Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Undaunted: How the Sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn Saved Russian Jewry, Reimagined American Judaism, Ignited a Global Jewish Renaissance

Rate this book
David Eliezrie’s Undaunted chronicles the extraordinary courage of the Sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn, as he confronted the brutal oppression of both czarist Russia and the Soviet regime. While many religious leaders fled as the Communists shuttered synagogues and schools, Rabbi Schneersohn remained, risking his life to preserve Jewish life and earning the reputation of “the last man standing.” Despite enduring torture, arrest, and a death sentence, his unwavering defiance and international advocacy ultimately secured his release.

Drawing on historical documents and rare archives, Eliezrie details how Rabbi Schneersohn introduced Chabad teachings in Western Europe, empowered women, and established yeshivas to nurture future Jewish leaders. The book recounts his daring escape from war-torn Poland – a feat made possible through a rare collaboration between the US government and Nazi Germany – and his dramatic arrival in the United States. There, he boldly declared “America is not different,” directly challenging the widespread belief that Judaism must conform to American culture.

Even after his exile from the Soviet Union, Rabbi Schneersohn continued to lead Jewish resistance there and worked tirelessly to save Jews. He reenvisioned American Jewry by founding the first nationwide network of Jewish day schools, and in the postwar years, laid the groundwork for a global Jewish renaissance, inspiring generations of Chabad leaders to sustain and expand Jewish life in the face of adversity.

Undaunted also explores the deep relationship between the Sixth Rebbe and his successor, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson.

In an era of unparalleled turmoil and challenge, the Rebbe emerges as one of the most consequential leaders of modern Jewry.

544 pages, Hardcover

Published November 4, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

David Eliezrie

5 books6 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
12 (70%)
4 stars
3 (17%)
3 stars
2 (11%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
Profile Image for kobushi.
239 reviews8 followers
September 28, 2026
“Keep your heroes in trouble.” - David McCullough

And keep the above quote in mind and it will be explained shortly as this good book covering Chabad history of the late 19th through the first half of the 20th century possesses an Achilles heel that becomes all the more apparent as the tale unfolds. But let me repeat: this is still a good book.

Undaunted for someone not familiar with Chabad may in some ways be something of an odd duck. It’s obviously written by someone of the movement and if not necessarily for those also within it, surely for those whom like myself are at least familiar with it. And about myself—one interjection on this front, I’m sorry—as I definitely lean significantly harder on the secular side of Judaism (Solomon Maimon I view as a role model after all (https://kobushi.substack.com/p/the-au...), but do see the benefit of some amount of reading pushing faith harder than reason, I went into this book wondering not whether it would be a sober yet enlightening look at the Sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe as obviously as it was published by an Orthodox Jewish publisher, that would not happen. However, Toby Press via Koren Publishers seems to do an excellent job of balancing faith with academia unlike Artscroll, their biggest rival in the Anglosphere of Jewish publishers that for similar works is nothing more than hagiography.

But that word: hagiography. It was on my mind and served as a lodestar. After all, a few years ago I read Joseph Telushkin’s excellent biography on Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn’s son-in-law the last (for now…?) Lubavitcher Rebbe and while it did not feel outright hagiographic, it sure got close. Faith and inspiration are important, but if it’s too disconnected to reality, for a reader like myself at least, will it work? Will it still inspire? Does it have merit? These were heavily on my mind when I read David Eliezrie’s biography. After all, for an almost first-time author writing such a large tome about the former leader of his own orthodox religious denomination, would he be able not to push too hard into what I call “cloyingly spiritual mush”? I gave the benefit of the doubt and by the end, I feel he…

The issues rise with that word: “undaunted”. This may not go down well with those who are deeply committed to the Chabad movement, but author David Eliezrie paints Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn as a Gary Stu character; yes, his life is tough—something few will deny—but he can do no wrong. He’s great, he’s perfect, he is anything positive you can conjure up. Yes, he finds himself in trouble, but Eliezrie violates popular historian David McCullough’s key rule when penning a biography: “keep your heroes in trouble.” Schneersohn himself never really is in trouble even when in troubling situations. Thus, it becomes hard to connect to this individual. Furthermore, within the book proper there is lack of source text quoting so we’re left with hundreds of pages of being told about his history and not really taking part in it. This is compounded by the fact that Schneersohn like all of us is human and humans—all of us—have flaws. Nobody has done no wrong and this along with the McCullough rule violation become all the more apparent the more one reads.

