A small-town occult horror for fans of Mona Awad’s Bunny and Grady Hendrix’s The Final Girl Support Group, blending ritual magic, toxic friendship, and queer terror in New England.
Witchcraft was just a game. Until the bodies started piling up.
Cinnamon Christine Carmichael doesn’t remember the killings. Not at first. But the blood on her hands, the whispers in her head, and the smile on her best friend Hedda’s face say enough. Something has been unleashed—and it’s using them to grow.
Two teenagers are burned alive in a corn maze as the crowd watches, paralyzed, filming every second. It’s the latest in a string of ritualistic murders that defy explanation. Sheriff Henry McGinty has seen a lot in his time—but nothing like this.
So he calls in Sister Eve.
Eve sees what others can’t: echoes of the dead, glimpses of the future. But this time, the visions are fragmented. Wrong. As if something is blocking her sight. Something old. Something evil. Something wearing the face of her mother, reincarnated in the body of a teenage girl.
As Halloween nears, Cinnamon’s coven races to complete a ritual that could bring the Devil himself to earth—and Eve, Henry, and irreverent deputy Fink may be the last line of defense between our world and utter damnation.
Nick Wallin (he/him) fell in love with writing after reading Stephen King and Jacqueline Susann novels at an unreasonably young age.
He lives in northeast Iowa with his loving partner, several ghosts, and their reclusive barn cat, Little Edie. He enjoys writing, gardening, decorating, and renovating their historic home, Gaye Gardens.
When he’s not writing about haunted women and cursed towns, he can be found haunting antique stores for velvet drapes, gilded mirrors, and anything that looks like it belonged in a 1970s brothel.
Rising Action Publishing will release his horror novel, THE QUIET RESURRECTION OF SISTER EVELIDA LIVINGSTON, on August 4, 2026.
He is also the author of two novels under the pseudonym Jethro Collins. IT TAKES A VILLAGE TO KILL YOUR HUSBAND and LOVE IN THE TIME OF CONTRACTS, which both went to #1 on Amazon's Kindle best-seller list.
4.5 stars for me! Thank you so much to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC! I absolutely loved this bubblegum slasher that had elements of haunting of hill house x the craft x witchcraft for wayward girls.
Nothing scares me more than horror books that center on witchcraft mixed with possession and satanic ritual. A small town with a dark past and an evil entity that tries to bring about the black mass was enough to scare the daylights out of me. A classic good v evil spook.
The writing style was great! I really enjoyed the multiple POV that almost played out like a movie in my mind. The 4 main girls discover they are witches via a secret book in a haunted estate and the story evolves from there (don’t want to give too much away). It’s violent and gory and just what I wanted for summerween.
I was really intrigued with this one, and I was totally into it at first. But then as the story progressed, I had a hard time staying engaged. Might have just been a me thing though. I still encourage checking this out, because not every book is for every person!
Thank you to Rising Action for the gifted eARC in exchange for my honest review! ❤️
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!
Please note this is a 3.5.
An aggressively bubblegum-pop slasher with undertones of ‘The Craft’ and ‘The Witches of Eastwick’ (I say undertones- that one is straight up referenced), this was a heck of a wild ride from start to finish. We follow a group of teen girls who very clearly have something ominous cast over their birthdays, and who soon spiral into a wild cacophony of murder, mayhem, and malicious witchcraft.
The characters were really well done, especially for the time that they’re tied to. I didn’t love some of the references to very 2026 specific material, and I feel with time the book may end up a bit dated, but I also understand that it’s designed to appeal to a specific audience.
The plot starts off being totally gung-ho, and then it slows a little bit as it goes through. This is, by no means, a huge detriment, but I did think that it would have been nice to see a little more in respect of the characters in there.
My favourite character was Cinnamon, particularly as she struggled with the morality and the change in her friendships and her ‘coming of age’ in the most brutal way possible. I got very ‘Witchcraft for Wayward Girls’ vibes off of the dynamic sometimes, but I actually think this book managed the struggle with those dynamics better than the former.
There are some nasty little scenes in here too from the horror perspective, and while the end petered down a bit and I wasn’t a huge fan of that, it was a lot of fun. Definitely a great Halloween read when it comes up- this one is made for autumn nights!
