What do you think?
Rate this book
Win a free print copy of this book!
1 day and 08:58:20
20 copies available
U.S. only
The Hemlock Saga #1
The Hearth Witch's Guide to Magic & Murder
Win a free print copy of this book!
1 day and 08:58:20
20 copies available
U.S. only
"For all intents and purposes, we are still blissfully separated from the mortals, but there have been…complications."
When a rise in London's supernatural crime puts Fey society at risk of discovery, the Winter Council turns to an unlikely solution: Avery Hemlock, the changeling they sentenced to 500 Years of Nightmares. Inherently lacking social grace and missing approximately two centuries of world knowledge, Avery must find a way to acclimate and solve the case or lose her probationary freedom.
After being left at the altar and dropping out of medical school, Saga Trygg attempts to rekindle her faith in life, humanity, and witchcraft. But when her new neighbor, Avery, accidentally reveals the Fey that have been living among humanity all along, Saga realizes magic is far more than prayers, intention, and candles.
Each faced with navigating an unfamiliar world, the two form an unexpected partnership—but shortly into Avery's investigation, they discover the threat might be closer to Saga than either of them imagined, and Avery will do anything to protect the first friend she's had in more than two hundred years.
When a rise in London's supernatural crime puts Fey society at risk of discovery, the Winter Council turns to an unlikely solution: Avery Hemlock, the changeling they sentenced to 500 Years of Nightmares. Inherently lacking social grace and missing approximately two centuries of world knowledge, Avery must find a way to acclimate and solve the case or lose her probationary freedom.
After being left at the altar and dropping out of medical school, Saga Trygg attempts to rekindle her faith in life, humanity, and witchcraft. But when her new neighbor, Avery, accidentally reveals the Fey that have been living among humanity all along, Saga realizes magic is far more than prayers, intention, and candles.
Each faced with navigating an unfamiliar world, the two form an unexpected partnership—but shortly into Avery's investigation, they discover the threat might be closer to Saga than either of them imagined, and Avery will do anything to protect the first friend she's had in more than two hundred years.
448 pages, Paperback
First published October 7, 2025
250 people are currently reading
54460 people want to read
About the author
Kiri Callaghan
11 books358 followersBorn from ink and stardust, Kiri Callaghan enthusiastically prods and catalogues the world around her. She’s driven by questions: the why’s and what if’s of life. Her peers call her fickle, seemingly unable to focus on a singular field of study. She reads, cooks, crafts, and games. Submerged in some new thing, she explores unexplained supernatural phenomena or how to make a proper cake pop. Kiri is a writer, singer, actor, and adventurer. Above all, Kiri is curious.
Kiri Callaghan currently resides in Los Angeles, California.
Kiri Callaghan currently resides in Los Angeles, California.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 312 reviews
September 2, 2025
This novel was a perfect blend of cozy vibes, mixed in with dark mysterious vibes, fantasy and humor! It made me feel emotional and adventurous. This author did an amazing job at blending genres for this book! I was a little skeptical before reading it, but the author nailed it! This is a medium paced read, which includes immersive world building.
This book has a whimsical tone in it, which i absolutely loved. The characters were believable, memorable and included a diverse representation. The characters were lovable. The character Avery Hemlock’s humor had me laughing a lot, while reading this book! It is about a found family, friendships, hidden societies and had some folklore in it as well. I feel that this book is perfect for the Fall season time! Overall, I give this book a 4 out of 5 stars!
This book gave me the movie “Hocus Pocus” vibes! Content warnings include emotional trauma and supernatural crime.
Thank you to NetGalley, author Kiri Callaghan and Poisoned Pen Press for this eARC in exchange for my honest review and feedback. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
This book is expected to be published on October 7, 2025!
This book has a whimsical tone in it, which i absolutely loved. The characters were believable, memorable and included a diverse representation. The characters were lovable. The character Avery Hemlock’s humor had me laughing a lot, while reading this book! It is about a found family, friendships, hidden societies and had some folklore in it as well. I feel that this book is perfect for the Fall season time! Overall, I give this book a 4 out of 5 stars!
This book gave me the movie “Hocus Pocus” vibes! Content warnings include emotional trauma and supernatural crime.
Thank you to NetGalley, author Kiri Callaghan and Poisoned Pen Press for this eARC in exchange for my honest review and feedback. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
This book is expected to be published on October 7, 2025!
October 7, 2025
This is the first book in a new series called The Hemlock Saga and, having not read anything by this author before, I was very impressed.
We meet Avery Hemlock, a changeling, who has spent the last 200 years in a kind of magical prison. She meets Saga Trygge, a young woman who is totally unaware of her own links to the Fey until Avery tells her! The two of them have a delightful connection which is a joy to watch. There is a lot of fun to be had too, especially in Avery's total lack of knowledge about anything that has changed in the last 200 years.
The author's take on witchcraft and magic is perfect, the story was well planned and all the characters came alive. I loved it all and look forward to more.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
We meet Avery Hemlock, a changeling, who has spent the last 200 years in a kind of magical prison. She meets Saga Trygge, a young woman who is totally unaware of her own links to the Fey until Avery tells her! The two of them have a delightful connection which is a joy to watch. There is a lot of fun to be had too, especially in Avery's total lack of knowledge about anything that has changed in the last 200 years.
The author's take on witchcraft and magic is perfect, the story was well planned and all the characters came alive. I loved it all and look forward to more.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
December 27, 2025
The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic and Murder is a perfectly slow murder mystery that reveals in the journey, rather than the destination. It is filled with copious amounts of magic and folklore, and features the sweetest, slow to build, sapphic romance.
This is a book for readers who don’t mind a bit slower pace, who enjoy a richly built, diverse world, and really love the feeling of being transported INTO a book.
Admittedly, I am not usually a fan of a slower plot, I blame the ADHD on my impatience! This book is rich with depth and interesting folklore, in a way that kind of (but not fully) makes you forget its slow pace. It’s fun to be in this world and the mystery unravels piece by piece in the more unpredictable ways.
I really enjoyed the audiobook and think it’s the superior reading format for this book. It is a full cast and the footnote style is quirky and adds to the overall experience!
Whats to love…
- rich world
- a variety of folklore and magic
- sapphic longing
- murder mystery
- a bit emotional
- plenty of character depth
- emphasis on the journey not the destination
Whats not to love…
- the journey takes a while, this isn’t one for plot driven fans.
| IG | TikTok |
Thank you to the publisher for the gifted book. All opinions are my own.
This is a book for readers who don’t mind a bit slower pace, who enjoy a richly built, diverse world, and really love the feeling of being transported INTO a book.
Admittedly, I am not usually a fan of a slower plot, I blame the ADHD on my impatience! This book is rich with depth and interesting folklore, in a way that kind of (but not fully) makes you forget its slow pace. It’s fun to be in this world and the mystery unravels piece by piece in the more unpredictable ways.
I really enjoyed the audiobook and think it’s the superior reading format for this book. It is a full cast and the footnote style is quirky and adds to the overall experience!
Whats to love…
- rich world
- a variety of folklore and magic
- sapphic longing
- murder mystery
- a bit emotional
- plenty of character depth
- emphasis on the journey not the destination
Whats not to love…
- the journey takes a while, this isn’t one for plot driven fans.
| IG | TikTok |
Thank you to the publisher for the gifted book. All opinions are my own.
