truth & showing the restorative hope of Christ. The lenses of Hannah, Kate, and Ashley show us the intricacies of life through grief, death, sorrow, sin, unbelief, abuse, and much more. Though many years pass between the time of Hannah & Kate, and the modernized world of Ashley—still, life holds to the same hardships.
Yet, even in the darkest of shadows, His light is evident throughout. The climactic crescendo of hope through Christ is woven throughout with scripturally based truths in the darkest of times, taking believer & unbeliever alike on a journey towards Him.
Lynn shows us compassion unlike any other. She shows us His blessings in such beautiful ways that we can only glorify Him. She shows us redemption, rescue, and love through His people & plan.
👉For the unbeliever, I recommend this.
👉For the believer, I recommend this.
👉For the prodigal, I recommend this.
To loosely quote a line in the book, I will say this for an absolute fact: “This beautiful story will have you clinging to the hope of the Gospel, right in front of you. Repentance, forgiveness, and new life” are found throughout these pages. 🙌🏻✝️
I encourage every person to add this to their wishlist immediately! It comes out in April 2026.
‼️Content Warning: There are scenes of death, abuse, abortion, prostitution, and alcoholism.
Again, I thank Tyndale House Publishers for the complimentary ARC of this book. My review is 100% my own opinion.
#thelumberbaronswife #books #bookreview #netgalley #bookish #bookstagram #jesus #faith #arc
October 8, 2025
"The Lumber Baron's Wife" is a split-time Christian fiction. In present day, Ashley moved so that her husband could have his dream job but lost her dream job in the process. The move highlighted all of the differences between Ashley and her husband, like she wanted to buy the well-kept 150-year-old house and he wanted a brand new build. When Ashley got pregnant, her husband pressured her to get an abortion because finances were tight and he didn't want kids yet. Even though they knew a couple who wanted to adopt a baby, the conflict was framed as: have an abortion or raise the baby themselves. Though likable, the two had such different interests that I wondered why they even got married.
In 1873-1875, Hannah's 3 young children died when their doctor father unintentionally exposed them to diphtheria. Afterward, few people wanted him as a doctor since he couldn't save his own children. (The death toll from diphtheria is higher in young children and in crowded, unsanitary, and malnourished situations. About 9 out of 100 symptomatic cases were fatal, and the bad epidemic in 1878 in Geneva had a mortality rate of 1.9 out of every 10 cases. So it would be disturbing that a well-to-do doctor lost all 3 of his children.) A lumber-baron friend asked the doctor to relocate to a booming lumber town, and they accepted to get a fresh start. Hannah's forced by events to get more involved with life again, including befriending the lumber baron's young, wild wife, Kate.
We get Kate's diary and so see how she struggled with becoming a 'proper' wealthy wife and her disbelief that God would just forgive her if she asked. She tried to earn His forgiveness. She recorded what happened to her in the diary, so Ashley's solving of the mystery was a matter of finding the diary.
The characters were complex, realistic people. Vivid historical and setting details were woven into the story, creating a distinct sense of the time and place. Hannah had to deal with her anger at God. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable story.
I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
In 1873-1875, Hannah's 3 young children died when their doctor father unintentionally exposed them to diphtheria. Afterward, few people wanted him as a doctor since he couldn't save his own children. (The death toll from diphtheria is higher in young children and in crowded, unsanitary, and malnourished situations. About 9 out of 100 symptomatic cases were fatal, and the bad epidemic in 1878 in Geneva had a mortality rate of 1.9 out of every 10 cases. So it would be disturbing that a well-to-do doctor lost all 3 of his children.) A lumber-baron friend asked the doctor to relocate to a booming lumber town, and they accepted to get a fresh start. Hannah's forced by events to get more involved with life again, including befriending the lumber baron's young, wild wife, Kate.
We get Kate's diary and so see how she struggled with becoming a 'proper' wealthy wife and her disbelief that God would just forgive her if she asked. She tried to earn His forgiveness. She recorded what happened to her in the diary, so Ashley's solving of the mystery was a matter of finding the diary.
The characters were complex, realistic people. Vivid historical and setting details were woven into the story, creating a distinct sense of the time and place. Hannah had to deal with her anger at God. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable story.
