TY to Thomas Nelson and Harper Audio for the gifted copies. 4.5 stars, rounded up.
Wes and Addie Had Their Chance is book three in the Adelaide Springs series, and no, I don’t recommend jumping in here. At the very least, read Brynn and Sebastian Hate Each Other first. A lot of the lower Goodreads ratings come from readers who didn’t realize it’s a series. You can follow the plot without the earlier books, but you’ll miss the emotional depth and the richness of the small-town dynamics that make this story so rewarding.
Now, onto the book itself — it’s my favorite of the series. This is a second-chance romance between high school sweethearts, now in their 40s, who’ve both been married and widowed. It’s a more emotional read than the first two in the series, with one of the most authentic portrayals of love after loss I’ve ever seen. Wes and Addie’s journey is tender, bittersweet, and honestly heartbreaking at times, but Bethany stitches my heart back together by the end. There are also some LOL moments that keep the emotional weight from feeling overwhelming.
The only thing I didn’t 100% love about this book was the ending. It felt a little rushed and not fully true to the characters. It’s not a dealbreaker, just a missed opportunity to stick the landing on what was otherwise a near-perfect (to me) book.
Audio: I split my time between the audiobook and my print copy. The dual POV narration is great — Patrick Zeller as Wes truly PERFORMS his chapters with so much emotion. At times, his intensity feels slightly out of sync with Addie’s narrator, Talon Davis, whose performance is solid but more subdued. Still a great listen overall!