July 5, 2025
"The Hearth Witch's Guide to Magic and Murder" came into my life at exactly the right time.
I have just finished my read-through of all the Sherlock Holmes adventures, which meant I could really appreciate all the references that were woven into this adaptation. (This knowledge isn't a necessity. This story can be enjoyed without having read the classic first.)
I can't describe how much I adore Avery and Saga's dynamic, which is incredibly wholesome and fun to watch. Their communication was incredibly healthy, especially when their time struggles caused them to not immediately understand what the other person was talking about. This level of trust and respect was exactly what was needed to make them the well-working crime-solving duo they were.
The writing style was incredibly fun, and the footnotes taught me a lot of facts about both the fairy and the real world (did you know that a first version of the shower was first invented in 1767??? I certainly do now.)
The recipes in the back made this book all the more unique and really made me want to try my hand at making them myself.
All in all, this is the perfect cozy crime read for everyone who wants to immerse themselves in a universe both similar and fantastically different from ours. I can't wait for this book (and all of the following ones) to come out!
Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for providing me with this ARC in return for an honest review.
I have just finished my read-through of all the Sherlock Holmes adventures, which meant I could really appreciate all the references that were woven into this adaptation. (This knowledge isn't a necessity. This story can be enjoyed without having read the classic first.)
I can't describe how much I adore Avery and Saga's dynamic, which is incredibly wholesome and fun to watch. Their communication was incredibly healthy, especially when their time struggles caused them to not immediately understand what the other person was talking about. This level of trust and respect was exactly what was needed to make them the well-working crime-solving duo they were.
The writing style was incredibly fun, and the footnotes taught me a lot of facts about both the fairy and the real world (did you know that a first version of the shower was first invented in 1767??? I certainly do now.)
The recipes in the back made this book all the more unique and really made me want to try my hand at making them myself.
All in all, this is the perfect cozy crime read for everyone who wants to immerse themselves in a universe both similar and fantastically different from ours. I can't wait for this book (and all of the following ones) to come out!
Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for providing me with this ARC in return for an honest review.
July 28, 2025
I'd describe this as a cozy witch mystery.
Saga Trygg was just left at the alter, has dropped out of medical school and needs some serious changes in her life.
She decides to rekindle her interest in witchcraft, and this is the catalyst to many magical uncoverings.
When her new neighbor accidentally unleashes tons of hidden magical facts, Saga's interest in all things magical hits overdrive.
Together they have a little investigation going, and their partnership makes this book! I could absolutely see myself following these two on many magical investigations. It is also a perfect way for mystery lovers to transition into the magical/fantasy realm and still feel in their comfort zone.
Thank you to NetGalley & Poison Pen Press for a chance to read this prior to publication in October.
Saga Trygg was just left at the alter, has dropped out of medical school and needs some serious changes in her life.
She decides to rekindle her interest in witchcraft, and this is the catalyst to many magical uncoverings.
When her new neighbor accidentally unleashes tons of hidden magical facts, Saga's interest in all things magical hits overdrive.
Together they have a little investigation going, and their partnership makes this book! I could absolutely see myself following these two on many magical investigations. It is also a perfect way for mystery lovers to transition into the magical/fantasy realm and still feel in their comfort zone.
Thank you to NetGalley & Poison Pen Press for a chance to read this prior to publication in October.
September 28, 2025
Thanks to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for this advanced reader copy. I have to say that the book design and layout are really cute, which gives a cozy feeling. The cover is lovely as well. I like that the author included fun and interesting footnotes for some phrases and words. I laughed many times reading this book! However, the pacing wasn't for me. I got bored from time to time due to so much information being added that I didn't find to be useful for the plot. I really wanted to love the book because the beginning was fascinating and got my full attention :(
December 25, 2025
The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic & Murder by Kiri Callaghan is a cozy, urban fantasy mystery about Avery Hemlock, a centuries‑old changeling released early from a magical sentence to help solve a surge in supernatural crimes in London that threaten the hidden fae world, and Saga Trygg, a hearth witch rediscovering her faith in magic after heartbreak, who becomes Avery’s unexpected partner in sleuthing as murder, magic, and belonging collide in ways neither of them expected. It’s the first book in The Hemlock Saga and blends folklore, modern mystery, and heartfelt character growth into a richly imagined world.
What charmed me most about this story was how warm and alive the world feels: modern London pulsing with fae politics, hidden magic, and a sense of history meeting the present, and how Avery’s fish‑out‑of‑time perspective made everyday things like phones and slang feel delightfully fresh and humorous to me. Saga’s journey from someone trying to put the pieces of her life back together to a witch embracing her power and purpose gave real emotional weight to what could have been a light mystery alone, and watching their partnership grow from wary collaboration to true friendship (and the teasing possibility of something more) felt genuinely satisfying and human. There’s a cozy undercurrent of hearth magic, herbal lore, and the kind of domestic spells that make me want to curl up with a cup of tea while reading, alongside a clever mystery that kept me turning pages even when the investigation slowed for character moments.
Rating: 4 out of 5. I’m giving this heartfelt cozy fantasy such a high score because it made me feel both comforted and curious throughout, with characters I genuinely rooted for, a mystery that had me guessing, and an emotional core about belonging and trust that lingered with me long after I finished. If you love warm urban fantasy with whimsical magic, found family bonds, and delightful dual protagonists, this one will wrap you in its spell beautifully.
What charmed me most about this story was how warm and alive the world feels: modern London pulsing with fae politics, hidden magic, and a sense of history meeting the present, and how Avery’s fish‑out‑of‑time perspective made everyday things like phones and slang feel delightfully fresh and humorous to me. Saga’s journey from someone trying to put the pieces of her life back together to a witch embracing her power and purpose gave real emotional weight to what could have been a light mystery alone, and watching their partnership grow from wary collaboration to true friendship (and the teasing possibility of something more) felt genuinely satisfying and human. There’s a cozy undercurrent of hearth magic, herbal lore, and the kind of domestic spells that make me want to curl up with a cup of tea while reading, alongside a clever mystery that kept me turning pages even when the investigation slowed for character moments.
Rating: 4 out of 5. I’m giving this heartfelt cozy fantasy such a high score because it made me feel both comforted and curious throughout, with characters I genuinely rooted for, a mystery that had me guessing, and an emotional core about belonging and trust that lingered with me long after I finished. If you love warm urban fantasy with whimsical magic, found family bonds, and delightful dual protagonists, this one will wrap you in its spell beautifully.
September 13, 2025
1 star
I sincerely struggled to get through The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic and Murder and honestly wish I’d DNFed it. To quote the author, “Dwindling interest waned with every second, not able to perceive anything long enough to care about it.” That perfectly sums up my reading experience.
For a book with “murder” in the title, it’s shockingly dull. One big hurdle was the heavy use of uncommon words—many with Greek, Dutch, or Gaeilge roots—defined only at the end of each chapter. Instead of feeling immersive, it was like reading with a dictionary in hand, constantly pulled out of the story.