🖋️ Author: Nick Wallin 📖 Title: The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston 📅 Pub Day: September 08, 2026 💌 Publisher: Rising Action Publishing 📚 Format: Digital 🏷️ ISBN: 9781998672271 ⏱️ Length: 368 pages 📌 Genre(s): Occult Horror, Dark Comedy, Queer Horror ⭐ Star Rating: 4
── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
I had a great time with this one. It's fast, it's gory, and it's got serious The Craft vibes. That whole ritual and power thing mixed with messy toxic friend group energy just works so well together.
I was not expecting the dialogue to make me laugh as much as it did honestly. There's some genuinely funny lines mixed in with all the horror stuff, and it kept the whole thing from feeling too heavy or one note.
The writing is solid too. I will say I noticed a few typos here and there in the NetGalley copy I read, but nothing that took away from how much I was enjoying the story.
I was very happy with how everything came together in the end. I don't want to spoil anything, but it felt earned instead of rushed or convenient, which is honestly rare to pull off with this kind of horror.
If you liked Mona Awad's Bunny, I can definitely see why the publisher is comparing this one to it. Small town horror, ritual magic, funny dialogue, messy friendships. Really solid read.
── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
If you like:
✔️ Ritual magic ✔️ Toxic friendships ✔️ Gory horror ✔️ Witty dialogue ✔️ Small town secrets ✔️ The Craft vibes
── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
Thank you to NetGalley, Nick Wallin, and Rising Action Publishing for gifting this ARC in exchange for an honest review! All opinions are my own.
This review is cross‑posted across multiple platforms.
This is deranged, wild, gory and crazy fudged up fun perfect for Halloween and just as bubblegum pop as its bad ass cover. This has several POVs and alternating timelines that all lead to one major crescendo!
Trust me, you do not want to be friends with these teenagers. I loved the power struggle between the four girlies and the different personalities. It reminded me very much of Jawbreaker or The Craft (if you are old enough to get those references) The dialogue made me LOL several times and there were some great campy references. My favorite characters were Henry and Fink. So cute. I could read a story just about those two.
Don’t clutch your pearls, my fellow friends but I think my favorite part of this whole book was the writing. It’s filled with sarcasm, witty quips AND sooooo many cuss words. My blackened sailor heart was in heaven lol Thank you so much @nrw2254 for my copy. I had so much fun with this.
I absolutely devoured this romp of a slasher. The story is told through multiple POVs and fluctuating timelines. The atmosphere is perfect, the character-development is solid for a majority of the characters, and the plot is outlandish and totally captures everything I adore about this genre. A majority of the cast are teenagers, which is reflected in the dialogue, but it never felt YA to me. There is a decent amount of violence throughout, and it’s gruesome. There’s a little romance, too, which I loved and raised the stakes.
The only reason I’m not giving this 5 stars is because I NEEDED more closure from the ending. It was so close to absolute perfection. I needed ONE thing buttoned up. 😭
The PERFECT read for October and I highly recommend. 👻
I think I would have been all over this book as a teenager. This book is about a group of girls that discover their witches and all hell breaks loose. I didn't love the writing style, pacing or dialogue as an adult. I do think a lot of people will enjoy this book though.
Thank you NetGalley and Rising Action for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
“The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston” by Nick Wallin is chaotic, witchy, gory, and an absolute blast. While it reads a little young at first with most of the perspectives being from teenagers, don’t let that fool you; this book is filled with blood and gore, which will practically punch you in the face right away in the first chapter.
The story follows four best friends—Cinnamon, Hedda, Lainey, and Eliza—all born on 06/06/06 When Cinnamon's family buys the town's infamous haunted house, the girls stumble across a spellbook and discover they're witches. Naturally, what starts as "let's play with magic!" quickly escalates into ritual murders, memory loss, demonic forces, and a very real possibility of unleashing Hell itself. Meanwhile, Sheriff Henry teams up with Sister Eve, a former nun who died, came back with psychic abilities, and now spends her time seeing ghosts and terrifying glimpses of the future. Honestly, I was sold from that premise alone.
The atmosphere is where this book really shines. It's soaked in creepy small-town vibes, occult rituals, religious imagery, haunted houses, corn mazes, blood, and just enough Halloween energy to make me want to read it with a pumpkin candle burning nearby. There are some seriously nasty horror scenes too, and the imagery was vivid enough that I could picture every gruesome moment playing out like a movie.
