re-read december 2025
spoilers below, don't read if you don't want to know what happens
Centuries ago, a great war took place between the Gods and Monsters, destroying the Gods' home, Rashearim and locking away all the Gods in different realms. The planet exploded, crashed into Onuna(the 'mortal' world), and somehow didn't wipe out all life in the process. Instead, a bunch of celestials essentially colonized the 'mortal' world and caused a plague to spread across Onuna, eventually killing a large portion of the 'mortal' population. Now, Celestials are in control, and our FMC, Dianna, despises them—mainly because the plague they caused killed her parents and nearly killed her and her sister, Gabby. On the verge of death, Dianna encounters Kaden, the villain of this story and self-proclaimed King of the Otherworld, who makes a bargain with her: he will save her and her sister's lives, but they must be transformed into creatures called Ig'Morruthens (though Gabby, for some reason, doesn't change in the same way as Dianna), and Dianna must work for him. Ig'Morruthens are the monsters that were part of the big war that destroyed Rashearim and are also apparently the ancestors of vampires. Dianna agrees and essentially becomes a vampire who can shapeshift, wield fire, see memories after drinking blood, teleport, compel people, am I forgetting something? Oh, also, she can't die, literally, they’ve tried decapitating her, and her head either reattaches or grows back like Jeebs in Men in Black. She becomes Kaden's second-in-command and his lover, killing anyone he tells her to kill, all for the sake of protecting her sister. I will forever remember Kaden's lava pit because all I could think of while reading it was Dr Evil dropping people into his pit of lava underneath his table.
Kaden is searching for an artifact called The Book of Azrael, which apparently contains information on how to reopen the closed realms where all the Gods are, a blueprint for a God-killing weapon, and how to destroy the world or something. During their search for this book, they encounter a group of celestial soldiers called The Hand, who our MMC, Samkiel, or as he's known in this book, Liam, handpicked centuries ago to be his personal guard. Dianna and Kaden get into a fight with one of these soldiers, and rather than be taken captive, the soldier takes his own life, which summons Liam to Onuna.
Now, Liam has been moping on the remains of Rashearim since its destruction because he was the cause of it. So rather than do anything to fix what he did, he just decides to pout alone for a thousand years until one of his friends commits suicide, and he just assumes someone murdered him and decides to come back to get justice for him? Okay. Sure. This leads him to Dianna; they fight, have a lot of banter that made me cringe; eventually, Dianna is taken captive, tortured for information; until she randomly has a change of heart and decides to kill someone from Kaden's side and asks Liam to protect her sister instead. He agrees, as long as Dianna helps him find the Book of Azrael (which he continues to insist does not exist), and, after all is said and done, she'll be tried for her numerous crimes. (Killing and eating random people at Kaden's beck, and also probably just for fun for the last however many centuries, you know.)
So, Dianna and Liam can both teleport, but for some reason, they go out of their way to get illegal passports? Only to be betrayed immediately by the person who made them the passports. So those were useless, so instead they drive around, go to a fair, eat some cotton candy and flirt (?), find some guy there, then sneak onto an illegal carrier plane, only to get off the plane and teleport anyway. And it took 350 pages to tell us that the reason they didn't just teleport in the first place was that Kaden can track Dianna's power usage? So, why didn't Liam teleport them? Why are they taking convoys everywhere? They go to Drake's(brother of vampire king, Ethan, who Dianna 'killed' earlier) house, send an invitation to Dianna's ex lover, Camilla and wait a fucking MONTH for her to accept it while Kaden is out there building a damn army and actively searching for the Book, meanwhile Liam and Dianna are catching feelings for each other constantly moping about whether or not they're friends, or if one actually likes the other one even though when all of this is over Liam is literally going to put Dianna in PRISON. They finally go to Camilla's place so that Liam can make out with her in front of Dianna. She can magically tell him that Azrael's daughter is alive and has the book when they literally could've just gone there a month ago and gotten that information, because now guess what, they've been betrayed AGAIN because the witch king, Santiago, showed up and said a lot of disgusting lewd things to Dianna. They get away, she almost dies, Liam saves her and Dianna realizes they have feelings for each other because Dianna was jealous watching him makeout with her ex-gf, they finger bang and blow each other in some poor old couple's house before going to see Azrael's daughter, finding the book, and then oh wait, they're betrayed AGAIN, it was Tobias, one of the four king's of yejedin, all along, now he has the book, and guess what else, DRAKE BETRAYED DIANNA TOO. NOW GABBY IS DEAD, so now Dianna will have a "villain" arc. The end.
Now, all of this had a lot of potential. I thought the plot was interesting, but the execution was horribly done. I don't believe a developmental editor touched this whatsoever. We have plot beats that are reused immediately after each other. Samkiel has a nightmare and gets all in his head about things, and gives Dianna the silent treatment, which in turn makes her panic until she's able to bring him around to talk to her. In the next chapter, Dianna gets some bad news about Kaden and gives Liam the silent treatment, which makes him panic, etc. Towards the end of the book, Liam learns some information that makes him spiral, and Dianna says
A harsh, self-deprecating laugh escaped him, and I knew I was losing him.”
the next chapter, Dianna learns some information that makes her spiral, and Liam says,
“She was filled with fear, and something darker I could feel lurking, waiting for its chance. I was losing her.”
This, to me, screams, I couldn't think of anything else to write, so I just did what I did in the last chapter, but reversed. There's a lot of redundancy as well, as in repeating what we just said, but in a different way, three sentences later. A lot of saying 'his' and 'her' without actually naming a character beforehand, so we have no idea who's being referred to. There's far too much telling instead of showing. You cannot possibly misinterpret what a character might be feeling because the author ensures you know every single thought and feeling flowing through their brain in the most robotic fashion possible. We have sentences like 'a sibilant hiss' when sibilant literally means 'with a hissing sound'. In Chapter One, we're told that the world knows about gods and monsters, but in the last chapter, Kaden does a live television broadcast and says that everyone believes monsters are make-believe. So, which is it? We're told during Kaden's meeting with the Otherworld creatures that the leader of the Shades is called Kash, but when Liam fights the Shades, his name changes to Hillmun. The amount of non-sequiters is wild as well. I'm most irritated that the word mortal is used as a replacement for human. Mortal and human do not mean the same thing. Mortality and humanity do not mean the same thing. They cannot be used interchangeably, but this book doesn't care. Every time Dianna says that her 'mortality was slipping back in', I wanted to punch her in the face. SOMEONE KILL HER THEN SHE CAN DIE RN because that's literally what that means.
We have names and creatures thrown at us with no explanation of what they are, and they're never mentioned again (at least not in this book). I still have no idea what a d'jeern is. There are also so many kings in this book that every time a new one is introduced, I have to laugh because what's the point of being a king when literally everyone is a king? Ethan is king of the vampires. Santiago is king of the witches. Kaden is king of the otherworld. Liam is king of the gods. Tobias is one of the kings of Yejedin. Like okay? Who the fuck cares?
I’d originally read the first edition of the Book of Azrael, but since then, it appears to have been revised two to three times. In the first edition, Samkiel is said to speak an ancient, forgotten language, but later calls his mom Madre and mentions going to a ‘bibletocea’. I remember reading this and being confused that they were speaking Spanish, because why would that language be ancient and forgotten? Do Spanish-speaking people no longer exist in this world somehow? Then, shouldn’t names like Martinez not exist? If no one speaks Spanish, why do we have Spanish names? But then the author says Liam is supposed to be half black, half Latine, so why wouldn't he be speaking Spanish? For some reason, a few months after publishing, Amber decided to go back in and change Madre to Merda, which literally means ‘shit’ in multiple Latin-based languages. Girl, come on!!!, Can’t you even bother to look up the translations for the words you choose to use? Can’t even look up the proper spelling for biblioteca? Then, when she realized it meant shit, she changed it to Mama but kept bibletocea for whatever reason. And on top of that, Dianna is supposed to be Armenian-coded, but she has a Spanish last name? Why?
I'm most disappointed that not only was this book just a lot of going from place to place and having the same conversations over and over, but there was also a lot of potential to create cool lore. I wanted to learn more about Nismera and how she managed to get all the gods on her side and convince the Ig'Morruthen to join them. I was more curious about the state of the world after Rashearim had crashed into Onuna. I wanted to know the mystery of Azrael and why Liam was so convinced the book couldn't exist. But we never get to see any of the research he does in the month he stays with Drake. We never even learn that Azrael had a daughter until Camilla says, "Oh, btw, his daughter is alive!" There was no hint that Tobias could be the King of Yejedin because we hardly learn anything about them other than they were created by Primordials and Haldnunen(Tobias) killed Liam's grandpa. That's it. I wanted to learn more about that, not hear Dianna and Liam's constant juvenile bickering.
The relationship between Dianna and Liam could have been so interesting, too. It is definitely a slow burn at first, but towards the end, it seems very rushed. I wish that, like, they had absolutely no romantic interaction whatsoever in this book, in all honesty. I wish the focus had been on the mystery of Azrael, and on them GENUINELY getting to know each other, and on Liam seeing her compassion. At the same time, WE THE READER got to see it too, instead of Liam just telling us how amazing and brilliant and gorgeous and intelligent she is. All I saw was her threatening a mother in front of her children for information, and considering going to eat some random people to interrogate Camilla.
There's plenty more I could say, like the fact that the author seemed to think it was necessary to include a line about Dianna shaving the hair from her
vagina
, but this is already long enough, and I think I've made my point. This book series needed way more time than it was actually given, and a developmental editor who was willing to help this author. Because, as it is right now, it's a disappointment.