I also found some of the late-book character details distracting rather than enriching. For example, a character’s ex-fiancé’s gender transition isn’t mentioned until nearly the end, and another character’s bisexuality surfaces even later. Representation is absolutely welcome when it serves the narrative, but these revelations felt tacked on and unrelated to the central plot, which only slowed the pacing further.
Overall, despite an intriguing premise, the book’s meandering execution and stop-and-start flow made it a slog. I wanted witchy murder mystery magic; instead I got a dry vocabulary lesson with boring characters.
I sincerely struggled to get through The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic and Murder and honestly wish I’d DNFed it. To quote the author, “Dwindling interest waned with every second, not able to perceive anything long enough to care about it.” That perfectly sums up my reading experience.
For a book with “murder” in the title, it’s shockingly dull. One big hurdle was the heavy use of uncommon words—many with Greek, Dutch, or Gaeilge roots—defined only at the end of each chapter. Instead of feeling immersive, it was like reading with a dictionary in hand, constantly pulled out of the story.
I also found some of the late-book character details distracting rather than enriching. For example, a character’s ex-fiancé’s gender transition isn’t mentioned until nearly the end, and another character’s bisexuality surfaces even later. Representation is absolutely welcome when it serves the narrative, but these revelations felt tacked on and unrelated to the central plot, which only slowed the pacing further.
Overall, despite an intriguing premise, the book’s meandering execution and stop-and-start flow made it a slog. I wanted witchy murder mystery magic; instead I got a dry vocabulary lesson with boring characters.
October 16, 2025
Not really sure what to say about this one. I enjoyed the premise and it certainly had potential, but it was about 150 pages too long. Way too descriptive and just felt like it was dragging. Nonetheless, it was an interesting cozy fantasy/mystery!
October 8, 2025
A lightly Sapphic Sherlock Holmes-esque urban paranormal tale, set in solarpunk modern London? Why yes, yes I DO want to read that. And so I did, and I had a lovely time, and I think you may too!
Our protagonists are Avery Hemlock, a changeling recently released from a Fey prison after 200 years when her brother needs help ... and Saga Trygg, descendent of the Hudson family, who is working out what 'moving on with her life' might mean after being jilted at the alter and dropping out of medical school. They work together on a bewildering murder case, while learning more about the unexpected worlds each finds themself in -- the marvels of modern London for Avery, the wonders of the supernatural world for Saga.
This moved a little too slowly for me in places, but counterbalancing that were little footnotes throughout, which were interesting/amusing/enhancing. I would love more solarpunk vibes in my life, and this was that perfect kind of cosy mystery with a solid plot and consequences, but confidence all will be well. The book has a clear ending, but hopefully begins a series as the two Fight Crime together, and perhaps lean into a little romance (there's a minimal amount in this story.)
This review is based upon a complimentary advance reading copy provided by the publisher.
Our protagonists are Avery Hemlock, a changeling recently released from a Fey prison after 200 years when her brother needs help ... and Saga Trygg, descendent of the Hudson family, who is working out what 'moving on with her life' might mean after being jilted at the alter and dropping out of medical school. They work together on a bewildering murder case, while learning more about the unexpected worlds each finds themself in -- the marvels of modern London for Avery, the wonders of the supernatural world for Saga.
This moved a little too slowly for me in places, but counterbalancing that were little footnotes throughout, which were interesting/amusing/enhancing. I would love more solarpunk vibes in my life, and this was that perfect kind of cosy mystery with a solid plot and consequences, but confidence all will be well. The book has a clear ending, but hopefully begins a series as the two Fight Crime together, and perhaps lean into a little romance (there's a minimal amount in this story.)
This review is based upon a complimentary advance reading copy provided by the publisher.
October 1, 2025
This was a perfect cozy weather book and with some dark mysterious vibes too. This author put everything together well.
The characters were lovable! This is a great book for fall season and you’ll want to snuggle with it.
Looking forward to the saga!
The characters were lovable! This is a great book for fall season and you’ll want to snuggle with it.
Looking forward to the saga!
July 28, 2025
It's raining and you expect a cozy murder mystery set in fantasy world, then this is the book to be read!
When Avery is asked by the Winter Council to investigate a murder investigation in the mortal world which had the involvement of magic; she finds herself in modern day London. There she meets Saga Trygg, a woman who becomes her investigation partner.
The story was so thrilling from the beginning. There was suspense throughout and I loved the combo of Avery-Saga. It was interesting to read how they unravelled the mystery of the dead woman and her missing organ in place of magical herbs.
I had many speculations as to what happened but none of it was right. I loved how the ending was unpredictable for me.
I must say that the characters, plot, and ending were well-suited for my reading preference that I enjoyed it thoroughly.
When Avery is asked by the Winter Council to investigate a murder investigation in the mortal world which had the involvement of magic; she finds herself in modern day London. There she meets Saga Trygg, a woman who becomes her investigation partner.
The story was so thrilling from the beginning. There was suspense throughout and I loved the combo of Avery-Saga. It was interesting to read how they unravelled the mystery of the dead woman and her missing organ in place of magical herbs.
I had many speculations as to what happened but none of it was right. I loved how the ending was unpredictable for me.
I must say that the characters, plot, and ending were well-suited for my reading preference that I enjoyed it thoroughly.
September 14, 2025
Wrong review was uploaded for the wrong books. Please see correct review below.
I picked this up on NetGalley and honestly didn’t expect to love it as much as I did! It’s got that perfect balance of cosy vibes and fae mystery exactly what I reach for when I want a comfort read with just enough bite.
Trope
✅ Cozy fantasy mystery
✅ Found family
✅️ Reluctant partners
✅ Changeling & fae mythology
✅ Hearth witch (herb & kitchen magic)
✅ London + hidden fae realm
📖 Storyline
Avery Hemlock is a changeling who’s been locked away for centuries, until the Winter Council decides to release her on probation to solve a string of supernatural murders threatening to expose the fae world. Landing in modern London is already a shock, but being paired with Saga Trygg, a grounded hearth witch with her own baggage, makes things even more complicated. Together they have to hunt down whoever’s targeting the fae, while slowly learning how to trust each other. The plot mixes a clever investigation with faerie politics and warm, domestic witchcraft, it felt fresh but also like slipping into a world I already knew.
🎭 Characters
Avery completely stole the show for me. She’s prickly, sarcastic, and quietly vulnerable under all that edge. Saga is her perfect foil,calm, steady, and quietly badass. Their banter made me grin, and watching their partnership shift from wary to protective was so satisfying. The supporting cast added colour and intrigue, though a couple of fae council members blurred together a bit.
✒️ Writing/Pacing
The writing has such a cosy, lived-in feel, I could almost smell the herbs and candle smoke while reading. The magic details felt researched and real, which made the world easy to sink into. My only gripe is that the middle lagged slightly as the investigation paused for some character moments; lovely scenes, but I wanted the mystery to keep its edge.
🌏 Worldbuilding
I adored how the author wove together a London you recognise with an undercurrent of fae law and hearth-witch rituals. It felt warm, layered, and believable. I’d happily spend more time exploring that kitchen full of simmering pots and protective charms.
