Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
You fall in love with a sinner and there’s two ways it can go...

Left to fend for himself as a young boy, Aiden has lived most of his life with little to call his own and little say in what comes next. But when his latest job working as a cattle driver for a wealthy rancher turns bad, he makes the deal that he hopes will give him a chance at a new start. All he has to do is spend the next week making sure nothing and no one causes his employer’s luck to run dry at the card table. Then he’s free.

Except in this bustling Texas town, Aiden finds far more than he bargained for once he encounters a charismatic gambler named Cypress, an apparent thief who seems far more interested in getting under Aiden’s skin than he does in playing the cards he’s been dealt.

The more Aiden learns about his illusive adversary, the more he’ll be forced to question if the promises he made are the right ones or if perhaps the one path he never saw for himself is the one worth taking—no matter where the road leads.

Set nine years before Adversity’s events, this Wild West romance tells the story of how certain enemies became unlikely allies willing to bet everything on each other.

331 pages, Kindle Edition

Published April 21, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ren Browne

6 books179 followers
Ren Browne writes character-driven romances that not only keep you up late chasing just one more chapter, but also stay with you long after the final page. When she’s not writing or reading, Ren is busy restoring a century-old farmhouse and barn with her Ron Swanson-esque husband, keeping up with their two adventurous kids, and caring for an ever-growing pack of animals.

Ren also co-hosts the Shelf-Aware Podcast with her sister Lizzy, where they deep dive into their favorite shows with the kind of analytical (and occasionally obsessive) enthusiasm that would make their AP English teacher proud.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
111 (56%)
4 stars
65 (32%)
3 stars
21 (10%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 99 reviews
Profile Image for em  (whats.em.reading) .
251 reviews22 followers
April 9, 2026
Arc review - chefs kiss. no notes. perfect. AND I’m in the acknowledgments which made me cry.

Beta read review -
genuinely one of the best cowboy romances i’ve ever read. It’s not a surprise considering how much i adore Adversity but this just took it to another level.
The TENSION the YEARNING, the most torturous slow burn.
This book gives us the origin story to how Cypress and Aiden met, 9 years before they meet Cora in Adversity it has high stakes, the best tension and ugh i just can’t help but fall in love with the Menace that is Cypress, and how much Aiden hates that he really doesn’t hate Cy :’)
They use verbal sparring as foreplay and i think i lost count how many times i said to Ren i could read 1000 pages of them just throwing witty comments back and forth.

So so excited for this to be out in the world, i will never stop recommending these books, the BEST historical cowboy romance <3
Profile Image for Florence ..
1,054 reviews307 followers
May 7, 2026
I had such a good time reading this one because enemies and yearning? Yes please sign up me any day of the week! I was so excited to read this one, and it did not dissapoint me in any way.
Profile Image for Kate.
474 reviews1,319 followers
May 29, 2026
I love Cypress so much it’s disgusting.

THE PREMISE: the prequel MM romance between the broody gunslinger and the charming gambler, before their MMF novel, Adversity.

TROPES & VIBES:
- Cypress is honestly everything to me.
- Reads like a slice-of-life story.
- Slowburn.
- Scars and tragic backstories.
- A fucking phenomenal love declaration.
- Be queer and do crime.

4⭐️ 1-1.5🌶️
Profile Image for Ri.
135 reviews
May 2, 2026
One of the most satisfying slow burns I've read. A gambler and a gunslinger fell in love (then later met their third).
Profile Image for Monica (switching platforms) .
288 reviews11 followers
May 8, 2026
4.5

When I saw that the author had released another book in the Midnight Gang series, I didn’t even bother checking the synopsis before requesting the ARC. I was way too invested in discovering which new characters the authors had created. So imagine my surprise when I realized this wasn’t introducing someone new at all, but was actually Aiden and Cypress’ story — the story of how they met before meeting Cora in Adversity.

I was honestly speechless. Partly because I didn’t expect this kind of “gift” from the author, and partly because I was so focused on possible new characters that it never even crossed my mind that the series could continue revolving around the same ones. And honestly? I’m so glad it did.

This prequel was everything I didn’t know I needed, and returning to this world - even just through the eyes of these two protagonists - felt incredibly nostalgic. But what truly drives the story is the way Aiden and Cypress cross paths for the first time and the chaotic little adventure that follows.

One of this author’s biggest strengths is her ability to make the most out of every single scene. I loved how the story kept moving naturally without feeling like it needed dramatic “plot development” every second, because the real focus was on the conversations and interactions between Aiden and Cypress. Their dynamic gave me funny, sweet, heartbreaking, and even spicy moments, all while making the pages fly by without me even noticing.

And once again, the Wild West atmosphere was absolutely on point. Revisiting this setting with its dusty towns, smoke-filled saloons, outlaws, and constant tension felt so immersive and honestly just really nice to experience again.

What surprised me the most was how emotionally intimate this story felt. While Adversity was more intense, action-packed, and undeniably spicy, Providence leans more into yearning, vulnerability, and emotional tension.

Cypress completely stole my heart here. He’s charismatic, chaotic, funny, and somehow manages to feel both dangerous and golden retriever-coded at the same time. Beneath all the charm and gambling tricks, there’s someone deeply wounded who just wants to help people and matter to someone. And then there’s Aiden… if you thought he was broody in Adversity, this book takes it to another level. He overthinks absolutely everything, keeps everyone at arm’s length, and yet watching Cypress slowly earn his trust was one of the most rewarding parts of the story.

