From award-winning sociologist Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve comes the first account of mass wrongful conviction in America, indicting a system purposefully designed to ensnare Black youth in order to close cases
“A must-read reckoning with past and present alike.”—Heather Ann Thompson, Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Fear and Fury and Blood in the Water
Wrongful convictions have long been dismissed as rare exceptions to an otherwise well-oiled criminal justice machine. But, after years spent investigating the largest criminal courthouse in the nation, Chicago’s Cook County, Dr. Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve began to uncover a far more chilling truth. Wrongful convictions are not accidental, nor There are at least hundreds of cases indicting innocent Black youth of crimes they didn’t commit. Arresting and incarcerating kids is the point—the “evidence” is tailored to fit.
In a suspenseful narrative account based on years of interviews, archival research, and the excavation of hidden documents, Gonzalez Van Cleve presents an ironclad “howdunit,” illustrating the steps that our supposed system of justice takes to “find” criminals, coerce confessions, and bury evidence.
A clear pattern emerges as Lee Hester, a disabled fourteen-year-old boy, is branded a “super predator” and convicted of killing his teacher. At just seven years old, Romarr Gipson is charged with a murder that is physically impossible for him to commit. Groups of boys like the Roscetti Four and Dixmoor Five are characterized as “wolf packs” in a pattern that connects them to the Central Park Five. These “crime fictions” are actively produced, perfected by police, enshrined in our legal records by the courts, and reinforced by the media.
Placing the exonerated boys at the center of their own story, Crime Fictions is a devastating, systemic account that leaves us to wonder just how many innocent souls have been claimed by the racist lies police tell.
Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve is an associate professor in the Department of Sociology at Brown University and an affiliated scholar with the American Bar Foundation, in Chicago, Illinois. She is the is the author of Crook County: Racism and Injustice in America's Largest Criminal Court (Stanford Law Books, 2016), which won numerous awards, including the American Sociological Association’s Distinguished Scholarly Book Award. Her book, The Waiting Room (Amazon Original Stories, 2018), is a collaboration with the Pulitzer Prize–winning team at the Marshall Project and examines how the suffering - caused by pretrial incarceration - extends beyond the cages of the jail and into the communities.
Her newest book, Crime Fictions: How Racist Lies Built a System of Wrongful Conviction (Random House), is the first account of “mass wrongful conviction” in the United States. Crime Fictions offers a novel intervention in the field of wrongful convictions by examining how racial stigma embeds in the seemingly race-blind, fact-finding stage of criminal investigations, demonstrating how wrongful conviction is systemic and actively produced by police.
Gonzalez Van Cleve’s written commentary has appeared in The New York Times, The Atlantic, NBC News, Crain’s Chicago Business, and CNN. Her legal commentary has been featured on NPR, NBC News, CNN, and MSNBC’s The Rachel Maddow Show.
Currently, Dr. Gonzalez Van Cleve is a native-Chicagoan, a first generation college graduate, and a proud alumni of Northwestern University (BA., MA., Ph.D.).
saying this is unbelievable only speaks to my immense privilege, but it’s how i felt. shocking that an entire system that’s supposed to protect us could perpetrate such shocking injustice, especially to children, and mark them as capable of the worst crimes imaginable. this is meticulously researched and documented, and the focus on a selection of victims was effective in outlining the gravity of what was happening. i found it to be a bit too short and would have read a book on this subject with this level of research twice its size. there are no words or reparations that can undo the damage that was done to these kids and to the families who believed that justice was being paid to those who murdered their family members, only to find out that the murder was a pawn for a larger game to wrongfully convict these children despite overwhelming evidence of their innocence. disturbing but important.
Amongst the lies that fill these pages from police files provided, the truth was that all along these babies were targeted for being free and black in America. My jaw hit the floor constantly with how well known the open secrets are. I now have a deeper understanding of the importance of lawyers. It's not just to know the law, it's to determine which laws the judge in question is willing to follow. That's scary.