💭 Final Thoughts
This was such a fun surprise. It’s comforting without losing tension, the characters have heart, and the mystery is just dark enough to keep the stakes high. I’m definitely picking up the next in the series.
🖤 Who Would Love This
✨ Readers who enjoy cosy mysteries with an urban-fae twist
✨ Fans of found family and reluctant partnerships
✨ Anyone who loves practical, herb-and-hearth style magic
✨ People wanting a murder mystery without gore
✨ Slow-burn friendship-to-more vibes
I picked this up on NetGalley and honestly didn’t expect to love it as much as I did! It’s got that perfect balance of cosy vibes and fae mystery exactly what I reach for when I want a comfort read with just enough bite.
Trope
✅ Cozy fantasy mystery
✅ Found family
✅️ Reluctant partners
✅ Changeling & fae mythology
✅ Hearth witch (herb & kitchen magic)
✅ London + hidden fae realm
📖 Storyline
Avery Hemlock is a changeling who’s been locked away for centuries, until the Winter Council decides to release her on probation to solve a string of supernatural murders threatening to expose the fae world. Landing in modern London is already a shock, but being paired with Saga Trygg, a grounded hearth witch with her own baggage, makes things even more complicated. Together they have to hunt down whoever’s targeting the fae, while slowly learning how to trust each other. The plot mixes a clever investigation with faerie politics and warm, domestic witchcraft, it felt fresh but also like slipping into a world I already knew.
🎭 Characters
Avery completely stole the show for me. She’s prickly, sarcastic, and quietly vulnerable under all that edge. Saga is her perfect foil,calm, steady, and quietly badass. Their banter made me grin, and watching their partnership shift from wary to protective was so satisfying. The supporting cast added colour and intrigue, though a couple of fae council members blurred together a bit.
✒️ Writing/Pacing
The writing has such a cosy, lived-in feel, I could almost smell the herbs and candle smoke while reading. The magic details felt researched and real, which made the world easy to sink into. My only gripe is that the middle lagged slightly as the investigation paused for some character moments; lovely scenes, but I wanted the mystery to keep its edge.
🌏 Worldbuilding
I adored how the author wove together a London you recognise with an undercurrent of fae law and hearth-witch rituals. It felt warm, layered, and believable. I’d happily spend more time exploring that kitchen full of simmering pots and protective charms.
💭 Final Thoughts
This was such a fun surprise. It’s comforting without losing tension, the characters have heart, and the mystery is just dark enough to keep the stakes high. I’m definitely picking up the next in the series.
🖤 Who Would Love This
✨ Readers who enjoy cosy mysteries with an urban-fae twist
✨ Fans of found family and reluctant partnerships
✨ Anyone who loves practical, herb-and-hearth style magic
✨ People wanting a murder mystery without gore
✨ Slow-burn friendship-to-more vibes
October 5, 2025
A great cozy read for fall, a murder mystery wrapped in an urban fantasy with an unlikely duo investigating. The book was witty, charming and unique. With that said, I found the pacing somewhat challenging and there wasn’t a point that the story really hooked me.
Avery is a changeling that has been sentenced to 500 years of nightmares for a previous crime. She brought back early to help solve a murder. There was a lot of humor as she learned to navigate the modern world, but I think I wanted more from her character overall.
The pacing was the biggest struggle for me, it seemed slow and a bit slogging at times. Several pages of dialogue here and there that really didn’t add much to the central story line. The addition of footnotes was charming, but for the most part started to just get to be more of a slow distraction from the story than adding to it.
Overall the story itself is wonderful, it’s the pacing of the novel that was off putting to me. It wasn’t something that was I excited to continue reading every day.
I think those who enjoy cozy mysteries, don’t mind a slow burn and taking the long way to get to the meat of the story will enjoy this much more than I did. It’s a great story, with wit and charm.
Avery is a changeling that has been sentenced to 500 years of nightmares for a previous crime. She brought back early to help solve a murder. There was a lot of humor as she learned to navigate the modern world, but I think I wanted more from her character overall.
The pacing was the biggest struggle for me, it seemed slow and a bit slogging at times. Several pages of dialogue here and there that really didn’t add much to the central story line. The addition of footnotes was charming, but for the most part started to just get to be more of a slow distraction from the story than adding to it.
Overall the story itself is wonderful, it’s the pacing of the novel that was off putting to me. It wasn’t something that was I excited to continue reading every day.
I think those who enjoy cozy mysteries, don’t mind a slow burn and taking the long way to get to the meat of the story will enjoy this much more than I did. It’s a great story, with wit and charm.
July 13, 2025
i really liked this book. admittedly, i am a sucker for this cosy fantasy genre, but adding in that element of mystery really tied the knot for me.
firstly, i adore the london that this author has created, and i wish it was real (there is free public transport… i am jealous). it felt as if the magic in this book was alive through the spells, the ingredients and just the different types of fey introduced. i love seeing the interpretation of all these creatures and their survival in the human world in comparison to how humans perceive them in folklore.
talking of lore, i loved avery’s background and one critique of this book is that i wish there was more. i wanted to see more of gideon and the winter council! but maybe this is for a future book… who knows….
the relationship between avery and saga was quite interesting to me! i particularly liked how slow they were yet how fast they delved into eachothers live. i think it balanced itself out quite nicely in the end and their chemistry is definitely that new love, jump in and think later, yet i’m scared and the butterflies are fluttering vibe (if that makes sense!).
saga’s rich knowledge in medicine combined with witchcraft was truly a marriage made in heaven (ah marriage, maybe a best avoided topic) but i really enjoyed how she could relay both diagnosis and spell at the same time.
i love riddle.
one of my favourite aspects of this book is definitely the footnotes. they give the story a whole other personality, and i love how funny and silly the author is. i am now the owner of many fun facts! and don’t get me started on the recipes… that’s pure genius.
all in all, i really enjoyed this book and i think a physical version would have been a much better experience so i will definitely be purchasing in the fall!
thank you to netgalley and poisoned pen press for giving me with this ARC in return for an honest review (which this is, i swear!)
firstly, i adore the london that this author has created, and i wish it was real (there is free public transport… i am jealous). it felt as if the magic in this book was alive through the spells, the ingredients and just the different types of fey introduced. i love seeing the interpretation of all these creatures and their survival in the human world in comparison to how humans perceive them in folklore.
talking of lore, i loved avery’s background and one critique of this book is that i wish there was more. i wanted to see more of gideon and the winter council! but maybe this is for a future book… who knows….
the relationship between avery and saga was quite interesting to me! i particularly liked how slow they were yet how fast they delved into eachothers live. i think it balanced itself out quite nicely in the end and their chemistry is definitely that new love, jump in and think later, yet i’m scared and the butterflies are fluttering vibe (if that makes sense!).
saga’s rich knowledge in medicine combined with witchcraft was truly a marriage made in heaven (ah marriage, maybe a best avoided topic) but i really enjoyed how she could relay both diagnosis and spell at the same time.
i love riddle.
one of my favourite aspects of this book is definitely the footnotes. they give the story a whole other personality, and i love how funny and silly the author is. i am now the owner of many fun facts! and don’t get me started on the recipes… that’s pure genius.
all in all, i really enjoyed this book and i think a physical version would have been a much better experience so i will definitely be purchasing in the fall!
thank you to netgalley and poisoned pen press for giving me with this ARC in return for an honest review (which this is, i swear!)