I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I was honored to receive an advanced readers copy of this book. I enjoyed this book immensely. Lynn's writing on this book was nothing short of amazing and kept me, the reader entertained and waiting for what happened next. Lynn had to have searched the history of this era to come up with this book. The Lumber Baron's wife was about Kate who came from a bad life. Her mom was a prostitute that kept her daughter hidden and safe from the men who visited her by keeping her in a locked up room. Kate did not know the love of a mother, having a friend, really knew nothing about how to be a society lady. Not knowing how to be modest, chaste and the wife of a rich Baron. Her mom did not show her love, or did she by keeping her locked up away from the men. Kate meets Henry who becomes a rich lumber man. He expects Kate to be who she is not...a rich Lumber Baron's wife, Henry Abernathy is her husband. She meets Hannah, Hannah is devastated by the loss of her three children from diptheria. Her husband, Dr John, brought the disease home to their children and all three perish. John and Henry serve together in the Army and Henry invites John to come with him to Michigan. He builds him a beautiful home in the forested area. His home and Henry's mansion become the theme in this book. Ashley, is the present day person in the story. She is married to David. They are a newly married couple just trying to figure out live. David moved Ashley to the area and. they struggle to choose a home, barely scrapping by to figure out life. Ashley is a history buff, and learns about the Abernathy mansion and becomes so excited about the possibility of restoring the Abernathy mansion. Ashley and David buy John and Hannah's homes which was also built by the same builder as the Abernathy mansion. There is so much more information in this book. Again this book keeps you engaged and wanting to see more about what happens next. This is a great read and may be one of the best I may read this year. Thank you netgalley for allowing me to read this advanced reader copy.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Beautifully written dual timeline story set in 1870's and present day Michigan. The story is told from three POV. Both Hannah and Ashley move to Michigan after their husbands accept new jobs. In the 1870's, Hannah quickly befriends Kate, a young woman with a tainted past. In the present day storyline, Ashley becomes interested in the restoration of an old historic home. She quickly becomes captivated by the unsolved mystery of the missing lumber baron's wife.
My favorite storyline was the 1870's line. While Kate was an extremely troubled young woman, she tugged at my heart. She had an unconventional childhood and found her free spirit and tender heart restrained by the social norms of the gilded age. Her journey of faith is touching.
Things I loved- there was excellent pacing between the two storylines, with some elements of the plot shadowing each other as they rushed rapidly to a satisfying conclusion. They intertwined with many characteristics reflected in both. All three women must fight for a purpose that brings fulfillment.
There is a clear presentation of the Gospel and its message of redemption and grace, yet it is deftly entwined within the story and does not seem forced.
Both storylines were connected by the effects of the logging industry. Ms. Austin includes some well-researched historical detail of the lumber industry and its effects on the economy and development, as well as its decline and long term effects due to the over-cutting and destruction of the magnificent white pine forests.
I found this an enjoyable and original story. The vivid descriptions brought the story to life and captivated my imagination. I highly recommend for fans of historical fiction.
Content warning- mention of abuse, attempted rape and prostitition
***I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and Netgalley. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
My favorite storyline was the 1870's line. While Kate was an extremely troubled young woman, she tugged at my heart. She had an unconventional childhood and found her free spirit and tender heart restrained by the social norms of the gilded age. Her journey of faith is touching.
Things I loved- there was excellent pacing between the two storylines, with some elements of the plot shadowing each other as they rushed rapidly to a satisfying conclusion. They intertwined with many characteristics reflected in both. All three women must fight for a purpose that brings fulfillment.
There is a clear presentation of the Gospel and its message of redemption and grace, yet it is deftly entwined within the story and does not seem forced.
Both storylines were connected by the effects of the logging industry. Ms. Austin includes some well-researched historical detail of the lumber industry and its effects on the economy and development, as well as its decline and long term effects due to the over-cutting and destruction of the magnificent white pine forests.
I found this an enjoyable and original story. The vivid descriptions brought the story to life and captivated my imagination. I highly recommend for fans of historical fiction.
Content warning- mention of abuse, attempted rape and prostitition
***I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and Netgalley. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
February 21, 2026
I would give this book 6 stars if I could!!!! I absolutely LOVED this story.
Dual time line. Three woman. Two friends. One tragic story that brings them all together.
In 1873, Kate Abernathy is a vivacious and spirited young woman who marries a man she fell in love with and becomes a Lumber Baron's wife. On the outside, it appears Kate could have everything a woman ever dreams of, a wealthy and respectable husband, a beautiful mansion and anything that money can buy but dark secrets, fear and abuse are hidden beneath.
Hannah Wagner has been through an incredible loss and the grief threatens to steal the life out of her when she and her husband John agree to accept Henry's (the lumber baron) offer of moving to Michigan to be the town doctor. John believes this will be a new start for Hannah and help her heal from their tragic loss.
