What do you think?
Rate this book
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015
Science fiction and fantasy enjoy a long literary tradition, stretching from Mary Shelley, H. G. Wells, and Jules Verne to Ray Bradbury, Ursula K. Le Guin, and William Gibson. In The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy award-winning editor John Joseph Adams delivers a diverse and vibrant collection of stories published in the previous year. Featuring writers with deep science fiction and fantasy backgrounds, along with those who are infusing traditional fiction with speculative elements, these stories uphold a longstanding tradition in both genres—looking at the world and asking, What if . . . ?
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015 includes
Kelly Link, Neil Gaiman, Karen Russell
T. C. Boyle, Sofia Samatar, Jo Walton, Cat Rambo
Daniel H. Wilson, Seanan McGuire, Jess Row
and others
JOE HILL, guest editor, is the New York Times best-selling author of the novels Heart-Shaped Box, Horns, and NOS4A2 and the short story collection 20th Century Ghosts. He is also the writer of the comic book series Locke & Key.
JOHN JOSEPH ADAMS, series editor, is the best-selling editor of more than two dozen anthologies, including Brave New Worlds, Wastelands, and The Living Dead. He is also the editor and publisher of the digital magazines Lightspeed and Nightmare and is a producer of Wired’s podcast The Geek’s Guide to the Galaxy.
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015 includes
Kelly Link, Neil Gaiman, Karen Russell
T. C. Boyle, Sofia Samatar, Jo Walton, Cat Rambo
Daniel H. Wilson, Seanan McGuire, Jess Row
and others
JOE HILL, guest editor, is the New York Times best-selling author of the novels Heart-Shaped Box, Horns, and NOS4A2 and the short story collection 20th Century Ghosts. He is also the writer of the comic book series Locke & Key.
JOHN JOSEPH ADAMS, series editor, is the best-selling editor of more than two dozen anthologies, including Brave New Worlds, Wastelands, and The Living Dead. He is also the editor and publisher of the digital magazines Lightspeed and Nightmare and is a producer of Wired’s podcast The Geek’s Guide to the Galaxy.
345 pages, Paperback
First published October 6, 2015
345 people are currently reading
2325 people want to read
About the author
Joe Hill
504 books29.6k followersJoe Hill's debut, Heart-Shaped Box, won the Bram Stoker Award for Best First Novel. His second, Horns, was made into a film freakfest starring Daniel Radcliffe. His other novels include NOS4A2, and his #1 New York Times Best-Seller, The Fireman... which was also the winner of a 2016 Goodreads Choice Award for Best Horror Novel.
He writes short stories too. Some of them were gathered together in his prize-winning collection, 20th Century Ghosts.
He won the Eisner Award for Best Writer for his long running comic book series, Locke & Key, co-created with illustrator and art wizard Gabriel Rodriguez.
He lives in New Hampshire with a corgi named McMurtry after a certain beloved writer of cowboy tales. His next book, Strange Weather, a collection of novellas, storms into bookstores in October of 2017.
He writes short stories too. Some of them were gathered together in his prize-winning collection, 20th Century Ghosts.
He won the Eisner Award for Best Writer for his long running comic book series, Locke & Key, co-created with illustrator and art wizard Gabriel Rodriguez.
He lives in New Hampshire with a corgi named McMurtry after a certain beloved writer of cowboy tales. His next book, Strange Weather, a collection of novellas, storms into bookstores in October of 2017.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 211 reviews
March 28, 2016
Every single story in this collection is fantastic.
It is so rare for a collection that claims to be the "best of" anything to consistently deliver on that promise, and this one has wrecked the curve.
Whether you're already a fan of the genre, or you're looking to explore SF/F for the first time, you will love the stories that Joe Hill and John Joseph Adams have collected in this volume.
It is so rare for a collection that claims to be the "best of" anything to consistently deliver on that promise, and this one has wrecked the curve.
Whether you're already a fan of the genre, or you're looking to explore SF/F for the first time, you will love the stories that Joe Hill and John Joseph Adams have collected in this volume.
February 14, 2016
What a wonderful science-ficiton/fantasy short story collection. I discovered a few new authors in addition to great stories. A few favorites:
*"Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" by Carmen Maria Machado
*"A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i" by Alaya Dawn Johnson
*"Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology" by Theodora Goss
*"Windows" by Susan Palwick
*"The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever" by Daniel H. Wilson
*"Skullpocket" by Nathan Ballingrud
*"The Relive Box" by T.C. Boyle
*"Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" by Carmen Maria Machado
*"A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i" by Alaya Dawn Johnson
*"Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology" by Theodora Goss
*"Windows" by Susan Palwick
*"The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever" by Daniel H. Wilson
*"Skullpocket" by Nathan Ballingrud
*"The Relive Box" by T.C. Boyle
September 15, 2025
This is the first of the now-one-decade-old annual Best American SFF anthologies I’ve read, and it’s a very strong beginning to the series. I’ve always loved the structure its related, long-running, non-SFF annual anthology adopted: every year, a renowned author selects 20 stories from about 100-120 that were handed to them, having been whittled down by an editor. The author in question reads them blind, not knowing the author’s names or where the stories were published.
In this case, I admit to being a little skeptical about how much taste the author in question, Joe Hill, and I would share. I wasn’t all that impressed with Heart-Shaped Box, the only book of his I’ve read, although I did admire aspects of what he was attempting to deal with in that novel.
At any rate, it turns out that he was drawn to all sorts of fascinating, surprising, richly imagined, and inventive work, most of which was among the strongest batch of SFF short stories I’ve read in a long time. As always, there were some that didn’t work quite as well for me as others, (including one by Seanan McGuire, the appeal of whose work continues to elude me), but there weren’t any out-and-out clunkers in the bunch, which is a rarity in anthologies such as this.
My favorites were by writers who found wonderfully innovative, surprisingly funny styles and forms to tell their emotionally complex tales. I was already a great admirer of Carmen Maria Machado’s work, and her brilliantly titled “Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead” is one of her very best stories. I’d heard great things about Kelly Link, and I found myself both cackling and being fascinated by her bold choices in how she told the story of a demon lover and his paramours, “I Can See Right Through You.” And the most affecting selection of all was the final one in the collection, a sweet and vulnerable portrait of an ace, depressed, neurodivergent youngster, “How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps” by A. Merc Rustad.
I’ll be very curious to see how much my tastes converge or differ with the other guest editors in subsequent volumes.
In this case, I admit to being a little skeptical about how much taste the author in question, Joe Hill, and I would share. I wasn’t all that impressed with Heart-Shaped Box, the only book of his I’ve read, although I did admire aspects of what he was attempting to deal with in that novel.
At any rate, it turns out that he was drawn to all sorts of fascinating, surprising, richly imagined, and inventive work, most of which was among the strongest batch of SFF short stories I’ve read in a long time. As always, there were some that didn’t work quite as well for me as others, (including one by Seanan McGuire, the appeal of whose work continues to elude me), but there weren’t any out-and-out clunkers in the bunch, which is a rarity in anthologies such as this.
My favorites were by writers who found wonderfully innovative, surprisingly funny styles and forms to tell their emotionally complex tales. I was already a great admirer of Carmen Maria Machado’s work, and her brilliantly titled “Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead” is one of her very best stories. I’d heard great things about Kelly Link, and I found myself both cackling and being fascinated by her bold choices in how she told the story of a demon lover and his paramours, “I Can See Right Through You.” And the most affecting selection of all was the final one in the collection, a sweet and vulnerable portrait of an ace, depressed, neurodivergent youngster, “How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps” by A. Merc Rustad.
I’ll be very curious to see how much my tastes converge or differ with the other guest editors in subsequent volumes.
July 23, 2016
A lot of grim dystopia here, some wonderful apocalyptastic stuff, especially "The Empties" by Jess Row, which was brilliant. Probably the best of the bunch are "A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i," which I read twice, and "The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever." I'm sad to say how very disappointed I was in "How the Marquis Got His Coat Back," some shockingly bad stuff from Neil Gaiman, so I won't dwell on it for too long. And I'm so happy that I read the Contributor's Notes, wherein I learned that the author of "Skullpocket," which was the reason I picked this up in the first place, is actually writing a novel about Hob's Landing! The story hints at all sorts of dark, gruesomely interesting stuff and the story works really well without spilling the details, but what a treat it would be to get some more info on Wormcake, the Church of the Maggot, the Frozen Parliament, and all that jazz. Here's a taste:
http://io9.com/read-skullpocket-one-o...
http://io9.com/read-skullpocket-one-o...
March 6, 2016
I really like the way Adams compiled this: making a long list and then submitting those stories blind to Joe Hill to choose from. Lots of good stuff, and several new-to-me authors.
Library copy
Library copy
March 18, 2016
This was without a doubt one of the best short story collections I've read, and easily deserves its 5 star rating from me. But because memory is a fickle mistress and i have stopped trusting it I'm going to review each story separately as a note to my future self who cant remember exactly what they were about.
How to Get Back to the Forest - Sofia Samatar : 4 stars. "You have to puke it up." A raw, haunting story about girls and their bodies, controlled and uncontrollable and as Sofia Samatar says in the contributor's notes "the idea of rebellion as a kind of sympathetic reaction." A great start to the collection.
Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead - Carmen Maria Machado : 5 stars. A Kickstarter shaped story about a girl trying to follow her sister down into the land of the dead. Beautiful and original with a great balance between the classic orphic tale of descending into the underworld and all the modern nuances of internet projects.
Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable - Cat Rambo : 3 1/2 stars. I am being unfair with my rating because that was a really good story about cloning (both the narrator's dead wife and the tortoiseshell cat in the title) with very interesting implications and causes for thought. All in all everything is handled really well and it just suffers from being a scifi story placed between two of my favorite fantasy stories in this collection so I was harsher with my rating than i would normally have been.
The Bad Graft - Karen Russell : 5 stars. !!! This was a very Weird story about a woman who got possessed by a Joshua tree during her honeymoon and the subsequent collapse of her marriage. It sort of carries the vibe of the film "The honeymoon" only it's done A LOT better. The story is simply fantastic.
A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i - Alaya Dawn Johnson : 4 stars. I was expecting to be disappointed because I'd loved the Summer PRince so much and I thought that a short story couldn't possibly capture all the beauty and feeling ADJ managed to infuse the Summer Prince with. Especially a story about vampires . Needless to say i was w r o n g. An amazing and complex and wonderful story.
Each to Each - Seanan Mcguire : 4 1/2 stars. This story was basically why i decided to finally get off my ass and read this anthology i mean. It's got everything. Mermaids. Genetic experiments. The ocean. TS Eliot. Seanan Mcguire really never disappoints me.
Ogres of East Africa - Sofia Samatar : 4 1/2 stars. I loved the format of this story, with the description and cataloging of the ogres and then the notes and kind of "background info" provided by the narrator. A great story about identity and racism and reclaiming what the world is trying to steal from you and yours.
Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology - Theodora Goss : 5 stars and a lot of exclamation marks. If you make a list of all the things I love to see in stories then this story would cross out a good deal of them. Stories shaping reality!! This is a bunch of anthropologists who literally created an entire civilization. It ran away from them, of course, as civilizations tend to do, and nobody could quite imagine how it would end up but. Stories made real! Stories shaping the world! and finally: weird creepy twins!!
Sleeper - Jo Walton : 4 stars. Again, this is a story about how the narrative shapes the reality. A woman works on the biography of a possible Soviet Sleeper agent SORT OF. A biography that features an AI based on the subject but programmed by the author. Revolution via strange King Arthur-like imagery. Sign me up.
How the Marquis Got His Coat Back - Neil Gaiman : 3 stars. But Marita, I hear you say. It's the Marquis! more than that it's Neil Gaiman! And I will nod myself and say: yes. but this was probably one of the most disappointing stories in this collection. It pales between the amazing stories that surround it and lbh I doubt it would have made it in if it wasn't so recognizably Neil Gaiman, and about such a beloved character.
Windows - Susan Palwick : 4 stars. A mother visits her son in prison to play him a clip sent by his sister who has been selected to be a passenger/crew/citizen of a generation ship. A story that focuses on the people left behind. Very real despite its Scifi setting.
The Thing About Shapes to Come - Adam-Troy Castro : 4 stars. What if humans stopped giving birth to baby shaped babies and gave birth instead to geometrical shapes, like spheres, or pyramids, or cubes. How do you love your child against all odds, not because it's your duty but because you genuinely honestly Just Do? A very strange but still beautiful and touching story.
We Are the Cloud - Sam J. Miller: 5 stars. Named by the author a "supervillain origin story", in a world that's ours, with a couple more gadgets and maybe a more prominent capacity for the oppression of the weak and different and unlucky. The most horrifying things mentioned in this are real, happening now, and as Miller says in the contributor's notes: In a world like that none of us come out clean. A must read, honestly.
The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever - Daniel H. Wilson : 3 stars Not one of my favorites. Still a beautiful story about the end of the world but not exactly my cup of tea. But then again I'm a fantasy girl, so I am probably being very unfair to it.
Skullpocket - Nathan Ballingrud : 4 stars. This didn't get my attention from the start but when it did, boy was it worth it. Probably the most classically horror story of the bunch -although all of the stories have an undertone of horror, probably understandable since they were chosen by Hill- it's got hints of Jerusalem's Lot and a slightly Lovecraftian feel.
I Can See Right Through You - Kelly Link : 5 stars. I have a hit and miss relationship with Kelly Link but this story was an absolute hit. The story of two former co-stars, lovers, friends, Maggie and Will, the Demon Lover. It's a story about the intimacy created by being loved by millions of people, and the loneliness that comes with it, and the weirdness, and the, yes, sometimes, horror of people's love.
The Empties - Jess Row : 5 stars. Narratives are static. Real life is kinetic. How do you write about the end of the world while you're living the end of the world? How do you reconcile years and years of watching the films, and reading the stories, and thinking you know how the story goes only to realize that the stories are really just stories, and have absolutely nothing to do with your reality?
The One They Took Before - Kelly Sandoval : 5 stars. You might have noticed by now that I, like a true millennial, am biased in favor of stories set in what is undoubtedly today. Not yesterday, or tomorrow, today. Add faeries to this and you've got a story of pain and longing and the need for autonomy and freedom that's as magical as anything.
The Relive Box - T C Boyle : 3 stars. Another victim of my Fantasy bias, this is a very interesting story that failed to captivate me that much. About a man and his daughter and their Relive Box, a machine that allows you to (you guessed it) relive points of your life. Addiction is unavoidable, and destructive.
How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps - A. Merc Rustad : 5 stars. A great end to a fantastic collection. The author says it's one of the most personal stories they've written and you can tell, you can definitely tell, reading it because it's almost raw in its honesty. I cried, a little, to be quite honest. And it wasn't just the mention of polyamory that made me cry. Nor the asexual character. Although they helped.
How to Get Back to the Forest - Sofia Samatar : 4 stars. "You have to puke it up." A raw, haunting story about girls and their bodies, controlled and uncontrollable and as Sofia Samatar says in the contributor's notes "the idea of rebellion as a kind of sympathetic reaction." A great start to the collection.
Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead - Carmen Maria Machado : 5 stars. A Kickstarter shaped story about a girl trying to follow her sister down into the land of the dead. Beautiful and original with a great balance between the classic orphic tale of descending into the underworld and all the modern nuances of internet projects.
Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable - Cat Rambo : 3 1/2 stars. I am being unfair with my rating because that was a really good story about cloning (both the narrator's dead wife and the tortoiseshell cat in the title) with very interesting implications and causes for thought. All in all everything is handled really well and it just suffers from being a scifi story placed between two of my favorite fantasy stories in this collection so I was harsher with my rating than i would normally have been.
The Bad Graft - Karen Russell : 5 stars. !!! This was a very Weird story about a woman who got possessed by a Joshua tree during her honeymoon and the subsequent collapse of her marriage. It sort of carries the vibe of the film "The honeymoon" only it's done A LOT better. The story is simply fantastic.
A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i - Alaya Dawn Johnson : 4 stars. I was expecting to be disappointed because I'd loved the Summer PRince so much and I thought that a short story couldn't possibly capture all the beauty and feeling ADJ managed to infuse the Summer Prince with. Especially a story about vampires . Needless to say i was w r o n g. An amazing and complex and wonderful story.
Each to Each - Seanan Mcguire : 4 1/2 stars. This story was basically why i decided to finally get off my ass and read this anthology i mean. It's got everything. Mermaids. Genetic experiments. The ocean. TS Eliot. Seanan Mcguire really never disappoints me.
Ogres of East Africa - Sofia Samatar : 4 1/2 stars. I loved the format of this story, with the description and cataloging of the ogres and then the notes and kind of "background info" provided by the narrator. A great story about identity and racism and reclaiming what the world is trying to steal from you and yours.
Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology - Theodora Goss : 5 stars and a lot of exclamation marks. If you make a list of all the things I love to see in stories then this story would cross out a good deal of them. Stories shaping reality!! This is a bunch of anthropologists who literally created an entire civilization. It ran away from them, of course, as civilizations tend to do, and nobody could quite imagine how it would end up but. Stories made real! Stories shaping the world! and finally: weird creepy twins!!
Sleeper - Jo Walton : 4 stars. Again, this is a story about how the narrative shapes the reality. A woman works on the biography of a possible Soviet Sleeper agent SORT OF. A biography that features an AI based on the subject but programmed by the author. Revolution via strange King Arthur-like imagery. Sign me up.
How the Marquis Got His Coat Back - Neil Gaiman : 3 stars. But Marita, I hear you say. It's the Marquis! more than that it's Neil Gaiman! And I will nod myself and say: yes. but this was probably one of the most disappointing stories in this collection. It pales between the amazing stories that surround it and lbh I doubt it would have made it in if it wasn't so recognizably Neil Gaiman, and about such a beloved character.
Windows - Susan Palwick : 4 stars. A mother visits her son in prison to play him a clip sent by his sister who has been selected to be a passenger/crew/citizen of a generation ship. A story that focuses on the people left behind. Very real despite its Scifi setting.
The Thing About Shapes to Come - Adam-Troy Castro : 4 stars. What if humans stopped giving birth to baby shaped babies and gave birth instead to geometrical shapes, like spheres, or pyramids, or cubes. How do you love your child against all odds, not because it's your duty but because you genuinely honestly Just Do? A very strange but still beautiful and touching story.
We Are the Cloud - Sam J. Miller: 5 stars. Named by the author a "supervillain origin story", in a world that's ours, with a couple more gadgets and maybe a more prominent capacity for the oppression of the weak and different and unlucky. The most horrifying things mentioned in this are real, happening now, and as Miller says in the contributor's notes: In a world like that none of us come out clean. A must read, honestly.
The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever - Daniel H. Wilson : 3 stars Not one of my favorites. Still a beautiful story about the end of the world but not exactly my cup of tea. But then again I'm a fantasy girl, so I am probably being very unfair to it.
Skullpocket - Nathan Ballingrud : 4 stars. This didn't get my attention from the start but when it did, boy was it worth it. Probably the most classically horror story of the bunch -although all of the stories have an undertone of horror, probably understandable since they were chosen by Hill- it's got hints of Jerusalem's Lot and a slightly Lovecraftian feel.
I Can See Right Through You - Kelly Link : 5 stars. I have a hit and miss relationship with Kelly Link but this story was an absolute hit. The story of two former co-stars, lovers, friends, Maggie and Will, the Demon Lover. It's a story about the intimacy created by being loved by millions of people, and the loneliness that comes with it, and the weirdness, and the, yes, sometimes, horror of people's love.
The Empties - Jess Row : 5 stars. Narratives are static. Real life is kinetic. How do you write about the end of the world while you're living the end of the world? How do you reconcile years and years of watching the films, and reading the stories, and thinking you know how the story goes only to realize that the stories are really just stories, and have absolutely nothing to do with your reality?
The One They Took Before - Kelly Sandoval : 5 stars. You might have noticed by now that I, like a true millennial, am biased in favor of stories set in what is undoubtedly today. Not yesterday, or tomorrow, today. Add faeries to this and you've got a story of pain and longing and the need for autonomy and freedom that's as magical as anything.
The Relive Box - T C Boyle : 3 stars. Another victim of my Fantasy bias, this is a very interesting story that failed to captivate me that much. About a man and his daughter and their Relive Box, a machine that allows you to (you guessed it) relive points of your life. Addiction is unavoidable, and destructive.
How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps - A. Merc Rustad : 5 stars. A great end to a fantastic collection. The author says it's one of the most personal stories they've written and you can tell, you can definitely tell, reading it because it's almost raw in its honesty. I cried, a little, to be quite honest. And it wasn't just the mention of polyamory that made me cry. Nor the asexual character. Although they helped.
Read
November 15, 2020Stalled. Many of his picks aren't really to my taste. A good detailed review here, by Kathy Davie:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
She confesses that "I stopped after 13 stories. It was too depressing." I didn't get that far.
Here is a story from this anthology I strongly recommend, available online:
Jo Walton's "Sleeper", which I rated 5 stars: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
And another, "The Relive Box" by T. Coraghessan Boyle: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/20...
I recall liking this one, and should reread it. But my monthly quota there has been used up!
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
She confesses that "I stopped after 13 stories. It was too depressing." I didn't get that far.
Here is a story from this anthology I strongly recommend, available online:
Jo Walton's "Sleeper", which I rated 5 stars: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
And another, "The Relive Box" by T. Coraghessan Boyle: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/20...
I recall liking this one, and should reread it. But my monthly quota there has been used up!