That Elezrie is a Lubavitcher puts him in a bind: can someone of the movement write anything even remotely critical? Even addressing the issue of his son-in-law not designating a successor leading to big M issues is something Joseph Telushukin—Orthodox but not Chabad—only lightly addressed in his biography of the seventh Rebbe. It’s thus difficult to write a well balanced book about a religious figure if one adheres strongly to his brand of the faith, a brand where dissent within halakha is allowed and in fact encouraged, but outside of it can be met with extreme ostracization. If one could have a ‘do-over’, re-writing Undaunted or at least consider writing a follow-up that switches from ‘general biography’ to an ‘intellectual biography’ may be a better choice for such a figure. This was done in outstanding Maimonides: Life and Thought by Moshe Halbertal where the ‘life’ aspect—what almost the entirety of what Undaunted covers is relegated to the first chapter covering a little under 100 pages. In this fashion, one can avoid issues of heroes and their troubles and focus more on what for a spiritual leader may be even more important: their thoughts and how those thoughts influenced their world.

The idea of ‘thoughts’ becomes ever more important and more obvious as the book runs its course. And just like Maimonides, Schneersohn is presented as someone who truly believes that if he does not make drastic decisions then and there, the fate of world Jewry could very much collapse. This is what is more or less presented, but while accurate from his point of view, I feel disregards the multivalent efforts happening all throughout world Jewry during the increasingly dark days of the first half of the 20th century. If one has limited knowledge of this period, it would seem like the only thing battling the demons of destruction was Chabad with secular Jewish authorities at best giving some help, but usually seen as prongs and daggers holding Chassidism back. From my secular Jewish perspective, the book is both in a strange way robust, all-encompassing, but also light on the what exactly Schneersohn wants to save and how exactly it gets done.

What’s more—and again, everything I write here is from the book—if financial issues arose (and they do very often, for we find out eventually the Rebbe was literally taking out loans for loans), it was to reach out to well-off less (or totally non-) observant Jews for help. If legal troubles came into being, the same. The goal of those like Schneersohn is both noble and worrying: the insatiable desire to dive as deep as possible into religious texts but almost at a cost of everything else. One can view this as an inspirational story in some light and it does work that way, but taking a step back and seeing the demographic crisis unfold in Israel (OK, this part is not from the book) due to an increasingly large percentage of the population cloistering themselves from the larger part yet demanding continued financial support for what amounts to Torah study for the sake of Torah study, the system starts to buckle. But still, these are for the most part future issues and not of concern in the early 20th century. But—yes again, but--given we’re provided with not one but several ‘prophetic’ happenings in this book via tales told on death beds about darkness in the coming dozens of years, it remains questionable why the lens could not be turned inward.

Unlike other reviews for this book I have seen here and there that feel like the readers really only saw the text at face value (if at all), I feel the need to take my gloves off. I did enjoy it immensely as I’m very fond of Jewish history and Judaism books in general, but the undercurrent of disparaging secular studies and even secular Jews outside of being donors and helpers for the metaphorical changing of lightbulbs (ie, lawyers representing them when it’s needed and formerly observant members reaching out to high level civil servants) felt like potshots against foot soldiers out there on the front-lines keeping things secure for a community that does not seem to view them much beyond a necessary evil. There’s also the issue of treating hearsay as fact. As a fan and a very distant armchair scholar of Justice Louis Brandeis, seeing him suddenly appear in the story, suddenly being told the Rebbe is in a bind, and him suddenly describing him as “the prince of Israel” felt...ah, pretty off. Here’s where I had to put the book down for a moment (this time literally) and find the source and sadly all I got was one article (https://crownheights.info/something-j...) that can’t decide if the story even if treated as fact was from the 1920’s or the very late 30’s. That nothing beyond sources of this nature can back this claim and given Brandeis’s precarious position of being a Jewish Supreme Court Justice, the chances of him even implying allegiance to a religious authority in such a way is unthinkable. Biographies both of current and especially more distant figures in history may allow the authors to make some amount of conjecture, but it should be used sparingly and clearly noted within the text itself.

