Thank you NetGalley and Henry Holt and Co for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
T.C. Kemper’s “The Ginghams” is a bold, eerie, and emotionally resonant middle-grade debut that perfectly captures suburban creepiness while also giving an empowering message about individuality. It’s the kind of story kids read with wide eyes and adults finish thinking, Wow—this is going to stick with someone.
The book follows 12-year-old Joni Bird, who returns to her small hometown only to realize something is very wrong. Her best friend is suddenly polished, polite, and obsessed with perfection. The ice cream shop sells only vanilla now. Everyone, kids and adults, is becoming eerily identical, like shiny replicas of themselves. At the center of it all sits the mysterious, too-perfect Ginghams family, pulling quiet strings and reshaping the town into a smiling, obedient copy of their own ideals.
The tone is delightfully unsettling, making it ideal for those who love a good chill but don’t want nightmares. There’s even a subtle sci-fi thread that adds depth to the strange mind control spreading through town, raising questions about how conformity can creep in without anyone noticing.
Beneath the suspense and eerie perfection, Kemper delivers a meaningful exploration of identity, creativity, and the courage it takes to resist social pressure. The book champions being “weird, artsy, loud, quiet, different—whatever makes you you.” As the town becomes more controlled and uniform, the horror doesn’t come from monsters or ghosts; it comes from watching choice, expression, and individuality disappear.
Joni makes a compelling heroine. She is authentic, flawed, and determined, and her friendships become the emotional backbone of the story. You watch bonds fracture under pressure, then rebuild stronger as the kids reclaim their agency and fight back against enforced perfection. The climax is fast-paced, thrilling, and deeply satisfying, offering both triumph and reflection.
The emotional honesty of Joni’s character arc and the hopeful ending land beautifully. The book leaves just enough lingering questions to spark conversation about conformity, autonomy, gender expectations, creativity, and what it really means to belong, which would work perfectly in a middle grade classroom or book club.
Short, punchy, and paced for burning through in a single evening, “The Ginghams” manages to be both a compelling sci-fi mystery and a powerful invitation to celebrate individuality. It feels like a future classroom staple; one that could fuel book-club discussions and, more importantly, remind kids (and adults) that “perfect” is often the scariest word of all.
Overall, the story is strange, sharp, heartfelt, and unforgettable. “The Ginghams” is an instant standout in contemporary middle-grade fiction and an astonishingly strong debut.