November 27, 2015
a lot of good stories in this! my favorites were "We Are the Cloud" by Sam Miller, "The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever" by Daniel Wilson, and (especially!) this amazing story called "The Thing About Shapes to Come," by Adam-Troy Castro... which you can read over at Lightspeed Magazine, where it first appeared, if you like:
http://www.lightspeedmagazine.com/fic...
such a great story! wish i wrote it.
http://www.lightspeedmagazine.com/fic...
such a great story! wish i wrote it.
July 6, 2016
I've actually been working on reading this one since January, and you know, I loved about 90% of the stories in this. That's really saying something -- I tend to not be much of a fan of short stories -- but the story curation on this one was superb.
January 23, 2018
Because reading Best Of compilations two years later is how I roll.
November 1, 2017
An anthology of twenty short stories in the science fiction-fantasy genre. I gotta confess that I stopped after 13 stories. It was too depressing.
The foreword is interesting as Adams breaks down the history of science fiction/fantasy.
The Series
"How the Marquis Got His Coat Back" (London Below, The World of Neverwhere, 1.5)
The Stories
Sofia Samatar’s " How to Get Back to the Forest " was disgusting. A nutjob girl believes there’s some kind of bug that’s put in you and that it has to be puked up.
Carmen Maria Machado’s "Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" was definitely creative with a gruesome ending.
Cat Rambo’s "Tortoiseshell Cats are Not Refundable" is well written and so depressing about grief and wanting the deceased back in their lives.
Karen Russell’s "The Bad Graft" is truly a horror of a sci-fi tale with plant life wanting to spread itself around. It was a curious read in terms of how the Joshua tree seedling(?) felt about the whole thing, but lord, this was depressing.
Alaya Dawn Johnson’s "A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i" is very creative about vampires who won the war and how they preserve their food. Another depressing story.
Seanan McGuire’s "Each to Each" is yet another creative tale that may appeal to women’s libbers who want freedom. It’s a case of mutation into a different species underwater. Not as depressing as the others.
Sofia Samatar’s "Ogres of East Africa" is science fiction with a heavy dose of fantasy in this listing of the different kinds of ogres who live in East Africa. Their appearance, fears, powers, regions preferred, and more.
Theodora Goss’ "Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology" was interesting if a bit confusing. Some college students invent a country with its own history, culture, mores, religion, etc., and are then surprised to discover its reality. Goss parallels our own world with its national and international politicking.
Jo Walton’s "Sleeper" finds a woman writing a book about a dead man who comes back to a sort of life in which he provides a simulation for the book that is intended to raise questions about the class system and why the English no longer have what they had.
I don’t know if I was influenced by all the depressing stories I read previous to this, but I found this one depressing too and somewhat confusing.
Neil Gaiman’s "How the Marquis Got His Coat Back" gives us the inside look on how the marquis gets out of his fix and saves a Raven lady from someone else’s fixation.
It takes place during Neverwhere , 1, which should be read before this.
Susan Palwick’s "Windows" is another well-written story that is so depressing, as a mother scrapes up the funds to visit her ne’er-do-well son in prison to wish him a happy birthday. She even has a video greeting from his sister who was lucky enough to win a place on a gen-ship.
Adam-Troy Castro’s "The Thing About Shapes to Come" is just plain weird when a mother has a cube-shaped baby instead of a proper-ball-shaped one.
Sam J. Miller’s "We are the Cloud" is too true, as this is a world which pays poor people to let them put a wire in their brain so the rich can have free wireless everywhere. There’s more in here about poor Case, his mother, the exploitation of his body, although oddly enough, there is an, odd, ray of hope at the end.
There are seven more short stories, but I was so depressed by all this that I gave up.
The Cover and Title
The cover has a black background with an arc of phases of the moon in silver across the top with Saturn in the center. Thin, thin silver rays emanate out through a series of thin silver arcs from the second to last silver icon in the vertical line-up that separates each word of the title. It’s a colorful title: two words in a greenish gold, then fuchsia, red, and ending with bright colonial blue. The editor’s name is on the bottom left while the series editor’s name is on the bottom right.
So, The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy of 2015, huh? Depresses the *@#! outta me.
The foreword is interesting as Adams breaks down the history of science fiction/fantasy.
The Series
"How the Marquis Got His Coat Back" (London Below, The World of Neverwhere, 1.5)
The Stories
Sofia Samatar’s " How to Get Back to the Forest " was disgusting. A nutjob girl believes there’s some kind of bug that’s put in you and that it has to be puked up.
Carmen Maria Machado’s "Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" was definitely creative with a gruesome ending.
Cat Rambo’s "Tortoiseshell Cats are Not Refundable" is well written and so depressing about grief and wanting the deceased back in their lives.
Karen Russell’s "The Bad Graft" is truly a horror of a sci-fi tale with plant life wanting to spread itself around. It was a curious read in terms of how the Joshua tree seedling(?) felt about the whole thing, but lord, this was depressing.
Alaya Dawn Johnson’s "A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i" is very creative about vampires who won the war and how they preserve their food. Another depressing story.
Seanan McGuire’s "Each to Each" is yet another creative tale that may appeal to women’s libbers who want freedom. It’s a case of mutation into a different species underwater. Not as depressing as the others.
Sofia Samatar’s "Ogres of East Africa" is science fiction with a heavy dose of fantasy in this listing of the different kinds of ogres who live in East Africa. Their appearance, fears, powers, regions preferred, and more.
Theodora Goss’ "Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology" was interesting if a bit confusing. Some college students invent a country with its own history, culture, mores, religion, etc., and are then surprised to discover its reality. Goss parallels our own world with its national and international politicking.
Jo Walton’s "Sleeper" finds a woman writing a book about a dead man who comes back to a sort of life in which he provides a simulation for the book that is intended to raise questions about the class system and why the English no longer have what they had.
I don’t know if I was influenced by all the depressing stories I read previous to this, but I found this one depressing too and somewhat confusing.
Neil Gaiman’s "How the Marquis Got His Coat Back" gives us the inside look on how the marquis gets out of his fix and saves a Raven lady from someone else’s fixation.
It takes place during Neverwhere , 1, which should be read before this.
Susan Palwick’s "Windows" is another well-written story that is so depressing, as a mother scrapes up the funds to visit her ne’er-do-well son in prison to wish him a happy birthday. She even has a video greeting from his sister who was lucky enough to win a place on a gen-ship.
Adam-Troy Castro’s "The Thing About Shapes to Come" is just plain weird when a mother has a cube-shaped baby instead of a proper-ball-shaped one.
Sam J. Miller’s "We are the Cloud" is too true, as this is a world which pays poor people to let them put a wire in their brain so the rich can have free wireless everywhere. There’s more in here about poor Case, his mother, the exploitation of his body, although oddly enough, there is an, odd, ray of hope at the end.
There are seven more short stories, but I was so depressed by all this that I gave up.
The Cover and Title
The cover has a black background with an arc of phases of the moon in silver across the top with Saturn in the center. Thin, thin silver rays emanate out through a series of thin silver arcs from the second to last silver icon in the vertical line-up that separates each word of the title. It’s a colorful title: two words in a greenish gold, then fuchsia, red, and ending with bright colonial blue. The editor’s name is on the bottom left while the series editor’s name is on the bottom right.
So, The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy of 2015, huh? Depresses the *@#! outta me.
October 3, 2024
I started this book in September last year; I wanted to read an anthology and to start, more specifically, this series of short-story collections! I read this one first because it was available.
It's always a bit hard for me to get to this kind of collections because I always have a hard time with incipits; if it doesn't grip me, I don't want to go on reading and I tend to let the book drift apart from me and never pick it up again. But I really wanted one at the time, so it worked for a while, until I got to a story that I didn't feel attached to and put the book aside.
- "How to Get Back to the Forest", Sofia Samatar
With this one, I had a dystopian feeling from the start: the vocabulary used was unusual, the characters were all teenagers and there was the question of parent figures. I always feel uneasy with this kind of narrative.
It was palpable that catastrophe has happened: the new society was quite creepy with The first scene was already so awful to read, with the The ending, , was chilling: from the start, we're wondering
It was well-written, which made me want to read more from the author - I have several of her novels in my wish-list, such as A Stranger in Olondria .
- "Help Me Follow My Sister Into the Land of the Dead", Carmen Maria Machado
I really loved this story: it moved me and was one of my favorites! It was really good, but so terrible at the same time! It was also very cruel, in a way - but it might have made it more real.
I loved the format and the writing-style: it was original, different, and I never read a story told this way before. I put the anthology it came from in my wish-list - Help Fund my Robot Army!!! & Other Improbable Crowdfunding Projects .
I really want to read other books by the author; some are already on my lists, such as In the Dream House or Her Body and Other Parties: Stories .
- "Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable", Cat Rambo
This one, like the first, was a bit disturbing to me because of the subject matter: clonage. It made me think a bit of Flowers for Algernon :
The ending was
- "The Bad Graft", Karen Russell
More disturbing still, and longer than the first ones, this story was awful to me because, this time, it felt close to . Even if the plot was disturbing to me, I loved the narrator, the way the story was told.
The ending is
I really want to read more from this author, Vampires in the Lemon Grove: Stories or Swamplandia! .
- "A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i", Alaya Dawn Johnson
Vampires!! They are one of my favorite fantasy creatures so I was glad to get a story about them! This story deals with how the world would be if they had won the war against humans.
It was sometimes hard to read scenes with such descriptions of blood and violence; yes, I love vampires, but I have to be contradictory: I struggle with blood. There's also TW for .
I loved the way vampire thoughts are different from human's: .
The ending is quite
I'll read other books by the author, like The Library of Broken Worlds .
- "Each to Each", Seanan McGuire
And mermaiiiiiids! One of my favorite horror books is Into the Drowning Deep by Seanan McGuire too, under the name Mira Grant; so I was really excited to read this story!
I loved the premisses of men having to change themselves in order to survive, not in space, but in the deep sea!
I still love this author and the ending was really cool, but it made me want to read a whole novel about the plot and So I was a bit left hungry for more! I also want the sequel to Into the Drowning Deep more than before I read this story!!
- "Ogres of East Africa", Sofia Samatar
The format of this one is quite original. The reader gets the feeling of a revolution against people who despise and belittle others because they don't understand them and still think they do.
The ending was good:
It's still well-written as the author has two stories in this anthology - I loved that the editors explained how they chose what would be in the collection and that they were surprised that Sofia Samatar had two stories but still decided to include both because they considered she deserved it!
- "Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology", Theodora Goss
This was a strange plot as what happens isn't explained: I had a hard time wrapping my mind around the idea.
Despite that, it's still a good story, with an awful core to it with
I also really liked the format! Other books by the author are on my TBR and wish-list, like The Strange Case of the Alchemist's Daughter and Snow White Learns Witchcraft .
- "Sleeper", Jo Walton
Again, this one felt original, quite unique. I loved the way it was written and the ending, the way
I want to read other books by the author, such as Among Others or Farthing .