I also really liked the friendship dynamics. These girls are messy, toxic, loyal, and falling apart all at once, and that emotional chaos gives the horror some real weight. Cinnamon ended up being my favorite because she's trying to figure out whether she's losing herself or becoming something much darker, and watching her question her own memories kept me invested from start to finish.
That said, this book definitely embraces chaos. The pacing comes out swinging before slowing down in the middle, and the mythology can get a little complicated. There were a few times I had to stop and piece together how the "every eighteen years" cycle and all the supernatural lore connected. Some of the teenage dialogue also felt a little off to me, and I wasn't always convinced by how the girls reacted in certain situations. Still, once everything clicked, I appreciated just how ambitious the story was.
Overall, “The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston” is a wildly entertaining occult horror packed with witchcraft, queer horror, creepy small-town vibes, toxic friendships, and plenty of bloodshed. If you're looking for a spooky autumn read that feels like a supernatural teen slasher with a heavy dose of Halloween magic, this one is definitely worth adding to your October TBR.
I'm not sure this book knows what it wants to be. It's marketed as occult horror - but let's throw in some slasher, some extreme gore and a haunted house (except let's infer the house is the problem than have everyone say "it's not the house"). It flip flops between different characters and different points of time and while these changes are well highlighted in the chapter titles it's still jarring to suddenly be 2 days prior at a murder that had previously already happened. The joy of horror is being able to create an atmosphere that's draws the reader in and 'Quiet Ressurection' has the perfect potential gothic backdrop. Instead the author has chosen to make this novel so dialogue heavy it becomes impossible to follow who is saying what, alongside some really frustrating repetition that adds nothing and feels like it's there for the word count. Plus we have Cinnamon's inner monologue sprinkled throughout in italicised text. There's zero character development so when the two very obvious would be couples start kissing before the final showdown I really didn't care because I wasn't rooting for them in the slightest. The teen girls are awful stereotypes and are not well written (write what you know maybe?) and there's an undertone of homophobia throughout - clearly the majority of the town dislike Fink because he's gay and the author using terms such as 'mincing' and 'sinning homo' has no place in a book set in 2022. Several plot holes are never answered and while Eve manages to stop the apocalypse (after being resurrected by God despite renouncing religion, which feels heavy handed) we have no idea who survives and whether Cinnamon is jailed for her crimes (surely 'my friend brainwashed me in to murdering innocent people and possibly eating a baby' won't stand up in court?). Instead we get a list of all the Devil's 'chosen ones', those girls destined to attempt the Black Mass. Evelida Livingston is on the list alongside 5 other girls in 1988. This is the first time this is mentioned so I'll just assume they never murdered and tried to end the world in the name of Satan shall I? Normally I would have DNF'd this book around 40% when I realised it wasn't going anywhere and that I didn't care if it did. But I'm trying push myself to finish books, especially arcs, irregardless but this was a slog.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Themes: Small town horror, supernatural, religious, magic, occult, trauma, slasher, multiple POVs, gothic
Trigger Warnings: Religious discussions, supernatural, toxic friendships, magic, graphic violence, gore, graphic child death, body horror, death, murder, demonic/ satanic rituals, occult, possession, animal death and cruelty
This is a mood heavy book. The plot follows a small town and its problem with the occult. “The Craft” meets “Witches of Eastwick” as Cinnamon Carmichael and her coven fight to summon Satan and his legion of demons and the sheriff calls in Sister Eve, who has certain abilities that should be able to help stop them. Something is keeping her psychic gifts from working properly though. Something sinister that she may have come across before.
This book seemed to be polarizing among readers from the reviews that I read. I thought it was fun. The characters are introduced through multiple POVs, each a well-written representation of his or her timeline. I thought the pacing was a bit slow sometimes, especially toward the middle. Other than that, I thoroughly enjoyed this. It was a solid horror book with some very graphic scenes that were truly delicious. The atmosphere is very dark at times, adding a little “Haunting of Hill House” to the “The Craft” atmosphere that made up a good contrast. The lighter portions contained some genuinely funny lines and teenage nonsense, which made the horror parts really effective. This would make a good movie.
Highly recommend this one, but don’t let the YA tone fool you. There’s some dark and gory stuff in this novel.