Gloves remain off during the dark days of WW2 where the Rebbe distraught at American Jewish leadership not pushing too hard for Jews in Europe for “...a lack of Jewish pride and courage.” On one hand, his opinions are sound, but just as he was locked on saving those he knew needed help, one can’t ignore the fact that those outside of his circle wanted to ensure the safety of their kind as well. It’s hard not to play a blame game here, as it often ends up happening. America’s history with Jews up until this time was bumpy and the push to fit in for many was as paramount as saving Torah scholars in wartorn countries for others. The end result was the same: both had sincere beliefs that what they were doing was the best for the future of American Jewry in a time when isolationism was still the norm and wanting those closest to them first and foremost to remain safe. It’s passages like this that while accurate I fear lead to a continuation of the “Orthodox = good, Liberal = bad” bias that permeates Judaism to our very day.

We also see a seemingly blurring of court cases during the section on ‘released-time’ in the later 1940’s. Liberal Jewish groups were against it for reasons similar to that of today: arguing that the Framers wanted a strong separation of church and state and these programs due to the government paying for bussing from schools to religious institutions were blurring the line. Eliezrie notes SCOTUS upheld the law which is true in 1947’s Everson v. Board of Education, but untrue a year later in McCollum v Illinois. This normally would not be a big issue, but it again plays into the above ‘O=good, L=bad’ bias. Schneersohn’s reasons for creating a Chabad-organized weekly released-time for non-Orthodox Jewish students, the subject of a later chapter in the book, I find very commendable, but also somewhat ironic because the same arguments the book presents against it by Liberal Judaism are just as true today: their congregants will go there, not have to pay as much (or at all), think it’s enough, and their synagogues would then lose members and eventually fail.

This as it should be obvious is a book I feel very conflicted about. It makes a great cause for “why Hasidism matters” and stays true to that from start to end; to that, I give the author much credit. As an ‘alternative’ source of the fight Jews were engaging in during a most dark of eras, seeing how those from an Orthodox and quite unsecular background attempted to navigate the complex systems of world politics and its economy was for a lack of a better word: neat. However, biases exist and it’s beyond obvious that the author took Isaiah 6:9’s last stanza to heart: “indeed you must see but you will not know.” (Robert Alter translation) by giving little due or mention to secular Jewry’s activities even though they obviously intersected. If anything, the untold thrust of the book can simply be that Orthodox Judaism needs Liberal Judaism as much as Liberal Judaism needs Orthodox Judaism yet no side wants to clearly say this out loud. Furthermore, this pushes hard into giving a hagiographic account of Schneersohn our hero who was in dangerous situations aplenty, but never really felt in trouble himself nor did the light ever shine on more ‘human’ elements of his life. Nobody is perfect although here one is essentially presented as that way always doing his best, never once being in the wrong, never once having an argument, never once delving into matters less “why my people and religion are important” but like Hillel once wrote: “If I’m not for myself…?”
3 reviews
July 22, 2026
My rabbi, Rabbi Bernath spoke about this book so I decided to take his advice and purchase it. I knew a little about the Sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe before reading it, but I had no idea how much he actually went through or how much of Jewish life today can be traced back to his courage.

Undaunted reads like history, but at times it almost feels like a thriller. The stories of Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn standing up to the Soviet government, secretly keeping Jewish schools, mikvahs and religious life alive, and refusing to be intimidated were incredible.

What stayed with me most was that he was not fearless. He simply believed that the mission was more important than the fear. Even after leaving Russia and coming to America, he continued pushing forward when many people thought traditional Judaism could not survive there.

It is a long book and there is a lot of history, but it gave me a much deeper appreciation for the people who risked everything so that future generations could live openly as Jews.

A fascinating and inspiring read about courage, leadership and refusing to give up when the odds are completely against you.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews