Dark Things : A Why-Choose Mafia Duet

by Angela Agnello

Revenge Consumes. Betrayal Burns.

In a world where shadows lurk and murder is the currency of survival, Rebelle Vischer thrives in the darkness. Someone who fades into obscurity until she’s released from her prison. Being a mercenary was never a life goal, but after being betrayed by the three guys who meant the world to her, she has no choice.

Trapped in a world so different from her past, Rebelle is assigned to take out Mario Russo, the head of the Russo Crime Family. But the mission takes an unexpected turn when fate throws her back to the three men who shattered her past and left her to suffer for their crimes. With only her partner and soulmate, Haunt Graves, by her side, she navigates through the mess of her past, colliding with her torturous present.

As she immerses herself in the mission, old wounds resurface, and the lines between loyalty and betrayal blur. With each encounter, the ghosts of their shared past threaten to unravel her carefully erected walls of wrath and rage, igniting a spark of unexpected yearning while placing her mission in jeopardy. Colter, Brooks, and Stafford walk around free and Rebelle intends for them to feel the same pain she has for the last five years. She just doesn’t know how far she’s willing to go.

Dark Things is book one of a why-choose mafia romance duet. The characters are morally gray and give zero f*cks about societal rules. Check triggers before reading.

If you love these tropes, Dark Things is a

Dark Mafia WorldAlphaholesSecond ChanceHidden IdentityFound FamilyUnderestimated FMCPolyamoryAssassins/MercenarySoulmates/Twin Flames

Genres: Contemporary

340 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 31, 2025

Reviews

[SJ · Rating 5 out of 5]

Book 1 of Payback Duet

Revenge Consumes. Betrayal Burns.

WOW, this why-choose mafia romance blew me away. It digs deep into emotions and difficult topics that are not easy to face with no apology. I was taken on a ride with this layered story and amazing interesting characters.
Angela Agnello had me at the dedication. Pulled me in and kept me compelled and turning pages.

If you're into reading:
• Dark Mafia World
• Alphaholes
• Morally-gray characters
• Second Chance
• Hidden Identity
• Found Family
• Underestimated FMC
• Polyamory
• Spicy
• Assassins/Mercenaries
• Soulmates/Twin Flames
• And more...
I can't recommend this book enough.
Check TW

Multiple POV
Rebelle BA FMC
Haunt is her protector/Partner
Colter, Stafford, and Brooks her past...

I loved how each dynamic evolved with the love interests.

There are so many elements to this book that make it addictive and kept me coming back for more. Mystery and suspense. Past and present colliding. Twisted games.
I can't wait for the second half of their story.

[Twinkle.butt.reads · Rating 3 out of 5]

Dark Things is a gripping and intense read that delves into themes of trauma, vengeance, and the complexities of relationships. Angela Agnello masterfully crafts a narrative that intertwines dark elements with raw emotion, making it a compelling exploration of the characters’ struggles and their fight for agency.
The characters, especially Reb and Haunt, are well-developed and complex, each carrying their own burdens and secrets. The story is fast-paced, filled with twists that keep readers on their toes, blending elements of romance, suspense, and dark themes. Agnello doesn’t shy away from heavy topics, addressing trauma and resilience in a way that feels authentic and impactful.
Overall, Dark Things is a bold and captivating novel that will resonate with fans of dark romance and psychological thrillers. If you’re looking for a story that challenges and engages, this one is worth picking up!

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[booklover · Rating 2 out of 5]

this book just pissed me off, so the guys apparently love her so much yet one of them dated another girl?? and the fact that she can't even take revenge on them for ruining her life is really pathetic?? I kinda hate this book

[Christie Krentz · Rating 4 out of 5]

Darkest Things was a good book. I always like a reverse harem, but a mafia one is usually better. This is my first time reading Angela’s books and I can’t wait for her to write more because I throughly enjoyed this one.