EDIT 23/06/2025: Expanded on item 6, added item 7+.
I was pretty disappointed in this one, after generally enjoying the first two books. I had specific gripes, so spoilers ahead:
1. In my review of the first two books, I said I wanted more world building. This really didn't give me much. I forgot about the blood moon until the end. It's this big bad thing that I really don't know that much about? Honestly, my brain just went to "The Purge" - like it was something you could hunker down for 12 hours to get through it. Clearly I was filling in some wide blanks.
2. So could they talk through the bond at all? Or is the bond just for feelings? I'm confused. Maybe (again) I'm filling in some of the lore on my own... but if they could have communicated at all with the bond, I would have expected some planning conversations? plotting? scheming? strategy? banter or romantic convos?
3. The "last 100 pages" trope (?) was this book. 60%-70% of this book could have been an email. I wanted more action. I wanted more politics. instead we got torture-fest and telepathic warm fuzzies.
4. Characters. There was a lack of character development across the board. It felt like quantity over quality. Bringing back everyone and their mother (literally) for short redemption arcs or emotional damage points. Like the last books, I'm most interested in the Crone, but even that took a strange path.
5. Did not see some of the 'twists' coming because they felt out of left field, or like a whole other field tbh.
6. the romance was non existent other than large declarations of love. the broken bond read more like someones phone line getting disconnected or something. edit: also note this has the "New Moon (Twilight)" situation where the MMC and FMC are apart for almost the entire book, and they're just suffering in each other's absence. No Jacob/secondary MMC as a distraction either.
7. Redemption arc for Finn (if we could call it that) was not an arc. The shape of the arc could be described as a marshmallow lucky charm rainbow. I would have liked more conversations/interactions with Vera to expand/deepen the POV/motivations of Finn.
8. I was confused about the Kylah / House of Anu goings on. This might be a 'me' problem though. I'll re-read the series and update.
9. I think this book could have benefitted SO much from Multi-POV.
After more thought, it's starting to feel like Quicksilver x Book of Azrael type vibes. But I do think those were more fleshed out (so far).
I bought the paperback AND the ebook to support. And I will continue to buy/read this series going forward, because I have hope. However, this installment just didn't work for me :(
Edit to add: I re-read the first two books leading up to this one, and was still a little confused. so I'm concerned I'm going to have to re-read all three before the 4th book comes out. Not out of anticipation or refreshing, but out of absolute necessity to give the 4th book the best chance. Until next year! <3