Ashley (modern day) and her husband David move to Michigan for David's job as conservationist for Michigan's wooded forests. Ashley is a historian who is intrigued by and drawn to the Abernathy mansion which was once Kate's home. While leading the restoration project to restore the beautiful mansion and make it into a museum, Ashley discovers what it means to find faith, family and friends as well as uncover the mystery of the Lumber Baron's Wife.
I can't tell you how much I enjoyed this story, the characters, the faith elements and the message of the gospel with lessons of forgiveness that were beautifully woven through this book.
This is a must read!
Trigger warnings: spousal abuse, mention of attempted rape but not detailed, murder, talk of abortion.
No language. Closed door with kisses only and martial intimacy implied.
** I was given a copy of this ARC from NetGalley and Baker Book House Publishing in exchange for my honest review.
Dual time line. Three woman. Two friends. One tragic story that brings them all together.
In 1873, Kate Abernathy is a vivacious and spirited young woman who marries a man she fell in love with and becomes a Lumber Baron's wife. On the outside, it appears Kate could have everything a woman ever dreams of, a wealthy and respectable husband, a beautiful mansion and anything that money can buy but dark secrets, fear and abuse are hidden beneath.
Hannah Wagner has been through an incredible loss and the grief threatens to steal the life out of her when she and her husband John agree to accept Henry's (the lumber baron) offer of moving to Michigan to be the town doctor. John believes this will be a new start for Hannah and help her heal from their tragic loss.
Ashley (modern day) and her husband David move to Michigan for David's job as conservationist for Michigan's wooded forests. Ashley is a historian who is intrigued by and drawn to the Abernathy mansion which was once Kate's home. While leading the restoration project to restore the beautiful mansion and make it into a museum, Ashley discovers what it means to find faith, family and friends as well as uncover the mystery of the Lumber Baron's Wife.
I can't tell you how much I enjoyed this story, the characters, the faith elements and the message of the gospel with lessons of forgiveness that were beautifully woven through this book.
This is a must read!
Trigger warnings: spousal abuse, mention of attempted rape but not detailed, murder, talk of abortion.
No language. Closed door with kisses only and martial intimacy implied.
** I was given a copy of this ARC from NetGalley and Baker Book House Publishing in exchange for my honest review.
September 26, 2025
Love loved this novel! Oh my! It had all of my favorite things in it that made my heart sing! Wow!
This will be listed on my favorite shelf for favorites.
I'm floored throughout this beautiful story from Lynn Austin.
Love, heartaches, restorations, discoveries. Let's see what else? Oh learning to find one's self again
Even though this story is told through three different women, my favorite was Hannah's story. I loved the historical parts. The one I really felt sorry for was Kate. My heart broke for her in so many ways. I wanted to pull her out of the book and give her a big old hug. I wanted to be her friend but Henry made it impossible by not letting her engage in anything. She's really a sweetheart no matter what her background is or wherever she came from.
Kate in my opinion made this story.
Ashley is just as determined to add her charm as well. I wasn't liking her husband David very well either. I wanted to shake him until he opened his eyes and saw what was right in front of him.
What a selfish pig.
I found myself rooting for Ashley, Hannah and Kate all the way through.
I learned about many events that took place in this novel. Yes, I looked them up and Austin has done her job well!!
Im still thinking about these wonderful characters and events and how scary they must've been!!
This is quite the story! I was so happy when Tyndale gave me this beautiful story to love and cherish
Many thanks for the opportunity to read and review this book. I was in heaven the whole time!
5 stars for a job well done! I loved every minute of it
I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.
This will be listed on my favorite shelf for favorites.
I'm floored throughout this beautiful story from Lynn Austin.
Love, heartaches, restorations, discoveries. Let's see what else? Oh learning to find one's self again
Even though this story is told through three different women, my favorite was Hannah's story. I loved the historical parts. The one I really felt sorry for was Kate. My heart broke for her in so many ways. I wanted to pull her out of the book and give her a big old hug. I wanted to be her friend but Henry made it impossible by not letting her engage in anything. She's really a sweetheart no matter what her background is or wherever she came from.
Kate in my opinion made this story.
Ashley is just as determined to add her charm as well. I wasn't liking her husband David very well either. I wanted to shake him until he opened his eyes and saw what was right in front of him.
What a selfish pig.
I found myself rooting for Ashley, Hannah and Kate all the way through.
I learned about many events that took place in this novel. Yes, I looked them up and Austin has done her job well!!
Im still thinking about these wonderful characters and events and how scary they must've been!!