The Quiet Resurrection of Evelida Livingston follows four teenage best friends, all born on 06/06/06. When one of the girls’ parents purchases the town’s infamous haunted house, the girls discover they’re witches. What starts as an exciting revelation quickly spirals into something much darker. Alongside them, we follow Sheriff Henry and (former) Sister Eve as these childhood friends team up and use Eve’s psychic abilities to try and stop the girls from unleashing hell.
I had such a fun time reading this book. It gave me The Craft meets My Best Friend’s Exorcism vibes, which is a combination I was immediately on board with.
There were moments where the writing felt a little disjointed, but I think that’s largely due to how fast-paced and chaotic the story is. My biggest struggle wasn’t with the magic or supernatural elements….It was with some of the teenage girl characterization. I was a teenage girl once, and some of their reactions and dialogue felt very much written by a man. There were a few moments that pulled me out of the story because they just didn’t feel authentic. For example, why are we talking about being starving while being held hostage and potentially murdered by your best friend? And how is a sixteen-year-old girl casually manhandling a fully grown man?
I also had a hard time following the “every 18 years” plotline at first. I found myself rereading a few sections to fully understand who was being discussed and how everything connected. Once it clicked, though, I realized it was actually a really unique and interesting premise.
If you’re looking for a fast-paced, spooky, teenage-witch story to get you in the Halloween mood, this is definitely one to pick up. The atmosphere was wonderfully eerie, the haunted house setting was a lot of fun, and despite a few issues, I genuinely enjoyed my time with it.
I went into The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston not quite knowing what to expect. It is the first bubblegum slasher that I've ever read. I really enjoyed the genre. The book has a dual timeline. The first part follows the teenage coven causing mass chaos, while the cops and clergy try to figure out what's really going on in the aftermath. The cops are feeling pressure because teenagers are being murdered left and right, and all of the deaths have satanic undertones. Little do they know the town has a dark history that repeats itself every eighteen years.
Going into The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston, I wasn't sure how I was going to like the title character. I have an irrational fear of nuns. Shockingly, she ended up being one of my favorite characters. I ended up looking forward to her POV chapters.
The multiple POVs and timelines added a lot of depth to the story. It was nice seeing the puzzle piece click into place. It was interesting to see the aftermath of the girls' spells before we got the full picture of what was happening and why they were slowly picking off their classmates.
I really wish we had a POV from Deputy Fink. He was my favorite character. He's such a golden retriever himbo, and I couldn't get enough. I loved how much he connected with Eve.
Overall, I would recommend The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston to anyone who enjoys a bubble gum slasher. Also, if you're a fan of The Craft, you will absolutely love this book.
Many thanks to Nick Wallin and Rising Action for the gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.
The entire novel feels drenched in candle smoke, blood, religious paranoia, and small-town decay.
The book’s greatest strength is its mood. Wallin delivers a queer occult horror novel soaked in religious imagery, violent intimacy, and small-town gothic dread. The book works best when it leans into its queer gothic horror identity. The tension between intimacy and violence feels real, and the emotional messiness of the characters gives the horror weight beyond simple shock value. There’s a constant sense that everyone is spiraling toward something awful, and that dread carries the novel through slower sections.
This feels very much like a “mood-first” horror novel. If you love books that prioritize atmosphere, symbolism, and emotional intensity over clean plotting, you’ll probably have a great time. If you prefer tightly structured horror mysteries with clear rules and resolutions, this may feel frustrating.
Unfortunately, the story itself never fully came together for me. The mythology becomes increasingly convoluted, and the book sometimes mistakes ambiguity for depth. There are stretches where events feel emotionally powerful in the moment but hard to connect into a coherent whole afterward. I also wanted more development for certain characters outside the central emotional dynamic.
Overall, The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston is a read that I admired it more than I loved. I found it a bit uneven, occasionally self-indulgent, but undeniably memorable.
I had some difficulty getting into this at first because initially everything seemed disconnected, the writing wasn't really grabbing me, and the characters felt a bit flat, but after a few chapters things started to fall into place more, the characters developed stronger, more nuanced personalities, and it became reminiscent of a classic Stephen King book with the small town setting and fairly broad cast of characters (Salem's Lot really came to mind).
I did end up liking quite a few of the characters, but the teenage girls never really grew on me. Most of their conversation dialogue made me cringe and the reactions of the more "innocent" of them to events were honestly kind of baffling even when following the book world's internal logic; they just did not seem as bothered by what was happening most of the time as I would expect they would be from the characterizations the author set up for them. I found the chapters following the adult characters to be much more enjoyable and consistent. With how this book pulled no punches with the death and gore, I was genuinely nervous for all the main characters as events ramped up. The ending was abrupt and I do wish there would have been a bit more after the climax, but overall this was a fun read.