- "How the Marquis Got His Coat Back", Neil Gaiman
I had already read this story (twice, I think) so I skipped it this time!
- "Windows", Susan Palwick
This one was really moving. It was well-written and, let's be honest, desperately sad.
- "The Thing About Shapes to Come", Adam-Troy Castro
The premises of this one were quite strange: babies are born in shapes like cubes, spheres and so on. I was a bit put off by the idea because it was so strange but I went along anyway.
And I was quite surprised: it's a moving story about a mother loving her daughter, no matter what, and despite what others might say. It was beautiful and I loved the ending and the way the reader can interpret it.
There's probably another layer to the story that I didn't fully get, another interpretation to have, but I still enjoyed the story for what I got from it.
- "We Are the Cloud", Sam J. Miller
This is where I made a big pause because I didn't feel compelled to go on with the first page of this story. So I put the book aside and got back to it fairly recently to finally finish it.
And, I wasn't wrong about this story as I had a hard time with the sexual and porn aspect of it. I didn't like that, so I didn't really like the story, even if it was quite interesting, satire-wise, and a good social comment. It made me ill at ease and, even if it was the intention, it's still not what I like to read.
- "The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever", Daniel H. Wilson
This story was both good and moving, and quite unusual. I loved to see the "robot" dad What happens is still terrifying to imagine;
- "Skullpocket", Nathan Ballingrud
I wasn't expecting that at all: what the fuck?! The violence came so quickly and so suddenly it actually felt like a blow!
It was cleverly made though, but I think I didn't quite like it? It's intelligent with this twisted "religion" - I always like to see religions in science-fiction or Fantasy novels/stories - but I'm not sure what I feel for this story.
- "I Can See Right Through You", Kelly Link
I loved the "haunting" and the ending, but the rest was a bit meh. I got the disturbed timeline to explain the falling out, but I didn't like it as much as I could have. I'll still read other books by the author, such as Magic for Beginners or The Book of Love .
- "The Empties", Jess Row
I'm always anxious with post-apocalyptic stories, they're not my cup of tea. Here, it was quite well-written, disturbing as expected, but not hopeless as some are - except, maybe, for the ending.
- "The One They Took Before", Kelly Sandoval
I love the idea of fairies ; but I felt no real attachment to the story.
I also loved the idea of talking cats, of course!
- "The Relive Box", T.C. Boyle
What a great story, even if it's awful in its meaning!
With this technology, I'm sure it could happen IRL - and, in a way, it's already the case. It also deals with a dysfunctional father/daughter relationship.
The ending is awful, but maybe
- "How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps", A. Merc Rustand
The final story is a very good one too; I loved it!
It's a great reflection about depression and how society and family expectations enhance that, not helping at all; but it's also a great story about friendship and support, about hope and the fact that we have people around us who love us and we can go on thanks to them.
So, I loved this anthology and I'm eager to go on reading others in the series - all of them actually!
It's always a bit hard for me to get to this kind of collections because I always have a hard time with incipits; if it doesn't grip me, I don't want to go on reading and I tend to let the book drift apart from me and never pick it up again. But I really wanted one at the time, so it worked for a while, until I got to a story that I didn't feel attached to and put the book aside.
- "How to Get Back to the Forest", Sofia Samatar
With this one, I had a dystopian feeling from the start: the vocabulary used was unusual, the characters were all teenagers and there was the question of parent figures. I always feel uneasy with this kind of narrative.
It was palpable that catastrophe has happened: the new society was quite creepy with The first scene was already so awful to read, with the The ending, , was chilling: from the start, we're wondering
It was well-written, which made me want to read more from the author - I have several of her novels in my wish-list, such as A Stranger in Olondria .
- "Help Me Follow My Sister Into the Land of the Dead", Carmen Maria Machado
I really loved this story: it moved me and was one of my favorites! It was really good, but so terrible at the same time! It was also very cruel, in a way - but it might have made it more real.
I loved the format and the writing-style: it was original, different, and I never read a story told this way before. I put the anthology it came from in my wish-list - Help Fund my Robot Army!!! & Other Improbable Crowdfunding Projects .
I really want to read other books by the author; some are already on my lists, such as In the Dream House or Her Body and Other Parties: Stories .
- "Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable", Cat Rambo
This one, like the first, was a bit disturbing to me because of the subject matter: clonage. It made me think a bit of Flowers for Algernon :
The ending was
- "The Bad Graft", Karen Russell
More disturbing still, and longer than the first ones, this story was awful to me because, this time, it felt close to . Even if the plot was disturbing to me, I loved the narrator, the way the story was told.
The ending is
I really want to read more from this author, Vampires in the Lemon Grove: Stories or Swamplandia! .
- "A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i", Alaya Dawn Johnson
Vampires!! They are one of my favorite fantasy creatures so I was glad to get a story about them! This story deals with how the world would be if they had won the war against humans.
It was sometimes hard to read scenes with such descriptions of blood and violence; yes, I love vampires, but I have to be contradictory: I struggle with blood. There's also TW for .
I loved the way vampire thoughts are different from human's: .
The ending is quite
I'll read other books by the author, like The Library of Broken Worlds .
- "Each to Each", Seanan McGuire
And mermaiiiiiids! One of my favorite horror books is Into the Drowning Deep by Seanan McGuire too, under the name Mira Grant; so I was really excited to read this story!
I loved the premisses of men having to change themselves in order to survive, not in space, but in the deep sea!
I still love this author and the ending was really cool, but it made me want to read a whole novel about the plot and So I was a bit left hungry for more! I also want the sequel to Into the Drowning Deep more than before I read this story!!
- "Ogres of East Africa", Sofia Samatar
The format of this one is quite original. The reader gets the feeling of a revolution against people who despise and belittle others because they don't understand them and still think they do.
The ending was good:
It's still well-written as the author has two stories in this anthology - I loved that the editors explained how they chose what would be in the collection and that they were surprised that Sofia Samatar had two stories but still decided to include both because they considered she deserved it!
- "Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology", Theodora Goss
This was a strange plot as what happens isn't explained: I had a hard time wrapping my mind around the idea.
Despite that, it's still a good story, with an awful core to it with
I also really liked the format! Other books by the author are on my TBR and wish-list, like The Strange Case of the Alchemist's Daughter and Snow White Learns Witchcraft .
- "Sleeper", Jo Walton
Again, this one felt original, quite unique. I loved the way it was written and the ending, the way
I want to read other books by the author, such as Among Others or Farthing .
- "How the Marquis Got His Coat Back", Neil Gaiman
I had already read this story (twice, I think) so I skipped it this time!
- "Windows", Susan Palwick
This one was really moving. It was well-written and, let's be honest, desperately sad.
- "The Thing About Shapes to Come", Adam-Troy Castro
The premises of this one were quite strange: babies are born in shapes like cubes, spheres and so on. I was a bit put off by the idea because it was so strange but I went along anyway.
And I was quite surprised: it's a moving story about a mother loving her daughter, no matter what, and despite what others might say. It was beautiful and I loved the ending and the way the reader can interpret it.
There's probably another layer to the story that I didn't fully get, another interpretation to have, but I still enjoyed the story for what I got from it.
- "We Are the Cloud", Sam J. Miller
This is where I made a big pause because I didn't feel compelled to go on with the first page of this story. So I put the book aside and got back to it fairly recently to finally finish it.
And, I wasn't wrong about this story as I had a hard time with the sexual and porn aspect of it. I didn't like that, so I didn't really like the story, even if it was quite interesting, satire-wise, and a good social comment. It made me ill at ease and, even if it was the intention, it's still not what I like to read.
- "The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever", Daniel H. Wilson
This story was both good and moving, and quite unusual. I loved to see the "robot" dad What happens is still terrifying to imagine;
- "Skullpocket", Nathan Ballingrud
I wasn't expecting that at all: what the fuck?! The violence came so quickly and so suddenly it actually felt like a blow!
It was cleverly made though, but I think I didn't quite like it? It's intelligent with this twisted "religion" - I always like to see religions in science-fiction or Fantasy novels/stories - but I'm not sure what I feel for this story.
- "I Can See Right Through You", Kelly Link
I loved the "haunting" and the ending, but the rest was a bit meh. I got the disturbed timeline to explain the falling out, but I didn't like it as much as I could have. I'll still read other books by the author, such as Magic for Beginners or The Book of Love .
- "The Empties", Jess Row
I'm always anxious with post-apocalyptic stories, they're not my cup of tea. Here, it was quite well-written, disturbing as expected, but not hopeless as some are - except, maybe, for the ending.
- "The One They Took Before", Kelly Sandoval
I love the idea of fairies ; but I felt no real attachment to the story.
I also loved the idea of talking cats, of course!
- "The Relive Box", T.C. Boyle
What a great story, even if it's awful in its meaning!
With this technology, I'm sure it could happen IRL - and, in a way, it's already the case. It also deals with a dysfunctional father/daughter relationship.
The ending is awful, but maybe
- "How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps", A. Merc Rustand
The final story is a very good one too; I loved it!
It's a great reflection about depression and how society and family expectations enhance that, not helping at all; but it's also a great story about friendship and support, about hope and the fact that we have people around us who love us and we can go on thanks to them.
So, I loved this anthology and I'm eager to go on reading others in the series - all of them actually!
December 29, 2015
"I did not think Americans were capable of poetry."Oh, but they are—we are—and this volume, despite its minor flaws, helps prove that assertion.
—"Cimmeria," by Theodora Goss, p.109
The name of the book at hand is The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015. It's a bold claim, but I won't quibble about most of it. The word "Best" is okay, for example—every story in this volume is both emotionally resonant and technically adept, a plausible choice in that regard. Nor do I object to the criteria that editors Joe Hill and John Joseph Adams used to define either "science fiction" or "fantasy"—I'd agree with them that every story herein falls somewhere on the spectrum of speculative fiction.
No, it's the arbitrary use of the word "American" that I found most troublesome. While the term usually means "of the United States," and has also been used to mean "of the continents of North and South America," John Joseph Adams' Foreword explicitly states that he limited his choices to stories from the U.S. and Canada—an idiosyncratic division at best.
A more accurate name for this anthology would be, "The Best SF We Could Find from the Two Mostly Anglophone Countries of North America... 2015," although that probably wouldn't sell as well, and certainly wouldn't fit as well on the cover.
Once you get past the exclusion of Mexico and the rest of the Americas, though, what you'll find really is a remarkably original and diverse collection. These are stories which do things that simply can't be done (or can't be done nearly as well) with mimetic fiction, and collectively they bode well for the future of sf as a genre. As Joe Hill says, "Whatever your sexual orientation, whatever your ethnicity, whatever your age or personal experiences, it is my hope you will find a hero somewhere here you can relate to, that speaks to the world as you see it" (p.xx) (emphasis in original). It's a laudable goal, and one in which I believe Hill and Adams succeed.
This is apparent from the very first line of the first story, Sofia Samatar's "How to Get Back to the Forest," though it takes awhile to get the full impact of what she's saying:
"You have to puke it up," said Cee. You have to get down there and puke it up.{...}"The stories that follow are frequently just as raw, and often just as of the moment, like the crowdfunding tale "Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead," by Carmen Maria Machado, and the indictment of shallow thinking about cloning that appears in Cat Rambo's "Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable." They're stories that could not have been written until the 21st Century, although they are most certainly as solidly within the same tradition of "if this goes on..." as the great SF of the 1950s.
—p.1
What follows those are tales by Karen Russell, Alaya Dawn Johnson (whose name also crops up in Rich Horton's The Year's Best Science Fiction & Fantasy 2014), Seanan McGuire, another one by Sofia Samatar and the aforementioned Theodora Goss, as well as stories by favorite authors of mine like Jo Walton and Neil Gaiman. (I read the latter's story, "How the Marquis Got His Coat Back," for our family's annual Christmas story exchange, by the way—it's a pleasant and long-awaited return to the world of Neverwhere.)
And that's only half the book!
Don't skip the authors' biographies and story notes, either, which are always entertaining and often illuminating.
The bottom line here is that The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015 is pretty much exactly what it says on the tin—and highly recommended, whether you're interested in a survey of the field or as simple entertainment.
November 30, 2017
Pure Brilliance from John Joseph Adams and Joe Hill
I love anthologies - I love discovering new authors and tales that I never would have found otherwise.
This one, like the title suggests, is the best of the best - of the best. Adams acts as a friend who reads every New Yorker issue, and every prominent and semi-prominent SF/F magazine out there, and delivers the cream of the crop to you - the reader.
And this one has some cream.
I got this originally because I was looking for more Nathan Ballingrud, and his tale Skullpocket is featured.
But I stayed for the rest of the tales, which I will outline below:
* Jo Walton's Sleeper - this might be my favorite of this group - though again, there were so many others, I dislike playing favorites. But it took me by surprise, and shook me in all the right ways.
* Karen Russell's The Bad Graft - Think of a New Yorker SF/F tale that really gets to you - this is one of those.
* Sofia Samatar's Ogres of East Africa - As crazy as the title suggests.
* Nathan Ballingrud's Skullpocket - This is different than his normal fare. More H.P. Lovecraft and John Shirley than what you find in North American Lake Monsters: Stories. Though I came for his usual fare - I admire him trying to branch out.
* Alaya Dawn Johnson's A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i - Honestly, this might be the most disquieting of the group. Great premise, and in a positive way - I was happy when it ended, because it shook me so.
* T.C. Boyle's The Relive Box - I read this in his own collection, happy to see it here.
* A. Merc Rustad's How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps - Great way to end this. Accessible, unique - and really humorous.
In short - THANK YOU John Joseph Adams and Joe Hill - you guys made the party and invited all the right guests. The world is a little bit better because of you!
I love anthologies - I love discovering new authors and tales that I never would have found otherwise.
This one, like the title suggests, is the best of the best - of the best. Adams acts as a friend who reads every New Yorker issue, and every prominent and semi-prominent SF/F magazine out there, and delivers the cream of the crop to you - the reader.
And this one has some cream.
I got this originally because I was looking for more Nathan Ballingrud, and his tale Skullpocket is featured.
But I stayed for the rest of the tales, which I will outline below:
* Jo Walton's Sleeper - this might be my favorite of this group - though again, there were so many others, I dislike playing favorites. But it took me by surprise, and shook me in all the right ways.
* Karen Russell's The Bad Graft - Think of a New Yorker SF/F tale that really gets to you - this is one of those.
* Sofia Samatar's Ogres of East Africa - As crazy as the title suggests.
* Nathan Ballingrud's Skullpocket - This is different than his normal fare. More H.P. Lovecraft and John Shirley than what you find in North American Lake Monsters: Stories. Though I came for his usual fare - I admire him trying to branch out.
* Alaya Dawn Johnson's A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i - Honestly, this might be the most disquieting of the group. Great premise, and in a positive way - I was happy when it ended, because it shook me so.
* T.C. Boyle's The Relive Box - I read this in his own collection, happy to see it here.
* A. Merc Rustad's How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps - Great way to end this. Accessible, unique - and really humorous.
In short - THANK YOU John Joseph Adams and Joe Hill - you guys made the party and invited all the right guests. The world is a little bit better because of you!
May 12, 2020
I forget about short stories at times and thus reminded why I need to revisit them more and more.
For those who aren’t into fantasy or science fiction, I get it. But I challenge you, a short story of either of those genres are a perfect way to get into them if you’re not familiar with fantasy or science fiction.
At about 350 pages, and 19 stories…that’s about 18 pages per story. That is so palatable to give these a try. And they do really run the gamut.
In Carmen Maria Macahdo’s “Help Me Follow My Sister Into the Land of the Dead,” the main character Ursula funds a kickstarter and details why she needs funds to go the Land of the Dead to rescue her sister.
“In the Relive Box” by T.C. Boyle a father and daughter fight over who’s turn is it to use the Relive Box…it’s technology that ties into the brain and projects any point in your life to see. How much is too much though when you relive the past and you forget the present?
Daniel H. Wilson wrote “The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever.”
“The cafeteria where I work plays the news during lunch. The television is muted but I watch it anyway. My plastic fork is halfway to my mouth when I see the eyewitness video accompany the latest breaking news story. After that, I am not very aware of what is happening except that I am running.”
The narrator is a physicist thus he’s knowledgeable of stellar occurrences that happen in our universe. By looking at the TV for an instant he recognizes one of these occurrences, and he freaks the heck out! It’s a powerful story that’s beautiful and sad.
Highly recommend this book, thanks!
For those who aren’t into fantasy or science fiction, I get it. But I challenge you, a short story of either of those genres are a perfect way to get into them if you’re not familiar with fantasy or science fiction.
At about 350 pages, and 19 stories…that’s about 18 pages per story. That is so palatable to give these a try. And they do really run the gamut.
In Carmen Maria Macahdo’s “Help Me Follow My Sister Into the Land of the Dead,” the main character Ursula funds a kickstarter and details why she needs funds to go the Land of the Dead to rescue her sister.
“In the Relive Box” by T.C. Boyle a father and daughter fight over who’s turn is it to use the Relive Box…it’s technology that ties into the brain and projects any point in your life to see. How much is too much though when you relive the past and you forget the present?
Daniel H. Wilson wrote “The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever.”
“The cafeteria where I work plays the news during lunch. The television is muted but I watch it anyway. My plastic fork is halfway to my mouth when I see the eyewitness video accompany the latest breaking news story. After that, I am not very aware of what is happening except that I am running.”
The narrator is a physicist thus he’s knowledgeable of stellar occurrences that happen in our universe. By looking at the TV for an instant he recognizes one of these occurrences, and he freaks the heck out! It’s a powerful story that’s beautiful and sad.
Highly recommend this book, thanks!
January 16, 2017
This book was a bit of a disappointment to me, as a "best" collection. Everything was well-written, but many of the stories were too, shall I say literary?, for my taste. Meaning, a bit vague, disconnected emotionally, cerebral in a self-referential way, and without a clear resolution. Some rose above the others. I especially liked the stories by Cat Rambo, Jo Walton, Neil Gaiman (of course), Sam Miller, and A. Merc Rustad. Three and a half stars overall.
January 7, 2018
Highlights:
"How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps," A. Merc Rustad
"Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead," Carmen María Machado
"We Are the Cloud," Sam J. Miller
"The Bad Graft," Karen Russell
"How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps," A. Merc Rustad
"Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead," Carmen María Machado
"We Are the Cloud," Sam J. Miller
"The Bad Graft," Karen Russell
January 29, 2016
A very solid collection of stories, many of them female writers. I hope there are more ofbyhese collections going forward.
July 11, 2017
A book with several exceptional stories, such as "Windows"(my favorite), "The Thing About Shapes to Come", "The Blue Afternoon that Lasted Forever"(my other favorite), "Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" and "The Relive Box" (which seems almost suspiciously similar to one of my favorite Black Mirror episodes from 2011: "The Entire History of You.")
The collection is somewhat marred however by some fairly poor or just outright bad/ boring selections like Neil Gaiman's rather strange disaster that wouldn't have made it in if he wasn't Neil Gaiman, and Seanan McGuire's "Each to Each" (several other stories I couldn't even finish and others I wish I hadn't taken the time to) which was probably my least favorite of the collection, it's really a travesty in every respect, from the often amateurish writing to the over-the-top premise to the lackluster ending. There were, I'm sure, far more insightful feminist sci-fi stories written in 2015, but I guess Joe Hill decided it merited inclusion because 'y'know, there's like fish-women and stuff, dude!'
In the prologue, the author writes about how he read like 7000 short stories, made a long list of his favorites, then gave them to Joe Hill to come to this collection. How it is it that such a strange mixture of excellence and mediocrity are grouped together perplexes me.
I have to give this book three stars because even though there were some really great stories, about half of the book was boring, cringe-worthy, or both.
If you're going to get together two writers to assemble the very best of American Sci-Fi, choose William Gibson and uh... I dunno, the ghost of Phillip K. Dick maybe? Anyone as long as it's not Stephen King (gotta love mushrooms and fish-girls, fuck yeah!) Jr., please.
The collection is somewhat marred however by some fairly poor or just outright bad/ boring selections like Neil Gaiman's rather strange disaster that wouldn't have made it in if he wasn't Neil Gaiman, and Seanan McGuire's "Each to Each" (several other stories I couldn't even finish and others I wish I hadn't taken the time to) which was probably my least favorite of the collection, it's really a travesty in every respect, from the often amateurish writing to the over-the-top premise to the lackluster ending. There were, I'm sure, far more insightful feminist sci-fi stories written in 2015, but I guess Joe Hill decided it merited inclusion because 'y'know, there's like fish-women and stuff, dude!'
In the prologue, the author writes about how he read like 7000 short stories, made a long list of his favorites, then gave them to Joe Hill to come to this collection. How it is it that such a strange mixture of excellence and mediocrity are grouped together perplexes me.
I have to give this book three stars because even though there were some really great stories, about half of the book was boring, cringe-worthy, or both.
If you're going to get together two writers to assemble the very best of American Sci-Fi, choose William Gibson and uh... I dunno, the ghost of Phillip K. Dick maybe? Anyone as long as it's not Stephen King (gotta love mushrooms and fish-girls, fuck yeah!) Jr., please.
September 20, 2017
Not as good as I expected there were a few stories I enjoyed and some are very very strange, the stories that stand out are: Ogres of East Africa, Cimmeria: From the journal of Imaginary Anthropology, How the Marquis got his coat back, Skull Pocket, The Thing about Shapes to Come and the Empties.
June 1, 2020
A really great selection of stories, a lot of them really make you think. And so many fantastic authors!
May 9, 2023
All bangers.
May 9, 2017
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015
I was very excited to read this anthology as I am a huge fan of John Joseph Adams’ theme anthologies such as The Mad Scientist’s Guide to World Domination, Federations, and Help Fund My Robot Army!!! Unfortunately, I did not find this collection as enjoyable as his other work. While I found several of the selections to be outstanding I was disappointed in many others. Overall the twenty stories in the anthology averaged a bit over 3.5 on my personal five point scale.
By no means do I in this or any other review feel that I am passing judgment on the worthiness of a text. I can only offer my personal evaluation of whether I enjoyed the work. This collection was in places not SF enough for me, I can be forgiven I think for my personal preference leaning more towards the work of the Golden Age of SF than some of the new literary fiction showcased in this volume. Again, I do not judge the intrinsic value of these stories but express only my own preferences. Now to the stories!
How to Get Back to the Forest by Sofia Samatar
This story was originally published in Lightspeed Magazine and is well written and atmospheric and, well. . . not especially enjoyable. This is one of the stories where I am just not certain that the story is SF to me (obviously, series editor Adams and volume editor Joe Hill disagree with me). 2/5
Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead by Carmen Maria Machado
I had read this short before in Help Fund My Robot Army!!! and enjoyed it then as well. The story is structured around the updates common to crowd funding campaigns on sites like GoFundMe or Kickstarter along with a couple of e-mail messages. The story follows the efforts of Ursula who needs to retrieve her sister Olive from the “land of the dead.” Machado does an excellent job of capturing the tone of such a personal fund raising campaign and paces things perfectly. The twist at the end is especially well done. 4/5
Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable by Cat Rambo
This story was originally published in Clarkesworld Magazine and a sensitive look at cloning and the grief one feels after losing a loved one. Widower, Antony, briefly comes out of mourning to order a cloning kit from the television to clone his mother’s recently deceased cat. What follows, while perhaps easily guessed, is handled so deftly by Rambo that you eagerly follow the story to the end. 5/5
The Bad Graft by Karen Russell
In “The Bad Graft”, originally published in the New Yorker, two impulsive lovers hit the road to escape their lives with no intention of ever putting down roots again. Andy and Angie are both restless sorts and heaven to them seems to be the freedom to move from place to place with no permanent attachments. Subsequent events complicate their plans. 4/5
A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i by Alaya Dawn Johnson
This story is set in a post vampire takeover Hawaii where small numbers of humans are retained to serve as a food source for the vampire rulers. The tale centers around the relationship of one human, Key, and the vampire, Tetsuo, who she met on the day they invaded her home. 4/5
Each to Each by Seanan McGuire
“Each to Each” explores the introduction of all female submarine crews into the navy.Not only are the crews all female but they are modified over time through various surgeries and treartments to become literal mermaids. McGuire explores the psychological impacts of these treatments. 3/5
Ogres of East Africa by Sofia Samatar
This story is written in the form of a zoological or anthropological investigative log. The data is obtained from the testimony of a woman named Mary. She describes the different ogres that she knows about. Are they real? Is she crazy? I am not certain but there is little to no story in this story. 1/5
Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology by Theodora Goss
Can mere thought or ideas create reality? Can it create a physical reality that brings a new nation into being complete with a history, complicated sets of mores, and a living, breathing royal family? It appears that the answer is yes when a small group of American graduate students publish a series of articles in the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology. 4/5
Sleeper by Jo Walton
Biographer Essie has programmed a self-aware simulation of her deceased subject, Matthew Corley. Matthew was an influential BBC director with many secrets in his past. The simulation was built by inputting everything known about the subject into the system and allows for the biographer to interview the subject. There are strict rules about making these programs self-aware and Essie may have exceeded the limit in this case. 3/5
How the Marquis Got His Coat Back by Neil Gaiman
The Marquis de Carabas is on a quest. The quest is to recover his magnificent coat which was stolen from him while he was recently dead. The setting is a dark, magical, Victorian London underground full of strange and wonderful characters. 5/5
Windows by Susan Palwick
Windows tells the story of Vangie, a poor mother of two on her way to see her son in prison on his birthday. The story is quite short but powerful. Unfortunately, there is only one small SF’nal plot point in the story which could easily have been replaced with a mundane substitute and you would lose nothing from the tale. A good SF story should have SF elements that are essential to the story. 2/5
The Thing About Shapes to Come by Adam-Troy Castro
More absurdist fiction than SF, in this story babies have begun to be born in various geometric shapes. Why? No idea. The way that people react to these spherical, pyramidal, or cubic children is explored but to my mind this is neither fantasy or SF. 2/5
We Are the Cloud by Sam J. Miller
This story is about a couple of teen boys living in a shelter who sell a portion of their brains as cloud storage. This is an interesting concept though it is secondary to the emotional and sexual relationship between the boys. A little more time exploring the implications of the technology and a little less time at the porn studio would have improved this story. 2/5
The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever by Daniel H. Wilson
This story revolves around the relationship between a single, physicist father and his young daughter. His wife left due to his being too logical and mechanical – accusing him of not expressing his feelings. This is belied by the sweet bedtime ritual he has with his daughter and how desperately he tries to hold onto her in the face of a disaster. 3/5
Skullpocket by Nathan Ballingrud
“Skullpocket” is a well told story of a town that has come to accept an undead being into their midst. Jonathan Wormcake is a ghoul and after seventy years in the town he is dying. The story tells the tale of his life in the town. This is reminiscent of a Gaiman short story. 4/5
I Can See Right Through You by Kelly Link
An actor, the “demon lover”, seeks to reconnect with an old flame after years spent apart. They meet up and explore their past together with much of the story told in flashbacks from the demon lover’s perspective. The SF angle is tied up in the question of whether he is the demon lover due to his acting role as a vampire known by that name or if he is the entity who influenced a Ouija board in his lover’s childhood. 3/5
The Empties by Jess Row
“The Empties” is a moody, depressing vignette of a post-apocalyptic future. It is well imagined but feels more like a sketch of the setting for a good story than anything else. 2/5
The One They Took Before by Kelly Sandoval
A former abductee (abducted by aliens, demons, who knows) deals with being back home and the mixed emotions of being free yet knowing someone else was taken in her place and at the same time missing being there. The author sets the mood nicely but nothing ever happens. 2/5
The Relive Box by T. C. Boyle
The relive box is a device that allows the user to fully experience any of their previous memories. The story deals with the dangers of such an immersive technology and the risk that one might live completely in the past. The experiences of a single father and his daughter, both of which spend too much time in the box, is used to illustrate the risks. 4/5
How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps by A. Merc Rustad
Tesla has a dilemma. She is in love with a robot. Not a fully humanoid, android like robot but the espresso machine robot at the local coffee shop. How will she make it work? 4/5
I was very excited to read this anthology as I am a huge fan of John Joseph Adams’ theme anthologies such as The Mad Scientist’s Guide to World Domination, Federations, and Help Fund My Robot Army!!! Unfortunately, I did not find this collection as enjoyable as his other work. While I found several of the selections to be outstanding I was disappointed in many others. Overall the twenty stories in the anthology averaged a bit over 3.5 on my personal five point scale.
By no means do I in this or any other review feel that I am passing judgment on the worthiness of a text. I can only offer my personal evaluation of whether I enjoyed the work. This collection was in places not SF enough for me, I can be forgiven I think for my personal preference leaning more towards the work of the Golden Age of SF than some of the new literary fiction showcased in this volume. Again, I do not judge the intrinsic value of these stories but express only my own preferences. Now to the stories!
How to Get Back to the Forest by Sofia Samatar
This story was originally published in Lightspeed Magazine and is well written and atmospheric and, well. . . not especially enjoyable. This is one of the stories where I am just not certain that the story is SF to me (obviously, series editor Adams and volume editor Joe Hill disagree with me). 2/5
Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead by Carmen Maria Machado
I had read this short before in Help Fund My Robot Army!!! and enjoyed it then as well. The story is structured around the updates common to crowd funding campaigns on sites like GoFundMe or Kickstarter along with a couple of e-mail messages. The story follows the efforts of Ursula who needs to retrieve her sister Olive from the “land of the dead.” Machado does an excellent job of capturing the tone of such a personal fund raising campaign and paces things perfectly. The twist at the end is especially well done. 4/5
Tortoiseshell Cats Are Not Refundable by Cat Rambo
This story was originally published in Clarkesworld Magazine and a sensitive look at cloning and the grief one feels after losing a loved one. Widower, Antony, briefly comes out of mourning to order a cloning kit from the television to clone his mother’s recently deceased cat. What follows, while perhaps easily guessed, is handled so deftly by Rambo that you eagerly follow the story to the end. 5/5
The Bad Graft by Karen Russell
In “The Bad Graft”, originally published in the New Yorker, two impulsive lovers hit the road to escape their lives with no intention of ever putting down roots again. Andy and Angie are both restless sorts and heaven to them seems to be the freedom to move from place to place with no permanent attachments. Subsequent events complicate their plans. 4/5
A Guide to the Fruits of Hawai'i by Alaya Dawn Johnson
This story is set in a post vampire takeover Hawaii where small numbers of humans are retained to serve as a food source for the vampire rulers. The tale centers around the relationship of one human, Key, and the vampire, Tetsuo, who she met on the day they invaded her home. 4/5
Each to Each by Seanan McGuire
“Each to Each” explores the introduction of all female submarine crews into the navy.Not only are the crews all female but they are modified over time through various surgeries and treartments to become literal mermaids. McGuire explores the psychological impacts of these treatments. 3/5
Ogres of East Africa by Sofia Samatar
This story is written in the form of a zoological or anthropological investigative log. The data is obtained from the testimony of a woman named Mary. She describes the different ogres that she knows about. Are they real? Is she crazy? I am not certain but there is little to no story in this story. 1/5
Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology by Theodora Goss
Can mere thought or ideas create reality? Can it create a physical reality that brings a new nation into being complete with a history, complicated sets of mores, and a living, breathing royal family? It appears that the answer is yes when a small group of American graduate students publish a series of articles in the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology. 4/5
Sleeper by Jo Walton
Biographer Essie has programmed a self-aware simulation of her deceased subject, Matthew Corley. Matthew was an influential BBC director with many secrets in his past. The simulation was built by inputting everything known about the subject into the system and allows for the biographer to interview the subject. There are strict rules about making these programs self-aware and Essie may have exceeded the limit in this case. 3/5
How the Marquis Got His Coat Back by Neil Gaiman
The Marquis de Carabas is on a quest. The quest is to recover his magnificent coat which was stolen from him while he was recently dead. The setting is a dark, magical, Victorian London underground full of strange and wonderful characters. 5/5
Windows by Susan Palwick
Windows tells the story of Vangie, a poor mother of two on her way to see her son in prison on his birthday. The story is quite short but powerful. Unfortunately, there is only one small SF’nal plot point in the story which could easily have been replaced with a mundane substitute and you would lose nothing from the tale. A good SF story should have SF elements that are essential to the story. 2/5
The Thing About Shapes to Come by Adam-Troy Castro
More absurdist fiction than SF, in this story babies have begun to be born in various geometric shapes. Why? No idea. The way that people react to these spherical, pyramidal, or cubic children is explored but to my mind this is neither fantasy or SF. 2/5
We Are the Cloud by Sam J. Miller
This story is about a couple of teen boys living in a shelter who sell a portion of their brains as cloud storage. This is an interesting concept though it is secondary to the emotional and sexual relationship between the boys. A little more time exploring the implications of the technology and a little less time at the porn studio would have improved this story. 2/5
The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever by Daniel H. Wilson
This story revolves around the relationship between a single, physicist father and his young daughter. His wife left due to his being too logical and mechanical – accusing him of not expressing his feelings. This is belied by the sweet bedtime ritual he has with his daughter and how desperately he tries to hold onto her in the face of a disaster. 3/5
Skullpocket by Nathan Ballingrud
“Skullpocket” is a well told story of a town that has come to accept an undead being into their midst. Jonathan Wormcake is a ghoul and after seventy years in the town he is dying. The story tells the tale of his life in the town. This is reminiscent of a Gaiman short story. 4/5
I Can See Right Through You by Kelly Link
An actor, the “demon lover”, seeks to reconnect with an old flame after years spent apart. They meet up and explore their past together with much of the story told in flashbacks from the demon lover’s perspective. The SF angle is tied up in the question of whether he is the demon lover due to his acting role as a vampire known by that name or if he is the entity who influenced a Ouija board in his lover’s childhood. 3/5
The Empties by Jess Row
“The Empties” is a moody, depressing vignette of a post-apocalyptic future. It is well imagined but feels more like a sketch of the setting for a good story than anything else. 2/5
The One They Took Before by Kelly Sandoval
A former abductee (abducted by aliens, demons, who knows) deals with being back home and the mixed emotions of being free yet knowing someone else was taken in her place and at the same time missing being there. The author sets the mood nicely but nothing ever happens. 2/5
The Relive Box by T. C. Boyle
The relive box is a device that allows the user to fully experience any of their previous memories. The story deals with the dangers of such an immersive technology and the risk that one might live completely in the past. The experiences of a single father and his daughter, both of which spend too much time in the box, is used to illustrate the risks. 4/5
How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps by A. Merc Rustad
Tesla has a dilemma. She is in love with a robot. Not a fully humanoid, android like robot but the espresso machine robot at the local coffee shop. How will she make it work? 4/5
November 19, 2015
I was fortunate to be chosen by Houghton Miffin Harcourt to be the recipient of their 2015 Best American Series via an Instagram giveaway. To say that I am thrilled to receive the entire set of this series is an understatement; I’m over the moon ecstatic is more like it.
