Disappointing. While many people think that the layout of this book is clever: telling a story through several different forms (emails, journals, student essays, etc.), I found it to simply be a way to distract the reader from the fact that Founds barely had a story to tell and didn't have original characters. The different forms were a distraction. They ended up becoming more of a nuisance than a genuinely clever way to tell a story. And this book barely had a story. Teacher driven crazy by her tough urban teenage students and gets sent to the nut house. But wait, there are other things in her life that added to her insanity. But then she finds a husband, and everything seems great until she suffers from postpartum depression and kills herself (gasp!) just like her mother did when she was four (or did she? the end leaves it slightly ambiguous...ohhhh...thought-provoking). But what about her students? They have to be interesting, one of a kind characters, right? Wrong. Janice, the main student this book follows is a Hispanic teenager whose mother left when she was young to live with her father. Her father marries another woman that Janice, shockingly, does not get along with. Janice is intelligent and finds literature as an outlet though, so she'll be fine. But oh no! She gets ousted from the school literary magazine once Ms. Freedman goes to the looney bin. With no positive outlet, Janice lashes out at her father by informing him that she is dating Danny Ramirez, a notorious bad egg. She isn't actually dating him, until it seems like her father doesn't care. But she's different right? She's a more complex character, right? Nope. She gets knocked up by Danny and goes on to live a difficult life. Stock Hispanic teenage female character. That's the thing. If you don't have much of a story, then it should become a character piece. However, the characters were generic. Yes, through the different forms of writing and varying perspectives, the reader gets to see some of their complexities, but really what makes these character "complex" is what makes them even more cliche. Maybe without as much surface-level viewings of the characters via the emails, short stories, etc. we could truly delve into more complex characters that divert from the cliche, but Founds never really gives us that opportunity.