An unexpected portrait of the first year of school for America’s youngest learners.
When we think of kindergarten, many might imagine joyous free play, and a tangle of trucks, dress-up clothes, and blocks, as five-year-olds explore their vivid imaginations and budding social skills. Others might envision a quiet group sitting cross-legged in a circle during story time. Neither of these scenes would be an inaccurate representation of the pivotal year of entry into traditional education in this country. However, neither offers a complete picture of what children do every day in those seemingly transparent, yet actually mysterious, classrooms. What can or should we expect during the first year of school? How are children learning and growing during those hours spent away from their homes?
Susan Engel embarked on finding these answers in American Dispatches from the First Year of School. Engel toured twenty-nine classrooms across fourteen states, observing each closely, with a special eye toward the ways each classroom’s goals reflect its community. As she made her way across the country, Engel found that on the surface, kindergarten students are good-natured, eager to learn, and deeply affectionate. Their classrooms, too, feature many of the same expectations, routines, and activities. But the differences between the classrooms were striking and often surprising. Over the two years of her classroom visits, Engel identified five promises that teachers and their classrooms make to their reading, order, thinking, identity, and love. Engel found that schools differ in how they prioritize and keep the promises they make; some make all five promises, while others emphasize only one or two. The five promises capture a set of values, aspirations, and goals that drive everything that happens in a classroom.
Engaging and incisive, American Kindergarten is the story of the promises our country’s schools make to five-year-old children, and how those promises are kept and sometimes broken.
Susan Engel is a developmental psychologist in the Department of Psychology at Williams College and the founder and director of the Williams Program in Teaching. She wrote a column on teaching for "The""New York Times" called "Lessons" and is a cofounder of The Hayground School in Eastern Long Island.
I absolutely loved this!! Perfect read as a I start my kindergarten teacher journey- I love the emphasis on feeding children’s appetite for learning (what it’s all about)! Made me think a lot about how I can get to know my individual students more and how I can help them grow and align with my classroom vision (joyful curiosity😄)! Lastlyy I feel inspired to creatively implement my curriculum so my students can learn & have fun- I really want them to love school :):) “Joy is not just a kindness to children. It is necessary to their educational success”!
I don’t have a lot of experience teaching or mentoring small children but am interested with my own children now approaching school so it was an interesting survey of many different types of kindergarten. I wish I could say a survey of “what works and what doesn’t” but this wasn’t a comprehensive research survey and didn’t follow classrooms over years. It’s just interesting multi day drop ins to a few classrooms, only a couple being memorable.
The author doesn’t say or predict what will work and which kids will turn out the best but she comments on the vibes and feelings of the classrooms that she visits. She seems to do a great job of noticing some of the special touches from some teachers. I don’t know if this kind of classroom review is common for professionals but it sounds like she can give some great feedback to teachers.
“Over the two years of her classroom visits, Engel identified five promises that teachers and their classrooms make to their students: reading, order, thinking, identity, and love.”
Further expanded: “The Five Classroom Promises
Reading: Opening the door to literacy and helping children interact with books and words.
Order: Teaching structure, routines, and how to keep things in their proper place so kids feel stable.
Thinking: Bringing the wider world inside by encouraging curiosity, questions, and problem-solving.
Identity: Supporting the unique self ("me, you, and us") and how a child fits into a social group.
Love: Providing a safe, warm, and deeply affectionate space where young children feel emotionally secure.“
Spoiler - she identifies the sixth promise that only a few teachers achieved- bringing joy to the children.
My thoughts on the 5 promises: There’s lots of ways to do the reading part and probably many books written on that topic alone.
Order I’d important but can be overdone and if it’s too much of a dictatorship then it won’t work (my words not hers).
I really enjoyed the section on thinking and will probably try to read more about this topic because definitely can be grown at school and at home.
Identity seems so hard to define and even witness so credit to author for discussing it.
Love is certainly important and honestly makes it so hard to ask so much of our school teachers and pay them so little.
Lastly, I can see what she means about joy but how do you see that or measure it? Such a challenge to replicate our teach.
“If you did want to know more about what does or should happen to children in kindergarten, you’d be hard pressed to find out.”
Exactly. Everyone goes to kindergarten; everyone sends their children there. And yet what we remember and what we hear as parents during 2 or 3 conferences that year is not enough. Susan Engel sits quietly in the classrooms and reports back with a combination of science, insight and dry wit. She breaks down the essential elements of the modern kindergarten experience as some combination of love, order, reading, identity and thinking. But what she shows us is that it is the teachers who decide the priorities and a good teacher, who balances all five, can be magical.
In kindergarten, my son came home with a 4-page story about his holidays, a basic sentence and a hand drawn picture on each page. One of the pages was: “We went to the tree farm to get our tree.” The picture showed the tree, the saw and the stump. I questioned him, “What’s up with this page? You’ve never been to a tree farm in your life.” He explained, “I wrote that we got our tree out of the crawl space. But Mrs. S erased it and made me do it over”. Looking closely, I could see the eraser marks across both the sentence and the drawing. I asked how he even knew about tree farms. He said he copied it from someone else’s page at his table. Mrs. S lost me right there.
Pulling back the curtain on something that is mysterious, but should not be, is powerful.
This book was great for thinking through what children really need when they enter kindergarten. It helped me refine my goals and philosophies for helping young ones flourish. My take-aways include: Ask more questions. Help children dig deeper into "why." Present ambiguities and let curiosity lead the way. Chit-chat! I appreciate a non-fiction book that is narrative-based. So much better than NF that tries to convince you of something through argument and fact!! Thank you to the author for that.