This highly regarded series is an annual compilation of the best fiction and non-fiction published in the previous year. The set includes:
The Best American Essays
The Best American Short Stories
The Best American Mystery Stories
The Best American Science and Nature Writing
The Best American Travel Writing
The Best American Sports Writing
The Best American Nonrequired Reading
The Best American Comics
The Best American Infographics
and for the first time this year, The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy
For this review I’m going to focus on The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy, the newest addition to this series. New York Times bestselling author Joe Hill serves as guest editor, and best-selling editor, publisher and producer John Joseph Adams is the series editor. The book starts off with a foreword from Hill and Adams where they give us an informative background on the science fiction/fantasy genre, and how reading such stories affected them personally. They also explained the painstaking process they went through in order to choose 10 science fiction and 10 fantasy stories from numerous sources.
The outcome is a diverse, imaginative and thought-provoking collection of stories that will stay with you long after you’ve finished reading it. Among my favorites are The Thing About Shapes to Come by Adam-Troy Castro and How to Become A Robot in 12 Easy Steps by A. Merc Rustad. The Thing About Shapes to Come gives us an intriguing look at a world where mothers are giving birth to geometric shapes. I know, how curiously-amazing is that? How To Become A Robot in 12 Easy Steps tells the story of Tesla who falls in love with a robot and longs to become one herself. Cleverly woven into the story are issues like depression and sexual orientation.
This anthology also includes Contributor’s Notes (from the authors of stories included in the book) and Other Notable Science Fiction and Fantasy Stories (60 stories that did not make it).
Personally, my exposure to science fiction/fantasy comes mostly from films, it’s only recently that I started reading books from this genre. I have to say the stories included in this anthology left me excited to explore more books from this genre.
Author Joe Hill expressed it best:
This highly regarded series is an annual compilation of the best fiction and non-fiction published in the previous year. The set includes:
The Best American Essays
The Best American Short Stories
The Best American Mystery Stories
The Best American Science and Nature Writing
The Best American Travel Writing
The Best American Sports Writing
The Best American Nonrequired Reading
The Best American Comics
The Best American Infographics
and for the first time this year, The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy
For this review I’m going to focus on The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy, the newest addition to this series. New York Times bestselling author Joe Hill serves as guest editor, and best-selling editor, publisher and producer John Joseph Adams is the series editor. The book starts off with a foreword from Hill and Adams where they give us an informative background on the science fiction/fantasy genre, and how reading such stories affected them personally. They also explained the painstaking process they went through in order to choose 10 science fiction and 10 fantasy stories from numerous sources.
The outcome is a diverse, imaginative and thought-provoking collection of stories that will stay with you long after you’ve finished reading it. Among my favorites are The Thing About Shapes to Come by Adam-Troy Castro and How to Become A Robot in 12 Easy Steps by A. Merc Rustad. The Thing About Shapes to Come gives us an intriguing look at a world where mothers are giving birth to geometric shapes. I know, how curiously-amazing is that? How To Become A Robot in 12 Easy Steps tells the story of Tesla who falls in love with a robot and longs to become one herself. Cleverly woven into the story are issues like depression and sexual orientation.
This anthology also includes Contributor’s Notes (from the authors of stories included in the book) and Other Notable Science Fiction and Fantasy Stories (60 stories that did not make it).
Personally, my exposure to science fiction/fantasy comes mostly from films, it’s only recently that I started reading books from this genre. I have to say the stories included in this anthology left me excited to explore more books from this genre.
Author Joe Hill expressed it best:
"This is the truth of science fiction and fantasy: it is the greatest fireworks show in literature, and your own imagination is a sky waiting to catch fire. And here is the truth of this book: we’ve got all the best, brightest, bangiest fireworks a person could want. The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy is not just a book but also an explosive device…..one that is, fortunately, entirely safe to bring on a plane.”
November 25, 2015
Unter den inzwischen unzähligen Jahresbest-Anthos an phantastischen Kurzgeschichten sticht diese hier insofern heraus, als dass sie Teil einer Publikationsfamilie ist, die sich an Nicht-Genreleser richtet und in den USA in literarischen Kreisen einen guten Ruf genießt. Dies ist der erste Band dieser Art nur mit SF & F und somit auch eine Art Genre-Leistungsschau für Nicht-Genreleser. So hat Herausgeber John Joseph Adams seine Aufgabe auch verstanden, tausende Geschichten gelesen und davon dann 80 ausgewählt und einem Gastherausgeber vorgelegt. Diesmal der preisgekrönte Horror-Bestsellerautor Joe Hill, Sohn von Stephen King. Hill dampfte den Stapel von 80 Geschichten auf 20 ein, schön säuberlich getrennt in 10xSF und 10xF. Das Resultat? Stark, könnte aber besser sein. Ein Genre-Fan kann sich denken, was man bei Joe Hill erwarten kann, Raumschiffe und Hard-SF machen sich rar und die Fantasy-Storys muten häufiger mal etwas seltsam an, was ja nicht schadet.
Hat ein solcher Anthologie-Ansatz mit dem Nicht-Genrepublikum Vorteile, liest sich das anders? Nur sehr begrenzt. Größter greifbarer Vorteil ist, dass einer der Highlights des Bandes, die apokalypstische Story "The Empties" von Jess Row von einem im Genre völlig unbekannten Autor (Stammgast im New Yorker, Tin House etc.) stammt, der hier in fremden Gewässern höchst erfolgreich fischt. Weiteres SF-Highlight ist die wunderschön-traurige "The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever" von Daniel H. Wilson um Kindereinschlafrituale, die unsanft von der Ankunft eines großen schwarzen Loches unterbrochen werden, sowie "Each to Each" um militärisch genutzte Kampf-Meerjungfrauen von Seanan McGuire. Stark natürlich auch die Stories von Joe Walton und T.C. Boyle, die ich schon an anderer Stelle gelesen hatte.
Da ich Fantasy-Kurzgeschichten nicht so mag, las ich den anderen Teil des Bandes nicht so gerne und fand auch für mich kaum was brauchbares. Fantasy in der Langstrecke immer gerne, Fantasy-KGs um Kobolde, Elfen und so, nein danke.
Die Geschichten von Alaya Dawn Johnson und Theodora Gross kannte ich schon und habe sie nicht noch mal gelesen (obwohl beide lesenswert sind!), ganz nett und gelungen war noch "Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" von Carmen Maria Machado, und überraschender Weise ein richtiger Stinker ist die Neil Gaiman-Geschichte, die ich auch schon kannte.
Insgesamt eine durchaus lesenswerte Jahresantho mit einigen starken Geschichten, aber sicherlich nicht die beste ihrer Art im Moment. Der Ansatz, damit Nicht-Genreleser ansprechen zu wollen, macht sich nicht so stark bemerkbar.
Ob Joe Hill für eine breite Auswahl (gerade, was SF angeht) wirklich der richtige Gast-Herausgeber war, darf man zumindest mal mit einem kleinen Fragezeichen versehen.
Hat ein solcher Anthologie-Ansatz mit dem Nicht-Genrepublikum Vorteile, liest sich das anders? Nur sehr begrenzt. Größter greifbarer Vorteil ist, dass einer der Highlights des Bandes, die apokalypstische Story "The Empties" von Jess Row von einem im Genre völlig unbekannten Autor (Stammgast im New Yorker, Tin House etc.) stammt, der hier in fremden Gewässern höchst erfolgreich fischt. Weiteres SF-Highlight ist die wunderschön-traurige "The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever" von Daniel H. Wilson um Kindereinschlafrituale, die unsanft von der Ankunft eines großen schwarzen Loches unterbrochen werden, sowie "Each to Each" um militärisch genutzte Kampf-Meerjungfrauen von Seanan McGuire. Stark natürlich auch die Stories von Joe Walton und T.C. Boyle, die ich schon an anderer Stelle gelesen hatte.
Da ich Fantasy-Kurzgeschichten nicht so mag, las ich den anderen Teil des Bandes nicht so gerne und fand auch für mich kaum was brauchbares. Fantasy in der Langstrecke immer gerne, Fantasy-KGs um Kobolde, Elfen und so, nein danke.