Every moment between them somehow felt better than the last, and their banter only kept getting stronger with every chapter until they finally started or at least Aiden finally started admitting what the other truly meant to them. And GOD, it drove me insane every time these two couldn’t catch a single moment alone together. They deserved their time, okay?! But of course the author makes us suffer right until the very end.

What I loved most is that this book doesn’t rely on spice to keep you invested because the emotional connection between Aiden and Cypress is already enough to make your chest ache. Their yearning, tension, and vulnerability carry the entire story so effortlessly that when those rare intimate moments finally do happen — when they’re finally able to let their feelings take over — it feels incredibly rewarding and absolutely worth the wait.

I genuinely loved getting more depth and background for these two characters. Knowing where they started only made me appreciate their dynamic in Adversity even more. And after THAT epilogue… yeah, I desperately need book 3 immediately.

Thanks to #Lunaliterary and #RenBrowne for the arc in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for vivian.
176 reviews32 followers
April 27, 2026
4/5⭐️

"Cora. Her name is Cora."

This prequel was everything i didn't know i needed after reading Adversity. Seeing the way Aiden and Cypress cross paths and their adventure was truly so fun. The setting of these books is my favorite thing ever, i adore westerns, the wild west scene with outlaws and shootouts and saloons filled with smoke. Truly Red Dead Redemption coded🙂‍↕️.

Can't wait to see what goes down for our trio in book 3!🤎
Profile Image for Tiegan | Bookstagram.
110 reviews1 follower
April 11, 2026
SYNOPSIS

Before the little bird… there was the gambler and his wolf.

Aiden was left to fend for himself as a young boy, and has lived most of his life with little to call his own. But when his latest job working as a cattle driver for a wealthy rancher turns bad, he makes the deal that could give him a chance at a new start. All he has to do is spend the next week making sure nothing and no one causes his employer’s luck to run dry at the card table. Then, he’s free.

Except in this bustling Texas town, Aiden finds far more than he bargained for once he encounters a charismatic gambler named Cypress, an apparent thief who seems far more interested in getting under Aiden’s skin than he does in playing the cards he’s been dealt.

Set nine years before Adversity's events, this Wild West romance tells the story of how certain enemies became unlikely allies willing to bet everything on each other.

Tropes

🤠 MM romance
🔥 Cowboy outlaws
🤠 Enemies to lovers
🔥 Forced proximity
🤠 Touch him & die
🔥 Who did this to you?
🤠 Slow burn
🔥 Gunslinger & gambler

MY REVIEW

God, how do I sum up the way I feel about this book?

I loved “Adversity” (book 1 of the Midnight Gang series) because of the age gap dynamic, romantic intensity, barren Western atmosphere, and incredibly sexy intimate scenes.

I didn’t know what to expect going into Providence, but I know I hoped for at least some of Adversity’s sexiness to travel over to Aiden and Cypress’ origin story. What I didn’t expect was to feel such heart-wrenching dismay when I finished the final page, having encountered not much spice at all.

Cypress, our chaotic gambler MMC, dresses like a funeral undertaker but has all the charisma and adorableness of a golden retriever. He likes to help the helpless, and punish those who deserve it by hustling them in high-stakes games of cards. Cypress suffered a lot of trauma when he was young due to running with the wrong crowd, which means he has a bit of a “need to be a hero” complex. He is observant, hilarious, and a total sucker for Aiden from the first moment they meet. Cypress’ personality brings so much light and humour into the story.

And if you thought Aiden was broody in Adversity, Providence DEFINITELY takes that up a notch or 3 😆 Like Cy, Aiden has suffered his fair share of trauma, and he keeps to himself as much as he can. He is also a serial over-thinker and overanalyses his interactions with Cypress to the point of wanting to tear his own hair out 😆 I love how the story in Providence (and Cy’s character) slowly and tenderly tease out Aiden’s soft side, being respectful of the need for Cypress to first earn Aiden’s trust.

If Adversity is spicy and action-packed, then Providence is cheeky, intelligent, and heart-clenchingly intimate. It doesn’t need to rely on spice to hold your attention (although when you do get some spice… HEAVEN) because just seeing these two characters let down their walls to let the other in is its own special kind of privilege.

This book is artfully woven from the first page to make you desperate for Aiden and Cypress to get their happily ever after. Can’t recommend it enough.

✨ 4.5/5
🌶️ 1.5/5
Profile Image for Rae Leslie.
103 reviews1 follower
April 27, 2026
When I finished reading Adversity, I remember desperately wanting to learn about Aiden and Cypress’ story. Thankfully, Ren knew to give the people what they wanted and gave us a prequel.

In this story we follow Aiden, a man with next to nothing to his name, as he hopes finally have a chance at a new start. All he has to do for the next week is ensure that his employer’s doesn’t run dry at the card table. After this, he’ll finally be free. However, things take a turn when he meets the smooth-talking and charming alleged thief named Cypress.

I’m so thankful that we were able to get a glimpse into these two’s origin story, but I was not expecting the emotional roller coaster Ren was about to put me on. We learn more about Aiden and Cypress’ past traumas and how they shaped the two of them into the men they are today. Despite their tragic pasts and the violence that surrounds them, we find just how gentle these two men are capable of being as they navigate what they mean to one another. I found myself emotional over their yearning for one another and the desperation that comes with ensuring one has more time with the person they love.

Sometimes we dream of what our future could look like and sometimes we encounter said dream. Ren reminded me that it’s okay to hold onto that dream and there’s beauty in running head first towards your future.

