What do you think?
Rate this book
Win a free print copy of this book!
5 days and 07:22:19
50 copies available
U.S. only
It Girl: A Novel
Win a free print copy of this book!
5 days and 07:22:19
50 copies available
U.S. only
A sweeping, sensational novel of America’s first “It Girl,” whose dramatic journey to center stage echoes through the decades—from the New York Times bestselling author of The Magnificent Lives of Marjorie Post.
New York, 1900. At the dawn of a new century, the city’s streets teem with electricity, automobiles, a brash young President Teddy Roosevelt—and the It Girls. As artist’s muses and working models, these independent young women soar to stardom not because of their pedigrees or inherited wealth, but because of their talent, charisma, and irresistible beauty. Pop culture is born, and in a world alight with Mr. Edison’s new bulbs, no one shines brighter than America’s sweetheart, Evelyn Talbot.
But the journey to stardom was not simple or straight. As a young girl, a grieving Evelyn is forced to take care of her widowed mother and kid brother. While working as a shopgirl, she is recruited as a studio model, and soon catches the eye of the preeminent artists of her age. When Broadway comes calling, Evelyn solidifies her status as the first self-made American female celebrity, a “Gibson Girl,” the most sought-after face of her time. Enter a parade of powerful and power-hungry men, from world-famous architect Stanley Pierce, the visionary behind Manhattan’s mansions and iconic landmarks, to Hal Thorne, the shockingly wealthy railroad heir and premiere “playboy” of high society. Each man promises comfort, glamour, security—even love. But fame and fortune are cruel teachers.
When Evelyn finds herself at the center of a murder of passion declared “the Crime of the Century,” the sins of the men in her life are blamed on her. In the media frenzy that erupts, Evelyn realizes that—to survive—she will have to take charge of her own ending. But can this artists’ muse turned showgirl pull off the greatest act of her life?
It Girl is a breathtaking ride inspired by a singular artist and survivor who captured the heart of American society. In Allison Pataki’s talented hands, we see Evelyn find the power to change not only the world around her, but her own destiny.
New York, 1900. At the dawn of a new century, the city’s streets teem with electricity, automobiles, a brash young President Teddy Roosevelt—and the It Girls. As artist’s muses and working models, these independent young women soar to stardom not because of their pedigrees or inherited wealth, but because of their talent, charisma, and irresistible beauty. Pop culture is born, and in a world alight with Mr. Edison’s new bulbs, no one shines brighter than America’s sweetheart, Evelyn Talbot.
But the journey to stardom was not simple or straight. As a young girl, a grieving Evelyn is forced to take care of her widowed mother and kid brother. While working as a shopgirl, she is recruited as a studio model, and soon catches the eye of the preeminent artists of her age. When Broadway comes calling, Evelyn solidifies her status as the first self-made American female celebrity, a “Gibson Girl,” the most sought-after face of her time. Enter a parade of powerful and power-hungry men, from world-famous architect Stanley Pierce, the visionary behind Manhattan’s mansions and iconic landmarks, to Hal Thorne, the shockingly wealthy railroad heir and premiere “playboy” of high society. Each man promises comfort, glamour, security—even love. But fame and fortune are cruel teachers.
When Evelyn finds herself at the center of a murder of passion declared “the Crime of the Century,” the sins of the men in her life are blamed on her. In the media frenzy that erupts, Evelyn realizes that—to survive—she will have to take charge of her own ending. But can this artists’ muse turned showgirl pull off the greatest act of her life?
It Girl is a breathtaking ride inspired by a singular artist and survivor who captured the heart of American society. In Allison Pataki’s talented hands, we see Evelyn find the power to change not only the world around her, but her own destiny.
399 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 10, 2026
683 people are currently reading
23664 people want to read
About the author
Allison Pataki
12 books3,522 followersALLISON PATAKI is the NYTimes Bestselling author of THE TRAITOR'S WIFE, THE ACCIDENTAL EMPRESS, SISI:EMPRESS ON HER OWN, WHERE THE LIGHT FALLS, and the memoir, BEAUTY IN THE BROKEN PLACES.
Her work has been translated into more than a dozen languages, has been featured on The TODAY Show, The NY Times, The Huffington Post, USA Today, FOX News, Morning Joe, and more.
Visit AllisonPataki.com to connect and find out more.
Her work has been translated into more than a dozen languages, has been featured on The TODAY Show, The NY Times, The Huffington Post, USA Today, FOX News, Morning Joe, and more.
Visit AllisonPataki.com to connect and find out more.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 375 reviews
November 5, 2025
It Girl brings to light the story based on real-life of Evelyn Nesbit - model, actress, and one of those first girls for whom beauty and talent allowed to become independent. They were one of those giving birth to the pop-culture.
Evelyn’s story begins in 1897 Pittsburgh when she is an apple in her father’s eye who encourages her to dream big, but the fairy tale talk ends when her father dies suddenly.
In order to help pay the bills, the mother takes thirteen year old Evelyn out of school and gets her a job at department store. Evelyn is told to present herself as sixteen year old, and to observe what life could be.
Evelyn’s features grab attention of a customer who is a sketch artist and approaches Evelyn to pose for her. This is the beginning of cascading steps that lead Evelyn to the Broadway stage and ultimately her greatest fame.
After arriving in NYC in 1899, she begins her career in the city with the city’s most venerated artist James Carroll Beckwith. Then, Charles Dana Gibson, the famed sketch artist who wants Evelyn to be the next Gibson girl.
But when a stage agent approaches Evelyn, that’s when her interest truly peaks. She wants to sing and dance on stage. Movement makes her feel alive, so different from stagnant posing.
As she becomes a chorus girl, she catches an eye of Stanley Pierce (based on real-life architect Stanford White), a much older admirer who becomes her benefactor, showering her and her mother with luxury living, goods and travels.
When things get rocky between them, to pacify her, he gets hear a lead role in Shakespeare’s beloved masterpiece –The Tempest. She resents his help but here is her big chance to become a serious actress.
When she nears twenty, she becomes one of the oldest girls backstage. The girls her age move on as soon as they receive marriage proposal. It seems as at the right time the right man appears, Hal Thorne (based on real-life railroad tycoon Henry Thaw) – steel and railroad heir.
The novel is narrated in the first person with eloquent prose. The voice of Evelyn sounds very real and endearing. She exemplifies a character of someone who at young age loses support much needed at such fragile age, and someone who becomes a supporter of the family at very young age. The characters are well-developed, intriguing and flawed.
The author is known for staying close to the facts with historical figures and events in her biographical fiction. With this biographical fiction, the author takes more creative liberties. The very ending is completely different from the real one.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Evelyn’s story begins in 1897 Pittsburgh when she is an apple in her father’s eye who encourages her to dream big, but the fairy tale talk ends when her father dies suddenly.
In order to help pay the bills, the mother takes thirteen year old Evelyn out of school and gets her a job at department store. Evelyn is told to present herself as sixteen year old, and to observe what life could be.
Evelyn’s features grab attention of a customer who is a sketch artist and approaches Evelyn to pose for her. This is the beginning of cascading steps that lead Evelyn to the Broadway stage and ultimately her greatest fame.
