Review on Training for climbing by Eric Hörst
Training for climbing is a classic book within the sports climbing books. The first edition was released 2003, and Hörst has also written other books on the topic of climbing.
What to expect from a book that covers the topic of climbing? One would expect to find a book that first gives the reader the inspiration, knowledge, and aspiration to train, climb and send routes.
The contents of the book are oriented around goal setting, training different aspects of the body, understanding of physiology, nutrition, but also a chapter on injury treatment and prevention.
I must say that the short chapter of sports climbing history is just about the right size regarding content before the author jumps into the essence and his foundation of the approach to climbing with one-third of physical activity, one-third of mental attributes and the last third of technical skills.
With this trinity of skills as the foundation or the essence of the climbing attributes one would expect to let this be the inhibition throughout the book. The physical aspect gets a good coverage and the physiological chapter and section are quite good, it has some new theories like the central governor (CGM) as a regulator of the stress threshold against depletion of ATP-CP. But the technical aspect is not covered, and the mental aspect has some brief exercises and guiding approaches.
There are lots of references as well to other researchers and studies accomplished within the science of sports climbing. This is good although the references are a bit vague in description.
Due to the relatively good chapter on physiology, the training and exercises are thus evidentially based. But there are some blind spots and the author point them out but sometimes he misses to mark them out. E.g. there is still a cross section between genetics and the trainable, which is a challenge scientist argue and dispute over, and it is a point the author is making the reader aware of. The author is not so clear and sometimes a little contrary as to be your own specialist up against to boost out some commandments that are not based on evidence. Some of them might be for safety reasons and some might be for the most pedagogic way of teaching, and these are of course elementary and solid arguments regarding the commandments functions.
The topic overall is very interesting, and it is clearly that the author takes the reader seriously, and wants to inspire and enlighten.
A little critical voice enhances in this reader when the author speaks about old ways of viewing the control center in the brain. The idea of the whole area of the brain who has to be engaged when one climb is indisputable, but it is not as schematic as the division of the right and the left side of the brain, where one side is controlling logic and emotions without connection in between. This is an old view though applicable to the left arm, and the right side of the brain but for more cognitive functions it is not so to speak, and the topic should be upgraded in a new version of the book. As this is a new version.
The book is also interactive and has a useful appendix, and interactive sections, so you can take upon the challenge of completing some self-tests to deepen your knowledge on what you currently and over the longer term, need to work on.
The climber who has completed several seasons are familiar with the concept of periodization. The concept that is introduced in train for climbing are the underlying micro-, meso- and macrocycles. This gives the reader more to be concerned about, and when he absolutely was sure of one way there are many simultaneously processes which happen during the development phase. This gives the reader a view of the nuances of development in climbing.
The book deepens the knowledge about training for climbing. Whether the book’s function just as a motivator could be questioned, like for example a climbing movie who serves the viewer with ultra-cool clips of boulders and routes with high profiled climbers. The author makes the reader very task oriented and not so much goal driven like a vivid imagination might do. It is a part of the syllabus and the mental training part. So one-third of the "trinity" is not left out but on the topic of mental training.
There is an approach to the physiological side of the body through different energy systems, that is explained thoroughly. And how to train the four-different energy system anaerobic power, anaerobic capacity, aerobic power and aerobic capacity. There is also put up scenarios where it could be questioned what type of energy system is active since the body is a whole and the isolated function of these systems might work a bit different while in synthesis.
There is also another cornerstone in the train for the climbing approach in this philosophy and it is to not try to train the acticlactic system too much, not solely focus on hard sustaining climbing. The argument is that working on the acticlactic threshold is a threshold that requires great patience. The author argues that it is the least trainable system. Whether this is true or not could certainly be a question of debate. The
difference between the theorem learned from evidence and the stated anecdote theorem
is a tricky one, in a book that is meant to be easily grasped and understood. It is also a point the author points out, that in your training you should not be guided by anecdotes It might as well be dependent upon how one threat climbing, is climbing mostly a skill exercise, an endurance sport, a power-oriented workout or gracefully choreography of tricks and solutions? These differences might be reflected upon in the reader's mind.
The chapter on nutrition and acceleration recovery are good, and its great to have a holistic view of the climbing and training since athletes might suffer from their own blind spots. In a sport that seems to depend greatly on the weight to body-mass ratio and with a clear warning of a severe risk of injury these two topics can`t get enough attention. The injuries in climbing from stress on the body can be avoided by warming up, working the antagonist's muscles, proper and sufficient rest and the right training-volume, load, and intensity. The injury section is very detailed and leaves the reader with the curiosity to explore the topic more.
The illustrations and pictures are good and there are lots of exercises to keep you going, some familiar and some new and some even a little controversy or new as being climbing related.
Great read and looking forward to the second read through as the author recommended.