August 15, 2025
Thank you NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for allowing me to read this advanced copy of the book. 4.5/5 rounded up for GR. This is a spoiler-free review:
I loved the characters that Kiri Callaghan developed for this world. A mix between our London and a realm of fae, dragons, Jinn, and many other creatures kept separate. Changeling Avery is a strong character who is independent and intelligent, but is dropped in a world 200 years in the future after being sentenced to 500 years of nightmares. She needs to learn to adapt to modern London as well as solve the first crime that will hopefully mark her partial freedom from prison. The method Avery uses to keep mental notes of the people she meets was interesting and allowed the reader to also get an overview of characters that this story doesn’t get to focus on, allowing me to keep them in mind but not be distracted from the plot. From learning modern technology and culture to adapting to the new world of crime, Avery is thrown in the deep end with almost no one to aid her. In comes Saga, who is a kind but lost character after being embarrassed and left at the altar by her ex-fiancé. A former med student trying to figure out who she is and is thrust into the world of the fae slowly due to misunderstandings.
The mystery is a little bit predictable if you read a lot of mysteries, but it was delivered well, and the writing allowed for a fun atmosphere overall while also going into the emotions and pain that arise along the way. The combination of magic and modern forensic science that is scattered about is a nice touch, allowing for the impossible to happen while also respecting how criminal investigations are actually carried out.
The footnotes throughout the story were fun and provided a lot of helpful information, like translations, while also being written with a tone akin to the characters we meet. I would have appreciated them being at the bottom of the pages they referenced rather than the end of the chapters, as it would have been more helpful with translating phrases to keep the flow of the story; however, I am unsure if this was just due to having an ARC copy rather than a final version of the book.
Overall, I would love to continue reading about what Avery, Saga, and their allies get up to in the future and see these interpersonal relationships develop. There are quite a few unanswered questions regarding characters' pasts and histories together, and I feel like this world has a lot more to explore.
I loved the characters that Kiri Callaghan developed for this world. A mix between our London and a realm of fae, dragons, Jinn, and many other creatures kept separate. Changeling Avery is a strong character who is independent and intelligent, but is dropped in a world 200 years in the future after being sentenced to 500 years of nightmares. She needs to learn to adapt to modern London as well as solve the first crime that will hopefully mark her partial freedom from prison. The method Avery uses to keep mental notes of the people she meets was interesting and allowed the reader to also get an overview of characters that this story doesn’t get to focus on, allowing me to keep them in mind but not be distracted from the plot. From learning modern technology and culture to adapting to the new world of crime, Avery is thrown in the deep end with almost no one to aid her. In comes Saga, who is a kind but lost character after being embarrassed and left at the altar by her ex-fiancé. A former med student trying to figure out who she is and is thrust into the world of the fae slowly due to misunderstandings.
The mystery is a little bit predictable if you read a lot of mysteries, but it was delivered well, and the writing allowed for a fun atmosphere overall while also going into the emotions and pain that arise along the way. The combination of magic and modern forensic science that is scattered about is a nice touch, allowing for the impossible to happen while also respecting how criminal investigations are actually carried out.
The footnotes throughout the story were fun and provided a lot of helpful information, like translations, while also being written with a tone akin to the characters we meet. I would have appreciated them being at the bottom of the pages they referenced rather than the end of the chapters, as it would have been more helpful with translating phrases to keep the flow of the story; however, I am unsure if this was just due to having an ARC copy rather than a final version of the book.
Overall, I would love to continue reading about what Avery, Saga, and their allies get up to in the future and see these interpersonal relationships develop. There are quite a few unanswered questions regarding characters' pasts and histories together, and I feel like this world has a lot more to explore.
August 10, 2025
It was such an interesting read, a little sad sometimes, but ultimately so heartwarming, to watch Avery adjust to the world and puzzle things out, or have Saga gently explain them to her. Avery is absolutely wonderful for Saga, helping her heal, rebuild, and bloom after being so harshly abandoned at the altar and losing herself.
I really enjoyed the universe and am so excited to (hopefully!) get more glimpses into these worlds. The magic was fascinating and fun, and I adored all the different magical beings. I would have loved even more interaction with the magical world, but maybe that’s still to come? Either way, I’m crossing my fingers we get to keep following Saga as she helps Avery navigate this updated world, all while solving mysteries and murders together.
It’s a fairly cozy read for a story with a crime at its heart, but the deeper I got, the faster I read - I just couldn’t work out who was behind it all! And I had to make sure nothing happened to my precious Saga and Avery.
Highly recommend for anyone who loves a good cozy fantasy/mystery crossover!
Thank you so much to Poisoned Pen Press, NetGalley, and Kiri Callaghan for letting me step into this wonderful world.
I really enjoyed the universe and am so excited to (hopefully!) get more glimpses into these worlds. The magic was fascinating and fun, and I adored all the different magical beings. I would have loved even more interaction with the magical world, but maybe that’s still to come? Either way, I’m crossing my fingers we get to keep following Saga as she helps Avery navigate this updated world, all while solving mysteries and murders together.
It’s a fairly cozy read for a story with a crime at its heart, but the deeper I got, the faster I read - I just couldn’t work out who was behind it all! And I had to make sure nothing happened to my precious Saga and Avery.
Highly recommend for anyone who loves a good cozy fantasy/mystery crossover!
Thank you so much to Poisoned Pen Press, NetGalley, and Kiri Callaghan for letting me step into this wonderful world.
April 10, 2025
4.25 🌟
This would be the perfect fall read!
I am loving the influx of fall reads lately and was so bummed I was unable to save this ARC for this fall. It was so fun to "watch" Avery come back after being locked up for 200 years and try to figure out how the world works. I loved the relationship between Saga and Avery. This will be a top read this fall!
This would be the perfect fall read!
I am loving the influx of fall reads lately and was so bummed I was unable to save this ARC for this fall. It was so fun to "watch" Avery come back after being locked up for 200 years and try to figure out how the world works. I loved the relationship between Saga and Avery. This will be a top read this fall!
October 14, 2025
The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic & Murder by Kiri Callaghan is the perfect read for fall. It’s a blend of murder mystery, romance, and fantasy, and it works beautifully. It’s at turns cozy, magical, and humorous, and I couldn’t put it down. Callaghan has done such a wonderful job of blending genres, tones, and vibes that you can’t help but be transported to the quirky and enchanting world she has created.
Set in a modern-day London where humans, fey, and various other mythical creatures abound, we follow Avery Hemlock. Avery is a brilliant fey investigator who has been asleep for 200 years, serving a magical prison sentence. She’s woken to solve paranormal murders plaguing the city. Avery is now thrust into a world vastly different than the one she remembers, and if she wants to remain free, she’ll have to figure out not only who the killer or killers are, but also how to navigate a world she doesn’t recognize anymore. Along the way, she meets Saga Trygg, a woman who comes from a long line of hearth witches and is struggling to get over a recent heartbreak. Avery winds up recruiting Saga as a helper on the investigation, and the story flows from there as we follow the two women throughout London as they try to unravel an increasingly twisty mystery where everyone is a suspect.