After arriving in NYC in 1899, she begins her career in the city with the city’s most venerated artist James Carroll Beckwith. Then, Charles Dana Gibson, the famed sketch artist who wants Evelyn to be the next Gibson girl.
But when a stage agent approaches Evelyn, that’s when her interest truly peaks. She wants to sing and dance on stage. Movement makes her feel alive, so different from stagnant posing.
As she becomes a chorus girl, she catches an eye of Stanley Pierce (based on real-life architect Stanford White), a much older admirer who becomes her benefactor, showering her and her mother with luxury living, goods and travels.
When things get rocky between them, to pacify her, he gets hear a lead role in Shakespeare’s beloved masterpiece –The Tempest. She resents his help but here is her big chance to become a serious actress.
When she nears twenty, she becomes one of the oldest girls backstage. The girls her age move on as soon as they receive marriage proposal. It seems as at the right time the right man appears, Hal Thorne (based on real-life railroad tycoon Henry Thaw) – steel and railroad heir.
The novel is narrated in the first person with eloquent prose. The voice of Evelyn sounds very real and endearing. She exemplifies a character of someone who at young age loses support much needed at such fragile age, and someone who becomes a supporter of the family at very young age. The characters are well-developed, intriguing and flawed.
The author is known for staying close to the facts with historical figures and events in her biographical fiction. With this biographical fiction, the author takes more creative liberties. The very ending is completely different from the real one.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
I really really really enjoyed this book, I've never read any of this authors work, but I feel I must find more from her. This was such an amazing story, at times tragic and sad, and other joyful and happy! When this book comes out, it is a must read!
September 23, 2025
It Girl tells the story of Evelyn Talbot, a Gilded Age “It Girl” who rose from rags to riches as a model, actress, and star. Loosely based on Evelyn Nesbit, whose own life was full of scandal, the novel blends history and fiction in a way that immediately drew me in since I love reading about this era.
The first half was especially compelling. Evelyn begins modeling around age 13 to help support her struggling family in Pittsburgh, who are living in a cramped boarding house and barely scraping by. They scavenge for food, work grueling hours, and rely on her early jobs for survival. When Evelyn is discovered, they move to New York where she quickly becomes a celebrated model, appearing in Coca Cola ads and on calendars.
The second half shifts in tone. Since this is well before the Me Too era, it is not hard to anticipate some of the darker experiences awaiting Evelyn. I found the narrative leaned more on her personal relationships than on her career as a performer, and I would have liked to see more of the latter. Still, it was entertaining, if a bit surface level, in capturing the complexities of the time. There is tragedy that occurs, and I felt it was brushed off.
I have enjoyed Allison Pataki’s other novels for the way she highlights women in different historical periods, and this one fit that same mold.
Overall: an enjoyable, if not deeply layered, read.
The first half was especially compelling. Evelyn begins modeling around age 13 to help support her struggling family in Pittsburgh, who are living in a cramped boarding house and barely scraping by. They scavenge for food, work grueling hours, and rely on her early jobs for survival. When Evelyn is discovered, they move to New York where she quickly becomes a celebrated model, appearing in Coca Cola ads and on calendars.
The second half shifts in tone. Since this is well before the Me Too era, it is not hard to anticipate some of the darker experiences awaiting Evelyn. I found the narrative leaned more on her personal relationships than on her career as a performer, and I would have liked to see more of the latter. Still, it was entertaining, if a bit surface level, in capturing the complexities of the time. There is tragedy that occurs, and I felt it was brushed off.
I have enjoyed Allison Pataki’s other novels for the way she highlights women in different historical periods, and this one fit that same mold.
Overall: an enjoyable, if not deeply layered, read.
November 5, 2025
This was a fascinating look at the life of Evelyn Talbot, a girl who was raised in poverty to become a Broadway sen sensation in the early 1900s. Based on a real person, Evelyn has the look that draws everyone in. As a young girl, Evelyn is spotted and becomes an artist's muse. She works her way up to model and then actress. The only problem is that this is a man's world and there are many wealthy men who want to take advantage of Evelyn. Her mother, who should be looking out for her, really only craves the comfort and security that Evelyn's new found fame has brought. Evelyn must figure out how to have it all including her freedom.
Evelyn's story was captivating and an excellent read for anyone who loves historical fiction or strong females. I loved her intelligence and spirit. She had so much happen to her in her life and I always love to read about women who can accomplish so much when there is so much against them. I appreciate that the author included an author's note where she described the life of the real Evelyn Nesbit. You know an author is really talented when they can take a real person from history and turn their life into an interesting story with great characters. This book should definitely be on everyone's TBR shelf for 2026.
Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for this ARC.
Evelyn's story was captivating and an excellent read for anyone who loves historical fiction or strong females. I loved her intelligence and spirit. She had so much happen to her in her life and I always love to read about women who can accomplish so much when there is so much against them. I appreciate that the author included an author's note where she described the life of the real Evelyn Nesbit. You know an author is really talented when they can take a real person from history and turn their life into an interesting story with great characters. This book should definitely be on everyone's TBR shelf for 2026.
Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for this ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A sweeping tale of America's first "It Girl", Evelyn Talbot, based on the true story of Evelyn Nesbit. Evelyn's journey begins in poverty following the death of her father, with her mother struggling to make ends meet. Evelyn sits for an artist in her hometown and quickly the family moves to New York City where Evelyn sits for famous artists as their muse. She becomes a Gibson girl where her image is everywhere and she ends up center stage on Broadway. Her fame comes at a price as she catches the attention of much older, wealthy men. Many adults, including her mother exploited her for financial gain. Despite all this, Evelyn is positive, resilient and resourceful.
The audiobook performance by Barrie Kreinik is exceptional and brings Evelyn to life. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and highly recommend it for those who love historical fiction or novels about celebrities or icons.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Ballantine Books, PRH Audio and Allison Pataki for the gifted advance reader's copy and advance listening copy. All opinions are my own. 🎧📚
The audiobook performance by Barrie Kreinik is exceptional and brings Evelyn to life. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and highly recommend it for those who love historical fiction or novels about celebrities or icons.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Ballantine Books, PRH Audio and Allison Pataki for the gifted advance reader's copy and advance listening copy. All opinions are my own. 🎧📚
March 13, 2026
This is historical fiction at its most entertaining—glamorous, immersive, and unsettling beneath the surface.
The story follows Evelyn, who begins modeling at just thirteen after the death of her father leaves her family struggling. If he had lived, she likely would have stayed in school. Instead, her ambitious mother pushes her into the spotlight. The family moves from a small town in Pennsylvania to Pittsburgh, then Philadelphia, and finally New York, chasing opportunity.
By fifteen Evelyn is performing on Broadway and telling everyone she’s eighteen. She becomes a “Gibson Girl,” the beauty ideal of the early 1900s, and quickly attracts wealthy admirers. Eventually a benefactor appears who seems ready to give the family everything they need—but of course there is a price.
Pataki does a fantastic job capturing Manhattan at the turn of the century. The settings feel vivid and alive, while the darker side of early entertainment and modeling—especially the working conditions—is hard to ignore. Evelyn’s “momager” feels like a 1905 version of Kris Jenner—you can almost hear her saying “you’re doing amazing, sweetie” as Evelyn is posing nude at sixteen.
