The Yellow Wallpaper may well be my favourite short story of all time. Five billion stars for that one. The most convincing first-person descend into madness I have ever read and there is so much symbolism to unpack…
That story stands out not only in quality, but also thematically. It’s more psychological horror whereas the others are classic ghost stories. I loved Poe, Stevenson and Shelley, as always (****). Sleepy Hollow was great as well, very funny and eerie (****). I liked the shorter stories towards the end as well as The Phantom Coach, though the latter seemed a bit rushed plotwise and more sloppily written than the others (***). I wasn’t a big fan of Henry James’ story: too stiff with too predictable a payoff that seemed unfinished in its execution (**).
As an anthology, it seems like Penguin just threw these stories together by copy/pasting from different works and published the thing without any sort of check. One story even refers to endnotes 9 and 10 that don’t exist? With the first eight missing it must be an editorial oversight. Also, I would have liked an introduction or at least some info on when/where the stories were first published!