I absolutely adore Franz Kafka as an author and in fact consider many of his tragic heroes such as Joseph K. of Der Prozeß (The Trial) and Gregor Samsa of Die Verwandlung (The Metamorphosis) as massively spiritually and emotionally appealing, as delightfully speaking to me. But no, I have to admit that I really have not at all enjoyed the 2007 graphic novel Kafka, finding both David Zane Mairowitz' text and equally so Robert Crumb's artwork as leaving rather much to be personally desired.
For while David Zane Mairowitz' general textual introduction to Franz Kafka is sufficiently informative and covers his often tragic biography (including Kafka's work as a writer, as an author and how he was ALWAYS really unsure of himself and of his literary abilities) decently and in a generally well enough researched manner (although the absence of an included bibliography in Kafka is rather ridiculous and a huge huge intellectual shortcoming for me), frankly and considering how much animosity Kafka always seemed to have felt towards ALL religions (and yes, this also and definitely includes Judaism), I do rather take umbrage with the main textual focus of Kafka seemingly being Judaism, and with author David Zane Mairowitz in my humble opinion also rather desiring us readers to believe that everything regarding Franz Kafka's life and in particular regarding his doom and gloom attitudes, his self loathing, his inability to fit into standard Central and Western bourgeois society was somehow totally and almost solely connected and related to not only Judaism but in particular to anti Semitism (and that Kafka's self hatred and his almost total lack of self esteem was thus and according to Mairowitz simply because of him being Jewish).
I mean, yes, Franz Kafka's writing (both his shorter fiction and his novels), it ALWAYS shows a huge amount of alienation and an inward turning anger and frustration often bordering on major animosity. But really, if you know about Kafka's family and in particular about how verbally and emotionally abusive Franz Kafka's father always was towards his son (whose artistic temperament and sensitivity the father not only would not but also did not seemingly even remotely want to understand), well, and in my opinion, the main reasons for Franz Kafka's mental health issues etc. (but also what made him such a great writer), these totally and utterly were and should be considered major family dysfunction, parental abuse, neglect and disrespect and therefore not (from where I am standing) primarily anti-Semitism (and that to and for me, David Zane Mairowitz actually with the way he focuses Kafla seems to inadvertently kind of absolve Kafka's father by making or at least by trying to make the horrible abuse and emotional terror Franz Kafka’s father was seemingly constantly visiting upon his poor son as somehow being part and parcel to anti Semitism and not due to the fact that he, that Kafka's father was basically a total and unredeemable massive and all encompassing freaking ASSHOLE).
In other words, just because Franz Kafka was often self hating in his life and in his work, this is (at least in my opinion) not because of Judaism and not because of anti-Semitism tainting everything around Kafka, including his family, not to mention that I also have to wonder how Kafka himself would react to such an assessment. And come on, many individuals who have experienced emotional abuse and neglect show signs of self hatred regardless of their religion or ethnic identity, and for Mairowitz to try to claim in Kafka that Franz Kafka's emotional issues, that his fragility and internal anger were being influenced mostly and kind of even only by Judaism alone, this seems more than a bit ludicrous and yes has also rather made me quite annoyed and frustrated. And combined with the fact that I also just do not consider Robert Crumb’s black and white cartoon-like illustrations all that aesthetically pleasing for my eyes (as I do find the featured artwork for Kafka much too visually busy, too parodistic and too exaggerated, although I do seem to be the minority here), sorry, but for me Kafka has been pretty majorly disappointing as a graphic novel and thus only a two star rating at best (with neither David Zane Mairowitz’ text nor Robert Crumb’s images working at all well for me).