A fun, quirky look into a mad woman’s mind, Julie Tudor Is Not a Psychopath delivered quite the hefty dose of dark, twisted humor. From the delightfully unhinged main character to a crazy-a** plot that just grew crazier and crazier, this was one book where suspending all disbelief guaranteed me a rollicking good time. After all, with a trail of bodies as long as the page count, Julie was the kind of woman you wouldn’t want in your life even if you would love to be a fly on her wall. Delusional, obsessive, and utterly wicked, she made this book binge-worthy in the extreme thanks to her innocent yet fool-like characterization. Bravo, Ms. Holdich, on a job well done with all of the above.
Unfortunately, though, that was where the fun sort of ended for me. Repetitive, sluggish, and downright disturbing, much of the story came off as sad more so than darkly amusing or witty. What bugged me the most, though, was a mix of the slow-boiling plot and the lack of any real mystery. Tacked onto the unfortunate pacing was a big missed opportunity in terms of Julie’s character development. Why was she such a chaotic mess? Who made her this way? Despite multiple timelines that showed the progression of her evil ways, we never dove into her psyche or even her childhood. For me, that left me wanting when it came to the star piece of the novel, which is a shame.
All said and done, though, while there were some definite missteps, I still raced through this debut in just one single sitting. With a very Fatal Attraction-esque vibe minus the spine-tingling fear and unbridled foreboding, in nevertheless delivered a unique unreliable narrator who pulled me right in. I mean, who wouldn’t love Julie’s downright hilarious inner monologue as well as the rapidly escalating calamity of a life lived on the edge? So despite the fact that parts of this just didn’t work for this thriller lover, I still recommend it to anyone who loves satirical plots or wildly unhinged personas. After all, while it wasn’t really a mystery/thriller, it was still a good solid read. Rating of 3 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
Julie Tudor is not a psychopath.
Julie Tudor is 49 and has it all: a fantastic job (well-maintained spreadsheets are the lynchpin of an efficient office), a beautiful house (some may wonder how she got the money for it, but nothing has been proved) and the man of her dreams.
Julie Tudor is not a stalker.
Sean is 25 and the love of Julie's life. The only problem is, he thinks he's in love with someone else.
And Julie Tudor is definitely, definitely not a serial killer.
But Julie has found herself in a similar situation before. And if there's one thing Julie knows, it's how to get rid of the competition...
After all, what's a little murder in the name of true love?
Thank you to Jennifer Holdich and Sourcebooks Landmark for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: June 24, 2025
Content warning: murder, violence, bullying, knife violence, mention of: animal cruelty