2.5 ⭐️ Intriguing concept but it wasn't my favorite
Let the Planet take you slowly, like a lover. Let her kiss the flesh from you. Sink in with me. Decay with me. Become bones with me.
WHAT TO EXPECT
✨ sci-fi / horror / romance novella
✨ doomed expedition to an alien planet
✨ scientist FMC × military MMC
✨ sentient plants
✨ 2.5/5 spice 🌶️ (some involving plants)
✨ "good girl" and "yes, sir"
✨ mental illness
✨ big reveals
✨ single POV
✨ not quite an HEA
My Thoughts:
I loved Thrum so I wanted to read another Meg Smitherman novella, so here we are. While the story was interesting, there were a few things that bothered me.
I didn’t really connect with the characters, and the FMC’s reactions often felt off - like they were driven more by what the plot needed than by any real emotional or logical progression (and honestly, there wasn’t much character development to begin with). When things start to get weird, there’s no real questioning or curiosity, which was frustrating, especially because she’s a scientist. I understand the influence of the Planet’s pull, but I still expected her to be more inquisitive, more skeptical. Instead, she just... goes with it, and it made it hard for me to stay fully invested.
Then, there’s the romance. The relationship itself was fine, but I didn’t fully understand how deeply invested she became by the end. They’d been co-workers for over a year, and while she had some interest in him, she pushed it aside. But once they arrive on the Planet, she suddenly can’t seem to control herself, and the two of them are instantly drawn together. By the end, she’s so attached that she’s willing to do anything not to lose him. It felt rushed.
Also, I needed more explanation for how the planet makes everyone so horny. I get that it’s supposed to have this intense, almost hypnotic pull, but in the end, we don't really know how. There is a reveal that explains why, but that's it. Nothing deeper. And why aren't the scientific machines picking up anything unusual? Why is everything symmetrical and perfect on this planet? Why did the radio battery not run out? So many questions.
And finally, I guessed the big reveal around halfway through the book. So by the time I was nearing the end, I found myself skimming because I wasn’t as invested anymore and just wanted to see if my theory was right."
While this wasn't a favorite, I do like how Smitherman writes a combination of sci-fi horror and romance, so I’ll continue to read her work.