This is quite the story! I was so happy when Tyndale gave me this beautiful story to love and cherish
Many thanks for the opportunity to read and review this book. I was in heaven the whole time!
5 stars for a job well done! I loved every minute of it
I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was an amazing dual timeline novel by Lynn Austin! Both stories were set primarily in Michigan, the historical timeline in the 1870s when the lumber barons were deforesting the area. The historical timeline is told primarily from the perspective of Hannah, the doctor's wife, who is the unlikely friend of Kate, the titular character of the lumber baron's wife, who mysteriously disappears. In the modern timeline, historian Ashley falls in love with the historical homes of the doctor and the lumber baron when she and her husband relocate to Michigan. This story explores the mystery of what happened to Kate, but also chronicles the journey of both Hannah and Ashley.
Though predominantly a character-driven story-line, there was enough that happened in this story to keep this plot-driven reader turning pages. I thoroughly enjoyed both journeys and the mystery surrounding Kate kept me intrigued throughout as well. The faith element of this book was front and center as all 3 women were on a journey of faith - Hannah coming back to God after a terrible hurt, and both Kate and Ashley coming to know God for the first time. There are some pretty serious topics in this book - child death, abortion, abuse and prostitution - but they are all handled with grace. I thoroughly enjoyed the redemptive arc of the story and how the mystery was solved/revealed in both timelines. This was an altogether enjoyable book and one I can heartily recommend to fans of all genres. Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
Though predominantly a character-driven story-line, there was enough that happened in this story to keep this plot-driven reader turning pages. I thoroughly enjoyed both journeys and the mystery surrounding Kate kept me intrigued throughout as well. The faith element of this book was front and center as all 3 women were on a journey of faith - Hannah coming back to God after a terrible hurt, and both Kate and Ashley coming to know God for the first time. There are some pretty serious topics in this book - child death, abortion, abuse and prostitution - but they are all handled with grace. I thoroughly enjoyed the redemptive arc of the story and how the mystery was solved/revealed in both timelines. This was an altogether enjoyable book and one I can heartily recommend to fans of all genres. Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I received an Advance copy of this story in exchange for a review.
In the 1870s, Hannah never saw herself moving to the lumber town in Michigan. Her home is in New York. It where she was born, where she was married, where her kids were born, and now where they are buried. After her husband loses several clients during a diphtheria outbreak that takes their children, Hannah is simply getting through the day. When her husband's friend comes for drinks one night with his new wife Kate that is young enough to be his daughter, she is shocked when her John considers the proposal to move and be the local doctor in the town. Arriving in town, she tries to take Kate under her wing to show her how to be the elegant and refined wife of a lumber baron. When Kate teaches her some facts about life as well, she begins to realize Kate isn't the only one who can learn about life when Kate mysteriously disappears. In present day, Ashley and her husband move to a new town to pursue her husband's dream job and move into a home built in the 1870's for the new doctor and his wife. While exploring her new town, she finds another house built the same time as hers that was the home of a lumber baron and wife that is shrouded in mystery. Can she discover what happened to Kate, nearly 150 years after she disappeared without a trace?
This was a really well written book. I started it while I was stuck waiting for them to clean up an accident on the road and I didn't want to have to start driving again. Word to the wise, when reading this story check the name at the beginning of each chapter to make sure you know which timeframe you are in.
In the 1870s, Hannah never saw herself moving to the lumber town in Michigan. Her home is in New York. It where she was born, where she was married, where her kids were born, and now where they are buried. After her husband loses several clients during a diphtheria outbreak that takes their children, Hannah is simply getting through the day. When her husband's friend comes for drinks one night with his new wife Kate that is young enough to be his daughter, she is shocked when her John considers the proposal to move and be the local doctor in the town. Arriving in town, she tries to take Kate under her wing to show her how to be the elegant and refined wife of a lumber baron. When Kate teaches her some facts about life as well, she begins to realize Kate isn't the only one who can learn about life when Kate mysteriously disappears. In present day, Ashley and her husband move to a new town to pursue her husband's dream job and move into a home built in the 1870's for the new doctor and his wife. While exploring her new town, she finds another house built the same time as hers that was the home of a lumber baron and wife that is shrouded in mystery. Can she discover what happened to Kate, nearly 150 years after she disappeared without a trace?
This was a really well written book. I started it while I was stuck waiting for them to clean up an accident on the road and I didn't want to have to start driving again. Word to the wise, when reading this story check the name at the beginning of each chapter to make sure you know which timeframe you are in.
