In The Mighty Continent, the renowned Pulitzer Prize–winning historian Walter A. McDougall recounts the truly dramatic tale of modern Europe’s ascent. McDougall serves this history straight up, free of shame, apology, and the cloying moralism so characteristic of today’s supposed scholarship. The result is a work that is not only expertly presented but thrilling.
McDougall’s sweeping narrative takes in the domestic political, economic, social, intellectual, and cultural developments in the major European nations from the fifteenth to the twenty-first century. Along the way, he provides new insights on and interpretations of the Renaissance, the Protestant and Catholic Reformations, the Age of Exploration, the Scientific, French, and Industrial Revolutions, the sources of modernism, the origins of World War I, the rise of totalitarianism, the advance of the European Union, the collapse of communism, and much else.
Comprehensive yet compact, objective yet unabashed, The Mighty Continent is history as it used to exciting, uplifting, ironic, not infrequently tragic—and above all, fair to the figures who made modern Europe so world-shakingly powerful and inescapably influential.
Professor McDougall is among my favorite authors. That said, I find his books “hit or miss”. His first two—both out of print, though the first won the Pulitzer—tackled familiar subjects from an orthogonal perspective: “The Heavens And the Earth” is a political (mostly US) history of the space age (through the mid 1980s). I kept it in my office and raided it for citations for 40 years.
McDougall’s second, “Let the Sea Make A Noise” is a political history of the North Pacific Ocean. It’s slightly marred by interstitial fictitious dialogues between the author and some of the strongest figures in this Wiggish History. This gimmick made me so mad the first time I read it, I skipped those pages. On second read, they are far more informative than what Morris disastrously did in his Reagan bio. I recommend it to anyone who wants an unusual take on what they might have thought familiar, and well-written besides.
Most of his other books left me cold, though I cannot now remember why. I note that McDougall got his History Ph.D. From Chicago, started teaching at Berkeley, then fled (for sanity’s sake) to Penn, where he ultimately chaired the History Department.
Prof McDougall always has been a clear writer, and often an exciting one. The flaw in this book may be that the beginning is pitched too low for those who have a basic grasp of early history—Greece, Roman, Hebrew. But that flaw is a strength to other readers.
Never mind: by the quarter-pole, McDougall has moved past my understanding and begins to flesh-out connections new to me. I amply notated my reading, which should provide you an idea of where I got interested. In addition, it’s a good showing of the Prof’s style: “Now, this didn’t work for four reasons. First…”. That sort of organization both draws me in and makes it easier to remember.
Despite being first below my level, then new to me, this is a book for everyone. Those new to the ancient civilizations can skim three chapters. Those knowledgeable about the Great War still will want to read McDougall labeling it as the end of European civilization, and the greatest tragedy ever to trip mankind.
If I’ve done this correctly, you should see over 120 highlighted passages. Interestingly, McDougall has a summary chapter—one that asks the same question so earnestly debated in the 1990s—the End of History or the same, with New Players. The latter won that argument then and remains ahead on points. Although McDougall doesn’t actually say this, his point is that unless we teach our children well of the advantages of Western Civ, they’ll blow it up or let it topple, unaware of what they’ve taken for granted.
Western Civ survey. Well presented. Informative. Identifies universality of European culture because of the “precious gifts” of “science and the technology derived from it,” “the rule of law,” and “the Judeo-Christian religion, which instructs human beings on how to use their power and liberty.” pp. 421-422. Throughout the book, the author indicates his belief that the third gift is the most important which leads to some uncomfortable conclusions by him regarding certain historical events. Seven hundred page book about centuries of history without a single map.