I have some VERY mixed feelings on this one. The Black Lotus is the finale of the Fatal Florals duet, and I so badly wanted to love it as much as I loved Blue Rose...but unfortunately, this one was a miss for me.
I DEVOURED book 1. It became my #1 dark serial killer romance ever. I'm always here for that. Blue Rose was gory, hilarious, twisted, and fast-paced. I couldn't put it down. But from the moment Aster’s sister was introduced at the end of book 1 (a plotline that felt random and unnecessary), I had doubts that carried into book 2.
Truthfully, The Black Lotus was a struggle to get into and even harder to stay motivated to finish. It took me weeks — not just days — actually almost one full month to get through, and this was an ARC I was super hyped for. So, I powered through as much as possible to leave a detailed and honest review.
That said, around the 20% mark, the story started to click again. I did enjoy seeing Aster and Serena evolve as a killer duo. Their banter is darkly adorable as they’re literally dismembering people and turning them into art, but somehow it still felt lighthearted and funny in a twisted way. I genuinely laughed at, “You know, you're really sweet for a serial killer.” I loved seeing their fierce protectiveness carry over into book 2, and seeing their styles blend together with their signature.
The main conflict centers around Aster’s imprisoned serial killer mother putting a hit on Serena (who was meant to be Aster’s victim, not his girlfriend). While the premise is solid, the execution felt chaotic. Too many plot twists, not enough depth. Some moments felt like filler twists to keep things interesting, but they didn’t land.
For example, and this one really killed me, there's a scene where a world-class sword-wielding serial killer with katana skills is taken down easily by Aster...who’s barely conscious, severely injured, hasn’t eaten or had water for days, and has zero sword experience. It was laughably unrealistic and just didn’t work. She also is the one who turned in his parents which was a very anticlimactic and empty confession IMO.
The sister subplot? Still pointless, in my opinion. Her role in this book was just to lurk around the edges, stalk Aster and Serena, and then vaguely help when needed. Her presence added nothing substantial, and I still hated her introduction.
Then we have the parade of other assassins who all supposedly elite killers who were surprisingly easy to eliminate. This is supposed to be a million-dollar hit job, with the best of the best coming for them. I expected more of a fight. Instead, it felt like things were being thrown at the wall to see what stuck. Even Serena's dads fiancé gets brought in out of jealously to kill her and admits to also killing her mother...which felt once again, anticlimactic and unnecessary. It was just another "twist" introduced for no reason.
By 75%, with the whipped cream scene I DNF’d. I just couldn’t push through any longer. This really just wasn't it for me and I genuinely tried. For weeks.
It’s not that the writing was bad or the author dropped the ball entirely — I think I just wasn’t in the right mood, and the story didn’t have any of the magic or pull that Blue Rose did for me. While I appreciate the ARC and the twisted creativity that went into this world, The Black Lotus ultimately fell flat, and I wish it was as interesting as book 1.