Unleash the dark and delirious with this electrifying anthology of folk horror from some of Britain's most iconic working-class voices
A phonograph cylinder that plays on a loop for eternity, casting out ghostly spectres of violence; a centuries-old stew made of severed body parts; a bigoted woman working at an ossuary, the bones she watches over her only remaining friends; three siblings who set out to scatter their father's ashes, a man none of them could stand; and a hag stone sitting in the pocket of a witch.
Uncanny and unsettling, wild and wyrd, the ten stories in this collection showcase the best of folk horror. Set in and across England, they celebrate working-class culture and history, and, sharp as a guillotine blade, reveal the real monsters that stalk our green and pleasant land.
Includes writing from: A.K. Blakemore, Daniel Draper, Emma Glass, Mark Colbourne, Mark Stafford, Hollie Starling, Jenn Ashworth, Natasha Carthew, Salena Godden and Tom Benn.
'A masterful collection' MAXINE PEAKE 'Astonishing and long overdue, you really need to read this’ ALAN MOORE 'An absolute treat' ADAM S. LESLIE
Dark and contemplative, this brief anthology, just 10 stories, has a strong sense of place. The stories are diverse but all fall into a somewhat subdued, almost melancholic mode, where history and tradition intersect with everyday life, bidden or not. The idea of using folk horror to explicitly explore working class stories is a clever one, and I enjoyed how both of those frameworks were played with across the stories. None of the stories really shook me or took my breath away, but I had fun with all of them. Daniel Draper’s Perpetual Stew, Hollie Starling’s Yellowbelly, and Salena Godden’s I am Hagstone were standouts for me in this collection, but each story offers something different and as a whole the collection is well-curated. There is nothing particularly flashy about any of these stories, they all thrum with a type of quiet dread, a preternatural dissonance that settles just beneath the skin.
“My good friends, things cannot go on well in England, nor ever will until everything shall be in common, when there shall be neither vassal nor lord, and all distinctions levelled; when the lords shall be no more masters than ourselves. How ill they have used us.” John Ball 1381 ‘When a person’s life chances are sealed by an accident of birth it’s no coincidence that it is the pitchfork that has become the most familiar totem of the angry mob,’ The subtitle of this is “A Working Class Anthology of Folk Horror” and it contains ten stories recently written (2025) and edited by Hollie Starling. There are stories by A K Blakemore, Daniel Draper, Tom Benn, Emma Glass, Mark Colbourne, Mark Stafford, Hollie Starling, Jenn Ashworth, Natasha Carthew and Salena Godden. At least two are printed for the first time. There is even a graphic comic fairy tale waring about selling your soul to social media. These are contemporary and reflect contemporary issues, the first being set in a post-Farage Essex. Starling’s contribution (set in Lincolnshire) concerns a modern sex bot/doll which educates itself via the internet and learns about misogyny with startling results. The trajectory of a number of the stories doesn’t go where you expect. Eldrich is about a 70s band that made one album which is now a cult classic and follows the lives of the members via a short piece about each track and it’s really odd. Perpetual Stew is also weird (that’s an understatement) about the tradition of a particular small community. Starling, in her introduction says those who have contributed: “do so as a refusal against the project of marginalisation, and to force reflection on just whose interests are vested in maintaining a system of feast and famine.” The mundane and familiar becomes uncanny and threatening and the order of things is not secure. Starling notes this is an attempt to rescue folklore and identity: ‘Unfortunately, tradition has been invoked to defend all sorts of cynical examples of British ‘cultural heritage’, from fox-hunting to blackface to smacking your kids. In online spaces, folk imagery, wistfulness for unspoilt landscape and appeals to ‘indigenous’ pride are used as dog-whistles to further the ethnonationalist fantasies of the far right.’ This collection challenges that and it is exceptionally good.
The working class have done us proud here, what a fabulous collection of stories.
The sense of dread, despair, unease and creepiness is evident throughout all of these gems of horror writing.
Each author has caught a very different thread and tapped into a unique fear to present storytelling at its finest.
I'd say the only story out the bunch that didn't capture my attention was It Fair Give Me the Spikes which felt a little too abstract and disjointed to be an enjoyable read. The rest of the anthology was absolutely 5 star class.