Adversity and Provide are both available now, however we will be returning to The Midnight Gang once again in February 2027.
Profile Image for Stephanie.
563 reviews15 followers
April 23, 2026
I'm so happy we got more depth of Cypress and Aiden’s story after having met them in Adversity.
In the first book we get more of Cora, Cypress, and Aiden. And this book we go back in time on how Cy and Aiden meet and the wild interesting journey they take up until we make it back full circle to the start of Adversity.
I thought I couldn't love these characters more than I already did, but I was wrong.
Getting more background history on these two just made things even better.
I couldn't get enough.
The fun banter and tension between them. The way Cy just keeps Aiden on his toes with his crazy gambling tactics. 🤣
But just overall these two cowboys are the ones you want on your side.
I just love them so much. And what was revealed in the epilogue 👀 I can't wait to see what's next!

Thank you Ren & Luna Literary for the arc. 🫶🏻
Profile Image for Hannah.
295 reviews9 followers
April 28, 2026
Cypress is this chaotic gambler who dresses like he's going to a funeral but has the absolute charm and energy of a golden retriever

Aiden is this broody, guarded wolf who spends the whole book being furious that he doesn't actually hate Cy at all 🫠

The tension between them is insaneee. It’s the most delicious and torturous slow burn I've ever read and they basically use verbal sparring as foreplay. I swear I could read 1000 pages of them just throwing witty comments back and forth.

an absolute masterpiece.

🥰MM romance
🤠Cowboy outlaws
❤️‍🔥Enemies to lovers
🫂Forced proximity
🙈Touch him & ☠️
🥹Who did this to you?
👀Slow burn
🫠Gunslinger & gambler
Profile Image for Em.
146 reviews3 followers
April 17, 2026
What happens when a snarky lone wolf meets a chaotic bisexual. THIS.

And I loved every second of it!!!

It was the Wild West with the gunslinging and poker and horses and trains. And then there was the pining!

Cypress couldn’t have been more obvious and Aiden couldn’t have been more in denial!

They made me laugh. They made my frozen heart thaw a little.
I’m definitely rereading Adversity. And then I’ll reread them both AGAIN before I read Prosperity!!!

Thanks so much for giving me the opportunity to arc read this novel !
Profile Image for Shannai.
690 reviews44 followers
May 8, 2026
4⭐️

I absolutely loveedd this, omgg, I adored the insight that this gave into Aiden and Cypress and how they met and came to be. 

Having loved Adversity, I was so eager for Providence, when Ren said that there would be a prequel as to how Aiden and Cypress met. This is book two in the series, and takes places almost a decade before the events of book one however, both can be read as a standalone, and in any order, but I couldn't recommend this series and Ren's books enough!!

They were just as loveable and themselves and they were in Adversity, but what I loved most was seeing them when they were younger and how very different, they were. Cypress pretty much fell in love with Aiden from when he first saw him and didn't miss the opportunity to antagonise the grump, always in control mam that Aiden was. 

The tension and yearning between them both was incredible, and I loved how they were both able to learn on one another and realise how much they both needed the other. Ugh, this really had me in my feels, and the way it was rounded, when they first glimpsed at Cora, felt like such a full circle moment.

I absolutely adore Ren's writing and this was no exception as to how much I adore these characters and series. I'm so excited for what's next and for what Ren has in store beyond the Wild West.

Thank you kindly to Ren and the Luna Literary team for the e-ARC of Providence in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.
Profile Image for Ellie.
86 reviews
April 26, 2026
We have a cover!! And it’s beautiful 🥰

I’m so excited for this sequel

UPDATE after release:

Oh my goodness!!!!!! This was absolutely worth the wait. I adored Adversity. I couldn’t believe it exceeded every expectation for a book that was already exactly my cup of tea. But Providence just blew it out of the water.

I loved seeing Aiden meet Cypress and fall head over heels in love. The banter? Constant and endlessly charming.

My cheeks hurt from grinning so hard for hours while devouring this book.

I’m immediately going to go reread Adversity with all this knowledge about the boys under my belt.

6/5 ⭐️ can’t recommend enough
Profile Image for Sadonna.
2,709 reviews46 followers
April 21, 2026
This review and much more can be found at Love Bytes Reviews

Note:  While technically Book 2 in this series, the events in this book take place in the years before Adversity and are Aiden and Cypress's origin story.   If you haven't read the first book, it won't spoil this one, but I definitely recommend the previously release as well and they can be read in either order.

Aiden is doing a job he doesn't like for man he detests.   He was out of options and needed the payday, so he signed on for a cattle drive from Texas to Kansas with an obnoxious boss.  Maddock is an entitled, condescending and far too over-confident bastard.  But he is the boss and he's determined to make Aiden come to heel.  Hmmmm.  This could be a mistake that could lead to disaster for everyone.

Maddock is determined to line his pockets in more than one way.  He's under his parents thumb and he resents it.  He really doesn't have any desire to drive cattle.  No, he has much bigger ambitions.  And he needs Aiden to make sure things go to plan.  He knows who Aiden is - or rather "was" to hear Aiden tell it.

When Maddock and his men, including Aiden and a ragtag group of cowboys stop in the town of Soldana, they are determined to win some money at poker at the local saloon with Maddock promising to share the winnings with the crew.  Aiden thinks this is a terrible idea.  He also doesn't like it when people recognize him from newspaper stories.  He's not that man anymore.  He refuses to kill for Maddock - or anyone else for that matter.  His gunslinger days are behind him.  Or so he wishes.