Die Geschichten von Alaya Dawn Johnson und Theodora Gross kannte ich schon und habe sie nicht noch mal gelesen (obwohl beide lesenswert sind!), ganz nett und gelungen war noch "Help Me Follow My Sister into the Land of the Dead" von Carmen Maria Machado, und überraschender Weise ein richtiger Stinker ist die Neil Gaiman-Geschichte, die ich auch schon kannte.
Insgesamt eine durchaus lesenswerte Jahresantho mit einigen starken Geschichten, aber sicherlich nicht die beste ihrer Art im Moment. Der Ansatz, damit Nicht-Genreleser ansprechen zu wollen, macht sich nicht so stark bemerkbar.
Ob Joe Hill für eine breite Auswahl (gerade, was SF angeht) wirklich der richtige Gast-Herausgeber war, darf man zumindest mal mit einem kleinen Fragezeichen versehen.
March 17, 2016
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy is a new comer to the "Best of" releases this year, and it was put together by one of my favourite editors, John Joseph Adams. The selections tend towards literary, but they were all quite exceptional.
A selection of my favourites included:
1. Each to Each by Seanan McGuire: An exploration in the changing identity and humanity of women turned into military mermaids. I reviewed this story separately on Goodreads, and it's a creative and contemplative piece on gender and technology.
2. Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology by Theodora Goss: A student participates in a project that creates a new civilization. It pops into existence and he finds himself experiencing the darker aspects of the cultural components he designed. This is such a strangely fantastical story that even the protagonist struggles to grapple with his reality.
3. Windows by Susan Palwick: A heart wrenching story about a mother who mourns one child in prison and one child on a generation colony ship and the cruelty of luck. Very light on the speculative aspects of story telling, but very good at characterization and emotion in a few short pages.
4. The Thing about Shapes to Come by Adam-Troy Castro: Women begin giving birth to children in the form of geometric shapes, and one mother refuses to abandon her cube daughter. Utterly haunting, strangely transfixing, and ultimately disquieting.
5. The Blue Afternoon that Lasted Forever by Daniel H Wilson: A single father and physicist holds his daughter as the world is ripped about by a micro black hole. Prepare for tears!
6. Skullpocket by Nathan Ballingrud: An odd and dark little story about a town where monsters and humans reside alongside one another, tied together with horrific traditions and a disturbing religion. Ballingrud was very successful at building up a coherent and complex world in such a tiny number of words.
7. The Relive Box by TC Boyle: In the near future, there's a machine that allows you to relive whatever parts of your life you wish. Humans, unsurprisingly, have a hard time dealing with this technology.
8. How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps by Merc Rustad: One of the most creative and affecting explorations of depression I've seen in the science fiction genre.
A selection of my favourites included:
1. Each to Each by Seanan McGuire: An exploration in the changing identity and humanity of women turned into military mermaids. I reviewed this story separately on Goodreads, and it's a creative and contemplative piece on gender and technology.
2. Cimmeria: From the Journal of Imaginary Anthropology by Theodora Goss: A student participates in a project that creates a new civilization. It pops into existence and he finds himself experiencing the darker aspects of the cultural components he designed. This is such a strangely fantastical story that even the protagonist struggles to grapple with his reality.
3. Windows by Susan Palwick: A heart wrenching story about a mother who mourns one child in prison and one child on a generation colony ship and the cruelty of luck. Very light on the speculative aspects of story telling, but very good at characterization and emotion in a few short pages.
4. The Thing about Shapes to Come by Adam-Troy Castro: Women begin giving birth to children in the form of geometric shapes, and one mother refuses to abandon her cube daughter. Utterly haunting, strangely transfixing, and ultimately disquieting.
5. The Blue Afternoon that Lasted Forever by Daniel H Wilson: A single father and physicist holds his daughter as the world is ripped about by a micro black hole. Prepare for tears!
6. Skullpocket by Nathan Ballingrud: An odd and dark little story about a town where monsters and humans reside alongside one another, tied together with horrific traditions and a disturbing religion. Ballingrud was very successful at building up a coherent and complex world in such a tiny number of words.
7. The Relive Box by TC Boyle: In the near future, there's a machine that allows you to relive whatever parts of your life you wish. Humans, unsurprisingly, have a hard time dealing with this technology.
8. How to Become a Robot in 12 Easy Steps by Merc Rustad: One of the most creative and affecting explorations of depression I've seen in the science fiction genre.
January 3, 2016
Oh boy! You know I love science fiction, and I'm a fan of Star Trek, and Isamov, and even Andy Weir (who wrote the Martian). And as an attempt to expand my science fiction literary horizons, I've been trying to get into some writers (old and new) to try and figure out what's out there.
Octavia's Brood got a lot of attention earlier this year for being a collection of speculative fiction short stories written by writers with a more leftist disposition. That book was a disappointment to say the least. So I turned to a more promising source, and what could be better than The Best American Series which has always impressed me with their comics?
So how does it measure up? Well, not exactly as engaging as I had hoped.
I had always wondered if maybe short stories are not the best way to write Science Fiction, but since Asimov has pulled off that format so well, it makes me wonder if he is actually an anomaly. The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy definitely takes a good (and interesting) stab at the art form, but again, I felt like I was left hanging for most of these stories. The good ones set the scene quickly and develop in interesting directions, but there simply is no chance to really get into the core of the stories and explore the ideas better. Highlights for me were definitely Neil Gaiman and How the Marquis Got His Coat Back about – you guessed it – some witty nobleman who is trying to get his awesome coat back, Daniel H Wilson's The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever about a family preparing for the end of the world, and Adam-Troy Castro's hilarious The Thing About Shapes to Come about a weird plague that makes it so that human can only give birth to shapes (cubes, balls, rhombuses, etc).
So yes, there are some highlights here, but there are just too few of them to really make this a stellar book.
Octavia's Brood got a lot of attention earlier this year for being a collection of speculative fiction short stories written by writers with a more leftist disposition. That book was a disappointment to say the least. So I turned to a more promising source, and what could be better than The Best American Series which has always impressed me with their comics?
So how does it measure up? Well, not exactly as engaging as I had hoped.
I had always wondered if maybe short stories are not the best way to write Science Fiction, but since Asimov has pulled off that format so well, it makes me wonder if he is actually an anomaly. The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy definitely takes a good (and interesting) stab at the art form, but again, I felt like I was left hanging for most of these stories. The good ones set the scene quickly and develop in interesting directions, but there simply is no chance to really get into the core of the stories and explore the ideas better. Highlights for me were definitely Neil Gaiman and How the Marquis Got His Coat Back about – you guessed it – some witty nobleman who is trying to get his awesome coat back, Daniel H Wilson's The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever about a family preparing for the end of the world, and Adam-Troy Castro's hilarious The Thing About Shapes to Come about a weird plague that makes it so that human can only give birth to shapes (cubes, balls, rhombuses, etc).
So yes, there are some highlights here, but there are just too few of them to really make this a stellar book.
Read
April 3, 2016Rather than review the individual stories, most of them excellent if you like some litfic in your SFF (as I do), a brief rant.
There were two or three stories, mostly toward the end, where I either finished them or got a few pages in and thought, "This isn't really even SF." What I meant, I realized, was that they lacked sensawunda. They had SFnal settings and themes, but my affective response was mundane. I felt the same way about Ex Machina, a pretty good three-hander neo-noir that, for me, didn't even attempt to capture the excitement or strangeness of AI emergence or its effect on humans (well, men really not humans, but that's it's own rant.) If I'd read those stories in Granta or the New Yorker I'd have probably responded more on the terms they intended. As it was, the stories around them delivered concentrated sensawunda as only short forms can, so the contrast was all the more marked.
A few, exemplary favorites: "Each to Each" by Seanan McGuire, "Cimmeria" by Theodora Goss, "The Thing about Shapes to Come" by Adam-Troy Castro, and the story that led me to pick up the volume, "Help Me Follow my Sister into the Land of the Dead" by Carmen Machado.
There were two or three stories, mostly toward the end, where I either finished them or got a few pages in and thought, "This isn't really even SF." What I meant, I realized, was that they lacked sensawunda. They had SFnal settings and themes, but my affective response was mundane. I felt the same way about Ex Machina, a pretty good three-hander neo-noir that, for me, didn't even attempt to capture the excitement or strangeness of AI emergence or its effect on humans (well, men really not humans, but that's it's own rant.) If I'd read those stories in Granta or the New Yorker I'd have probably responded more on the terms they intended. As it was, the stories around them delivered concentrated sensawunda as only short forms can, so the contrast was all the more marked.
A few, exemplary favorites: "Each to Each" by Seanan McGuire, "Cimmeria" by Theodora Goss, "The Thing about Shapes to Come" by Adam-Troy Castro, and the story that led me to pick up the volume, "Help Me Follow my Sister into the Land of the Dead" by Carmen Machado.
April 16, 2016
This is an extremely good collection. The generic title, franchise character of the series and totally unintenteresting blurb description, and John Joseph Adams questionable past editing history are totally misleading—this is one of the best collection of speculative fictions I've ever come across. It's largely women, feminists, often queer, and nearly every story is absolutely brilliant. Apparently 2015 was a marvelous year for speculative fiction, and the editor, Joe Hill, is worth following. Sam Miller, Kelly Link, Jo Walton, and Neil Gaiman are all familiar to me and superb writers. But others were equally remarkable and I haven't previously come across: Sofia Samatar, Karen Russell, Alaya Dawn Johnson and Susan Palwick. These people are extremely good. Notably, the stories work effectively both as speculative fiction—in the sense they have novel ideas about creative world premises—as as psychological realist fiction. Their characters are convincing and rich, with a level of depth we've only recently seen be common in SF. This is a great introduction to today's SF for the curious, and a solid read for die-hard fans.
February 17, 2016
This collection is less than the sum of its parts. It overwhelming contains, dark, humorless, solemn, earnest stories, and the uniformity of tone drags it down. Now, this is supposed to be the years best, and maybe the best stories are all almost "grimdark", but I doubt it. I think the editors have fallen into the trap that Robertson Davies warns of, where they think to be serious, a story must be solemn. But life is no more consistently grim than it is consistently happy.
As for the stories, aside from their solemnity, several of them also suffer from poor world building (you should not finish a story and immediately think "that makes no sense!"), or inconsistent characterization or a basic misunderstanding of how things actually work. There are some good stories here, but whatever the editors were looking for in these, it isn't what I look for in stories. I do not think I will be buying next year's.
As for the stories, aside from their solemnity, several of them also suffer from poor world building (you should not finish a story and immediately think "that makes no sense!"), or inconsistent characterization or a basic misunderstanding of how things actually work. There are some good stories here, but whatever the editors were looking for in these, it isn't what I look for in stories. I do not think I will be buying next year's.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 211 reviews