Absolutely excellent short story collection. Shocking, localised, entertaining and sometimes meaningful. A couple didn't land for me, but the rest were cracking!
Amazing intro and reading list Horrible lady who hangs out with skulls Village soup and brother jealousy Mother of lost child stuck in the mud Overanalyzing of an obscure folk rock band AI girlfriend learning about social history Siblings visiting abandoned hotel to scatter ashes Lost mother and an island of secrets Anti-bad-boyfriend hagstone Meh.
I wanted to read this book as soon as I heard about it, and more so - I wanted to love it. Growing up working-class is a strange thing, but not without its artistic inspirations. There are working-class TV shows (the soap operas are the biggest example), working-class film and film stars (those actors who grew up poor and fought for their place in Hollywood), and working-class music (whole genres created by poor, struggling kids on rough council estates). But I don't think I had ever read a working-class book - or rather, I had never read a story written by a working-class writer. I may have done, and I apologise to any authors that I'm mis-class'ing. But nothing had ever felt really... gritty and down at the level I grew up in. I'm not saying I grew up a Dickensian orphan, but I was fully aware of the different class status of the kids at school - the houses and tastes and jobs the other parents had. And whilst it didnt exactly put a 'chip' on my shoulder, it is something that I have been vaguely aware of my whole life. And so, to Bog People. I think what struck me most of all, was the anger. The anger of the characters - of their place in the world, their station and limitations. But also my anger. The editor, and contributing author, Hollie Starling says in her excellent introductory essay that - "Those vested in the maintenance of capital-driven systems of control have worked hard to distract from one of history's most abiding truths: that there are more of us than them." This was like a rallying cry, a call to arms, a stirring of my working-class soul to action. It was interesting to read that this country has always worked roughly the same as it does now - keeping the rich rich and the poor poor. The stories felt like history, because maybe they have all been played out a hundred times before, in a hundred council estates and farming villages. It is odd to glance over the notes I made of the stories as I read them, as the words that jump out time and again are - bleak, angry, sad, familiar, inevitable. But there were also moments of lyrical beauty and solid, relatable characters who's story moved me. And through it all, you come to understand (if you didn't have a firm grasp on the definition already) what folk horror is. Whilst it is linked with the land, it is also linked with the people who work it (in all the modern connotations that meaning now has). It isn't about lamenting your place as a working-person, but rather defending your rights and holding anyone who would seek to take advantage of you to rights. I loved this book. For the stories, for the excellent writing and the slow, creeping horror. But also for the fire it stirred inside me. For the window it opened and the realities it showed me of what it is to be, and be seen as, a working-class person.
“Perpetual Stew” was worth the price of admission alone. Also loved “I am Hagstone,” “Yellowbelly,” and “Carole,” all stories with completely different tones and POVs that fit the theme of the anthology so perfectly. There were a few stories in here that I didn’t really connect with, and one or two that I feel like had a kernel of something there but didn’t quite coalesce or that I found hard to follow, but overall an interesting, solid collection.
The introduction was great. Thought-provoking and some interesting takes. Many of the stories in this volume, though, didn’t live up to this opening. Quite a bit of reformulated themes each time but a few really novel ones that have unexpectedly stayed with me - AI-sex-robot-witch, anyone?
Really fun, absolutely obsessed with the concept of this book and the execution was fantastic too. Enjoyed some stories more than others. Thought the last one was the weakest which was a shame. But a really great winter read
These stories are all very readable, but only a few stand out. The Ossuary by A K Blakemore which concerns a bigoted eighty year old woman volunteering at a museum. Perpetual Stew by Daniel Draper which concerns feuding brothers in a remote village where little has changed for decades. Blakemore’s story in particular, encapsulates that capacity of folk horror to lay bare what lies ‘beneath’, the small horrors every person is capable of inflicting on another, and upon themselves.
I really enjoyed reading this over all, but I found quite a few of the stories uninteresting so I cant go any higher than 3 stars. I kept notes of each story as I read, which you can find below.
The Ossary: Boring and uneventful.
Perpetual Stew: Brilliant!! Why don't we get to know what happens?! Though I guess we can assume... I would have liked to see the younger brother win it.
Carole: Odd one. A mother leaves a hearing in court about her daughter's death, starts walking and doesn't stop until she sinks in a bog and drowns. I found it interesting. I wanted to know what happened and the people she comes across as she walks and sinks are very odd. A sad ending, if not anticlimactic.