The first night though a very unusual man show up to the card game.  And he loses.  But Aiden's watching him and he is pretty sure there is more going on than meets the eye.  When he confronts the man in the alley, well things don't exactly go as Aiden had planned.  And when the man, Cypress, gets the better of him, well he's not at al happy about it.  The longer they play these games and the more time they spend dancing around each other, the more worried he gets.

When Cypress leaves him a gift, Aiden is once again surprised.  He can't figure out what this man's game is.  Or what he wants with Aiden since he certainly doesn't leave him alone.  As the week in town winds down, things get out of control and Aiden and Cypress have to make a run for it.  They have left a mess behind them that is going to restrict their next moves.  Cypress isn't exactly unhappy about that.  Aiden isn't exactly happy about it. ;)

The crazy journey they take to finding who and what they mean to each other is a hair raising saga.  Cypress has friends that help them along the way.  These two are going to have to learn how to blend their moral compasses and overcome or at least make peace with their respective traumatic pasts in order to have any kind of a chance at a life together.

This book was sooooo good.  I loved the whole tone of this story.  I honestly would not have survived the wild wild west!  God what a crazy time and place.  Lawless.  Dangerous.  At the mercy of the elements.  Corruption.  No modern medicine.  No thank you! I am, however, a HUGE sucker for broken characters finding each other and figuring out how to come together to make something good.  Aiden and Cypress both have overcome terrible ordeals in their past.  They didn't have childhoods really.  They've been on their own since way before they should have had to take care of themselves.  They could not be more different and that is likely what makes them work in the end.  Cypress is outgoing, a good actor and his motivation for what he does is so unexpected.  Aiden is a stoic.  He's not interested in risking his heart and being devastated ever again.  He's determined that killing isn't for him and he isn't going to do it unless he absolutely has to save his life or the life of someone he cares about - which has been no one up to this point.  Turns out killing didn't actually resolve anything much for him, despite trying his best to only kill those who needed killing ;)  Together they eventually have to find a balance after much reluctance on Aiden's part and so much resistance to Cypress's charms.

When push comes to shove, these two realize that they belong together and they are going to have to be honest about their feelings after a LOT of pining.  Despite their banter and their disagreements, they are not going to be any good, one without the other.  Dolly, Cypress's friend, helps these two get out of their own way and she also has their backs.  A critical piece to their story, Dolly is a fabulous character and I absolutely loved her. Also, the UST is off the charts with these two!  This is a slooooooow burn that gets derailed a few times on the journey.  The author's writing was so evocative.  I kept picturing the Wild Wild West meets The Big Valley the whole time I was reading this book.  I highly recommend this series to anyone who loves a hard fought battle for a love that is so deserved with loads of pining and banter.  Historical fans will love this also.
Profile Image for jess.
169 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
April 15, 2026
“I have never once pretended like I didn’t want you. Anytime, wolf. Any place. You just say the word.”

Review: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️

Ex-gunslinger Aiden finds himself making a deal with a wealthy rancher in exchange for a much-needed fresh start, only to become wrapped up with a clever gambler that he can't seem to stop running into (and thinking about).

I loved Adversity with my whole heart, so I was so excited when I heard that we were getting more of Aiden and Cypress. This is such an amazing book and a perfect compliment to the first, I loved that their story was the 2nd in this series (and a prequel). In Adversity we get to see how well Aiden and Cypress work as a team, so to get to read their initial meeting and how they fell for each other first was such a treat. The title for this book is so perfect as well - I loved the threads of fate that felt like were woven in their meeting (and the winks at their little bird, I stg I teared up each time! I LOVED that Cora has always been a part of them, even before they fully knew it).

Getting to see how gruff Aiden is again - how he sees so much and get is utterly oblivious as hell to what's happening between him and Cypress at the beginning was the sweetest thing, there were so many moments that had me grinning and kicking my feet. And Cypress - he is as smooth as ever, thought I loved the moments where Aiden swept him off his feet, I truly have too many moments between them highlighted. Each scene between them felt like it had it's perfect place, and I could have easily read a thousand more pages of them flirting and fighting - I love them so much.

Dolly was such a delight as well, I hope I am half as cool as her when I grow up. You can feel the way Cypress dotes on her, she really is such a part of his family and I love the way she sees their attraction so clearly and works so hard to get them (Aiden, mostly) to see it as well. The tension between Aiden and Cypress is palpable, and the way their feelings build is done so well. They truly are inevitable, and I believe that with my whole heart.

I loved this so much, and am heading back to reread Adversity - this series is so, so good. If you love a cowboy romance that is dripping with yearning and fighting for the things (and people) you love, you are going to eat this up. 💖

Tropes & Tags:
🐴 mm cowboy romance
🌵 gunslinger x gambler
🖤 morally grey mmcs
🐴 enemies to lovers
🌵 forced proximity
🖤 dual pov
🐴 opposites attract
🌵 old west setting
🖤 touch him and 💀
🐴 slow burn

[I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review, thank you so much Ren Browne and Luna Literary Management! 📖]
Profile Image for Anna.
390 reviews78 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 19, 2026
“Providence” by Ren Browne

5⭐/5⭐
2.5🌶/5🌶

“He’s part of what I’ve been searching for, and finding him made me think that it actually was worth it. That there was a reason for it. That I haven’t been wrong to believe…”

“Providence” is the highly anticipated follow-up to “Adversity”, but with a twist: this is a prequel about Aiden and Cypress, and how the two seemingly opposites meet and fall in love. I still recommend reading “Adversity” first, even though the events of “Providence” take place years in the past. There are so many little Easter eggs and details that new readers will gloss over, and I think those details are too important to miss when reading “Providence”.

Set in the wild west of American history, the story focuses first on Aiden, a hardened gunslinger who desperately wishes to be free of his past. He works for unsavory individuals until he’s able to make a clean break, but before he can make his move he meets Cypress, a charismatic gambler. There’s something magnetic about Cypress, and Aiden can’t get him off his mind. Meanwhile, Cypress moves through life as though he knows the path laid out, and that path leads right to Aiden. He has a set of ethics and morals, and while he doesn’t break them, he certainly stretches their limits in order to get what he wants. The two are forced to team together, forever altering their lives.

I think what I loved the most about this story was the amount of yearning between these two individuals, and how different it looked based on which POV I was reading. Aiden is confused about his affection towards Cypress, and doesn’t know what to make of this other-worldly pull he feels towards this other man. That’s not to say he’s confused about being attracted to another man, the confusion is about Cypress as an individual. Cypress is so *different* from Aiden, and the way he talks about Aiden initially scares him. Whereas Cypress is acting based on a fated feeling towards Aiden. Aiden is, as he says in the book, inevitable; all of his actions have led him to this other man.

This is a slow burn, with the tension building in such subtle ways, by the time action is taken, it’s almost explosive. You can think of the book as taking a deep breath, an incredible crescendo, and when Cypress and Aiden act on their feelings, the exhale is so satisfying.

There are so many instances of these two men expressing their admiration and affection toward the other that will make you blush, and perhaps bring a tear to your eye; the writing is so beautiful. I really loved getting the chance to read about Aiden and Cypress meeting, and how they establish a relationship; it makes me want to go back and reread “Adversity”.
Profile Image for whatmarissareads .
314 reviews43 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 19, 2026
🌵“Cy…” I murmur, inching closer so that my forehead is pressed to his as I wrap an arm around him, tight enough to hold us both together. “Will you tell me?”
☀️“Why?” he mutters. “So you can be burdened instead?”
🌵“So I can keep my word to you,” I tell him. “I want your future, Cypress, but I want your past, too. So when you go back to visit it, you’re not alone there anymore either.”

5 ⭐ 1.5🌶️

I had no idea what I was walking into with this book…but I am not the same person walking out
I LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I am seriously so blown away by Ren Browne’s writing!!! This was EXCEPTIONAL and I already have Adversity downloaded and ready to go the second I hit post on this review hehe!

The banter is what completely sets this book apart...
It’s so beautiful watching Cypress want Aiden so badly while being (somewhat) patient LOL as he waits for Aiden to catch up to what he already knows

The grumpy x sunshine dynamic shines SO well here!!!
Cypress is the sunshine! he loves out loud, so deeply, and his quick witted humor had me giggling and blushing right alongside Aiden. I love that he’s been through SO MUCH and still chooses to wear his heart on his sleeve

And when he buys Aiden that gift…
omfg my heart just melted into a puddle 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

His love language making Aiden feel seen and loved no matter how hard Aiden pushes back was everything TO ME!!!!

Aiden is our grumpy, no nonsense type… but underneath? A total teddy bear He’s exhausted from being seen as the town hero and deeply haunted by his past. He’s determined not to repeat it.. and to him that means not letting anyone get close. Because love, in his mind, only leads to pain.

God… some of the writing in this story is just pure poetry.
I felt it SO deeply.

When Aiden shoots the top of the train car for Cypress…
OMFG. I had tears streaming down my face I LOVE THEM SO MUCH

And I think that’s what makes this book so special is it’s the little moments that quietly build into something so powerful by the end.

It’s a sloooow burn,
with tiny puzzle pieces coming together to create something that feels like a true work of art.

I LOVED IT. I cannot say that enough.
I love these characters SO MUCH!!!!!!!!

And somehow… I’m sitting here wondering how there could possibly be more love between them??
But with Cypress’s soothsaying abilities, I am VERY intrigued to see who might fill that third chair…

Literally running to see what happens next!!!
Profile Image for Caitlynn Burnaman.
227 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
April 14, 2026
"Loving you is not something I needed to decide, wolf. I was looking for you for so long. In every face I passed I looked for you, hoping that when I saw you, I would know. And I did. I saw you and knew who you were in this life and in the next and in all the ones that came before, because you were mine in every single one of them. I saw you and I knew that I would gladly go through it all again, that I would relive every single moment of my life just to have one single moment where I mattered in yours. To have one single moment where you let me."

Once upon a time...two outlaws cross paths, and fate refuses to let them walk away.

I didn't expect this story to feel as tender as it did, considering it was an MM love story between a gambler and a gunslinger. The two men are the definition of rough and tumble with survival and morally grey choices always close at hand. What surprised me most was the quiet tenderness they showed each other. Neither wanted to be the first to admit their true feelings while also never quite hiding the pull between them. Truly, Providence is the perfect 'sweet' to balance the 'spicy' of Adversity.

Ren Browne has quickly become one of my favorite western romance authors of all time. She captures the grit of the western frontier while grounding it in deeply emotional, character-driven romance. Her work feels like a balance between Janet Dailey and Elsie Silver - classic grit with a contemporary emotional core. The heated, intimate scenes are filled with the perfect amount of gruff, male dominance and cautious vulnerability making the characters and their story so captivating. Cypress and Aiden pull readers along through quiet yearning and restraint. Their feelings are undeniable, inevitable - yet neither is willing to be the first to give in. Readers will be enthralled by the enemies-to-lovers tension, forced proximity, and a slow burn that truly earns its payoff. I'm convinced there's nothing more compelling than being loved by Cypress or protected by Aiden.

Providence is defined by quiet tenderness and restrained longing between two hardened men. Their feelings refuse to be held back by their reputation as outlaws. Discovering this author and The Midnight Gang series has been one of the highlights of my reading and reviewing career! Thank you to Ren Browne and Luna Literary for the opportunity to read and review.
Profile Image for Tiffani Jo.
466 reviews3 followers
June 3, 2026
I need someone to explain why a morally gray outlaw with obsession issues immediately overrides all survival instincts in my body because this man could have looked me directly in the eye and said “get in the truck” and unfortunately I would have.

No hesitation.
No follow-up questions.
Gone.

This romance feels raw in the best possible way. Dusty, dangerous, emotionally bruised, and absolutely overflowing with tension. The enemies to lovers dynamic has TEETH here too. Not playful irritation. Real hostility. Real emotional damage. The kind where every interaction feels like one of them might either kiss or stab the other and honestly? Both options felt possible at several points.

Which made it impossible to stop reading.

And HIM.
Good lord.

This man is possessive in the exact way that rewires my brain chemistry. The kind of morally gray MMC who acts cold and detached while simultaneously being one inconvenience away from committing violence over her. The “who did this to you?” energy mixed with the hurt/comfort dynamic absolutely wrecked me because underneath all the danger and emotional repression, there is still this overwhelming need to protect.

And I folded immediately.

The slow burn works so well here because it gives all the tension room to rot into obsession first. Every moment feels heavy. Every glance feels loaded. Every touch feels like somebody crossed a line they are not coming back from. And once the emotional vulnerability starts slipping through all the walls? Fully devastating.

Also… outlaw cowboy romance should honestly come with a warning label because the things I would do for a morally questionable man in boots who looks at one woman like she personally hung the moon are deeply concerning.

This was dark, intimate, chaotic, and weirdly romantic in that “we would absolutely survive a shootout together” kind of way.

And honestly?
I ate every single second of it up.

Tropes

• ❤️ MM cowboy / outlaw romance
• 🔫 Gunslinger / gambler MMC
• ⚡ Enemies to lovers
• 🖤 Morally gray MMCs
• 🤕 Hurt / comfort
• 🏠 Forced proximity
• ☠️ Touch him and die
• 🔥 Slow burn
• 👀 Light stalking vibes
Profile Image for Bree.
266 reviews4 followers
May 8, 2026
✨️ARC REVIEW✨️
4🌟
2🌶

Thank you to Ren Browne and Luna Literary Management for the opportunity to read this fun origin story.

Aiden is nothing running from and searching for his past. The man just wants to forget his days as a gunslinger, but can't remember his life before. Aiden takes a job as a cattle driver in hopes that once he moves the herd across Texas he can return home to Arizona. His boss has other plans that lead him to a small town where he meets Cypress. The man just gets under Aiden's skin in a way no one else has. Before Aiden gets his answers about the mysterious card player, all Aiden's plans go up in smoke. Now he must decide if staying with the card player will get him back home.

The yearning in this story was amazing! Watching Aiden battle with the pull towards Cypress was too delicious to put down. Cypress was so cheeky and instantly lovable. The pay off from the back and forth slow burn was so worth the wait. Watching the story unfold and getting to know the snippets of back story for each cowboy had me chomping at the bit. I loved this prequel story to get to know their dynamic and history more before I dive into Adversity. I'd certainly recommend this for a fun, twisty, cowboy read!

Tropes:
🧡 MM Cowboy Outlaw Romance
🧡 Gunslinger/Gambler
🧡 Enemies to Lovers
🧡 Who Did This to You?
🧡 Forced Proximity
🧡 Hurt/Comfort
🧡 Morally Grey MMCs
🧡 Light Stalking
🧡 Touch Him and Die
🧡 Slow Burn

Favorite Quotes:
"Those fucking eyes. Every time they turn in my direction, something crackles beneath my skin.”

“I think I might be in love. The feeling, however, does not appear to be mutual. Yet. It does not appear to be mutual yet.”

“What we are, Aiden…I hope the appropriate word is inevitable.”

I received an advanced copy of this book and I am leaving this review voluntarily. The above opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Lauren.
102 reviews
May 9, 2026
Providence is the continuation of the Midnight Gang series by Ren Browne. I want to thank the author and Luna Literary for allowing me to read this book as an ARC. I was not surprised by how fast I read this book. I loved Adversity so much when I read it and I knew Providence was going to be just as good. Ren really knows how to make you fall in love with fictional characters.

Cypress and Aiden are truly special. The depth and character growth though out this story is incredible. I already loved these two in the previous book, and Providence just made them that more lovable. Their relationship is strong and kismet in a way. One of those things you search for in every lifetime. People that are just meant to be part of your life and help shape who you are. They are comfortable with one another. It feels like a cozy blanket or a favorite sweater. The banter is again knocked out the park by this author. The love they share is evident, even from the very beginning.

Although this book is the second in the series, it could be read before Adversity. It explains how Aiden and Cypress became who they are and how they found each other. It allows us the opportunity to see what happened before they met Cora. Either way you decide to read the series, it won’t really matter. You will love this Wild West story.

I swoon for these two cowboys. Riding horses, drinking whiskey, and they are not afraid to get a little dirty. It is not the typical cowboy romance, but I think that is what makes it stand out. I can’t believe there is more story to come in the next book, and I honestly can’t wait to see what Ren comes up with this time. It will be an adventure for sure.
Profile Image for Maggie.
552 reviews8 followers
April 21, 2026
ARC REVIEW
Providence by @renbrownewrites
⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5/5)

Ren Browne makes the Wild West feel immersive—even for someone like me who doesn’t usually gravitate toward Westerns. Her writing is vivid and atmospheric, pulling you straight into the dust, heat, and tension of the world.

And the characters? So well done. Layered, complex, and completely believable. Aiden is a stoic, guarded gunslinger trying to outrun his past—and I ate him up. Controlled, closed off… until Cypress.

Cypress is a charismatic gambler who immediately gets under Aiden’s skin. He’s secretive and clearly hiding something—something Aiden can’t help but chase. I loved how his carefree exterior masks a wounded but still hopeful core.

Together? The tension is immediate. It’s enemies-to-lovers energy, but one-sided because Cypress is already halfway gone. And when their slow burn finally tips into spice? Absolutely delicious.

This is a prequel to Adversity, so it works as a starting point for The Midnight Gang series. And yes, I will absolutely be continuing—because a polyamorous romance is right up my alley.

If you love slow-burn MM romance with outlaws, loaded stares, and characters who might ruin each other—and choose it anyway—add this to your TBR immediately.

Thank you to Ren Browne and @lunaliterary.management for the ARC.

For fans of:
🤠 MM Historical Western Romance | 😤 Enemies to Lovers | 🐎 Outlaws on the Run | 🔥 Slow Burn

#MMRomance #HistoricalRomance #WesternRomance #EnemiesToLovers #Bookstagram
Profile Image for Cerian.
627 reviews84 followers
April 22, 2026
Set 9 years before the events of Adversity, Providence gives us the story of how Aiden and Cypress met and what followed from there….I love that Ren wrote their story before Cora came into their lives and it’s such a great prequel.

Aiden is as taciturn and monosyllabic as ever, and we love him for it. His walls are sky high and he’s not really living anymore, just surviving and passing the days working as a cattleman and trying to outrun his gunslinger past.
Cypress is the same irrepressible, chaos agent I’ve come to know and love. His devil may care attitude hides a wealth of pain though, and he has his own demons. However, he doesn’t let those demons hold him back and he’s just a delight to read.

Opposites really do attract when it comes to Cypress and Aiden - the epitome of a grumpy x sunshine pairing on the surface of things. But their pasts also give them a deeper understanding of each other, and the intimate bond that builds between them was gorgeous. I loved that it was a slow burn - it particularly makes sense for Aiden as he’s slow to trust and I think it was more poignant when they finally did give in to the burning attraction between them.

The tension and sheer yearning that builds through the story was glorious. Add in some outlaw shenanigans, Wild West style shootouts and a touch of soulful stargazing, and you get a tender but action-packed ride of a book that will have you wanting to read Adversity immediately after (even when you only read it a couple of weeks ago like me)!

*I received a review copy from the author - this is my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Julia.
659 reviews8 followers
May 14, 2026
I REALLY enjoyed this book. I’m such a sucker for a Wild West setting, and this one completely delivered on the atmosphere. Aiden and Cypress immediately pulled me in. They both have such strong, charismatic personalities, and the chemistry between them is absolutely electric from the start. What made them work so well for me was how different they are while still fitting together so naturally. Their personalities balance each other perfectly, and every interaction between them had this easy magnetism that made the romance feel effortless to sink into.

I’m really excited to continue with the series, especially because I’m reading in chronological rather than publication order. This worked wonderfully as a prequel to Adversity, and now I’m even more invested in diving into the rest of this awesome world that Ren Browne has created.

I did end up knocking off a star for the editing issues, because they became distracting often enough to pull me out of the reading experience. There were several sentence fragments that didn’t feel stylistic so much as grammatically incomplete, especially standalone prepositional and participial phrases. Elliptical sentences can absolutely work when used intentionally, but here the phrasing sometimes felt awkward and disjointed enough that I’d stop to mentally untangle the sentence structure instead of staying immersed in the story. It’s frustrating because the book itself is so compelling, and stronger editing could easily have polished those issues away.
Profile Image for Jovie Robin.
152 reviews2 followers
June 1, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I thought I would get another set of books about the same world, but I didn't think I'd love Aiden and Cypress more than I already do. It was very interesting to see how their relationship started, I felt like I'm discovering history I didn't think I knew.

The relation between the characters was, for me, the highlight of this story. No need to rush with urgency because each and every conversation, each and every look, each and every moment they shared was important. The chemistry was pretty awesome but it was the emotional tension that was what I was completely engrossed in. I was in the throes of a fantasy of their banter one minute, then breaking my heart the next.

I absolutely loved Cypress in this book. He is good-looking, hilarious and has a way of making things fun even when they're not. Meanwhile, the emptiness and agony that lurk beneath his surface, which endeared him to me more than ever. It was also rewarding to see Aiden slowly break down his walls and open the door.

The setting really had a lot of atmosphere with the Wild West. It was immersive, but didn't overpower the characters, and made the journey with them even more memorable. This book touched me more than anything. It was full of longing, tenderness, friendship, love and at the end I was not ready to leave these characters behind.

I can't help but feel like I've become a little obsessed with them and I want the next book to come out as soon as possible.

ARC READ
Profile Image for Claudia "The Artful Reader".
21 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 13, 2026
3.5⭐You are surrounded by sinners, gunslingers, and gamblers. Cue the western music, smell of smoke & whisky in the air, while you watch a poker game. This book has you jumping back in time from book one to get more of who and where Adien & Cypress come from. The author's writing style and flow are uniquely her own. From meeting her by chance in a Wisconsin bookstore, I can hear her personal voice being pushed onto the pages. Her storytelling is something I love!

This book is filled with tension, yearning to be loved by a found family. Two characters searching for their own inner peace and what that means to them. Can what they have done in the past be forgiven/taken away, or will it haunt them forever? I enjoyed the push and pull between Cypress and Adien and how their two outlooks on life come together. That old saying applies to opposites attract.

I stated in my review of Adversity, “ It felt a little forced on how all three of the main characters got together in the beginning. It was hard to correlate how the two men were both instantly interested in Cora.” I feel this was answered in a very beautiful way, and I am getting the answers I needed!

After finishing the book I am really in the mood to play poker. Is that just me? lol

What I DID like:
✨Old Western Gunslingers and Cowboys
✨️Elegant & Engaging Writing Style/Voice
✨️The Emotional Impact of “Who Did This To You” Trope
✨️Little Bird & Wolf
Profile Image for Sarah .
401 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 19, 2026
ARC REVIEW

Providence by @renbrownewrites

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
🌶️🌶️

Thank you for the ARC @renbrownewrites and @lunaliterary.management - I loved Aiden and Cyprus’ story.

I hadn’t realised how much I needed Aiden and Cypress’ story until I started reading and then I became obsessed and demolished Providence within a day. Set nine years prior to Adversity, this is how Cypress and Aiden met and their journey. And it’s blummin amazing.

The yearning!!!! It’s on a whole other level. This story is such a slow burn but it’s beautifully done. Cyprus and Aiden are both complicated so it was never going to be an easy ride but throughout it’s obvious they aren’t going to let anything happen to one another; protect one another.

There are some beautiful emotions shared in this book; Cyprus has a found family that makes you smile - I think everyone needs a Dolly in their lives to absolutely have your back but also to perhaps meddle as well. Some of the moments between Cyrus and Aiden is enough to bring tears; discussion about your worth as a human being despite the choices you have made, how your past doesn’t define you and there is always hope that you will find the person (or people as we know Cyprus and Aiden meet Cora in the future) in the future.

If you loved all the gunslinger action of Adversity you absolutely need to read Providence and then be as excited about the prospect of Prosperity in 2027.
Profile Image for Emily Knaus.
608 reviews6 followers
April 28, 2026
Slow-burn tension, banter sharp enough to cut rope, and two men who circle each other like they’re already halfway in love but too damn stubborn to admit it.

“I have never once pretended like I didn’t want you. Anytime, wolf. Any place. You just say the word.”

Providence is the kind of origin story that makes you lean in because you can feel the future coming. Cypress the charming, reckless gambler with a smile that lies as easily as it seduces and Aiden the gunslinger who’s all grit, precision, and quiet storms meet in a way that feels like fate rolling dice.

And from the moment they share a page, the banter is basically foreplay.
Not the cute kind.
The kind that leaves you breathless because every line is a dare, a test, a tease.

This book is all tension and promise. A slow burn that smolders under every exchange, every near-touch, every moment they pretend they’re not watching each other. You can feel the weight of who they’ll become in Adversity, but here? Here they’re just two men trying not to fall into something that already feels inevitable.

“I believe he’s mine. That I belong with him and he with me.”

A huge thank you to Ren Browne & Luna Literary for the early copy!
99 reviews
April 30, 2026
Many thanks to Ren Browne and Luna Literary for the opportunity to read an ARC of this book. Those opinions are still my own.

Providence was everything I dreamed of and more. We were introduced to Aiden and Cypress in Adversity when they meet Cora and I've been wanting to know more about their backstory ever since. 

Going back in time while knowing how it's gonna end for both of them didn't lower the stakes, whether in their relationship or in the plot. 

The tension and banter between Cypress and Aiden were just off the charts. I loved how similar and yet different they were from the ones we met during Adversity. Cypress, already convinced that their love was meant to be and Aiden refusing to believe that he could be that lucky. 
Each of them battling with their own insecurity and struggles. Watching them open up and share their past with each other was heartbreaking and heartwarming. 

I loved that the book took its time in introducing them. How their relationship built slowly and strongly. While also keeping turning pages and holding my breath at what was happening to them. 

I cannot recommend it enough. And I cannot wait for the next instalment and to witness our favourite Midnight Gang back together. 
Profile Image for Amanda.
2,262 reviews99 followers
May 3, 2026
I'm just so so tremendously glad we got to see the start of Cypress and Aiden!

If you've read the first book of the Midnight Gang, you already know that these two revolve around each other, but I just adored watching how that all played out.

Aiden remains a big favorite for me. The way he plays it as broody and irritated, but he's really...well he is really those things BUT he's also a caretaker at his core and truly just does not want to add anyone else to his life, because he's just so worried that he may lose them one day.

But luckily, Cypress has never met a challenge that he gives up on. He was the surprise star of the show for me. Of course I loved him in adversity, but he truly shined here. The way he brought about the wit and levity, but also the epic yearning, the way he loved so hard so fast, and just how he put 100% into everything he did, even when he scared him. I loved him so so much and I love that he has Aiden to protect him now too.

It's high action, high stakes, lower heat in terms of number but just as high in terms of intensity.

The ending was pure perfection, bringing us right to where we started in adversity, with the guys on their way to getting their little bird.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 99 reviews