Thank you to Rising Action Publishing Co. for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
3.5/5: The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston
Cinnamon and her gal group of friends are like any other teens...until their memories start feeling fuzzy. & things start getting bloody. & her bff Hedda starts acting off.
Unfortunately, Sheriff Henry, deputy Fink, and (former) sister Eve seem to always be one step behind the terror the teen girls are releasing into their community.
This was a middle of the road tread for me. It started off feeling flat and super disconnected, but the pacing sped up and things (sorta) came together in the end, plot wise. I think unfortunately for me this felt more like a VIBES read vs a PLOT read. If you love reading books that are all about the mood and "the Craft" like vibes, you will likely adore this book! But if you want something with a more logical plot then this might not be for you. I'd also note that the character writing in the adult POV chapters was stronger than the teen POV chapters.
The highlight for me: I personally really did love the character Fink, though. I didn't especially care too much about what was happening to the girls but 100% rooted for Fink! Get the man a donut!
....... Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. All views expressed are my own.
Picture Mean Girls + The Craft having a creepy, horror, bitchy little twat baby… and you’re getting pretty damn close to The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston. 💀🖤
I’m STILL so grateful for the absolutely fabulous box Nick sent me because every single thing in it tied back to this book and honestly?? SO. MUCH. FUN. 🙌🏼
We’ve got haunted house vibes, a creepy coven witchcraft, culty chaos, ritualistic murders, annnnd the Catholic Church (because apparently we weren’t already scared enough 😬🤣), ohhh AND my new final-boy best friend, Officer Fink 😘 I would like to formally request more Henry and Fink immediately, thank you.
This one was cunty, chaotic, and just an absolute blast to read. The whole “witchcraft was just a game until the bodies started piling up” thing? Yeahhh… things escalate QUICKLY. 🔥
Cinnamon and her coven thought they were just playing around with witchcraft… until a string of brutal ritual murders makes it VERY clear that something much darker has been unleashed. With Halloween closing in and a terrifying ritual underway, Cinnamon, Sheriff Henry, and Sister Eve have to figure out what the hell they’ve awakened before the Devil gets his invitation. 😈🩸
If you like your horror with witches, spooky small town energy, a little religious terror, and a whole lot of WHAT THE FUCK IS HAPPENING?! — add this one to your list.
Nick, you absolutely understood the assignment. 🖤🔪✨️
The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston by Nick Wallin is an occult horror story with witchcraft, ritualistic magic, toxic friends, and terror. The story is about Cinnamon Carmichael, Hedda Bunad, Lainey Lopez, and Eliza Taylor. Four girls born on June 6, 2006 in a small town, they referred to as 'the sixes' due to their date of birth The girls find a spellbook in the supposed haunted house the Cinnamons parents purchased. With spellbook in hand, the girls discover their witches. The teenagers playing around with witchcraft turn into something much darker when murders start happening in the girls' town. Cinnamon begins to experience memory issues and wonders if she had something to do with them. The sheriff brings in Sister Eve Livingston, who has supernatural abilities after she was shot, then returned to life. She now has visions and a tie to the supernatural, seeing the dead as well as possible futures. The girls unleash something dark, and it's up to Eve to stop it. This book was interesting and reminded me of 'The Craft' and other teen witch shows I used to watch. The pacing started to drag a bit but picked back up. The mood and imagery of this book was one of the things I enjoyed most, while gory, i could picture the scenes in my head. I received this ARC from Netgalley in exchange for my honest opinion and thoughts. Im rating it 3.5 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Rising Action Publishing Co. for an eARC copy of The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston.
This wasn't a terrible book, just not the book I was hoping for. The blend of witchcraft, demonic horror, and small-town mystery had a lot of potential, and there were a few genuinely creepy moments - especially the opening murders - but the story never fully delivered on the tension I was hoping for.
For me, there was just too much going on. Between Cinnamon, Sister Eve, Sheriff McGinty, Fink, the coven, reincarnation, visions, and the looming apocalypse, it felt like the narrative was juggling so many ideas that none of them were explored as deeply as they could have been. I also struggled to connect with the characters, so the emotional stakes didn't land as well as I wanted. It also took me a few tries to start reading the book in general.