She brings us through so many wrongful convictions. Many of which the one convicted couldn't have possibly done it because either the physical evidence matched someone else or they were with a teacher in school, out of town or even in other police custody at the time of the crime. Jurors believing that this person magically slipped out of jail, committed a heinous crime and then slipped back into jail is a leap in logic that sent me punching my pillow.
Racism has always been well alive. Marginalized communities continue to have to prove their humanity to walk freely. The enemy is and always has been white supremacy in all its forms.
My one big criticism is that in the audio book (which my friend read while I read the physical copy together simultaneously for our bookclub) is narrated by the author and she fully reads the n- word. In text, it is quoted from cop and attorney testimonials to show how they openly talked about black defendants. I do not think it was necessary for her to read it outloud at all. She is white passing latina. Not her place to say. This was a publishing decision I would not have chosen.
Other than that, this book is full of knowledge everyone needs to know. Thank you to the author and publisher for a free copy in exchange for a review.
“I’m the Blue Power Ranger. I’m going to fight for you” - Andre who created the Power Ranger dream legal team for a terrified 8 year old boy, upon seeing that the Chicago Police Department fabricated a story accusing children of rape and murder. Children who don’t know what a lawyer is, and cry for their mamas, denied that because the rule of law is to request for a lawyer.
I cried several times reading this book thinking about terrified babies and the monstrosity of the Chicago Police Department, meant to be those who protect but are the perpetrators of violence and extreme trauma. The term white supremacy is not strong enough to describe the pure evil of the actions of the police in falsely incriminating Black children to settle cases. The author at one point describes the police as a “modern day slave patrol” to describe the atrocities the police commit against Black communities in Chicago.
I’ve read ACAB books such as The End of Policing, but this book that puts you inside the story of innocent children being incarcerated by torturing them, forcing false confessions, hiding evidence of their innocence, and terrorizing them after they are found innocent puts a whole new meaning to ACAB.
Ever since I started reading this book I’ve been angry and I think I will be angry for a good deal of time. I told my friend Vaughn yesterday that the more I learn about the world, the angrier I become; that isn’t fun.
CRIME FICTIONS – HOW RACIST LIES BUILT A SYSTEM OF MASS WRONGFUL CONVICTION – by Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve
‘Wrongful convictions have long been dismissed as rare exceptions to an otherwise well-oiled criminal justice machine. But, after years spent investigating the largest criminal courthouse in the nation, Chicago’s Cook County, Dr. Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve began to uncover a far more chilling truth. Wrongful convictions are not accidental, nor anomalous: There are at least hundreds of cases indicting innocent Black youth of crimes they didn’t commit. Arresting and incarcerating kids is the point—the “evidence” is tailored to fit.’
‘Until 2021, when Illinois passed a law banning the police from lying to children, there was nothing that prevented this interrogation tactic from being used against not only one kid but many, as police created witnesses and suspects.’
To say I was incensed whilst reading this book would be a complete understatement! What happens to all the children Van Cleve highlights in this book is so gut-wrenchingly disturbing that my soul aches.
However hard this book may be to read, the life stories within are truths that deserve every minute of our time and attention.
Highly Recommend!
Thank you, NetGalley and Penguin Random House (Random House), for providing me with an eBook ARC of CRIME FICTIONS at the request of an honest review.
When it comes to history, “truth” is shaped by the person telling the story—and that’s exactly what makes this book so powerful. It challenges readers to examine not just the narratives themselves, but the people behind them, exposing a deeply troubling pattern that has long gone unchecked.
At its core, Crime Fictions reveals how those in power, specifically within the criminal justice system, construct the stories that determine guilt and innocence. Police don’t just investigate crimes. They shape narratives, crafting “crime fictions” that fit a desired outcome. Through coerced confessions, manipulated reports, and systemic bias, innocent Black youth are pulled into a machinery designed to close cases rather than seek justice.
