DNF
Where Are You Now by Jenny Hale tells the story of Ava St. John, a woman who deeply values her career and the life she has built for herself. On the way to an important business meeting, her world changes in an instant when she is involved in a devastating car accident. While unconscious in the hospital, Ava encounters a powerful, otherworldly voice that offers her two stark choices: to let go and pass away peacefully, or to return to life with the mission of finding Lucas Phillips.
Determined to live, Ava chooses the latter—yet this decision forces her to revisit the past. She hasn’t seen Lucas since her teenage years, and now her path forward becomes a personal journey of rediscovery, testing everything she thought she knew about both herself and Lucas.
I’ve read and loved many of Jenny Hale’s earlier books, but I’ve struggled to connect with some of her more recent releases. For that reason, I hesitated before requesting this one. In the end, it was probably a mix of curiosity and a sense of not wanting to miss out that convinced me to give it a try. Unfortunately, I have to admit with a heavy heart that this book was another miss for me.
Despite several attempts, I couldn’t immerse myself in the story. I even waited for the audiobook, hoping the narration would help me engage more fully, but I found the voices grating and couldn’t continue. Ultimately, I made the decision to set the book aside and not finish it.
My biggest struggle was connecting with the main character. Ava’s voice, choices, and inner reflections never resonated with me, making it hard to feel invested in her journey. On top of that, the religious undertones throughout the story weren’t to my taste and created a barrier between me and the narrative. As others have pointed out, the novel seems especially suited to an American audience, and I would agree with that observation.
While I know many readers will find meaning, comfort, and inspiration in Where Are You Now, it simply wasn’t the right fit for me.
I kindly received this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you so much Harpreth Road / Books Go Social