The pacing was uneven. Some sections dragged with exposition, while others rushed through major reveals that should have had more impact. The horror elements were entertaining enough, but found them more over-the-top then genuinely frightening.
That said, if you're looking for an action-packed supernatural horror novel with plenty of gore, occult themes, etc., there's still fun to be had here. I like to think of it as a B-rated horror film. It just wasn't what I really wanted or expected.
OH was this book fun as hell!!! Officially my favorite read of the year! I finished this book in one sitting, I was INVESTED! I’ll be re-reading for the remainder of spooky season! That’s how you write a horror, culty, witchy, chaotic GREAT story!!! 😝🧙🏻🔥🪦🖤
I loved everything about this book!! * Multiple POV’s * The pace was perfect (gave enough to tell a story) * The amount of thrill & drama * The spookiness surrounding cults, rituals & witchcraft
What’s better than a haunting ritual taking place on Halloween, a resurrected nun & a toxic friend group that escalates?!
Cinnamon was definitely a morally gray unreliable FMC. I loved the uncertainty of never knowing if she was the victim, villain or both. I had my qualms with her BUT, I was also rooting for her! 🤭👀
Sister Evelida is a seer & fearless nun who brings this mysterious religious horror element to the story, adding another layer of fun supernatural chaos to navigate.
My favorite dialogue that had me hysterical ⬇️ “Hot Father Bill looks like Chris Evans & Henry Cavill had a moody baby with graying hair.” 💀
P.S: one specific person is a little bishhh & can kick rocks with open toed shoes!!
The book had an interesting premise, but its execution fell short. The characters often share the same voice and speech patterns, making it difficult to distinguish them as individuals. Even the four teenage protagonists struggle to stand out from one another. The narrative suffers from abrupt transitions, cutting away just as a moment begins to build tension or reveal something interesting. Revelations pile up, answers arrive out of order in a way that it was difficult to follow up and the story rarely gives its ideas enough room to develop. The result is chaotic, but not in a particularly compelling way. The book was marketed to fans of Bunny by Mona Awad, but I found little resemblance between the two. Bunny keeps you disoriented throughout, whereas The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston often left me simply confused. There is a difference between deliberate narrative disorientation and a story that fails to provide enough coherence for its reader to follow. Some passages worked remarkably well, particularly the more graphic scenes, and Cinnamon and the supposedly villainous teacher were among the few characters I found genuinely interesting. Unfortunately, these moments of promise were not enough to compensate for the uneven storytelling and deeply unsatisfying ending.
Thank you to Rising Action and NetGalley for the ebook!
Summary: Cinnamon and her friends thought witchcraft was just a game until something much darker begins happening around them. As ritualistic murders pile up, Sister Eve is called in to help, but even her abilities are being affected by whatever has been unleashed. With Halloween approaching, the group is getting closer to completing a ritual that could have terrifying consequences.
My Review: I really think a younger reader might connect with this one more than I did. I kept thinking about myself when I was younger in the 90s, watching The Craft, and I know I would have eaten this up. Witchcraft, a teenage coven, Halloween, friendship, and something seriously dark happening underneath it all would have been completely my thing. I honestly cannot give a big reason why this didn't work better for me now. Maybe I am just older and this particular story wasn't meant for me anymore, and that's okay. There were definitely things I liked about the concept, and I can easily see this finding readers who absolutely love it.
Would I Recommend? Yes, especially for readers who love witchy horror, teenage covens, Halloween, occult stories, and that The Craft kind of feeling.
Thank you to NetGalley and Rising Action Publishing for an eARC of The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston.
I enjoyed this more than I expected. The first few chapters did not hook me, but as more of Lawrenceville's past was revealed, I really got sucked into the novel. The horror was dark and intimate and there was definitely a lot of gory horror and religious iconography.
The girls' chapters were my least favorites. I read some other reviews and agree that the girls, especially Lainey and Eliza were a little two-dimensional. My favorite characters were Fink and Henry. For the formatting, I found the jumps backwards and forwards in time a little jarring at first, because it was hard to keep track of what had happened/had not happened. It did work for what the author was trying to do by revealing pieces of the story slowly.
This was a random snag for me from Netgalley and was not a bad trip.