I found the accounts of the wrongfully convicted boys—including Lee Hester, Romarr Gipson, George Jones, Omar Muhammad, and the so-called “wolf packs”—devastating, and it was almost impossible to comprehend the level of manipulation involved. And yet, these stories were also impossible to put down. Gonzalez Van Cleve creates an immersive read through vivid storytelling, insightful character analysis, and a meticulously built argument that reveals a hidden “shadow system” of justice operating within the courts.
I realized I was holding my breath as each case unfolded, watching the patterns repeat and hoping (even when I knew it was impossible) for justice to prevail. The book reads less like an academic study and more like a true crime thriller, which makes its findings all the more accessible, and all the more unsettling.
While nothing can undo the harm to these boys, Crime Fictions shines a necessary light on systemic failures that demand our attention. Definitely recommend this for anyone interested in true crime and/or injustice in America.
I received a free copy of this eBook from Random House and NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving this review.
These stories of massive, gross injustice are both heartbreaking and appalling. Obviously, changes need to be made within both the Chicago Police Department and the prosecutor’s office to address these acts of willful malfeasance by some of the officers as well as by prosecutors and others who turn a blind eye as to the actions of those determined to create cases simply because of skin color. Many readers may find it difficult to believe that police officers could be responsible for these miscarriages of justice, but the extensive accumulation of evidence speaks to their culpability.
Although the stories recounted here are horrific, the author’s willingness to bring them to the attention of the general public should be commended. This should be a must-read for everyone who believes in true justice.
Recommended.
I received a free copy of this eBook from Random House and NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving this review. #CrimeFictions #NetGalley
This brilliant book offers an in-depth examination of the U.S. criminal justice system and its disproportionate impact on Black Americans and people with disabilities. Gonzalez Van Cleve combines meticulous research with accessible storytelling, making complex issues understandable without ever oversimplifying them.
What impressed me most was how the author weaves academic rigor with real human stories, creating a narrative that is both powerful and easy to follow. The book sheds light on systemic inequities, biases, and discriminatory practices that often go unchallenged. Despite its serious subject matter, it is written in a clear and engaging style that keeps you turning the pages.
Crime Fictions is a must-read for anyone interested in social justice, reforming the justice system, or simply understanding the truth behind its failures. It’s informative, eye-opening, and leaves a lasting impact. Highly recommended!
Amazing book about an important topic. Candace, Omar and "the blue Power Ranger" were real life heroes here We need more people like that willing to risk it all.
The Chicago street files are sickening and horrific. The ongoing collusion between police and prosecutors needs monitoring Two small notes about the author's writing. Nicole is an amazing writer who really pulls you in to each story that she writes about. At the start of the book I felt an "anti cop" bias. Don't get me wrong . I am 100% against the actions of nearly each cop that was written about. BUT in order to save more people from the dates of those in this book, we need allies and we need to sway people who do not believe how often these horrific things happen. Sometimes I felt that the language painted all cops or most cops in the manner that the cops in this book painted black people.
Last note, Lean on Me will forever be my favorite movie and I will always be inspired by Mr. CLARK!
As the mother of a 13-year-old Black son who is already 6 feet tall, Crime Fictions didn’t just make me angry…it terrified me and validated the exact systemic BS we have already experienced in the school system. Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve brilliantly and brutally exposes how the justice system strips Black children of their innocence, weaponizing their age and size to turn them into "suspects" rather than kids. Reading this made me want to repeatedly hit every educator and law enforcement officer over the head with this book, even though I'm not sure it would actually change their minds. This book is a gut-punch, a masterpiece, and a stark reminder of the monstrous assumptions our children are forced to navigate. An absolute must-read that left me completely furious.
Thank you Random House and NetGalley #CrimeFictions #NetGalley.