I found everything about this book a delight. The characters are wonderfully written, the world-building is exquisite, and the story is mysterious enough to keep you on your toes and turning pages late into the night. In fact, my only complaint is that I was so invested that I finished the book in 2 days, and now I want more. Thankfully, this is book one in a planned series, so hopefully we will be getting more of Avery and Saga in the future.
Thank you to NetGalley, Poisoned Pen Press, and Kiri Callaghan for the gifted eARC.
Set in a modern-day London where humans, fey, and various other mythical creatures abound, we follow Avery Hemlock. Avery is a brilliant fey investigator who has been asleep for 200 years, serving a magical prison sentence. She’s woken to solve paranormal murders plaguing the city. Avery is now thrust into a world vastly different than the one she remembers, and if she wants to remain free, she’ll have to figure out not only who the killer or killers are, but also how to navigate a world she doesn’t recognize anymore. Along the way, she meets Saga Trygg, a woman who comes from a long line of hearth witches and is struggling to get over a recent heartbreak. Avery winds up recruiting Saga as a helper on the investigation, and the story flows from there as we follow the two women throughout London as they try to unravel an increasingly twisty mystery where everyone is a suspect.
I found everything about this book a delight. The characters are wonderfully written, the world-building is exquisite, and the story is mysterious enough to keep you on your toes and turning pages late into the night. In fact, my only complaint is that I was so invested that I finished the book in 2 days, and now I want more. Thankfully, this is book one in a planned series, so hopefully we will be getting more of Avery and Saga in the future.
Thank you to NetGalley, Poisoned Pen Press, and Kiri Callaghan for the gifted eARC.
September 29, 2025
Avery has been woken up early from her 500 years of Nightmares to assist the Winter Council with a rise is supernatural crimes.
Avery must adjust to two centuries worth of changes in order to solve the case and work alongside her new neighbor, Saga.
Saga’s life has been upended, she was left at the alter and she quit medical school, oh and Avery accidentally told her that Fey have been living among mortals!
As each get use to their current situation and the investigation intensifies, an unexpected partnership forms between Avery and Saga.
It was fun to see these women work together and their knowledge compliment one another in this cozy, paranormal mystery.
I enjoyed the authors footnotes- I found some interesting facts, got a few chuckles, and learned some new phrases. The strange medical anomalies were fascinating and I love the added recipes!! This was perfect fall read to start off the “witchy” reading season!
Thank you to the author, Kiri Callaghan, Publisher Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book. I received an epub and am leaving my review voluntarily.
Avery must adjust to two centuries worth of changes in order to solve the case and work alongside her new neighbor, Saga.
Saga’s life has been upended, she was left at the alter and she quit medical school, oh and Avery accidentally told her that Fey have been living among mortals!
As each get use to their current situation and the investigation intensifies, an unexpected partnership forms between Avery and Saga.
It was fun to see these women work together and their knowledge compliment one another in this cozy, paranormal mystery.
I enjoyed the authors footnotes- I found some interesting facts, got a few chuckles, and learned some new phrases. The strange medical anomalies were fascinating and I love the added recipes!! This was perfect fall read to start off the “witchy” reading season!
Thank you to the author, Kiri Callaghan, Publisher Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book. I received an epub and am leaving my review voluntarily.
July 14, 2025
When supernatural crimes plague London, who better to call than the changeling prisoner who knows the best of both worlds - Fae and Mundane. Or at least she did. Avery Hemlock has served 200 years out of her 500 year sentence and has been released into modern day London to solve the case. Balancing investigating a crime with acclimating to all the changes of the modern day, will she be able to solve the case before she loses her probationary freedom?
To help her with the investigation, Avery accidentally recruits Saga, a magical baker and tea maker. But it’s not just her baked goods that are magical. Saga has always believed in witchcraft but never realised just how true it was. Armed with her first year of medical school knowledge and a whole lot of enthusiasm, the pair of them set out to find the truth.
This book merges together my two favourite genres - fantasy and mystery. Mix in a little bit of slow burn romance and that’s the recipe for success. Or should I say spell for success?
I adored the split perspectives for the book. Avery is such an interesting character, she’s been thrust into modern day London when her last experience of living was the 1800’s. As the reader, we get to explore her journey of discovery, not just in her solving the case, but also learning how to use a mobile phone amongst other more modern inventions. Saga provides us with the medical knowledge, which as any mystery lover knows, is an integral part of the plot.
I love how the author uses footnotes throughout the story to provide information on historical discoveries, translations and mythological contexts as well. The recipes at the end are an amazing touch and I can’t wait to start casting my own spells!
The fantasy elements are really interesting and well-explained. The mystery itself evolved, and wrapped up incredibly well.
There are several Easter eggs for fans of a certain male detective and his partner, but I’ll leave that up for you to discover.
I highly recommend this book to fans of fantasy and cozy mystery books. I will absolutely be ordering copies of this book for me and my family/friends!
Thank you NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
To help her with the investigation, Avery accidentally recruits Saga, a magical baker and tea maker. But it’s not just her baked goods that are magical. Saga has always believed in witchcraft but never realised just how true it was. Armed with her first year of medical school knowledge and a whole lot of enthusiasm, the pair of them set out to find the truth.
This book merges together my two favourite genres - fantasy and mystery. Mix in a little bit of slow burn romance and that’s the recipe for success. Or should I say spell for success?
I adored the split perspectives for the book. Avery is such an interesting character, she’s been thrust into modern day London when her last experience of living was the 1800’s. As the reader, we get to explore her journey of discovery, not just in her solving the case, but also learning how to use a mobile phone amongst other more modern inventions. Saga provides us with the medical knowledge, which as any mystery lover knows, is an integral part of the plot.
I love how the author uses footnotes throughout the story to provide information on historical discoveries, translations and mythological contexts as well. The recipes at the end are an amazing touch and I can’t wait to start casting my own spells!
The fantasy elements are really interesting and well-explained. The mystery itself evolved, and wrapped up incredibly well.
There are several Easter eggs for fans of a certain male detective and his partner, but I’ll leave that up for you to discover.
I highly recommend this book to fans of fantasy and cozy mystery books. I will absolutely be ordering copies of this book for me and my family/friends!
Thank you NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
July 18, 2025
This is my favorite read of the year so far! It's a cozy mystery/crime fantasy mashup set in modern-day London that's just a wee bit altered from our reality (free public transportation and solar panels for all...if only). I used to love fantasy but don't as much anymore, and if there are alternate realities and totally new mythos I'm not into that. This is not that: magic and witches (and fey and vampires) are real, but it's not a totally world-altering reality.
Regardless, there's some murders that need solving, and several unlikely people reluctantly team up to solve them. If you know what 221 Baker Street means and who the Hudsons are (and an Inspector Lahiri that seems an awful lot like an Inspector Lestrade), you'll love this even more! Our main characters are realistic and flawed, funny and sad, and the perfect foil to each other. The atmospheric writing is perfect for reading on an autumn day, the writing sometimes made me laugh and cry, and this book came into my life at just the right time.
Thanks to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen for the ARC.