Eldritch: Fantastic beginning... the rest was rather dull.
The Spit in Your Mouth and the Bile in Your Stomach: Loved that there's a graphic short story included!! And a quick enjoyable read.
Yellowbelly: A story of a sex robot being inspired by folklore to rise up against her owner. Very good, I enjoyed this one.
The Hanging Stones: I don't get the point of this one. 3 siblings scatter their father's ashes in the moors, the place gets misty. End of story. It's well written and the characters well fleshed out, but the story is pointless.
The Keepers: I enjoyed this one, but it feels like there are massive chunks of story missing that we'll never get to see.
I Am Hagstone: I liked this one. Reading the story from the pov of the hagstone was really interesting! It's well written and full of drama, driven to the extreme by a demon inhabiting the hagstone. Brilliant autumn read.
It Fair Give Me The Spikes: I found this one incredibly hard to follow. Not a fan.
This is a great collection, I don't think there's a weak story in here, and I love the exploration and expression of folk horror beyond the 1970s.
Eldritch is a lovely twist on a cursed artwork story, Perpetual Stew is perhaps my favourite? Though Yellowbelly is a marvellous modern take, and It Fair Give Me The Spikes is a great haunting (again, in a very modern understanding of how a haunting can work).
I devoured this book - it was fantastic. I’m a great lover of folk horror, and each story in this collection brought something fresh to the genre. And that’s before one even mentions the fabulous focus on working class writers - whilst none of the stories were focused on my home town of Doncaster, the stories felt relatable and meaningful to me - as I’m sure they will for many others. Sheer perfection.
DNF. I had a free Audible credit and used it for this book. I only listened to The Ossuary and Perpetual Stew, and they were both boring. Carole, the next story, almost put me to sleep 5 minutes in, so I decided to call it quits.
This is probably the best collection of short stories I've ever read. Each of them was so unique in its story, narrative and style, and each of them left me thinking of something different.
This is particularly true for 'Eldritch', by Mark Colbourne, which is probably going to become my favourite horror short story. From the very concept of it, to the delivery, and the narration, I was absolutely hooked throughout
Mixed bag, some stories definitely deserved more than 2 stars, others didn't do anything for me, overall it was an ok read, but definitely not as good as I expected from the premise.
I want to start off by saying “Bog People” was my first interaction with the folk horror genre. Furthermore, I am not British so my knowledge of British folklore goes only to the extent of what is represented in popular culture. All of this combined made me pretty excited about this anthology.
Well.. I was severely let down. See, me being Slavic means I’m pretty familiar with Slavic folk stories and I’ve always debated the potential it has for the folk horror genre. And when I say horror, I mean *horror*. Creepy old women living in a house in the middle of a dark forest and a bunch of ladies performing a folk dance next to a lake at 3AM with folk music coming from seemingly nowhere type of horror. Naturally, I expected something similar from the stories in “Bog People”.
Let me first address the “folk” side of folk horror in this book. I felt the representation a bit lackluster. To me, the stories were focused far more on the protagonists’ own story and agenda, as well as on modern world issues than the folklore itself. Where there were some folk elements, they were overshadowed by the plot itself and I was left wondering, is this completely fiction or is it actual British folklore?
Then we get to the “horror” part. Sorry, but many of the stories had absolutely zero horror factor. Some of them did make me repulsed (which is a good thing!) and had this eerie presence about them, but nothing overly exciting or unheard of before.
And this actually is what is working against these works - they are predominantly good, nothing negative I can say about them, however if you put them in the “horror” bucket they just stick out as outliers as, quite frankly, this is not their place. I have individual mini reviews of each story below and you will notice that had their genre been different, I’d rate them higher. I believe “Bog People” isn’t a collection of already published stories and all stories in it are entries and winners in a contest, so I’m not exactly sure why it was decided that they fall within this genre, which I guess is my biggest issue with this anthology. Anyways, moving to the mini reviews:
The Ossuary - 1⭐️- follows the daily life of a conservative old lady. Nothing special, really. Would have given it 3 ⭐️ if it wasn’t presented as “folk horror”. There wasn’t any kind of horror element in this story.
