Fun but also hyper unrealistic
While I did enjoy the book, both in the story, characters and progression. At times I had to face palm of just how dumb it could get. While SJ is quite slow and stupid at times with Dave having to explain basic ideas to her or remind her of things. She isn't all that bad. Wish she'd inspect more stuff to level the skill and make more reasonable choices but oh well.
The hyper unrealistic stuff can be skipped over with a roll of the eyes. If want an example? So there is a list of playable races, classes they can have, then those classes have specializations. Now both Natives and Reborns both have classes and what not but let's just stick to reborns. There has been 25 MILLION reborn so far. Currently on the world around 150,000 alive. Now everyone makes it a big deal and never heard of that she picked not just her race, class and that specialization. People with tons of knowledge are acting like it's a first ever. Really? Thats like saying in World of Warcraft with 25 million players, no one picked an undead cleric with a shadow specialization. As if there was never one and they are the first ever of 25 million players to pick that. There weren't unlimited options for races and classes or specializations. There were like 10 races, 10 classes and 6 specializations for each class. Not counting the billions of natives, out of the reborns. All the people of her class never ever picked what she did? REALLY? That's how hyper unrealistic it is.
SJ is pretty slow and stupid at times, unable to connect simple dots. Yet everyone treats her like she's some sort of genius because all the other reborn apparently just pick 'orc fighter' then charge dragons on day one to die? Apparently all the other reborn are less intelligent than 6 year olds. Making her basic average intelligence seem like Mastermind solve it all chosen one material.
Now if you can ignore that and not be bothered by everyone hyping up SJ when she really isn't that great. Just enjoy the book, the adventures, the progression and world. Then it's a great book.
I just had to read it in the mind set of alternate earth where she came from where the common human has the intelligence of a very stupid gorilla. Because even a gorilla would know not to charge at deadly huge monsters.
Worth a read even with how unrealistic it is at times or how needlessly complex she makes things some times for no reason. Instead of simply saying 'Oh I read a book on it and that doesn't match it at all' she will instead go into some big complicated lie with many round about ways to get to the point for no reason. Which just makes her seem even more stupid when 'I read it in a book' would be more realistic and easier believed.