My copy of this novella must be the Canadian version. There is no subtitle mentioning a Montana Holiday, or any holiday at all for the impoverished family depicted, so I assume the American version must have other differences as well. Perhaps I did not read the same book others are reviewing here. It was not a book I would have chosen, but it purported to be set in the Nova Scotian town of Truro, an hour from where I live (much of the story takes place at the well-known exhibition grounds and race track) and I read it because I am interested in supporting local books. Suzy, the six-year-old who wants a pony for Christmas, is not on holiday at all, but living at home. In Truro. Instead of being subtitled, "A Montana Holiday Novella," I am informed beneath the title of my copy it has been written by an "Award Winning Author." It might have said "Adapted for Canadian Readers."
I did enjoy the book, but wonder now if I favoured it because of its Nova Scotian slant. But I did like it being neither a children's story nor written for adults, a book for anyone. A quick read, it was a pleasant way to pass a December afternoon, with a not-exactly-surprise ending, but a reasonably satisfying one. Besides the nicer lead characters, it had its unkind ones, bully-boys and the mother of Suzy's best friend who wouldn't let Suzy into the winner's circle after the race because "she's not a club member." While it was supposedly set in Truro, I recognized it could be situated anywhere, even in Montana, say. I liked it enough I could picture it playing on the Hallmark Christmas channel, the muted, background love story given its due.