Perpetual Stew - 4⭐️ - a story about internal family conflict and generational cannibalism. In a rather grotesque way “Perpetual Stew” highlights the extremes to which families can go to only to secure their legacy
Carole - 4⭐️ - “Carole” follows the story of a mother who has lost her child and has just divorced. The story is Alice-in-Wonderland-esque where at one point the reader isn’t exactly sure if this is all a dream (or a nightmare) or real life. The mother sets off to travel by foot through the country and encounters several folks on her way. To me, the fact that none of them offered to help or acknowledged the fact that she’s traveling on her own is just a representation of the helplessness she experienced ever since her child passed away.
Eldritch - 2⭐️ - written in a magazine article format, this story is neither folk, nor horror. It consists of a critic analyzing a music album by a rock/alternative band. While the ending is somewhat good (and the general premise of a demon-inviting music album does have potential), the whole story is littered with useless information that does not move the plot forward and just makes it heavy to read. Had it been a bit shorter and had it leaned more into the horror factor, I would’ve enjoyed Eldritch a lot more.
The Spirit in Your Mouth and the Bile in Your Stomach - 5⭐️ - a short comic with an ending that makes your skin crawl.
Yellowbelly - 2 ⭐️ - I suppose it’s an okay story but I’m not sure I understood it completely - I couldn’t grasp which parts were inspired by folklore. And again, this is not horror.
The Hanging Stones - 5⭐️ - this was another really good folk horror story that I can get behind. A father of three has passed away. Due to his narcissistic behavior and drinking problems his children were never close to him. They book a house in a remote village only to get rid (quite literally) of their father’s ashes and in a eerie turn of events, two of them end up becoming their father and meet their death in the near future. “The Hanging Stones” is a perfect example how the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.
The Keepers - 3⭐️ - a nice story about going back to your roots and embracing tradition, however this is not horror, thus the 3⭐️ rating.
I Am Hagstone - 5⭐️ - I absolutely loved this one! The main protagonist, a young woman, finds a hagstone possessed by a demon which gives her supernatural powers. The story really reminded me of the 1996 movie “The Craft”.
It Fair Give Me the Spikes - 1⭐️ - the writing style was really everything that I hate into one - lots of characters, a story too fast paced and convoluted for its length. Moreover, it had zero horror elements in it.
My overall review: An interesting collection that makes good on its promise of ‘folk’, though less so on its promise for ‘horror’. Definitely worth checking out for the stories “Perpetual Stew”, “Yellowbelly” and “I Am Hagstone” alone. I would rate the overall collection 3.5/5 stars.
My reviews of the individual stories:
“The Ossuary” by A.K. Blakemore 3.5/5 stars I have read and loved Blakemore’s The Glutton and was excited to see her name on the back of this book. Although a strong short story on its own – Blakemore’s writing is always sharp and her character studies wonderfully incisive, plus I love the setting; I do love a good ossuary – I don’t think this really reads as horror, which is something I hate to say (horror is so subjective, and people level this accusation at female writers all the time, unfortunately) but I do genuinely believe is true here. It is for this reason alone that it doesn’t get a higher rating, since this is an anthology of folk horror. Having said that, it’s still definitely worth reading; I think it is a wonderful example of a short story done well.
“Perpetual Stew” by Daniel Draper 4/5 stars This story has a compelling concept and a good execution of said concept. Draper also managed to arouse emotions such as indignation, curiosity, and fear within me; what more could I ask for? The only reason it’s not getting 5 stars is because I found the ending to be a bit too abrupt, but I believe I shall be thinking about this one for a long time to come.
“Carole” by Emma Glass 3/5 stars If I had to use two words to describe this short story, they would be ‘sad’ and ‘surreal’. Not a bad short story by any means, but again, I’m afraid it doesn’t really read as horror. There is no dread, no fear, just this dreamy, otherworldly feeling. Still worth your time, though; any story with a bog is!
“Eldritch” by Mark Colbourne 4/5 stars I am a bit of a slut for found footage/epistolary novels, so from the first paragraph, I knew this story would work for me. It’s folk, it’s cosmic, it’s horror; what more could I ask for? If you enjoyed Wylding Hall by Elizabeth Hand, you’re bound to like this story as well.
“The Spit in Your Mouth and the Bile in Your Stomach” by Mark Stafford 4/5 stars I was pleasantly surprised to find a comic in this collection; in my humble opinion, more anthologies should invite graphic novel artists to contribute. The art style fits the folk horror theme perfectly, and this story, though certainly short, definitely packs a punch.
“Yellowbelly” by Hollie Starling 4.5/5 stars Other reviewers have mentioned this story as (one of) the highlight(s) of this anthology, and right now, I am inclined to agree (please note that I write the review of each story right after finishing it). We love a good story of men getting what they deserve, and the combination of an AI sexbot with folk horror is creative and well-executed. Very good!
“The Hanging Stones” by Jenn Ashworth 4/5 stars This one could have been turned into a full-length novel, I think; the dynamic between the siblings was certainly interesting enough, and there was a delicious thread of unease running through it all. I wanted more!
“The Keepers” by Natasha Carthew 3/5 stars I don’t mean to sound snobby (especially not when reviewing working-class horror), but I think this one should have had another round of copy edits, because the commas weren’t all where they should be; I counted several comma splices as well as sentences that could have sorely used a comma (or two, or even three). It unfortunately did effect my reading experience of this story, which is a shame, because this one had a lot of potential: cults, mermen, mommy-daughter issues…
“I Am Hagstone” by Salena Godden 4/5 stars Delicious! I love a hagstone, and I love a story of nasty men getting what they deserve.
Lived up to exactly what I hoped for from this anthology - of course some are stronger than others but I love how every story takes a very different angle, especially with how class sometimes feels right at the forefront, while in other places sinks into the background as though reflecting some ‘natural’ order of things.
Ranking:
1. Perpetual Stew - ive always had a personal obsession with perpetual stews anyway so this was destined for top spot. I love how it takes a fairly traditional folk horror approach and combines it with an incredibly textured and recognisable portrait of modern british mundanity. Exceptionally enjoyable. Exactly what I hoped for from this anthology with a very clever approach.
2. Yellowbelly - Probably the one that blew me away most with its ingenuity. Feels like an immediate departure from the expectations of the genre so becomes doubly surprising when it brings everything together and delivers a home run of an ending.
3. Carole - Heartbreaking. Made me feel a little sick to my stomach with the pain of it all - the strange, fable-like logic of her slow bog death as she chatters with strangers is the type of thinking I love from old folk.
4. I am Hagstone - I couldn’t help but love it. A great story of karmic revenge told from a fascinating perspective with a style of writing I just adored. The whole approach was just a joy to read. (also Liverpool mentioned !!!)
5. The Hanging Stones - I loved the understated nature of this story. The way it felt like everything was hanging in the background, just off of the page. Very cool and character focused and obvs love to see some Pendle Hill.
6. The Ossuary - Similarly rich (and depressing) portrait of a very bleak, ‘post-farage’ Essex. I love how it really digs into the contrived and contradictory thinking of such a hateful old woman.
7. Eldritch - I think it speaks to the quality of this whole anthology that this is somehow in seventh because I also thought this is my type of thing. I think it had a premise, set-up and perspective that was so compelling to me that the ending unfortunately couldn’t live up to it. I would read pages and pages and pages more of it though.
8. The Spit in Your Mouth and the Bile in Your Stomach - So cool to have a graphic story halfway though, and what a great title.
9. It Fair Give Me the Spikes - Haunting atmosphere. Unfortunately it just felt like things didn’t quite come together for me.
10. The Keepers - Unfortunately just didn’t seem to hit for me but I need to read it again.
Special mention - The introduction is also amazing and I WILL make it through that reading list.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A pet peeve of mine is horror fiction that tries a little too hard for metaphorical or social significance and ends up scanting the need for frights—as much as I like a good bit of incisive social commentary, I also very much enjoy reading about people getting killed by ghosts, demons, witches, or ghost demon witches. BOG PEOPLE, for all its well-crafted prose, often struggles on this front, delivering a few primarily realist works which emphasise the "folk" far more than the "horror".