The story builds slowly, but the pacing works because it feels like a journey. Along the way there are hints that Evelyn may not be able to trust every man who showers her with money and attention. She’s also incredibly lonely and forced to grow up far too fast, which makes you feel protective of her at times.
The tension builds to a dramatic conclusion, and I was completely riveted.
Evelyn is based on a real person, but Pataki offers a more detailed and empowered ending—so don’t skip the author’s note at the end. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Thank you to Ballantine books for the finished copy!
The story follows Evelyn, who begins modeling at just thirteen after the death of her father leaves her family struggling. If he had lived, she likely would have stayed in school. Instead, her ambitious mother pushes her into the spotlight. The family moves from a small town in Pennsylvania to Pittsburgh, then Philadelphia, and finally New York, chasing opportunity.
By fifteen Evelyn is performing on Broadway and telling everyone she’s eighteen. She becomes a “Gibson Girl,” the beauty ideal of the early 1900s, and quickly attracts wealthy admirers. Eventually a benefactor appears who seems ready to give the family everything they need—but of course there is a price.
Pataki does a fantastic job capturing Manhattan at the turn of the century. The settings feel vivid and alive, while the darker side of early entertainment and modeling—especially the working conditions—is hard to ignore. Evelyn’s “momager” feels like a 1905 version of Kris Jenner—you can almost hear her saying “you’re doing amazing, sweetie” as Evelyn is posing nude at sixteen.
The story builds slowly, but the pacing works because it feels like a journey. Along the way there are hints that Evelyn may not be able to trust every man who showers her with money and attention. She’s also incredibly lonely and forced to grow up far too fast, which makes you feel protective of her at times.
The tension builds to a dramatic conclusion, and I was completely riveted.
Evelyn is based on a real person, but Pataki offers a more detailed and empowered ending—so don’t skip the author’s note at the end. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Thank you to Ballantine books for the finished copy!
February 17, 2026
This book got me out of my rut! Yay!
For the past week I have not felt like reading but since I received this book as a digital ARC I wanted to make sure I read it before its release date. Once I started I could not stop!
This historical fiction novel is loosely based on the real life of one of the Gibson Girls, a model, Broadway showgirl and actress of the early 1900’s. And as Allison Pataki, the author of this novel says, “history is juicer than fiction.” The main character, Evelyn, is a poor young girl who needed to work to help her mother pay for necessities. At 13 she has to lie about her age to work in a department store and when a shopper offers her money to pose as a model her life begins to change. Over the next few years she poses more and more and is in demand; finally she and her mother move to New York to capitalize on her beauty. This is when her life really changes.
What a story! I enjoyed every minute of it. Thank you Netgalley and Ballantine Books!
For the past week I have not felt like reading but since I received this book as a digital ARC I wanted to make sure I read it before its release date. Once I started I could not stop!
This historical fiction novel is loosely based on the real life of one of the Gibson Girls, a model, Broadway showgirl and actress of the early 1900’s. And as Allison Pataki, the author of this novel says, “history is juicer than fiction.” The main character, Evelyn, is a poor young girl who needed to work to help her mother pay for necessities. At 13 she has to lie about her age to work in a department store and when a shopper offers her money to pose as a model her life begins to change. Over the next few years she poses more and more and is in demand; finally she and her mother move to New York to capitalize on her beauty. This is when her life really changes.
What a story! I enjoyed every minute of it. Thank you Netgalley and Ballantine Books!
November 9, 2025
Absolutely fascinating. I had never heard of The Gibson girls, but anything this author writes, I read. She has an amazing gift as an author. This story was based on a real person and Pataki adds to her story which makes for a fascinating and engaging story. Her life was not an easy one and I felt for her and her circumstances. The ending was icing on the cake, when she found out what her life could truly be and I loved how it played out. Don’t want to give away the ending. Will be preordering as well.
September 22, 2025
This book isn't historical fiction, as the author has taken liberties with a true story and made it her own. She describes in the author notes what she did to modify the true story of Evelyn Nesbit, the woman on whom the main character is based. I found both the real story and the story written by the author of this book to be very compelling.
It was so easy to empathize with Evelyn. Her life was rough from a very young age. As more of her story is revealed, my heart hurt for her. On the other side of it I absolutely loathed Stanley Pierce. What a nasty piece of work this guy was. I wished I could have had a conversation with this guy. I wasn't much fond of Evelyn's mother either. Wish I could have had a word with her, too. This story evoked so many emotions while I was reading it. Characters I liked and characters I just couldn't stand. I thought the author did a great job in creating a wide range of characters, and as a result, it added a lot of depth to the story.
This book is over 400 pages, so there is plenty of time to spend with Evelyn and get to know her from childhood to womanhood. This is a story that I was really able to immerse myself in. The story is very well written and has a good flow to it from chapter to chapter. This is the second book I have read by this author, and I like her writing style. She has a way of pulling the reader into the story and keeping their attention. I found myself looking up things as I was reading the story. Reading about Madison Square Garden was interesting, as I had no idea what it looked like during the time of this story.
I highly recommend this book. Even though it isn't technically historical fiction, it has that feel to it. It is a well-written story and one that will stay with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my opinion.
It was so easy to empathize with Evelyn. Her life was rough from a very young age. As more of her story is revealed, my heart hurt for her. On the other side of it I absolutely loathed Stanley Pierce. What a nasty piece of work this guy was. I wished I could have had a conversation with this guy. I wasn't much fond of Evelyn's mother either. Wish I could have had a word with her, too. This story evoked so many emotions while I was reading it. Characters I liked and characters I just couldn't stand. I thought the author did a great job in creating a wide range of characters, and as a result, it added a lot of depth to the story.
This book is over 400 pages, so there is plenty of time to spend with Evelyn and get to know her from childhood to womanhood. This is a story that I was really able to immerse myself in. The story is very well written and has a good flow to it from chapter to chapter. This is the second book I have read by this author, and I like her writing style. She has a way of pulling the reader into the story and keeping their attention. I found myself looking up things as I was reading the story. Reading about Madison Square Garden was interesting, as I had no idea what it looked like during the time of this story.
I highly recommend this book. Even though it isn't technically historical fiction, it has that feel to it. It is a well-written story and one that will stay with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my opinion.
October 3, 2025
4.0. I’ve enjoyed Allison Pataki’s books, all very well researched and well written. This one, as she admits, is more fiction than historical fact, but it still is very interesting. She has loosely based this novel on Evelyn Nesbit, a Broadway actress, the subject of portraits from well known painters, the face of advertisements, and a beauty from the turn of the century. In the novel, the woman, Evelyn Talbot, apparently follows the life of Ms. Nesbit, but there are digressions. I had never heard of Evelyn Nesbit, but I learned about the times during the Gilded Age as well as the difficult life that Ms Nesbit as a child and then even as a successful person. Well researched, good character development, and interesting to read. Thank you Netgalley for an advance copy in exchange for a candid and unbiased review.