This book was hard to read. Not because it was complicated, but because it was horrifying. The amount of injustice and the level of cruelty were shocking to read about.The way vulnerable people were failed by a system that was supposed to protect them and even targeted them in an inhumane way. I cried while reading this book more than once. How can a system fail children this badly and still call itself justice? What makes it even harder is that these aren't fictional stories. These are real people. Real lives. Real trauma. Every case left me angrier than the last. This book made courtrooms feel less like places of justice and more like places where power, connections, a law degree or a badge can decide whose truth matters and for who truth is a fantasy. It is an infuriating, heartbreaking book and I don't think I'm supposed to finish it feeling comfortable and I think that's the point.
Crime Fictions by Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve is a thought-provoking and engaging read that offers a fascinating perspective on crime, justice, and the stories we tell about both.
The book kept me interested from beginning to end, presenting its ideas in a way that was both accessible and compelling. I appreciated the author's insights and the way complex topics were explored with depth and clarity. It gave me plenty to think about long after I finished reading.
If you enjoy nonfiction that examines crime and the criminal justice system from a fresh perspective, this is a book worth picking up.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advanced reading copy in exchange for my honest review.
This is a powerful and important book. Anyone who thinks racial injustice Is a thing of the past needs to read it. The author documents egregious behavior on the part of the Chicago police department including fabricating evidence, coercing confessions, hiding exonerating evidence, and perjuring testimony. Even more concerning is the prosecutors and judges who willing went along with these wrongful convictions and kept innocent people in jail for decades. While it is well written and well researched, it is a sobering and disturbing read. Highly recommended
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for an advanced reader copy.
Thank you, Penguin Random House, for providing the copy of Crime Fictions by Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve. This was a tough read, but I’m glad I gave it a try. Of course, I watched When They See Us, the brilliant film about the Central Park Five, but I had no idea how many Black children were unfairly convicted of crimes in other states. This book focuses on Chicago, and wow, the terrible things that were happening made me gasp. Everyone should read this enlightening book. 3.5 stars rounded up to 4.
Crime Fictions is a hard but necessary read. Very well written but the information within is just difficult to digest. Police coercion is something that I knew existed but not at the level described within this book - in addition to the population most impacted. The author does a great job of presenting the information and the impacts of this type of behavior. It is a compelling read. Should probably be required reading. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
I think “Crime Fictions” is the best book I’ve read this year, and I’ve read some great books.
With examples primarily from Cook County, the author explores the systematic way that wrongful convictions have helped reinforce the racist system that is U.S. policing. She delves into the techniques and reasoning used to force black kids to confess to crimes they didn’t commit. We see how often disability is used to pin the crime and close a case. And we see the monstrosity of charging a seven-year-old boy with rape and murder.
Thoroughly researched and intimate in its details, this book will make you sad and make you angry. A must-read.
I received a free copy of, Crime Fictions, by Nicole Gonzalez Van Cleve, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Chicago's cook county has always been crime ridden, and politicians go to jail more then regular people it seems. I live by Cook county so am aware of whats wrong with it, and why its called crook county. Many male blacks were charged with crimes they did not commit, as mentioned in this book. This was an eye opening read.
“And that waiting, that horrendously slow violence, is the most shocking part of this system. The lie that we all accept is that the innocent will go free and that the “mistakes” will be rectified. But the reality is that accusation and conviction are nearly one and the same, and accuracy is an afterthought.”
A compelling and disturbing account of racial profiling and wrongful convictions in the United States justice system.
Crime Fictions is really well-written but difficult to read at times. It details the issue of mass incarceration and false confessions of Black youth. She discusses specific cases, and these narratives really broke my heart. It's a sobering read and very important book. Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for the ARC.
Been reading some heavy hitting non fiction recently. This was so sad, especially given the content was focused on Chicago. It's crazy to me that police go to these lengths to arrest, prosecute and harass black boys for LITERALLY NO REASON. Boooooo Chicago cops.