Cinnamon wakes up covered in blood, I know I know what girl hasn't?? But this is uh the blood of others and the voices she hears, this can't be good.
Cinnamon and her friends are all witches and born on the same day and then things get dark quick, playing with things they don't understand and calling on things older then the world itself..
As small town Sheriff McGinity is facing some things, specifically kids being burned alive, so he turns to Eve, who just so happens to see more then most. But this time something is in the way and it's from her past.
Can the town survive the blood shed and what could be the end of the world if the devil shows up to the call of Cinnamon coven?
This was a quick faced paced read and wouldn't mind checking out more from the author.
The Quiet Resurrection of Sister Evelida Livingston - Nick Wallin
I enjoyed this book. I love the bubblegum pink horror slasher vibe this book has. The author really knows how to write a good suspenseful and intense atmosphere. The characters are also really compelling. I loved bouncing back-and-forth between everyone’s point of view. Cinnamon, Bill, Henry, Walker, Eve, and Hedda were great characters and I loved reading about them and getting to know them. I definitely will be reading more from this author.
Thank you Netgalley and Rising Action Publishing Co. for providing me with an eARC!
🌟 3/5 Stars
Giving this three stars is a little generous because I do not think it's a good book. It's messy, not particularly well written, I couldn't care less for the majority of the characters and it's overly long when it doesn't need to be. Too much detail in places where it's unnecessary and lacking detail in places that would benefit it. However, I didn't have a bad time with it. It was definitely a conscious effort to get through and finish but it's not something I was dreading to read. I feel like I enjoyed it in the way I enjoy B-movies, it's a mess and nonsensical but it has its charms and can be fun at times and sometimes that's enough. Overall, it didn't really deliver on what I was hoping for and was a disappointment in most ways but I feel generally indifferent about it.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review. As was noted from the publisher when I use quotes from the book they are subject to change. (though I don't think they will change the whole format of this book lol)
[Spoiler-free Review]
To sum this book up in two sentences: Men shouldn't write female characters and SO MUCH FUCKING DIALOGUE.
This is genuinely the first book I would rate a 0 if I could. Even the other 1 stars I gave had at least SOMETHING. But this book was pure nonsense and a waste of time. Shame. The cover was beautiful and the blurb sounded interesting. But this ain't it, chief.
There is ALOT of talking and not much describing going on. And I mean A LOT. I've never encountered this in a book before and I don't like it. Dialogue is good, banter can be nice, but this is just non-stop talking. I'm not listening to a podcast I'm trying to read a book lmao. Also the dialogue is definitely not strong enough to carry this. If I had to make a guess I'd say it's 70-80% dialogue.
Let me give you an example of what most of this book looks like:
“For what?” “You were right. I need you. We need you.” “I’m sorry, can you say that again?” Eve tilted her head with a glow of superiority. “You. Were. Right.” Henry closed his eyes dramatically. “We need your help. It’s Cinnamon Carmichael.” “Did you arrest her?” “Not yet, but hear me out.” “How’d you find out?” “Fink,” Henry said, the name lingering on his lips. “Of course, you know, you really should be nicer to him.” “I know, I know.” Henry tried not to smile. “He’s just so—” “Kind. Sweet. Nice. Everything you are not.” “Yeah, yeah.” Henry dipped his head in agreement.
I'm so for real. I didn't even purposefully pick the worst one, it's genuinely like this the whole book. Some chapters are better than others where we get at least a little bit of descriptions but most of it is just DIALOGUE. And it's so goddamn boring, everyone sounds the same, the dialogue is either 0 charisma or downright cringe with all the "bitch" thrown in. Teen girls say bitch a lot, right guys? I genuinely can't get over the format of this book, why in the hell would you pick dialogue only for a horror book. A horror book lives from descriptions and building atmosphere. Listening to characters with interchangable voices talking non-stop about nothing interesting is not spooky or atmospheric.
It takes about 250 pages out of 380 to get SOMEWHERE and at this point I don't care anymore.
I have never DNF'ed a book yet, though I came close once or twice and this book has tested my patience. I genuinely wanted to DNF, erase it and forget I even started it to preserve my no DNF rule. But I will not let this book have that power over me lmao, I finished... but at the cost of my sanity. Not that there is much left.