March 24, 2026
3.5 Stars
I found this story about Evelyn Talbot and her rise to fame at the turn of the century to be a really entertaining read. It is intriguing and well paced, certainly never felt bored. Evelyn is a young beauty and starts her modeling career at just 14. She then becomes a Gibson Girl and moves onto being a Showgirl on Broadway. All seems to be going her way, a rags to riches story, as Evelyn lives in Manhattan with her Mother and is able to pay for school for her younger brother. Soon Stanley White enters the picture, and right away I was creeped out by him as he has 16 year old Evelyn over and takes her upstairs to see his velvet swing in his bedroom. Next, he is asking that she calls him Stanny. I felt so bad for Evelyn, as she is too naive to see what is happening and her mother is too enraptured with the expensive gifts and food that she refuses to ask any questions. This is when you know, life may seem tied in a Beautiful Bow, but that will prove to be an illusion. I routed for Evelyn, being such a young girl and having so much happen to her by only 20 years old was tragic yet seemed a sign of the times she was living. She did gain much life experience and actually being the top beauty and true show girl offered a chance to enjoy that experience in a way woman normally would not.
The reason I gave this 3.5 Stars is because of the ending. This is a story based on the life of Evelyn Nesbit. I think if you are going to write about an actual person, then diving into fantasy elements does not work. The story could have been told just keeping the character completely fictional and let it stand on it's own and let it be the enjoyable story it is with an ending that I would than love.
Suggest reading this if you are looking for a great story set in a time period you don't get to read about that often. It is an entertaining and fast paced read. If you are looking for historical accuracy about a real woman, then this might not be the best book for you.
Thank you NetGalley and Ballentine Books for a copy of this book. I always leave reviews of books I read.
I found this story about Evelyn Talbot and her rise to fame at the turn of the century to be a really entertaining read. It is intriguing and well paced, certainly never felt bored. Evelyn is a young beauty and starts her modeling career at just 14. She then becomes a Gibson Girl and moves onto being a Showgirl on Broadway. All seems to be going her way, a rags to riches story, as Evelyn lives in Manhattan with her Mother and is able to pay for school for her younger brother. Soon Stanley White enters the picture, and right away I was creeped out by him as he has 16 year old Evelyn over and takes her upstairs to see his velvet swing in his bedroom. Next, he is asking that she calls him Stanny. I felt so bad for Evelyn, as she is too naive to see what is happening and her mother is too enraptured with the expensive gifts and food that she refuses to ask any questions. This is when you know, life may seem tied in a Beautiful Bow, but that will prove to be an illusion. I routed for Evelyn, being such a young girl and having so much happen to her by only 20 years old was tragic yet seemed a sign of the times she was living. She did gain much life experience and actually being the top beauty and true show girl offered a chance to enjoy that experience in a way woman normally would not.
The reason I gave this 3.5 Stars is because of the ending. This is a story based on the life of Evelyn Nesbit. I think if you are going to write about an actual person, then diving into fantasy elements does not work. The story could have been told just keeping the character completely fictional and let it stand on it's own and let it be the enjoyable story it is with an ending that I would than love.
Suggest reading this if you are looking for a great story set in a time period you don't get to read about that often. It is an entertaining and fast paced read. If you are looking for historical accuracy about a real woman, then this might not be the best book for you.
Thank you NetGalley and Ballentine Books for a copy of this book. I always leave reviews of books I read.
September 20, 2025
Allison Pataki’s books capture my attention, no matter who she writes about.
“It Girl” is a poignant tale of Evelyn Talbot’s childhood of poverty and her tenacious rise to stardom. She is very naive and it quickly becomes evident that some of the people who help her along the way do not have her best interests at heart.
Mr. Gibson told her, “Learn to swim. And then you’ll survive.” Eventually Evelyn grows up and comes to understand his message. But her glamorous lifestyle in New York gives us a fascinating glimpse into early Broadway and the Gilded Age.
Based on the true life story of Evelyn Nesbit.
Special thanks to the publishers at NetGalley for the advanced reader copy to review.
“It Girl” is a poignant tale of Evelyn Talbot’s childhood of poverty and her tenacious rise to stardom. She is very naive and it quickly becomes evident that some of the people who help her along the way do not have her best interests at heart.
Mr. Gibson told her, “Learn to swim. And then you’ll survive.” Eventually Evelyn grows up and comes to understand his message. But her glamorous lifestyle in New York gives us a fascinating glimpse into early Broadway and the Gilded Age.
Based on the true life story of Evelyn Nesbit.
Special thanks to the publishers at NetGalley for the advanced reader copy to review.
September 18, 2025
Another magnificent story by Allison Pataki. This book is based on the life of Evelyn Nesbit and is an absolutely incredible tale. The author does an amazing job of weaving the true facts of Nesbit's life with our fictional character Evelyn Talbot's life. Evelyn's story is sad, tragic, inspiring, hopeful and satisfying. Told with just the right amount of details - this book has it all! Thanks to Netgalley, the author and publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.5 Stars
Trigger warning: rape and pedophilia.
Also, try not to do any research on these people, as it may spoil the book for you.
This is a Historical/FICTION book. Remember the word ' fiction' when you are reading this, since many reviewers are getting hung up on some things that don't fit their idea of what this book is about.
I did some mild research (Wiki) on who these people were based on other reviewers naming names. And becuase of that, some parts of this book were spoiled for me, but the biggest shock was how the author ended this book. Let me tell you, it was a huge shock, and it was wonderful.
The only reason why I didn't give this a full 4-star rating was that the characters annoyed me so much. I realize this book was written at the turn of the last century, and times were WAY different, but I still thought that Evelyn should have stood up for herself a bit more and not have been so naive. Perhaps she should have just asked more questions of those around her who had more experience in the arts and the theater. I just can't help myself. When I see a person who has been warned and still does what she was warned against, I get annoyed.
However, this book has very richly drawn characters, and an interesting plot twist near the end of the book and a wonderful look into the lives of the artists' models, the Gibson Girls and Vaudeville.
I would highly recommend It Girl: A Novel, especially to book clubs looking for something a tad more controversial to discuss.
*ARC supplied by the publisher Ballantine Books/Random House Publishing, the author, and NetGalley.
Trigger warning: rape and pedophilia.
Also, try not to do any research on these people, as it may spoil the book for you.
This is a Historical/FICTION book. Remember the word ' fiction' when you are reading this, since many reviewers are getting hung up on some things that don't fit their idea of what this book is about.
I did some mild research (Wiki) on who these people were based on other reviewers naming names. And becuase of that, some parts of this book were spoiled for me, but the biggest shock was how the author ended this book. Let me tell you, it was a huge shock, and it was wonderful.
The only reason why I didn't give this a full 4-star rating was that the characters annoyed me so much. I realize this book was written at the turn of the last century, and times were WAY different, but I still thought that Evelyn should have stood up for herself a bit more and not have been so naive. Perhaps she should have just asked more questions of those around her who had more experience in the arts and the theater. I just can't help myself. When I see a person who has been warned and still does what she was warned against, I get annoyed.
However, this book has very richly drawn characters, and an interesting plot twist near the end of the book and a wonderful look into the lives of the artists' models, the Gibson Girls and Vaudeville.
I would highly recommend It Girl: A Novel, especially to book clubs looking for something a tad more controversial to discuss.
*ARC supplied by the publisher Ballantine Books/Random House Publishing, the author, and NetGalley.