However, a few stories in this anthology find a more successful balance between the two. "Perpetual Stew" is a punchy little story about cannibalism and stifling family ties; the latter anxiety also dogs "The Keepers", which blends this theme with an exploration of tradition and ownership over land. "Eldritch", framed as the review of the eponymous folk album by a journalist who's since disappeared, uses this clever conceit to discuss the history of the folk-music revival (even if the conclusion of the story somewhat runs out of steam amidst the jarring arrival of a supernatural presence). My favourite works in this anthology are probably Salena Godden's "I am Hagstone", which puts a contemporary twist on the classic premise of witchcraft and cursed objects with a story, narrated by the titular magical stone, of infidelity and female power, as well as Mark Stafford's beautifully illustrated comic "The Spit in Your Mouth and the Bile in Your Stomach", which finds a satisfyingly simple payoff in a brief plot inspired by urban legends and fairytales.
I liked Bog People! It's an anthology of folk horror set in England that celebrates working-class culture and history. I really liked the premise of this book and overall I enjoyed most of the stories as many of them had some interesting ideas. My absolute favourite out of all the stories was Perpetual Stew. It has family drama and a creepy village tradition around a centuries-old stew that has a disturbing main ingredient in it. It was definitely the best story in the collection and I really wish we got to see how it ended; but I also enjoyed being able to guess for myself.
I do wish some of the stories included were scarier as a few of them barely felt like horror at all. Overall this was still an enjoyable read that I'd recommend checking out. My individual ratings for each story are: ▫️The Ossuary - 2⭐️ ▫️Perpetual Stew - 5⭐️ ▫️Carole - 3⭐️ ▫️Eldritch - 4⭐️ ▫️The Spit in your Mouth and the Bile in your Stomach - 4⭐️ ▫️Yellowbelly - 4⭐️ ▫️The Hanging Stones - 3⭐️ ▫️The Keepers - 3⭐️ ▫️I am Hagstone - 4⭐️ ▫️If Fair Give Me the Spikes - 3⭐️
A very good anthology, always hard to rate as some you love, some not so much. But the overall standard was high. Favourites: Perpetual Stew, Carole and Yellowbelly.
I had high hopes for this anthology based on the first three excellent stories but it rather drifts down hill after that. The premise is a good one - that folk horror has looked at the working class as the 'other', often in negative terms, and that a correction is worth making.
The introduction is a solid and thoughtful explanation of where the book is coming although it presages the book by declining into a bit of a rant towards the end. Is this a book about the working class or about the frustrated outrage of would-be escapees from that class with literary aspirations?
Over half the authors are women which should be a fair and good thing but some of them have confused feminist politics with working class politics. The portrayal of men in these pieces is certainly not providing much in the way of solidarity.
The Editor, Hollie Starling, provides a well written story but it is of this type. Its link to folk horror is tenuous to say the least. It is an aggressive and murderous piece of science fiction horror masquerading as folk in which ball-cutting revenge by a sex bot is riddled with hatred.
Most of the stories are fine if not inspiring, although the last two are literary to the point of self-indulgence (witchery in Hastings) or obscurity. This last - 'It Fair Give Me The Spikes' by Tom Benn - is a linguistically accomplished ghost story marred by its sustained incomprehensibility.
Earlier than this, there is a weird fantasy response to 'The Wicker Man' from a quasi-class angle (Cornish fisher folk in this case) that actually ends up with something that might be classed as a 'happy ending'. Happy endings are not part of the genre description.
So, let us praise the first three stories as well above the average, worth considering for future anthologies. In these stories, the authors maintain both the horror and the ordinariness of existence and some decent relation to the genre they are supposed to be emulating.
The first is the best - 'The Ossuary' by A. K Blakemore - which is rather subversive of the Editor's avowed intent. The publisher might have hoped (from the blurb) that we would despise the aged prejudiced guardian of bones but Blakemore presents her with real sympathy.
It is a subtle story in which the pricks are the liberal leftie children who are pompous and callous while two urban Asians behave unpleasantly amongst her bones. She is a cultural dinosaur doomed to extinction but she is also a person. Blakemore treats her as such.
Daniel Draper's 'Perpetual Stew' could so easily have gone wrong with its outrageous premise of a mining village held together by grand guignol petty cannibalism but he pulls it off because of his close observation of working class life and his allegiance to the tropes of folk horror.
Finally, Emma Glass' fantasy of grief over the death of a child that leads to the willing immersion of a mother in the ancient earth works because the fantasy is embedded in absolute fidelity to the powerful emotions involved. It is quietly devastating as it turns from realism into folk tale.