I'll be so real with you men writing about women, especially underage girls is very icky 90% of the time. Case in point when Cinnamon compares her body to Lainey's. Idk the word "Curvaceous" is kind of cursed nowadays. Not to mention Cinnamon's mom who is the bimbo stereotype and everyone is looking at her tits... like... okay? Also the cringy sex jokes in between... That's why if I have to read something by a male author I'd rather read Middle Grade, the chances of weird sexual shit there is minimal. Not impossible... but minimal.
And I understand there is a theme of beauty standards here and the pressure of it. But men are the ones demanding those standards (while looking like the missing link of course) and they have no clue what it's like, so a man writing about this topic is just... don't. Just don't. You are allowed to look like a goddamn thumb that got mangled and blown up and you'll still have people say "oh my god but he could be funny... give him a chance, won't you?". Nuh uh.
I'm honestly going crazy there is so much fucking dialogue and none of it is relevant or interesting. These girls have zero personality or charisma, if I wanted to listen to NPC's talking nonsense I'd play Skyrim. And I don't play that game for obvious reasons.
I can't take this book serious when the "pure evil incarnate voice" says "run bitch run". Are you for real? Is this a comedy? Well, I'm not laughing.
"Is someone pressuring you into sex?" "No, mom," Cinnamon giggled. "Sadly, nothing like that." - Only a man could think not being pressured into sex is a "sad" thing. Why do men even bother writing women? I'd honestly rather have them use a self insert than fumble around with female characters.
I 100% believe the positive reviews are fake or the authors friends. There is no writing style to be liked, it's only dialogue! And bad dialogue at that. Even the books I hated before and gave 1 star I at least could see how others enjoyed it, but this book has genuinely nothing. The only horror thing about this is how much GODDAMN DIALOGUE you can cram into almost 400 pages. This should've been 200 pages at max. The reviews who say this book at least nails atmosphere is a goddamn lie. There is no atmosphere. It's not funny, it's not spooky, it's a headache through and through.
"Now we are going to find out if you actually taste like cinammon." - Ah yes, comedy right there. Very witty, much funny. I wish men would finally accept that they aren't funny and would stop trying, it's embarassing.
Even the sheriff, Fink and the nun talk like the girls. If the name of the POV wouldn't be written at each chapter I wouldn't know who tf is speaking. Hey, if you say bitch more then I will totally believe you you know how to write teen girls! lmao
Thank you to Netgalley and Rising Action Publishing for the eARC.
If you like a bloody, propulsive, and genuinely creepy horror novel that balances high-stakes ritual magic with grounded, emotional trauma, And, also offers slow-burning dread, psychological tension, and stories about the darker side of witchcraft, this should absolutely be on your radar.
Wallin does an incredible job of leaning into classic New England autumn aesthetics—crisp air, dead leaves, and community events—and subverting them into something deeply unsettling. It also offers sharp commentaries on modern cultures, fascinating character dynamics and a deep dive into toxic relationships.
Thanks to Rising Action Publishing and netgalley for a copy of this arc
This is fun horror bordering on a horror comedy in a few places.
It's bloody and a little gross and not mean spirited at all.
It does have a plethora of pop culture references that will I think keep it very tethered to now, and that not my particular favorite but i think will really work for some readers.
This skews a bit young with most of of our cast being in school but in a way that if you don't particularly enjoy ya as a whole it wouldn't be a negative but if you do would be a draw.
It gave me big Codie Crowley vibes and was such a fun beach read.
The book draws you in completely from the beginning and then slows down as you’re introduce to the characters. While the stories are being told from different timelines, you’re introduce to a group of girls who slowly start to get in over their heads and the adults who are figuring it out with both groups meeting in the end for the finale.
Considering how great the beginning of the book was for me, the ending didn’t feel as exciting to read. Overall, enjoyed the story, enjoyed the switching timelines. Some reference did seem slightly out of place but otherwise still a fun read. 3 ⭐️
I really enjoyed how weird and unsettling this one felt. It has this grimy, almost suffocating atmosphere that made me feel like something terrible was always lurking just around the corner. I especially liked the mix of witchcraft, religious horror, gore, and resurrection—it gets pretty messed up at times, but in a way that kept me curious.
The story definitely isn’t for everyone, especially if you’re sensitive to graphic or disturbing scenes, but personally, I liked how unapologetically dark it was. There’s something about horror that doesn’t try too hard to be pretty or comfortable, and this one really leans into that.