Regardless, there's some murders that need solving, and several unlikely people reluctantly team up to solve them. If you know what 221 Baker Street means and who the Hudsons are (and an Inspector Lahiri that seems an awful lot like an Inspector Lestrade), you'll love this even more! Our main characters are realistic and flawed, funny and sad, and the perfect foil to each other. The atmospheric writing is perfect for reading on an autumn day, the writing sometimes made me laugh and cry, and this book came into my life at just the right time.
Thanks to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen for the ARC.
October 19, 2025
3.75
This turned out to be one of those reads that quietly sneaks up on you. It’s got this brilliant mix of warmth and weirdness, soft, witchy comfort tangled with murder, secrets and a sharp sense of humor. The characters are easy to root for, full of quirks & charm and the friendships feel genuine and tender.
Avery Hemlock’s humor had me cracking up more than once and I loved how the author built a world that feels both whimsical and slightly eerie. There’s so much personality in the writing, especially with those footnotes aaaaaa they’re witty and clever without feeling forced.
I’ll admit, the pacing wobbled in spots and sometimes slowed the flow but the overall atmosphere made up for it.
This turned out to be one of those reads that quietly sneaks up on you. It’s got this brilliant mix of warmth and weirdness, soft, witchy comfort tangled with murder, secrets and a sharp sense of humor. The characters are easy to root for, full of quirks & charm and the friendships feel genuine and tender.
Avery Hemlock’s humor had me cracking up more than once and I loved how the author built a world that feels both whimsical and slightly eerie. There’s so much personality in the writing, especially with those footnotes aaaaaa they’re witty and clever without feeling forced.
I’ll admit, the pacing wobbled in spots and sometimes slowed the flow but the overall atmosphere made up for it.
December 15, 2025
3.5/5 rounded up
Starts off a bit rocky but finds its feet fairly quickly, just occasionally the diction and sentence structure feels like a newer writer.
I think the murder mystery part of the book is pretty well done. It was interesting and magicy and the slow realization of the murderer was nice
Starts off a bit rocky but finds its feet fairly quickly, just occasionally the diction and sentence structure feels like a newer writer.
I think the murder mystery part of the book is pretty well done. It was interesting and magicy and the slow realization of the murderer was nice
October 22, 2025
3.5/5
A fairly entertaining Sherlock Holmes retelling.
I feel like there's a tiny bit of an identity crisis between being set in historic England or the modern day, and the supernaturals have a bit of an identity crisis since they mostly just present as humans with spicier backstories as opposed to truly being other; but overall it's a good time.
A fairly entertaining Sherlock Holmes retelling.
I feel like there's a tiny bit of an identity crisis between being set in historic England or the modern day, and the supernaturals have a bit of an identity crisis since they mostly just present as humans with spicier backstories as opposed to truly being other; but overall it's a good time.
December 25, 2025
I loved this book for the interesting & creative features that I have not seen before. Namely, the author’s note at the beginning & the footnotes throughout which gave great information about fey folklore. The footnotes were also quite funny at times letting the author’s sense of humor show through. I highly recommend this book because it truly demonstrates the definition of “hygge”, which is what the author was going for.
December 3, 2025
Reader, I did not even make it to chapter 2.
What do you mean, ‘the words roughly translated always meant the same’? a) that is in fact how translation works, thank you for explaining that to me, b) that phrasing is horrific. It should at least be ‘the same THING’. Perhaps ‘the words, roughly translated, always meant more or less the same thing:’, I don’t love that but it would be acceptable.
I’m not even gonna touch the fact that the thing rhymes, or the implication that it will also rhyme when translated.
Do you have any idea how many times I had to reread that before I understood that some kind of magic barrier was appearing when his hand drew near it? Abominable phrasing. ABOMINABLE. ‘as he made contact’ contact with WHAT?!
With a what?
‘impeding my movement’? ‘ACCLIMATE’? Maybe you’re trying to make this character sound formal because they’re hundreds of years old, but what you’ve done is make them sound like an alien who swallowed a thesaurus.
No.
Quick question, who opened the door?
Nuh uh, I’m done.
Like all magic, the chant came in many languages, both fey and mortal, but the words roughly translated always meant the same: Bless the wretched, the crimes they make, the world of weeping, and the tolls they take.
What do you mean, ‘the words roughly translated always meant the same’? a) that is in fact how translation works, thank you for explaining that to me, b) that phrasing is horrific. It should at least be ‘the same THING’. Perhaps ‘the words, roughly translated, always meant more or less the same thing:’, I don’t love that but it would be acceptable.
I’m not even gonna touch the fact that the thing rhymes, or the implication that it will also rhyme when translated.
Gideon’s brow furrowed, and he carefully removed the black leather glove from his left hand. Pale fingers splayed and reached forward, iridescent strings of magic lighting up briefly as he made contact before vanishing from sight again.
Do you have any idea how many times I had to reread that before I understood that some kind of magic barrier was appearing when his hand drew near it? Abominable phrasing. ABOMINABLE. ‘as he made contact’ contact with WHAT?!
He stepped over the fast-decaying remnants of the spell and approached the pedestal with a clinical disposition.
With a what?
“We’re on a bit of a tight schedule, I can’t abide dawdling.”
“I have two centuries’ worth of pins and needles impeding my movement,” Avery spat, but it did nothing to slow the Archfey’s pace. “Perhaps your secretary can arrange something, so my legs might have a precious second to acclimate?”
‘impeding my movement’? ‘ACCLIMATE’? Maybe you’re trying to make this character sound formal because they’re hundreds of years old, but what you’ve done is make them sound like an alien who swallowed a thesaurus.
The downpour startled her into stillness.
No.
He walked down the steps to the vehicle where his driver was already waiting, opening the door as the Archey approached.
Quick question, who opened the door?
Nuh uh, I’m done.
November 20, 2025
3.5
didn't know this was going to be a Sherlock Holmes retelling haha
this was very cute and i liked the world and the characters, though i do feel like it could have gone deeper into some things.
the footnotes added absolutely nothing and just messed with the pacing, 95% of the time the same information was mentioned in the narrative on the next page, and the rest of the time it was just translation. it also begs the question of the author, so maybe it could have been cute as another modernisation of Watson's writing, but that makes no sense with the structure of the book and Saga as a character, so I think it would have been better without.
really liked Saga and Avery as characters and their developing relationship, though!
didn't know this was going to be a Sherlock Holmes retelling haha
this was very cute and i liked the world and the characters, though i do feel like it could have gone deeper into some things.
the footnotes added absolutely nothing and just messed with the pacing, 95% of the time the same information was mentioned in the narrative on the next page, and the rest of the time it was just translation. it also begs the question of the author, so maybe it could have been cute as another modernisation of Watson's writing, but that makes no sense with the structure of the book and Saga as a character, so I think it would have been better without.
really liked Saga and Avery as characters and their developing relationship, though!
October 4, 2025
This was delightful. I feel like if you asked someone to compile a book with some of my favorite things, they couldn't have done better--clever, funny, full of nerdy word trivia and so much folklore my Google history is overwhelmed. And to top it off a mystery that I did not manage to solve until the reveal was literally crashing down around me. Of course I loved this!