October 1, 2025
I've read Lynn Austin many times before. And yet, I still wasn't ready for this story. At times, this story had a feel like some of Jaime Jo Wright's plots with the mysterious past written in dual time.
This story was one definitely exploring marriage and how to ride the waves of loss and trials. The power of faith to carry you through the lowest times. The power of the forgiveness of God. The power of friendship. The power of love.
I wasn't prepared for the debate of abortion to take center stage...but it fit the story very well.
Lynn Austin always uses messages of faith to help her characters get through their battles and boy, did they all have their battles!
Kate: positive there isn't enough good works she can do to wipe clean her slate; sure that she was unredeemable
Hannah: questions how God can be a good God and worthy of her worship and love if He doesn't heal children and lets them die.
Ashley: not really sure about God in general but wanting the relationship with Him that her new friends have
The story is written from three POV by these women and we get insight into their lives. Kate and Hannah in the 1800s and Ashley in modern day learning about them through her historical research.
Topics: spousal abuse, abandonment, child loss, grief, abortion
Highly recommend this book.
5 Stars
*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this book. All opinions are 100% my own.
This story was one definitely exploring marriage and how to ride the waves of loss and trials. The power of faith to carry you through the lowest times. The power of the forgiveness of God. The power of friendship. The power of love.
I wasn't prepared for the debate of abortion to take center stage...but it fit the story very well.
Lynn Austin always uses messages of faith to help her characters get through their battles and boy, did they all have their battles!
Kate: positive there isn't enough good works she can do to wipe clean her slate; sure that she was unredeemable
Hannah: questions how God can be a good God and worthy of her worship and love if He doesn't heal children and lets them die.
Ashley: not really sure about God in general but wanting the relationship with Him that her new friends have
The story is written from three POV by these women and we get insight into their lives. Kate and Hannah in the 1800s and Ashley in modern day learning about them through her historical research.
Topics: spousal abuse, abandonment, child loss, grief, abortion
Highly recommend this book.
5 Stars
*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this book. All opinions are 100% my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Lynn Austin, whose books I've loved for a long time, has always been a favorite of mine. Her new book, The Lumber Baron’s Wife, made me remember how much I like the way she tells a story. This dual timeline novel delicately and authentically explores women's issues in an imaginative plot easy to identify with.
Though one hundred fifty years apart, the three women share a sisterhood bond in these stories, their struggles and triumphs unfolding amid the sights and sounds of their unique time periods. By the end of the novel, it’s impossible not to feel a deep connection with Kate, Hannah, and Ashley, considering them as friends.
The rich historical details about Michigan’s lumber boom after the Civil War transported me back in time, letting me experience the era firsthand. The modern storyline, reflecting the intricate choices that women face today, made this novel more relatable than typical historical fiction. Austin skillfully merged the two narratives with historical resonance, creating a seamless and brilliant literary effect.
But what really captured me was the mysterious ambiance, which created a suspenseful experience that compelled me to keep reading. I simply had to find out what happened to Kate. The ending was superb, wrapping things up with a strong faith thread that had me near tears. This book is just another treasure in Lynn Austin’s amazing repertoire as an author.
I received a complimentary copy from the author but was not required to leave a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Though one hundred fifty years apart, the three women share a sisterhood bond in these stories, their struggles and triumphs unfolding amid the sights and sounds of their unique time periods. By the end of the novel, it’s impossible not to feel a deep connection with Kate, Hannah, and Ashley, considering them as friends.
The rich historical details about Michigan’s lumber boom after the Civil War transported me back in time, letting me experience the era firsthand. The modern storyline, reflecting the intricate choices that women face today, made this novel more relatable than typical historical fiction. Austin skillfully merged the two narratives with historical resonance, creating a seamless and brilliant literary effect.
But what really captured me was the mysterious ambiance, which created a suspenseful experience that compelled me to keep reading. I simply had to find out what happened to Kate. The ending was superb, wrapping things up with a strong faith thread that had me near tears. This book is just another treasure in Lynn Austin’s amazing repertoire as an author.
I received a complimentary copy from the author but was not required to leave a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
WOW! This is an extraordinary book! I was immediately drawn into the story. The main theme is forgiveness: forgiveness with friends and family and also the ultimate forgiveness of God. I enjoyed reading about the renovations to the Abernathy mansion!