These three stories make an otherwise very uneven collection well worth owning. It is certainly not that there is anything truly bad in it (though one or two come close) but that the 'working class' writers were perhaps not pushed hard enough to meet the brief by the editorial team.
As to its working class authenticity, I find it hard to judge - the idea of the working class has transformed from the idea of a class defined by its relationship to the means of production to something more amorphous as those left behind by neo-liberal economics.
The purpose of the book (a worthy one) was ostensibly to reverse the patronising assumptions of 'The Wicker Man' and of urban horror writers who positioned rural and other working class communities as containing some threat to 'nice' educated middle class people. Grammar school patrony!
The much-appreciated Nigel Kneale was always a bourgeois at heart who feared the mob whether urban or rural as becomes clear from any sensible reading of 'Quatermass and the Pit' and 'Quatermass IV' (both the epitome of intelligent science fiction-based folk horror).
Similarly most of the neo-pagans who swear by 'The Wicker Man' seem deliberately forgetful that the film was an attack on irrationality, paganism and the suggestibility and weakness of ordinary folk. A literary challenge to all this was long overdue.
Unfortunately, the challenge is not coming from 'authentic' communities but from individuals who are part of or aspirant to becoming part of a particular and increasingly proletarianised artistic and creative community that is threatened with extinction in economically troubled times.
The working class communities here are largely being 'imagined' in no less a manner than they were 'imagined' negatively by their 'bourgeois' predecessors. Nothing wrong with that - Irvine Welsh 'imagines' his amoral thugs in much the same way and creates great literature.
However, the atomisation and fragmentation of the working class and the replacement of positive 'socialist' or 'labour' politics with the politics of identity and 'ressentiment' creates something that is more petit-bourgeois than proletarian.
This creates uneasiness as to authentic appropriation of working class tropes precisely because the appropriation is for a politics as unrecognisable to most traditional working people as would be the top-down social democratic and patronising politics of past denizens of Hampstead.
Still, I wish all the authors well. Most of them have huge potential to refine their art. It is good that the anthology was attempted. If only the rather vicious man-hating (which is anti-working class) aspects could be removed and the final step taken from the identity politics of the liberal Left!
Was going to snarkily say that this anthology of folk horror short stories feels more like the nominees of a short story competition at school but apparently this literally was a competition and these were the winners.
Despite every story essentially having the same beats and themes (mainly the dissonance of being proud of where you're from whilst acknowledging suburban and rural areas also being hotbeds of bigotry), there are some standouts and some stinkers. Best ones are Perpetual Stew by Daniel Draper and Yellowbelly by Hollie Starling; both are witty, take unexpected turns and have surprisingly fleshed out characters for short stories. Almost worth the price of admission alone but I would recommend just seeking those out and skipping most of the rest.
Also I would be remiss to ignore that we are in a particularly fucked moment in terms of inequality and routes into the arts that a book is being marketed as "Working-Class" by a large publisher. Perhaps slightly tangential but everyone should read this essay on the Authentocracy!
Short story anthologies are always a lottery in a sense. Some stories are awe inspiring, others are quite mid, and others are well, lackluster or contain elements that just aren’t my cup of tea so to speak. This isnt about the writing quality- Ive yet to read an anthology where the writers weren’t gifted- however, Ive never read an anthology where Ive loved every single story either. This one was pretty noteworthy, however. I think Ive enjoyed more stories than I have not- though these are definitely much darker folk horror stories than the original creators of the genre would have dreamed up. If I could, Id give this 4.5 stars, and recommend that this only be read by adults. The stories that have stayed with me the most have been The Perpetual Stew and Eldritch- they still give me shudders.
This is horror not in the scary sense, but in the sense that everything is so bleak that it gets to you. Ultimately though, this is a mixed bag of stories, but the premise of getting working class voices out there is something that very much appeals to me. My stand out stories were The Ossuary, Perpetual Stew, Yellowbelly and Eldritch - the latter especially as a music journalist that one had a particular resonance and gave me chills. I enjoyed the surrealism of Carole and its references to the West Country, but the rest of the stories didn't have much of an impact on me. The one that I have a particular bone to pick with was It Fair Give Me the Spikes, it felt like words for words sake and I still don't really know what the story is about, so it was a weak one to end on.