In The Hearth Witch's Guide to Magic and Murder we first meet Avery, a half-fey changeling who's on probation of sorts from the magical council. They need her keen mind to solve a magical mystery. Avery quickly teams up with Saga, her equally brilliant neighbor, and the two set off around London to solve the case.
I loved how very full of folklore this was. Avery and Saga meet magical characters from a myriad of mythologies--Irish, Finnish, Germanic, Middle Eastern. I was impressed with her colorful representation and delighted in looking up artistic renderings.
I also loved the tone and feel of this book. It's cozy fantasy, so while Avery and Saga are chasing a killer, they're also eating lemon tarts and drinking healing cups of tea. Characters are treated with kindness and care (especially the cat), and it was obvious that the author had great affection for her characters and their world because it reads with love and amusement. This book is perfect for curling up with your own cup of tea and cozy blanket and settling in, which is exactly what I did.
And it has footnotes. Sometimes when I see a fiction book has footnotes I groan a little, but these were a delight! Sometimes it was a brief description or explanation of a folkloric character, but others it was to translate a foreign term of endearment (or an Irish curse word). And my personal favorites were a little snarky and full of a dry humor that made me sure the author and I would be friends.
This book ends with the promise of more to come and I genuinely cannot wait for more.
*Thank you Netgalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted copy of the book. The opinions expressed are entirely my own 🩷
In The Hearth Witch's Guide to Magic and Murder we first meet Avery, a half-fey changeling who's on probation of sorts from the magical council. They need her keen mind to solve a magical mystery. Avery quickly teams up with Saga, her equally brilliant neighbor, and the two set off around London to solve the case.
I loved how very full of folklore this was. Avery and Saga meet magical characters from a myriad of mythologies--Irish, Finnish, Germanic, Middle Eastern. I was impressed with her colorful representation and delighted in looking up artistic renderings.
I also loved the tone and feel of this book. It's cozy fantasy, so while Avery and Saga are chasing a killer, they're also eating lemon tarts and drinking healing cups of tea. Characters are treated with kindness and care (especially the cat), and it was obvious that the author had great affection for her characters and their world because it reads with love and amusement. This book is perfect for curling up with your own cup of tea and cozy blanket and settling in, which is exactly what I did.
And it has footnotes. Sometimes when I see a fiction book has footnotes I groan a little, but these were a delight! Sometimes it was a brief description or explanation of a folkloric character, but others it was to translate a foreign term of endearment (or an Irish curse word). And my personal favorites were a little snarky and full of a dry humor that made me sure the author and I would be friends.
This book ends with the promise of more to come and I genuinely cannot wait for more.
*Thank you Netgalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the gifted copy of the book. The opinions expressed are entirely my own 🩷
July 24, 2025
Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and Sourcebooks for the eARC of this book!
This book is an interesting mix of crime thriller, light romance, a few laughs, a lot of magic and folklore, and added bits of science and medicine and history, all mixed into an alternative London setting. I almost want to describe it as a cozy mystery - except for some of the grisly deaths that occur. Overall, the vibes are very reminiscent of the Rivers of London series by Ben Aaronovitch, which I've very much enjoyed. I loved the bits of historical context and medical details (and even fictional storylines merged into a real world setting) that are mixed in, helping the story bridge the gap between the past and the present day, much like Avery has to do when she is awakened in a London that she no longer recognizes, 200 years into her future. And this book has footnotes! Which I really love when they are done right, in this case its to add more context to the story without the plot itself going on a tangent, or has funny little quips and extra bits of banter. This book is LGBTQIA+ friendly, as it is clearly a sapphic romance along with many side characters with a wide range of preferences and genders.
I will admit the book was a little difficult to get into at first, because the writing is very quintessentially British whereas I am very much an American reader, so there were times that I was struggling over the sentence structure or with some of the terminology (though much of the magical terms and history are explained really nicely in the footnotes). But once I got past the first few chapters, I absolutely felt myself getting sucked into the story.
I really enjoyed Avery and Saga, both as individual characters as well as partners in solving crime. Their meet cute and subsequent banter were adorable, and match the almost YA-romance vibes that this book has in the initial stages of what appears to ultimately be an ultra-slow-burn romance in later books. The initial chapters focus on building out the backstories for each main character, and then once you have a better understanding of them, really starts to dig into the mystery at the heart of this story. They definitely are a well-suited pair for one another, and I can't wait to see how their relationship continues to grow in the next book of this series.
The mystery itself is really quite interesting and unusual, I haven't read any similar sort of plots though I'm sure they do exist since much of the fantasy in this book is based on actual folklore (though it might be tweaked a bit to suit the story, as is noted in the beginning). The plot keeps you on your toes as the two MCs cycle through the cast of characters as potential suspects and work on inspecting their possible motives. The mystery keeps evolving throughout the story with each new clue that is discovered or plot twist that unfolds, leaving the reader guessing until close to the end of the book what really happened and who is behind the strange happenings.
Ultimately I really enjoyed this book, and will be picking up the next in the series once it's released.
This book is an interesting mix of crime thriller, light romance, a few laughs, a lot of magic and folklore, and added bits of science and medicine and history, all mixed into an alternative London setting. I almost want to describe it as a cozy mystery - except for some of the grisly deaths that occur. Overall, the vibes are very reminiscent of the Rivers of London series by Ben Aaronovitch, which I've very much enjoyed. I loved the bits of historical context and medical details (and even fictional storylines merged into a real world setting) that are mixed in, helping the story bridge the gap between the past and the present day, much like Avery has to do when she is awakened in a London that she no longer recognizes, 200 years into her future. And this book has footnotes! Which I really love when they are done right, in this case its to add more context to the story without the plot itself going on a tangent, or has funny little quips and extra bits of banter. This book is LGBTQIA+ friendly, as it is clearly a sapphic romance along with many side characters with a wide range of preferences and genders.
I will admit the book was a little difficult to get into at first, because the writing is very quintessentially British whereas I am very much an American reader, so there were times that I was struggling over the sentence structure or with some of the terminology (though much of the magical terms and history are explained really nicely in the footnotes). But once I got past the first few chapters, I absolutely felt myself getting sucked into the story.
I really enjoyed Avery and Saga, both as individual characters as well as partners in solving crime. Their meet cute and subsequent banter were adorable, and match the almost YA-romance vibes that this book has in the initial stages of what appears to ultimately be an ultra-slow-burn romance in later books. The initial chapters focus on building out the backstories for each main character, and then once you have a better understanding of them, really starts to dig into the mystery at the heart of this story. They definitely are a well-suited pair for one another, and I can't wait to see how their relationship continues to grow in the next book of this series.
The mystery itself is really quite interesting and unusual, I haven't read any similar sort of plots though I'm sure they do exist since much of the fantasy in this book is based on actual folklore (though it might be tweaked a bit to suit the story, as is noted in the beginning). The plot keeps you on your toes as the two MCs cycle through the cast of characters as potential suspects and work on inspecting their possible motives. The mystery keeps evolving throughout the story with each new clue that is discovered or plot twist that unfolds, leaving the reader guessing until close to the end of the book what really happened and who is behind the strange happenings.
Ultimately I really enjoyed this book, and will be picking up the next in the series once it's released.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 312 reviews