The characters are written brilliantly! I found myself genuinely interested in the lives of Kate, Hannah, Ashley and Freida. Kate is an amazing character. She has a childlike quality. Her childhood wasn't the best but somehow she maintains an exuberant personality! She strives hard to fit into "polite" society and making her husband proud. Hannah's story is heartbreaking. She lost her three children to illness and has basically shuttered herself from life and love. Ashley just longs for a forever home. She loves everything historical! Freida is the friend that everyone needs in their life. She speaks the truth in love and always points people to God.
There are some difficult topics brought up: prostitution, alcoholism, loss of life (some children), physical abuse and talk of abortion. Thankfully, the author presents that there is hope in these situations through faith in God! "My faith had grown during the past year, and each time my anxiety swelled, I chose to trust God's love." Towards the end of the book a woman named Ruth is talking to Kate about God's forgiveness. Her example brought tears to my eyes; that Jesus sets us free!!
I was provided a complimentary ARC copy of the book from Tyndale via NetGalley through Interviews and Reviews. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The characters are written brilliantly! I found myself genuinely interested in the lives of Kate, Hannah, Ashley and Freida. Kate is an amazing character. She has a childlike quality. Her childhood wasn't the best but somehow she maintains an exuberant personality! She strives hard to fit into "polite" society and making her husband proud. Hannah's story is heartbreaking. She lost her three children to illness and has basically shuttered herself from life and love. Ashley just longs for a forever home. She loves everything historical! Freida is the friend that everyone needs in their life. She speaks the truth in love and always points people to God.
There are some difficult topics brought up: prostitution, alcoholism, loss of life (some children), physical abuse and talk of abortion. Thankfully, the author presents that there is hope in these situations through faith in God! "My faith had grown during the past year, and each time my anxiety swelled, I chose to trust God's love." Towards the end of the book a woman named Ruth is talking to Kate about God's forgiveness. Her example brought tears to my eyes; that Jesus sets us free!!
I was provided a complimentary ARC copy of the book from Tyndale via NetGalley through Interviews and Reviews. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Lynn Austin is amazing; as usual. This story has so much packed in a small amount of pages. She amazingly addressed heavy subjects and was also able to keep the story light and flowing. This was a duel time period and also a mystery.
Hannah is married to a doctor. She lost her three children to illness. When her husband's friend from the civil war invites him to be the town doctor in a town off of lake Michigan her life is changed in so many ways. One of the main ways is befriending her husband's friends new younger wife; Kate.
Kate has a past that is a mystery to everyone except Hannah. Their friendship brings out all her secrets. After a bipolar relationship Kate goes missing with no explanation. There is so much mystery behind her disappearance. It is never solved.
Ashley moves to the same small town in lake Michigan. Her husband is an environmentalist and needs to be there for work. When she convinces her husband to buy the old doctors house she takes an interest in the old Abernathy mansion and disappearance of Kate Abernathy.
This story was so moving. It also addressed heavy subjects in each time period. Lynn Austin again does a wonderful job at showing hard situations women have to face. I also love the element of faith that she always brings into difficult choices. This is a good story for sure. I highly recommend it.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Tyndale House Publishers through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
Hannah is married to a doctor. She lost her three children to illness. When her husband's friend from the civil war invites him to be the town doctor in a town off of lake Michigan her life is changed in so many ways. One of the main ways is befriending her husband's friends new younger wife; Kate.
Kate has a past that is a mystery to everyone except Hannah. Their friendship brings out all her secrets. After a bipolar relationship Kate goes missing with no explanation. There is so much mystery behind her disappearance. It is never solved.
Ashley moves to the same small town in lake Michigan. Her husband is an environmentalist and needs to be there for work. When she convinces her husband to buy the old doctors house she takes an interest in the old Abernathy mansion and disappearance of Kate Abernathy.
This story was so moving. It also addressed heavy subjects in each time period. Lynn Austin again does a wonderful job at showing hard situations women have to face. I also love the element of faith that she always brings into difficult choices. This is a good story for sure. I highly recommend it.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Tyndale House Publishers through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Lumber Barons Wife by Lynn Austin is an attention grabbing dual timeline Christian story. This nicely written story takes place near Lake Michigan during the 1873 with lumber baron Henry, his wife Kate and the doctor who saved his life during the war, John and his wife Hannah. Woven through out the story is present day Ashley and her husband when they move to the area for him to pursue his dream job. They purchase the doctors home while Ashley helps to restore Henry and Kate’s home to turn it into a museum.