December 7, 2025
I truly loved the magnificent lives of marjorie post by this author. So when the opportunity came up to review another book by Alison Pataki, I jumped to the chance! Although I was unfamiliar with the subject, Evelyn Nesbit (Talbot in the book) I was excited to dive in. Wow! What a challenging but privileged life she led. I learned a lot, and my heart broke for her. Alison Pataki has become one of my must read authors.
September 27, 2025
A compelling fictionalized story based on the life of Gibson girl and Gilded Age "It Girl," Evelyn Nesbit. The author writes masterful historical fiction that illuminates exceptional women: Their lives, their hopes, their triumphs and downfalls, and It Girl is a perfect example of why I love her work. Highly recommended!
Read
March 19, 2026A propulsive tale reminiscent of the sad fate of starlets like Britney Spears and Marilyn Monroe awaits in Allison Pataki’s latest novel. Inspired by the real life of an early 20th century model and showgirl, this novel takes you from the frigid streets of Pittsburgh to the lights of Broadway in New York City. The sordid underbelly of the entertainment industry is evident even in its earliest iteration, and I felt so horrible for this young woman and her lack of protection. Allison always writes such descriptive prose that you can visualize the scenes in the gilded ballrooms of New York and the stifled mansions of Pittsburgh. This is the first time that Allison has embellished on the historical record in her books so know going in that it’s not a fully true story - but it is entertaining and full of rich historical details.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my ARC.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my ARC.
March 22, 2026
“As we showgirls often quipped backstage, with a bit more world weariness than our tender ages should have afforded us: ‘It's either learn the ropes, sweetie, or else hang.’”
Allison Pataki’s “It Girl” is a ravishing and ultimately devastating portrait of Evelyn Talbot: a fictionalized version of true icon Evelyn Nesbit, the original American “It Girl,” whose dazzling rise through turn-of-the-century New York society concealed a darkness that would come to define her. This novel is historical fiction at its most immersive and most necessary. Intoxicatingly glamorous on the surface but unflinching about the machinery beneath, Evelyn’s story succeeds as an intimate character study, narrative reclamation, and historical excavation.
Pataki’s prose is a masterclass in immersive atmosphere, conjuring turn-of-the-century New York with a vividness that feels more like memory than research. From Gilded Age drawing rooms to sunlit artist’s studios, the dazzle of showgirl life on Broadway to the precise poise of Old Money, each scene is a feast for the senses. It would be easy for characters to be overshadowed by such evocative scenery, yet Pataki provides a cast that feels fully inhabited and alive. Even minor characters simmer with complexity and personality. Beautifully written without being overwrought, everything from the imagery to the characters to the language functions as a vehicle for the novel’s glamour.
Pataki opens with a structural gambit that lesser novelists would fumble: a prologue that reframes everything that follows and pays off, in the final pages, with the kind of cathartic shock that compels readers to instantly start over from page one. By immediately establishing high stakes and preparing readers for an unhappy ending, the prologue hooks readers with a propulsive sense of foreboding. As the reader’s investment in Evelyn deepens, so does their dread. The prologue functions as load-bearing architecture whose full purpose only becomes clear at the novel’s conclusion, even as it sustains narrative tension throughout.
At the novel’s heart is a shattering act of violence against a sixteen-year-old girl, and Pataki handles it with the gravity and unflinching honesty it deserves, tracing the long shadow it casts over every choice Evelyn makes thereafter. She is forced to set aside her innocence, giving way to calculation as a matter of survival. Yet, Pataki clearly argues that Evelyn hardens herself not as corruption but as adaptation: a young woman learning the rules of a game she never agreed to play. Her story is told with striking empathy that cuts straight to reader’s hearts.
What elevates “It Girl” above a mere tragedy is its final, hard-won turn toward agency; the conclusion refuses to let men be the architects of Evelyn’s salvation or damnation. As Evelyn finds herself in a state where everything she is is too much—too free, too vulnerable, too beautiful, too soft—her reclamation of power comes through genuine female solidarity rather than the romantic rescue she’s always leaned into. In a novel about a woman used by men, there is a deliberate and meaningful feminist throughline that successfully returns the power to Evelyn while indicting the historical figures who got away with her harm.
Pataki’s meticulous author’s note, which carefully delineates the real Evelyn Nesbit’s story from her fictionalized counterpart, transforms what might have been a footnote into an essential companion and sends readers immediately to their search engines. By being transparent about the moments where fiction filled in the fact, Pataki beautifully honors Nesbit’s trials and legacy. In a mark of great historical fiction, most readers will likely enter into this story unfamiliar with Nesbit; yet, they will finish genuinely more knowledgeable about a real icon during a turbulent chapter of American history.
In an era when women’s stories—particularly those of women who were used, discarded, and then blamed for both—are finally being reclaimed and retold with the complexity they deserve, “It Girl” arrives as an urgent and luminous contribution to that conversation. Evelyn’s story is a mirror held up to enduring patterns of exploitation and resilience; her world is gone but her experience is not. This book will entertain readers drawn to Gilded Age glamour and character-driven historical fiction. But even more, this story will resonate the most with those drawn to stories about women who refuse to stay broken, who fight to reclaim their agency and their joy, and who force people to ask what is owed to the women that history has used and forgotten.
Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Allison Pataki’s “It Girl” is a ravishing and ultimately devastating portrait of Evelyn Talbot: a fictionalized version of true icon Evelyn Nesbit, the original American “It Girl,” whose dazzling rise through turn-of-the-century New York society concealed a darkness that would come to define her. This novel is historical fiction at its most immersive and most necessary. Intoxicatingly glamorous on the surface but unflinching about the machinery beneath, Evelyn’s story succeeds as an intimate character study, narrative reclamation, and historical excavation.
Pataki’s prose is a masterclass in immersive atmosphere, conjuring turn-of-the-century New York with a vividness that feels more like memory than research. From Gilded Age drawing rooms to sunlit artist’s studios, the dazzle of showgirl life on Broadway to the precise poise of Old Money, each scene is a feast for the senses. It would be easy for characters to be overshadowed by such evocative scenery, yet Pataki provides a cast that feels fully inhabited and alive. Even minor characters simmer with complexity and personality. Beautifully written without being overwrought, everything from the imagery to the characters to the language functions as a vehicle for the novel’s glamour.
Pataki opens with a structural gambit that lesser novelists would fumble: a prologue that reframes everything that follows and pays off, in the final pages, with the kind of cathartic shock that compels readers to instantly start over from page one. By immediately establishing high stakes and preparing readers for an unhappy ending, the prologue hooks readers with a propulsive sense of foreboding. As the reader’s investment in Evelyn deepens, so does their dread. The prologue functions as load-bearing architecture whose full purpose only becomes clear at the novel’s conclusion, even as it sustains narrative tension throughout.
At the novel’s heart is a shattering act of violence against a sixteen-year-old girl, and Pataki handles it with the gravity and unflinching honesty it deserves, tracing the long shadow it casts over every choice Evelyn makes thereafter. She is forced to set aside her innocence, giving way to calculation as a matter of survival. Yet, Pataki clearly argues that Evelyn hardens herself not as corruption but as adaptation: a young woman learning the rules of a game she never agreed to play. Her story is told with striking empathy that cuts straight to reader’s hearts.
What elevates “It Girl” above a mere tragedy is its final, hard-won turn toward agency; the conclusion refuses to let men be the architects of Evelyn’s salvation or damnation. As Evelyn finds herself in a state where everything she is is too much—too free, too vulnerable, too beautiful, too soft—her reclamation of power comes through genuine female solidarity rather than the romantic rescue she’s always leaned into. In a novel about a woman used by men, there is a deliberate and meaningful feminist throughline that successfully returns the power to Evelyn while indicting the historical figures who got away with her harm.
Pataki’s meticulous author’s note, which carefully delineates the real Evelyn Nesbit’s story from her fictionalized counterpart, transforms what might have been a footnote into an essential companion and sends readers immediately to their search engines. By being transparent about the moments where fiction filled in the fact, Pataki beautifully honors Nesbit’s trials and legacy. In a mark of great historical fiction, most readers will likely enter into this story unfamiliar with Nesbit; yet, they will finish genuinely more knowledgeable about a real icon during a turbulent chapter of American history.
In an era when women’s stories—particularly those of women who were used, discarded, and then blamed for both—are finally being reclaimed and retold with the complexity they deserve, “It Girl” arrives as an urgent and luminous contribution to that conversation. Evelyn’s story is a mirror held up to enduring patterns of exploitation and resilience; her world is gone but her experience is not. This book will entertain readers drawn to Gilded Age glamour and character-driven historical fiction. But even more, this story will resonate the most with those drawn to stories about women who refuse to stay broken, who fight to reclaim their agency and their joy, and who force people to ask what is owed to the women that history has used and forgotten.
Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
March 10, 2026
It Girl by Allison Pataki was one of my most anticipated new novels of 2026. I’m a big fan of this author, having read and enjoyed several of her previous novels (my favorites are The Queen’s Fortune and The Magnificent Lives of Marjorie Post). I anticipated It Girl to be another well researched and well written historical fiction novel, and I was not disappointed. It Girl tells the story of Evelyn Talbot, loosely based on the life of Evelyn Nesbit, a famous artist’s model and Broadway showgirl in the early 1900’s, and possibly the world’s first “it girl.”
I was quickly captivated by the drama of Evelyn’s life. She’s young and naive (I blame her mother!), but motivated by success and easy to root for. The way she was groomed by elite men in power was infuriating, but sadly unsurprising. I initially had mixed feelings about how realistic the ending was, until I read the fascinating author’s note. Her explanation for choosing to write this as fiction, rather than biography, was both interesting and enlightening. I would highly recommend this well written and entertaining new historical fiction novel. 4/5⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for this advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
I was quickly captivated by the drama of Evelyn’s life. She’s young and naive (I blame her mother!), but motivated by success and easy to root for. The way she was groomed by elite men in power was infuriating, but sadly unsurprising. I initially had mixed feelings about how realistic the ending was, until I read the fascinating author’s note. Her explanation for choosing to write this as fiction, rather than biography, was both interesting and enlightening. I would highly recommend this well written and entertaining new historical fiction novel. 4/5⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for this advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
November 1, 2025
This HF is by turns a spicy , poignant and revelent fictionalized account of Artist's Model Turned turned Broadway Showgirl Evelyn Nesbit; called Evelyn Talbot in this novel. The story opens in The late 1890's & Evelyn ,her mother and younger brother ,Kit ,have fallen on hard times after the father ,who Evelyn was very close to, suddenly passes. The family is left penniless, forced to eat from dumpsters & beg outside of restaurants for any left-over food. After humiliating themselves when asking for money from of the wealthiest women in Pittsburgh, her mother,who dreams of becoming a dressmaker to the town's Millionaire's Row women, decided to give up that dream for a job as a shopgirl in Wanamaker's Dept store . She then gets her daughter to lie about her age so she can work there as well . iNot long after working there she gets discovered by a local female artist , who while shopping gets waited on by Evelyn,notices her striking beauty and wants the teenager to pose for her,which he does .
This leads to other modeling gigs w/artists and illustrators such as William Frederic Church and Charles Dana Gibson( who used Evelyn as his inspo for his famous "Gibson Girl") Soon Evelyn's beautiful face is everywhere from Candy Boxes to a semi -nude painting;which although the male artist handles it well,Evelyn feels exposed , awkward and relieved when it's over.
Tired of sitting for hours on end while modeling and w/enough money saved ,Evelyn persuades her mother to let them relocate to New York City,where Evelyn can try out for Broadway shows. After putting her brother Kit in a boarding school ,they make the move. Living in a boardinghouse while Evelyn auditions & then lands a part in the chorus . She loves being able to perform rather than sit for portraits and soon lands a featured role. Then the men come calling..
The much-older Stanley Pierce ( based on real-life architect Stanford White) becomes infatuated with Evelyn after watching her onstage repeatedly . He soon makes an "Arrangement" for Evelyn and her mother to live at the Aubodon ,a posh hotel that he designed, w/their every want & need generously supplied. Evelyn (now only 15 ) is thrilled at first but then things go south when he drugs his young mistress and "Unvirgins" her. He also likes to have her play on a red velvet swing . She soon finds out about his other woman ( all also most likely on the "Younger Side" ) and a disillusioned Evelyn decides -to her mother's dismay -to leave "Stanny".
After a brief summer affair w/a young illustrator who,much to Evelyn's auger,is bought off by Pierce ,Evelyn meets Hal Throne( Based on Railroad Tycoon Henry Thaw) They soon marry , moving to Pittsburgh,where Evelyn feels like a caged bird ,living in the same large, cold mansion where she begged just a few years before. Her mother-in-law is a rigid church-going widow who despises her new daughter -in-law,whom she's frequently left alone with while Hal goes golfing & hanging out at his gentlemen's club. He's also fiercely jealous of his new bride's former relationship w/Stanley Pierce and starts becoming abusive to Evelyn, also going around w/a pistol to "Protect his Booful Wife"'
The book comes to a head when Evelyn begs Hal to take her to NYC as an anniversary gift. What happens next is quite different from the actual events which bothered me a little,though I liked how Pataki let Evelyn take matters into her own hands. This was a fast -moving tale which sadly parallels recent events regarding exploited under-age girls which added a layer of pathos to it . I enjoyed "It Girl" though I felt it could've gone a bit deeper emotionally . Recommended for those who enjoy their HF mixed w/ scandal . ( I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review)
This leads to other modeling gigs w/artists and illustrators such as William Frederic Church and Charles Dana Gibson( who used Evelyn as his inspo for his famous "Gibson Girl") Soon Evelyn's beautiful face is everywhere from Candy Boxes to a semi -nude painting;which although the male artist handles it well,Evelyn feels exposed , awkward and relieved when it's over.
Tired of sitting for hours on end while modeling and w/enough money saved ,Evelyn persuades her mother to let them relocate to New York City,where Evelyn can try out for Broadway shows. After putting her brother Kit in a boarding school ,they make the move. Living in a boardinghouse while Evelyn auditions & then lands a part in the chorus . She loves being able to perform rather than sit for portraits and soon lands a featured role. Then the men come calling..
The much-older Stanley Pierce ( based on real-life architect Stanford White) becomes infatuated with Evelyn after watching her onstage repeatedly . He soon makes an "Arrangement" for Evelyn and her mother to live at the Aubodon ,a posh hotel that he designed, w/their every want & need generously supplied. Evelyn (now only 15 ) is thrilled at first but then things go south when he drugs his young mistress and "Unvirgins" her. He also likes to have her play on a red velvet swing . She soon finds out about his other woman ( all also most likely on the "Younger Side" ) and a disillusioned Evelyn decides -to her mother's dismay -to leave "Stanny".
After a brief summer affair w/a young illustrator who,much to Evelyn's auger,is bought off by Pierce ,Evelyn meets Hal Throne( Based on Railroad Tycoon Henry Thaw) They soon marry , moving to Pittsburgh,where Evelyn feels like a caged bird ,living in the same large, cold mansion where she begged just a few years before. Her mother-in-law is a rigid church-going widow who despises her new daughter -in-law,whom she's frequently left alone with while Hal goes golfing & hanging out at his gentlemen's club. He's also fiercely jealous of his new bride's former relationship w/Stanley Pierce and starts becoming abusive to Evelyn, also going around w/a pistol to "Protect his Booful Wife"'
The book comes to a head when Evelyn begs Hal to take her to NYC as an anniversary gift. What happens next is quite different from the actual events which bothered me a little,though I liked how Pataki let Evelyn take matters into her own hands. This was a fast -moving tale which sadly parallels recent events regarding exploited under-age girls which added a layer of pathos to it . I enjoyed "It Girl" though I felt it could've gone a bit deeper emotionally . Recommended for those who enjoy their HF mixed w/ scandal . ( I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review)
March 11, 2026
Thank you to net galley, ballantine publishing company, and Allison Pataki for allowing me to read this book. The author puts a lot of research to write about a real life person known as the "it girl" Evelyn. This book can be compared to the modern day Epstein files. I look forward to reading more books from this well researched author.
November 23, 2025
This is inspired by Evelyn Nesbit, a Gibson Girl. In this version, Evelyn Talbot has similar ups and downs, with a chance to rewrite her ending. It's sad that her main suitors were able to hide their evil sides for so long.
Side note: I hate the cover. It doesn't feel representative of the novel's time period.
Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for the ARC.
Side note: I hate the cover. It doesn't feel representative of the novel's time period.
Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for the ARC.
Read
January 9, 2026I crack my egg of love
crush my power
sing to sun
dance to moon
shag my star
iam girl nt aged with leaf fall
darw my love of art
paint my futur aginst poor past
fight my war
iam girl nt aged with flying year
murder any stone
play with clock of grom
sea my words
sing my dream
iam girl nt aged with storm of season
crush my power
sing to sun
dance to moon
shag my star
iam girl nt aged with leaf fall
darw my love of art
paint my futur aginst poor past
fight my war
iam girl nt aged with flying year
murder any stone
play with clock of grom
sea my words
sing my dream
iam girl nt aged with storm of season
March 22, 2026
It Girl is surprisingly my first book by Allison Pataki. The description drew me in as someone who is interested in Broadway and the performing arts. While this book is inspired by real life model and chorus girl Evelyn Nesbit, It Girl is a work of fiction.
I was drawn into the first half of this book as Evelyn. makes her way from a young girl working to help put food on her family's table, to a young starlet. Her journey at the beginning from model to stage is incredibly interesting. I liked the juxtaposition between her maturity in the workplace and her naivety when it came to relationships.
The story got tough for me with the introduction of Stanley Pierce. His presence in Evelyn's life is believable, especially knowing what we do in present times. Stanley Pierce love bombs and grooms Evelyn knowing very much so that she is a minor. I felt uncomfortably tense as Stanley pursued Evelyn knowing that something bad would happen, and it does. While the SA in this book is not graphic it is present. After that he entraps her in the relationship, using his money and power to control her lifestyle and career.
As the book moved forward I felt that the pacing got stuck a bit. Hal Thorne, even more rich than Stanley, enters the plot as a way from Evelyn to escape under Stanley's finger. I wanted to feel relief but much of the relationship between Evelyn and Hal felt like a slightly more mature copy and paste.
The description led me to believe that the murder of passion labeled the "Crime of the Century" would take up the last part of the book. Instead, it occurs at the very end and is a very quick scene that leads to the ending with very little drama.
As someone who has made a career out of the performing arts, part of me is glad I read this book. I had never heard of Evelyn Nesbit before and it shed light on a piece of history that I didn't previously know about. In order for me to personally enjoy this book I wish more time had been spent on Evelyn's performance career and a little less time spent on the grooming and assault of the powerful men in her life.
I was drawn into the first half of this book as Evelyn. makes her way from a young girl working to help put food on her family's table, to a young starlet. Her journey at the beginning from model to stage is incredibly interesting. I liked the juxtaposition between her maturity in the workplace and her naivety when it came to relationships.
The story got tough for me with the introduction of Stanley Pierce. His presence in Evelyn's life is believable, especially knowing what we do in present times. Stanley Pierce love bombs and grooms Evelyn knowing very much so that she is a minor. I felt uncomfortably tense as Stanley pursued Evelyn knowing that something bad would happen, and it does. While the SA in this book is not graphic it is present. After that he entraps her in the relationship, using his money and power to control her lifestyle and career.
As the book moved forward I felt that the pacing got stuck a bit. Hal Thorne, even more rich than Stanley, enters the plot as a way from Evelyn to escape under Stanley's finger. I wanted to feel relief but much of the relationship between Evelyn and Hal felt like a slightly more mature copy and paste.
The description led me to believe that the murder of passion labeled the "Crime of the Century" would take up the last part of the book. Instead, it occurs at the very end and is a very quick scene that leads to the ending with very little drama.
As someone who has made a career out of the performing arts, part of me is glad I read this book. I had never heard of Evelyn Nesbit before and it shed light on a piece of history that I didn't previously know about. In order for me to personally enjoy this book I wish more time had been spent on Evelyn's performance career and a little less time spent on the grooming and assault of the powerful men in her life.
March 20, 2026
I really enjoyed this one. ♥️
A huge thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for my advanced copy of It Girl by Allison Pataki.
I both read and listened to this story, and I highly recommend experiencing it in either format.
This novel offers a fictionalized look at the early life of Evelyn Nesbit through the character of Evelyn Talbot, and I loved how it brought depth and humanity to a figure I had only known in fragments. Like many, I was familiar with the photographs and the vague outlines of her “scandalous” love life, but this story gave me a much fuller understanding of who she was and what she endured.
Evelyn’s story is not one of glamour. It’s one of survival. She comes from poverty, and one of the earliest scenes, where she’s knocking on a wealthy family’s door with her mother and brother begging for Christmas dinner, sets the tone for just how precarious her life was. She is young, vulnerable, and often taken advantage of by the very people who should have protected her.
I found myself emotionally invested in her. Through it all, she does what she has to do in order to survive, and her resilience really stayed with me long after I finished the book.
This was my first novel by Allison Pataki, but it definitely won’t be my last. It Girl was everything I look for in historical fiction : engaging, accessible, impactful, and rooted in real history in a way that makes you want to learn more.
Well Done.
A huge thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for my advanced copy of It Girl by Allison Pataki.
I both read and listened to this story, and I highly recommend experiencing it in either format.
This novel offers a fictionalized look at the early life of Evelyn Nesbit through the character of Evelyn Talbot, and I loved how it brought depth and humanity to a figure I had only known in fragments. Like many, I was familiar with the photographs and the vague outlines of her “scandalous” love life, but this story gave me a much fuller understanding of who she was and what she endured.
Evelyn’s story is not one of glamour. It’s one of survival. She comes from poverty, and one of the earliest scenes, where she’s knocking on a wealthy family’s door with her mother and brother begging for Christmas dinner, sets the tone for just how precarious her life was. She is young, vulnerable, and often taken advantage of by the very people who should have protected her.
I found myself emotionally invested in her. Through it all, she does what she has to do in order to survive, and her resilience really stayed with me long after I finished the book.
This was my first novel by Allison Pataki, but it definitely won’t be my last. It Girl was everything I look for in historical fiction : engaging, accessible, impactful, and rooted in real history in a way that makes you want to learn more.
Well Done.
February 20, 2026
She was an artist's muse, a Gibson Girl, America's sweetheart. But behind the fame was a sixteen-year-old girl fighting to survive. This story wrecked me.
It Girl is based on Evelyn Nesbit's life, and what a journey it is. This has a darker undertone that can be felt from the beginning. It builds as we follow the progression of Evelyn's life, from artist's muse to showgirl.
Pataki's words captured the emotional resonance of Evelyn's sense of family - being the provider at sixteen. She was an ingénue grasping to understand the world around her. She was conscious of being seen as naive, which made matters worse.
I was most disappointed by Evelyn's mother in the story. I couldn't believe her nonchalance and how she entrusted Evelyn to their patron. My heart broke for Evelyn. She was pulled in all directions.
This novel was heartbreaking, dramatic, and wonderfully written. It stirred so much in me - from curiosity to sadness to triumph.
While the ending differs from real life, I enjoyed this version. Her fight for self-worth and independence resonated deeply.
Audio experience: Listening to the audiobook, I felt transported to the 1900s. Barrie Kreinik mirrored the way they spoke in that era. Her portrayal of Evelyn and how she evolved from a sixteen-year-old to a woman was spot on and stayed true to what the book was trying to convey.
You'll love this if: You want historical fiction about early celebrity culture, women fighting for agency, and stories based on real lives.
Thanks to Ballantine Books, Penguin Random House Audio, and NetGalley for the advance copies.
It Girl is based on Evelyn Nesbit's life, and what a journey it is. This has a darker undertone that can be felt from the beginning. It builds as we follow the progression of Evelyn's life, from artist's muse to showgirl.
Pataki's words captured the emotional resonance of Evelyn's sense of family - being the provider at sixteen. She was an ingénue grasping to understand the world around her. She was conscious of being seen as naive, which made matters worse.
I was most disappointed by Evelyn's mother in the story. I couldn't believe her nonchalance and how she entrusted Evelyn to their patron. My heart broke for Evelyn. She was pulled in all directions.
This novel was heartbreaking, dramatic, and wonderfully written. It stirred so much in me - from curiosity to sadness to triumph.
While the ending differs from real life, I enjoyed this version. Her fight for self-worth and independence resonated deeply.
Audio experience: Listening to the audiobook, I felt transported to the 1900s. Barrie Kreinik mirrored the way they spoke in that era. Her portrayal of Evelyn and how she evolved from a sixteen-year-old to a woman was spot on and stayed true to what the book was trying to convey.
You'll love this if: You want historical fiction about early celebrity culture, women fighting for agency, and stories based on real lives.
Thanks to Ballantine Books, Penguin Random House Audio, and NetGalley for the advance copies.
February 18, 2026
Book Report: It Girl by Allison Pataki
At the turn of the twentieth century as New York blazes with electricity, ambition and social change…a young shopgirl named Evelyn Talbot rises from poverty to become America’s first true “It Girl.” From artists’ studios to Broadway stages…she becomes the face of a generation…admired and ultimately scrutinized…learning the hard way that fame comes with a price.
This was truly such a great piece of historical fiction inspired by a real and remarkable woman🌟 I read this as my nighttime Kindle read and was genuinely giddy to return to it each evening. Following Evelyn’s journey…from hardship to glittering fame and through the tragic moments in between. It kept me completely invested. I was so curious at every turn what would happen next.
And the author’s note? So thorough and fascinating. Learning about the real life Evelyn Nesbit who inspired this story made it all the more compelling.
Thank you Ballantine Books for the advanced ecopy!
Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/Lyon.brit.A...
At the turn of the twentieth century as New York blazes with electricity, ambition and social change…a young shopgirl named Evelyn Talbot rises from poverty to become America’s first true “It Girl.” From artists’ studios to Broadway stages…she becomes the face of a generation…admired and ultimately scrutinized…learning the hard way that fame comes with a price.
This was truly such a great piece of historical fiction inspired by a real and remarkable woman🌟 I read this as my nighttime Kindle read and was genuinely giddy to return to it each evening. Following Evelyn’s journey…from hardship to glittering fame and through the tragic moments in between. It kept me completely invested. I was so curious at every turn what would happen next.
And the author’s note? So thorough and fascinating. Learning about the real life Evelyn Nesbit who inspired this story made it all the more compelling.
Thank you Ballantine Books for the advanced ecopy!
Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/Lyon.brit.A...
Read
March 4, 2026I don't read that much historical fiction but am always up for something set during the Gilded Age (I have a whole list of Gilded Age Fiction here on Jen Ryland Reviews
The It Girl was very readable and slightly modern feeling, with lot of research clearly put into it. Going in, I had only the vaguest idea the whole Evelyn Nesbit/Harry Thaw/Stanford White deadly love triangle, and it took me a while to realize that is the true story this book is based on. In the afterword, the author explains what changes she made.
If you're a fan of Gilded Age stories, I'd definitely give this a try! If you've read other books by the author let me know what you recommend in comments!
Thanks to the publisher for providing an advance copy for review!
The It Girl was very readable and slightly modern feeling, with lot of research clearly put into it. Going in, I had only the vaguest idea the whole Evelyn Nesbit/Harry Thaw/Stanford White deadly love triangle, and it took me a while to realize that is the true story this book is based on. In the afterword, the author explains what changes she made.
If you're a fan of Gilded Age stories, I'd definitely give this a try! If you've read other books by the author let me know what you recommend in comments!
Thanks to the publisher for providing an advance copy for review!
November 5, 2025
Allison Pataki is a go to author for me. She has written a fictionalized account of the tragic life of Evelyn Nesbit changing the names of the actual people involved. Her writing made the time period of the early 20th century come alive. All her characters were well developed which kept the story moving along. The main character was a naive teenager with extraordinary good looks which made her in high demand as a model, chorus girl and actress. She quickly learned the price of becoming the top It Girl as she became the pursuit of many men. Excellent writing about a time period when women didn’t have much power makes this a book that I highly recommend. Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for an advanced eGalley of this book for an honest review. All opinions are my own. #ItGirl #AllisonPataki #NetGalley
Displaying 1 - 30 of 375 reviews