A moving and powerful debut novel celebrating and embracing the richness of life, even in the face of death.
Not long after giving birth to her eighth child, Renie—a thirty-nine-year-old wife and mother—is diagnosed with Stage 4 breast cancer with only three months to live. In confronting her own mortality, Renie creates a journal to leave for her children.
While writing and reflecting, Renie realizes that she has spent her life in duty of others—her parents, her family, her husband, and children. With this sudden and momentous revelation, her fear and subsequent preparation for death becomes replaced with an intense desire to live her last days on her terms.
With writing that’s both wise and wistful, Every Goodbye Ain’t Gone is a triumphant celebration of the human spirit from a powerful and imaginative rising literary voice.
Thank you NetGalley, Simon & Schuster, and the author Dana Renee Green for gifting me with this ARC to review.
I was going back and forth between rating this book a 3.75 or a 4.0. In the end I truly enjoyed the book but it fell more in the “average” range for me.
Liked:
-spiritual. While I’m not religious or spiritual myself I do sometimes enjoy reading about a characters religious journey and how their faith can sometimes be shaken (or strengthened) by things like what Renie went through. Her struggle with figuring out which faith (her dad’s more traditional viewing of the bible and Jesus or her mom’s more spiritual cultural one) resonated more with her was interesting.
-people are flawed and families will always be messy. Something I really liked about this book is that all the characters have their flaws. Renie isn’t always the best mother in terms of meeting each of her child’s needs or sometimes flavoring one child over another. Walter has a drinking problem and has childhood trauma that he projects onto Renie and his kids. Renie’s dad disowns Renie when she doesn’t follow his dream of going to college and planting herself in a white neighborhood. I could go on out all the other characters but I’ll stop at these ones lol. Our flaws are what make us humans and it’s beautiful to be able to acknowledge them and still love those people deeply.
Disliked:
-story dragged at certain points. It was mostly when Renie was going through her past. I figured we’d dive into her past a bit but I wanted more of her “living her life on her terms” in the present if that makes sense.
ARC REVIEW ~ The first thing I thought once I completed this novel was simply WOW!! I was so blown away that I had to read the Acknowledgements just to learn as much as I could about the person who birthed such an emotionally gripping story.
This novel tore me to pieces in a beautifully touching way. I don’t feel like I just read a book. I feel like I went on an emotional and spiritual journey through love, family, faith and grief.
In this novel we follow Catherine “Renie”Rogers who after giving birth to her seventh child is diagnosed with stage 4 breast cancer and is given three months to live. Renie takes us on her journey as she faces the unimaginable reality of telling her family (her husband Walter, her seven children, her parents, and her siblings) that she is dying. We go through the stages of grief with Renie as she makes some of the most emotionally challenging and important decisions of her life.
But her physical journey is only one part of this story. We also witness Renie’s spiritual journey as she wrestles with her belief in God and how her religion collides with her spiritual roots and ancestral connections that have been passed down through her family.
What stood out to me was how beautifully this book is written. It’s wonderfully poetic without being overly written. It flows so naturally, and the way the author described everything made me feel as if I was right there in every moment. For example, there was a scene in Chapter sixteen where the protagonist Renie writes in her journal about a big family picnic she attended as a child. The descriptions were so vivid that I felt like I was there. It reminded me so much of the family reunions I attended as child. It’s these captivating descriptions that are laced throughout the book, that made each moment feel authentic and real.
Green also does a beautiful job of capturing all of the complicated emotions that come with facing the end of life and the grief of a losing a loved one.
I was emotionally invested in the characters. The love story between Renie and her husband Walter melted my heart. Somewhere along the way, I stopped feeling like I was simply reading their story and started feeling like I was living through it with them. I felt their heartbreak. I cheered for the love. I understood their questions. And I relished in the beautiful moments that existed in the middle of so much pain.
This book grabbed my heart and it did not let go. The story was soul stirring, thought provoking, tender, and full of so much emotional depth. I don’t know what I expected when I started reading it, but I definitely wasn’t expecting to feel this much. I don’t know when was the last time I felt this way about a novel. It wasn’t simply a good story. It was an emotional experience. These are the kind of characters who leave an imprint on your heart. It is also the kind of book that reminds me exactly why I fell in love with reading in the first place.
📖
Thank you so much Yahdon Israel, Netgalley and Simon and Schuster for gifting me both a print and digital galley for review. This journey was amazing!
Heartbreaking, Tender, and One of the Most Beautiful Books I’ve Read This Year
📚 On Casey’s Bookshelf
Book: 94 Dates read: 05.10.2026 – 05.12.2026 Title: Every Goodbye Ain’t Gone Author: Dana Renee Green Format: digital ARC
#caseysbookshelf
This book was painfully, heartbreakingly beautiful.
I stumbled across it while browsing Edelweiss looking for review copies. Beautiful cover. Black author. Immediate download. I didn’t even realize while reading that it doesn’t release until November because once I started, I could not put it down.
At its core, this is a story about mortality, motherhood, sacrifice, and the secrets we carry to protect both ourselves and the people we love. But more than anything, this felt like a woman writing her own eulogy while she still had time to live it.
Renie is a 39-year-old mother of seven who is diagnosed with Stage 4 breast cancer shortly after giving birth. Given only months to live, she begins writing journals for her children. What unfolds is not just grief, but reflection. A woman finally looking honestly at the life she built, the dreams she buried, and the pieces of herself she sacrificed in service of everyone else.
What hit me hardest was how many truths this story quietly exposes. The way oldest daughters are often forced into caregiving roles and denied the softness of childhood in ways older sons rarely experience. The way medical racism continues to endanger Black women even now. The way love sometimes costs you family, comfort, and belonging. And the reminder that the people who truly love you would rather carry your burdens with you than watch you suffer alone.
This story felt intimate and intentional. I found myself slowing down while reading because I wanted to sit with it. Savor it. Witness every moment Renie fought to hold onto with the people she loved most.
This is absolutely a statement debut and one that makes me excited to see what this author does next.
⚠️ Please check trigger warnings before reading.
This title releases November 17, 2026.
Thank you Simon & Schuster via Edelweiss for the #giftedcopy in exchange for an honest review.
Another book off the shelf. We keep reading with intention. 📚
A story full of big emotions, real-life themes, and a reimagining of what a “happy ending” can be, Every Goodbye Ain’t Gone is a touching novel that just might shift your perception of what truly matters in life. Green writes with such vivid prose that I often found myself relating her writing to that of Toni Morrison. Again and again, the scenes rose up around me—drumbeats pulsing in my blood, danger tightening my spine, grief settling heavy in the room, belly full with a good meal. I held space for so many who had been wronged, and I honestly can’t remember the last time a book made me cry this much; both sorrowful and joyful tears. And this is a debut.
Rest assured, this is not a novel simply about grief. All facets of the human experience are exposed. There are moments where I laughed out loud HARD and others where I found myself shaking my head with vigor, seconding the "real talk" a character laid down.
The characters were written with depth and heart. The situations carefully reported by someone who KNOWS. I repeatedly felt for the characters who, in all honesty, let me feel for me and mine as well.
I did find sections of Part Two to be a bit slow, but I also cannot find one misuse of space on these pages. And as a true empath I had to take long pauses throughout the book due to some heavy topics. But in the end, I felt that rare and beautiful balance of heartbreak and peace. I walked away with a renewed desire to let Love lead and let shame fall away. Green draws from her own family’s ancestry in powerful ways, and in doing so brings us closer to all of ours.
I highly recommend reading this book slowly—with a box of tissues nearby and maybe a journal of your own.
This is a beautiful story full of many themes such as grief, terminal illness, spirituality and religion, motherhood, and family. This story takes place from the 30s-50 so underlying themes of racial hatred and discrimination and the trauma scars it leaves behind. But the underlying constant them is love. The writing is this book in such a way that it is felt and you become a part of the story. It is truly a journey, much like being diagnosed with cancer. We follow Renie our FMC on a journey as she pulls herself through this journey of spiritual reflection, facing impending death, all while hiding her diagnosis from her family. This book answers the questions what we leave behind and what will be remembered when you pass on. I am not a deeply religious person as I have been a member of most religions and like Renie for me it is more spiritual rather than found in a church. The way the love was expressed in this book was some of the most significant parts of the journey and reading about confronting a haunted past when looking towards a future that is non existent was the hardest. This is a book that will stay with you and so many thing to discuss. Have you ever felt guided by your ancestors? What parts of you do you want your family to hold onto after your last goodbye?
Gratitude to the Advanced Reader's Club at Simon and Schuster (and Sr. Editor Yahdon Israel!) for this ARC.
I loved tracing how this character grew throughout the book, continuing to redefine for herself what it means to live, to mother, and to learn and blossom to the very end. The middle section is where I connected most deeply with the character; the structure and confessional style gave deeper insight and I couldn't put the book down after this shift. After finishing it, I am still thinking about Dana Renee Green's choice to craft such a compelling character by exploring her interiority. Often, I find that middle-aged mothers are often only written as central or interesting when they make loud, provocative choices. Dana Renee Green gives depth and richness to a character who may feel familiar to many of us in the form of our mothers, grandmothers, aunties, ourselves. We are left with the reminder of all the depth and meaning of the human experience, no matter how "big" or "small" it looks from the outside. I'm so grateful this exists and look forward to reading more from this author!
⭐️⭐️⭐️My review: This is a heartbreaking book about how to live at the very end of life. Reine is 39, the mother of 7, poor, and dying of breast cancer. It is 1950's in the South and doctors don't care much for African American patients. Reine is given months to live. But she wants to make the most of it, especially before she tells her husband, children, and parents. Reine's story moves between the history of her life and relationships with family, and her present circumstances. How do you say good bye to your children, knowing some will barely remember you? How do you tell the man you've loved your whole life that you are dying? Reine's strength is out of this world. It was ridiculously sad and I worried for her family. She was the actual glue. Well written and very descriptive. Just too upsetting for me.
Thank you to Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for an advance digital copy to review. These opinions are my own.
Renie is only 39-years-old when she is diagnosed with Stage 4 breast cancer and told she only has three months left. She has eight children and the story centers around a jornal she is writing to leave behind for her children, and the way confronting death makes her reconsider how she has lived her life.
This debut is very emotional and thought-provoking. You will find yourself wondering if you are living your own life to please others or if it is on your own terms. This story isn’t only about death, it’s also about taking a look back and hopefully having no regrets.
As a debut novel, this is written beautifully, with many emotional moments. I found it bittersweet, yet hopeful. This is an impressive novel that I can easily recommend.
Thank you, NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for the eARC.
I was in tears the whole time reading this. I could relate to this character since I'm currently the same age as she is and I'm scared for my life I don't want my children outliving me at all. I could imagine what her children were going through. My dad was dying at the time while he was teaching me how to cook since I had my own children but the mere fact that he didn't disclose how long he had left with us. I wish I could hear him one last time and his smile. I'm ever so cautious now about how to speak up when I go to the doctor because medical racism is here and I don't want to become another statistic.
It took me a while to read this book. I kept having to take breaks because it is heartbreaking. You know that going in, from the very beginning in the author’s note, you know this will be a hard journey. But it is worth it because mostly this is a book about joy and love and living. Renie is forty years old when she learns she has only months to live. She is a loving wife and mother to seven children, the youngest only a baby. She is an ordinary Black woman living in the 1950’s South. Her life has had joy and sorrow and hardship, but what does it all mean at the end. That’s what this novel explores so well. I was fortunate to receive an advanced copy of this book from the Editor.
A beautifully written and moving book!! This book creates a world and characters that I fell in love with. There is such a depth to the protagonist that is refreshing in fiction writing. The book is also grounded in history, Southern context, and the horrors and reality of racialized violence. In this regard, the past becomes very much alive through the characters. I highly recommend this book to any reader who loves outstanding writing and storytelling and for anyone who needs to feel. This book is an excellent teacher of empathy.
🥺 @yahdon @advancedreadersclub @danareneegreen WOW! such a powerful book. I am honored to have read this advanced readers copy! Please read this book when it comes out on 11/17/26 and then come back so we can discuss it! “You want a woman who know who you are, not who you want the world to think you are, but who you really are inside. You want a woman that’s soft enough to let you cry, but strong enough to hold you up when the world has beaten you to a bloody pulp and you don’t think you have not one thing left to give.” @biglos401 I hope I am this woman to you! 🫶🏽
I’m not a soldier, and I didn’t enlist. I’m a mama. My babies need me. 🌹
Renie is a mother of seven who is dying of cancer and she doesn’t have much time left. She writes in her journals. She loves her babies to the end, and there is a woman's desire for fulfillment and endless love. Every goodbye ain’t gone is a beautiful novel about motherhood, self-preservation, and the infinite woman’s identity, needs, and bosom resilience. Call upon the ancestors that Dana Rene Green has created the key to a mama's heart. ❤️
I received a free copy of, Every Goodbye Ain't Gone, by Dana Renee Green, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This was a sad read but a good read. Knowing death is coming for you too soon, when you still have children to raise. Cancer does not discriminate it affects us all.
Thank you to NetGalley & Simon & Schuster for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC. Renie at thirty-nine, is diagnosed with Stage 4 breast cancer and given three months to live. She is the mother of 7 and she decided to start a journal for her children. This is a very heart breaking story, have tissues nearby.
Every Goodbye Ain’t Gone by Dana Renee Green is a masterpiece of a debut novel and an absolute must-read. This book is heavy—it deals with trauma, coming to terms with illness, and grief—but it handles each of those themes with such honesty, tenderness, and beauty that it feels incredibly real.
It truly was an honor to read this book. One of my absolute favorites of the year.
ARC- wow. I love emotional books and this delivered. It’s written so well that you fall in love with the characters. Even though I was hoping for a different ending, I thought the last chapter was written so beautifully.
A sweeping story that captures the essence of family and what it means to be you, choose you, in the midst of it. Beautifully written, captivating, warm, and bold! A MUST READ!!
Really unique writing structure and profound character development. I continue to think about Renie weeks after reading the book. Explores death and live in poignant and evocative ways.
DRC from Edelweiss and Simon & Schuster Heartwarming story about a black woman in South Carolina in the 1940s and 50s. Married, with her seventh child on the way, 39 year old Renie is diagnosed with stage four breast cancer and is given three months to live. She spends that time writing in her journals, telling her children all the things she knows she won’t have time to tell them. She tells them how she met Walter, her husband. How her father was disappointed that she got married instead of going to college. How unfair life is when you’re black in the south. And most importantly, how she wouldn’t have traded anything for what she had with them.
Every Goodbye Ain’t Gone by Dana R. Green is one of those novels that asks something of you. I cried through much of it, yet by the final page I didn’t feel emotionally wrung out. I felt held.
Renie’s story follows her from childhood through marriage, motherhood, and her final months living with breast cancer. The plot line that struck me wasn’t just her illness, but the human ache of unfinished relationships, especially the distance between her and her father, and the courage it takes to prepare the people you love for a goodbye you don’t want to say.
This isn’t simply a novel about dying. It’s a novel about living with intention, loving people while you still can, and finding dignity, grace, and even beauty at the edge of loss. Dana R. Green reminds us that death is never the whole story. Life always is.
OMG ! I have not read a book like this that I re-read again immediately after finishing reading it. The author writes the story so eloquently and humanizes the character Rene. Rene seems like she carries shame for disappointing her father in that she was not able god envelop a relationship with him till she was diagnosed with the disease. The other also touches on grief , regret , spirituality. I connected most with the character in the middle section where the character was revealing certain things of her life. The church guy part had my heart jumping like “omg he is not going to take advantage of her”.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.