This story is so good! I appreciate how the story shows how three different women follow their husbands to Michigan for their jobs and how the women are forced to take on new lives. For Hannah, she leaves behind the area she has always know and the place where her three children are buried. Kate is forced to become a high society wife and follow all the boring rules expected of her while living with an abusive husband. And Ashley struggles to find a job as a museum worker in a town that doesn’t have a museum. I like how the story shows how strong each of the women are and how they accept and excel at the challenges they are faced with. I like how for each woman there was someone that brought them to God. I especially enjoyed how Ashley was able to find out the truth of her husband’s family situation. I admire the strength Hannah has to adopt children and the desire Kate has to care for others.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book, this is my honest review.
This story is so good! I appreciate how the story shows how three different women follow their husbands to Michigan for their jobs and how the women are forced to take on new lives. For Hannah, she leaves behind the area she has always know and the place where her three children are buried. Kate is forced to become a high society wife and follow all the boring rules expected of her while living with an abusive husband. And Ashley struggles to find a job as a museum worker in a town that doesn’t have a museum. I like how the story shows how strong each of the women are and how they accept and excel at the challenges they are faced with. I like how for each woman there was someone that brought them to God. I especially enjoyed how Ashley was able to find out the truth of her husband’s family situation. I admire the strength Hannah has to adopt children and the desire Kate has to care for others.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book, this is my honest review.
September 29, 2025
Lynn Austin’s The Lumber Baron’s Wife is a beautifully layered tale that seamlessly weaves together past and present, mystery and healing, faith and friendship. I was completely absorbed from the first page and will be enthusiastically recommending this to fellow historical fiction lovers.
In the past timeline, we meet Kate, a woman whose life is tightly controlled by her husband, Henry. Despite his rigid nature, Henry surprisingly encourages a friendship between the vibrant, outspoken Kate Abernathy and Hannah. Kate, with her boisterous charm, carries a haunting secret—one she entrusts only to Hannah.
Fast forward to the present day: Ashley Gilbert, a historian, relocates to Michigan to support her husband’s dream job as a conservationist. She quickly falls in love with a 150-year-old home that is for sale, once owned by John and Hannah that her husband agrees to buy. Once moved in, Ashley joins a local restoration effort for the grand Abernathy mansion. She uncovers the long-buried mystery of young Kate’s disappearance—a puzzle that has lingered for generations.
This novel is a masterful blend of historical intrigue and emotional depth. It celebrates the enduring power of female friendship and explores themes of forgiveness, faith, and healing with grace and authenticity. Lynn Austin’s storytelling is rich, heartfelt, and utterly compelling.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All comments and opinions are my own.
In the past timeline, we meet Kate, a woman whose life is tightly controlled by her husband, Henry. Despite his rigid nature, Henry surprisingly encourages a friendship between the vibrant, outspoken Kate Abernathy and Hannah. Kate, with her boisterous charm, carries a haunting secret—one she entrusts only to Hannah.
Fast forward to the present day: Ashley Gilbert, a historian, relocates to Michigan to support her husband’s dream job as a conservationist. She quickly falls in love with a 150-year-old home that is for sale, once owned by John and Hannah that her husband agrees to buy. Once moved in, Ashley joins a local restoration effort for the grand Abernathy mansion. She uncovers the long-buried mystery of young Kate’s disappearance—a puzzle that has lingered for generations.
This novel is a masterful blend of historical intrigue and emotional depth. It celebrates the enduring power of female friendship and explores themes of forgiveness, faith, and healing with grace and authenticity. Lynn Austin’s storytelling is rich, heartfelt, and utterly compelling.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All comments and opinions are my own.
March 24, 2026
The Lumber Baron’s Wife by Lynn Austin is a dual-timeline novel set in 1873 and the present day in Michigan. Since I’ve always enjoyed stories with dual timelines, I was immediately drawn to this one, and it didn’t disappoint.
I found myself especially invested in the historical storyline. John and Hannah’s relationship was deeply moving, particularly in how they endured and survived such heartbreaking circumstances. Their story had a strong emotional core that kept me engaged. I also loved Hannah’s friendship with Kate, who ended up being my favorite character. Kate’s journey was incredibly compelling—despite her turbulent past, she showed remarkable kindness and a genuine desire to help others, which made her stand out.
In contrast, the present-day timeline with Ashley and David was less engaging for me. It felt slower and at times repetitive, making it harder to stay invested. I also struggled with David’s treatment of Ashley, which made it difficult to connect with him and their relationship. There was one part of their story that was particularly disturbing.
Overall, though, I did enjoyed the novel. The way both timelines were connected and resolved was satisfying, and the faith elements woven into each storyline felt meaningful and well integrated into the narrative.
3.5 stars
I found myself especially invested in the historical storyline. John and Hannah’s relationship was deeply moving, particularly in how they endured and survived such heartbreaking circumstances. Their story had a strong emotional core that kept me engaged. I also loved Hannah’s friendship with Kate, who ended up being my favorite character. Kate’s journey was incredibly compelling—despite her turbulent past, she showed remarkable kindness and a genuine desire to help others, which made her stand out.
In contrast, the present-day timeline with Ashley and David was less engaging for me. It felt slower and at times repetitive, making it harder to stay invested. I also struggled with David’s treatment of Ashley, which made it difficult to connect with him and their relationship. There was one part of their story that was particularly disturbing.
Overall, though, I did enjoyed the novel. The way both timelines were connected and resolved was satisfying, and the faith elements woven into each storyline felt meaningful and well integrated into the narrative.
3.5 stars
November 14, 2025
‘The Lumber Baron’s Wife’ is a compelling dual-timeline novel that connects three women: Hannah in the 1870s, Ashley in the present day, and Kate through her 19th-century journal entries. Each one faces major life changes and rediscovers purpose in her own way.
The writing is smooth and approachable, which makes the historical timeline easy to follow even for readers who might normally shy away from historical fiction. I especially enjoyed the glimpses into Michigan’s lumber industry and the effort to preserve its history through Ashley’s modern restoration work.
Each woman’s faith journey feels authentic, showing both the flaws and growth of believers and nonbelievers alike. The relationships and redemption arcs are heartwarming, and the blend of women’s fiction, light mystery, and faith-based storytelling kept me engaged from start to finish. I can see why Lynn Austin’s books are so well loved, and I will definitely be reading more.
Special thanks to Tyndale Fiction and NetGalley for providing an advance review copy. I received this book for free and am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions expressed are completely my own.
The writing is smooth and approachable, which makes the historical timeline easy to follow even for readers who might normally shy away from historical fiction. I especially enjoyed the glimpses into Michigan’s lumber industry and the effort to preserve its history through Ashley’s modern restoration work.
Each woman’s faith journey feels authentic, showing both the flaws and growth of believers and nonbelievers alike. The relationships and redemption arcs are heartwarming, and the blend of women’s fiction, light mystery, and faith-based storytelling kept me engaged from start to finish. I can see why Lynn Austin’s books are so well loved, and I will definitely be reading more.
Special thanks to Tyndale Fiction and NetGalley for providing an advance review copy. I received this book for free and am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions expressed are completely my own.
February 1, 2026
3.75⭐️
I have read a few of Lynn Austin’s previous books and thoroughly enjoyed them. This one however, just didn’t hit me in the same way. I’m not sure exactly what it was about it but I found myself skimming through some parts just to get back to the “meat” of the story.
It’s written with multiple POVs and a dual timeline. I did really enjoy parts of it, but then other parts were just sort of “meh” for me.
The writing was done well but I just didn’t feel like I really fully connected with any of the characters. The Kate character, at times, would speak in ways that seemed like it would have been too modern for 1870s ~ that was a bit jarring and made it a little hard to really stay “in” the story
I definitely did *not* predict the conclusion to the mystery ~ the author did really well with that aspect of the story!
I also really appreciated the gospel message and the strong pro-life message.
All in all, it was a good read but I just felt like it wasn’t quite as good as some of her others.
*Content Considerations* abortion, prostitution, suicide, mental health, spousal abuse, infertility are all touched on in this story.
*Thanks to NetGalley for my eARC copy ~ all opinions are strictly my own and have not been influenced in any way.*
I have read a few of Lynn Austin’s previous books and thoroughly enjoyed them. This one however, just didn’t hit me in the same way. I’m not sure exactly what it was about it but I found myself skimming through some parts just to get back to the “meat” of the story.
It’s written with multiple POVs and a dual timeline. I did really enjoy parts of it, but then other parts were just sort of “meh” for me.
The writing was done well but I just didn’t feel like I really fully connected with any of the characters. The Kate character, at times, would speak in ways that seemed like it would have been too modern for 1870s ~ that was a bit jarring and made it a little hard to really stay “in” the story
I definitely did *not* predict the conclusion to the mystery ~ the author did really well with that aspect of the story!
I also really appreciated the gospel message and the strong pro-life message.
All in all, it was a good read but I just felt like it wasn’t quite as good as some of her others.
*Content Considerations* abortion, prostitution, suicide, mental health, spousal abuse, infertility are all touched on in this story.
*Thanks to NetGalley for my eARC copy ~ all opinions are strictly my own and have not been influenced in any way.*
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews